Skip to main content

tv   The Media Show  BBC News  May 15, 2024 3:30am-4:01am BST

3:30 am
we will have the headlines for you at the top of the hour, which is straight after this programme.
3:31 am
3:32 am
3:33 am
3:34 am
to the press, and they had some very light media training, you know, just teaching them how not to get tripped up. and if you can imagine, the press are kept outside the campus in this huge line and are let in at a certain time. you have 100 journalists swarming this encampment, and you have six or seven students just trying to field all these requests, journalists fighting over them. so that was one of the things that they learned from '68, wasjust this discipline of message, making sure they say the right things and their words couldn't be twisted. i saw that some high—profile journalists in america have been criticising the protesters for not speaking to media outlets. it sounds to me like it was easy for you to speak to the people who'd been designated, but you couldn'tjust go around asking other students to talk to you. or did you try that? i wonder what your take is on what people are saying about that. i was turned down a couple of times, but it's completely understandable. any sort of protest situation, not everyone wants to talk to you. and one example, i went up
3:35 am
to one student at one point and said, "hey, do you mind if i talk to you a few minutes?" and he said, "what's your name?" and i told him my name. he googled me in two seconds and he was reading out my biography and said, "0h, you've covered syria. "you worked in the middle east. ok, let's do this." so they were very savvy. vetting you on the ground. yeah! i think if someone had trouble getting interviews with them, it was probably because the students didn't trust them. did you come across studentjournalists who were also trying to get access? did you interact with student journalists at all while you were covering it? they were everywhere that night. yeah, they were at every barricade, in every side street. they had special markers on their back saying "studentjournalist" to identify themselves. deeply, deeply impressed by their commitment to get out there and get involved. i saw student protesters following the live stream of the radio station. that was their tool to keep up—to—date on everything that was happening. so, yeah, they were everywhere that night. really interesting. richard hall from the independent, thank you. well, next let's talk about student journalists, because they've been commended by the pulitzer prize board for covering protests and unrest in the face of great personal and academic risk. julia vargas jones
3:36 am
is a master's student at columbia journalism school and also a freelance reporter. julia, welcome to the media show. i know that you were covering some of these events for cnn. just tell us how that happened. well, thank you for having me. well, i had, you know, i had a connection with cnn before — i'd worked with them for many years. and in the moment, you know, i got a call from another classmate, natasha caragnano. she called me at around 3am, and she said, "you should be here." and honestly, i didn't even ask cnn if they really wanted me to go. ijust said, "i'm here, you should take me live," and we started coverage from the occupation. i think when i got there, we were about six, seven hours in. and i did talk to people, you know, i was able to talk to people who were not media trained and said, "look, i'm not media trained. "i can't give you an interview." i'm like, "look, i'm a fellow student. "i want to report for the entire world. "we're about to go live on cnn.
3:37 am
"i need to know a little bit of what's going on. "help me out here. "i want to understand, how did the night go? "was it peaceful? "like, what happened after people went inside?" and i think, obviously being a student, i was able to build that trust with some of the protesters. julia, i'm interested — so you call up cnn and you say, "i'm here, i can go on air as soon as you like." but what are the practicalities of that? because you've been woken up at 3am in the morning, you've rushed down to where the story is. what are the practicalities of getting on air? i'm assuming you're using your phone. or am i wrong? yes, so, you kind of need two phones and a tiny tripod with a ring light and microphones, wireless microphones, and a headset, a very simple, bare—bones headset. now, throughout the day, we were able to charge.
3:38 am
i actually had to recruit some fellow master's students to help me and be my camera operators. the biggest challenge of the coverage was, eventually, the phones started dying, batteries started running out and we just had to make do with whatever we had. so it's switching phones, it's switching live methods. so every time that you saw me come back up, i was probably trying to figure out another logistical issue before i could, you know, talk to the anchors at cnn. while you were dealing with all of that, and you were no doubt encountering lots of other students who were reporting on it... you mentioned columbia's journalism school. i know a makeshift newsroom was established to deal with the level of interest in this story. just tell us what that was like. i have to commend the journalism school for everything that they did to help student journalists continue reporting. a lot of people arrived there.
