decisive, it either works and serves our unity and unification now for a common victory, or we sink into a whirlwind of conflict situations that definitely do not work for our unification, for our unity. we just have to decide whether we want to win in this confrontation with the enemy 's army or whether we are ready to surrender to the enemy's death, but here i have very bad news, because the enemy who is invading our land, he plans to destroy ukraine as a state, and ukrainianness as constituent community of peoples of the world, then... he cannot to be illusions, let's remember the events of 1918, muravyov's army, kruty, and what happened after the heroic defenders of kutiv were killed, and moravyov's army entered kyiv, looted, raped, destroyed the countryside, and then for more than 70 years, ukraine found itself in in the soviet occupation, in the russian occupation, there can be no illusions, unification, grouping for the sake of... a common goal, this is the only way

to negotiate, there are no other crazy things. mr. vladyslav, at the end of our conversation, this news literally appeared when we started talking with you, the commander of the joint forces serhii nayev from the armed forces of ukraine reported that on february 11, he learned from the media about the presidential decree on his dismissal from the media, whether this is how the dismissal procedure works, or whether this is the way the commander learns, should learn that... he was dismissed, this is wrong, and in fact, here again the question arises as to how effective the personnel policy is in our country, in particular in the general staff of the ministry of defense, being a member of the system, i know well who takes care of these issues, what they do, and unfortunately, some posts by maryana bezubloi regarding in particular, personnel policy, they are right, they have a very serious basis, if we close our eyes and pretend that everything is fine, then it is our business. kabskyi, if

the transformation and reformation of our system happens, then we have a chance, there can be no illusions here. i will repeat once again, speaking the truth is simple, and it is very important, because if we want to win, we must conduct a dialogue, in particular, open such an adult dialogue between the ukrainian authorities and ukrainian society, between military personnel, between the ministry defense and the ukrainian generals of the staff, there are a lot of challenges, and they are all timely, and they all have a fundamental impact. on the current state of affairs, and it is precisely on proper communication that our victory on the battlefield depends, well, of course, resources, resources, this is artillery, this is ammunition for this artillery, other components that determine the technological superiority of the ukrainian army on the battlefield. thank you, mr. vladyslav, vladyslav tseliznyov, military expert, colonel of the armed forces of ukraine, spokesman of the general staff of the armed forces of ukraine in 2014-2017, be with us now we are going for a short break, we will come back and continue our marathon. we will talk with

valery peker, a public figure, entrepreneur and teacher of the kyiv-mohyla business school, about the main news of this week, in particular, stay with us. tired of heavy and bulky saws, then the strong saw from razpak is just for you. with it you can easily cut trees and bushes. it is so convenient to use it for carpentry. it is the perfect tool for your home. chisada, and the price is only from 1499 hryvnias, also reliable battery included, just call now and order , free delivery is available, check with consultants, cut branches, cut a beam, chop firewood, all this will be done in one movement, with a strong saw, just see how quickly it copes with even thick branches , once ready, and unlike standard saws, it is so convenient to use in hard- to-reach places, it comes with a powerful...

battery, a key and a screwdriver, as well as a charger. call and order a reliable and convenient tool from only uah 149, with the possibility of free delivery. check with consultants: a powerful strong saw is what you need. call if you are tired of heavy and bulky saws, then the strong saw from razpak tv is just for you. with it you can easily cut trees and bushes. it is so convenient to use it for carpentry . it is the perfect tool for your home. or garden, and the price is only from uah 1,499, also a reliable battery is included, just call now and order, there is the possibility of free delivery, check with consultants, cut branches, cut timber, chop firewood, you can do it all in one movement, with a strong saw, just look how quickly it copes, even with thick branches, once it's done, and unlike standard saws , it is so convenient to use in hard- to-reach places, the set includes a powerful...

