netanyahu and macron, or we can say between israeli society and the west, it exists, objectively, this is a contradiction, and by the way, it reminds us to a certain extent, because we want to achieve a maximalist result, that is, we want to go to the border 91 of the year, we consider it a victory, i consider it a victory, you consider it a victory, everyone considers it a victory, how easily it can be achieved, exactly so, and what will happen next, we will end the war, russia will collapse, but it is ours desire, we don't know what will happen next if our army... goes to the border in 1991, it’s true, we just talked with mr. chal, it all doesn’t look so simple from the point of view of our participation in security organizations and so on, and now the next question is: and israel knows what will happen, if you mean or who needs the forces to actually destroy hamas, while hamas has a huge electoral base, uh, in the gas sector, it's a support base for violent terrorist organizations, not just something like that, and that's a huge question, of course . and you know, from the fact that

macron recognizes the palestinian state, nothing will change significantly, russia recognizes the palestinian state, there is an embassy of the palestinian state in moscow, china recognizes the palestinian state, there is an embassy of the palestinian state in beijing, ukraine recognizes the palestinian state, there is an embassy of the palestinian state in kyiv, and what? the state is real control over the territory, not recognition by other states, a large number of countries there recognize the sahrawi arab democratic republic, and the united states considers it part of morocco, so what? that is, it is important where is the real government. what he controls really, if he controls the embassies in other countries of the world, that's just his problems, so it's really very important to get to the point where we see how the middle east issue is going to be resolved, and i'll tell you honestly, i think every such excess that we see, it does not bring the creation of a palestinian state closer, but most likely makes its existence almost unreal, i generally believe that every decade that the inhabitants... spend on struggle, not on

the creation of their own state and not fixed institutions in the territory they have basically turns the palestinian state into a political fantasy, because the mood in israeli society is changing, and the mood is changing in the arab world, and israel is looking for some kind of agreement with the arab world, and the arab world is not very interested in the palestinians , the elites are definitely not interested, 10, 15, 20 years will pass, and the palestinian state will remain only in its embassies in other countries of the world, and this is also an absolute reality, which... must somehow be accepted by those people who today they believe that violence is the best way to create such a state, i think that this is the most obvious way to the fact that it remained exclusively in the analogue, not even in history, because there has never been a palestinian state in history, in analogue there international organizations that advocated for its creation, there is nothing new in this, but i would just like for the middle east to have a model of two states for two peoples who would recognize... each other and would not

want to destroy the other until that moment , while the palestinians think their state will be to be on the territory of the state of israel, they don’t care about anything except support for terrorist organizations, israeli special operations, displacement from the territories where they live and absolutely historical hopelessness, it’s a pity that it doesn’t work with russia, because according to the court they also think to capture, kill, of course , because for hamas , the palestinian state should be on the territory of israel, and for russia, the russian state should be on the territory of ukraine. it is yes, it is the same approach, and if someone does not agree with it, then we will kill them, rape them, loot, we cannot have a political dialogue about it, because in fact it has been necessary for all these decades, if you go back to the middle east, to have a political dialogue, this is how we recognize your jewish state, this is how we believe that the fact that we are not in this territory, it is a disaster for us that we left the places where we were, and jews from arab countries were resettled by our arab... compatriots to

israel, but we want, we want to have a state, we want to receive compensation for damaged and stolen property, we want you allowed us to visit the territories where we were without any problems, we want joint investments, we want the coexistence of two states, we want and we want this, and we want this, and this is a political conversation, and when we speak, we want to kill you, depose you into the sea, the armies of the arab states will come and cut you all down, well, excuse me, then it will be a completely different story, there will be a different conversation. a conversation with you in the language of power, which only you understand, and then we will see who is stronger, and this is how this confrontation has looked since 1948, and of course, i repeat for this a party that has not yet understood that the logic of force does not lead to anything, it is absolutely hopeless, and it does, in principle , absolutely fantastic, the fulfillment of all those goals set by both terrorist organizations, such as hamas, and previous organizations, such as the organization united palestine, which never liberated palestine, which never understood the futility of this effort, and when it understood, it was already too late, because... that already

