[000:00:00;00] its territories in the near future, then this will only turn away the desire to help it, this is the thesis being put forward, and it would be better for ukraine , on the contrary, to switch to a defensive strategy that would allow for less losses on the battlefield, on the one hand, and on the other hand would demonstrate that ukraine is in principle ready for some diplomatic search for a diplomatic, diplomatic solution to the war, already now and so, the authors say, most likely russia, at the moment, which is still hoping for some territorial gains, let's call it yes, that is, to occupy even more ukrainian territories, they will not agree to this, i mean to the proposal that would come even from kyiv, to sit down at the negotiating table, but in this case, at least ukraine will shift the emphasis, that is, what ukraine is emphasizing now, that we want to defeat russia, it will be

less and less, said the challenge. enthusiasm of western partners, instead, if ukraine says that we are ready to reconcile, but russia continues its aggression, this is in the long term, sooner or later it will be if we play in favor of ukraine, well, words, here is some kind of vision , what do you think about it, let's analyze these arguments and try, maybe we don't agree with them, well, in fact, strategically, this article has two key tracks, against the background of which it is actually perceived a little differently than we perceive it primarily in the context of what is happening on the battlefield, well, in the context of what problems are actually faced by how ukraine will continue to receive financial and military-technical assistance from those of the united states itself america, taking into account at least the current political situation there, has adopted

funding bills. continued funding of government institutions, well, in principle, yes, there is what is happening between republicans and democrats in congress and the senate, but strategically, this article actually has two additional dimensions, the first dimension, well, it is directly understandable, it refers to , which is objectively happening on the battlefield, including, obviously, at certain moments, it is pushed away from the situation that really developed around of the ukrainian counteroffensive, well, in the end, for... first of all, political expectations from it, because well, military experts, both ukrainian and western, they perfectly understood that , relatively speaking, on the one hand, the armed forces of ukraine were given western weapons, ah, although not in sufficient quantity, this is a very serious factor that affected the pace and dynamics of the counter-offensive, but on the other hand, we were not given a key component that allows us to use these western weapons to the maximum, this is the aviation component, because it's all western

weapon. it is within the framework of western strategic doctrines, it, well, fights most effectively only when there is an advantage, well, our allies in the air, and when the enemy does not have this advantage, well, and since we did not have this air component, well it is clear that from such a purely military professional point of view any additional inflated expectations from this counteroffensive, in such objective realities, could hardly be expected, well, but on the other hand we... know that there were political assessments which from differed a little from such a professional , objective, professional assessment of what happened on the battlefield. it is obvious that the thesis of this article is , on the one hand, an attempt to reflect, and in this context to smooth out, so to speak , the differences that existed between, in assessments between military professionals, including, by the way, from of the united states of america, and those political assessments that sounded both from

washington and from european capitals, our western allies in the countries of the european union and in the european member countries of nato, with on the other hand, it seems to me that even to a greater extent the second track of this article, it is even more important for understanding its correct context, it is actually very important here what you said at the very beginning about the authors of this material, this text, because by and large account, we see that the start , or rather the preparation for the start of the presidential... election campaign in the united states of america takes place in the most acute contradictions not only between democrats and republicans, but also within each of these camps, that is, we we see that the republican party is divided between a small, but very loud and visible trumpist wing, the far-right, so to speak, conservatives, and what if the core of the republican party, which is more moderate, and even

the reagans of the reagan type, but the same we must understand that the camp of the democrats is also divided to a certain extent, we see on the one hand the policy of the current administration of president biden, well, this is more decisive. proactive, and one that relies on, well, let's say, continued active support of ukraine, including weapons and financial resources and so on, but on the other hand , we see that in the democratic party now, well, their left wing, so to speak , of the left democrats, represented by such close associates of the former us president obama, who, well, as they say, was such a very bright' left-wing democrat, yes, such a left-wing democrat in the white house, and in the end, this is the left wing of the democratic party, it is on the one hand, it is trying to oppose

