Skip to main content

tv   Inside Story  Al Jazeera  August 13, 2024 2:30pm-3:01pm AST

2:30 pm
every story, every step isn't a separation of what we can choose when to reach the well to simmons and exclude. does that affect the redesigns luxury leasing, trusting of future? today, we create the expanding ukrainian incursion into russian territory. forces must go to evacuate. civilians is an embarrassment for president vladimir putin, the murano police to for ukrainians. but why has keep launch this operation? now? this is inside story, the fellow that i'm james bay's, the battle lines in the war and ukraine seemed to have changed
2:31 pm
a little in recent months with alice calling his stay all night. and yours was conflict since world war 2. but then the lightning attacked by ukrainian forces into russian territory last week took not had any russia by surprise, but the rest of the will to ukrainian troops are reported to be advancing and russia's cook region. and most goes on to the evacuation of civilians from fat and neighboring belgrade. so why is the surprise operation being launched now? how is it being seen within russia and you try and we'll discuss all of this more with all guess shortly. but for us, this report from image and came back ukrainian troops push the button to rushes, western coast region. the surprise of talk is the most significant concussion into russia since it invaded ukraine. february 2022. issue who would name the bushings devil? him to the augusta stated to ukraine, he's proving that's enough. and that really bring justice and we've got to increase exactly the kinds of pressure that is needed. you know,
2:32 pm
progression on the dresser. ukrainian media reports citing on named security officials say the incursion is aimed destabilizing russia, and stretching exposes and that the coast region has been used by the russian military, correct. the wolf is a platform to fire into ukraine. thousands of russian civilians have been evacuated from the area of many things sent a temporary combination. no much with blue eyes each and we started moving people out. it was quite difficult because the queens are showing the civilian population . they show the paramedic sacrifice themselves. why moving civilians out to the russia has also begun moving people from the neighboring belgrade region to come under attack. the russian f o submitted treaty been attacking crazy until it gets inside russia. but a failed to dislodge the rush as president cold ukraine's action a pro vacation. it shouldn't be put in your cube, or
2:33 pm
a shame is undertaken. another large scale provocation, indiscriminately shelves, civilian buildings, so residential houses ambulances with different types of weapons. and including myself, the thoughts is by ukrainian forces fully with many military analysts described as a state of stalemate. new water will most your controls grind, 18 percent of you cranes territory. and it's used, it's great to a number of troops to make gotcha advances. president zelinski maintains that ukraine will not negotiate and will not relinquish ukrainian soil to russia. but while ukraine has benefited from western support, with the us, u. k. e u countries would have provided millions of dollars worth of military age and weapons. key fees if the us presidential election in november results in a win for donald trump over maybe jeopardize imaging came out to 0. the inside story. well, let's show you the state to the battlefield right now. not much has changed inside
2:34 pm
. you probably know not a great deal. there's been a grueling war of attrition that was heavily fortified front lines. the very large desk told them both sides. but what's news here? the cleanings cut this plan to see chris and the element of surprise seemed to work so far and offensive into the russian province of ca. some report say they come more than 30 kilometers from the border. deep into russia, as villages where they are on the states of emergency was declared and civilians have evacuated from parts of the neighboring province of boca road as well as from coast so let's bring you know, a guess for today's discussion in p. unless you 40, i know is the co founder of ukrainian security and cooperation center in moscow pebble folk. and how is an independent russian defense analyst and the boss in the u. k. patrick brewery is a defense and security analyst at the university of boss and a former british army officer. welcome to all of you. let me start in cave. as
2:35 pm
we've been saying, let's see it. this took everyone by surprise. i think the big question is, what is you crying trying to do here? what's the, what have you cleaned? we're always going to be a better time for this operation because we just received ukrainian forces just received a western. i'm been asian started to receive that in and off spring uh in the beginning of the summer and we just started them possession processing of crazy. so yeah, the separation took the implant name, not as much time as it could. and uh, yeah, this operation is a and boeing where you cannot claim the just a cleaning operation of for an eye on because sick, green and officials are not claimant x budge. the operation gauge much resolved as of now, and we're talking about a gift to,
2:36 pm