3:39 am
student journalists arrived there after the gates were closed, and the dean and the vice deans had to physically escort people into the building. in one of the main halls of the journalism school, there was coffee, water, pizzas, snacks, advice from very established professors, people that have been in the industry for 30, 40 years. so i think it was probably the best education injournalism that this cohort is going to get. julia, thanks for speaking to us. that's julia vargas jones, a master's student at columbia journalism school. well, next, let's assess how effective the protesters have been about getting their message out via the media and how media coverage, especially via the mainstream, has shaped americans' perspective on the protests. doug mcleod is professor ofjournalism at the university of wisconsin—madison. doug, welcome to the media show. i know you've been studying how the media frames protest. and you use an interesting term, you talk about the protest paradigm. just explain what you mean by that. yeah, well, we've been studying social media coverage of social protest for over 35 years.
3:40 am
we've studied it across a variety of different protest contexts, both left and right groups, abortion groups, environmental groups, black lives matter anarchists, a whole host of different types of protest topics. and one of the things that emerged when we looked at mainstream newspaper and television coverage of these protests was a certain common pattern of covering social protests. the stories look pretty similar in terms of structure and the way the protest was covered. and that's what we call the protest paradigm, a way of covering social protest. so what are the pitfalls that news organisations can fall into, in your view? so, one of the pitfalls is really getting caught up in looking for dramatic stories, dramatic images, looking for, say, conflicts between protesters and police or between protesters on one side of the issue and protesters on the other. as rich talked about before, it looks like a war scene, and it makes great video images.
3:41 am
but one of the real problems is that the issues, the underlying issues of the protest, sort of get lost in the process. are you saying that the media isn't interested in peaceful protest, i'm wondering? well, i would say calm, rational protest that stands up to have expressed an opinion to try to influence public and policy on a given issue is unlikely to get a lot of media attention unless they can create a certain amount of drama that fits what journalists are often looking for. uh, and so you often see clashes with the police. you often see incidents of property damage, even though in many of these protests, the people who are actually engaged with, uh, police or other counter protesters is a small fraction of the larger protest group. and so when it comes to these protests that we've been seeing and they've obviously been
3:42 am
punching out across the media, you know, certainly across america and wider here in the uk. um, some people have been saying that the student protests have overshadowed their cause. has the message cut through, or how has the message cut through, do you think, and how does that, um, reflect the coverage? yeah, i think it's a pretty good example of what we're talking about with the protest paradigm. there has been a ton of attention on our campus at the university of wisconsin, on the police removing the encampments from campus, uh, and arresting protesters. it's pretty similar to the way, uh, the protest has been covered across campuses. um, the nod to what the protesters are looking for in terms of things like divestment are sort of briefly acknowledged within these stories, but there's little exploration of what divestment means. what are the investments of a university in israel or with companies that supply the israeli military? what is it that is problematic about what universities are doing that have
3:43 am
led to the complaints that the protesters, um, are trying to allege against the administration? it's very hard, as a member of the public to really, um, divine what it is that the protest is all about. and so if you don't have a lot of thorough discussion, uh, of what the protest is about — the protest looks very foreign to you, very disruptive, uh, particularly radical tactics of the protesters tend to be focused on and their, their issues kind of get lost in the clutter. professor mcleod, thank you. we've heard three perspectives on these campus protests. let's hear one more. we'rejoined by shaina oppenheimer from bbc monitoring. shaina, you're with us from jerusalem, and we're going to speak to you about
3:44 am