a huge number of palestinian youth have already stopped thinking in a realistic way, and this the same, by the way, that is happening with the russians, this is very true. it's a pity , and that's why i say that i see a solution to all these issues only when it comes to political dialogue. after all, when putin told kavsyn that we, ukrainians, are invented and one people, and any karpson could ask him why he is killing this people, if you think that kharkiv is russia, why are you destroying kharkiv, if you think that mariupol is russia, why are you destroying mariupol, if you think that odessa is a beautiful russian city, why are you shelling? everywhere, there are other examples, bulgarians there consider macedonians to be their bulgarian brothers, but they do not shell ohrid and try to destroy macedonia, they conduct a political and historical dialogue, the poles want to talk with us about historical memory, but they do not want to destroy it lviv or ternopil, because

they don't like that ukrainians live there, civilized peoples talk even on topics they don't like, and barbarians, they kill, shoot, rape, that's exactly what we started with. our dialogue today that it begins with the killing of strangers, and then there is a huge desire to kill your own , those who do not agree with you, because this is the only opportunity to prove your political opportunity and your power, it is simply to kill wherever you can kill, here we are dealing with such situation, christy, thank you, thank you infinitely, vitaly portnikov, the saturday political club, were with you and we hope to see you next saturday. support the armed forces of ukraine, think critically, this is extremely important nowadays. good luck.

turn on the heart-chilling investigation. the new chapter of the hbo series in... true detective, find out what secrets the alaskan ice hides, exclusive to the mega subscription, there are discounts on glicised and gliceset max, 15% in pharmacies, plantain, pam and save, there are discounts on pector one plus, 10% in pharmacies plantain, memory and savings. according to the results of january, the espresso tv channel continues to hold. position among information broadcasting channels. for the 10th month in a row, we are the first. greetings, it's news time on the tv channel. this november we turned 10 years old, we updated the design, sound, we continue the saturday political club, khrystyna yatskiv and vitaly portnikov. our values ​​and ukrainian

point of view remain unchanged. stay tuned for espresso updates and thank you for your trust. hello, this is svoboda ranok, an informational project of radio svoboda. top guests every day. this is the shipping district, kherson. turn on live. we are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut. we tell the main thing. on weekdays at 9:00. verdict with serhiy rudenko. from now on in a new, two-hour format. more analytics, more important topics, more. top guests are foreign experts, inclusion from abroad, about ukraine, the world, the front, society, and also feedback, you can express your opinion at any time of the day with the help of a telephone survey, turn on and turn on, the verdict with serhiy rudenko, every weekday from 20 to 22 for espresso. the war

created many challenges for us. ukrainians and even more so for ukrainians with disabilities. but we know that we can be stronger only by uniting together. friends, welcome. friendly online community enable me ukraine. this is the first communication platform in ukraine persons with disabilities. here you get all the information about disability, medical services and relocation. free consultations of a lawyer, psychologist, doctor, employment specialist, volunteers from all over europe. here you get support, advice and real friends. together we support each other, share useful information and learn new things. together we

grow. join us. become part of our enable me family. ukraine. with support. national assembly of persons with disabilities of ukraine enable me ukraine. greetings to everyone, this is a football format and we will summarize this week of sports football, about how the miner played with marseille, the chances in the match, and whether upltb will be exactly what all the viewers expect, i am oleksandr vashchuk and andrii with you malinovsky, andriy, congratulations, so hello to everyone. in fact, what this week will bring us, brought