his vision, the policy of the biden administration, which the white house is currently pursuing with regard to ukraine and israel, by the way, and on the other hand, it all overlaps very strongly with this start of the pre-election presidential campaign in the united states, because well, at least on the one hand president biden has announced that he intends to... uh, run for the democratic party in this presidential election, but on the other hand, there are polls across the united states of america that say, well in fact, americans are far from delighted with the age of president biden, and in principle, well , the same applies to the presidential candidate, possibly the future one from the republican party, donald trump. americans would like to see a much younger president in the next white house, and it seems to me that this causes a certain activation of these left-wing bodies in the democratic party, because it is obvious that they understand that they have a chance to promote their own candidate as an alternative to the president biden, and this one

the candidate will reflect, well, these very left-wing views in the democratic party , in contrast to the agenda that is currently broadcast by the white house and president biden personally, well, it is a little different, to put it mildly, from that worldview. which was, dominated the administration of barack obama , and it seems to me that this article , it combines several factors in this way, it primarily reflects, well, if this is the internal agenda, the internal political agenda in the united states of america and even more it is to a greater extent even concerns this internal agenda in the democratic party of the united states, in those, let's say, different readings, strategic priorities of the united states, which are among the representatives of the democrats, that is, well, this, in my opinion, is another such and such, an indicator of another exacerbation of this internal political, pre-election struggle in the united states of america, and this is not even an inter-party struggle, but an intra-party struggle, that is, both democrats and republicans

are currently experiencing not the best of times in in the context of who they can nominate, which of their leaders, they can nominate for the presidential race, because it is obvious that none of the parties has such a bright leader who would be so well received, at least by the majority of the citizens of the united states of america, no, and this is obviously a crisis of both parties, political and internal, yes , that is, the question of some kind of internal leadership, internal hierarchy, they obviously, well, if they moved to the background, and in the end we now see the results of what these issues of party building, so to speak, were neglected by both republicans and democrats, yes, well, the democratic wing, the left wing of the democratic party... the american one can of course nominate bernie sanders, but he is two years older than biden, i think , it will be a kind of option that you couldn't resist it madly, there is the truth, the truth is that there are talks about michelle

obama, and well, if it is a serious option, then there will be a combo, because it will be the first woman, the president of the united states of america and the first an african-american woman, the president of the united states, so that it does not happen as it happened in the first term. trump, when the attempt to put him on the presidency, on the wife of a popular president, failed. i'm here, the only thing i also want to say is, yes , do i still have time, actually, just to ask very briefly, the other, the other position is that actually, and that's the position that we've heard from philip as well bridle, and from mcfaul, for example, from many, now mikrai is writing about it. likewise a retired australian general expert that the fact is that ukraine had an unsuccessful counteroffensive, that russia is now very well prepared and the war has entered a protracted phase in which

russia really has a chance, at least putin rightly thinks that perhaps time is working for on him, the biden administration is also to blame, because from the very beginning, these people, his critics, said give the ukrainians more help. don't give the ukrainians 30 tanks, give the ukrainians 2,000 abramts. after all, we remember valery zaluzhnyi's publication before the offensive, which looked very dissonantly against the background of our all these. stated that tomorrow we will drink coffee in a christmas tree, book hotels, but it was very sobering, as we now understand the publication, where, where valery the brave commander wrote that only 600 tanks were needed for one operation, they gave us in the end there , how much more than 100 a little bit, and in total, 200, yes 200, yes, that is, this is this too, this is also what is there still a chance now, what we see now, we, we actually expected what, what if not will be successful. counteroffensive,

they will start delivering these bills to us, that i begged everything, sit down and negotiate with russia, they have taken half , there is 20% of the territory, thank you that it is not half and that is all, are there still chances that this second position will also win, because among the republicans there are also people who, this mccall, for example, who says: well, okay, just give another program to give the ukrainians, more weapons, let 's talk about it, and here actually, to put it very briefly, the main problem is that ah, well by the way, this is a parallel with the current situation in which israel got into, yes, that is, there is a very big discrepancy between, purely military purposes, such as what is happening on the battlefield, and those political , strategic goals that are set in both of these specific situations, yes, we have a clear political position of the ukrainian authorities, both about the fact that the territorial integrity of ukraine must be restored

