Skip to main content

tv   Inside Story  Al Jazeera  May 13, 2024 2:30pm-3:01pm AST

2:30 pm
i need to let him do that to us. the evidence in this case is frankly even stronger than that that we had against the nazis at nuremberg. and these crimes continued in the fast of a 2 part series out to 0 photos, powerful cases of all crimes against civilians allegedly killed by the syrian government. with photographic evidence from the seas of files, the lost souls of syria on al jazeera, the election excitement in indian as minutes of kashmir. the 1st parliament dream votes since its special status was revived. but any of the governing policy isn't contesting a number of key seats. the why is the b j p skipping these poles? this is inside story, the
2:31 pm
hello there and welcome to the program. i'm nora. kyle: but it is all going to the polls in indian administered cash man as the 1st paula ministry elections that surrender moody's government cancel the regions partial autonomy in 2019. and for the 1st time in years people i'm not boy crossing the votes. the prime minister says, repeating cash, mrs. special status has health integrated with the rest of the country. he also says it's bolt piece and development of the decades of separate his violence. why then has moody's policy not nominate to the candidate to contest the 3 seats and the muslim majority range, and we'll put this question on the move to august and just a moment. but 1st of this report, like cateel depends how the general elections are highlighting the political tensions in indian administered kashmir. it's been on edge for years. a decades long uprising against indian rule has killed tens of thousands of people this year for the 1st time since 1996. the governing beach, a piece or by the jonathan party,
2:32 pm
has not fielded a candidate in the muslim majority breach in india and administered kashmir. has traditionally bully caught at elections following calls from separatist, but opposition candidate for he would recommend puerto wants to change that this election would be a dining point when dino didn't go and does a huge vacuum of by 6 years. and this is, this will be an expression, people to vote with their feet come out and you know, express themselves. some analysts say the beach, i didn't nominate a candidate to avoid public defeat and political backlash. they are skeptical them sense. and they're scared of pipe and i look shows static medias addressed to dom up exploration. is it extra of the things do not get reported as they used to get, so it is not a month to, to maybe not months helping good areas. because not,
2:33 pm
not of muncie. i'll pick them up in our system until 2019 indians administered kashmir, enjoyed a special status with a separate constitution. after it was removed, general and kashmir was divided into 2 federal. the ruled areas was broad under the direct control of new delhi. they used always give ordering it. we will vote with the hard that there is prosperity and kashmir every now and in things get out of hand. we don't want the situation to too bad or violent motors are despite the recent sporadic violence, the b j. p points to the relative stability and peace under the leadership of prime ministers and around promoting. there have been signs of economic growth and a decrease and separates as violence, but voters in india and administer kashmir, say it's cost them their autonomy. patsy, a little bit civilian. how does 0 for insight story?
2:34 pm
well that's bringing all a guess now and from sure to go, no i went by is a retard political science professor at the university of kashmir, whose research focuses on indiana minutes of kashmir and south asian affairs from john moves. and they'll set the as a spokesman for the governing b, j. b, in general of cash man. as in new delhi, bought a coma, an offer an academic and 2010. she was one of 3 government appointed members of a panel representing the views of cash, married society to india's cabinets committee on security. if i would welcome to all of you. so the 1st of all this ask you why would be a p is not contesting these 3 seats and cache map see, in order to understand what's being done, we have to understand the problem of catch me. one 3rd of catch me, it is under the need the local patient or practice that of what last more than 75 years august by me is finding proxy. why be the india they are supporting tourism.
