Skip to main content

tv   Close up  Deutsche Welle  February 6, 2024 10:15pm-10:46pm CET

10:15 pm
the new close up is up. next, i'll see you tomorrow and have a good one. everybody, the ice cold, b. c. at the end of the pesa, new. an expedition ventures on 2 places that no one has the climate research in the ice, the dos march, 3rd on dw, the, to the heart of sean pine. you and you can see there is money here. major champagne brands are enjoying record sales,
10:16 pm
but the people at the other end of the value chain face a very different feed get from i thought i worked for 4 days to the left without paying exploitation. human trafficking slaves like labor reports because when i st code used to be where we are today, all because of profits, it makes me say something in champagne you. affluence, is just opposed with abject poverty or so when you see this, you must stop. it will still be the, the town of at the ne, in northeastern france, the center of the world's famous champagne industry. says this they avenue to show
10:17 pm
sonya levin and she'll find them. it is, most of the big brands are here. robert schmid. stephanie van gas and shaka nice belong to an international collective of journalists there in champagne year for the harvest season to investigate what's behind the industry's glamorous facade. so the fancy buildings? well, it's clearly affluent. many of the major champagne brands are backed by large corporations, luxury conglomerates, and investors. business is booming in 2020, to the industry, so record turnover of more than 6000000000 euros to maintain these profits. someone 100000 seasonal workers are needed for the great harvest. every year, take a look at the crates and they would say that over they put the groups as well. i'm gonna say yes. are supported by journalism funds. europe. the reporters are researching a story they hope to publish in german and french media,
10:18 pm
investigating whether there's illegal exploitation and human trafficking in the champagne industry. cities, how they work. they do is very strenuous and eventually some people aren't adequately paid. lee is also a buckle like to multi point of therapy in cases of people house and terrible conditions. of course, this isn't the norm, but it does happen. but as really to me yet, we want to see exactly what's going on and what sort of deals can excuse specic victim. yeah, because because your lots of people who come here from eastern europe, africa and asia don't know their rights. he couldn't spell it. and sometimes if they don't dare defend themselves against abuses, say that because i'm or if you g, i knew i feel your situation is the, do not have a civil income and that's why they are ready to do any kind of job done of the photographer, a journalist the i would like to tell is
10:19 pm
a story. the reporters have no idea that this harvest season will mark a milestone with hundreds of new cases of exploitation and human traffic and coming to light. to begin, they want to find out more about the actual grape harvest on the bay. not families, champagne estate. the work day begins before dawn. don't go into the home with me. shelby now married a winemaker 30 years ago. she helped out in the kitchen during harvest. season these days it's a thriving family business and she's in charge of the great picking teams to seek to use. the harvest is hard work. the press has to be fed. grapes have to be picked off, so please, no one is here to sit around to see the show they want to harvest, harvest harvest factor,
10:20 pm
yet the polish workers are already waiting outside. they're directly employed by the family and live here on the grounds. so in this, there are 9 of them here, so there are 14 others in another building with awesome. everyone prepares their lunch here to take to the vineyards. this year the harvest starts in early september, when temperatures can still reach over 40 degrees celsius. as the sun rises, the work begins. each of the harvest workers will take several 100 kilos of grades today. wildly show, make sure there aren't too many leaves in the crates. the reporters ask the workers how they cope with the heat. and we finished work earlier because this time it was the burning hours king. what's about your bag for less hours of work it's it hurts but to some of us
10:21 pm
take medicine or have a different way for a buck. bang. daria is a student. this is her 2nd hard the season with a big, not a family. others have been doing it for more than 10 years and take time off from their actual jobs to come. that much want it in 10 days. it's for fall into it's too much like it's yeah, you can count on that much money in 10 days. on a good slope. darya can earn more than 150 euros a day. the prospect of a decent wage like this is attractive. many wine growers now outsource the harvesting to service providers that recruit and manage teams of foreign workers. me share okay, now prefers to do it all herself, even though it's sometimes hard to communicate with the workers to home because i just, the service providers are useful. i just, for instance,
10:22 pm
i don't speak any polish and the workers don't speak french, so to speak english. but otherwise we communicate with gestures. so i prefer to have my own teams much preferable. if you work with a service provider, you need to ask how the people are being accommodated and where and under what conditions. the winemaker has seen outsourcing grow over the years as major brands want to maximize profits. but she still stays true to her way. i'm happy there, beautiful grapes. my son can work well with ease college. nearby, her son, charlotte awaiting the harvest. he studied city culture before taking over the state. this is his 3rd harvest season. this is where i take over as soon as the grapes arrive, we start the press. yup. and then we make one and it takes 4 tons for one load. the
10:23 pm
