this week in the program judicial control with tatyana shustrova. candidates for the vrp on the president's quota, how to save for elite property, eating rations from the state. i am a person who knows how to save. and what new facts of judge gorbasenko's dishonesty did the state administrative court reveal. the fortunes were analyzed and a conclusion was made that there are no questions. on thursday , june 20 at 5:45 p.m., watch the judicial control program with tatiana shustrova on the espresso tv channel. continues on your screens, in the studio of gul sum khalilova andriy yanitsky, we are talking about crimea, crimean news, the second block is devoted mainly to the humanitarian aspects of the kremlin's stay on the peninsula and what is happening there, we have guests. ms.

ilmira ablyalimova cheygos, an expert of the crimean institute of strategic studies, should be in touch already, ms. elmira, congratulations. greetings, selyam aleikum. glory to ukraine. we will talk about the khan's palace, and for those who do not know, the khan's palace is the only preserved palace complex in the world, a sample of crimean-tatar palace architecture. and residence the rulers of the crimean khanate of the heraev dynasty, so let's start with this simple news: the lego company is a world-famous toy manufacturer, presented a constructor in the form of the khan's palace, and this constructor, of course, popularizes the crimean tatar culture and the history of crimea in general throughout the world, i i hope that children all over the world...

will be able to play with these toys and learn more about crimea, the crimean tatars, but we know that there are also realities, now the palace is under occupation and is not in the best condition, as far as i know. well indeed recently, very exciting news has appeared, during illegal excavations, as it became known, a previously unknown building was discovered on the territory of the bakhchrai khan's palace. the foundation was discovered in the harem garden of the palace complex of the famous heroes, claim russian propagandists, referring to their diggers, their so-called archaeologists, they promise to dig until they reach the layer of earth that the owners of the khan's palace used to walk on. elmira khanovna, how risky it all is, how all these actions of russian diggers are, archaeologists, they are illegal and they harm our palace. uhu, well, first of all, i wanted

to thank you for raising such a question, it is extremely important, especially for the crimean tatars, because indeed, you are absolutely right, the boghesrai khan palace is the only monument that really confirms our existence. ethnogenesis, statehood on the territory of crimea, so preserving this monument is our number one task. uhu, as for the works that we record on the territory of the bagchesrai-khan palace, from the point of view of international humanitarian rights, they are illegal, because all these works must, firstly, be authorized by ukraine, and secondly, they must carry such a restoration function. today we see everything except restoration.

first of all, it is very similar to repair work, reconstruction, as a result of which we are losing the authenticity of the monument, unfortunately, and a striking example of the fact that we are losing this authenticity is, first of all, that the great khan mosque, where the so-called yes, from the point of view of the russian authorities, the occupation authorities, restoration work has begun. still in in the distant year 2016, they, it, unfortunately, is not open to the audience today, that is, these works that they started, they brought, led to certain consequences, consequences, and these consequences are still impossible to overcome, here, and as for i wanted to reflect a little, if possible, you know, our... it's a pity, in the ukrainian environment there are a

lot of such stereotypical ideas that were imposed on us since the days of the soviet union, the russian empire, and so on. and the first object that the lego campaign did about the crimea, it was like this, swallows, swallows on nest, yes, you remember, here, and unfortunately, unfortunately, well, the first is their first attempt to show crimea and associate it with this landmark, well, it caused such indignation in society, including i wrote many posts about it. occasion, that is why i spoke about the fact that i believe that crimea should be associated among ukrainians with the crimean tatar culture, with the unique crimean tatar culture, and i am very glad when

the khan's palace really appeared this year, and finally elmira khanum , and regarding khansky palace, i still have a few questions, you said that we are losing, unfortunately, today... the authenticity of the khan's palace, and indeed, if you look at these pseudo-restoration works of the russian occupiers, we saw before that what they they removed our old shingles there, and they brought another one from spain and put it there, well, it's really just a loss of all authenticity, and this old shingle, it was lying there somewhere under the rain and so on, it was simply destroyed, as far as... that's it all these processes are irreversible, that is, when we we are already de-occupying the peninsula, we will come to crimea, we will be able to properly restore it all, return it all, how irreversible and risky it all is, well, it is difficult to answer here, because we

do not have access to this object, it seems to me from that and based on from what we see in the photos or videos that we will receive from crimea. indeed certain works, they are already irreversible, it is almost impossible to restore the authenticity, we can reconstruct the object, but to restore its authenticity, well , it is almost impossible for some objects of the complex, you know that the khan's palace is a complex that consists of several monuments, well, some of them have already been partially completed. loss of authenticity of the object, and it seems to me that even the question of including the palace in the usk world heritage list will be a big problem, because the first factor of inclusion is the authenticity and

