uah 3.5 million. remember, each of your donations brings our victory closer, protects our soldiers and destroys our enemies. together we can protect those who protect us. good health, dear ukrainians. we, the fighters of the first assault battalion, the third separate assault brigade, who will defend our native land on the front lines. we urgently need your help. we need radio electronic equipment. fight against the enemy's small bpolas and komikaz drones, we really ask for your help, glory to ukraine, glory to the heroes, join me, i strongly urge you, and now we will talk with oleksandr vilkul, the head of the kryvyi rih defense council, we will discuss one issue, well, which is worth discussing, because there are certain statements that are made, very often misinterpreted, or everyone has something in their own way. interprets, i want to ask mr.

oleksandr about one thing, and of course, let's talk about preparations for the winter period, the autumn-winter period and the security situation in kryvyi rih. oleksandr vilkul, chairman of the kryvyi rih defense council, mr. oleksandr, i congratulate you. yes, good evening. first of all, of course, i will ask about the security situation. how this day and night passed for kryvyi rih, the kryvyi rih community. please. well, today passed, thank god, normally. several martyrs were shot down at night. developed the drone, but completely, thanks to air defense, everything is fine, there were no impressions, now i want you to comment, because again, i am not taking any side here, many people have already commented on your words that now, i might miss a word somewhere, but the bottom line is that now nothing will significantly change the issue of renaming streets in crooked corner, explain what we are talking about, because as far as i understand, it is not what i understand, i just... knowing your work now and your

position, they clearly understand that you are for decommunization, for de-russification, for patriotic education and in general, the return of either authentic names to the soviet ones, or some names dedicated to the names of the newest heroes of ukraine, what prompted your words and for you to explain to people what you meant, please, well, look, everything is very simple, i am in favor all that you are doing now is the consolidation... of society before its invasion in russian, in front of the enemy, and against everything that prevents this, that is, in kryvyi rih , all the streets that had some russian names there have been renamed, there moskovskaya, volgogradskaya or any other, but i believe that the renaming of streets that bear er , the names of the people of kryvyi rih, heroes of the second world war or the afghan war. war, because we do not

glorify the afghan war, we pay tribute to the memory of those citizens of kryvyi rih who, uh , fulfilled their oath and behaved really like heroes, that is, i believe that this issue is definitely not at the time, definitely not at the time, it's definitely not will improve the consolidation of society, well , they renamed the streets there, which were named after the heroes of kryvyi rih, the underground, yes, who fought with the nazis. occupiers, and what were they supposed to do, they were supposed to go and serve the nazis, yes, and reduce, to carry out their plan to reduce the ukrainians of the untermanche, yes, as they called it, that is , they are heroes of older generations, older generations, so i believe that this definitely does not affect the consolidation of society, i would not be involved in this, there is no ideological background or anything. on the other hand, i

i believe that we do everything that consolidates society, everything that does not consolidate, and all issues are debatable, these issues are not timely and we do not need to deal with them. that's all, thank you, it was important for me to hear you, or to give you the opportunity to state my position, i will not ask additional questions, again, comments, i agree with many things, but i believe that there will be a time when there will be a victory and it will be possible to... also name streets, alleys, squares, some other, perhaps cultural buildings, with the names of the heroes of this liberation war, against the enemy, we have named, we have already named more than 60, names, names, names, heroes, i know what it means that other heroes must be abolished, yes, fine, thank you, here i am saying, here it was important to just hear your comment i will not continue this

discussion, because there is actually no room for discussion here, this is your opinion and your position, i want to ask about preparations, well, first of all... the current state of energy in ukraine, in principle, the last week plus- minus there is no turning off the lights, but except for those districts, regions of the community that are in the front-line zone, where the enemy is destroying networks where, let's say , there is no light at all, it has been there for months, but what is the situation now with the crooked horn, well, and also the question of preparing for the autumn-winter period in view of the opportunities that are available now, because we know very well that the blows can be , you can’t guess here, as they say, but is this work ongoing, because in many cities of ukraine , work continues on preparations precisely in order to survive and provide heat and electricity to the city, the community, even after enemy strikes, please, now the situation is stable,