young winemaker has plans to improve the vineyard. as according to the law regulating champagne production, the grapes have to be hand picked to avoid any damage. we want to plant ivy and fruit treats with you can't only think in terms of for profit water with a heat right now when the harvest workers want to take a break, there is no shape and bush, so it's a project that's close to my heart. so that's one, that's not what he can look at best, but not everyone has such a whole. some approach, the main producers have financial goals to meet and around 2 thirds of the harvest go to the big brands. industry leader l v in h produces more than $70000000.00 bottles a year. so they know as goals are more modest, he's happy with the 70000 bottles. they're hoping to produce that, you know, we went out into the cold to prune the vice scott on the tractor to attend to them . it took time and energy,
10:24 pm
and in the end we got something great because we won't be drinking this wind for another 4 or 5 years. so you need to bear that in mind to the 1st bay. now champagne overseen from start to finish by showed will be ready later in 2024. but there's already a reason to celebrate. oh no, we've started the last press. so now we can take a deep breath with a toast to end the day. one of the ones this won't take off now there's only one either. another day done 14000 kilos picked 1.3 heck. tears processed everything went well. well, so it's a deficit. so here's, do you know, most of them here's to you all to many, one, growers and brands stick to the rules, but they're also some black sheep in the industry. back in may, we've heard that people arrive at the station looking for work and the harvest by
10:25 pm
best when they sleep in the park outside and wait for sub contractors to come along and offer them more expensive that are these for the whole village. hardly anyone here wants to speak out against a sub contractors. finally, someone agrees to talk to us secure. what are you waiting for? what is your thought? the 12 by i'm looking for work a deal. are you expecting sub contractors? yes. deals that have you been offered to work on your legs on property? yes, but for 50 or 60 years a day or so. i won't do that. it's not enough to finish. but the use of lives in lee is he's here because he needs the money. we always have you ever had problems before then ways yeah, yes. 2 or 3 times people came along. i went with one of them, works for 4 days and then he left without paying on my cards. not so it goes.
10:26 pm
that's how it works here. use it is holding out for a decent offer until then. he'll sleep here in the park back in the vineyards, a team from the powerful french trade union. c g t has come to show solidarity with the workers c g t general secretary, subbing delaney is a trained nurse. now she's fighting for the rights of seasonal workers for to the press book there. that's it. there's a code of silence. we don't know how many people are effective for yeah, for, for maybe it's only a few cases. but even one case is one to many parts without having to sit on the top of the, the front of our job is to make sure that nobody is employed here under slavery like conditions while you're from discovery during the harvest season. the c g
10:27 pm
t team is in the vineyards every day, speaking with a great pickers pulled it on it. we're here to talk to the harvest workers and been sick because the trouble is they won't talk. they won't say anything of them. they're afraid of losing their jobs. no one talks in the vineyards or there's also a language barrier. if you don't mean where do you sleep in terms of thunder, a tar bullen to the english and to the last longer silver and gold? was it the language barrier? is a big problem. still we give them the leaflets so they can read them, pack them, perhaps with the help of some of the french who can explain to them why we're here . pulling it off. if they do have problems up, they only come to us after the grape harvest to them when they need more information. the news. this group of bulgarians also
10:28 pm
works for a service provider. the fields belong to a large producer, shift the boss, and they put in a problem. if there are problems and here's our phone number. yeah, give us a call and we'll answer all your questions. i'll look into problem was the sound of just call. here's our number, we will answer your questions. i will get to where do you sleep? part body. body harris. you're going back to paris in the evening here. yes. 100 kilometers on the legally, the workers have to have an 11 hour break between shifts. the union is suspect, this rule is going to being observed. but the c g t is not an official investigating authority. typically, computer complicated to restrict, the boss says he's going to drive 100 kilometers to spend the night somewhere and come back the next day you will be under the, we don't know if it's a 100 kilometers or more exactly, solely the workers can say. so again,
10:29 pm
he can only find out if they're being cheated, if they come to us. so we can't just guess what's happening up on, you know, on a coupon. but it's up to the laborers themselves to report problems. only labor inspectors and police can take action against exploitation in the vineyards, but both declined our interview requests. the reporters turn to the corporation of champagne. one, growers which comprises several 1000 medium sized wine growers. joseph gunnar, thanks for seeing us. there's a section of course. please don't penny is the winemaker himself and has been active in the association for years where we need to resume play out. we bring the wine growers together and host events where various
10:30 pm
issues are flagged through just such as working conditions, social issues, and the other official matters are a new scottish gift. cool. what can you tell us about service providers? i don't know if as well there are lots of small businesses and shop on your with assuming that it's sometimes hard for them to find workers. you don't get it and it's becoming increasingly difficult to recruits people locally. that's why we've seen an increase in ad sourcing and recent years. go to how i well up wish to assume for the better because we provide information on this on and communicate stroke. if adult assaults the difficult about. so when you work with a service provider, you have to follow certain rules and make sure you check everything on the sites. is an order of the restaurant to speak. the concord? i think 3, april 2 is their awareness of the conditions paper work in the show. it seems the same problems arise year after year on any. you're supposed to just, i wouldn't say every year i will know. the grape harvest is