battery, a key and a screwdriver, as well as a charger. call and order a reliable and convenient tool from only uah 149 with the possibility of free delivery. check with the consultant. a powerful strongg saw is what you need, call! there are discounts on pshyk, 10% in psychnyk, fam and oskad pharmacies. what to do when there is a liver? alohol, but what for bile? alohol, it protects the liver and gall bladder. alohol, with care and respect for the liver and bile. an unusual look at the news. good health, ladies and gentlemen, my name is mykola veresen. sharp presentation of facts. and competent opinions, in america they also say, let's have better roads , we will have even better ones, a special look at events in ukraine, there will be some katsaps on the border of kyiv and beyond, which the world dreams of, mr. norman, we can imagine it, all this in the information marathon with

mykola veresny, saturday 5:10 p.m., sunday 6:15 p.m. on espresso. vasyl zima's big broadcast. two hours of airtime, two hours of your time. two hours to learn about the war and what the world is like, two hours to keep abreast of economic and sports news, two hours in the company of favorite presenters, presenters who have become familiar to many, as well as respected guests of the studio, the events of the day in two hours, vasyl zima's big broadcast, a project for smart and caring people, espresso in the evening. the espresso channel and ukrainian pen present the self-titled project with myroslava barchuk. a series of conversations with ukrainian and western intellectuals, who interpret and comment on the most relevant social discussions, what news will be analyzed by the guests of the project this week and, in fact, who will be the guest of the studio , we will find out already this sunday, clearly, the topics will be relevant, the guests will be special, their own

names with myroslava barchuk, sunday 17:10 at espresso. well, dear friends, we are continuing our marathon, and valery pekar, public figure, entrepreneur, teacher of the kyiv-mohyla business school, is already appearing on your screens... , good afternoon, as soon as all of ukraine learned the news that valery zaluzhny was dismissed, you wrote the following post: many people ask what to do, i answer, go to bed, this is the best thing you can do for yourself and the country right now , if of course if they are on combat or civilian duty. since then, what other tips do you have for people who are still anxious, and so many people say they have a feeling like it's a few weeks or a week before 24/22/22, some kind of deja vu 'yu, you know, in order to overcome

anxiety, it would be better to read the posts of psychologists, actually, my post was written late at night, when people could not calm down and took risks. to spend the whole night in this anxiety, the advice to go to sleep was associated with this, and ukrainian psychologists enough has been written about how to overcome this anxiety, which is certainly not directly related to one or another personnel changes in the leadership of the armed forces of ukraine, but rather is an internal problem or an internal challenge, it is better to say, of each specific person, since i am not a psychologist, then i can only read... related posts, for example by svitlana roys, where it is explained in great detail what exactly needs to be done in order to overcome anxiety. regarding the resignation of the servant, everyone had some kind of condemnation, as if something wrong happened, but maybe we are exaggerating, there are many examples that

have been quoted, mentioned from history these days, when churchill dismissed some commanders somewhere on some southern front, a hold. who sent in the 51st year the super-popular hero of the second world war, general macarthur, and whom, by the way, roosevelt also wanted to drive out of office, but the fact that there was a war was mentioned, i don’t know, there, they even mentioned abraham lincoln, who changed generals there during the war like gloves, eh, is that too, by the way, are the analogies correct in this case? it is difficult to say, because we do not know the details of those dismissals, just as we do not know the details of these dismissals, and not only the commander-in-chief of the armed forces of ukraine was dismissed, a number, more than a dozen leading leaders, commanders, generals were dismissed, which means that on their new people will take their place,

and mostly they will be people who definitely have positive, high-quality military experience, well , simply because there are no other generals of us today. armed forces of ukraine, but for some reason sediment remained sediment, and why sediment remained, i will say, in my opinion, it remained because there was very weak public communication, and it actually... and there is, ah, when a high-ranking official is fired, society always looks at it and wants to hear why he was fired. it is also important for those who come to their places, because even when the reasons for the dismissal are known, it is somehow easier for society to understand the logic of the top management and it is publicly clear what we are punished for, what we are rewarded for, what we are fired for, what to work employee in this case the society did not hear anything special, except that new approaches are needed, well, it