a couple of subjects on today's media show. but i was interested to ask you, you spend your time looking at media coverage that you can view from jerusalem. i wonder how these campus protests have been covered in israel. i think it's important to understand, kind of as a starting point, that the israeli media does not really cover what happens in gaza from a humanitarian standpoint. there are very little images of the civilian impact of israel's military actions there. so then israelis have a really hard time comprehending or understanding what the anger is and why people are protesting on college campuses in the us. so the media kind of use interchangeable terms like anti—israel protests and anti—semitic protests without ever mentioning the cause and the reason why students were protesting. and they take these images that we were talking about of the most extreme cases of violence, and they use it to kind of question and perhaps
3:45 am
delegitimize, some people would say, the protest movement at large, without contextualising it at all. shaina, you are going to be staying with us. before we carry on talking, let me say thanks to richard hall, professor doug mcleod, and julia vargas jones, who've been with us, as we've talked about those campus protests in the us. shaina, let's stick with what's happening in israel. um, because israel's government has shut down the operations of the aljazeera television network in the country for the duration of its war in gaza. here's a clip of their correspondent, imran khan, announcing the move, to viewers on sunday. if you are watching this pre—recorded report than al jazeera has been banned in the territory of israel. allowed the prime minister to ban al jazeera. he has now enacted that law. that was aljazeera's imran khan. prime minister benjamin netanyahu says the israeli cabinet agreed to the closure while the war in gaza is ongoing.
3:46 am
as i said, shaina oppenheimer from bbc monitoring jerusalem, you are still here. just tell us why, why it's happened. well, the israeli government, i mean, in general, israelis do not view aljazeera quite favourably. as i mentioned, there isn't really a lot of coverage of how israeli policies, um, affect palestinian civilians. so there's an inability to understand where aljazeera is coming from in that sense, now, during the war, and at large. and there's this long—time accusation that aljazeera works kind of in kudos with hamas. people in israel see it certainly as a mouthpiece. so for a long time, israel has not seen aljazeera favourably. and certainly when this war started, this idea of perhaps doing something to shut its operations has kind of been in the background. and the timing was quite sensitive, because at the end
3:47 am
of the day, aljazeera is based in qatar, and qatar is quite a key player in negotiations with hamas. and there are even ongoing negotiations right now. let's bring in mohamed moawad, who's managing editor of aljazeera, and with us live from doha. uh, mr moawad, thank you very much indeed for your time. um, following this vote, mr netanyahu claimed in a statement that aljazeera reporters had harmed israel's security and incited against soldiers and has called your network a hamas mouthpiece. how would you respond to that? uh, these are unfounded, uh, unfounded, uh, baseless- allegations that the israeli government is, is, - unleashing against us. and, uh, this is the least . dangerous action they have taken against al jazeera. we've lost, uh, three colleagues covering l from the front line of this conflict, and they were i targeted by air strikes. so, uh, to be honest, - this is the least dangerous action by the israeli government. - and, uh, um, this is something
3:48 am
that we have heard before, - uh, against aljazeera - from the authoritarian regimes in the, in the mena region, in the middle east. - uh, when they shut down offices for aljazeera, - uh, with the aftermathj of the arab spring, uh, this is the, the same, uh, . authoritarian, uh, playbook. and, uh, to be honest,l we see that as, as a way to conceal what's - happening inside gaza. well... we heard today from israel hayom that the minister i ofjustice in israeljust told the, uh, hostages familiesj that, uh, he is watching - aljazeera because he knows arabic and he's watching i aljazeera to follow what's happening with the negotiationsl and the war, because netanyahu is not telling them much about what's going on. l let me pick up on a couple of things. first of all, israel denies targeting aljazeera journalists. indeed, it denies targeting, uh, alljournalists. also, the israeli, israeli intelligence,
3:49 am
