because the situation around us was understood, that the external media also reacted first of all to what was said inside, internally this situation developed extremely badly, with poor explanation and communication around us, in which we have not just an individual and some ordinary manager, conditionally minister, here is mrs. laputina, with all due respect to her, but she is gone now, and especially no one among ordinary ukrainians has noticed what is changing in us. rather , the minister of veterans affairs is retiring, we we don't even know who will replace him, for what task and when he will be there, but the hardworking person is a legendary figure, because he is associated with the perception of the first months of the russian invasion and the fact that ukraine did the impossible, resisted when everything seemed that against us, and zaluzhny managed to organize this process, everyone understood that we survived not only thanks to the master zaluzhny, but... first of all thanks

to ukrainian society, the state, as always , showed that it is behind the scenes in relation to society and readiness to self-organize, but the industrious became this symbol, which concentrated this image on itself, and therefore its replacement for a part of society was the taking away of something so close, something part of the resilience of these people, because someone associated with it the fact that victory will definitely be in us, the fact that ukraine is capable of doing the impossible, the fact that the ukrainian... in the political leadership, everyone is in their place, this myth, its myth of understanding is not about lies, but about the perception of the situation, the ukrainian military epic, it was taken and crushed before our eyes for several weeks ago syrskyi is also now an unbiased person who has his strengths and weaknesses. even his opponents, for example, point out that he is a strong organizer, as an organizer, he is a strong person. at the same time, there is a burdensome image of him. which is included in a meme or a nickname

that comes down to us from the front trenches under the name of the butchers, which has already been written about by the western media, accordingly, he starts from the position that he is in the shadow of the legendary hard worker and he will be constantly compared with those the good times that were before him saying that an industrious man would not have done that, and for industriousness, perhaps this would not have happened, and he will need to prove now, first of all, that he is not a peasant and... and that he is the first, one from the first statements he said that soldier life is a priority for him, this is very good, it is an admission that he understands that this will be his weak point, and his steps in this direction will always be under a microscope. and the second point is that the main tasks before him are of an organizational nature, because here i want to say that despite the fact that the whole situation developed in kraipkepsk, at the finish line, i applaud the way it ended, zaluzhny...

the authorities behaved absolutely worthy of themselves by also awarding the order to zaluzhny and awarding it to him, that's why they hugged at this presentation, despite the fact that later they saw photos of zaluzhny and sirstvo, by the way , zaluzhny is, if i am not mistaken, a subordinate of syrsky in the past, before zelensky appointed zaluzhny as the head in the 20th year, and all this demonstrates that on today is the day of complaints to zaluzhny... the military unit has no one and not because of that and it is not because of any claims, but because of the fact that a certain reorganization is needed, certain organizational challenges facing us now, perhaps with which syrsky argues better. in the end, i root for it to be like that, i think, like all ukrainians, but the fact that now it will be necessary to prove that it was not a mistake, it will have to be done by syrsky at every step, and the responsibility for the entire military situation, now take off zelensky's bulletproof vest, she completely...

will fall on his shoulders, because syrskyi will not be perceived separately from zelenskyi, in contrast to how zaluzhnyi was perceived. mr. olezh, i, by the way, while i am in kyiv now, i went here for reconnaissance and roughly imagine the reasons for the dismissal, i will not say, but i will ask you, when you say the word communication, in peacetime, i understand, it is really absolutely necessary, in wartime, i just don't know, i don't have... war experience, well , except for the last two years, and even more so, i 'm not in the headquarters, and i'm just having a hard time i imagine how it is possible to communicate in such personal moments, talking about someone, if even someone knows the sins of another, but we are talking about the highest levels on which the fate really depends, not without exaggeration of ukraine, and that president, or that syrian , whether that zelenskyi or. who thinks, well, i

have to come out now and say one reason, the second, third, fourth, fifth and sixth, and it is not known what the result of this will be, that it will be bad for sure, because... society is even more will get upset, here's how to get out of this situation communicative collapse during the war? well, first of all, in the conditions of the modern digital and computerized world, it is impossible to be silent at all, even the second world war, if we take it, then the same churchill gave his speeches all the time, other leaders did the same. in the soviet union, levitan was not so simple one of the top units of nazi germany, or at least a soviet one was being created. propaganda is such an image that it is a single whole, it has always been communication one of the key components for the stability of any society, and therefore especially in the conditions of war. the worst thing that can happen is a vacuum: the dream of consciousness creates horrors, and if nothing is said, then