to your questions told us we're talking about a russian military infrastructure includes regions destroyed. and so yeah, just to the fact that this is the 1st time since the beginning of, of since the 2nd, 2nd, both for when foreign ami is in the treasury of crushing penetration. so this is what i did to be clear to me, not from what you're hearing. do you think you create implants to hold this, terry tree, or is it going to withdraw or at some point in the near future? ah, well, i've ever seen in some the matter is that the operation continues incomplete. secrecy decisions are taken by the operational command of a. so let's, let's see what is next. okay, patrick, it's going to be pretty hard to judge whether this is the success. so no, so if we don't know what we're trying to do, what the objectives all, isn't it absolutely jet and then we can really judge it ultimately on it's uh,
2:37 pm
honestly, i don't know. i think there's a couple of things we can take away. there was a little info at the start of this, but this being senior ukrainian ministry to monitor sadie since it started that bought different objectives. one of them mentioned that it's by. busy going off, russian forces a military focus from the don, yet score they were actually getting into a group started into maybe into mental games. and those other ones, one is the by the morales. but are you planning people on the ministry, especially the army which is being suffering a lot of heavy binding. i'm actually having to give ground in don. yes. sky for the last year and again, we have their sales offensive the summer last year. so this isn't a morales, i think finding a more early on in terms of the operation objectives. the other one is to show that they can kind of one still, the russian border is not safe. even areas which are, you know, not being. busy over are not say, the ukraine has the capability and the will to do this on the bills. so some sort of panic on, on in the day the stabilize the russian regime. i think they're the operation
2:38 pm
objectives from what i would say, i think what you're kind of getting out with your question, who is on, on an image and sort of picked up on again, an operation like this where they've got a good deal to surprise strong operational security and then manage to use mechanized forces with an air defense. i mean you got charged war for a whole lot of them to protect that takes a lot of planning. so this is the mean time for a while and there was some indications in the us media, and that's uh us defense secretary lloyd austin had asked you credit is not to go ahead with some operation a couple of months ago. question markup. but if you take that this operation probably talking about your most to prepare a few months ago is looking much more likely to balance on getting into the uh, the one has in january. that is the date on day 2. you would be flushing for it and you claims to need some sort of deal. then this operation makes much more sense strategic me because i got, may come to want, we would expect just so you know,
2:39 pm
you're going to be in crane and we'll. ready it or to hold at least some of the territory. ready they've got so far so far more of the information problem is come out of most go about what's going on there now. so the key, the creighton ends up being relatively quotes about this. um, the latest things i've seen, the governor of coast creation, the russian governor that says ukraine has advanced 12 kilometers controls 28 settlements. but the other thing is suggesting that the ukrainians have gone as far as 30 kilometers also. so one report say ukraine controls 430 square kilometers. that is the size of a small country, a pretty small country. i looked it up at 6, was exactly the size of the caribbean island of i'm kind of an island nation about that. you'd also probably tell us what you know about the current situation to hello gordon. this man off last said that the ukrainians have occupied the area of that so drama. there's one dentist,
2:40 pm
a deep and the $42.00 islanders by the same time. he said, we don't need the russians. he said, we don't know the russians don't know where the grading in mobile groups are as no establish trunk line at all. so that means that the cranial immobile groups could be much deeper and operating. keep behind rush in lines, and that's a band with the main, a success so far, the ukrainians, a, something that they sell to do last year, they broke through the russian lives. they are now after operational a free, they're moving in the mobile, they're fighting immobile war. what they wanted to do last year fail now, but yeah, they'll, this is in a very different area. but basically that makes sense. you are back to where the enemy is weaker and not where, where is the stronger and that has changed the battery very much. the overall
2:41 pm
position, the strategic position is shifting the rush and a sense of that began in spring a. she the lots of time of success, but that we know some basic break through the same direction. reserves are being between the next step. so now in the premium script times, we managed to put together a grant. some reserves wanted to do the restroom lines. there's the rushes, struggling not just to push them out, the russian baron just appears to stop them. and i believe the common couple months through october may be, are it into october when the autumn, where time comes to premiums will be trying to capitalize on this. but a sort of may be spreading out on the us, the governor said the 2000 russian civilians are under a gradient occupation and the rest does not know. ready that's with them on the
