of ukraine, which again, elected by whom? politicians? parliament, he personifies this parliament , absolutely right, because no matter what we say, yes, again from these quotes, there is parity in uavs, there is poverty in drones, but there are no, sorry, those industrial opportunities that would allow this parity to be overturned , they don't exist, that's what... sometimes they throw it in one direction, now i try to throw it in the other direction, so that they don't think that everything is simple there. i know of only two high-ranking military officers who defended their doctoral dissertations during the war. one last name is kuzmuk, when minister ony tenyukh ordered him to go to the crimea, and it is not yet known what would have ended if he had gone.

the second one, this is one question, the second question is the politicization of the armed forces, how should i react to the fact that the crooked nose was not taken, but, excuse me, zabrodsky was taken, or how should i react to the presence of the secretary, colonel of the sbu in the security and defense committee , understanding what democrats are. an even more provocative question is how many rights and freedoms do military servicemen have today? silence, no one knows, i will tell you, 22, they are outlined by the council of ministers of the european union, do you know what the first right is? what is the right to life, and

what is it supported by, the right to life is supported by sufficient weapons, sufficient provision, let's say, of everything necessary to exist at the front, so that a person does not die in vain, this is a key question, and politicians do not mention it today , no, what are you, god forbid. next, we ask one more question: zaluzhnyi goes out and takes pictures with various girls, a volunteer, they will tell you what it is, climbs into politics? at the beginning, i also perceived it as getting into politics, and then i realized that no, it is not getting into politics, it is an ordinary marketing ploy in order to get those volunteers... to get all

the necessary ammunition for these guys, because all these signed flags, all these photos, they are later provided, as a certain proof that everything will be fine, and everything will be delivered, you see, this is also a moment that no one takes into account, do not understand that the cabinet of ministers of ukraine, elected by politicians, is not able to give everything to the armed forces today forces of ukraine, where did it go in 30 years? another point, very interesting, yes, was zaluzhny's statement that there is no longer any accumulation of resources sufficient to carry out a counteroffensive, this counteroffensive will not be carried out, was, was carried out, ugh.

resources turned out to be insufficient, moreover, it was stated that our concept was largely wrong, the idea was that we would destroy 30,000 there, the russians would give up the war. well, this is dilettantism, in my opinion, from the point of view of what i know how former military man, you understand, and such moments that, for example, the politicization of the army, i said, yes, such moments... a lot, moreover, today you will see a very interesting trend, it is an attempt, ah, well, to integrate military and political society, that it takes place in a different form, absolutely in a different form, we are already preparing people in military uniform for the elections today, it doesn't matter if he participated or not. but we are not

preparing a legal framework today, which would, for example, not allow those who passed to accept the front, i don’t know, participation in state authorities or you... who has not passed the front, not to be a civil servant, does he not have the right to apologize for the future, well, the elections, that’s all these moments, they popped up in the conflict between politicians and military, so i'm not surprised, for example, defending a military thesis, well, you'll fire me, i'll get the maximum pension that i can get, uh, that's how i would describe it all, okay? of course it is possible with something, there are different questions in different directions, it is important that we also have them voiced on our broadcast, valery chalyy is already expecting, we will finish the discussion in our studio regarding the voluntary mobilization, but with mr. extraordinary plenipotentiary ambassador of ukraine to the usa in 15-19 years, chairman of the board

of the ukrainian crisis media center, still mr. valery, well, if you have any thoughts and regarding what you heard in our studio, of course you can express them, but today the decisions of the european union finally allocate this money, which... we talked about, we have already been waiting for a long time, not blocked by hungary, not blocked slovakia, on the other hand, there are already opinions that during the covid the european union allocated much more, well, it just allocated funds for support there in a different order, but nevertheless, we must be thankful for what is there, or is this the decision of the european union today, this some kind of breakthrough and this support machine from the eu will continue. work better and better given that compromises have been found with orbán and fico from slovakia, your analysis, congratulations, kudos to ukraine, and also congratulations to everyone in the studio, i didn't really get to hear much there, but yes

at the end i heard mr. igor, well, i will reflect only one thing, there are many aspects during the war, and i think that it is normal that we are conducting. discussions, i just heard that we do not have a restriction on civil servants there, there will be such a restriction, now in the draft law, i think it is absolutely fair, those who will claim to be a civil servant must undergo either military service or basic military training, at least, well, this is absolutely the right moment, i think that this is how the deputies will accept it, and regarding the fact that relations are political and military, you know this is... well, history is as old as the world, and in many wars it all manifested itself, so i think that we will continue this discussion for a very long time, i would very much like to wish everyone that the discussion would turn into this plane, so that we already our soldiers, who