more precisely, is that most likely we will watch football in the same pool now, and in fact, great pride for the fact that the ukrainian club in this new 24th year represents ukraine on the european arena and represents to a great extent worthy natalya such a powerful opponent, at least nominally, as marseille is, well, then let's move on to this match, shakhtar-marseille are playing in hamburg, let's remind you, and here's the thing that shakhtar... is always good it works, there were enough, well, there were a lot of fans, but after the game, we had such expectations that both marseille played strangely, and shakhtar not everything, thank god, and it came true. well, actually, about marseille, we also carefully analyzed the game of genar gatou's team recently, and it was said that one of the worst versions of marseille at the moment, because the team is unbalanced, and therefore it is a huge plus for the miner, but here is what... what the shakhtar usually works on, especially when he played at home, or at least played not in donetsk, but relatively speaking, in lviv or kyiv, he

carefully watched the lawn. here, after all , it was not the weather in hamburg that made football conditions not so bad, the lawn was not like that, at least, which we are used to seeing in the home arena of donetsk shakhtar. well, the match itself ended in a 2:2 tie, which leaves, well more or less equal chances for teams from this stage to advance to the next round of the europa league competition, relative to game, we definitely didn't know what to expect from pushych's team either, because it's only nominal, again we're talking about the fact that pushych is still in the process, with the donetsk shakhtar club, which has been structurally developing for a long time, in a similar way, and pushych, who had not played in such stages as a head coach before, he, we know, worked only in the lower dutch divisions as a head coach, here he was with the miner, although when he scored for eguinalda in the dying seconds of the match, we saw him raise his hands in the air, he was rejoicing, well in the best jose mourinho tradition, when he won the champions league. about the lawn, this

can definitely be said, that's why there are some impressions of the game, there are the same, well, in particular, in terms of personalities, about si kakan, it seems to me, if possible, a little better inoculation, on it he could several times get into very promising positions. in fact, shakhtar in general looked quite balanced, despite the fact that this is only the first official match of the season, and despite the fact that the opponents at the meeting were not the strongest, we spoke. about the fact that, on the contrary, the miner has opponents with whom he played number one, and with marcel , the miner still largely started the match from defense, because he had to play reliably, not to concede, but when he missed after the break, then the miner already played in his such powerful attacking football, with some adventure, which was also necessary, considering that shakhtar conceded twice during the course of the match, well, as for vaccination, not only sikan, but also those footballers who are there they tried to give the same zubkov to sudakov, to give him. monahid was also not all right with the boots, all due to the fact that

the condition of the lawn did not allow him to play perfectly, well, plus, again, we do not forget that this is the first official match and somewhere, perhaps, the accuracy also suffered because of this lack of the lawn and because this is not yet the miner's game tone. we will remind you once again, i think most of you watched this match, you know that it was 2:2 in the 64th minute pierre merika bamayang, immediately in the 68th minute mykola matvienko equalized the score, 1:1. 1:2 on in favor of marcel, it seems that everything is not very good, and malyuky ginaldu at 90 + 4 minutes scores this one at 90 + 2nd scores this saving goal 2:2 and now there is no difference, whether 0:0 or 2:2, away goals are not counted, so in the match you need to either win or draw and then win in extra time or penalties. according to the composition of the team, you say that you had some insider's idea that taras stepanenko would still be able to play, because the majority of experts...journalists predicted that taras would not play. look, now we are the numbers we looked, yes, we saw that according to the numbers

, after all, marseille vs. xg is a very important indicator, marseille surpassed shakhtar, so the fact that the draw is 2:2 is still a bonus for shakhtar, that they did not lose, and as for yes, taras stepanenko, first of all, the head coach didn't even have insiders, marin pushych, who admitted that he didn't know a few hours before the game whether stepanenko would play or not, well, that is, the head coach, if he doesn't know, then we understand. that no insider. no one wants to know, except for taras, whether he will play or not will play, that is, if it was the desire, will, character of taras, then it was decided whether he would play in this match at the start or not, to a large extent other positions. were predicted, and we understood that eginaldo was played as the main winger, taking into account also the injuries there, many performers who claim to be the basis, we understood that this is exactly what the composition will be, the only thing is that in the position of defender we did not know who there will be kryskiv, who is also injured, nazaryn, who to a large extent still mostly attacks, he would look great as a second support, but this