2:42 pm
120000 that you know, but actually that, that the 60000, they're still on the move. so we're talking about the, about to south $100000.00 russians being right now, becoming refugees in the course and, and, oh god. so this is of course a very serious problem for most patrick, when i 1st heard about this last week, i saw it was going to be straight in and quick out. so very, very quick incursion, but they are still there. it's a very old basis operation. as a full, a soldier and military military strategist, there's an operation like this. also the carry, pretty big risks. so yeah, no, i was surprised to james, you know, like because we, we basically were watching the finance having to slowly uh, not high cost to the russians, but nevertheless, continues to get a small amount of granted done yet. so you can start to think that they have, these are us already for gays,
2:43 pm
ready to go for this punch and are able to pull it up. it looks like the russians actually, the military near sue's or where the breaker. uh or telling them that there was a bill that might be a credit invoices, but the reason i come out and and knocked on it. so, um, yeah, it from my perspective, this is an operation that's been fine. really well and exactly like possible said one of the things it made it to stay on. they've done and done yet skins. our region, for example, isn't that russians have gotten molly called, persisted di sr, which means intelligence surveillance, reconnaissance, their reliance on their grounds make those jobs can see up to like the. ready kilometers behind the phone line, very difficult to move and i being seen depending difficult to concentrate your forces that they've been saying. and therefore ukraine has managed basically why a lot of their, their attacks and fails, you know, they, they just getting seen him before. he can do anything but what they want us to do by moving the focus to cars in an area where the russians have far less persist in di, sr. so they've been able to concentrate and use their arm or the german,
2:44 pm
modern times. their americans try come broadly, vehicles that comes through, and then they filled it with a lot of western air defense assets to protect it. so you basically want to put a bubble over your mechanized sources. and then you have electronic warfare capabilities, which you're trying to disrupt the drones or the, the questions i got assigned in, she was energetic, cetera. so yeah, it's being wow then exactly like tablets that they've broken through and know that the initiative is with those guys. the question is, in the longer term russian build up, start to show i'm pushing back of it. let's see. let's bring you in again. if i go back just over a year ago, year in 2 months ago, june the 24th. that's when the founders of lagging a group, you have any progression stays his rebellion that ended up very badly for him and everyone's still approved to the pin strength. and so now as you look at this, you'll view from keith. how humiliating is this for the russian president?
2:45 pm
oh, wow, this is a great question, james. because yes, this is, as i said before, this is the 1st time since the 2nd world war, the for an army has on george washington to try it and then switch it to a significant disease. so of course, this is an incredible blow as if with him and his forces, the official loss has happened to be announced. but we understand that the losses and of course region are happy because russia had lost the entire line of equipment from infantry too much vehicles to tax helicopters, aircraft. everything has been destroyed or captured. and meanwhile, the emanation captured from the russians is now being used against them to continue the operation. we have that information from the oppression brown at the defensive line on break experience of google's had been spanned, has been breached. this is another case of communication for the kremlin, i guess, and it is all 3 of it put and has become more afraid of police on milton street and
2:46 pm
the fact that they are a wage. so it just kind of grandma show long, but that comes to terrorist operation. we've been at this be in charge. but meanwhile, just recently, just a couple of hours ago, the meeting a pushing health imaging with a military preventative side. gotcha. and e a, she did a task to, uh, uh, to, to go to the cruise korean and to, to the find the russian charge very to m o d, and to the border gods service. so this is, this is quite interesting to see how, how far was uh, working under this a, in this very, very interesting situation and okay, let's see. probably you might see it differently. i don't see, tell us how this is being seen in moscow by the military leadership and ultimately
2:47 pm
people and you have the, let's see, is that talk about the f s b being put in charge? the spy agency? nope, the, the military. guten cook declared marshal laurel. say the russian was a mistake to look. war is put in, you know, talking talk, but doesn't want to spook the russian people too much. i don't know, butch, this actually holding back to the very beginning. he made statement. when he up and we a believe, does you believe in the beginning or if this is going to be just the ready to go in, go out a such res happened before and the premium russian border. uh now let's say we as we're much more a massive operation and he's kind of the resume that happens in session times. and 34 years ago or close to was on the news over time, the course new quarter, separate himself. and in august the 2,