it's been a week or maybe two weeks since the temperature dropped a little, now it's 30°, but it 's no longer 45, as it was, now the situation with energy... has improved, but we are preparing for a very difficult winter, because there are forecasts, well , the forecasts are not very good and regarding the sub-zero temperature and regarding, you all have seen the official statements of the energy experts, yes, how many, how many hours will there be light in winter, so we, well , we are going in different directions, we are opening additional points of unbreakability, we had them 213, now we open another 69 there with everything that you also need a generator. and with heat guns, outdated and so on, most of the infrastructure, we are doing everything we can to transfer to generators, well, yes, hospitals 100%, yes, the first four increases in water supply, boiler houses, which are possible, these are also generators,

because the part where there is 220, it is possible there, where it was asked from the people, there are no such generators here, but we put on pumping groups there in order to pump the water so that the pipes do not burst. also, we are already installing, well, of course, it is not all 700 thousand city, but we will partially close the issue, cogeneration plants are also being installed at one of the largest boiler plants, i will not say which one, well, on television, we are also installing mini boiler plants, that is , the preparation is quite large and quite thorough, how to survive in the absence stable electricity supply, yes. the issue of solar panels, let's say how relevant it can be in winter, yes, please, by the way, the issue of solar panels is also there, and this is one of the points that we implement, we, this year, well,

so far the first in ukraine, we installed solar panels in several hospitals, plus kindergartens there, we do everything, although, well, it is clear that it will be more effective in the summer, than... in the winter, this is a separate block, we deal with it , but i say once again that the 700-year-old city on solar panels, well, it definitely won’t last in the winter, it’s a complex project, somewhere it’s ordinary generators, somewhere it’s po-generation, somewhere solar panels, uh, well, we’re implementing a complex program, it’s better that way to say, here is one of the regions, i'm just afraid now, i think it's about the kharkiv region or about zaporizhzhia, i'm just afraid to lie now, so i'll say that this is one of the regions, well, i... not far from dnipropetrovsk, if zaporizhia, then it borders, of course, but i'm not sure that zaporizhzhia, the point is not that, but increased expenses a place in local budgets for one billion 600 million, it's just like a number, and dnipropetrovsk region, especially kryvyi rih, is an industrial region, and today we will

talk, my colleague oleksandr morchuka will talk about the shortage and even more shortage in the future of possible workers in ukraine, for obvious reasons, that is, the mobilization from those somewhere abroad, but what is the current situation in your community with the availability of workers at key enterprises that are city-forming, in fact, budget-forming, and is it still possible to book a certain number of people from what you know so that enterprises taxes also worked, which is important, because we know what they are talking about, the deputies told us before they went on vacation, that in september there may be a lack of funds for the most important thing. now it is to finance the army, so it is very important to understand what the situation is in those regions, in particular kryvyi rih, where there are large industrial companies, large industrial businesses, please look, in terms of jobs, there are a lot of vacancies, well

, there at arcelormittal, for example, now there are 1,500 vacancies at the metallurgical enterprise, this is literally yesterday i had a conversation with the director, there are 350 repair jobs at the kvadokanali mission, especially repair jobs... there is even a problem with the cashiers there in the atb stores, so to speak, that is , there are a lot of vacancies in kryvyi rih, i believe that there are 2,000. well, at least , that you can tomorrow, well to go to work, that is, somewhere it is closed, somewhere it is closed due to immigrants, somewhere it is closed due to retraining, for example, to metallurgical enterprises, now they are willing to recruit women, but there is a problem, a big problem, in relation to the work of enterprises, enterprises work somewhere on on average, at 50 power, at 100%, well, they do not work. for obvious reasons regarding the e -budget, the e-budget this year is not very

big, but you also know that we also have personal income tax for police rescuers and military personnel of the central budget, it was somewhere around 16% of our budget, but this budget, which is planned for this year, we implement, we implement, and i am sure that we will implement the plan, so that up there... there will be a failure of such it won’t be , uh, well, by the way, you mentioned such rather large numbers, and it is clear that maybe in your conversation, you talked about a conversation with the director of arsrol, and is it being considered just interestingly, maybe such issues are already being considered, the involvement of specialists from abroad, i am not talking now about zachaidna europe, but in any case, ukraine has...