clean, the only support, apart from taras stepanenko, unfortunately, to date, the donetsk miner has no alternative to taras and... this is a huge problem, we saw when shakhtar, when taras stepanek left the field, we saw that shakhtar, he and so lost the fight in the center, and there the team was generally disjointed and there was not the balance that taras stepanenko maintains when he is on the field. you know, they also recorded kevin on the left there in the attack, 15 million was still paid for him, but ginaldu also came out and well, rather not disappointed, because he also scored a goal and that goal that was not counted, a strange decision of the referee, well, this... he had actions, by the way, the referee even apologized after the game, these insiders are just without directly from germany, that he gave too much the whistle, i.e. the whistle that he had no right to give, he gave it, he apologized, but it still did not allow shakhtar to score in that episode, that is, the goal did not exist, which was in this match with the score still 0:0, but

well and yes, to a large extent we understand that... ginaldu is the right decision, he scored, he had his moments, and he could still score again with a header already with the score 2:2 in the last seconds of the game, he could also be noted for the second goal of this match, eginaldu looked confident enough, well, a plus for kevin, that micro damage, therefore , it was clear that before the game it was definitely clear that eginalda would play on the left flank in the midfield, you know, let 's listen to taras stepanenko, where he summed things up a bit like this. he also commented on the result and also that episode with the referee's strange decision, well, i asked the court why he whistled, he ska, well he, i saw that he made a mistake, because he said that everyone stopped, and i say, no one stopped, the game continued, there the goalkeeper crashed into

the defender of the match points ginaldo and there someone scored, everyone played, that is, he... i think that he blew the whistle earlier, because he thought that the goalkeeper had already taken the ball in his hands, the goalkeeper released the ball and the ball turned out to be ours, that is, according to all the rules today, the way var is, he should have been allowed to play until the end, and then watch, due to the fact that we played back, then you can say that in principle they earned a point, because they missed the second ball very late and in principle they played back there... at the end of the match, so let's say that, but if you look at the whole game, they could have earned more. well, taras stepanenko is a wonderful speaker now, a captain, and it seems to me that he would look great either as an expert, or perhaps as a spokesman. well, definitely better than pushych, he

studies the situation in the team much more thoroughly, he knows what is happening in the club, he knows everyone young football players who are still in law school. he is training, he is actually for the club , he is a legend at the moment, he is still close to dario sarna in terms of the number of matches played, and he is not going to end his career, and the contract has been extended, and in fact for the club he is, well, he is real a star, he is a recognizable star, and he is identified precisely with ukrainian football, because he was both the captain of the national team and the captain of the donetsk miner for a long time, that is why taras stepanenko and... such an eternal fusion due to the injury of taras stepanenko, the damage he suffered, they did an mri , there is no tear or tear, but it is clear that there is some discomfort and it is not yet known whether he will play in the return match. well, yes, there was a relapse at the same time, and the fact is that he is just recovering, mostly due

to experience and his character, he came out, played when he could, and now he is preparing to play the return match in a week, therefore... taras will most likely prepare for the match with marcel in marseille under an individual program, and here the most important thing is that he recovered, because without him it will be very difficult to understand who will play defender from the first minutes, because it is necessary from the first minutes to restrain marseille, although again we do not know what tactics gattus will choose, but if he more or less something there understands somehow in football, it should still go on the attack from the first minutes, taking into account the home stands, taking into account the fact that the team is in good shape, although shakhtar survived, we saw that it is functional. shakhtar is ready, and again, it's not pushych, it's that the club has been working on that program for a long time and the physical therapists who worked for a long time under lucescu are responsible for physics. also, we have such statistics in the match, where there are single combats, aerial combats, and shakhtar lost these duels, which probably indicates that individually, well

