tv HAR Dtalk BBC News February 29, 2024 11:30pm-12:01am GMT
11:30 pm
georgia has just been granted eu candidate status and talks ofjoining nato, yet its government is seen as sympathetic to russia. it's a diplomatic tightrope, and one my guest needs to walk. salome zourabichvili is the country's president. where does georgia's destiny lie — with russia or the west? salome zourabichvili, welcome to hardtalk.
11:31 pm
thank you for having me for the third time. do you think that russia wants control of georgia? russia wants control of not only georgia, but probably parts of europe. it has its... ..old ambitions and old aspirations of remaining as an imperialist state. but should we be thinking about what russia wants or what we want? well, the last time that you came on hardtalk, which was at a time when russia was on the back foot in ukraine, it was the end of 2022. you said you didn't think russia would invade georgia. the situation in ukraine looks very different now. and i wonder if you fear for georgia, particularly if president putin is successful in ukraine? well, i think that we should, again, all fear if president putin is successful in ukraine. but i don't think that he is successful in ukraine. he has been losing in ukraine
11:32 pm
all his first ambitions, strategic ambitions — taking kyiv, dividing the government and the population, dividing ukraine from europe, dividing european between themselves, european with their populations. all of these big ambitions have not materialised. so, yes, he's not yet defeated strategically, militarily, but he is not victorious. so i think that it's the time... but he is at this moment in time.. ..to gather efforts. but he is at the moment taking land. and i wonder if there's a situation, and georgia knows this full well, because russian troops invaded in 2008, if he retains control of part of ukraine, do you fear what that means for georgia? we all, again, we all have to fear what it means if russia retains land and does not have to retreat in its own internationally
11:33 pm
recognised borders. but, at the same time, georgia has not been invaded once, georgia has been invaded three times at least, and we can count more. so there is nothing much more that russia has to do. russia is occupying our territories. it's not a question of separatism. it's a question of directly occupying russia's military bases on our territory. so what russia is now trying to do, and will continue as it does with other countries in europe and elsewhere, it's a hybrid war which has already started. it's trying to win through propaganda, it's trying to destabilise. today, we add another person that has been hijacked in the occupied territories. it's all the time on this non—existing border that they're taking hostages. so the constant attempts
11:34 pm
to destabilise georgia is something that we know very well. 0k. one thing that we can say is that probably we are a bit more resilient than other countries would be in that situation because of the experience, because the georgian population knows quite well. well, i want to come on, and we'll talk about the breakaway regions in a moment, butjust in terms of the war in ukraine, russia is building a deep—sea port in abkhazia, one of these breakaway parts of georgia. president zelensky said russia announced the creation of a new base, but we will reach them everywhere. that port, could that see georgia being dragged into the war? it could. it's a project. it's, again, part of the russian propaganda for the time being, the way mr putin, as an old kgb agent, he's, infact, waging a psychological war more than a military war. and it has been true with ukraine,
11:35 pm
it's true with the rest. it's very important what's happening with this port. and i think that it's something that the europeans should realise, because it's the black sea that is at stake. nobody can afford to see russia taking control of this part of the black sea, which is our coast on the black sea, because that means that all the projects for the future that the european union has with connectivity, strategic transport over the black sea and connection with the rest of... over the caucasus to the central asian countries, that is something that we all need very much, is at stake there. so we need... you talk about it being a psychological game. there's been dredging there. do you not think that that sea port will be built? i don't know. it's not for the time being. it's something that is a project that is announced with very loud voices. but what i'm saying is that we should react
11:36 pm
to that already now, we shouldn't wait for the port to be coming into function, which will take probably one or two years if they decide to go ahead. that's now that we need to have the europeans consider that in the black sea, they cannot be evicted by russia. they have to... what can they do about it? sorry, what are you calling on the eu to do? they have to restart what was happening before, which is the port calls in the black sea, in georgia, especially in the port of batumi, poti. they have to support the creation of anaklia port, where we should see active investment of the european union and of the americans. it shouldn't be words that we need... that's not going to stop russia building that port there. excuse me? that's not going to stop russia building that port. no, but we should be ahead. what, so that literally they can face off against each other? well, they are facing off one way or the other. but i think that the determination should be there and seen that
11:37 pm
european union considers what it is now that, the black sea is de facto a european sea, where europe has a right to be present, where europe cannot be excluded. and that's something that can be discussed together with turkey, which is a very important partner in the black sea, something that should interest uk. russia being cut off from the west has led to increased trade with georgia. there's been a hugejump in imports in the first year of the war. georgia's also the land route from turkey to russia. is that bringing the two countries together, because georgia's even more dependent on russia? we're a bit more dependent towards russia. we are less dependent than many countries have been on energy matters, because we have a close neighbour that is azerbaijan, and that has helped us to avoid this dependency. we're dependent in exports and imports of products, mainly agricultural products