2:35 pm
so new tourism through engines did or can you think the truck can park isn't that by d and it's and you should have done by the agents and was farmed in 1951 were the only motive, but there should be fun. india, there should be no separate constitution, different windows, so especially the status to any state. for, for 60 years after 60 years, we achieved onto it before it goes to the 19 body, the moving car to go to 70. and for the integrating cash read with india. so these are the addictions that are being turned off at 2019. for the 1st time for 5 different, i didn't talk to you because it, nobody was nation is more important than having fuel seats from do it or do it or forming the government. this is a huge bit to, for the fight india, which is being forwarded to catch me. product isn't the party has taken, they've gone shows and strategic diseases under treatment,
2:36 pm
not going to stop by the inventory eviction from g 5. inventory cost to truancies induction. we don't, we have large abuse of well goes and gets muted, running into next look to the workers about isn't that part of being this cost agencies? they wouldn't be running into more than $5.00 back. okay. we have uh for just thank you. so now let's just get a reaction to the 1st of all, i can turn to norfolk meant that you are in showing a go. so they'll set the space into the government b, j, p. the says that the nation of india is more important at this stage of relations between new delhi and engine minutes of kashmir. van b j. p winning a few seats, 3 st says up for grabs in cash met. what do you make of that? so it's very difficult for us to understand here. here, let me give you some folks from giving notes on understanding of it. but what
2:37 pm
a comment about some of you have a concern often having in the residential market on the changing girl for you to go to the audio and get you a big be a not conducting direct them directly and say that don't understand the meaning of what is your social beer cuz people know how to get a one understanding of it by lot of people can possibly be confident enough to election. you've got to the doctor doctor exploded itself to the water. the chair water response in this condition. so the full we get to read, this is what we're bringing rather as one cell to respond to that because it's a 5 point, isn't it? that we have got the b j. p contesting and john moving him? do don't many to jump me away. you will, but not in muslim majority, kashmir. why is that? that is a bit on statement because we are fighting get it now. so we are fighting on the
2:38 pm
seats. we have, we may not be having the video, realistic tons of reading it as the election is not for winning and losing only they've got these other decisions which are big on in the interest of the nation. is that more than pardon for those reading seats is not the only criteria and 2 months or 3 months down the line that would be in addition to the assembly of the union turn into the bucket. and 3rd party wouldn't be testing all the seats, offer simply including all the suits and catch me around. so you're not afraid of elections that does not to the find. my friend was saying was up to date on this is the start of the season, which was digging in the interest of the nation. ok, well, i'm sorry. what's the address of the nation does the spring? you see this is a, this is a fine. yeah. there is a fight between the forces which are supporting the separatism. what would have been digging the technical support from separate disk and believed that he meant those on the person's work,
2:39 pm
contesting that national congress ought to be mended. and then there are forces were uh, taking the initial is digging ident, our fall would be one that there should be a conscious effort now from the catch me that they should come forward and defeat the forces of separatism for all the things through. okay, rather less bringing you at this point, how much of a surprise was it festival? to have beach. i was not going to contest this, but because we did see them outcome this identity. the local members of the b g p policy was going don't to don't campaigning up until the announcement up actually i didn't expect them to contest because it's fairly clear that they would use and they would prefer not to be seen to lose. and i think that there is any strategic elements involved in this decision than that. it is easy to governments that they don't want to be seen to lose all the seats in the cushion to evaluate the other arguments. i failed to see it all together. i don't
2:40 pm
see how some kind of quiet, aged be support for break away parties like the me party is going to necessarily help or is a strategic decision if, if the gentleman is saying that they want to fit one lot of cushioning areas against another lot of cushion movies, i'm sorry, that is hardly a strategy. and i wouldn't say that that to be not only truly, but actually raw that it was found at the moment. where ironically enough, we are going to see perhaps one of the higher donalds ever in the session era in this election. and it's wonderfully ironic because in the rest of india, this has been quite a lot lost the election campaign. as the almost every analyst has concluded,