10:31 pm
a lucrative business. it's all a to model, and unfortunately the trucks, sometimes dishonest people or fortunately, but it was more to live. okay. after we finish filming the wine makers present several proposals. there is to be more accommodation for workers. the work should be better organized and above all stricter rules should apply to the service providers. whether this will actually come to be remains to be seen shows a blown go, has worked in the champagne industry for 36 years. today. he's a trade unionist and tackles the exploitation of workers by sub contractors. he starts work early, one parties, most of them aren't even earning a 100 zeros a day. they get between 40 and 50 years. that's below the going rate. is always the over the years and entire system has evolved here with the support of the
10:32 pm
industry. and the authorities simply look the other way, the companies who no one will be happy that we're digging around these reports to their book. we're going to, you know, start up using the don't see that van over there. it's just arrive. but again, talk to me, then we'll feel the people are watching subsidy. they know we're here in the course of his campaign against exploitation shows a has met the minister of labor and been in touch with the local politicians about visiting the vineyards. this work makes them a target. tea and the reporters are clearly under observation. it's a french license plates, a local one. what is the sky one? the only watching us? yes, the he's on the phone. they keep an eye on all the time. josie is undeterred. he knows that some of the
10:33 pm
sub contractors come to this car park to recruit workers. i'm gonna wait. you can see the buses arriving here from various places and also from parents that definitely and dropping people off looking for work in the vineyards. the so the no one dropped off here stays with the wind growers. otherwise they'd be taken directly to the vineyards and don't coast that. ok, that's a long commute. natalia post absolutely. on that. some of the been traveling for 2 hours now they're waiting to see where they will be sent. josie have long ago was convinced that some of the subcontractors are part of the organized criminal networks. okay. the best sense, so there are people orchestrating at all. oh yeah, and it's a team leader so to speak and the supervisor is full of this show. we go over
10:34 pm
and talk to them, you know, call me much, but i'd rather not easy for them. it's all well organized and secret is told me. so i am worried about my safety a recent case showed that criminal activity does indeed exist after seasonal workers reported a sub contractor network. the service provider was convicted of human trafficking in 2022. of the self assessing into for to this is one of the photos published in the local press it over there. you can see workers sleeping on mattresses on the floor so, so they might know most of them were asylum seekers and putting them on to that in the journal. this is chuck nice news. how powerless people can feel in such
10:35 pm
situations. he fled from afghanistan, defense himself after being in touch with one of the seasonal workers from the court case for a while. you shocked me some for an interview in paris. c for to an advisor is also from afghanistan. this is the 1st time since the ruling that he's speaking publicly about, the criminal network that exploited him. in general, the we were told that we'd have a room for 2 people who know that everything was clean and tidy and that there would be food fox. news and when we got there everything was different, but there was only one big room, add ons, no beds, and no mattress. it's fine. of course, you know, we slept on the floor, you've got to send them and you didn't sign any contracts that when we applied for the job they didn't give us a contract number. i worked for 5 days without a contract and then i told them if you don't give me a contract,
10:36 pm
i won't work here anymore. that's why i called the police it, i mean the police michigan. okay. tell me more about the working conditions kind of thing. that's a work was very hard. we worked until just before midnight. in the morning we got up around 5 or 6. like, there were $36.00 people and one rooms, and there was only one toilet fast enough, but within that, the for one user. these days, if i tools that cfo has a job with a proper contract in paris, his statements resulted in the biggest case of human trafficking and champagne year to date. many of the of gun workers were represented by a lawyer based in the city of loans. bullshit, marshall used to take part in the great harvest as a student himself, a lot has changed since then. not known as eustace. nobody's reached the court who
10:37 pm
is right in the middle of the region. they own, you know, and now it's also dealing with this industry in activity. they couldn't measure. it's a major economic factor here which you know, that is going to be that good. but we weren't used to dealing with it in a criminal court. the no cost of it, and then we heard a case that turned out to be huge this morning since you know, the lawyer agrees to talk about it. he says that even no more than a year after the ruling, many questions remain unanswered. dates on politics of cnn. it was an extraordinary trial and more fully spend one point in your but in terms of the outcome, it was extremely frustrating to the next 10. first ice. you just a moment was able, the verdict was frustrating or visual named gong on the launch on pan. uh, we saw a very large champagne brand that outsourced to a sub contractor, which in turn notes sourced to another sub contractor. uh,
10:38 pm