, marseille players are still stronger than shakhtar players, but they are powerless, well, not them non-attacking, and the scheme of the game, how they play, they cannot take advantage of this advantage, here we see that, for example, 36%, in marseille 60% of duels won, in aerial duels in general 72 is a 22% advantage of the miner, and also... shakhtar's dribbling is only 29%, marseille's dribbling success rate is 67, well, we see gaps there three, four times according to some indicators. well, in part we can see that marseille took advantage, the only thing that was in the end were problems for marseille, because marseille should have scored more, the french had much more of the same scoring chances in this match, and the fact that , due to the fact that dmytro riznyk won these duels and created moments near the goal, which despite the fact that... missed two, played a great match, there were not a lot of problems in the defense, but the fact that as a differentiator now manages the process, nevertheless, again we must note,

he is now absolutely essential in the miner, and it has long been forgotten that anatoly trubin was in such perfect order, now dmytro riznyk is also covering this position, well, almost perfectly, despite the fact that trubin is also in excellent shape, he also plays at a high level in bentiitsa, well , marcel had more scoring moments, but such pre-goal, in particular there, for example, from... zubkov's date, he was probably the most active, he made aggravation, but how much else did he not do, where a slightly different solution is possible, and would it be one-on- one exits or would he bring partners to super striking positions? zubkov was actually very active, and then again, maybe zubkov’s intelligence would have been a little higher, and he definitely wouldn’t have played in the miner, he would have played in the same way, probably, as most of our national team leaders now play in the premier league there, because in fact sometimes there were strange solutions, with preferred thanks to his positional football, thanks to his speed , thanks to his dribbling, but the continuation is like this , well, it seems obvious, he did it differently than what

even a simple football vision requires, and thanks to this, in fact , things didn't happen in the best way in the attack, and once again the fact that two scored is very good, and again, if the attacks were advanced, well, more or less, let's say that, correctly, not just academically, but exactly correctly. and reasonable, maybe shakhtar could claim more, what about 150 million, i.e. sudakov, did he prevail so much, well, in the game of bondarenko, who is much cheaper to put a clause? well, this week again, we say again, well , almost every day we read about the news that sudakov is interested, probably all the top clubs of all the top leagues, none, it seems that there are still no clubs left, who, according to the information, so -called insiders again. who is not interested in sudakov, but so far sudakov has played one of the best matches with marcel, and i think that 150 million is clear, what is possible now

to draw any amount, we understand that, because igor surkis estimated, for example, shaparenko there at 300 million. therefore, now it is just hype, and so every day we can read and listen, but we see the game that he demonstrates sudakov, he is a very useful football player for the donetsk miner, but we understand that for such money, well... as long as georgy does not pull, we also need to look into next thursday, where the match will be played at the velodrome stadium, there is always support there, if the team does not played, and this legend of the stadium, how to beat shakhtar, even more so valery bondar received such an unfortunate yellow card and will not play, that too, well, now valery bondar is undoubtedly the main player of the miner, so here is the question, who will the coaching staff put on this miner now, i... the choice of rakitsky is obvious, but we we understand that in terms of speed he is now inferior to marseille's fast enough attack, well, thanks to his experience, maybe he will somehow

be able to work in this match, the only thing is that pushych, unfortunately, does not play with three central players, it might be more interesting here, but probably, maybe he saw such schemes when he was watching football there, but he did not record this scheme, so with three central defenders it would be easier for a slow-moving guy like rakitsky to play as the third central defender, but he plays... the miner is a classic two central defenders, so it is probably rakitsky will play in the central position, well, we will see how to play, well, after all, we are listening to the general director pushych there, they tell us what the result will be, the most important thing is to play attacking football, although it somehow even sounds so amateurish from a university such leading football figures, so shakhtar should play pragmatically in this match and should be patient and have just their counter football. the best kind of counter-football to show in this match, the only thing is, well, if they crawl forward, they can run into the fast, powerful attack of marseille, maybe not the same in terms of names,