2:41 pm
okay, in the valley, this is not lackluster to know. perhaps you can fill us in on why cache marys also interested in this particular phase. when in previous folks i've always been cold, simply costs are yes, that's more completely different particular context. another possibility for a beer, but how not so hard. uh, uh, so i, i never did call the defender to me for an actual uh, sub pump national level. are in the airport department, go back a little bit. uh, but should uh, people are expressing discharge this time because they want to look for the other. uh they want to want to be there. people are longer part of the presentation in garcia, dot har, dot india and they were in the connecticut to the golden cache. me it is how much hard i need to present it. to me, she just quoted you one cuz me it does not cover when the doctor did not have it,
2:42 pm
just kind of prevent it all. well, got a presentation on last few years. so this time i think people are and just dr. parts good. i'm do. did x pressure to do that because it doesn't do showing dental deal you're pointing to in just so i and just send it to them. okay. send it will set the time is run domady visited this region in law. so that was his 1st visit since 2019 i put it to you, but perhaps that didn't go as well as he expected. and that played in to his decision on the beach a piece decision not to run in the cash. smith elections. you know, that gives us a new key fobs run. the hon prime minister visited catch me. the stadium near the program was served, was jam packed, and there were more than one that close. i'm just what in attendance in different
2:43 pm
districts of catch me, which was fine, but if you do a conference that is actually complete on motion, the response was response was i would rather make even more than what we could have part in catch me. but until then, after due to the 19th, 1st thing, but i'm just there visiting it and just meet the people who are on pumped up. you'll see what is the crown the other day in guest meet after due to the 19 present data is most on parenting. the violence has come down to minimum the people that live drinking good. confidentiality of the tourist are coming in the next in guest. new book, everybody is happy this, this electronic thought would be part of the issue of the development. the don't get to the moment, let me just bring it in right to. i'm not knows it's fast point isn't that that buttons has lessened in kashmir since 2019 um, it's so difficult for him to prove either way. if you think, you know,
2:44 pm
if you look at the she goes suddenly stone, 3rd thing is is down to or. ready 0 me back, if you look at a 10 to the attack, then you are not going to see a great decline. i'm, i'm very mind that cushion you again has a much higher security presence then it has 5 in the 10 years of these process earlier. so my argument would be that it's, you want to actually judge balance. you have to also look at whether your need for security presence is low or on. know, that is the best test of whether you are moving to which piece. and if you apply doctors, then you will see that it was only even the years off, 2004 to about 12 that you had a really sharp,
2:45 pm
significant decline in violence. it then went off. when you had the b, j, p. b, coalition government in uh, in the smooth and you have to be just the, at the center bottom so actually increased in 201720161718. and so when we talk about it being low, uh, quite often the feature piece sports people are using the c goods for the use of 20161718. okay, all right, let's let so now the respondents of that, because that is why the says customer is one of the wells most heavily. i'm going to try zone if the level of violence has come down, why does it remain? so a r c, when we talk about the declining data resume, i don't know from the fingers are being taken by it. mr. i back on my cheek has to come. be sure, you know, good to change in get should be you have to come to so you're not going to see the
2:46 pm
change in the values of the people they are mentioning says that the tax on security forces, i'm not decline is not the figure. it's, it is, it is almost gone. it doesn't make any money. now, it is not the same situation that we're not talking about until then $1670.00. we are talking about the situations often 1990. there is a see change in cash. we know crush me. it is, you have not months or late yesterday. there was a big demonstration in progress, but not gonna break the trust me, but people build onto dry in india. why are the people there wanting to drain india? because they are afraid of the less bringing nor i have to get his the past due on this particular point. no, i commit the right. it says that the figures of levels of violence are coming from the home ministry. what is the security threat that in kashmir today?