, sovereignty, ensured security, punishment of the putin regime, as well as bringing to justice all those who, let's say, made decisions, were responsible for this war, unleashed against ukraine, but our western partners, unlike us, here we are at our level we see these political landmarks, our western partners unfortunately do not see these political landmarks at the strategic level, that is, the question of what the victory of ukraine means for the same united states of america in this war. this question is open, because the vast majority there like to say that it should not be a defeat for ukraine and, if not, a victory for russia. but, well, these are very ephemeral things, because, well, the ultimate political, this ultimate political priority, it has to be very clearly defined. that is, it should be either the vision of the victory of ukraine in the context of the defeat of the russian military group on the territory of ukraine and the displacement of the russian army, its remnants from beyond the internationally recognized ukrainian-russian borders, so

or so it should be, well, obviously, in this format the event has been operating all these almost two years, yes , the creation of a certain political pressure on the russian regime, dosed transfer of actions to ukraine in order to prevent us, on the one hand, from defeating the russian army as quickly as possible, because this could shake the internal stability in russia, and with the collapse, another disintegration on the territory of russia, the west is obviously not ready to deal with it, they still have... phantom fears of the times of the end of the cold war, when the soviet union collapsed too suddenly, when the american secret service gave him 5-8 years to live a little there, and here it suddenly fell apart literally there less than a year after these assessments were announced, and the fact is that most likely, including in the united states of america, these strategic political priorities are not clearly defined, that is, what victory should mean of ukraine in the context of the russian regime, yes, it has a collection, but it should turn into north korea there, or should it simply be

the collapse of the current political system in russia, and then it is clear that one must correlate these risks with that, and what to do next with this territory, there are a lot of factors, in fact, because there is also how the states will be able to come to an agreement with china, and well, there are a lot of other points, including those that are tied to other regional conflicts, but it is obvious that this desan , how many and which weapons received by ukraine and the goals... set for themselves by our western allies, it is obvious, because if from the very beginning the victory of ukraine was understood as primarily a military defeat of russia in a field battle, then it is obvious that we would have been given the tools to to achieve this, but since there were discussions between, obviously, between our allies about what kind of victory this should be, and unfortunately there is no clear answer to these discussions at the moment, we have this situation, but with the war that

with russia's help, iran has gone bad, gone bad we have a report, contact with mr. taras, mr. taras, are you there, lost, lost, lost connection, tarastenko, international security expert, democratic initiatives foundation, candidate of political sciences, member of the public council at the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine was with us, we will continue to talk about what is happening in israel, stay with us, there will be. it's interesting that vasya, you drank an antibiotic, you got a rash in your tummy, and you girls, but how after an antibiotic, you have a rash, so problems with the joints limit movement, it's unpleasant and painful. strengthen them with the help of longs joints, these are bags with collagen and vitamin c to restore joint cartilage. dolgit joints contributes to the normal functioning

of the joints and has a positive effect on the health of the bones. long joints facilitate motor functions. stretch your joints, move freely. only victory grants a ticket to the european championship. november 20 at 21:45, watch the match of the year. we cheer for the national team throughout the country. turn on sports on mego. when colds and colds come. noses want to go to the resort. humor for daily prevention and complex treatment of the undead. humor - sea ​​resort for the nose. there are discounts on huyumer nasal spray. 30% in travel and savings pharmacies. wivinil agency presents: december 3, 18:00, fest republily invites you to a fabulous concert of solomiya chubai koleskovi for oleksa. time to believe in miracles. jalapita group, rococo, school of arts, free and indifferent. concert of light and goodness on nicholas day

for children with love. december 3, 6:00 p.m. festrepalik ticket equals charity, live sound. in october 2023, the espresso tv channel holds the leadership in the top ukrainian informational tv channels. greetings to all espresso viewers, time to learn about the most important thing of the moment. according to measurement data, viewers choose the ukrainian view from espresso. an informational marathon is underway on tv channel uso. we work for you. thank you ukrainians for your trust. espresso works for you. vasyl winter's big broadcast. two hours of air time, two hours of your time, two hours to learn about the war and what the world is about. two hours to keep up with economic and sports news. two hours in the company of favorite presenters, presenters who have become like family to many, as well as respected