2:48 pm
2000 and bush and kind of disappeared for several days from the news cycle and right now, but she doesn't know, or van community has no good news to say because because of that event 25 years ago, that was the very start of pollutants rule and it was, it was a really bad mobile friendly. it was a really bad moment for yes, it does a very bad moment. and now it's monday to, because right now the russian probably just find the frustrated the of course, people who are being eventually they are very angry and moscow. well, it seems through a big pass happening somewhere there. but again, it depends, a fresher, has a really degree just the, it's reserves so much at the origin reserves and dividing. that's happening for several months. and then finding that the next 3 gym and doesn't have enough back over the forces to switch straight for cal stuff and push out the brand new in from goes region. that's a serious political problem. maybe would love to have to declare
2:49 pm
a another way of mobilization, which would be extremely unpopular. so he's the, the rest of the brand one right now. and moscow is in the 6. want to do next, throw it against web and 5. and these are different pieces of our a, a barrel mill. that's true units trying to stop the radians, trying to defend strategically important position their right, the where power plant them chords and the bags. we matthew and 9 for sure. where are they? in brittany immobile units and where are they going to head from any direction? and so this is a very serious crisis in the process of developing a sparse patrick. we've heard how the russian people know all about the name coast . but of course, president putin is an avid reader and quote to of history and of course, cause the site one of the most decisive bottles of world war 2 of the biggest tank
2:50 pm
battle in history. do you think the historical residence is important here to yeah, i mean, i'm not rushing, but it obviously has most of the residents in terms of history. i think that'd be, you know, the maximum asset that the russians would probably do is to protect this house that, that new hire pine, 1st of all. and then behind that, the see of course, i thing, you know, as, as we're seeing this time developing, the ukraine just did a talking as of today. but the longer it goes on with these breakthroughs have been difficult because your enemy is working for us, is that the more difficult they usually get out of all way. but usually my goal is to keep advancing all say about the whole sustainment uh, issue of standing around for the deeper into uh, into russian territory over the longer a longer time. so while there is a risk to say, congress, i think the longer this the longer takes you payments even get there. and that's
2:51 pm
like the, the comes with all the a week into that operation. so, um, yeah, of course it has a different kinds but whether they actually get the car. so i think that's another question olds. yeah. let's see. um, let's just turn to where we were in the war and ukraine before this bold move by the ukranian side. and we talk about a stalemate. but actually in recent months and all this year, it's only been russia that's been making slight gains throughout the year. both sides to be losing manpower, huge losses. but of course, russia has a bigger source of band pop, then ukraine. so we'll see crane until this moment. very much on the back foot. uh well this is uh, also very interesting uh question because, you know, as i said before, uh, russian uh, operation of an offensive this home at sunset didn't stop. and if it was a russians had their success as well. but it's actually interesting to
2:52 pm
uh, just see the comparison of their results and their, their results in the ukraine and the certified to crane. and the results of course, ration and to compile them into and y as in result twice because this is so this was a 70 yvonne segmentation we can take as a do ration russian, some our offense to in your praying. they've lost more than a $7000.00 soldiers in casualties and they gain couple of villages and they're what it is not comparable, i guess uh, with a course cooperation with 6 days and a almost so she almost such a village is increased korean and many, many, almost be goats and people go uh, captured into the,
2:53 pm
the grains of to get to you so. uh yeah. actually it was not easy for you. cran. forces uh do you in the summer bugs uh where you can see one of the results i was talking about other off this operation in course is that uh, some of the reserves are already being pushed from the cartridge region and from the hardware spencer. and as of yesterday, uh, you print enforcers, grant that it was a less attacks from the russian side. uh in, in, in a box in mc. yes, it would be less and an intrinsic ascent. patrick wiring late. we've already mentioned this, there was a new, clear dimension in your assessment. do you think that they might the ukrainians might be going for the coast? nuclear pont? we've seen a file reported for each of that's the nuclear pond in ukraine. se you crate that's
2:54 pm
