is it possible to go to a red light, a traffic light, or after all, just like in europe, to go only to green and so on, that is, these moments are correct, i understand how these negotiations are taking place, please, mrs. maria, eh, mr. mykola, there will be everything that you mentioned and much more, why, because we have officially opened the negotiations on joining the european union, but this also means that we have officially opened this whole rather complicated process. to a certain extent, one can say a long bureaucratic process, because two such things will happen now the main points, yes, that is, we are fully preparing our negotiating team, we must fully prepare our vision for the negotiations, we must also prepare our society, that everything is already in an inevitable movement towards the european union, it has begun. now

it's completely official. and the second point, we still have to prepare the european union itself, well, the european union itself has to prepare to accept new members into its ranks, and most likely it will not be only ukraine, and believe me, somewhere we have a 50/50 problem that the european union will need a lot to do what in principle we should do, and there is also a very significant part that we will do together, and we must understand that joining the european union is primarily about very specific reforms, very specific standards, very specific commitments, very specific temporary the framework, which will also have to be negotiated literally at every stage, and it will still last the next six months, until we officially open some, i hope, maybe even several chapters and clusters of negotiation, and the last thing that i really want to emphasize is ability. as well as the ability of the ukrainian

civil service to conduct these negotiations, there is a lot of talk about this, and it is not for nothing that the european union insists that the reform of the public administration should continue and continue, because it will be one of the key points of the negotiations. mrs. maria, look, but the algorithm is the same, approximately, i understand that different countries, but approximately the same as with poland, as with estonia, as with... bulgaria, that is, the algorithms, they are all similar, approximately so expensive i understand correctly, absolutely, very similar algorithms, the european union is in no hurry to change this established practice, you can understand why, because all their institutions are imprisoned under certain bureaucratic processes, they always say that they use these rules of their own , yes set. rules and

in principle, in relation to negotiations with any applicant country, there is an absolutely clearly defined procedure, from the negotiating framework of the framework to all stages of the negotiation process. the only point that they insist on and about, what all european politicians and officials emphasize is that ukraine, of course, has a unique path, primarily due to the fact that we are conducting a full-scale. war, and by the way, it was very interesting to observe how the rhetoric of european politicians has changed, they are already constantly talking about the war in europe, that is , there is no such thing as a conflict anymore, there are no such defined terms as russian aggression or the war in ukraine, everyone is talking about war in europe, and everyone says that the future expansion, that is, the entry of new members, he will be very strongly related to this updated security. within the framework of the security agenda

of the european union. mrs. maria, look, there are 11 demands of orbán, because i am not even asking about orbán , but about the ukrainian community, the magyar- ukrainian community. however, when i talk in ukraine, as with you, only with people from uzhgorod or kyiv, with magyars, they say, we write letters, we say, we have no oppression, everything is fine with us. you don't have to listen to this orbán, he doesn't know about the life of hungarians in ukraine, it's absolutely normal, we don't suffer anywhere, in europe, in brussels knows about this or they write letters, because they tell me, we, we inform, we call, we write that everything is fine with us, so i ask you, do these letters arrive, or is the ukrainian post somehow not working well, or the european one , is the belgian post bad.

works, they do not know that the magyars in ukraine do not have any problems, letters and messages, both public and non-public, and... the best result of this communication, exactly what we have already heard, came out in public plane, that mr. orban even is going to a bilateral meeting, it would really be very nice if this bilateral meeting took place somewhere in transcarpathia, so that everything you said about mr. orbán was voiced personally, but it must be understood that mr. orbán is quite an experienced politician, and he has interests orban in the first place, one might even say not only. about the interests of hungary, namely the interests of orbán, and they dominate all our bilateral negotiations, about the 11 demands: the first point, it is necessary to understand very clearly that this is about the process, yes, that is, the things laid down there, which definitely require a lot of time for their

implementation, for their implementation, even for their approval, and this was basically the calculation, further it is necessary to understand that the process... from the negotiations, well, that is, now there is a lot of talk that orban artificially puts sticks in the wheels of european, in ukrainian european integration, this is possible, but let's not forget that our process, accession is still a bilateral process between ukraine and the european union, and no matter how much hungary wants to influence it, how no matter how other countries want it, let's not forget that we don't only with hungary there is an intensive dialogue, and there will be even more such dialogues, we have this bilateral direction. two-way track, and all decisions are made in the european union by the majority, this is both a plus and a minus, but i lead it to the fact that in ukraine there are not only those who put sticks in the wheels, but there are a lot of those who sincerely support cheers and helps us in this european integration path. another

