moves on the part of germany, this is very important. from the point of view of the fact that the security of the eastern flank of nato is currently being strengthened, germany also plays a role in this, because literally on december 18, the day before , the relevant protocol was signed on plans to deploy another german brigade in lithuania. and it is very well received in lithuania. and, well, let's just say, they expect it. well, this should take place during 2024. and in general , from what is visible, today finland is very significantly strengthened, you can see that the finns, in parallel with joining nato, this was not enough for them, and they , in addition, signed a separate agreement with the united states, which gave, this agreement made it possible to use the airfields and ports of finland for american planes and ships, respectively, that is, to strengthen in this way.

well, in the end, this is what russia is trying to form in the leningrad district there and so on, to a certain extent, if they will concentrate their forces there, the troops, where in what way even to their advantage, because they can concentrate less on the war against of ukraine, but in general, what can be said today i see threats to nato countries of a hybrid nature, that is, what they are today, well, they are what we have seen. about six months ago from belarus to poland, wagner terrorists who were practically ready to cross the border and under the guise of illegal migrants, enter the territory of poland, then commit sabotage there, various terrorist acts, why? in order to cause a disjointed reaction and discussion within nato, is this aggression by russia, or is this an attack by terrorists? now they are trying to implement something similar in finnish border and that's why finland is forced to close

all checkpoints already in the second or even the third, and in this way you can say that they are actually preventing russia from trying to let someone in there under the guise of illegal migrants, but let's look at the general trajectory and strategy, the very fact of moving russia's nuclear weapons to belarus is in many respects an aggressive step towards... nato, the very statements regarding finland and the very statements in general are equally aggressive actions towards in relation to nato, and it seems to me , of course, that the reaction of the north atlantic alliance will be, and once again it is necessary to understand that these are simply these aggressive attacks of russia, they do not stop and will not stop in ukraine, and the germans are also talking about this, and others talk about it openly, the americans, so i think it's a reason for europe to invest. more, do

more, and now it’s simple, i guess, it’s clear where to invest, it’s ukraine, because the more russian troops are destroyed here, the closer ukraine’s victory is, the less threats to nato, it is obvious. by the way, david cameron, the minister of foreign affairs of great britain, said that the support for ukraine will last as long as it is needed, and compared the war to a play. let's hear what david cameron said. the first act was the stunning failure of russia in its attempts to achieve its goals, the second act was the counteroffensive of ukraine in the summer of 2022, a brilliant success that the ukrainians showed in pushing back the russians, regaining half of the lost territories. the third act was more difficult on land, but the fourth act is not yet written, and we must to make sure we write it right, together with our friends and partners in the western world. mr. oleksandr, if... to

use this terminology of actions and plays that are not unwritten, in your opinion, what should be the fourth action of ukraine and the western partners? i think the answer, let's say, in part, if we're talking about britain, was given to us by zayla 's telegram today, who wrote that there could be a pact between britain and ukraine, actually about long-term... defense and security support that would predict that britain will strengthen ours opportunities, in particular at sea , together with norway, now we are talking about a maritime coalition, and this is very important, by the way, the minister of foreign affairs, lord cameron, he visited both kyiv and odessa, which shows, let's say, a special interest in the successful implementation of the black sea strategy on the part of ukraine, this is a very important point, so i think that in this direction... they will help us

and work, just as far as the black sea is concerned, and why i am talking about this, because this, at least a part of this act, and a separate action of this act. if we speak like that in theatrical language, during which there should be this war at sea, the continuation of this war at sea and the reduction of the capabilities and capacities of the black sea fleet of russia, then of course it is the continuation of support, which should now include this fourth action not just transfer arms to ukraine, and an increase in the production of weapons for ukraine and an increase in the production of weapons by ukraine, which is also an important point. which should not be forgotten, because it is also our duty to increase the defense capability, i think that this has this action is next. thank you, and to use this theatrical terminology, if a weapon is hanging somewhere, and a gun is hanging, it