society follows the path of least resistance and raises the simplest, most emotional, most superficial versions, and they look. quite justified in this case, because no one denies them and does not give any arguments to replace them. in our case, for example, the most popular explanation is why they remove the industrious one, and what was asked by the lead and journalists, what was said by a whole range of experts, and not only those who affiliated with one or another political forces, but in general, when they are silent, the question became whether it is a political settlement of accounts, and not because of great sympathy for the industrious inside. this happens in society, because if they are silent, then the river flows by itself, and you know, in a ship that has no sails, it has no tailwind, the wind will always blow in the wrong direction, so in this case it was important for the authorities to create a certain perception, it is not

necessary to give all the details, but people do not have enough there should be a feeling that they understand what is happening, and that there is nothing tragic about it, and that the situation in general was proceeding logically. the best thing was to find a better, new model of cooperation in the conditions of a long war with zaluzhnya, and not to take this step at all. if it was no longer possible to do this, we saw how this tension, it developed in several stages, then it was not necessary to launch maryana zaluzhna, bezuzna, excuse me, in a zuluzhny way, but with various theses, throwing mud, at because some of the criticism she says is in principle fair but the way she speaks and what she says has already discredited from the very beginning any words that will be spoken by her, but nevertheless, we have seen that, unfortunately, there was also foul play from various sides, and on the part of various forces of the opposition faction, when they made a fool of themselves against his will, in particular, against his will, and

pushed a political figure against him, making him a counterweight to zelenskyi, we also saw that, that is, you are convinced that ms. maryanna is not just yes... she was like a hell of a hemp, that was it some kind of, well, let's say, an operation of the authorities, at certain stages it looks like it was so, from a certain stage, and i assume and tend to think that maryana's action is meritorious, meritorious, again, what are you going to do, without a corner, but she did, and she acted herself, and the only thing that is important is that from the first stages it was visible how this information... was spreading, and without regard to whether it was personal theses, the personal position of ms. bezuglai, it was given a certain flair and by certain social networks , through botfarms, through specific telegram channels connected with understandable persons, all this

merged and sold, it was given a specific focus, which really makes it possible to say that we were dealing with a media campaign. well, mr. oleg, more about... we cannot do without russia without russia, mr. danilov, the secretary of the national security and defense council, i.e. a highly respected and high-ranking person, she says that since the term of mr. zelensky is coming to an end, well, such a non-military one, and such a civilian, yes, this topic and this thesis that zelensky is not the president of the russian federation will, will, if it is strong enough the fact that the president is illegitimate, but we have such a beautiful, legitimate one in russia, but the ukrainians, therefore, illegitimate, how much should we pay attention to this, how dangerous is it, or do we already have some kind of antibiotic, and we don't care what is being said in the kremlin or around, well, for us

this is a major side effect, although it is clear in ukrainian society that this will disturb a part of society, and we saw recently, for example, a post by... mr. volakh, and here i will directly call by name, which is called one of the political experts who at one time said that corruption is a good thing, and called for a protest. on the maidan, then the truth was changed to the action of thanks to zaluzhny, but nevertheless, these are similar situations, he had a post, and his words, i am quoting arbitrarily, now, i apologize that i do not have the text in front of me, that zelensky should go to resignation, since after the month of may he will be illegitimate, and firstly, i would not confuse legitimacy and legality, after all, these are different things, and secondly, if we talk about legality, then there is article 103 and there is article 108 of the constitution. this is the part about the president in the constitution, and everything is clearly stated there, the president is elected for 5 years, and

article 108 says the following: the president performs his duties until a new president is elected. next, we look at the election law, which clearly prohibits holding presidential elections. yes, it so happened that the constitution, it prohibits only parliamentary and local elections, and presidential elections are prohibited by law in our country, the principle on which the president is respected is written in the constitution. continues if the elections are not held, then inside ukraine they will try to destabilize the situation, but i do not think that this is a serious issue, we literally have no more than 40 seconds, but this stability and cohesion, for which you are responsible to the entire ukrainian people, as a co-founder of the national platform, it's under attack, it, it, it may or may not be destroyed, because it's obvious that they're going to find... people who are going to say, "give this, give this, give all of them, yay yay yay,