2:47 pm
so data, how big the incidence of all measured while understood and give you a window either one or no, but but the question is, like the lodge done, you have tinnitus, by the sword, not about a liver distribution of student. she dare taught him your work or speech without help, with the people all across the region that aspire to part are steer towards a part issue for the part that egypt. and then what i wanted to how i could go on then direction was in local assembly a doctor, adults are not happy as long as they would be that they do not as it goes, did someone did the class has vision does. it's not really integrated the hard one days to call the mind. but i think the just a lot, the right time did the bones that people have even more strongly,
2:48 pm
guys all the time. you're mostly heavy with the changes. i'm the grandpa border because they have an instrument only means you can use them, but you do want to come to the same thing and hopefully this, this is all for him to be qualified. what type of piece is it the roger is we want to talk about these ways to elections because so neil bruce is all pallet. he said that within 2 to 3 months, that would be we to know elections, assembly elections in time of cash. man moody has promised to restore state hood. yeah, these elections have been delay several times before. do you believe the beach i pay when they say they will allow reso elections within the next few months? when let people do it this way? this is the order by the supreme court. the supreme court of it, yeah,
2:49 pm
had said that elections have to be held before the end of september. and by the way, in the supreme porch, the solicitor general law of india argued on behalf of obviously the union as well as the states administration, that the security situation was such that they could not restore state could. so, you know, on the one hand, in the supreme called, they're arguing, security is bad. and uh, on the other hand, in the public domain, they're arguing that they have achieved the gray. d one is, you know, attempted to say, please make up your mind and please release the pop up. he goes to show one way or another. because if you have misled the supreme court, the supreme court is extremely clear in saying that they are only accepting the union administration argument of a delay of state to the on the grounds of security. that was the only ground that
2:50 pm
they were accepting it on. and they have said that they owe the full dodge as soon as the elections are held. the state assembly is the election which have to be before the end of september. they are hoping that states would, would be restored very soon off. so now your question will be, did the follow through on what the board has directed them to do? i can only hope that they will, it will be cried with phoning to defy an order of the supreme court as one hopes that they won't find the other ways around. but we don't know what will happen until the new parliament is in place. okay, you're not real quick, that's not a problem. and then the inside story down the line. so now set the, i want to bring all the was back to the boat that's going to be taking place. so over the next few days, how free i'm fat is this boat going to be that in the region because we've seen restrictions on media, on freedom of expression al jazeera actually has not being drawn to visas to cover
2:51 pm
the election within the country. so can people trust that this vote is going to be free and fast? and there is a 100 percent guarantee that the addictions would be fee of and don't forget addictions. so there's no restrictions on the media mediations defaulting each day . the media is the 14 our games, the government, we are not stopping them be anybody can come and see that is i don't think there is any education not even complain from anybody, much less from i'm so you know, the addictions would not be fit if we did we would have in contesting? you would have been saying this thing to me that this selection is unfair because means if he wants to win this me uh, by other means we have not in the free, but we would insure the addictions. would it be for you in fair number one, number 2, assembly elections. this open board said that the addictions would be headed in friday, september end be stand by 8, but the addictions will be here to the assembly by september end. and that would be
2:52 pm
a government off, don't want to just read off the people document this week, which will be due be elected the fortune of every time in the union due to the, to the state as it was before due to the 19 is obviously coming spring, which has been made by the central government and up sort of the 5 new mentoring for the. so think order for and you're also uh see situations not been c n situation turning around. these are 2 different things that would be addiction. so for assembly of union to their duty, there is no doubt about that after the union due to the elections and the government will be found in the union turner to the then the decision will be taken for formation of us, of the state, from the union donor to the i don't think that will be on on do it in that also. okay, no, i fled festival. although any complaints from within the region in the way the elections have been carried out in the run up to them and the way they all set to be carried out in the next few days. you know,
2:53 pm
i think the other certainly would be if you had heard it this time and for different parties not to participate in, one of the zip is not but spending in direct them further. but kids, the more most, almost all the most part, the, the uh, parts creating an attribute. i don't think that has been completed on data, but oh, so a lot of, uh, with that we, we loved to the intern barge and actually let you know, i don't, i think uh next time with this type of people that will work to parts. they do not have that number, don't be on to the past. and what do you do? i mean, they are going to be p and p and i like them. okay? all right, let's pick up on the scenarios of a point where it says that you have a cache me and the reason will be restored it statehood. so the situation before 2019 it raises the question why the government repealed also cool 370, which case significant autonomy to the engine admittance of cost me a reason why it repealed it in the 1st place?
