for espresso.

a journalist who joined the armed forces, a political expert who became a special agent, taras berezovyts in a new project on espresso. the real front is a thorough analysis of the main events. reports, comments of leading specialists and experts. analytics from the major of the armed forces. how to make sense of disturbing news and distinguish truth from hostile propaganda. the real front program with taras berezovets, which... at 21:30 on espresso. the beraber program continues on your screens, in the studio of gulsum andrii khalilova yanitsky, we are talking about crimea, crimean news. the second block is mainly devoted to the humanitarian aspect of the kremlin's stay on the peninsula and... and what is happening there,

we have a guest, ms. elmira ablyalimova cheygos, an expert of the crimean institute of strategic studies, should be in touch already, ms. elmira, congratulations, congratulations from the village of maliki, glory to ukraine, glory, we will talk about the khan palace, and for those who do not know, the khan palace, for those who do not know, it is the only palace complex in the world. which has been preserved, and a sample of crimean taran palace architecture and the residence of the rulers of the crimean khanate of the heraev dynasty. so, uh, let's start with such a light news, the lego company is famous in the world, the toy manufacturer presented a constructor in the form of the khan's palace, and this constructor, of course, popularizes the crimean tatar culture and the history of crimea in general. all over the world, i hope that children

all over the world will be able to play with these toys and learn more about crimea, the crimean tatars, but we know that there are realities, now the palace is under occupation and is not in the best condition, as far as i know , well, very exciting news has been appearing recently, during illegal excavations, as it became known on the territory of... the khan's palace of bakhchrai, a previously unknown building was discovered, the foundation was discovered in the harem garden of the palace complex of glorious heroes, claim russian propagandists, referring to their diggers , on their so -called archaeologists, they promise to dig until they reach the layer of earth that the owners of the khan's palace walked through. elmira khanovna, how risky it all is, how illegal are all these actions of russian diggers and archaeologists.

and they feel sorry for our palace, huh, well , first of all, i wanted to thank you for raising such an issue, it is extremely important, especially for the crimean tatars, because really you are absolutely right, the bashchesrai khan's palace is the only monument that really confirms our existence, ethnogenesis, statehood on the territory of crimea, therefore to preserve... this monument, this is our number one task, uh, as for the works that we record on the territory of bagchesrai, khan's palace, from the point of view of international humanitarian law , they are illegal, because all these works must be, firstly, authorized by ukraine, and secondly, they must carry such a restoration function. today, we see

everything except restoration, first of all, it is very similar to repair work, reconstruction, as a result of which we lose. the authenticity of the monument, unfortunately, and a vivid example of the fact that we are losing this authenticity is, first of all, the fact that the great khan mosque, where the so-called, yes restoration work from the point of view of the russian authorities, the occupation authorities started way back in 2016, they, she, unfortunately, not today. open to the audience, that is, these works that they started, they brought about, led to certain consequences, consequences, and these consequences are still impossible to overcome, here, and regarding, i also wanted to reflect a little, if

possible, you know, unfortunately, in ukrainian environment, that there are a lot of such stereotypical ideas that were imposed on us. or from the time of the soviet union, the russian empire and so on, and the first object that the lego campaign did about crimea, it was so swallows, swallows on the nest, yes, you remember, here, and unfortunately, unfortunately, well, the first such, their first attempt to show crimea and associate it with this attraction, well, it caused such outrage. in society, including i wrote many posts about this, that is why i spoke about the fact that i believe that crimea should be associated among ukrainians precisely with the crimean tatar culture, with the unique crimean tatar culture, and i am very glad

that this year the khan's palace really appeared, well, finally and ilmira khanum, and in relation of the khan's palace, there are still a few questions, you said that, unfortunately, today we are losing the authenticity of the khan's palace, and indeed, if you look at these pseudo-restoration works of the russian occupiers, we saw before that that they were filming our old shingles, but they brought another one from spain and put it there, well, it's really just a loss of all authenticity, and this old shingle, it was lying there somewhere. her under the rain and so on, she was simply destroyed, as far as all these processes are concerned, they are irreversible, well, that is, when we we are already de-occupying the peninsula, we will come to crimea, we will be able to restore everything correctly, return all this, how irreversible

and risky it all is, well, it is difficult to answer here, because we do not have access to this object, it seems to me from that and based on from the fact that... we see in the photos or videos that we will receive from the crimea, indeed certain works, they are already irreversible, to return the authenticity, well , it is almost impossible, we can reconstruct the object, but to return it to the authenticity, well, it is almost impossible on some objects of the complex, you know that the ghanaian palace is a complex that consists of several monuments, well, here, and some of them really. the work has already led to a certain partial loss of authenticity of the object, and it seems to me that even the question of including the palace in the list of world heritage will be a big problem,