everybody , all enemies and zelensky resigned and zaluzhny and syrskyi, and in general all of them must resign, and in general, however, no one says what will happen next, it is necessary to surrender to russia immediately after the resignation of all high-ranking ukrainian officials. what do you say? regarding the previous topic, i am more afraid that either orban or fitz will be used to say that i am not meeting with zelensky because he is illegitimate, illegal ?" compactness, it is based on our principles of self-organization, on the fact that ukrainian society always, let's face it, protects and holds ukrainian statehood in its hands, and no one can do anything about it, there may be crises, there may be strikes, but nevertheless , no one has yet managed to destroy this ukrainian potential and it won't work now, thank you very much, thank you very much, oleg sahakyan, political scientist, co-founder of the national platform for sustainability and cohesion, now there will be

advertising, and then you and i will get on planes and fly all the way to the united states of america, oleksandr will accompany us kraev, director of north america programs of the ukrainian prizma foreign policy council, but advertising is ahead of all that. nothing has come out yet, not yet, it's a hoot. normolact honey, take normolact. normolact eliminates constipation, normalizes bowel function, restores the amount of lactate and bifidobacteria. everything worked out. normact and everything will work out. there are 15% discounts on feivex in pharmacies, plantain, bam and savings. stiffness in the joints and spine. osteochondrosis, gout, radiculitis, arthritis and arthrosis. with all these problems , a means for external use will come in handy decrasin consultations by phone. 0800-215. 349. calls are free. why am i here i have sensitive teeth, eat ice cream, pain,

cold air, pain, sweet, pain. the dentist prescribed lakalot sensitive, which effectively reduces tooth sensitivity. if i had known lacalud sensitive earlier, i would not have had to come here at all. lacalot sensitive - reliable protection against pain. there are discounts on penger and herpavir. 15% in psarynyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. there are discounts. paracytomol gift card 10% in travel pharmacies for you and savings. joint problems limit movement, which is not pleasant painful strengthen them with the help of long joints. these are bags with collagen and vitamin c to restore articular cartilage. dolgit joints contributes to the normal functioning of the joints and has a positive effect on bone health. longer joints will improve motor functions. stretch the joints - move freely. there are discounts on glycysed and glycyset of max 15% in psyllanyk, pam and oskad pharmacies. oh, and we got wet,

can you have some tea? mom, dad, what to do in order not to get sick? vitamin c, d3, zinc and, most importantly, quercitin to strengthen blood vessels. just take quertin immuno. all in one package. in one capsule, four components together. so simple, one capsule a day. so convenient. quertin immuno. what to do when there will be a liver, alochol, and what for the bile? alohol, it protects the liver and gallbladder, alohol, with care and respect for the liver and gallbladder, every week. the saturday political club helps to understand the processes taking place in ukraine and the world. vitaly portnikov, khrystyna yatskiv and invited experts based on facts give their assessment and forecast of the development of events. do you want to understand how our today will affect ours tomorrow, see saturday politics club, every saturday

on espresso. vasyl zema's big broadcast. this is the great ether, my name is vasyl zamai, we are starting two hours of air time, two hours of your time, we will discuss many important topics with you today, two hours to learn about the war, right now we will talk more about the war, serhiy zgurets from us, and how the world lives, now about what happened in the world, yuriy fizar will speak in more detail, yuriy, good evening, please, you have the floor, two hours to keep up with economic news, time to talk about money during the war, oleksandr morchivka with us, oleksandr, welcome, please, and sports news, review of sports events by yevhen postukhov. natalka didenko is already ready to tell us about the weather for the coming day, as well as the distinguished guests of the studio, andriy parubiy, people's deputy of ukraine, who was also the chairman of the verkhovna rada of ukraine. events of the day in two hours, vasyl zima's big broadcast, a project

for smart and caring people. espresso in the evening. see 21. news, summaries of the week. he dared, almost two years later full-scale war, president volodymyr zelenskyi replaced the commander-in-chief of the armed forces. ice from the chair. the us senate came close to considering a bill providing for assistance to ukraine. zircon is the newest weapon of the russian federation, what is it and did they hit kiev with a missile, and what other wonders does it have. in your arsenal, about this and not only, look at espressoo 21st. once again, good health to everyone, my name is mykola veresen and we will be together for about an hour more, but we will not be together with

