understands how she will behave when she finds herself at a certain level of responsibility, well, half of russia is freezing over there, and putin is like this, i am, in general, there is something i, not me , they don’t recognize me, well, something, something is unclear, and of course , as you understand, a lot of different people there, some who work, also started right there. in russian eyes , all the networks write propaganda, but not everything is so scary, well, you think 30°, well, it’s okay, they will survive somehow, well, that is , they tell that nothing is happening at all, these are some separate literally some that are now being liquidated and everything will be fine, well, but as you can see, it was not liquidated in any way, that is, it is still going on, and now, when we are even talking to you, it is continuing this and the flash mob is beautiful and all that. the inclusion of energy in them, moreover

, i will tell you, and the frosts continue, and they have yet to intensify there now, so we are waiting for new incendiary videos from literally there about how they freeze, let's see, evaluate, well, putin, well, what , he talked about really important issues during this trip, let's find out, if you watch these modern cartoons of western production , everything there is shooting from... or running, in half an hour your head will fall off from this movie, how can children endure it, our soviet cartoons are of a completely different quality, you know, considering traditional values, the question arises: why does an old man, who now officially does not have a wife and children, watch children's cartoons, even foreign ones, with whom does he watch these cartoons, is it with small children, and whose children are these? why are they with putin, isn't it criminal?

crime, is it sometimes? and in general, where do the fighters for the traditional family look? as for putin's gloomy state of mind, you know, you can understand him, he has experienced personal grief. the fact is that just a few days ago, putin's so-called gerontologist, that is , a person who is engaged in maintaining the health of old people, died. in the photo of the 17th year next to the russian dictator, this is standing. scientist volodymyr khavinson, who is called putin's personal gerentologist in zma, and this khavinson promised putin another 20 years in the 17th year active life, and in general said that people can live up to 100 years, but the other day hyvinson died, he was 77 years old, i will remind putin 70, so, i will tell you, not everyone will survive such a blow, and not only here you will talk about cartoons, children, so we sympathize with that. and we will see each other again,

hello, hello, woman, what to do when there is a liver problem, you need to take allochol, and what about gallstones, allochol, it protects both the liver and the gallbladder. with care and respect for the liver and gall bladder, the vinyl agency presents taras chubai and songs that all of ukraine sings along to. the special guest of the concert is the lviv men's academic choir chapel dudaryk. karabask tickets, live sound. oh, and we got wet, can you have some tea? what to do in order not to

get sick? vitamin c, d3, zinc and, most importantly, quercitin to strengthen blood vessels. just take quertin immuno. all in one package. in one capsule, four components together. so simple, one capsule a day. so convenient. quertin immuno. there are discounts on hepargen. 10% in travel bam pharmacies and savings. everyday life is now full of stress and anxiety. cope with these challenges. melamamag b6. melatonin, magnesium and vitamin b6 contribute to a full rest and restore strength. melamach b6. full sleep and recovery from bhfz. i congratulate you. this is svoboda live on radio svoboda. we have already approached the serpent himself. the following shots may shock you. news from the scene. live political analytics objectively and

meaningfully. there is no political seasonality. exclusive interviews, reports from the hottest spots. freedom of life, frankly and unbiased, you draw your own conclusions. vasyl zima's big broadcast. two hours of airtime, two hours of your time. two hours to learn about the war and how the world lives. two hours to keep up with economic and sports news. two hours in the company of favorite presenters, presenters who have become silent to many. as well as distinguished guests of the studio: the events of the day in two hours, vasyl zima's big broadcast, a project for smart and caring people, espresso in the evening. the war created many challenges for

us ukrainians, and even more so for ukrainians with disabilities. but we know that only together united, we can be stronger. friends, welcome! friendly online community enable me ukraine. this is the first platform in ukraine for people with disabilities to communicate. here you get all the information about disability, medical services and relocation. free consultations of a lawyer, a psychologist, a doctor, a specialist in the employment of volunteers from all over europe. this is where you get support. advice and true friends. together we support each other, share useful information and learn new things. together we grow. join us, stand up part of our family, enable me. with the support of

the national assembly of persons with disabilities of ukraine, enable me ukraine. what am i worse than other people, those who are fighting, why do i need a country in which there will be no freedom? kateryna, an officer of the armed forces of ukraine. he has been in the army for about four years. at first , she worked as a specialist in moral and psychological support, and now she is an illuminator. the work of the military at the front. the task of the press officer is to show the truth of what is happening, that is , through the eyes of the press officer, the whole world sees the horrors and crimes committed by russia on