authenticity of the monument, but it seems to me that there is something that we don't talk about much , but... also a big problem, the fact is that any monument, it is also historical material, a source of future scientific research, and precisely by restoring, no, oh, sorry, by carrying out reconstruction, and not by restoring a monument, we lose certain, well, sources of knowledge that can be used as a source of research. future research, because even construction and construction techniques are also a source of knowledge about how the productive forces were developed in a certain period before the crimean khanate, we know that russia still

imposes such a thesis that the alleged crimean khanate was such an understate in which well, there wasn't, the economy wasn't developed, there weren't... certain attributes of statehood, yes, it was a state that lived only on begami and so on, but it is precisely the practice and construction technologies that show the development of the production forces, and are a source of certain knowledge, and by losing such sources, we almost lose the future , where the mythologizing to... investigation, which would give us additional knowledge, i was so, you know, amazed when they were dismantling the roof of the great khan mosque with such a complex construction of the roof of the great khan mosque, without a single nail, there were

built structures that were not even understandable to modern engineers, because the only thing... they couldn't, the only decision they made was the dismantling of this very roof, but, that is, the construction was so complex that... exactly the roof of the great khan's house mosque, but today we have lost this structure, we have modern, you are absolutely right, modern materials, modern technologies, modern tiles, which do not correspond to the era of construction or the technologies of that time, and it seems to me that we have even lost a little of this the integrity of the complex, when one part... of the complex is under one department

of building materials and technologies, and the other part is under another. elmirana, you mentioned unesco, and we know that the khanovsky palace was included by ukraine in the previous lists for inclusion in the cultural heritage sites of world importance, but was not finally included, but unesco somehow can. to influence russia, stop this bezlat and still force the occupier not to destroy the khan palace, but to carry out exclusively restoration works, not repairs. and did we as a state address this issue to unesco? and yes, we applied. the state of ukraine has done everything in its power to preserve not only this monument. all the objects that today are under the influence of the occupying power,

yes, the fact is that russia is not only rebuilding the bagchesarai khan palace, it is conducting illegal archaeological excavations on the territory of the occupied territories, it is moving museums of value from the occupied territory to the russian federation and even with of newly occupied territories , certain... values ​​are transported to the territory of occupied crimea, yes, russia appropriates cultural values ​​and objects of cultural heritage together with cultural institutions, it uses them for military purposes, to date certain facts of abuse of the use of archaeological monuments are already known crimea, which are located in the north. of the peninsula as fortifications, well, of course, it

is rebuilding certain sights, and we recorded all these facts and forward them to the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine and the ministry culture and information policy. as a result of such work, there is a unesco decision to conduct annual monitoring of the state of protection of objects of cultural heritage and science. culture, religion, that is, in everything, in the entire mandate of unesco, but the problem is that international law, in particular in the matter of protection of cultural heritage objects during an armed conflict, very easily prescribes the issue of responsibility, and to hold russia responsible for these objects, extremely. extremely difficult and i think that this will be precisely such a task of ukraine for

the future, to become at the forefront of the processes of a more careful consideration of the norms of international law, regarding the prosecution of people who to crimes against cultural heritage, by the way, on july 4-5 , our organization, the crimean institute of strategic studies, together with the ministry of foreign affairs of ukraine, together with the ministry of culture and information policy, as well as our partners, all-ukrainian organizations of international law, are holding a conference, which is dedicated to the 75th anniversary of the hades convention and... the fifth anniversary of the second protocol, and the focus of this conference will be the very issue

of criminal responsibility for crimes against cultural heritage, well, unfortunately, unfortunately, it is not news that empires steal cultural values, even the old empires, which seem to be civilized now, still keep a lot of cultural values ​​from other countries in their museums, it would be good to actually return them and still in... to get rid of the imperial consequences at all, but if we talk not only about the khan's palace, not only about directly cultural values, in general about life in the crimea, right now with... we see, for example, in kyiv, that on the beaches, on the rivers, the beaches are full of people, and here are the shots from the crimean beaches, which are unusual empty, why is this happening, has russia stopped sending these pro-soviet workers to the sanatorium, the military, they don’t

even risk them anymore, i understand that a tourist by himself is unlikely to go to crimea, well , isn’t he a very... risky one, who is ready to adventures, to put it mildly, yes, but we know that the russians developed this organized tourism, now the beaches show that even this organized tourism is not so much anymore, do you have any data on what is happening with tourist crimea now? well, you know, i have always been rather skeptical of the russians' attempts to create a tourist region from crimea, as if it were there, because it seems to me... to all people who understand russia's intentions regarding the arbitrary seizure of certain territories, we understood that all this is being done for military purposes, and sooner or later this story with crimea, supposedly a tourist region, would have ended, but today it seems to me that the situation that