2:54 pm
yeah, i don't think that the uh, any arguments that are given on the basis of the situation or to go she need to on to watch your actual the, the tune system please. that would be just the um, the preferred service before the jun song done before that taking the mazda by. i'm so i'm on opposed object to the $370.00. so it's been a long standing feature. if he demands that it should be rolled back on when uh at the move, the administration had a 2nd. um, with a very large majority, they search that they could uh, roll it back. it's as simple as that. now the way that they did it, we are all aware of what they did. they uh they imposed and knocked out on the stage. they arrested more than 5000 political leaders. they uh, and had talked to,
2:55 pm
they had to the longest internet shut down in history. all of this, we know that these with the message that we use for road by august to 370 a. so now what does movie do about cache man? c, v will complete use in case we, if we want the people of course me to new really and there should be no debt or there should be no separatism said via the decision was taken in books. the 19 was all out of town. so for this reason, reason for creating the freedom to separate his i'm english meet often because and 19 there is a complete integration of the democrats weaver that yeah, i don't think that stage is going to turn back right. there is no party to be in guess meeting which is talking the more practical $370.00. these are these people in okay, uh we're having a bit of trouble with your line,
2:56 pm
but let's just put it in nor i fled to pick up on that point. is anyone talking about 370? i mean, so those rises that is not being part of any election campaign. what the cash mary's wants for the future of the people who made all the dr. billboards helpful articles, need someone to be acceptable for the process to get the work done. i want to double door, local participation and local come to all of our local elected. going think about that out there all across the street, even though we just bought them the 1st one. you might catch mr. joel on the dock and catch me that there is a aspirational part you got to do is to godaddy all online. a good deal for a job done by it people out of the district. so if you had a doctor and you do some of these empty data, uh or how do we are about this problem? i don't know, but people won't get scanned over to sydney about ok. the drawers. oh gosh,
2:57 pm
the people are very trying to do on our did get presented beacon data, how to raise the i think the local governments are going to take up this issue and the board and wondering about present the electronic part is the district from the region. uh, several of them on the go, these 2 are okay, because we will have to leave all the discussion today would be very interesting to see the outcome of this phase. and i'm, shall we be revisiting this very interesting issue in the future here on inside story many thanks to our guests today nor i quit baba samuels at the end, right, that come and thank you to, for watching. you can see the program again, any time by visiting our website that's out, is there a dot com, a valid discussion to you guys? well, facebook page, that's facebook dot com forward slash ha inside story. you could also enjoy the conversation on x a homeless as a inside story from me, laura kyle:
2:58 pm
and the whole team here. bye for now the how the sinews, who are expelled from their nuns in the neck of 1948. still don't have the rights of return today is that the land was extorted and settlements were built 20 houses here a world goes back with young, good old palestinians to re discover their ancestral homes. why doesn't my grand parents stay here? why aren't i here? return to palestine on al jazeera, the investigating the use and abuse of power across the globe. now to 0, there's a next generation in the united states. they're not happy with what is happening in
2:59 pm
gaza. they're not happy with the u. s. foreign policy and that's why they're trying to make their voices heard. the administrators of each university really have a choice to either escalate and calling police be confrontational, or to actually listen to what their concerns are. city stream of people being arrested, wasted zip tie and cups and taken away many of the purchases we talked to have said they will continue protesting until their demands are met. the in the solomon islands, the deadly legacy of world war 2, remain on the lounge. why they placed it and it exploded it now i do this. they are literally the sense of taking the time on 101 east meets the solomon islands some time to escape a war that ended decades ago on, on jersey. there is no tunnel cover in the world views like we do. the scale of
3:00 pm
this camp is like nothing ever but we want to know how does the people we revisit, please stay even when there are no international houses. there are really invest in that, and that's a privilege as a journalist, the time serial venue in doha with your top stories analysis era. there's been more violence in north and south guys that palestinian fighters say they are engaged in running battles with his really forces. east of the jamalia refugee camp. civilians are fleeing in search of safety. high. the tank is behind the classrooms into schools. god is our savior. and to dispose of our affairs, we did not want to leave until we saw it with our own eyes. i looked and i saw that the time was behind us. i said to them, the time has passed leave. if my daughter had to read.

8 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on