territory of ukraine. kateryna joined the army in 2021, although the desire arose much earlier. the woman was preparing to become a teacher of physical education and the basics with... then the revolution of dignity began and plans changed. since then, she went to the military hospital several times, but they did not take her. i'm young, i'm healthy, i thought i was a physically strong, intelligent woman. and why can't i help the state, why, well, if i can't do something, i 'll learn it. in the 17th year, it seems, i came again to another. military commander, and they told me there: well, if you were still there an officer, maybe you would become a deputy from the mpz there, there was no mpz then, but it seems that it was called differently there, i say, do you want an officer, it’s not a question at all,

i say, i will come to you next time as an officer, kateryna fulfilled her promise and still signed a contract with the armed forces of ukraine, became a deputy for moral and psychological support. one of the divisions. at that time, the brigade was already performing tasks in the combat zone. we drove there for 40, 50 km, to a point where there was a mobile fire group for to work with the staff. but to be honest, i didn't like it very much, it doesn't match my character, it doesn't match any of my ambitions. so kateryna transferred to another position. and began to work in the press service of the 30th separate mechanized brigade of the armed forces of ukraine. covered the events of the svitodar arc and ubahmutya. i was very comfortable because every day we had no day, not until february 24th, the 22nd, not

after, when we stayed at home. that is, maybe some sunday somewhere, but it's all the same there was work with materials, we were constantly leaving, we communicated. these are very cool people, soldiers, officers, sergeants, each person is such a pearl, a pearl that shines, you just need to open the shell. to watch the beginning of a full -scale russian invasion, the brigade had already been in the combat zone for seven months, kateryna was just waiting for a rotation, these were positions near horlivka on may day, and i took the journalists of one of the tv channels there, because there was heavy shelling there, even before february 24 , it was the month of january, russians they mercilessly hit... the houses of civilians, they just destroyed, they also killed people

, after a couple of days, it was january, i go to that position again, i take journalists, because there was another hit in a civilian house, and i take a puppy, a white, fluffy javelin, and already when a full-scale invasion took place, on february 24, everyone was running. they collected their things, hid them, handed something over there, i held the dog close to my heart so that , god forbid, he didn't run away, so that nothing would happen to him, the dog, a camera and a laptop. then the woman felt the threat of a great war. assaults, we filmed there, i don't know, the tanks fired with direct fire, and i even filmed it near the test site, you can hear it there from the first shots, i put the phone on the ground. stood, waiting for tanchyk to work, and there, in

literally three minutes , the aircraft worked, the tanks worked, the saw worked, our equipment worked, that is, everything happened in those three minutes. kateryna took part in the kharkiv counteroffensive, recorded the consequences of the crimes of the russian troops on ukrainian territory. and now we have arrived at the position of the invincible second army of the world and will get to know their finest. the best guns, this is how they look powerful, powerfully standing and rotting in the ukrainian land. we left for the units , we just filmed while the metal was still red-hot coming out of the tank, that is, it was just after the droppings, we filmed as the equipment burned down, we still saw the warm bodies of the smelly people there... russians, this is very, very beautifully executed , this is a very cool and powerful

operation of the defense forces, that is, this is a resource, it's people, it's equipment and it's information, it's very powerful, it's very cool, that is, we really, we really didn't even expect it ourselves, there was also what was most impressive about the counterattack, the general picture and... where the russian military was for a certain time , there they put a mirror for themselves, put a portrait of a woman with bare breasts attached to the boxes from under arms, put toilet paper, something was russian in them, something they stole already here, that is , everyday life itself, and they also kept with them old propaganda newspapers, oh... me i was surprised, they took these newspapers in order to wrap the food, or they were specially

brought to them, because the dates did not correspond to the fresh ones. the woman is convinced that the work of the brigade's press officers is important at the front, because they have the opportunity to be the first to see and cover combat operations and the consequences of russian actions and convey information to the whole world. inclining to the transparency of the media, we take a conventional foreign publication, and we look at... the situation, if the situation allows them to be brought directly to the position, we bring journalists directly to the position, they they film the events that are happening there, they take comments from our boys and girls, and they show the world that this is really happening, the world should know, the world should support us. khrystyna parobiy, espresso tv channel. watch this week in the judicial control program with tatyana shustrova.

catastrophic lack of personnel, where to take half of the judges. there is a high probability that certain appellate judges will be suspended. but how did judicial reform progress in ukraine last year? we have a chance to choose normal judges of the constitutional court. congratulations, that's it judicial control and i, tetyana shostrova. we received the status of a candidate country for joining the eu, but. subject to the fulfillment of the so-called seven steps, the criteria defined by the european commission, among which are anti-oligarchic reform, the fight against corruption, changes in the laws on national minorities and... and one of the key points is the implementation of judicial reform. and over the past year, ukraine has managed a lot. today we will tell you how far this reform has moved. but first to the news. the courts of appeal of ukraine lack half of the judges. from 1350 700 positions are vacant. in the last 10 years