because the first factor of inclusion is the authenticity and authenticity of the monument, but it seems to me that there is something ... which we don't talk about much, but is also a big problem, the fact is that any monument, it is also historical material, a source of future scientific research, and precisely by restoring, no, oh, sorry, by carrying out reconstruction, not by restoring a monument, we lose certain, well, sources of knowledge that can be used. as a source of research for future research, because even construction and construction techniques are also a source of knowledge about how the productive forces were developed in a certain

period before the crimean khanate, we know that russia still imposes the thesis that the crimean khanate was so an understated state in which... well, there wasn't, wasn't a developed economy, there were no certain attributes of statehood, yes, it was a state that lived only on begama and so on. but it is the practice and technology of construction, they show the development of production forces, and are a source of certain knowledge, and by losing such sources, we almost lose the future, mythologizing research that would give us additional knowledge, i was like that, you know , was impressed when they were carrying out... er, the dismantling of the roof of the great khan mosque by such a complex

structure of the construction of the roof of the great of the khan mosque, without a single nail, structures were built there that were not even understandable to modern engineers, because the only thing they could do, the only decision they made, was to dismantle this very roof, but eh... that is, the construction was so complicated that is, the roof of the great khan mosque, but today we have lost this structure, we have modern, you are absolutely right, modern materials, modern technologies, modern tiles, which do not correspond either to the era of construction or to the technologies of that time, and it seems to me , even lost a little... such integrity of the complex, when one part of the complex is under one type

of building materials and technologies, and the other part is under another elmirano, you mentioned unesco, and we know that the khan's palace, it was entered by ukraine in the preliminary lists for inclusion in the objects of cultural heritage of the world. but not finally included, but unesco can somehow influence russia, stop this mess and still force the occupier not to destroy the khan's palace, but to carry out exclusively restoration work, not repair work. and did we as a state address this issue to unesco? yes, we appealed, the state of ukraine has done everything it can in full. in order to preserve not only this monument, but all the objects

that today are under the influence of the occupying power, yes, the fact is that russia is not only rebuilding the bagchesarai khan palace, it is conducting illegal archaeological excavations in the occupied territories, it moves the museum of worthlessness from the occupied territory to the russian federation and... even from the newly occupied territories transport certain museum values ​​to the territory of the occupied crimea, and russia appropriates cultural values ​​and objects of cultural heritage together with cultural institutions, it uses them for military purposes, to date certain facts of the use of archaeological... currents of crimea, which is located on the north of the peninsula as

fortifications, and of course it is rebuilding certain sights, and we have recorded all these facts and are passing them on to the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine, the ministry of culture and information policy, as a result of such work there is a unesco decision to conduct annual monitoring of the state of... protection of objects of cultural heritage, science, culture, religion, i.e. in all of unesco's mandate, but the problem is that the international the law, in particular in the matter of protection of cultural heritage objects during armed conflict, the issue of responsibility is very easily spelled out, and it is extremely and extremely difficult to bring russia to... responsibility for these objects, and i

think that it will be just that such a task ukraine for the future, ah, to become at the forefront of the processes of a more careful consideration of the norms of international law, regarding attraction. to the responsibility of people who are involved in crimes against cultural heritage, by the way, we are holding on july 4-5. our organization , the crimean institute of strategic studies, together with the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine, together with the ministry of culture and information policy, as well as our partners, the all-ukrainian organization of international law, are holding a conference dedicated to the 75th anniversary of the gast convention and the 25th anniversary of the second protocol, and

the focus of this conference will be the issue of criminal responsibility for crimes. against cultural heritage, well, unfortunately, unfortunately, it is not news that empires steal cultural values, even old empires, which now seem to be civilized, still keep in their museums many cultural values ​​from - other countries, it would be it is good to actually return them and, after all, to get rid of the consequences of this imperial e, but if we are talking not only about the khan's palace, not only about... directly cultural values, in general about life in crimea, now is the season, we see, for example, in kyiv, that on the beaches on the rivers, the beaches are full of people, and here are the shots from the crimean beaches, which are unusually empty, why is this happening, really russia has stopped