question, agriculture is important, well, it was 10 and 15 years ago, when i talk to specialists, they say that this is the stone stumbling big, because such agricultural opportunities exist in ukraine, and that's all, this tsunami will hit europe, and european farmers are not happy about it, and quotas will begin, some restrictions, no, i won't say a word bans, but how serious is it, the poles are terribly nervous, as far as i understand, because we are direct competitors of the poles, who really fed. europe is intensive enough, now ukrainians are coming and will feed not only apples, and melons, pumpkins and and and and berries and so on and the like, and we have a lot of this, and it is cheap, and it is difficult for me to imagine who can withstand competition with ukraine in

the agricultural sector, please have your opinion, you know, mr. mykola, not only does it compete with us for the price, it must be said that our products compete in terms of quality, and this is... a huge advantage, this, no matter how it is perceived as a risk, we should be proud of it, it is really ukrainian pride, and we should communicate very clearly, constantly about is to remind that our agricultural products, our products food, our organic products, for which there is a huge demand all over the world, they are competitive not only in the european union, they are waiting for us in the same way in other markets of the world, also in rich markets, not only in the european union market. the poles, of course, will raise this issue, but it does not only concern polish farmers, but let's consider this factor as a positive. the single agricultural policy of the european union has long been in need of serious reform and serious discussions. that is exactly

what is expected from the presidency of poland in the council of the european union, which will begin already in january of the following year. dialogue, because it has not only matured, it has even matured, now there is a huge redistribution of funds, for example, by the european union, and everyone understands that the money that was spent on the common agricultural policy and was not always spent effectively, everyone admits this publicly, they should probably be redistributed and, for example, spend more on defense, that is, in any case , changes in... this agricultural sector are inevitable, and here ukraine can actually just show first of all, we consider ourselves a reliable partner, because not only does it depend on poland, our food products, as i have already said, are waiting for them on the shelves of supermarkets in many countries, so we simply can at some point not

only can, but we must sit down, and it is possible to conduct a certain dialogue with the key agricultural countries separately and remove possible reservations. of which there are actually a lot, that is, all this is already overgrown with a large number of myths that have nothing to do with reality, but they appear somewhere here, and one more point... we have reconstruction, yes, which is taking place in parallel with such attempts and setting up ukraine to win this war, it will bring enormous opportunities, because joint investments, including in our agriculture, are interested not only in europe, but also primarily in the united states, they can help to relieve this tension very much. our last question is literally... wait a minute, ms. maria, but there are deep specialists in brussels and deep

specialists in kyiv who can sit down and talk so that brussels understands kyiv and understands that that specialist knows the ins and outs places in the ukrainian agricultural industry, what we can do, what we can't do, where we have high quality, where we have transport and logistics capabilities, and where they are not, and so on and so forth, and in kyiv there are specialists who understand... what europe wants, because if, if it is a blind man and a deaf man, they will not speak for two years, as usual, but 22, this is what i think, there are such experts as you think, mrs. maria, there are such specialists, i not only think, i know, i know that we have a very strong negotiating team, and we have excellent specialists who, by the way, work in ukrainian specialists, they work not only in kyiv, but they also work in brussels, especially in the agricultural sector, there are also experts here, let me say this, the policy of the european

union, it is not only connected with these bureaucratic tendencies, and it is not only about bureaucrats, in the european union, and especially in the agricultural sector, the significant role of the association is very large, and these are specialists, experts, professionals, people from the fields, yes, who in the european union influence european politics 50, 60, 70 and... 100 years old, they know the state of affairs perfectly well to each industry, and this is a completely transparent, current established practice, when the european commission or the european parliament make certain decisions, they consult, so i am not worried about the quality of the negotiations, i am more worried and insist on being clearly defended precisely our national ukrainian interest. thank you very much, patriotism, ms. maria golub, well-known, now we are convinced once again, an expert on european integration at... explained all this, thank you ms. maria, very much, now advertising, then to russia, we, you know,

so, in the opposite direction, let's see what is happening in russia, what is happening in europe, we, mrs. maria told us, and now after the advertisement, mr. oleksandr shulga, doctor of sociological sciences, head of the institute of conflict studies and analysis of russia, will talk about russia , but after advertising. fm: galicia. listen to yours. tingling, numbness or crawling of ants in the limbs arise spontaneously and bother you? a special complex of active substances dolgiit. neuro helps in normalizing the functioning of the nervous system. capsules dollyed antinevro - help for your nervous

system. ask at pharmacies: good day pharmacy and dolgit antineuro capsule pharmacy with a 20% discount. do you suffer from heartburn? i recommend izoto. isoto interacts with the acid in the stomach, which leads to a reduction in heartburn symptoms. isotaa your water if heartburn bothers you. there are discounts, they represent unbreakable discounts on the gel ventilate. 20% in pharmacies plantain, memory and savings. exclusively on the air of our channel. congratulations, friends, politklub is on the air on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week: the war against russia of ukraine, the war in the middle east, the crisis on the border between ukraine and poland, topics that resonate in our society. drone attack on kyiv. and other cities of ukraine, drone attacks on moscow and other cities of russia. analysis of the processes that change