guests of the studio. events of the day in two hours. vasyl winter's big broadcast. a project for smart and caring people. espresso in the evening. channel espresso. and ukrainian pen present the project own names with myroslava barchuk, a series of conversations with ukrainian and western intellectuals who interpret and comment on the most relevant social discussions. what news will be analyzed by the guests of the project this week, and actually, who will be the guest of the studio? we will find out this sunday. undoubtedly, the topics will be relevant, the guests will be special. own names with myroslava barchuk. sunday: 17:10 at espresso. espresso - interesting facts. over 10 years , the tv channel's youtube channel has been viewed more than 3 billion times. over 10 years , the tv channel's youtube channel has been watched more than 2,005 million hours. over 10 years, the tv channel's youtube channel has received

more than 6 million comments. so, dear friends, now we will talk about israel , as you can see, the israeli flag is already developing behind our backs, arkady milman, an israeli diplomat and former ambassador of israel to russia , is in touch with us, we will ask him about what is happening in israel, just now , is mr. arkady already with us, he is, now he will be added to our ether, tzahal actually assures that all goals in the gas have been achieved, we congratulate you, mr. arkady. what does it all mean and what's next? i congratulate you, this is a difficult question, because it can only be said by the higher command, which sets a task for our army, but i think that this can be explained by the following, that at the moment the

tasks that were set have been achieved, but until the end of this war it is still very much far, and we know this, this is all... we understand and we will have to fight for a long time to destroy this terrorist organization. at the moment, the troops are there, they have completely surrounded the city of gaza, they have completely cleared the northern part of the gaza strip, and now combat operations are starting in the south of the gaza strip. and in israel they say that the end of this war is still far away, the full-scale ukrainian invasion has been going on for the 633rd day, the israeli special operation has been going on for a month. i'm already lost today is the 42nd day, we are today the 42nd day, the 42nd day, that is, on the 42nd day, the israelis

are told by the authorities that the end of this war is still far away, i understand correctly, correctly, you understand, correctly, the point is that it is very difficult to compare the war that ukraine is waging, because it is on several levels, heavier, scarier, bigger, heavier than the war we are waging. against hamas, because russia is a huge country, even with resources, the ukrainian army is fighting hard, large forces are involved from two sides, from the ukrainian side, and from the side of the aggressor russia, we have, of course, a different picture, it is very difficult to fight with terrorists, but still we are stronger than them and it is clear that there will be one result here, we will destroy them, but it takes time, because we fight with regular army - this is one tactic to fight with terrorists, who, in principle, are mainly in underground

tunnels, underground bunkers, with them it is a second war, it is a different one, i cannot say that it is more difficult or easier, but it is simply a second one, so it also takes a lot of time the war, the ukrainian war, is somehow leaving the columns of the main publications, i don't know there today, i opened the new york times, i opened the telegram there. and there is something about israel, well, there is almost nothing about ukraine, the guardians wrote something there, and well, now i am talking not only about this, but about the fact that somehow this war in israel, in israel, it touched some very many cultural, pain points and so on, primarily in the western world, we see these huge demonstrations , anti-israel or pro-palestinian, i don't know how to call them correctly, and i and and and i also see that, for example, a lot of people who are

representatives, i don’t know, there, on the left, of some left-liberal schools, in europe, in western europe, they sympathize in this story, i don't know if they sympathize more, more, more, well, definitely not hamas, but nevertheless, there are some things that are difficult to separate, where where it is... you can even call it anti-semitism, and where you can call it, i don't know , solidarity with people who, on the other hand , support terrorists, in a word, a very complicated story now, all around, well, here i am i read, for example, in a polish weekly directly about how one of the polish intellectuals writes that she is taken aback, unpleasantly confused by that israeli nationalism, and when the chorus chants a dead, good arab, then there is a dead arab, and i try to do the same

to somehow correlate with what is happening in our country, because in our country, we can sometimes even joke like that, and sometimes we don't joke, that there is a good russian, there is a dead russian, and in our situation, it seems to me that we can afford it, in a word, this parallel is complicated here, but how to explain this foundation of such dissatisfaction with what is happening in israel, such disapproval of this war. uh, you touched on a very deep, very important question: first of all, the fact that the world 's focus has completely shifted from ukraine to the middle east, the gas sector, this serves the interests of russia and russia will do everything in order to in our country, the conflict will also continue, continued and will contribute to the instability of the western countries, to