sending these pro-soviet activists, the military, to sanatoriums, they don't even risk them anymore, i... a tourist on his own is unlikely to go to crimea, well, is he a very risky one, who is ready for adventures, so to speak, yes, but we we know that the russians developed this organized tourism, now the beaches show that even this organized tourism is not so much anymore, do you have data on what is happening with tourist crimea now? well, you know, i have always been quite skeptical of attempts... to create a tourist region from crimea, as if there, because it seems to me that all people who understand russia's intentions regarding the seizure of certain territories, we understood that all this was done for military purposes, and sooner or later this story with crimea, supposedly a tourist

region, would have ended, but today it seems to me that this is the situation that i now i see on... on your footage, it very clearly shows the intentions of ukraine regarding crimea, and the citizens of ukraine who are in the territory of crimea today, they are happy to perceive such a wonderful picture, it seems to me. yes, i will remind you of this sacramental phrase of a russian tourist, mother, mother, it is necessary to dump from here, it is necessary to dump from here, give me the address. to all russians who are illegally on the territory of the peninsula, this phrase and let's return to other issues, the prime minister, mr. chmygaal, made a statement about what will be after the liberation of crimea, he said that what will be developed there, and in particular, it was about tourism development, you

say that you are skeptical of russia's attempts to develop tourism in crimea, but ukraine can turn crimea into... such a tourist mecca, and you know, this is a difficult issue, i think that the first thing we have to do is to solve certain issues regarding the protection of our borders, because this crazy neighbor, crazy neighbor, yes, she will not go anywhere from us, and we have to do everything for... the fact that any of her efforts, even to look in our direction, they were perceived as an intention to seize, you understand, therefore, first of all, what we need is to ensure such security of our borders, regarding further actions, then i think

so, indeed, because crimea is wonderful, you know, literally yesterday... i thought a little bit about what could be in crimea and about myself in crimea personally, and i came to the conclusion that first of all you can study history, world history through the sights of crimea, he is unique from this point of view, and world history, the history of mankind in that number, and we have a lot of different attractions, starting from nierdert. and ending modern history, crimea is wonderful from the point of view, it is picturesque, extremely, picturesque, it was such an inspiration for poets, and for ... writers and for artists, and it can be like that, it is a health center, it is the homeland of the crimean tatars, and it seems to me that if

we return to the political question of granting the status of crimea, crimean tatar territorial national autonomy, and not be afraid of this question, then... crimea can become the most beautiful city on earth, such as we all see it, but before that we need to do a lot of work, first of all, on the decolonization and history of crimea, on the decolonization of the territory, on the reinterpretation of the history of crimea, including that which is part of the history of ukraine, on the reinterpretation of certain... . historical personalities, certain historical events, and then, perhaps, we will form

our new vision of crimea as an integral part of the state of ukraine. thank you, chogsag, edmira blyalimova chi gos was in direct contact with us, an expert in crimea institute of strategic studies, and really make crimea the way it dreams of. it was made by the leader of the kremstar people, noman chilibikhan, together with his assistant jafer siydamet, and to make such a second switzerland in crimea. and finally, we will show you how russia day was celebrated in crimea, if possible, but there are our people in crimea, and they do not give up, we see the symbol of the partisan movement, and also the burning russian flag, i hope for such a positive. i hope that this is the fate of all russian flags on the peninsula. on this we are completing our berber program together, a project jointly produced by

the espresso tv channel and the first crimean tatar tv channel atr, and we are two presenters, andrii yanitskyi and gulsum khalilova. see this week in the collaborators program. why was the ukrainian producer bardash suspected? i came here, roughly speaking, with a backpack. yes, i have been to moscow before. but how does the son of the ex-mayor of odesa own the temporarily occupied territories. our russian people are always used to fighting any difficulties. greetings, i am olena kononenko, and this the collaborators program is about traitors who went to serve at the call of their hearts and wallets. rashish occupiers. today there will be many new faces of treason, who are asking to be slandered throughout ukraine. but let's start with the well-known seller, music

producer yuriy bardash. after the full-scale invasion, he fled the country, first hiding in georgia. there , on his social media pages, he compared ukraine with nazi germany, and called himself a russian. after that, bardash allegedly started receiving threats from the georgian legion, so the traitor decided to scratch. while i'm still in russia, i came here, roughly speaking, with a backpack. yes, i have been to moscow before, but not with the awareness that i am here forever. now bardash is sitting in the pig capital and runs a telegram channel where he calls for the capture of kharkiv and kyiv. he believes that the descendants of russia will study how a quasi-great power ruled the history of the whole world. and here are glimpses of ukrainian patriotism that... the phrase "putin took away ours" is a phrase that reassured ukrainians, they wanted me to tell them that.