upon arriving in ukraine, their jobs will be taken by workers and, if they are mobilized, because these are taxes, because please, let's say, let's say frankly, we have 55 km to lbz the line of battle, none of the foreigners will go to the crooked river, until the end of the war, this model, maybe it will be effective. somewhere in lviv, yes or there in kyiv, but in kryvyi rih, it’s fantastic, it’s unrealistic, and 55 km, and i’m here, you know, it’s time to ask about the construction of fortification, but as soon as i ask about the construction of the fortification, here in the chat on youtube they start writing that we are surrendering everything to the enemy, so i will not ask, i am convinced that the necessary work is being carried out and in any case the enemy will not succeed in... his paw on the wonderful the city of kryvyi rih, i thank you very much, well, if you want, you can say something about the fact that

the works are actually ongoing, because you know, so that people don't think that someone is watching, please watch, we're on it, we're on it we understand, in the 22nd year, the war was very close to us, the nearest 200 m from the sign kryvyi rih, and then kryvyi rih and kherson oblast were already liberated, so we understand very well what needs to be done and how it needs to be done, in more detail, you are right, probably this is not necessary. to say, thank you very much, thank you for your comments, thank you for your work, first of all oleksandr vilkul, the head of the kryvyi rih defense council, was in touch with us, you know, he just said this phrase that ukrainian men are at the front and there is nothing wrong , that they could be replaced by men of another nationality, in fact this is bad, because in ukraine they have to work, well, somehow specialists exactly, and the ukrainians, it is, but, as people's deputy natalukha said, the war is, in principle, yearly. is fair, and when there are certain circumstances that we have now, both mobilization and people

are needed, moreover, specialists are very often needed at the front, narrow-profile, and if it were possible to attract foreigners to work, it is actually cool, because these are taxes in budget, now, by the way, we will talk about it with oleksandr morchyvko, but i read that even in poland, due to the reduction of migration from ukraine to poland of ukrainians, in poland there are problems with... working hands and heads, this is a serious problem, and we need to keep these people in ourselves, volodymyr tsybulko, with us, political commentator, people's deputy of ukraine of the fourth convocation, poet and blogger, youtube blogger, congratulations, mr. volodymyr, congratulations, glory of ukraine, glory to the heroes , well, i would like to continue this topic, but let's not talk about working hands and the economy, but by the way, we planned, let's... you know how i will ask you now about this, and what do you see, what do you see

logical, political, first of all not, because the economy is a consequence of politics in any case, the political steps of the government, well , maybe we have a change of government, the mobilization continues and will continue, people, especially some technical professions, narrow-profile specialists will still be taken to the front, that is clear, there will be new types of weapons, yes... more something, something else, well, as long as the war lasts, it will continue, everyone understands it, the question of how to come up with a way to replace people and provide working hands, not everything can be done by women there, but now we... in a crooked way only one company has 1,500 vacancies, 2,000 vacancies all over the city, what should be the solution here, or is there none now, but we just have to pull with the forces that are available? first of all, there is only one way: maximum robotization of production, maximum robotization, but

high-class specialists are needed to service the robots of robotic systems, and here we simply do not... because high-class specialists are needed now, the armed forces need them, so it is necessary to come up with some, let's say technological chains, when in ukraine there were only growing stages, that is, or large-nodal large-nodal assembly of the final product, or maximally robotic production lines, then it is possible to ensure a decent level of production with a smaller number of working... hands, secondly, it is necessary to stimulate the return of ukrainians home, it is necessary, well, the only mechanism here is, firstly, simplification conducting business, secondly, stimulating all kinds of taxes. instead, our government will come up with the opposite,

demoralizing taxes, which are supposedly... well , designed to solve, uh, these huge cash gaps that happened in the budget in the last months, but they warned the authorities about this, the authorities dragged it to the last, now they want to put everything on the shoulders of a simple ukrainian, well , really, i remember, i have oleg penzin and dliygachandrii on the air, well, they said that it would be like said kuchma. already was, that is, well, well, this is just mathematics, this, these are laws, there are laws of economics, there are laws of physics, there are laws of nature, just ordinary, and you, no matter how you say that i will jump from 15- th floor and fly, without special equipment, you will fall down, because there is a law of gravity, it works, that's all,