except for abomiyanga, there are no such superstars. but all the same , marcelo is a very fast attacking player, so it is necessary to play very pragmatically and rationally in this match. well , you know, our expert, honored coach of ukraine serhiy kovalets used to say that it is better to lose 5-0 once than 1-0 five times. pushcic probably doesn't know this. he made a very strange statement that it is better to lose 5:1 than 1:0. although we will remind you that the previous coach was probably fired precisely because of crushing defeats. let's listen to what marino pusic had to say when he analyzed his game like this... in charge of the team against barcelona, ​​i think it's better to lose 1-5 than 0-1, yes, but goal difference, what difference does it make, you lost the game, but i wasn't going to give up because i didn't yet know certain points about the composition of the team, about the individual ones players, because there were changes since my last meeting with the miner, so in that game i just had one thought in my head that we could play eight strikers with players who

can ... go to the goal and create something. from the line to the goal line at the olympic stadium in barcelona, ​​probably about 40m. i went over and asked what forwards we could still bring in from the bench. everyone was surprised, said that there were one or two more, but what to do with them? i replied that everyone was warming up, everyone would be involved. so, you see, the coach comes to the team, he sits down on the bench to manage and does not know which players he has attacking. it's quite strange. for me, well, the most important thing is that he should, at least for the second year there, study all the football players who are at the disposal of marin pushych, and that the football players should study who marina pushych is, that's why the balance is important here again, so far we understand that marina pushych is close to the process created by the donetsk miner, which has long been in the topic, long in the structure, long in the model, so for now marina pushych is being brought up to the level of the donetsk miner, as it was with

previous mentors, that we understand that after luchensk, almost all mentors were below the level of the donetsk miner, and fonsek, and kashtra, and so on, left, the same jovichevich was pulled up, but there was a force majeure, just him started working with young people, that was the structure of the club, so they went to a meeting there, they started making interesting and high-quality transfers there and leveled the situation in the miner, and then they took the retired player and so on, that is, now they took pushych, too, to bring the miner to the level of the miner first, and then we will see what he is capable of. we all knew napusych what andriy lunin is capable of, and now all of spain knows, all of madrid knows, because andriy lunin started tuesday at the base of real madrid, in the 1/8 finals of the champions league against leipzig and simply defended to zero, he made a lot of saves there as well it was placed in the columns of newspapers, well, it seems to me that this is a closed question, we always say that it is a closed question, but after marka az placed it in the columns of the newspapers in front of the first, well...

recognition is unequivocal. well, yes, he made nine saves in the match against german leipzig, allowing real to win that match. by the way, this is a club record, he repeated it after thibaut courtois, he also has nine saves, and even ancelotti, the head coach of real madrid, told kepe, already lunin's backup, that andriy lunin will be the main goalkeeper of real madrid , and now the question is who will be number one in the national team, because luninta was even missed by the last team. he wasn't even out of the national team at the last match was called up, and now lunin is part of real madrid, probably the strongest team in the world right now, and andriy lunin, the goalkeeper and number one of this team, let's see who will now stand to defend the goalkeeper's goal, who or the donetsk miner riznyk, who also plays europub lunin , who plays for real, yes, trubin, who is in full order in benfica, and maybe bushchanshchyna is getting in shape, trubin played on

thursday in the match. europa league, toulouse won 2:1 and he conceded a goal and already, let's just say, this week he became a little more serious about it evgeny dykiy told us exclusively about such an absentee confrontation, how pltb is created, what perspectives it will be possible to watch, and also about the preparation of ukrainian teams for the championship, which resumes in 5 days, we will tell you after such a short break. there are discounts on perfectil original of 15% in psyllany bam and oskad pharmacies. 10 years of war, the war for freedom, from the revolution of dignity to today's battles. if something happens to me, if i don't happen.