will fire sooner or later, but i hope that this gun will fire in the direction of the russian federation. thank you, mr. oleksandr, it was oleksandr mosienko, the director of the center for military and legal studies, friends, during this broadcast we ask you the following: do you trust president zelensky, yes, no, if you watch us on tv, pick up your phone or smartphone and vote if you trust 0800 211 381, no, 0800 211382, all calls to these numbers are free, please show the intermediate results of this survey, i will also say that we also conduct this survey on youtube, i trust 32% at the moment, 68%, no. warning. an incredible novelty. from razpak tv. super warm and very comfortable alaska stayle boots. perfect fit, water-repellent material and a feeling of warmth even in 30-degree frost.

alaska stayle boots have a universal design and practical black color. therefore, they will fit both men and women. sizes - from the 36th to the 46th. therefore, take two pairs at once. to myself and my husband. zippers will ensure a perfect fit, even on the widest leg. eco futro insulation perfectly retains heat and wicks away moisture, and the top is made of a fold of permeable and wear-resistant raincoat fabric and reinforced with eco-suede. alaska style boots can be worn both in wet weather and in very cold weather. high-quality, light and warm alaska stayle boots will provide comfort in the changeable wet autumn and in the frosty winter and in the unpredictable spring. you will always be warm, comfortable and dry. universal base design. black color and a favorable price of only 799 hryvnias. call attention - an incredible novelty from razpak tv. super warm and very comfortable alaska style boots. perfect fit, water-repellent material and a feeling of warmth even in 30-degree frost. alaska stayle boots have a universal

design and practical black color. therefore , they will fit both men and women. sizes from 36 to 46. therefore, take two pairs at once. to myself and my husband. zippers will ensure a perfect fit even on the widest leg. eco futro insulation perfectly retains heat and wicks away moisture, and the top is made of water-impermeable and wear-resistant raincoat fabric and reinforced with eco-suede. alaska stayle boots can be worn both in wet weather and in very cold weather. high-quality, light and warm alaska stayle boots will provide comfort in the changeable wet autumn and in the frosty winter and in the unpredictable spring. you will always be warm, comfortable and dry. universal design. black color and a favorable price of only 799 hryvnias. call big broadcast by vasyl zima. two hours of airtime,

two hours of your time. two hours to learn about the war and how the world lives. two hours to keep up with economic and sports news. two o'clock. in the company of favorite presenters, presenters who have become like family to many, as well as distinguished guests of the studio, the events of the day in two hours, vasyl zima's big broadcast, a project for smart and caring people, in the evening at espresso. verdict with serhiy rudenko, from now on in a new two-hour format, even more analytics, even more important topics, even more top guests, foreign experts, inclusion from abroad, about ukraine, the world, the front, society. and also feedback, you can express your opinion on the bad day with the help of a phone survey, turn on and turn on, the verdict with serhii rudenko, every weekday from 20 to 22 on espresso. greetings, friends,

the live broadcast of the espresso tv channel continues about... the verdict program, my name is serhii rudenko. a big press conference, volodymyr zelenskyi's annual press conference, took place today. let's talk today about what he said. commander in chief armed forces of ukraine, and even today in the program about this. another year of war, the final press conference of president volodymyr zelenskyi, key statements from the head of state. control over europe and the collapse of nato, putin's goal in the war against ukraine and the forecast for 2024. ukraine is on the way to eu membership. what steps are already behind and what still needs to be done? in the course of our program

today, we ask you the following question: do you trust president zelensky? yes, no, if you watch us on youtube, it's pretty simple, two options: yes, no, or your comment, write, please under the video. if you watch us on tv, during the telecast, you can pick up the phone and vote, yes 0800 21138. we conducted such a survey a few days ago regarding the head of the armed forces of ukraine valery zaluzhnyi, you know, friends, that there are a lot of such surveys on trust , mistrust, conducted by sociological services, we decided to conduct this survey as well. i would like to introduce the guests of today's studio - they are people's deputies of ukraine, viktoriya syumar, the faction of the european so... i congratulate you, thank you for joined our broadcast. elizaveta yasko,