are now putting their lives on the future of the country, so that they really have the absolute greatest right to build the country, i... i would like us to live to such times as soon as possible. now, regarding your question, i think it's a very good positive signal that we are received together with our successful attack, on this ivanovets, which our ternopil once set as a target, and now this missile boat was very skillfully struck, and we are in our center, the ukrainian media center, we are leading. we have such a diagram, how many russian ships have been eliminated in the black sea, you know, i like it, i like it more and more, and the command post, by the way, in relation to it, most likely it was not just a communication node near the bilbek airport , but

rather a command point, so very much thanks to our who do such successful operations, the european union is another positive news and i'm considering, by the way... is very timely because today there was a talk by ursula fondelai, the head of the european commission, the former german defense minister, she perfectly understands the importance of such decisions in the conditions of war, and she has already called joseph biden, this is a very good signal washington, a very good signal, that is, we will, of course , only hear the figure of 50 billion euros, but if we go deeper, what... this, then i can to tell, of course, but all the same , 500 billion euros of aid to the european union will appear in the coming days and weeks, and this shows that the european union still has a long-term vision, not an immediate one, by the way, they do

it better than in the united states today, such are the strategic visions, i would like them to tighten up with shells in the same way. but this is a signal to the kremlin that look at what you didn't do there, you didn't spin, you didn't twist, we see ukraine in the european family, not only geographically, historically, but also politically, economically, this is very good signal, and despite the fact that there will still be certain stages, and it will be for four years, but the european union is taking the lead, the european union is now objectively the first in terms of aid to ukraine in the world, if we take the european union as a whole, so i think let's, we haven't had a lot of upbeat news like that lately, let's take it from that angle. very optimistic news, especially since all these loans, grants, or technical

assistance will undergo eu control procedures in the process of european integration, it is also there is hope that they will use these funds and all these efforts will go in the right direction. mr. chala, in our broadcasts and also in others that i watched with your participation, you talked about the fact that this is the possibility... that russia will attack nato countries this year, maybe next , it is very high, and do you think that this decision of europe, so positive for us financially, will cause these threats, in particular? well, i would say, the reasons were in washington, european leaders understood that not everything can be expected from america. and they began to invest more actively in their security, european security, in this respect, this is positive, but will it

deter possible russian provocations there? well, i think not yet, because in fact this aid, it goes more to the macrofin, that is , economic and financial issues, and what the president of ukraine called on them to provide, by the way, two presidents. and zelensky called, and poroshenko called, that they provide money from the european peace fund. this money, which they gave 5.62 billion euros at the time, they are now really for now blocked these are funds that go to military needs. and the next step would be good if it was for military needs. if the european union, the united states, and the whole world support ukraine in such a way that we of this war could switch to another high-tech, maneuverable one, then they

can avoid a direct russian attack on a nato country, if not, i stand by my opinion, it can happen even next winter. mr. valery, one more question, already final , probably just for you on our broadcast, we talk a lot about the discussion around potential resignation or dismissal is more correct, probably yes. to formulate zaluzhnyi, this week not only telegram channels, some people's deputies or opinion leaders in ukraine talked about it, but also all international well-known, well, not all, many international major publications, media holdings, including cnn and so on and so on something like that, well, maybe you saw some kind of trend, because you know some kind of such, and opinions about that always... you can’t dismiss, these articles didn’t have it, but there was a lot of information on this topic, that’s how to count

according to those, including articles and reports of international media, how does the international community relate to this, to this situation, which now has the status of potential in our country? well, with all due respect to the international community, i think it's unprofessional if we're talking about institutional stability. countries of the personnel policy, we will give the opinion or evaluations of the zones for ransom. these are our questions. if we talk about personnel policy, it is not ideal, not only in this. the specificity lies in the fact that it is very difficult to change the management structure in the course of the war, starting with to the commander-in-chief, and it's not just him, it was fixed in two years, after. a large-scale invasion and to this management, whatever it is, the best