11:38 pm
and some cars, shipments. but it has brought georgia a bit closer to russia. but that doesn't mean that georgia is closer to russia. that will never happen, because we have the occupied territories, because we have our history. we know how much closer we can get, which was not the case for some of the european countries that let themselves to be overwhelmed by the energy dependency towards russia. 0k. so do you think...? to hear you, one would think you would... georgia needs to choose betweenjoining nato and the eu on the one hand, and russia on the other. georgia has chosen. constantly, since 30 years, the georgian population, when asked — or when it has to march on the streets, it marches — constantly, 80% of the population, and that's a very high percentage, say that it wants europe, it wants nato,
11:39 pm
and it doesn't want anything else. there is no other perspective for georgia. 0k. but there's a difficulty, which you will be fully aware of, which is that the politicians, despite what the polls suggest, appear to play both sides. and we have the then prime minister of the governing party, georgian dream, now its chair, irakli garibashvili, said lastjune one of the reasons russia invaded ukraine was ukraine's will and determination to become a member of nato. therefore, we see the consequences. and yet you're making it clear the government has said that it wants to join it. so what would that mean? governments come and go. the georgian population's will has been unchanged over 30 years of independence. it has been unchanged before that, because one of the countries that was the most reticent to the soviet rule was georgia. but if we leave with the recent period, georgian population is very determined. and i think that what is important
11:40 pm
to see is that since the decision of the european union in december to grant the candidate status, the government has changed its rhetoric. the government has changed, the prime minister is gone and there is a new prime minister who is now with a completely new rhetoric, very pro—european, has been to brussels as a first trip. they've just swapped places. they have swapped places, but they have swapped... the prime minister and the chair. and that's very important. if that forces a consensus, that's fine, and i can only hail that. if not, whichever government will not be definitely on the european side will not win the next elections. but we're in a situation where we have the... he's now chairman of the party saying the european parliament's been trying to drag georgia into the war against russia. are you saying that's...?
11:41 pm
no, i'm saying that he has said that he's president of the party. that party is going into elections in october and the georgian population's will is unaltered by these declarations. let's talk about the strange situation, because the truth is that georgia can'tjoin nato, for a start, because of the breakaway regions of abkhazia and south 0ssetia. and that's not going to change, is it? why is it not going to change? can you see...? for 30 years, abkhazia and south 0ssetia have been separate. can you...? have been occupied. and i can see... i mean, i know some examples. germany was one. so i'm never going to say that there is no hope for reuniting not only territories, but populations. and the very big hope, the very clear path towards one form of reunion of these occupied territories is what? it's a european pass, it's european integration.
11:42 pm
butjust wait one second. we should make clear to people what you're talking about, because the georgians, and we're talking about a fifth of what was georgia... 20% of our territory. indeed. exactly. and there were georgians who were displaced. and now it's those two territories, south 0ssetia particularly, extremely dependent on russia. there's no will to be reunited with georgia in those territories. in south 0ssetia, there is no will. south 0ssetia is a large military base with people that are living there, that are basically the people working for the military base. so there, i agree, you cannot talk about political will. the case in abkhazia is very different. abkhazia has been discovering that what russia had promised, which would be to consolidate its identity, to consolidate its language, culture, all of that has not happened. and not only it has not happened, but russia has been putting
11:43 pm
very heavy pressure to counter what is the political will of the people that are living in abkhazia, which is never to give their lands to russia, never to allow that their sovereignty be contested. and that's what has been happening. but the people of abkhazia may not want to be part of russia, but they don't want to be part of georgia. no, but they might want to be part of european union together with georgia. so that is the aim — eu membership and then... that is the perspective that we can offer to them if they do not see georgia reintegrating. georgia, as sometimes is said, as a perspective, they can see coming together with us in the european union as a perspective. so this... but...
11:44 pm
since...the eu candidate status was granted at the end of last year, can you see a point at which georgia will be an eu member? certainly. i think my immediate... i've lived practically and i came back to georgia as the first diplomat and then the minister and then the president, after having been in the parliament, basically for that. that is my aim and my strong belief. and i've seen georgia going from, when i came back the first time, in europe, it was said that georgia could not evenjoin the neighbourhood policy, that we were too far away for that. and i've seen neighbourhood policy association, visa liberalisation, all the things that somebody would have thought completely impossible 30 years ago. you talk about the political changes since that status was granted. one of the things that changed is that bidzina ivanishvili, the founder of the governing party georgian dream, has said he is back in frontline politics. now, we should explain.