servant of the people faction, mrs. elizaveta, i congratulate you and thank you for being with us today. good evening and thank you. and yaroslav yurchyshyn, voice faction, head of the parliamentary committee on freedom of speech. mr. yaroslav, i congratulate you, thank you for being with us today. good evening. so, ladies and gentlemen, zelensky's big press conference was held today, a lot about... there are no comments, this press conference ended an hour ago, did you hear the answers to the questions you had, is it clear to you, with which messages volodymyr zelensky came out, with annual messages, with final and forecasts for the next year. let's start with yaroslav yurchushin, please, but let's start with the fact that the press conference was held, it's already in... the fact that the president is talking to the press, and

this should be noted for the second year of the full-scale invasion, for the 10- and the year of the war, the value of freedom of speech is so important to society that the government must maintain the stability of the tradition, and of course there will always be a desire for more, of course there will always be a desire more deeply, and honestly... speaking, the press conference resembled pre-war press conferences, you always want more depth on acute issues, on issues that hurt society, the questions were very, let's say, of a wide range, both from tactics in relation to the war, and here it is rather possible to understand why there is no specifics, and to specific questions in relation. true facts of corruption in the environment, so

there was a very revealing answer to this question that there is a small sample of managers in the president's team, and accordingly the loss at least one of them carries great risks, and that's why the president won't go for it, and here's the question, are there really only four or five managers in the country, right? so, does the so-called hr team work well in the president's team, well, there are probably big problems with this. ah, it was, let's put it this way, i would like more specifics, especially in matters that do not relate to the sphere of national security and defense, where in principle one can assume certain aspects there, but - the press conference took place, there is food for thought. want to there is more, well, even a demonstrative one, but the unity of the military and civilian

command, but i want to emphasize once again, let's appreciate what we have, yes, we, as a society, have actually achieved the fact that, having all the possibilities of implementing tough censorship, ah, being in the 10th year of the war, we have press conferences with the president, he... is forced to answer, he wants to, he doesn't want to, but he answers uncomfortable questions, the quality of the answers, the list of journalists for the discussion, but she , we have it, it's... a demonstration the stability of ukraine itself and the accountability of the ukrainian authorities. thank you, mr. yaroslav , ms. victoria, mr. yaroslav mentioned this small team that volodymyr zelenskyi mentioned, about six or seven people, thanks to whom we have everything, as he said, and we may simply not have air defense , or there was such a phrase somewhere. in this case, isn't

ukraine a hostage of these five or six people, if during war, only these five or six people can solve many issues and what will actually happen if these five or six people are not there around president zelenskyi? and i think that ukraine will definitely not lose, even if there are not five or six people, because everything really depends on national unity, and we did not hear an answer about this today, and it is really a pity, a pity that there is no understanding, that in the coming difficult year, when unpopular... decisions will have to be made , after all, probably a government of national unity could be one of those decisions that would unite a society that naturally supports different political forces, and it could add impetus to the work of the parliament, and in particular, again, in the adoption of unpopular decisions, what i saw today, the president obviously does not want to take on

these unpopular decisions, says that the decision on mobilization is the request of the military , first of all. ah, unfortunately, we did not hear answers to the questions , for example, about strategic plan a and plan b, for example, for the country, taking into account the geopolitical challenges facing the country today, the next elections in america next year, and in the european union, and in many countries of the european european union, all this really needs such good communication with society, when people would understand how we should hold on to... we should be based and how it should all move, well , we heard about maryana and valera, it would be better if we of course, they did not hear about it, because after all , such hints about disdain for the military, for the commander-in-chief, they certainly do not add optimism to ukrainian society today, well, since you have already mentioned