the country and each of us. the country should get the right to start negotiations on joining the eu. vitaly portnikov and guests of the project: we are bored, because there is nothing to fight about, let's invent. they help to understand the present and predict the future. trump's second presidency will be for the world terrible a project for those who care and think. political club. every sunday at 20:10 at espresso. summer is a time of rest and recovery. and i believe that this year we will be able to present a real fairy tale. and a little peace for the children, a world destroyed by war. these are the children of fallen heroes, father or mother, who died at the front while protecting us and you, our country, and they, like no one else, need our

support, because they are the future of our country. our experience has shown that travel helps. children recover faster after a loss, children feel better emotionally, i am asking you to support our project. we are planning to organize two trips for the children of fallen heroes this summer. children will experience bright emotions, they will get to know a new country, a new culture, find new friends, and most importantly, they will receive the help of qualified psychologists. and maybe now this video will be seen by entrepreneurs or... big business owners who will be willing to step in and help, remember that your donations are the key, the key to hope, dreams and support for those who lost a loved one, because their parents went to protect our country. i really liked the trip to austria, i liked the museums we went to every day, it was incredible, and i really

liked how we went to restaurants, i visited the cities of zazbu. this trip affected me quite positively, i became more cheerful, thank you very much for such an incredible trip, it will never be forgotten in my heart. let's together give memories that will warm hearts and help to survive these difficult and scary moments. good health once again, ladies and gentlemen, again mykola veresen and oleksandr shulga, as i promised, doctor of sociological sciences, head of the institute of conflict studies and analysis of russia. good health, mr. oleksandr, congratulations.

listen, russia is generally amenable to analysis, that's what i said, and then i thought, but it's possible to analyze. some irrational, irrational, can it be analyzed? this is actually one of the most powerful myths that the entire russian state has been working on for more than a century. this is exactly what we are facing in the problem of russian-ukrainian understanding the war and its impact on other countries, primarily western countries. this is exactly the myth that you cannot understand russia. we are so mysterious. are so spiritual, and you with your capitalism, rationalism, without spirituality, you cannot understand us, it is not like that, everything can be analyzed, and russia is not a black box, it can be unpacked, laid out and dissected, well, i would argue with you on you know, on the basis of mr. dostoevsky, because when you read dostoevsky, you still understand

that, yes, something can be understood, but far from that's all, but you and i somehow... let's move from philosophy to specifics, i would ask you first of all, i have some cheat sheets here, but first of all i would like to see the dagestan events , i would be very interested in what you would say about these events with arson, with beheadings, with attacks on synagogues, on christian churches, and so on, this, what happened, or this, or whether this is a sign of something, or this... one may not pay attention to this, as well, as always there are terrorists, they are possible in any country, and it is not always some kind of systematic work, it is just i don't like something, i left, i blew something up, if i'm a terrorist, it's definitely in dagestan, what was it, well, in fact , you can't pay attention to it, and it's really an indicator of such serious systemic problems

in russia, at the federal center level. individual subjects of the federation, primarily at the level of the north caucasus, in fact these events set russia back some 24-25 years, in 1999, when the emirate-caucasus was declared there and there were hostilities, and indeed the signature style of the dagestani rebels in that they have always set their primary goal liquidation of the security forces, that is, if there... chechen rebels and their arab, let's say, brothers who came from other countries, they could seize schools and hospitals, we know that. it's precisely dagestanis that's their signature style, it's their attack on checkpoints, on the pps, and in fact we saw it this

time, the absolute majority of those killed are precisely security forces, and so there is an attack on a synagogue, there are again killed security forces that guarded after the events of the fall of the 23rd, and one priest was killed, shot in the head, but the main... the target was the security forces, so this is really the first conclusion, russia is returning to the beginning of the 2000s, in fact what putin promised, let’s look at it, i have put things in order here, these events cross it out, secondly, this is an indicator of the degradation of the security agencies and , well , in fact, their inability to respond to challenges, when there are not some students, liberals, but armed, determined opponents. and thirdly, this is very important, it showed that ideology, intimidation and financial infusions

do not work even on the scale in which it is done in the north caucasus, because those declared as performers were, well , in fact, the local golden youth, who, in fact, could use all these charms of the current regime. money, influence and inheritance, yes, this is the father and uncle, it seems to me, or the grandfather, parts of these partners, i have a blue nephew, in short, but the question is still the same, maybe more precisely, i will ask, you named three factors, which means this attack , but does this attack mean that in the caucasus they exist and are ready to act. some anti-russian forces, some terrorist groups, and you see, i sometimes get the impression that when you say that the weakness of the russian government, i can