you, we will be together with oleksandr kraev, director of programs north america council outside. see him on our screens and thank him for making time for us on a saturday night. mr. oleksandr, the question is not easy. do you think mr. trump will really not support ukraine and will flirt with the russian federation. it's interesting, because on the one hand, everyone is afraid of us and in europe they are worried. and in america, the democrats and supporters are worried, here suddenly a certain president, not just any, mr. duda, the beautiful president of poland, comes out and says: "no, no, no, no, don't pay attention to it, he, he, he consistent, this is not a quote yanukovych". but, simply, what do you think about this? first of all, he already has a history of flirting with the russians, he is already

known for the fact that right in the face, relatively speaking, of the director of the cia, when he was in the hall, he exactly... stood together with putin at the press conference, he declared that he trusts what putin tells him more than what his own intelligence tells him, that is, he can even abandon his own people, well, as they say in america, to throw him under the bus, just because putin told him something, and he believed putin in it, this is the first thing, secondly, it's still a trip tucker carlson to moscow, this can really be considered an information check, trump's entourage and trump's people in general, how they will react to the russian agenda . on what the russians say, on what putin says and, in general, on the extent to which it is possible to have at least some contact with putin, this is secondly, and thirdly, for now he is an anti-systemic person, he remains someone who, relatively speaking , biden says black, he should be told white. biden and the system and in general the entire american establishment are now for ukraine, and therefore trump will say that nothing, i can

come to an agreement with russia, and with ukraine you dance as you wish. well, you know... so, the kid and carlson, who lives on the roof, i see that it absolutely corresponds to this fairy tale, because really, putin is small so, so, small, so, he is so small, so, and carlson, he is, well, clearly higher, but i have a question, when you say that it is a test, yes, how did the kid pass the test, considering that after the program he said that putin does not know how to explain and lives in... in his own world, which means that putin is an idiot, if translated from language so journalistically diplomatic , in ordinary language, he simply told the whole world...said that putin is a mentally ill person, and how does this affect putin's reputation in the eyes of the republican hawkish bloc,

let's say this, i would actually develop this idea a little more , we must clearly say that putin lost a unique historical chance, you see, putin could reach his audience in the west. through kalsan, through his media, putin could talk to... with those who still believe that russia is about family values, that russia is about religiosity, it's about a good conservative family, it's about how white people used to live, there are still those in america who say that, and putin could appeal to them, putin could throw very correct messages, putin could drop very correct active messages about negotiations, that is, yes, he said that russia is ready for negotiations, but he could write down how he sees them, he could write down what the outcome ... he wants, he could put pressure on those conservative politicians in the west who have been talking about negotiations for a long time, that is, he had a unique chance, a unique opportunity to talk to people who

still want to hear him in the west, and what we have as a result is a two-hour lecture about history, about the fact that hitler turned out to be right, about the fact that the poles, like ukrainian provocateurs unleashed major wars, and in general you do not understand anything about what is happening, that is , ma, well, as you say, well... that is, this is not only my point of view, but also yours, as an expert, i do not an expert, i'm just a journalist, but the goal is to attract attention and to win sympathy among people across the ocean and in front of the ocean , it has not been achieved, and then i have to talk not with oleksandr kraev, but with psychologists and psychiatrists, because really, because i would ask you... but i think that you just you don't know about this, i would, my next question would follow very organically, what do you think, is he himself, contrary to the prompts of his entourage

, began to say what he is saying, or is it that they too have gone crazy and they throw him some pieces of paper, where it is written that he does not answer the questions that are asked to you, tell them better about the manamaha cap, well, i don't know about that, he talked a lot about history there, but this. absolutely no one understands this, all of his, all of his campaigns in the distant past, the americans don’t know what khmelnytsky is about, who those people are, in general, and i look at it and think, well, well, man , well, you want to, at least wake up at last, can you say something, aren't you a psychiatrist after all? you know, after all, to be a political scientist is to study political psychology a little, and from the point of view of political psychology he's...becoming not just a classic dictator, he's becoming a caricature dictator, you see, he's a man who doesn't accept what calson said, he's not used to answering questions,