uh, accuses aljazeera of revealing the locations of the israeli army in some of your coverage. do you accept that perhaps in some of your coverage, you have accidentally given away information that could put israel's military at risk? i don't think covering from the front line i of the conflict, uh, - giving voice to the voiceless, uh, uncovering the atrocities committed in gaza _ that was described i by the united nations and other, uh, humanitarian organisations as, uh, - war crimes, i don't think this is revealing positions - for israeli forces or. something like that. this is a fine journalism. this is the core mission- ofjournalism around the globe. and that's our mission. we're giving voice to the voiceless. i we're reporting the gazan side, and we're reporting _ the israeli side. i mean, we're airing the statements- by israeli government officials, _ and we are being criticised, by the way, in the middle east
3:50 am
that we are airing them. - people are criticising, - criticising us and saying that aljazeera is givingj a platform for, uh, for the israeli government lies and that we are airing - after them what contradicts what they are saying, - because they go on air and say we, we care about civilians. i and then we report that - hundreds are killed in their... this is your immediate reaction to the ban by mr netanyahu and his colleagues. is there anything further that you can do about this? can you challenge the ban legally? of course — we've . started the process. we are pursuing all legal- actions to make sure that we, uh, you know, counter these unfounded allegations. - and we are sure that, you know, that the whole israeli _ government and the israel. is now, uh, is being tested. the democracy in israel- is being tested because they are using the same playbook of the authoritarian regimesl in the middle east, but they'rej calling themselves democracy. so let's see if, if, - if the israeli institutions are going to defend -
3:51 am
freedom of speech and, uh, you know, the freedom ofjournalists to operate . in israel, uh, - in front of the court. mohamed moawad, managing editor of aljazeera, with us from doha, thank you very much indeed for speaking to the media show. thanks to shaina oppenheimer, too, from bbc monitoring. thank you. i want to turn to something very, very different now, but it would have been hard to miss. the photographs earlier in the week, splashed across the media, as stars took to the red carpet in sometimes questionable and often entirely impractical outfits for the annual met gala in new york. but of course, practicality isn't the point, i get that. um, i just want to give you a taste of the jamboree for the dozens of photographers at the event. here is the arrival of ariana grande and cynthia erivo. ladies, turn together. turn together. together! this way. cynthia. and look in here, ari... there you go.
3:52 am
it's a hugely profitable co—mingling of celebrities, sponsors and brands overseen by vogue magazine supremo anna wintour. and it's... the met gala is the source of seemingly endless coverage, fascinating and baffling in equal measure. and we're lucky enough to say we've got someone who was there to cover it, here on the media show, uh, jada yuan, features reporter at the washington post. some people won't have seen the photos. others will. just explain, though, how big a media event is the met ball? uh, it's, it's huge. it, um, it comprises not just of the red carpet, which is kind of famous, along the steps of the, um, of the metropolitan museum of art, and this time was not red, but actually, um, green and beige, with hedges of real plants along the side. it's a, it's a huge production. the tent is up there for days and you have, um, just hundreds of reporters and photographers
3:53 am
inside this scrum. but then you also have a side show that has — this sort of social media side show that's been happening at nearby hotels where, um, crowds will gather, um, tojust take photographs of stars as they get into vans to drive two blocks over to the museum, and yeah, it's just, it's just insane. and how do you get your spot? where, where do you stand as a reporter? where were you this time? we're, we're way at the top. we're at the — i'm at the upper end of the lowerend of the food of the food chain. is that good or bad? i can't quite work it out. it's not, it's not great. i mean, the whole game of being a reporter at the met gala, other thanjust sort of taking in the sights of, of these ridiculous outfits and just the crush of celebrity that's coming through is to try and get them to come and talk to you. and my videographer found a box, and wejustjumped up
3:54 am
on top of this box, so we were taller than everyone else and were able to sort of shout a little bit louder. and that's how we managed to get some folks over to us. and who did you get to speak to you? lana del rey, jeff goldblum, um, nicole kidman. there were some people... not bad at all. yeah. we probably had 20 or 30 people at least. the thing i'm always fascinated by is what actually happens inside. do you know what they do? do they go in and change immediately into something more comfortable, or do they stick like that for the whole evening? yeah, i know, even though i've never been inside myself, there's a few reporters who've been able to get in, but it's mostly closed to the press. um, i think that most of them take off their giant trains and their huge hats, and they're, like, lana del rey was wearing a crown of thorns. and i hope for everyone's sake around her that she didn't have those on still, and then i