agree here, but also the weakness of the russian opposition, armed or not, moscow, leningrad or caucasian, that they just sit and simply never attack, and that is why the russian government lives well both in the caucasus and in in moscow, in st. petersburg and everywhere, because... they have no problems, and when problems sometimes arise, well , they are problems there once every six months, once a year, well, they can be somehow overcome these problems, is society ready caucasian to some opposites, as bright as we are we see now on the tv screen, illuminated by various lights, please, mr. oleksandr, well, when you and i talk about the russian opposition, we should talk, well, if not about... 50 shades of the russian opposition, well, at least with ten, the fact is that girkin, a war criminal, is also a russian opposition, but

not a liberal one, there is not only a liberal opposition, well, the russian opposition that only exists, panamarov and the russian volunteer corps, this is another russian opposition that is not fake , which is trying to really change russia with weapons in hand, and there is this opposition... who said that the anti-putin opposition is only liberal-democratic or anti-patriotic? yes, yes, i am not saying that you, i, this is a rhetorical question, for example, the islamic opposition also, it will not lead to the beautiful russia of the future, it will lead to, for example, emarato caucasus, their long-standing dream, with sharia, with niqabs everywhere , and in fact there is cutting off hands, who said that this... any russian opposition is about democracy, so this opposition really, it has very good starting positions, well, for example, let's give some numbers, in

dagestan there are twice as many schools, secondary schools, mosques, prayer houses and madrassas, 50 times more than technical schools and colleges, 120 times more than universities. therefore , this huge religiosity, of course , leads to the fact that such centers appear there, and they appear en masse, low low education, high religiosity, high unemployment in those on the scale we are talking about in dagestan, and it is very important lack of social... elevators, that is, there is a local nobility and all, although even she, like us we can see, perhaps falling under these serious radical movements, and again, zm, or, as

it is called in russia, wahhabism, it is really very widespread in dagestan and has a very strong such a serious history of about 50 years, because even in in the 1970s in the ussr, it began to gain strength precisely in dagestan, and it was precisely during the 1990s that salafism was the driving force that moved dagestan to fight for independence, and in 1999 it was such a manifestation, therefore.. .the environment is really prepared, that is, you think that the prospect of the separation of dagestan, chechnya, and certain regions of the north caucasus from russia is real, that is, it is not some empty fiction of many experts who say, no, they will secede, and the caucasus will secede in the first place, and other pessimists

they say: they won't be able to survive, they won't, they don't have anything, it will be difficult for them, so they won't secede from russia, well, i don't know how poor dagestan can be with such a caspian sea, with trade with the central asia, with iran, with the same azerbaijan neighbors, i think that they can help themselves there, or whether i am wrong, i want to say about the first part of yours. the question of whether they will disconnect, i am sure that they will definitely try to do it and there will be a third chechen and a real first dagestan one, this will definitely happen as soon as there is, well, let's say, sufficient weakening and overstrain, this is the first sign that we we see this overstrain of the system and degradation of the system, just at these events, it will definitely happen, i don't know if they will succeed, but it will definitely happen

attempt, secondly, this is a very good argument indeed, we hear it all the time, yes, no, they will not disengage, they are the beneficiaries, and they will not survive without russia, well, who said that based on religious fundamentalism, someone will , for example, for example, to think about economic calculations, well, if we are talking about the emirate-caucasus, this is already a victory, we are already living according to the laws of islam and for the law. his prophet, what else do you need? the last question, after all, why putin did not react publicly to what is happening, is dozens people died, well, at least two dozen for sure, of which 15 are representatives of the authorities, i.e. policemen, and the president is silent, why? it is mandatory, absolutely, it is such a mandatory strategy in any, in any similar situations, crocus, for. in

the future, which you and i will soon see, in no way be associated with failure, first of all, the failure of the special services and the failure of the security forces, his face is not there, well , according to their strategy, it should not be in any way associated with such failures, he always kept silent and will do the same in to repeat it in the near future, there is nothing new here. many thanks to oleksandr shulza, doctor of sociological sciences, head of the conflict institute. logy and analysis of russia, who at the end said a beautiful phrase, i liked it so much that we will soon see terrorist attacks again on the territory of the russian federation, nothing pleases me personally more than terrorist attacks on the territory of the russian federation, now there will be news, and then we will talk about america, then we will talk about poland, and then we will talk about many other things, but for now under all conditions we will have news.

the attack of the muscovites of zaporizhzhia, what is currently known about the situation near ternivchea, the armed forces managed to repel the enemy and why the military uniform did not help to escape from ukraine. version. will tell you about everything, everything worth knowing, congratulations, anna yavomelnyk is with you: explosions outside zaporizhzhia, writes the head of the region ivan fedorov, monitoring channels reported on ballistics from russia. in the afternoon, the occupiers attacked one of the critical infrastructure facilities in the zaporizhzhya district, there is damage, no people were injured. russians four were killed, seven more were wounded, in the lyman community, the enemy attacked the village.