for people in these communities, some libraries were forced to move from the front line to the west, and even there they continue to look for their readers, gather the community and provide the support that is needed, and we have literally been back from chernihiv for a week, and this incredible library, where we had joint events, the libraries of kotsyubynskyi and dovzhenko, and this library was damaged several times during the shelling of the occupiers, we remember, especially the second floor, the roof there... leaked, there were no windows, it was a very difficult situation, and literally a year passes, and so do we saw a completely modern, beautiful library that gathers full audiences, film screenings, discussions, debates, for me it is a kind of miracle, for me it is about some kind of great resilience, resistance of each of our communities, which is really fascinating, and since you have already started talking about chernihiv oblast, i will mention one moment, because tatyana and i were together on this very trip, and together with other

beautiful members of pen, with kateryna kalytko again, sofia andruhovich with vakhtan kybuladze, and here in novgorod siverskyi, which is actually a border territory, so there 20-30 km to the russian border, one man stood up at the meeting, there was an unusually sincere conversation, and he told us the following, he says that you will not believe it, but in... ukrainian writers did not come to us from in 1989, 1989 , and we were all very impressed by it then, i remember that the soviet authorities took very good care of ensuring that there were contacts between artists and writers with people in the provinces, cities, towns, villages farthest from the center, even there on the links. pig farms, they

did concerts everywhere, some, some meetings, like this can be done now, that is, there is no such propaganda apparatus, yes, what would this contact provide, but contact is needed, as you see it, how can it be organized so that it is on some such a wider level, because peng will not be able to to do this, yes, this contact, which is very necessary for both us and them, how can it be done? you know, i was also very impressed by this moment, this man's speech in novgorod-syrskyi, i also think about it constantly, and i still think not only about the fact that it was part of the soviet propaganda cars, but i also think about that generation, we are talking about the sixties, partly about dissidents who, not only because of the soviet system and the opportunities provided by the soviet government, but also because of their own calling, really wanted to go to the people, that is, we know.

tried to instrumentalize, but in fact these contacts, but on the other hand, i heard about these meetings in the same chernihiv, they remembered how pavlychko and drachi also came there with such enthusiasm that leading, leading ukrainian writers came to us to talk like that with us, with yours readers, that is, here is a very important moment of the community that we talk about a lot today, the community of the sixties, their influence, their desire to know and feel their country like this. my, my lands , ah, when i think in general, about these experiences, i think about the fact that even before the 22nd year, pen actually traveled a lot, we had two programs, lace, within the framework of which we travel to district centers ukraine, we had a rapprochement program, we went to big cities, but it was during these volunteer trips that i realized that i i don't know my country, i've always traveled a lot, i've been to all regions of ukraine, but now when we travel... to small

towns, when we visit villages, even in these communities, i realized that we do this not enough, and that i don't know my country, so it's obvious that i need to continue this, travel even more, and now other initiatives are appearing, yes, initiatives of public organizations, the publishers' forum is now also traveling with a book initiative to the regions, but for sure this will never be enough and obviously we are we have to go to the state level, when the state, state institutions... will also use all opportunities for writers and artists to travel to all regions of ukraine. do you remember that in novgorod sivorsky, this opinion was also voiced that maybe if there were more of these contacts, these conversations about what we live in, the situation in this region would be different, more ukrainian books would be read here , and no one knows how the hostilities would take place there, and it is a very painful such moment, and it is addressed to ukrainian artists, he belongs to us.

addressed by these people, and you have to think about it, now of course there is a great difficulty with the security moments in these trips, these stories, but at the same time we see. we are convinced from our experience that it is possible and that this is most importantly necessary, by the way, not only in novosibirsk, but also in general, in these border territories, the opinion is constantly heard that there is no vacuum, one way or another, the absence, absence of ukrainian culture, so it was filled with television, which kind was russian-speaking and pro-russian , russian performers, russian books, and so on, that is, where there was a void, it was filled with something very foreign, i want to show another dear to me excerpt from the film about mykolaiv, about pen's trip to mykolaiv, because from it it becomes

even more clear, how pen actually communicates with local libraries, local cultural figures, what conversations they have, these are very small snippets, but they ... give this insight, please, then we removed all this because we were preparing before the evacuation, and while we are still unpacking the books, firstly, and secondly, two- thirds of the team is missing, so we have some kind of department. are not working, which ones are not yet, to date 58 libraries are damaged, 58 of them, i will say very briefly what we are doing here, everything we see, we will tell, it is very important to be physically present, both in ukrainian and in crimean tatar , because it is important for us to maintain

the crimean tatar identity, including in the occupied territories, this is one of the key threats to the occupiers, a strong national, ukrainian.