i.e., it is all woven from regularity, economy is very simple, you increase taxes. you have an increase in the cost of products, the cost of products increases to such an extent that people lose the opportunity to buy them, then it is necessary to raise them, well, in fact, in a circle, this is what it is called, the inflationary vertical is this carousel, the inflationary carousel and when it is launched, then, well, even. that the authorities came up with this nonsense with the introduction of excise taxes according to the european circular about the e-e green transition. first of all, we are not a country of the european union, the cabinet pushed us in the form of, well, trying to patch it up in the budget, they slipped us a european circular about

increasing excise taxes, er, this is stimulating an increase in excise taxes. with the aim of transitioning to green, well, giving up fossil electricity, from fossil energy, from coal, stimulating excise taxes for the purpose of transitioning to green, to green energy, what do we have, instead of stimulating at least, well, households to block now there is a shortage of electricity by some domestic... people will be on home generators, something will save themselves, it will even make it more expensive, i am not talking about the load on enterprises, because they have completely different prices for electricity, and now fuel is also

more expensive, and this will all lead to what if you compare two liters of milk in ukraine and poland, for example, it's just twice as much, 2.5 times more expensive milk in us than in poland, i'm not even talking about polish-made cheeses on ukrainian counters, you can see right away that they cost 30% cheaper , than ukrainian production, and in terms of quality, maybe in terms of quality it can be better from ukrainians, you know, it is, well, you and i for sure, mortgaged for years. nine, when the accident occurred at the chornobyl nuclear power plant, the fourth power unit, there was also an experiment, but when the nuclear protection there did not work and everything fell below pe'. at a certain voltage level, an explosion occurred, that is , it is just like there were nuclear laws, also physical laws, it can also happen here, when certain things move in a certain

direction, sooner or later an explosion occurs, that is this should be prevented, we hope that it will be possible to prevent it, maybe there will be new members of the government, although, to be honest, i have the opinion that it would be very good to really gather such a brain staff, a ukrainian brain staff, wherever they would sit. really smart people and just in the online mode offered a bunch of ideas and solutions on how to get out of this or that situation, because the calls are silent and very often it can be that it can be late, here you have to act quickly, i just want, we, maybe we'll come back to that now, because it affects us directly, our lives and our pockets, we definitely do not want to disperse treason here, we do not want everything, as they say, to disappear, we want to get out of it all, and come to victory, and go through this difficult period, which... definitely are and may be further complicated, but i still want to briefly return to this topic of russian oppositionists, i don’t even know whether

to call them oppositionists or what to call them judging by what they declare, there pivovarov, yashin and karamurza, well, that's it pivovarov and yashin, ilya yashin and andriy pivovarov, who were exchanged there for putin's murderers and rapists, well, criminals, in a word, gave an interview to the reuters publication and they talked about... that it's not putin, you are putin who is to blame for the war, sanctions against ordinary russians should either be lifted or glorified, because they are innocent, it is not ordinary people who want this war and in general, let's review all this somehow, explain why these people say this in russia, is it really putin's narrative, or are they so simple they are afraid that putin will get them there as well they have to do what has to be done, are they sincere... in that, no, please, it's not a conviction at all, it's part of the contract, that is, they were released from prison, on

bond, well, start their stay with certain narratives, i.e. now, why putin released them, because putin has such a sad picture, there is pressure from all sides and he would like to freeze some for a certain moment. war, and he even goes to such exchanges, but in order to promote precisely the thoughts that here is a separate people, separately, political power, separate the opposition, the opposition wants to take away, to me their style of behavior is very similar to the style of behavior of the exchanged soviet dissidents who were sent to the west. and arranged among themselves such a menace that essentially led to the impossibility of using any of these dissidents for promising political

work. i believe that from the very first statements, all the characters showed that they have no prospects in the west, but they also have no prospects in russia. they cannot be a tool for achieving any goals of a civilized community. in my opinion, sweet as a certain, like a certain yeast, to disturb, er, the solidarity of the civilized world. well, but i think that, well, again, i am always glad when people, well, even more so, definitely unjustly convicted, neither yashin, nor pivovarov, nor karamurza, definitely did not deserve to be imprisoned there with those huge terms that they got, well, therefore, if people are free, thank god, because sitting in prison, especially in putin's prison without guilt, is absolutely... an anti-human story, and i am glad that they are free. the second question, to me it seems that it is so much, well, it’s not nimtsov, it’s not navalny, it’s so much for europe, for