i know what the price was, he did potential on sale, he's the court looked at the 2nd and 3rd levels through a cable she buckled, but at the top of the pyramid. oh, look you up with someone who was supposed to supervise the grape harvest on behalf of the big champagne brand. we live on the ocean. this person slipped through the naturally night this. let's look sort of, we didn't get the impression that an industry and some important players were being protected like the measure. next, whether there's somebody, odds and regions is relies to a large extent on wine growing like that. know the input by some patient don't say good folks. you know, you can't help thinking the case targeted the people doing the enforcing usually the whole not those giving the orders me up and while doing all this of course does not apply to the whole industry, but evidence against them. sub contractors is piling up back in the vineyard. this
10:39 pm
young man who works for a sub contractor of a major champagne producer wants to remain anonymous. i'm too afraid of his statement. sounds familiar. i received no contact from all nothings. and what, what about the post diesel, the one in the room for the little cuz sometimes who gets along sometimes with the list some guy in good faith like 400 zeros for working 10 days. you live in this for the same guy you're working for or for and having the same day when i got on the reporters here, similar accounts over the following days. the image of sean han yet has been tarnished, says trade unionist visuals. a blanco. it's high time to stop exploitative sub contractors. he says in the interest of big brands as rival products, such as a tally and pros. seco are becoming more popular,
10:40 pm
just possibly legal for you. we hope that the employers, especially the main brands, will sit down together and put it into this, these people. all right, the software for the, for the sake of the image and the future of champagne. what i don't know who default we're fighting for our jobs. our industry for our return, your call as you utilize your shows a blown go, was born and jump on you and worked in the industry for decades. his own son works in the vineyards during the harvest. he maintains, there's been systematic exploitation for a long time. inadequate accommodation for workers is one issue, the another camp, semi legal, let it on. yeah. last year they put labels on the dungeon wins just now this year. there are stickers for separated trash cancer subsidies, which means they've been provided by the municipality of the pac on a to morning. that means every one of them, they are the units suppose association and the municipality is in fact,
10:41 pm
tensor especially forbidden in this part of sham tanya. yet illegal comes could be found all along the roadside up in the forest. the conditions are especially shocking and informative tools you'll say, together with your colleagues, noel sounds the just a wants to see for himself. know where you are. that looks like a ranch and table problems resolutely unconditioned steps to. so it's a proper account. there was a cam here, but now everyone's gone. we'll schedule it to complete it on you to camp they're looking for is believe to be further north. let me once before i think we have to go past the vineyard. all right, let's go who. what did they find? what they're looking for at the edge of the forest, make shift tens. no toilet, no water connection. multiple plugs in wet grass shows
10:42 pm
a is outraged. up what seems waiting or even after a long day in the vineyard is in the rain. imagine coming back in the evening to conditions like this, with this catastrophic motion. is there a wild boars? and these, for the most part, i can just see them dropping by in the evening. this will get or for it also looks like there are children living here. suddenly a woman appears with her daughter. they don't want to be filmed way. okay, that's okay. we won't from what's the bosses name? i don't know. we've only been here for 2 or 3 days. big is everything. okay. my husband is going to work and i'm here with my daughter. do you work in the vineyards too? yes. well the min wage, stephanie listens to the woman's story. a to z. let them any, she's from romania. she came here with her husband and the rest of her family or
10:43 pm
somebody and they were promised the proper accommodation with the toilet. but when they arrive on the x, there was nothing here. you know how they did what it did she days on detroit. so that's human trafficking. absolutely, that's a good human traffic. i'll call the labor department. and that's how it works, and trump on the and that's how it works is we condemn it off. but this isn't about the union, this is about these people, not cities, or wherever they are from their human beings. we can't allow this to happen though . it has to stop. after we finish filming the reporters, the footage of people in catastrophic accommodation given in edible food, it's clear that these are no isolated cases. by the end of the season, hundreds of new victims of modern slavery have been discovered with ongoing investigations into unpaid wages, totaling millions and 2 new cases of human trafficking. a sorry indictment of one
10:44 pm
of the richest regions in the world. the rules we say there about never getting up every weekend on the w cost about why does that mean? because now, i'm lisa the new hosting, the last not that much of join us for an exciting is to
10:45 pm
ation of everything in between moses video and audio production, 5 d w. i hope that you will tune it. imagine you have to write a law or a thesis, that's a lot of work, but then you want to kind of a i do it better than i can both on the so why is one of the world's biggest future best heading to x family, twitter post as the videos does a last want to make x when you take talk and it's a disturbing phenomenon, but a i generated nude picks us searching online and kids using them to bleach of that, even though it is illegal. these are the topics that i'm moving the tech love with you soon have to tons of x to watch your favorite creative and generate one of the . well, the biggest need to be who is the beast dropped the video and x for the 1st time. instead of inches.

12 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on