he's used to saying things, he's used to not being told disputed, because there was even an interesting moment, it seems that you just showed it, when carlson asked a clarifying question, and putin just froze for a few seconds, he is not used to the fact that someone can disagree with him, he is absolutely... night not used to the fact that people do not take his words as the truth of the last resort, and in fact , this is what they are sick with and were sick, believe me, all world dictators will be sick, they are absolutely sure that they are the last before god, that only they should be listened to, all these tips, all these this rational advice or anything else is from the evil one, the only thing people should say is what they say, because they are a beautiful dream, they are... a higher level of evolution, and they really should be listened to, and that is why putin , you know, since the 14th year we have drawn comparisons of him with hitler, butler and everything else, this is the case when the meme became

a reality, even this is his justification of hitler, and even more so his answers showed that he really became a meme of reality, yes, but it will look cynical, and this is not me to you, but to the audience, super cynical, sorry if anyone doesn't like it, but when we talk about hitler... at least until '42, we know we got it, got it, got it, got it, well if, well, the germans they are standing, well, he really is some kind of cool uncle, there musalini is somewhere, this one is in africa, well, he lost everywhere, but he entered somewhere there he showed the whole of italy, great, great , mao zedong built it, in short, and putin did nothing in... russia's successes are the price of oil and gas at the beginning of zero, that's it, the end, nothing, there were no achievements, he did not win the war in georgia, did not win in ukraine

, well... what are we talking about, what greatness, but my question may be different: what do you think, yes, i am for trump, but trump began to give weapons to ukraine, i'm sorry, after all trump , what i observe is probably not as deep as you, but i see that he, well, for example, on in the middle east, his successes were obvious, israel's capabilities were obvious. to bribe saudi arabia, these moments of signing the abrahamic agreements and so on, all this seems to show that when he wants and when he understands what he wants, he does enough, well, precisely because he is not systematic, he does not go as the system says, in this way, but it just comes, here we will do it this way, well, what do you say, but this is actually the worst and

at the same time the best feature of trump. it is his inconsistency and unpredictability, us, us we just don't know what to expect from him, what will be his reaction to this or that event, and on the one hand, this is negative, because we don't know how to convince him, we don't know what points to press on him, we don't know what should he offer to get the desired result for us, conditionally speaking, we just don't know what kind of reaction to expect, but on the other hand, you are right about the javelins that he started giving them when he started giving them? when putin did not agree to go to a normal agreement with him and sign with him some joint communique. oops, the javelins are gone. remember when the syrians decided to fire on an american convoy, what happened at night? he fired the largest missile in the arsenal of the united states, killing a bunch of assads and even about a dozen russians. that is, he reacts extravagantly sharply. and really, that's one of the few chances we have with trump. because russia and putin personally will clearly

be. on america, they will provoke her, they will pull her by the mustache, they will provoke european allies, and precisely this chaotic, trump's extravagance can play into our hands, because he, you know, trump is very infantile, he can't take insults, he reacts to every insult very, very sharply and very, very badly, both personal and political, and therefore he will not miss a blow from russia, if you excuse me mr. oleksandr, we have literally. 30 seconds, but what you're saying shows me that it's very easy to shoot the case, because people like that who are always offended, they should be praised, they should come to trump, first of all, zelensky or anyone from europeans should be hired, and not only political psychologists, but just psychologists, maybe psychiatrists, ask, and it's just a smooth road to success, come trump, you're the best in the world, we adore you, we

're ready to be friends and kiss you. you not only in the lips, but also in the ass, and he will say: okay, what he wants, what is needed, everything is needed, tanks, missiles and so on. well, i'm sorry, i have to finish, because the news, i thank oleksandr kraev, director of north america programs, we were just talking about it, for the sake of ukrainian prism foreign policy. he was in touch with us. thank you, mr. oleksandr. now we will have news, and after the news we will have poland. israel and such an all-arms philosophy from a military analyst from the united states, and i 'll say goodbye to you for a commercial, but i'll definitely be back in 10 minutes.

greetings to everyone from espresso, i'm anneva melnyk and it's time to learn about the current events at the moment: dozens of artists caesar and the shells for them. france provides new aid to ukraine. this will take place within the framework of the coalition initiated by france and the united states of america artillery, president emmanuel macron said during a telephone conversation with his ukrainian colleague volodymyr. the heads of state discussed the current situation on the battlefield and ukraine's defense needs. zelenskyi also expressed his condolences to the families of french volunteers who were killed by the russian strike in the kherson region, as well as the preparation of a bilateral document on security guarantees for ukraine. seven people were burned alive in kharkiv. the russians attacked the city of shahed.