i see in your footage very clearly shows the intention. of ukraine in relation to crimea, and the citizens of ukraine who are in the territory of crimea today, they are happy to perceive such a wonderful picture, it seems to me. yes, i will remind you of this sacramental phrase of a russian tourist, mommy mommy, it is necessary to dump from here, it is necessary to dump from here. let's address all russians who are illegally on the territory of the peninsula. this phrase and we will return to other issues, that's it the prime minister, mr. chmygaal, made a statement about what crimea will be like after liberation, he mentioned that what will be developed there, and in particular, it was about tourism development, you say that you are skeptical of russia's attempts to develop tourism in

crimea, but ukraine can turn crimea into such a tourist mecca, right? and you know, this is a difficult issue, i think that the first thing we have to do is to solve certain issues regarding the protection of our borders, because this crazy neighbor, crazy neighbor, yes, she will not leave us anywhere, and we have to to do everything so that any of her efforts, even... to look in our direction, they are perceived as an intention to capture, you see, so first of all, what we need is to ensure such security of our borders, regarding further actions , i think so, really, because crimea is wonderful, you know,

yesterday i literally thought a little bit about... about what could be in crimea and about myself in crimea personally, and i came to the conclusion that at first in turn, you can study history, world history at the sights of crimea, he unique from this point of view, from the point of view, and world history, the history of mankind, including, yes, we have a lot of different monuments, starting from the niertal people and ending with modern history, crimea is wonderful from the point of view... was such an inspiration and for poets, and for writers , and for artists, and it can be like that, it is a health center, it is the homeland of the crimean tatars, and it seems to me that if we return to the political question, regarding the granting of the status

of crimea, crimean tatar territorial... national autonomy, that and don't be afraid of it question, crimea can become the most beautiful city on earth, as we all see it, but before that we need to do a lot of work, first of all, on the decolonization and history of crimea, on the decolonization of the territory, on... understanding the history crimea, including that which is part of the history of ukraine, regarding the reinterpretation of certain historical figures, certain historical events. and then, perhaps, we will shape our new vision of crimea as an integral part of the state of ukraine. thank

you. edmira blialimova, chi gos was with us at direct communication, an expert of the crimean institute of strategic studies, and really make crimea the way the leader of the crimean people dreamed of making it. to make such a second switzerland in crimea. and finally, we will show you how russia day was celebrated in crimea, if possible, and there are our people in crimea, and they do not give up, we see the symbol of the partisan movement, and also the burning russian flag, i hope for such a positive note, and we see it, i hope that this is the fate of all russians. leeches on the peninsula, this is where we end ours the beraber together program is a project jointly produced by the esso tv channel and the first crimean tatar tv channel atr, and we are the two

presenters, andriy yanitskyi and gulsum khalilova, until the meeting of korushkenja, korushkenja, see this week in the collaborators program. how a traitor from melitopol led the russian youth movement. i thank vladimir vladimirovich putin for his strong-willed decision to start the svo. but which of the kremlin propagandists received 15 years in prison? russia has already said that no one will talk to this scarecrow at all. hello, i'm elena kononenko and this is a collaborator program about traitors who, following the call of their heart and soul, went to serve the rashi occupiers. in today's issue, we will continue to talk about... those who exchanged hryvnias for rubles, and their native country for the bolotyan half-empire. he called for the capture of ukraine and pointed rockets at mykolaiv, for which he was

punished by the ukrainian themis. this is yury podoliaka, he is 48. he was born in sumy, lived in verkhny pischany, that is where his father, a retired doctor, lives now. yuriy is a graduate of sumy state university. he was a private entrepreneur, specializing in auto repair. first. the russian invasion of donbas before the occupation of crimea in the 14th year, he went to bolot, from there he has been conducting subversive activities for more than 10 years. for me , this is routine work, i am not afraid of this word, a professional in this matter. i am developing some directions myself in russia. podoliaka takes an active part in the information and psychological operations of the russian special services, regularly appears on propaganda tv channels, in particular on solovyov's talk show. during broadcasts. urges to the capture of ukraine and the support of the russian occupation groups in the destruction of the civil infrastructure of our country. legitimacy in ukraine and before the maidan was such a