on january 23, 2024, yuriy bardash received passport with a chicken, already on may 22, the security service of ukraine notified the former well-known ukrainian producer of suspicion on four articles, in particular, for justifying the war and calling for changes to the borders of the territory of ukraine. in response to... bardar said that he is looking for those involved in this decision. considering his actions and publication in telegram, it can be assumed that the former producer has not yet been released by the mushrooms. well, he will have to undergo a rehabilitation course in a ukrainian colony. and this collaborator has not received the suspicion yet, but he is persistent working on it. worthy films with a patriotic upbringing, mood, which show exactly the role of russia, that it is a great country of the great. meet yevhen ivanovich maksymov , born in 1961. in peaceful life, he was the organizer of a multi-year

amateur film festival. kinokimeria also became famous for destroying the cultural center kherson art and helping to hand over the premises of the former cinema, in which the center was located, under the control of vladyslav mangru, the ex-chairman of the kherson regional council, sentenced to 10 years in prison for murder activist kateryna hantsyuk. prior to that, maksimov was the director of the regional utility company kino-videorokat, when chobit of the occupier set foot in kherson, maksimov decided to change his ukrainian passport to a russian one and start. a new page of his life, treacherous and worthless, but at first he did it with a shorthand, his betrayal became known when the occupiers fled from kherson to the left bank of the dnieper, maksimov ran with them, at the same time he did not forget to grab the equipment from the yuvileyny cinema, maksimov settled together with equipment in the new kakhovka and began to take care of the russia cinema, which used to be called ukraine. this is a piece of his interview, where the traitor tells about installing the stolen

equipment in the local. so -called colleagues from the temporarily occupied crimea helped the cinema. thanks to my colleagues from crimea, many thanks from the feodosia cinema of crimea, who volunteered to help us, literally for the past few days i have been bringing technicians and engineers from there. however, for a short time maksimov took care of the issues of cinema, he was promoted. when russia held illegal elections in the temporarily occupied territories of ukraine, this traitor received the mandate of feykova kherson regional duma deputy from putin. thanks to the personal initiative of the secretary of the united russia party and the senator of the kherson region. two beautiful autonomous clubs came to kherson oblast. this progenitor can often be seen in the occupied henichesk at backward film festivals that he organizes in honor of the occupiers and russian figures. as part of the united russia party and children's sports project

, we presented a film about... a beautiful sportswoman for our schoolchildren. we have ours instead, we want to see maksimov as the hero of another documentary film, about how traitors end up on the dock, and then arrested. he is wanted in ukraine, in the swamps he faithfully serves the regime of murderers. our russian people are always used to fighting any difficulties, and the more these difficulties, the more the function of patriotism is included. this is volodymyr ruslan from odessa, bodelan. born in 1975, he is the son of the former mayor of odesa, ruslan bodalan. in 1997, he graduated from odessa state polytechnic university, obtained qualification of a specialist in engineering mechanics. in 2010, he graduated from the st. petersburg academy of management and economics. he was a member of the maritime party and the party of regions. in 2002 and 2010, he was elected a deputy of the odesa city council. in 2012 and 14

years ago, he took part in parliamentary elections, but never became a people's deputy. since december 2010 , he held the position of head of the main territorial department of the state emergency service in odesa region, and the events of may 2 ended his career in this position. law enforcement agencies opened criminal proceedings against bodelana the investigation believes that it was the firemen's inaction that caused the mass death of people in the odessa building of prospilok. being near the scene of the fire, bodelan ordered his subordinates not to go. the first fire engines arrived at the building only 40 minutes after the fire started. in no way will i dare and do not intend to cast a shadow on the results of the expert commission, but what i saw directly at this fire, by all accounts, could not have caused the death of people. subsequently, bodelan fled the country, the national police declared him wanted. in

2007, it was reported that he received russian citizenship and works in crimea, temporarily occupied by russia, where he holds the position of head of the so-called crimean branch of the federal cousin institution, the center for strategic studies of civil protection of the ministry of emergency situations of the russian federation. when russia unleashed a full-scale war, volodymyr began to appear in the temporarily occupied territories of ukraine. as it turned out, he was appointed deputy of the fake governor. of the kherson region and the head of the representative office of the kherson region in moscow. i can only be proud of this patriotism. we thank russia for accepting us, and this is the first time for us. and i hope that we will never let russia down in this. this traitor does not want to let his bloody idol down, so he is improving the work of russian state institutions. russifies the temporarily occupied territories and believes that erefia is a great state, and...