’s like that, not very high-quality public communication, and here i remember the government of oleksiy koncheruk, the first government of president zelensky, which was also dismissed with the statement that they worked good, but not good enough. such a system of public communication is very demotivating as citizens. as well as everyone involved in the management hierarchy in which changes are taking place. in the case of honchoruk, it was the government, in the case of zaluzhnyi and his deputies, it was armed forces of ukraine. it is difficult for me to say what mood prevails there now, because i can communicate only with those dozens of people who are sufficiently frank with me, although it is still a large number, but i want to say that public communication in ukraine until... it needs changes , and as for the understanding of the channels of this

communication, we understand that the single marathon is no longer working, and the so-called positive bloggers can no longer create trust or deliver a message, and likewise telegram channels, they will rather win a negative function than a positive one, at the same time, not only the channels, but also the packaging of public communications itself, that is, the very messages to society, also... only increase anxiety and uncertainty, and the public communication of the heads of state during the war, but should reduce uncertainty and increase confidence, and reduce anxiety, not increase anxiety, i would put it this way, uh, how to do it all, uh, that's obviously the task of those people who deal with communications in the office of the president, because when the team the president came to... authorities, their public communication was definitely their strongest point, where did this

qualification go in two years, in a few years, it is difficult to say, many political scientists and politicians note that having such a huge credit of trust that valery zaluzhnyi had, who united, and those who are in the same camp, who in the same camp in 2000... 19 voted for poroshenko and those who voted for zelenskyi, and those who did not vote for any of these candidates, you, who are ukrainian speakers, and russian speakers, that on the contrary, this credit of trust would be better to use, and not to deprive of this trust, by dismissing valery zaluzhnyi, why in the president’s office, why volodymyr zelenskyi did not take this moment into account, as you think, first of all... i want to say that the commander-in-chief of the armed forces of ukraine is not a political figure, in it is not his task to unite east and

west, russian-speaking and ukrainian -speaking, those who voted for zelensky, those who voted for poroshenko, this is not his task, and this additional function should not be hung on him, his task is to command the armed forces of ukraine and to achieve ukrainian victories, and from this point of view we had one commander-in-chief, now we have a second match, and the new one deserves public trust as well as the previous one. the fact that general valery hlushnyi really was for many the personification of ukrainian stability and ukrainian victories is essentially the result of the fact that it was under his command that significant results were achieved in previous years, but this does not mean that it is necessary to mold the position of commander-in-chief into a political position, it a military position, not a political one. and military the command often has to do unpopular things, it happened in the past

, it will happen in the future, that is why there is a proposal not to hang on the commander-in-chief armed political tasks, but to free his hands so that he can perform his immediate task, which is assigned to him his position, or syrsky in the position of commander-in-chief will have free hands, and of course, if we do not demand from him that he unite, as you say... this is the whole society, russian-speaking, ukrainian-speaking, the east and west, south and the north, uh, those who serve and those who don't serve, those who are for zelensky and who are for poroshenko, and you who are for tymoshenko, uh, if we don't hang on him. political tasks, and we will expect a high-quality command of the armed forces from him, we will definitely see it, that is, i am in favor of categorically separating military tasks from political ones, let politicians deal with political ones, and let them not interfere with military ones, and here it seems to me that society itself is a little to blame for the fact that it constantly invests some money in the military

additional hopes that go beyond war and victory, i believe that ukrainian victory is... such an important task that for the sake of it you have to forget about all other tasks, and the war is such a big challenge for ukraine, a challenge for itself the existence of our nation and our state, that for the sake of this we need to forget about all secondary tasks and er not er tie the hands of the military with our somewhat inflated expectations, we already had inflated expectations from the armed forces of ukraine in 2023, it did not end in anything good , it's over. such mass disappointment, depression, anxiety, and people drove themselves into all this , well, of course, government communications, which i have already talked about, also played a role here, but mostly people drove themselves into these inflated expectations themselves, and then they themselves suffered from it , uh, we, my view is that let's give the military an opportunity to concentrate on war, an entrepreneur

to concentrate on the economy, a government official to concentrate on management. parliament to concentrate on closing the gaps in ukrainian legislation, of which there are many, and we will work ourselves, help the armed forces and mind our own business , mr. valery, actually someone very well said that it is characteristic of democratic societies to fall in love with their generals during war, because they really look very advantageous against the background of politicians during martial law, war, but in... at the same time, it seems to me that you are arguing with the fact that zaluzhny became the personification of certain qualities that we also lack in politics, that is, he looked, at least he looked like a sincere and good person, that is, what is it simply missing, and also he has become his own for many people, and something , this, this, this, this, this is such a, some point