11:45 pm
this is a man who is considered by many to be an oligarch, georgia's only oligarch. he made a fortune in russia that's estimated to be around a third of the wealth of georgia. there are a number of conditions that the eu has put on georgia. prominent among them is the de—oligarchisation. now, when eu says that, is that who they're talking about? i will be precise. the eu has put as a condition... ..system of prevention of oligarchisation, not what is called... so it doesn't matter that he's back in front...? no, it matters. it matters. it's good thing that he's back in politics, because that takes away this part of shadowiness, which was a very big problem of not knowing where the source of power, of having no responsibility, no... ..necessity to be answerable to the population. so i think, personally, that it's much better to have him in a clear position, even if he's a wealthy man. and we see that in many
11:46 pm
other countries that... they're not called oligarchs, they are called billionaires that are very influential. what i think is very important... in december 2022, the european parliament called on the eu to sanction him. well, the european parliament, and it has not been sanctioned. that's not the question of power. and the question of system, which is very important, is that we have to put in place the conditions for preventing the oligarch power in the country. and that, i think, is a concern for many other countries than georgia. where i think is more directly a concern for georgia, if we're talking about system of power, is the fact that we are still in a one—party system. that's why it's very bad that the vertical of the system, which is a one—party system, is one person. 0k. so you are... and we should explain this. i mean, you're president, but it's a largely ceremonial role.
11:47 pm
you have been... the government tried to impeach you. we have elections coming this year. if it's largely ceremonial, why did they want to impeach me? well, 0k. why did they want to? i will answer. i will. what is your answer to that question? my answer is the same as gutierrez when he was asked, "what is your power?" and he answered, "it's the word, it's speaking." and that's the same thing. in a country, when you have a word that is recognised, that you are legitimate, because i was elected by the people, you can say many things and you can be very influential. so probably it was more of a political attempt to limit... we have elections this year. what does that mean, then, for the elections? what are you planning to do? i'm first planning to play my role as the president to the end, because i think that this institute, as an independent institute, has a very big role to play. to be on one side, and i intend to do that, to oversee the way the elections are going to be
11:48 pm
prepared and handled. the second thing i want to see what the government, who is now promising to do everything that's needed by the nine recommendations. there are now nine left of the european union. i will see and push so that they are doing their part of the work. will you vote for them? at the same time... i'm not going to tell you who i'm going to vote for. but you're not going to stand. for elections? yes. in the elections, no, i'm not going to go down in the political arena. i am the president. my mandate goes until the election. let me ask you — do you trust georgian dream to maintain and improve the democracy in georgia? they have to. otherwise, the georgian... do you trust them? they don't have to be trusted. if they do not do it, if they do not deliver in the timeframe that has been given by the european union, the georgian people are not going to vote for them. and that's the reason why they have
11:49 pm
changed the rhetoric. that's the reason why they are now saying that they're going to do everything possible to put in action these nine recommendations. we'll see. i'm going to be like the georgian voter. i'll look at what has been done. but at the same time, i'm working with all other political parties to prepare a platform that would be the platform that would be put into action by whoever comes into the parliament at the next elections. and i would wish that it be a coalition government. why? because i think the time has come for georgia, which has done the long way towards democracy, to move from a one—party system that is a legacy of the old times to a coalition government. you talk about the powers that you have as president. one of them is to be involved in what happens next to mikheil saakashvili, who is in prison. he is...
11:50 pm
the pictures of him show that he has been incredibly ill. i mean, they are quite shocking. should he still be in prison? well, i think that saakashvili is not navalny. and these comparisons that we hear... he compares... he's georgia's former leader. he's georgia's former leader that is injail because of the things that he has been doing when he was a president, not as a political opponent, but as a former president. so the answer to my question, should he still be in prison? i think that it's not for me to judge whether he should be in prison or not. it's for thejudges, for the georgian population. but the fact is that the georgian population, in its vast majority, consider that he has been, while he was the president of georgia, overdoing his power in many, many... ..respects. and that's why he's in jail. now, on the humanitarian side that
11:51 pm
you were talking about, i have been very involved in overseeing what was happening to him, trying to make sure that the treatment that were delivered were... there are reports that he's been tortured and has been poisoned. do you believe that? no. you absolutely don't believe that? i don't. and you say it's down to the courts and down to the people, but you have a role and you have been pressed. i've been pressed. and the more i'm pressed, the more difficult it will get, because i cannot accept that the discretionary power of pardoning, which belongs to the president and which is the fate also of many other people that are in jail, in very different conditions, i cannot accept that it's put under pressure either from within or from outside. so the pardoning power is something that is my moral decision, which i will take without informing anyone in advance.