, not a single judge has come there. this affects the terms of consideration of cases. and their quality, there is a high probability of stopping the work of certain appellate courts, so currently only four judges work in the sumy court of appeal, imagine, but this is both a criminal and a civil chamber, taking into account the fact that in appellate courts cases are heard as part of a collegium , i.e. three judges, two judges in each chamber, in fact it is impossible to create a collegium, and they involve the criminal chamber. civil, civil, criminal, that is, how long they will last, let's say, is unknown in this state and in this mode of operation. only 13 judges work in the kharkiv court of appeal out of 60 positions by state. in the largest kyiv court of appeal, out of 145 judges by staff, there are not enough 70. the higher qualification commission of judges plans to start interviews with

candidates for vacant positions of judges in appeal courts in autumn next year. competition. has already started for the occupation of 550 vacant positions of judges, more than 200 candidates are applying. most willing to take the position in the general court of appeal - 912, the least in the commercial court of appeal - 183. the meeting of judges of the civil court of cassation of the supreme court elected judges olga stupak and serhiy pogribny to the grand chamber for a term of three years. according to the estimates of the foundation's experts, there are appointed judges. unscrupulous, according to the conclusion of the public integrity council, the property of olga stupak's family does not correspond to income, and the judge allegedly deliberately understated the value of the purchased real estate in the declaration. olga stupak assured that she bought 10 acres of land in kyiv, allegedly for uah 149,000, and a new house with an area of ​​380 m2 and 13 acres of land near kyiv, svykrusa

managed to buy it for almost three times less than the market value. from the conclusion of the public. integrity councils, in particular, unconfirmed sources of income for the acquisition by the candidate of a house with an area of ​​380 m2 and a plot of land of 0.13 hectares under it, which are located in the village of stoyanka, kyiv-svitoshyn district, kyiv region. according to data from real estate sites, the market value of such buildings is from uah 5 million. in the candidate's declaration the cost of the house is not indicated at all, but is reported in the explanations. that the house and land were purchased for uah 1,862. the national anti-corruption bureau conducted an investigation into possible declaration of false information by supreme court judge olga stupak and verified the compliance of the judge's income and wealth. detectives found many violations, but the judge was lucky. the constitutional court of ukraine

annulled the article for unreliable declaration. regarding the elected judge of the grand chamber of the supreme court'. pogribnogo is also negative conclusion of the public council of virtue. in particular, it refers to his decision with signs of political influence regarding illegal construction on the odesa coast, and the transfer of land to the kyiv zoo, which the judge allowed to be built very quickly in one sitting, 10 days after accepting the lawsuit. also, the judge forbade filming at an open session, although the parties to the case did not object, thereby violating the open principle. last year, despite the large-scale war unleashed by russia, ukraine confidently continued path to the european union, fulfilled two of the seven recommendations necessary to maintain the status of a candidate for membership. in particular , we spoke with the head of the foundation, mykhailo

zhernakov, about the judicial reform in terms of conducting competitions for judicial governance bodies and tried to sum up the results of the judicial reform in 2023. little was accepted, or little was completed, that is , those processes that had already begun in the 21st year of the reboot of the bodies of judicial governance, the higher commission of judges, the higher council were completed justice, that is, these two bodies were created, started working and already, thank god , show a different quality of work, at least than the previous ones. in january of last year , the renewed high council of justice, a key judicial body responsible for the integrity of the entire judicial body and the only one with constitutional powers, began its work. for the dismissal of judges and the granting of permission to bring them to justice, and currently there is a lot of work in the vrp. more than 12,000 disciplinary complaints against the actions of judges have been registered in the body. mainly. after all, the product of the activity of the high council of justice is disciplinary, well, the main function, probably, it is disciplinary, it is , accordingly, decisions in disciplinary cases, they still have not passed them, despite

the fact that they have been granted by law back, while the service of disciplinary inspectors is being created , they were given back the right to conduct disciplinary cases, to consider, there are some very strange decisions that show , after all, that the supreme council of justice acts for... the status quo, and not for cleaning up the renewal of judicial power. in june, after three years non-functioning, the higher qualification commission of judges, the competition for which was the largest in the entire history of the judicial system of ukraine, became operational. 19 people for one place, 16 selected through a tough competition, members of the supreme judicial council are responsible for forming the judicial corps, transferring judges from one court to another, as well as ensuring their proper level, in particular through qualification evaluation. currently, the sccc has two priority tasks: to complete the qualification evaluation and to appoint more than 2,500 judges, who are in short supply