is, it's just that the country is very complicated, the country is very complicated system, which one do you like? to say ukraine is particularly difficult, and here, the decision turned out to be so simple and poorly communicated, and did we, did we become stronger after it, what could be the consequences of zaluzhny's resignation, in fact, i am sure that general zaluzhny not only looked sincere and good person that he is actually a sincere and good person, and because of that, people began to project their own expectations onto him. and significantly went beyond what was assigned to him directly for his duties, and we see the successes of the ukrainian armed forces in the recapture of ukrainian territories in the kharkiv and kyiv operations in 2022, we see incredible and unfortunately underestimated victories by ukrainian society at sea and in

the air in 23, we associate the 23rd year with a year of military failures, and this is wrong. because we have overestimated the expectations of land war, and thereby put themselves in the position of underestimating the successes of the armed forces of ukraine at sea, where the black sea fleet was actually defeated, and in the air, where in fact we have, despite the fact that missile attacks continue and something flies in and ukrainians die , we actually have a victory over russian missile attacks, due to such underestimations we are actually starting to worry, if we do not have overestimates, and if we look at the situation soberly with a cool head, then we must evaluate the successes of the armed forces in 22-23 years in total as very positive in the conditions that existed, and obviously society associates this with the names

of the commanders of that time, including the commander, commander-in-chief. armed forces, but i am sure that we will also have further successes of the armed forces, and they will be associated with some new names, it is actually about the fact that we constantly have failures in public communication, and people still close them just the failures of the public communication of the government with its own conjectures, its own projections, expectations and so on and so forth, as if people don't care to say, they will guess. they guess not in the best way, and now let's remember that there is also russian propaganda that helps to guess, mr. valery, but if you don't guess, volodymyr zelensky fired valery zaluzhny, a photo appeared. where they shake hands with each other and smile, the next day, the next day, it seems, he was awarded the title of hero of ukraine, and in this

video, which we see, they hug, budanov also received the hero of ukraine, and budanov and volodymyr zelensky are not hugging, but before that, we monitor, for example, the page of maryana bezuglaya, as a people's deputy, not just maryana bezuglaya, a private person, who for several months just... purposefully attacks the commander-in-chief valery zaluzhnyi in various ways, even resorting to what he has problems with alcohol, or that he likes women a lot, uh, and there is some kind of, well, and then we also get signals that there is tension between the president and the already former commander-in-chief, and there is some kind of mismatch, because after you turn out that everything is fine between them, as we can see in the video and in the photo, but several months before that we saw that everything was not fine. if you read some pages on social networks and you think that they do not adequately reflect the situation that you see, just stop

reading them and everything will be fine, as for hugs, well, first of all, i understand when a person who resigns, sincerely congratulates and says goodbye to... his direct supervisor, when a person who continues to be in the service and continues to perform duties, certain official, behaves more restrained and more formally, it's absolutely army-style, it's normal, and there's nothing to be ashamed of. well, here is the question that just me, i would formulate it a little differently, perhaps, you know, many people have noticed some analogies, for example, with yushchenko and kuchma, when... yuvshchenko was terribly in fact not going to and did not want to be any kind of leader of the future revolution, but the circumstances and people's expectations pushed him in the end, but in this and or, for example, from

koropatskyi, which is also being written about a lot now, and for example, in the central council, who were afraid of his influences, of some of his there are not enough left-wing views, and this also ended with the occupation of kyiv, muravyov, but in general, i just thought that in this, if these analogies somewhere... at least somehow have the right to exist, then in each of these analogies there are, as it were, three valid persons, that is, there is a conditional yushchenko from skoropad, and there are also people who expect something from him, but there is also the conditional kuchma, and that is why our government in this story with zaluzhny also looked very similar to a kuchma, and what to do with it ? i don't think president zelensky looked like a president pushin, i do not see parallels here, that if ukrainian successes on the battlefield and in various fields continue, then we will simply forget about all these troubles, and if they