, the worst, or not effective, or whatever, but i don't see anyone proposing a better model, that is, it's not just one person, it's a lot of deputies, commanders, well , deputies, at least, and i will tell you that what is outside, i am not very pleased that we will learn some information from the outside. articles, and when ours, well, there is no trust in bloggers, in what appears in ukrainian ones information resources, by the way, i have confidence in such publications, which are not all telegram channels, which, by the way , are analyzed in moscow by artificial intelligence systems already today, and everything you write in a telegram about your relatives, you contact yours, by the way, yours, write, what do you call your relative who is fighting, everything gets to moscow, the kremlin in the telegram channel, telegram and not only, well, this is a separate issue,

so i think that you should also trust your , it was said about it, what is the issue of consideration. given, that is, i do not consider it a catastrophe consideration of any issues and their discussion, i consider it difficult to reduce the efficiency of the work of state administration, including in the military sphere, if the president of ukraine has something to offer and take responsibility and propose a better model, well, it will be better for defense , if it is done for other reasons, it will simply give the enemy certain opportunities to... destabilize our system for at least a few months, and as for the long-term, our partners will never interfere with our so much internal affairs, the only thing they will be interested in is how you see further, how you will protect the country in the conditions, when you have such ideas, and i think victoria noland

is now acting deputy secretary, that is, she is now... deputy anthony blinken, secretary of state. for some reason, she interrupted her visit to turkey and came suddenly to kyiv. to be honest, i was hoping that it was about nato and this visit of scholz to washington and nato issues in general, but i'm already looking, i get the impression that she wanted to convey other messages to washington, what is actually happening, so it is necessary. how will you explain it to your partners, how will you explain it, communicate it, as it is fashionable to say in society, and what do we have now, we are already the enemy of russia, we gave a lot of excuses, nothing happened, and we have already weakened our position in the hybrid and hybrid plane of war, and so you can't do it, the president made a decision, do it, don't do it, then don't do these things,

thank you, valery chaly, ambassador extraordinary and plenipotentiary. in the usa in 2015-19 , the chairman of the board of the ukrainian crisis organization of the media center was with us via skype, shared his expert opinions on the topics that are important. taras tetskiv, today's decision of the european union, these are the things about which inuland himself said, chala's interesting, interesting thesis was actually thrown on our air, because victoria nolan came and said that they are waiting for putin. for ukraine, these will be pleasant surprises, for the russian federation , they will be unpleasant, these are the ones, well, we can say that ours a little, as if our partners have moved a little, as you think, well, i agree with the assessments of valery chaly, this a really positive signal, and i think it

will have a positive impact, er, i think it's already obvious er... it's clear that europe, european countries, the european union, is taking the lead in helping ukraine, and so far in america this inter-party discussion and quarrel continues, which can drag on for a very long time, it honestly scares me, because in some places what is happening, everything is getting worse and worse, that is, the situation is not even equalized there, i will tell you that it feels like ... the historian is sometimes reminded of the times of the late roman empire, i would very much like to be wrong, but if in america, the political establishment does not stop this, this, these games, then it may cost america the loss of world leadership, and this will be reflected in the fate of the west, as a system of the liberal order, and it will also be reflected

in ukraine, and the fact that now the european union is well aware of this situation in america. actually puts ukraine on the shoulder, well , i don't know what it will lead to, i don't want to draw such far-reaching consequences, conclusions, but i think that the first swallow, this agreement of ukraine with britain in the field of security, these are not security guarantees, then 100%, here our authorities simply use such a term in vain, these are some security obligations, but this is the first swallow that can... can lead to a change in a certain security architecture in europe, to the transformation of nato itself, and this is good for ukraine against the background of what is happening. in the united states of america, this kind of help, despite the opposition inspired by moscow, hungary, and partly slovakia

managed to accept it, so it is good for ukraine, well, we don’t have so many of these signals now, we continue to be in a very difficult situation for a month now, in such a pit, our relatives, and this signal can give such a person to be the first in... such a first sign of getting out of this pit, in which ukraine is now from the point of view from the point of view of our defense, so i think this is a good signal. mr. kozi, i have a question for you, we very often hear that europe cannot increase the production of the projectiles that they promise us to a sufficient level, there we do not compare with what even the russians are producing, that europe... so a little sleepy, to put it mildly, but we hear about various polls, where, well, actually, you know , it's also russian, when they

say that a small number of europeans are ready to fight, but there are large percentages, yes, they there are also those people who are ready to go as volunteers, do you think we will be able to get the military aid that we keep talking about, or see... all the reports that ukraine is critically short of ammunition for conducting defensive operations now, in fact, first of all, will become more and more, well, not just such threatening messages, but will lead to some, well, unpleasant, to put it mildly, news from the fronts that are on the territory of ukraine now, whether they will rush or not, that's a cool question, you know, when i talk to... a big business that produces ammunition, they say we are ready to increase, we are ready to give, yes, the germans even said we are ready to build