these hints about valera and maryana, we let's listen, we have this synchronization. i would also like to ask mr. and mrs. elizaveta what your impressions are, whether zelenskyy answered all the questions of society and journalists, and whether you understand what, what, what will happen next, what is now, or are there clear answers to the questions you personally had? it seems to me that president zelenskyy raised quite a few topics at this press conference and gave answers to very difficult questions that concern not only our internal processes, but international ones, i want to point out here pay attention to his answer about nato, about the fact that , unfortunately, we are not invited there yet, these are his very sincere answers regarding

the situation with poland, and... where he honestly talks about problems and progress, as well as everything , which concerns, for example, the exchange of prisoners, about which countries help us with the return of children, our prisoners, where there is progress, where there is not, i think that he outlines the situation quite clearly, that it is not easy, that it is difficult, and it seems to me that this is very important, and indeed in the country... where its mobilization is currently operating in our country, wartime, we understand that there can be a lot of restrictions on freedom of speech, nevertheless, he really answered uncomfortable questions, and it seems to me that ukrainians, every

ukrainian, received certain answers to the questions that were asked, it seems that under the end of the year is very important. thank you, well, since we have already mentioned zaluzhnyi and the cornerback that president zelenskyi was asked about, president zelenskyi said that he trusts zaluzhnyi and that zaluzhnyi is part of a team, a big team, and he has a working relationship with diligent let's hear this fragment. " i have a working relationship with the commander, he must be responsible for the result, for the result on the battlefield, as a commander, we are together with the general staff. there are many issues there, there is also the commander of tavria, who, well, was in charge of operational command, look,

this is a difficult issue , attack, something happened , something didn’t happen, something happened, something is missing, or maybe it won’t be there, well, that is, it’s a complicated, very complicated story, i think that we can afford to live in ukraine with daily... results , that's what i think if we are ready to bring this result, each of us, and this, you know, this is not a joke, that's what i would like to say, i think that being the head is an honor, zelensky was asked about maryana bezuglu, as well as about these posts that regularly appear on the page of the people's deputy of ukraine from the servant of the people and what the supreme commander-in-chief of the armed forces of ukraine said, let's hear. mr. zaluzhnyi is also my

representative, as well as all those whom i appointed or who came with me, to some, to some i am very grateful, to some i am ashamed, and as for any uh... uh comments on facebook, i'm sorry, i don't do that, i don't have time, i don't have time for daily, daily and daily these unnecessary dialogues, fruitless, and as for maryana, valera, and they have a few more people there, very difficult. they all really like to comment , like, and on facebook, they communicate there very often, they have dialogues, they are from the first days, then they go to the front together, then they

quarrel, these are difficult questions, to be honest with me, that's why i and said, i think we all need to give results to the state daily, and we'll have time for a selfie, mrs. victoria, i'll ask you, doesn't zelensky remind you of a class teacher who says, well, maryana, valera, what, what kind of familiarity is this with the commander-in-chief of the armed forces of ukraine during the war, why does he call him valera, maryana, they share something with each other there, take selfies, collect some likes, well, that is, did they expect such an answer from zelenskyi, regarding the hard worker? i think the first answer was a lot. better about the working relationship, let's say so, i will not judge there now the level of general culture and education, someone, whoever it may be, i would still speak here

about the need for unity between the top leadership of the state, the leadership of the armed forces, the armed forces of ukraine and ukrainian politicians, and in such conditions, with such demonstrative contempt , it's basically complicated, and i can understand why it bothers people. because they see this as a threat, because society today is horrified to think what will happen in the event of a conflict, yes between the highest political leadership and the military leadership, well anything can happen, and here people need to be calmed down, and not provoked with such, well , statements, it seems to me somewhat ill-conceived, i hope that it was not some kind of special preparation, it happened by chance. thank you, ms. victoria, mr. yaroslav, i will ask you already, as the new chairman of the parliamentary committee on freedom of speech.