held by russia. do you think that is a coincidence? um, do you think that maybe some quite a new name perhaps to try and one for the other? yeah, it would make sense as maybe a secondary are nice to have objective if you can get us given the fact that the russians of pounds operation and but it to take it. but it's like that you need to do it in the early days by surprise. essentially, again, it seems sort of just in the last 24 hours of defense and being built around, or i would go with the bit since things that actually count the inner ends up version new kind of our model. go with the problem, the more likely course of action being, if the russians have done something there in an attempt to show that we still have leverage over there. so just be careful what you do in case you guys close to the car, 6 firefox, but he's looking at some of the 4 lines of own troops. so the brains, it's just a bad within our tennessee range. now, of course, he's financed on pay. buying is my pay by the rules. ready different way to the
2:55 pm
russian, so i'm going to just, you know, set up a bunch of artillery and stuff. i'm borrowing the cars, power plant. why would they say they have more of either international reputation? probably in the past we've seen a tax inside russia, but they were carried out by groups that are being helped by ukraine 90 pooped in groups. how. what do you think the kremlin will be that this will impala more of those groups? who may well have been working with the training on me to prepare this incursion? a lot of the there weren't actually no real reports of that. these kind of around gear. yeah. and then so they're considered as triggers, and they're, i mean, yeah, me, mon russia are really involved in this offensive. this the latest today. i heard that there are page 5 fresh and the russian side says that there are 35, your, your grading and briggs involved in the offense to do air bore and then the heavy.
2:56 pm
okay, but let me stop. you. let me, let me stop you that briefly. let's see. do you, have you heard any news that they're all, they're, all russians were thing on the side of ukraine and this offensive empty fulton groups. uh yeah i, i, i say not about the military groups, but about russian practice brands because we have witnessed some videos from the cruise korean on the matter. and we know that there are a large number of people, alabassic who disagree with fragments, policies, and for that people we have in a crane without state projects that could help them and contact them. so yeah, as of russian designs of the course of it's a trick with screeching charter tray. i would say that it is, it is true that they both sides. okay. the last word on that um how, how, how worried do you think the kremlin might be this moment? i think they're very worried because they don't know what's coming next. has been
2:57 pm
an issue different now on the north and they have broke through. they are operationally free, they can try to say the or the course and you clear background, but maybe maybe by this faith, brad, and say they can find a south and into the builder region and begin for robots and by a russian from the, from the re or maybe the dance, of course, on their bass and also absolutely, yeah. how much reserves he managed to secretly put together, i'll be seriously the budget m. can they ask your overturn the last bonds of the russian from or so just going to be calling in the rush or maybe the whole bit the rush or i would say, well, it is very embarrassing. but that does not really good to go to a great show for the russian regime for moscow. and i believe right now for most of
2:58 pm
the worst possible scenario is that there is a serious d. that was the issue of the, from on the north. and the russia like in september 20 to have to declare a partial mobilization, additional partial mobilization, which would be very detrimental, politically speaking, the comic was big. okay. title. that's very interesting. thank you. 20, 3 of august today. elisia 40 i nova pub, old folk, and hoya, and patrick brewery. it's a false moving situation, but you can watch and follow out to 0 for the latest developments, our website is out as their adult calm. what do you think about the situation you'll come in? so, welcoming on facebook page, that's facebook dot com, forward slash a j inside story or tweet. so what's now officially cool x we are at a inside story for all of us here. thanks for joining us. i'll see you again soon. thank you. by the of
2:59 pm
african stories from african perspectives. really, but i need to do more. we've mainly to show a documentary used by african filmmakers from morocco, and kenya, close to pieces, can cut down to your one with the customers. it's can you move them into the echoes of unity and kenyon on mars a new series of africa direct on i'll just the era the
3:00 pm
. ringback the . ready ready hello, i'm sorry, i'm to lising and don't have a quick look at the main stories this. how now greece is baffling. the lawn just fi of the year for the day, which is fast moving towards athens. at least one person has died and 66 of us have been injured on the outskirts of the capital. hundreds of 5 fighters battling the inferno which broke out on sunday. when the authorities are evacuating towns and hospitals near athens as flames destroy, forest and homes. countries in europe all sending 5 flies.

10 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on