a world in which 100 events change every day, and with all due respect to people, minor characters that they don’t hold for long, it seems to me, the european audience with these stories about how let's lift the sanctions, because people are innocent, it's not people who make cabs at factories, it's not people who blink tanks, it's our work in russia, it's all putin... nights non-stop 24x7, please, well, first of all, it passed because of the war no less than 2 million russians, no less than 2 million russians, and whether putin alone or not, i am not talking about the number of people who, well, not people, more precisely, what four million work in the military-industrial complex of the russian federation, i'm not talking about... the fact that up to 6 million security forces, so-called, are in the orbit of the russian federation. the police, the national guard, the armed forces, the f.sb, the prisons, well, in general, this is

an incredible huge amount of manpower that is all soaked in hatred for the civilized world, and well, again, i think that this topic, it will just go down, in a lot of things are happening in the world, so that certain characters from russia are not of the first political magnitude, so that they are attracted to themselves. the attention of a civilized person, but, but now, i say, now so many things attract people's attention that, well, here we are fighting to keep attention, we have the biggest war in the world since the second world war, so we are trying to keep this attention , because they look at something differently every time there, whether there will be an attack by iran or not, but i know, very briefly, i would like to ask you how politically the parliament, which will leave the president and the government,

maybe the newly created one? it is possible for this government, with certain changes, to retain people politically and communicatively, but yesterday there was a statement from the ministry of education that please do not wait for a teacher salary increase, because there is no money, i am here again, this is just a fact, social security is frozen, that's all it is frozen, taxes are rising, we have to pay for the war, and we have to, but everyone, and not think up every time how to still steal at the tender, everyone, when this financial burden on families will be serious. with him, as politically with people need to talk and how to act so that we can get through this difficult period, maybe this is the last difficult period of this war, maybe we will overpower putin, but how to act correctly, please, well, i think that the government has achieved its goal, because the encapsulation people, closing in on themselves at such a family level happens at an incredible speed, firstly, the circumstances with... it seems

so, people can express their opinion mainly in social networks, thank god that there is still a parliament and there is some representative office where the opposition can express the real sentiments of the citizens, but the fact that in many regions life is becoming unbearable and they will explode is already a fact, it's just that the ccc sometimes acts as a lightning rod, but in general... i think that since the middle of september, the situation from power will lose controllability, certain. the power, the power has led, in general, to a certain, well, defragmentation of the single, single state field, and the lawlessness that is also cultivated by the robber who arranges zelensky's closest entourage, to mention at least the robbery at

the memorial tender. the cemetery, that is they, they steal from the living, they steal from the dead, they steal from children, they steal, well, what are soldiers dripping on, that’s all or it should stop immediately and zelensky’s leadership role should be manifested in this , although i don’t believe that that he is any kind of leader at all and that he has something, let's not believe it, and i will believe it, but there will be and no, i just really believe that... who believes that someone has this leadership role to take on, because you know, well, the last story you told about tenders, that tender for 2.9 million was canceled, well, as they say, it didn’t work out, well, they noticed, they noticed, now they came up with a tender for 14 million for consultation and technical supervision for the reconstruction of okhmadit, and that it was offered by the company that built okhmadit, which still needs consultation and technical supervision,

if they were building it and offered one of... all on 14 million, let's announce a tender for technical supervision consultation, it was canceled, that is, it just doesn't go to your head, you put it in the door, it climbs through the window, well, well, where is the level of this arrogance, we literally have 20 seconds, that's it, mr. vasyl , according to the ahmadiyit at least, well, the donors got mad, raised a cry, and po the memorial cemetery of cabins does not make any decisions, well, we must press, we must press, mr. volodymyr, in any case, this is our role and our mission. while we are here, and we can do it, thank you very much for joining, thank you for your comments, volodymyr tsibulko was with us, political commentator, people's deputy of ukraine of the fourth convocation, poet, blogger and youtube blogger, thank you very much to him, well, literally news in a moment, big ether, good evening, we are from ukraine.