do not continue, if we are beset by one failure after another, then the ukrainian authorities will remember all that was and even that which was not add up. kuchma's problem was not that he accused yushchyna. kuchmu's problem was that the country at that time... reached a certain point of development, could not develop further, and in fact the system that was built, it restrained this development, everything is actually a problem, and when there is a problem of development, it is obvious that one way or another social changes begin, and some person becomes the personification of these changes, even perhaps without wanting to. today we have one big problem, it is a war with russia, it is a war for survival, there will be no revolution in the near future. we have one way to win this war, it is the consolidation of society around the ukrainian flag and participation in contributing to this

victory by everyone and everyone, who can, who mobilizes, who fights, who works, someone helps in the rear, someone volunteers and so on and so forth. if we now deal with the internal revolutionary situation, we will simply lose ukraine. we actually lost it 100 years ago, i want to remind you that 100 years ago we had a country, our grandfathers and great-grandfathers created it, our great-grandfathers defended it and they lost it, they lost it because of three key things, in my opinion, i have read dozens of different explanations in various historical works, but three factors seem the most important to me, the first such factor is internal political the quarrels, which you mentioned, are good, but if there are, i will continue. internal political quarrels, there are practically no chances in ukraine, that is why we see that during the entire 22nd year, in general, quarrels were completely stopped and

there was not even the slightest. smaller political ones after that, somehow they continued, the second factor - unfortunately, unfortunately, we don't have time, we have to interrupt the conversation, valery the baker was with us, dear friends, let's take a break, come back and continue. oh, and we got wet, can you have some tea, mom, dad, what to do, not to get sick? vitamin c, d3, zinc. and the main thing is quercitin to strengthen blood vessels. just take quertin immuno. all in one package. in one capsule, four components together. so simple, one capsule a day. so convenient. quertin immuno. there are discounts at acc long. 15% in psarynyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. joint problems limit movement. it is unpleasant and painful. strengthen them with dolheit joints. these are packets of collagen and

vitamin c to restore articular cartilage. stretching the joints contributes to the normal functioning of the joints and has a positive effect for bone health. lengthening the joints facilitates motor functions. with long joints, move freely. there are discounts on lactial. 10% in psarynyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. stiffness in the joints and spine. osteochondrosis, gout, sciatica, arthritis and arthrosis. with all these problems , a means for external use will come in handy. rasyn consultations by phone 0800 215 349 calls are free nothing has happened yet no constipation about normolact dear, take normolact normolact eliminates constipation, normalizes the work of the intestines, restores the amount of lactose and bifido bacteria, everything worked out, normolact and everything will work out, there are 25% discounts on emolium in pharmacies plantain for you and savings. what to do when

there is a liver? alohol, but what for bile? alohol, it protects the liver and gall bladder, alo hol with care and respect for the liver and gall bladder. exclusively on the air of our channel. congratulations, friends, politklub is on the air on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week: russia's war against ukraine, the war in the middle east, the crisis on the border between ukraine and... poland, topics that resonate in our society drone attack on kyiv and other cities of ukraine, drone attacks on moscow and other russian cities. analysis of the processes that change the country and each of us. the country should get the right to start negotiations on joining the eu. vitaly portnikov and guests of the project: we are bored, because there is nothing to fight about, let's invent, they help to understand the present and predict

the future. for the world, a second trump presidency will be terrible. a project for those who care and think. political club. every sunday at 20:10 on espresso. verdict with serhiy rudenko is now in a new two-hour format. even more analytics, even more important topics, even more top guests. foreign experts, inclusion from abroad. about ukraine, the world, the front, society. and feedback. you can express your opinion at the expense of the day. with the help of a telephone survey, turn on and turn on, the verdict with serhii rudenko, every weekday from 8 to 10 pm on espresso. i'm here temporarily, i'll be back home soon.

live now where you are, congratulations. everyone from espresso, i'm anna yavomelnyk and novyn team will tell about the most relevant events at the moment: 12 injured as a result of an accident in kharkiv region. today , a truck and a minibus, in which there were 11 people, collided in the village of malynivka. according to the regional police, the bus driver drove into the oncoming lane, where he crashed into a car. 33-year-old kermanych and all his passengers, including two children, were injured.