3:55 am
think it's, it'sjust a party. it's a party inside the met. i've been to other parties at the met. it's usually really beautifully lit, and i know there's usually a performance. and so you might be sitting at a table and beyonce might get up on and sing onstage. and then... and then everyone leaves incredibly early. i mean, rihanna is always an hour late. she didn't come this year, cos she had the flu. but usually as she's walking in, people are leaving and they're going to the after parties. 0k. sounds great. a party that not many journalists are invited to, but one day, jada, one day. jada yuan from the washington post, thanks so much. i'm afraid that's it for today. thanks to all our guests. we'll be back at the same time next week. but it's goodbye from me, katie razzall. and from me, ros atkins. thanks for watching. we'll see you soon. bye— bye. and if you'd like to hear a longer version of today's show, search bbc the media show, wherever you get your bbc podcasts.
3:56 am
hello. we've some damp weather out there at the moment, and there's also some rain in the forecast for wednesday — not an awful lot. here's the outlook for the rest of the week — a bit of a mixed bag, a little bit of sunshine, some scattered showers, but at least it'll be relatively warm. now, on the satellite picture, you'll notice this swirl of cloud — that's an area of low pressure. this is the weather front, and this low pressure will stick around really for the rest of the week. so actually, the overall weather pattern won't change an awful lot across the uk, but there will be some regional differences from day to day, of course. here's the morning, then — around 7am, we will have had temperatures between 12—14 celsius, some damp, if not at times wet, weather from east anglia into lincolnshire and along these eastern counties. but elsewhere, it's a bright and even sunny start to the day, and through the afternoon, i think our best weather will be in the north of scotland. some sunshine there in the highlands, and temperatures could reach 23 celsius.
3:57 am
that's the exception, though — for most of us, it'll be in the range of 18—20 celsius. now, with this low pressure not really moving away anywhere, the weather front�*s still in the same place, so thicker cloud and, at times, outbreaks of rain from east anglia and across northern england, and elsewhere, we'll see some clear spells. and here's thursday morning — again, the weather front still in the same place, at least roughly. there'll be some glimmers of brightness between the layers of cloud, but also some rain at times — or at least showers — coming and going. and again, temperatures between around 18—20 celsius — maybe a little bit cooler where the clouds thicker and the rain�*s just that little bit heavier. into friday, then, you can see the distribution of showers in slightly different places in scotland, maybe the north—west of england, too. i think further south, it should be brighter, and again, temperatures don't really change — it's because that area of low pressure is basically carrying the same atmosphere, and the temperatures won't be changing. high pressure is starting to push
3:58 am
in through the weekend, but it'll be a very slow process, so don't expect major changes. so here's the summary for the rest of the week and the forecast into the weekend — notice that actually more northern parts of the uk fare better as we head into the weekend, with some sunshine on the way for belfast, and really quite warm. bye— bye.
3:59 am
live from washington. this is bbc news. live from washington. as georgia's controversial
4:00 am
foreign agent bill gets one step closer to becoming law. america's top diplomat makes a surprise visit to ukraine, reaffirming us support for the country. presidentjoe biden puts major new tariffs on billions of dollars worth of chinese imports including electric vehicles. riot police clashed with protesters in the georgian capital of tbilisi after parliament passed a divisive foreign agent law that has already sparked weeks of mass protests. the law would force civil society and media organizations to register if they receive foreign funding. on tuesday, georgia's parliament passed the third and final reading of the bill, clearing a major hurdle before
4:01 am
it can become law. it's likely to be vetoed by georgia's president,

12 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on