something here in ukraine, that is normal, but when you start with scientists, even in the same oberamargau ask , talk about everyone these things, they lead to the fact that there is still no political decision regarding... let's say, the build-up regarding the implementation, regarding, uh, well, it is enough to provide a sufficient amount, all these words that came out in that article, they are not they appeared not without reason, you will understand correctly how the chief of staff can plan an operation if he is not ready to tell you how many missiles he has or how much he... i don't know, he will receive a projectile resource tomorrow, the day after tomorrow, for 7 days he has to plan the operation , at least he is not ready about it

to say, and the question is that yes, at the political level we hear the signals there, we will provide a million and so on, let 's wait for march, we will once again make sure whether europe is capable, not technologically. namely, from a political point of view, i already have this feeling of this conviction, that it is not inhibited directly by big business, but precisely that it is inhibited at a certain political level to provide us with this million projectiles, i hope that this will happen, but so far there are no signs of this, well, very little, but now they said that gps was missing on the territory of the countries.

are members of the parliament of the european community and work for the intelligence of the russian federation and are, sorry, leading scientists. in baltic universities and also recruited by the russian federation, i.e. the issue of counterintelligence support, it is relevant today, as always, not only in ukraine, but also in the west, and how to do it, we expect elections in romania, what will happen after that, moreover , just before our main broadcast mr. portnikov said that these people can be increased in the parliaments, in the authorities of various european countries, this is an interview report. portnikov is on our youtube channel, says velikiy lviv, you can go there and watch it, we will be grateful to you for it, it is for the viewers of the tv channels, i say, you have

one and a half minutes, then we, er... we will say goodbye to the viewers of espresso on the air youtube will continue , but now try, i will quote valery zaluzhny: according to the conditions of today's war, perhaps the main option for gaining an advantage is mastering the entire arsenal of relatively cheap, newest and extremely effective means that are rapidly developing, it is the attempt to take advantage of the gains of progress in the development of the latest technologies that will allow us to win the war, what i am leading to is ... it is in our hands, accordingly we think what will be there, no doubt, it is possible, but the father is in our hands, so remember our last broadcast with my participation, it was actually about innovations , technologies, thank you, thank you, so we are now saying goodbye to the viewers of the tv channel, traditionally we will see each other here in the project in the project studio says velikiy lviv on the largest discussion platform of our country exactly

in a week, traditionally at... 21:15 on espresso, we will continue on youtube in literally 20 seconds. thank you for being with us. there are discounts for... 15% in psyllanyk, pam and oskad pharmacies. why am i here i have sensitive teeth, eat ice cream, pain, cold air, pain, sweet, pain. the dentist prescribed lakalot sensitive, which effectively reduces tooth sensitivity. if i had known lakad sensitive earlier, i would not have had to come here at all. lacalot sensitive - reliable protection against pain. a person who has fallen into a coma will learn the news.

everyone was lied to by spartacus on saturday, who? now my girlfriend and her mother will come there, my girlfriend will also be there, my grandmother will be there, let 's play something, show my google search history, the real search history, we are definitely playing, there were some elections, 100% for lebigovych, i suggest peeing and go to sleep, maybe i'll take a look. allegedly the first sex in two years, there are 10% discounts on citramondarnitsa in pharmacies, plantain, bam and ochad, there are discounts on zippel 10% in pharmacies, plantain, pam and ochad, usual affairs become unreal, difficult bags are not for my sore back,

back pain, try the cream. relieves pain, reduces swelling and improves joint mobility, with dolgit cream, what do you want to lift, dolgit - the only yellow cream for joint and back pain, buy with a 15% discount, dolgit cream 100 g at the pharmacies of antz pharmacy, kopyka pharmacy and shaar pharmacy. there are discounts on perfectil original, 15% in psarynyk bam and oskad pharmacies. laughter, physical activity, sneezing. even during such a small load, urinary incontinence can make itself felt. feminost helped me uro. thanks to the natural ingredients, feminost uuro helps to restore control over urination both during the day and at night. feminost uuro - urination under control. ask at pharmacies. there are discounts on afida max of 10% in psyllanyk, pam and oskad pharmacies. every week, the saturday political club helps to understand

the processes taking place in ukraine. vitaly portnikov, khrystyna yatskiv and invited experts based on facts give their assessment and forecast of the development of events. if you want to understand how our today will affect our tomorrow, watch the saturday political club, every saturday on espresso. a separate set of unmanned aerial vehicles. tsipsapsan of the state special service of transport, are appealing to the viewers of the tv channel to join the collection of crown funds and technical equipment for our unit. thank you, glory to ukraine! glory to heroes. greetings, this is svoboda live,

my name is. vlasta lazur. now we are talking about an attack on...