has currently caused a real crisis and overloading of judges, about 200 vacancies must be filled by the higher qualification commission of judges in one way or another, including the selection announced for about 100 judicial positions, and this is quite significant and in the appellate instance. and in the first place, and this is a rather significant opportunity to both update the system and, let’s say, to sanction what we had before, how the higher commission of stakes treats the assessment of certain aspects of integrity is of fundamental importance, both in order to finally remove from the court the system of those judges who are not worthy to be judges, and so in order to fill it with virtuous qualified personnel. an important link of the judicial reform last year was the reform of the constitutional court, one of the... most important judges of the country, it was under threat of disruption due to efforts to once again politicize the process of appointing judges. the law on changing the process of selecting judges

of the constitutional court, creating an advisory group of experts and greater public involvement was accompanied by scandals, since instead of changes the proposed the draft law increasingly politicized the procedure for selecting judges. in the end , it was possible to overcome the contradictions and the law was adopted, taking into account the majority of positive changes, but not without a fight. we still have a chance to choose normal judges of the constitutional court, but there is no guarantee, precisely because the venice commission treated this process in a very specific way. they issued six different opinions, six different decisions of their own regarding conclusions, regarding how and what should happen in the constitutional court, and they almost all contradict each other. they contain factual errors, everything led to what we have now, well, far from optimal, far from optimal law, the text of the law,

it could be and should be much stronger. nevertheless, in general, the european commission has noted good progress in the introduction of competitive selection, and this is extremely important, because the fate of several key reforms, in particular, the further reform of the supreme court, depends on the constitutional court right now. justice, land market reform and others. after the end of the war , the constitutional court will consider complex cases the issue of reintegration of the occupied territories. based on the results of a survey of member companies, the european business association concluded that the effectiveness of the judicial reform in ukraine improved during the 23rd year, but is still in the negative plane. so for this year, tasks for the further movement of judicial reform and improvement of the judicial system of ukraine. should we first introduce a mechanism that will still remove these unscrupulous elements from the supreme court, and secondly, hold a competition for

positions that are already vacant in the supreme court. the next task in terms of complexity, probably also in terms of priority, is new administrative courts, instead of the liquidated district administrative court, the third is legal education, reform of legal education, there is quite a long list, ugh, that is, we need to fundamentally change the way we prepare. our lawyers, so that they already at that level understand what integrity is, and act accordingly. we hope that all this will be implemented in 2024, and we will continue to carefully monitor the movement of judicial reform and the implementation of changes. that's all for today, you watched judicial control, i am tetyana shustrova. if you want to report corrupt or illegal judges. solution, write to me on facebook or to this email address. see you in exactly a week.

europe understands this, or should eventually understand it, so we in ukraine count on your support in our relations with the alliance, and on your principled position in the dialogue with all partners, regarding the future of ukraine in nato, the unconditional future in nato. modern security is common security, and it is precisely such security, modern, such security, effective, that we all have together we have to build, thank you, thank you, latvia, glory to ukraine, thank you very much, we will continue then with the media, and ms. inesa from latvian television, good evening, latvian television, i want to ask

what enduring this year means enduring the entire war, i wanted would like to ask what exactly is such a key point this year, of course you mentioned a lot, but what is needed both from ukraine and from others in the other world, both politically, economically and also emotionally. that ukraine not only endures, but that ukraine wins. and gentlemen rinkevich, a question: what would you like to say to european leaders today, when you are standing next to volodymyr zelenskyi, why europe is delaying making such necessary decisions, for example, when it was possible to completely sever all economic ties with russia. thank you. simply, thank you for

a very serious question, and this is the kind of question you have that can be discussed for a long time, but in wartime there is probably no time for discussion, although this discussion, it, it would be important, especially for partners who all more, you know, balancing in their confidence. therefore, to endure this year, not to surrender our territories , not to let anyone freeze the conflict, the narratives of russia, and not only their narratives, which are spread, unfortunately, even by the media platforms of europe and the united states, etc., have deep penetration , and russia invests a lot of money in disinformation, so... don't let

the conflict freeze, don't give russia the opportunity to prepare for a powerful counteroffensive in a year, in two, in three, in five, don't let them do it, end the war by this one, no to give them opportunities, and to increase their production, not to give an opportunity to freeze the conflict in this area. that their military began to prepare, began powerful training, so that young people who today do not know why they come to our land and die, so that they do not turn into the information policy and through additional years and training, so that they do not the army itself.