so, it was mykolaiv, what do you remember about mykolaiv, what impressed you in mykolaiv on that trip? you know, i do every time. when i watch these videos or see some photos from our trips, i have the feeling that i see my own people, and library managers, library workers, people to whom we return, to whom we now often ask for advice when we travel in this direction, and mykolaiv is absolutely just my hometown, we are very close friends today with their libraries, that is why i am filled with such great joy that i see these faces and i remember this one. in fact, this trip was at the same time as kherson, we first went to mykolaiv oblast, then from there we went to kherson, and first of all i remember this library, how we were met, what questions were asked, what it looked like library, that is, even in those

difficult conditions, we know that mykolaiv was also in very difficult conditions, the first months of the invasion, but despite this they show that we are already windows here. they replaced the old prints here, they showed you, the old prints show, here we have a piece of rocket that fell directly in the yard, it did not explode, we continue to work, and they told how they went to the library, even on the most difficult days, when people tried not to leave the house, but they went to check what was happening here, whether the books were safe, tried to keep in touch with our audience, it really fascinated me and still fascinates me, and in fact mykolaiv also encouraged us to... such an expansion of our assistance to libraries, we started, in addition to the fact that we ourselves purchase and bring new books with our penbus on de-occupied front-line territories, we also began to announce all-ukrainian collections of books, and we managed to collect even more publications for mykolaiv and kherson, and these are

such active people that they try not only to help the city, the region, but it seems to me that they they help the whole. in ukraine with their activity and everything they do, everything they do today, and i want to ask you about another such unique phenomenon, about how volodya yarmolenko, a philosopher, and the president of the ukrainian foam, and his wife, tetyana ogarkova, they collect money on the cultural podcast platform of their kultpodkast, and almost every time, well, not every time, but very often, they bring not only books, but also a car, like for the armed forces of ukraine, which they buy with the money they collected on this podcasts i am interested in how you see the reaction of western intellectuals, foreigners to this, in general, how

they perceive it, because this is something unique for an intellectual, so that on the one hand, here is such an activity, and on the other hand, these people must support their army in this way, and it is obvious that they are often surprised by this, this question is always about the role of intellectuals in the conditions of war, it is already such a question, where does it start... almost every international event where we are invited, and i am always talking about the ukrainian artists who are at the front today, who joined the army , i tell their stories, i tell how they explain this decision to join the army and defend their country today, and tell other stories, i always say that so many of our authors joined the ranks armed forces, everyone else became volunteers, i always say that in ukraine everyone is a volunteer, and so on... he tells separate stories, in particular he tells the stories of tetyan and volodymyr,

i also talk about the history of the cult podcast, it arose as a project even before the full-scale invasion , and according to my feeling, as a listener , this project was designed to show ukrainian culture, as an absolutely obvious part of european culture, to tell us and remind ourselves who our marks are, who are these big, large-scale names in... culture, and then after the 22nd year, when tetyana and volodymyr are actively involved in information work, so they still conduct dozens of broadcasts in different languages ​​for foreign audiences every day, they also start traveling with humanitarian aid to the de-occupied territories, and then they also come to this realization and decision, that everything they do, everything that keeps culture alive today, it should also support our army, and always abroad, when they ask how to... help ukraine, how to help writers or artists today? the very first thing we all say is that

please support our army, it is the main partner of ukrainian culture. and the story of the cult podcast is actually a very strong example and a very strong metaphor of how ukrainian culture today supports its country and supports its army. tatyana and volodymyr organize many initiatives to raise funds, they will continue to record podcasts in different languages. well , in particular, all the events that take place in our space, our tenants, they are all aimed at raising funds for the army and buying the next cars. i i think that, in fact, there can be no other scenario in ukrainian culture today. ukrainian culture should also work to support the country and support the army. tanya, thank you for this conversation. tetyana teren, executive director of ukrainian pen, was with us today. you understand that supporting culture is a part, a very important

part of our, our resistance to russian aggression, if you want to support a ukrainian book, ukrainian culture, do it, help the kherson libraries, help the podcast cult, help all-ukrainian collection for damaged libraries, and in this way we will only be stronger, and our culture will be. thank you for being with us today, and see you in a week, there are discounts on phyto broncholithin, 15% at travel pharmacies, bam and savings. there are discounts on aquaspray oxy, 20% in travel pharmacies. bam and savings there are discounts on amixin ic tablets, 10% in psarynsky, bam and oskad pharmacies.