representatives of telegram channels were present at zelenskyi's press conference today. well, our telegram channels became part of the information space with the war, and these telegram channels started to develop dynamically enough, it is clear that there are verified telegram channels, well , for example, the verified espresso telegram channel, the verified bbc telegram channel, the verified league telegram channel, everything is clear there, who is the founder, who owns these telegram channels and to whom owns these media, because the ownership structure is spelled out, well, on our website, for example, it is spelled out quite clearly. i don’t know what a scumbag’s telegram channel is, for example, but he was today at a press conference with president zelenskyi in... you, as the head of the parliamentary to the committee on freedom of speech, are there any questions about how these, well, i don't know, not the media, well, for me, some of these

telegram channels are... well, typical cesspools, where they either pour mud into or write different nonsense, different things about people, about public people, about people's deputies of ukraine, about journalists, how to react in this situation at all, if the office of the president of ukraine, well, actually legalizes these telegram channels and says that they are equal among equals , well, let's remember that this is not new in... actually in the teams of the current government, remember, the previous head of the president's office, mr. bohden, said that we don't need media, we are our own media, again, telegram channels and social media began to replace traditional media even before the war, and there are a lot of challenges here, and for example, you can’t advertise there and worki, tobacco or some other aspects of telegram channels, well

, there are no such prohibitions, that is... you can really raise your own, let’s say, attract resources to which you don’t have access, and the second point , moment of verification, you if will provide untrue information from some false source, you can be appealed to, you will refute, yes, what about the telegram channel, who to appeal to, if we do not understand who it is, yes, if you, if the channel itself is not verified , and here , too, there is such a strange double... position, because the secretary of the national security and defense council says that anonymous telegram channels are a threat to our national security, ah, because today the ukrainian authorities communicate through them, tomorrow they paid a little more or paid from another source and comes russian propaganda, and in principle there is not much that can be done about it, that is why, in my opinion, this is a very ill-considered step, i understand what is going on...

let's say, trying to communicate with a larger audience, but if communicating with a larger audience is of poor quality , then in principle we are losing a very important factor, the factor of information security, and in fact we are opening the rear of our armed forces of ukraine, and therefore i would, let's say this, be happy if we for... all authorities worked in cooperation the mechanism by which verification can be required or restricted unverified sources of information in social networks, technologically it will be very difficult, the european union and large countries are working with it now, but we are already witnesses of lawsuits against the former twitter, now the hchyk network, as it is called, against musk, as the owner of this network, so for

spreading fakes. i really hope that this will be a good precedent, ukraine should theoretically, especially with the hands of the supreme leaders, actually with the hands of the supreme commander-in-chief, take care of the formation of a safe information field, because as on i think this is a very ill-conceived step, but if only such a nuance was invited, but they were not allowed to ask a question, at the same time, it is very nice that... in particular, the journalist espress was given the opportunity to ask a question, yes, but it is better to invite the media, well, because we can understand who forms the editorial policy, how it is formed, we can demand a balance of opinions in telegram channels, this is impossible, and therefore we can prepare weapons, in particular against us, that is why i, as i did not influence, of course, as the head of the committee of the supreme...

the council and the committee do not have such powers to form the list of actual invitees, this is entirely the responsibility of the communication team of the president's office, but the issue of anonymous telegram channels and even more correctly, the anonymization of sources through social networks, this will be one of the topics that we will work with in long-term period, i really count on the position of experienced colleagues from the parliament, in particular ms. victoria. as the former head of the same specialized committee, but i will not say that there are simple things here, the only thing that is not it is necessary to make it easier, it is not necessary to replace the media, not the media, the media is the fourth power , it is what we understand, it is what we understand how to work with, social networks are a little different, by the way, sorry that i now i will ask out of the context of what zelensky said, but the question about...