the demonstrations, they will they will be behind on all social networks, they do it here, in germany, and in france, and in other countries, they will do everything only with one goal, because it helps them take the focus from ukraine to us, and such a feeling , as if there is no war in ukraine, right? there is no ovdiivka, there is no kherson direction at all, yes, there is nothing, there is no war there, yes in ukraine, that is, it is not at all clear what you are doing there, yes, the whole war, everything here, everything is scary, everything is bad here, now eh, what it happens, it's not left-liberal, those who are left, let's say yes, extremist leftist, progressive-minded circles, they are against liberalism, these are people who fully take a position that will be - on the basis of some political correctness, will say various things that contradict the very present moral compass, the point is

that in in these circles, in these circles , the moral compass is broken, if they can support the terrorist actions of hamas and what happened when these terrorists burned people alive, cut off the heads of small children, bodies that were burned in such a way that we cannot identify them, we do not know who these people are, who were burned, they are considered missing in our country, that we do not understand who it is, yes, it is difficult for us to determine which body, where, women were raped, killed, this... everything is now called a war against colonialism, imperialism, and this is exactly such an absolutely extremist leftist narrative, which in principle serves terrorists, now the demonstrations that take place in europe, the main mass, this is the muslim minority, which in principle came to europe, and some of these people, or

let's say, the main part of these people, do not want to integrate in europe. she wants to live, let's say, in the muslim world, only in very good social conditions, yes, let's take france, there is a huge number of families where men do not work, they receive social assistance from the french state, which is at a very high level, much higher times than in any arab country, but they pray, they want only islam, they want to live as if they were not in an arab country, but they are in france and this is the absence. we also get the desire to integrate at these demonstrations, where all these people come out with these posters. there is , of course, a part of society that supports them, but does not understand why the conflict is happening, just like a part of europeans, in european countries, that they they say that ukraine should cede territory to russia, well, why

continue the war, it’s exactly the same, it’s exactly the same, now what’s the slogan in this... that palestine will be from the sea to the jordan river, then we will destroy israel, so if you want to live in peace, why are you fighting us? if you do not want to live in peace, then we must answer you and also fight with you, that is , the problem here is still in logic, in the absence of minimal morality, for example, i will give an example, these terrorists who entered the territory, they raped many women , uh, we asked the united nations, women's organizations to condemn... it starts now, prove to us that it was, yes, it's exactly like in buch, yes, in buch, it's not the russian army killed ukrainians, it was the ukrainian sbu who staged it, zelsky came up with the idea that it is now blaming the russian army, that’s exactly how it is, that is, if you pay attention, a completely similar approach to what is happening in ukraine, because what is happening in

our country why i will explain, because these circles, circles together with right-wing extremist circles, they are against the very foundations of democracy. it is not for nothing that president biden said that hamas and russia are fighting against democracy and those who do not want this democracy, they support, these are deep processes, complex processes, they are very difficult and will not end quickly, that is why we are now and ukraine and israel are in this plan, absolutely, we are part of this chain of events, where you... this is such a link, we are a link , your situation is more complicated than ours, because we are still 100% in the same boat with them and we are actually at the forefront of this confrontation between the liberal world and authoritarian countries, thank you very much for this conversation, arkady was with us milman, an israeli diplomat and former israeli ambassador to russia, and now

anna javamelnyk will be with us, which means that we will watch the latest news, what happened in ukraine and the world in the last hour. annoyeva, congratulations, you have a word. greetings, colleagues, thank you for your work. the news team continues to work. in this issue, i will tell about the consequences of the night attack of the rashists on ukraine, as well as who in dnipropetrovsk region stole land worth a billion hryvnias. be with us. a 56-year-old man was wounded by russians in the kherson region, in the afternoon the occupiers hit the enterprise with artillery in the village of veletenske of the belozersk community - reported in the regional military administration. the victim is in the hospital. he has an explosive

injury, chest and leg injuries. also muscovites. injured a 42-year-old