vasyl zima's big broadcast. this is the great ether, my name is vasyl zima, and we are about to begin. two hours of air time. two hours of your time. many we will discuss important topics today. two hours to learn about the war. right now, we will talk more about the war , serhiy zgurets with us and how the world is living now , about what happened in the world , yuliy fizar will speak in more detail, yuriy, good evening, please have a word. two hours to keep up with economic news, time to... talk about money during the war oleksandr morchuvka with us, oleksandr, congratulations, please and sports news, a review of sports events from yevgeny pastukhov two hours in the company of loved ones presenters thank you very much to elina chechenna for the information about cultural news, presenters that have become familiar to many. natalka didenko is ready to tell us about the weather on the day i will come, as well as the distinguished guests of the studio. andriy parubiy, people's deputy of ukraine,

was also the chairman of the verkhovna rada of ukraine. events of the day in two hours. vasyl zima's big broadcast. a project for smart and caring people. espresso in the evening. the premium sponsor of the national team represents. united by football. stronger together. see this week in the collaborators program. ministries of the occupiers, whom were the rashists appointed managers? i want russia to be on the lands of the kherson region, and it will be. but how did the fake minister rob his owners of millions of rubles? the accused is detained. on tuesday, march 26, at 5:45 p.m., watch the collaborators program with olena kononenko

on the espresso tv channel. an unusual look at the news. good health, ladies and gentlemen, my name is mykola veresen. sharp serve. facts and competent opinions, in america they also say, let us have better roads , we will have even better ones, a special view of events in in ukraine, on the border of kyiv, there will be some katsaps and beyond, which the world dreams of, norman, we can imagine it, all this in the informational marathon with mykola veresny, saturday 5:10 p.m., sunday 6:15 p.m. at espresso. see this week in the judicial control program with tatyana shustrova. candidates for the constitutional court, who live at the expense of their parents? yes, this is unacceptable, i agree. but who managed to buy two apartments, a house and garages for 1 hryvnia. i tried to convert karbovantsi into hryvnia. greetings, this is a judicial control program, and how we always talk about the main reform, the direction of which depends on our european

prospects. how is the new judiciary formed in ukraine? the competition for the constitutional court of ukraine is in full swing. 26 candidates apply for five vacant positions, and for the first time in the entire history of the appointment of judges of the constitutional court, the competition is truly open and with the participation of international experts. about all this today, but first traditionally to the news. ivano-frankivsk oblast commercial court judge volodymyr bulka was sentenced to six months for a €500 bribe years of imprisonment. the national anti-corruption bureau has exposed yet more bribes. in august 2018, then the judge received €500 for passing a decision on the extension of the powers of the arbitration administrator in the bankruptcy case of the company. volodymyr bulka asked for five bottles of champagne. the bribe payer explained: five is in euros or dollars. after being exposed for bribery in 2018, judge bulka submitted his resignation and went on

an honorary pension with a lifetime allowance. if the judgment becomes final, the resignation and benefits will be suspended. in in ukraine, a competition for the selection of candidates for the positions of constitutional court judges is underway. for the first time , judges are chosen by an advisory group of experts, a specially created body for a comprehensive independent assessment of moral qualities and professional competence of candidates. and experts have a lot of work. not all applicants can boast of integrity. not always everything happens as indicated. this is maksym muzyka, judge of the economic court of khmelnytskyi region. 2011, a judge purchased a new hyundai santa fe for $38,000 when his combined annual income tripled smaller part of the, uh, funds that went into the purchase of said car were my funds, and part were provided by my parents, i indicated that in my written explanations. of course, parents are a classic judicial non-

exhaustive source of money. however, the advisory group of experts was not convinced by the explanation. we couldn't. find out the complete source of income for the purchase. your mother 's income in 2011 was 361 thousand ukrainian hryvnias. and if you take into account what your mother carried in the process of entrepreneurial activity expenses, this amount will be somewhat lower. besides, yours. the mother had personal daily expenses. so that's the problem, because we can't find it. accordingly, the amount of those savings even on her part. experts also drew attention to the fact that in the same year 2011, the judge's father

bought a new car worth 30,000 to 40,000 dollars. well, it doesn't match at all. in 2019, maksym muzyka bought an apartment for half a million hryvnias, for this he took a loan from the bank and did not do without breaking the law. bypassing the provision that obliges to carry out notarized settlements. exclusively in cashless form, i know the provisions of the law, but life is much more complicated than our idea of ​​it, and maksym muzyka neglected the norms of the law not only in this part, for example, in 2012-13 he did not declare a land plot with an area of ​​1000 m2. the explanation is brilliant. probably, for this we need to go back to 2012-13. and to remember how, how the declaration took place, the declaration, well, i will say frankly, it was so, formally. maksym muzyka is a doctor of philosophy, less than six months ago

he defended his thesis, but at the interview he was unable to recall the names of those who helped him get his degree. the reviewers were women. in addition, there are many plagiarism issues with music. he forgot to indicate the authorship of the sources he used , and in the midst of it all. of a large-scale war , i used russian sources, i did not indicate in several of my articles, there were no references to the authors, yes, this is unacceptable, i agree, we will find out soon whether maxim music will become a judge of the constitutional court of ukraine. and this is another candidate for the ksu, oleksandr radutny, he is an associate professor of the department of criminal law of the national university of law named after yaroslav the wise. perhaps the declaration is... a kind of dialogue. oleksandr radutny, according to the declaration, has two garages, two apartments and a residential building, and all this is worth 1 hryvnia. the candidate for the constitutional court does not count well. i have several