11:52 pm
which is why you have ref... you told hardtalk you wouldn't pardon him. then in an interview with radio free europe in mid—december, you said, "i've not refused to pardon him." it's still a question mark. it's a question mark. the former us ambassador to russia, michael mcfaul, said that saakashvili's death injail would be a victory for putin and a blow to georgian democracy. is he right? i don't think he will die in prison. i'm trying to and i will oversee until the end that this doesn't happen, because i agree that that would be a terrible blow for georgia's reputation, which we cannot let happen. that's why i was in daily contact with all the authorities involved, to be sure that nothing of that kind would be happening. but at the same time, there are other ways the government is directly responsible, the justice minister. the possibility of extradition is still there. ukraine and poland have
11:53 pm
said they'll take him. yeah. so that's the government's responsibility. is that the route you think will happen? it might. just a final thought. we're talking about georgia, because of geography, because of politics, being almost at a pivot point. is that how you see it with the elections coming up this year, that these elections are critical to the future of georgia? it is certainly a very decisive year. but at the same time, when i look back, i think i must have said that almost every year, because we are living, really, since independence, an almost yearly existential situation where we never know next year what will be the situation, that's why we have to be so determined and so united. salome zourabichvili, thank you for coming on hardtalk. already? already. thank you very much for having me.
11:54 pm
hello there. we did manage something would bite her because northern areas, though here in shetland, we did have some fairly strong winds that brought with it some quite large waves. 0n into the forecast now and looking quite a cold start to the day for the northern half of the uk on friday with some patches of frost around and into that cold air comes an area of low pressure. the
11:55 pm
inclusion here rings with the risk of some hill snow. we could see some snowfall in the hills above 200 metres elevation, across the high ground in northern ireland, the amount of snow we are going to get is going to vary a lot from place to place. cold outbreaks of rain. temperatures really struggling underneath that slow—moving band of rain, probably two or three degrees for eight good chunk of the day. 0therwise which are g temperatures away from that around 8—9 . 0n into friday night, that same area of low pressure stays with us, the risk of some snow over the highest hills into parts of scotland, potentially, another cold one with frost developing in rural areas to take us into the start of the weekend. a week and i will continue to be dominated by the same
11:56 pm
area of low pressure. at least the low pressure will be weakening over the top of the uk but is how we get to sunday. weather—wise, sunshine and showers. showers for the widespread, so most places will see downpour two, and some of the areas could have mixed in. not going to cause an impact. tempers below average for the time of the year. highs ranging between six and nine celsius. the second half of the weekend is a little bit cheerier. although the area of low pressure is still with us and will continue to bring showers, especially the part of scotland, northern ireland and perhaps into the northwest of both england and wales, further south, showers could be relatively few and far between, there could be a few more in the way of brighter spells pushing through. that will help lift temperatures still a little bit below average for the time of year. monday, another area of low pressure moving in from the atlantic. the
11:57 pm
risk of some localised flooding given how what the weather has been over the course of february, but across scotland and eastern areas of england, it stays dry and bright. beyond that, we've got something of a battle zone across the uk, the jet stream will continue to bring areas of low pressure off the atlantic to bring some rain at times to western areas of the country, whereas eastern areas of the country, we are closer to an area of high—pressure. across western parts of the country, cloud and rain at times. temperatures generally around 10-12 c, but the temperatures generally around 10—12 c, but the driest of the weather, the brightest of the weather, the brightest of the weather, will be across eastern areas of scotland and eastern areas of england. it's a bit milder in london, temperatures reaching around 14 degrees by the time we get to the following weekend. that's the latest weather. bye for now.
11:59 pm
12:00 am
has killed at least a0 people. president joe biden and donald trump may competing visits to the us—mexico border to address a surge in illegal crossings which is a key theme for voters. thousands of south korean trainee doctors or refused to return to work on thursday, the day the government says is a deadline to end the mass walk—out. we start this hour with events in the middle—east. more than a hundred people are reported to have been killed in gaza as they tried to reach a convoy carrying food aid. crowds of people had gathered to get close to the lorries: israel's military told the bbc tonight that it killed a handful of people they believed were a threat — a palestinian witness told the bbc that most of those who died were run
23 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
BBC News Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on