conditional concept. i can compare the russian reality and the ukrainian reality. and he will impose all this on a large audience. has almost 3 million subscribers in telegram and almost 500,000 in russian roorub. how many rotten kremlin narratives pour from these channels, you can even imagine. terrible. russia has already said that this is an effigy, no one is with him at all will talk, because it is not clear what. most of the world is listening to us, not that green scarecrow sitting over there. according to the sbu, podolyak was involved in the correction of massive russian missile attacks on the mykolaiv region, and he formed his own networks of informants in the region to guide russian weapons. in april 2023, podolyats were notified of suspicion under five articles at once. among them are calls to violate the territorial integrity of ukraine, propaganda of war and treason. at the beginning of 2024 , the ukrainian court sentenced him to 15 years

deprivation of liberty, for the time being in absentia. we hope that this mouthpiece of kremlin propaganda will soon be conducting its broadcasts only for its cellmates. youth of the zaporizhzhia region. most of them support russia, that russia came to us. all these years, very strong propaganda was carried out at my school, they forced 20-year-old yulia klymenko to wear red t-shirts, speak ukrainian, they literally forced 20-year-old yulia klymenko to speak the state language of ukraine. before the full-scale war, she had a different surname - varzhak, graduated from lyceum number 16, after which she entered the melitopol state pedagogical university named after bohdan khmelnytskyi, won prizes in the regional stage of the all-ukrainian course of student creativity, dedicated to the centenary of the formation of the ukrainian central rada and the proclamation of the ukrainian people's republic on the topic of the motherland - it is not someone and somewhere, i am also

the motherland. now she already has it. another family and new ambitions, political. the youth of zaporizhzhya region invites all regions of the russian federation to visit our beautiful azov region sea. we are waiting for you. when russian troops occupied melitopol, yulia was in her first year of university. the 80-year-old student quickly gave up everything she used to live for during independent ukraine. so, the ukrainian yulia varzhak became a collaborator of yulia klymenko. i am yulia, a resident of melitopol, i thank vladimir vladimirovich putin for his strong-willed decision to start the svo, to liberate donbas, we have been waiting for this for 8 years. klymenko waited and started a career in russian youth organizations, became the leader of the volunteers movement for russia here is a photo where the traitor is delivering humanitarian aid with the inscription: "i will help you, son, russian scumbags." thanks to

diligent work on the whole. the south-molody youth movement congratulates all residents of crimea and sevastopol on the day of reunification with russia. and most recently, klymenko became the head of the regional wing of the so-called young guard of putin's united russia party. now, in fact, she was given complete control over the entire youth movement in melitopol and the region. all the youth of the zaporizhzhia region. with this action, wants to prove to the whole world that melitopol is it russia. on march 27, 2024, our law enforcement agencies announced suspicion against this star of the russian tv show for justifying the armed aggression of the russian federation against ukraine. hopefully, the suspicion will very soon become a court sentence with a long term. and this is our next traitor from mariupol, 30-year-old nikita avyarkin. we celebrate this day with

honor, with pride for that. that we are part of our great and powerful country. until february 24, he managed his own security company, worked as an instructor in the federation of service and sport dog breeding, and was also a member of the public organization iskranast. when mariupol was occupied, he decided that it was time for him to be an obedient dog for his new owners in exchange for a bone. and this bone he eventually got. he assumed the position of the so -called head of the youth affairs department. the policies of the administration of the city of mariupol, the so- called dnr. today we came as a team and vote for the president, for donbas and for victory. he evidently served his masters faithfully, so he soon received another promotion. a young woman became the leader of putin's youth organization in mariupol united russia guard. thanks to our federal leaders, we have the opportunity to organize this event on a grand scale. his main task

from the kremlin in this position. to instill russian peace in children, and one of the main theses in all his speeches is the distortion of the events currently taking place in ukraine, when russia held illegal elections in the temporarily occupied territories of ukraine, avyarkin managed to get a mandate and become a deputy of the mariupol city council from the united russia party . his work is actively covered by the propaganda tv channel mariupol-24. in order to everything was in accordance with the letter of the law, you take ownership, complete everything. documents in 2023, the october district court of dnipro sentenced him in absentia to 10 years in prison for collaborationism. on may 17, 2024 , averkin became a participant in a new criminal proceeding. received suspicion due to the production and distribution of materials that deny the temporary occupation of part of ukraine. this traitor is serving the russians so honestly that soon he may get to serve another article of the criminal

code. it was the collaborators and i program olena kononenko, if you want to talk about the kremlin sellers, write to us at this email address or just on facebook, together we will send all the traitors on the trail of the russian ship. we'll see in a week on spresso. greetings, we are looking for two children who disappeared in temporarily occupied donetsk. one of them is 15-year-old kostya tyzhnavoy. the connection with him was cut off on october 26, 2023, and nothing is known about the boy since then. due to the fact that he disappeared during the occupation, we know little about the circumstances of his disappearance. it is likely that kostya is still temporarily in...