times tried to convert karbovantsi into hryvnia. at other times when filling out the declarations, i wanted to indicate, well, in order to give my explanations about this 1 hryvnia. of course, 1 hryvnia attracts attention. this is actually for the dialogue i wanted to do. uradutny's calculations do not agree not only because of money conversion. last year, he submitted two declarations, one annual, the other for competition, to the constitutional court. i filled them with a difference of several months. during this time, he forgot how much the ford car cost him, whether it was 90 or 70 thousand hryvnias. radutny explains that he bought it abroad and brought it to ukraine almost as scrap metal. i have documents in my hands, none of which are there. the amount from which you can pay as much as you, i paid different amounts, as different amounts, i paid for the auction, this car was purchased after an accident

at the auction, well, you paid for the auction, in what way through a private bank, everything, that is, you have documents, all these documents are at the state registrar of this vehicle, i only have the certificate in my hands, because after it was imported, after... repaired, it was not yet considered a vehicle, so how can a doctor of legal sciences, associate professor of the department of criminal law, who is applying for the position judge, i decided to fill out the declaration , i was based on my previous experience with the suzuki kisashi car, i roughly calculated that the old one, this one and the new one, it has a larger engine volume, the one with a smaller engine, as much as it can be, about 90, however a group of experts found out how much the council is worth in the end. paid for the car this car completely matches the course and description of the car. 2020 ford escape sold for $7,000 excluding

auction fee, shipping from us to eu, customs registration and so on. this car was purchased for seven, for transportation, for $ 700, well, approximately transportation 7.800. finally remembered the purchase. of this car was part of the renewal plan: sell the old car, buy a new car, use these funds. and it rained again. oleksandr radudny purchased ford in 2021. he sold his previous suzuki car only a year ago, so he got money from the future. oleksandr radutny's social networks proved to be eloquent as well, testifying to his anti-ukrainian position. on his page in social network facebook. in june 2014 , you made a link to the material with the title yevgeny gilbo in ukraine vyzhivet ne boleh 8 mln chelovek frankly. non-phobic

content, also in the russian social network vkontakte, in 2014 you posted two posts of ambiguous content, one about the navy, the armed forces of ukraine, and the other containing criticism of euromaidan, where participants of peaceful protests on the maidan are called putschists. since the 14th year, without having access to these platforms, anything can happen there, any fakes, any omissions, in order... to clarify, i completed the answer to this question, in order to explain the difference between my publications and such fake ones, i gave examples from my other documents, where there is a translation into english , has a surname , a name, and so on, which just prove that these are not my publications. the explanations are questionable, to put it mildly, but experts will assess their adequacy and compliance with integrity criteria. and finally.

for 1000 hryvnias the average price of similar real estate at that time was four times higher, it had technically small dimensions, there are 407, it seems 48 meters of the total area. and this is the last floor, that is, it had its own disadvantages, a number of disadvantages. in 2008, a candidate for the ksu bought a volvo for uah 30,000. almost nine

times. cheaper than its real value. the car was in a damaged condition, before that it was standing on the penalty area. in 2022 , volodymyr ratush bought a suzuki and again at half the market price. he explains this by the fact that the car is broken after an accident. maybe volodymyr ratush just likes to fix everything so much? town hall's wife works and receives income, but he does not indicate this in his declaration. the reason, as for a candidate for a constitutional court judge, is interesting. we really are. joint household, but i believe that if it can be interpreted as a violation of the law, well, maybe i will agree, i have no other way out, i respect the interests of the person i love. don't lend volodymyr ratosh ambitions. in 2019 , he wanted to become president. he tried to register as a candidate, but

he did not pay the monetary deposit required by law. so the cec refused him. the man is still is trying to challenge it and claims another high seat in the constitutional court. however, i haven't decided yet, why? i want to become not only a judge, but also a member of the constitutional court of ukraine. i want to lead it. the leader is satisfied. so. lead so that the three dots continue to go. will volodymyr sit down? into the judgment seat and can we see what he meant by those three dots? we will find out soon. in a few days, by the way, a group of experts must select contestants who will proceed to the next stage: conducting interviews regarding assessments of a high level of competence. we hope that the esteemed jury will not have to sit on the fence, choosing between cool people and singers, honest, professional and worthy

candidates will be chosen for high positions. and for today, that's all for me, if you want to report corrupt judges or illegal decisions, write to me on facebook or to this email address, we'll see. in exactly one week, there are discounts on vitamin d3, d3 max, 10% in the pharmacies of psyllanyk, bam and ochadnyk, there are discounts on otrivin.