to the fact that they also, of course, have means of countering drones, and russia has always been known in principle, well, for powerful means of electronic warfare, but the situation on our side is leveling off, i would say, recently the situation is leveling off, well yes, we are also currently collecting for rap, you see, we also have such a collection, which is for both drones and for rap, so... in this regard , we also try to help as much as we can, and tell me in general, how do you assess the ratio our such drones to theirs, well, that is, after all, it is also now parity or not parity, how is it from your side? again, i can only say from my experience from the area where i am, it is close to parity, yes. it is clear, well, this, this, i

would say so, means that it has become a little more difficult for us than it was before, because before this parity still did not exist, yes, yes, yes, it is clear, tell me, here i am now a bit of a question, well, since you're in this direction, i think that somehow, well, you're probably also somehow discussing this among yourselves, what do you think... what allowed the russians to break through near novohorodivka so quickly, and so unexpectedly quickly, yet we thought that they would stay there longer, do you have any versions of your own regarding this, any explanation of your own? i have versions, but i don't think it 's worth expressing them live now, let's say. so he will say, then yes, could there be

any objective to this, no not subjective there, which are connected with some certain moments, but objective, well, they use something there a lot, and it really it was difficult because there were still as far as i understand, equipped positions, it is easier to fight in equipped positions than in some other places where from the very beginning it was not very well equipped, objective reasons. they were also like that, and i will say it even happened anyway , and well, there is still a certain, let’s say, not hope, but a calculation that what will happen after all, the enemy forces will be distracted to put out the fire at home, and be distracted they will also be from the pokrovsky direction, where exactly... the russians are advancing

the fastest, so, well, for now, unfortunately, we are not we are observing a massive, so to speak, rebasing and transfer of units from the direction of the russian federation to the kursk oblast, belgorod oblast, and so on. well, unfortunately, yes, so far we are talking about the fact that there are simply too many of them. ok, unfortunately, our time has run out, we would like to talk even more, thank you very much for joining us to... it was a goose fighter, an aerial scout of the second battalion of the 68th separate hunting brigade from the pokrovsky direction, and we will meet with you in a week, and you stay with the espresso tv channel. see this week in the judicial control program with tetyana shustrova. the qualification of the assessment is in jeopardy. why the grand chamber of the supreme court? has changed

its own practice, the case clearly shows that there are problems with the supreme court, and which of the unscrupulous can remain in office, a number of judges who are there can be quite sensitive, important for the judicial mafia. congratulations, judicial control is on the air. institutional rebooting and personnel renewal of the judiciary based on the norms of professional ethics and integrity is the basis of the judicial reform, which is now held in ukraine. its successful implementation is the main requirement for our further path to the eu. however, today we will talk about how successful the transformation is and whether the moral and professional qualities of justice officials meet high standards. in the framework of the judicial reform in ukraine, a lot of attention is paid to the personnel issue. in order to overcome corruption among judges and increase the trust of citizens, every... resident

of themis must pass a qualification assessment. this applies to new job candidates, even acting judges. a body specially created for this purpose, the higher qualification commission, conducts evaluations and recognizes representatives. appropriate positions, or unworthy to work in the judicial system. however, the qualitative evaluation of the servants of themis was under threat. the grand chamber of the supreme court passed a decision that can significantly affect the system's cleaning and the course of judicial reform as a whole. it is about the case of the judge of the commercial court of the kharkiv region vitaliy usatoy, who appealed the procedure of his qualification assessment. he received a negative opinion from the public integrity council. why? conclusion, the beginning is , of course, as is usually the case with property, but he had valuable property, which was a question of declaration, the question of where the money came from, in particular to him and his wife, the second - it was, he received a prize weapon from minister avakov,

e- eh, and the state administrative court submitted a conclusion about this, this conclusion got to the commission, despite the conclusion that the mustache did not meet the criteria of integrity and professional ethics, a panel of... three members of the previous composition the supreme court of appeals decided that the judge is fit for the position. this decision was preliminary and was supposed to enter into force after consideration by the plenary composition of the vcks, that is, by its 11 members. and that was exactly what usato didn't like. he denied the next review, believing that the decision of the troika about his suitability for the position is quite enough. judge usatiy, he indicated that in his opinion, in fact, he... has already been recognized as virtuous, of course, for judges , it would always be desirable that when three of my colleagues recognized them as suitable, then they should continue to work that way, and actually the practice , reading of the law, its interpretation was such that everyone always expected this plenary

composition, that 11 people would give their opinion. vitaly usati went to court and the country's highest judicial body supported his position. in the center of anti-corruption. emphasize that the grand chamber of the supreme court broke its own practice and manipulated the law, because the procedure for evaluating judges with negative conclusions of the supreme court has been working in the plenary for almost eight years, it was followed by both the previous and the current supreme court of appeals, the grand chamber also recognized this, in particular in the decision regarding the ex-judge of the solomyan district court of kyiv, maria zelinska, and the judge of the economic court of the kyiv region, pavlo gorbasenko. we counted at least. five decisions of the grand chamber of the supreme court, which earlier in the same grand chamber indicated a completely different position, they indicated that it is really necessary for such a decision to be supported by the entire plenary composition

of the highest qualification commission of judges, and the decision of the panel itself is not enough. the decision of the grand chamber of the supreme court contains a number of dangers for... judicial reform. by according to preliminary estimates, it can help about 180 judges who have already received negative conclusions from the public integrity council to remain in their positions. this decision of the grand chamber helps these, specifically 180 people to avoid this procedure now, and in fact they already automatically remain evaluated, if, in fact, this practice and this decision of the grand chamber are higher. the qualification commission and the vrp will now take it as a basis and say that we must apply this decision to all these judges, which means that these people automatically are considered to have passed the qualification assessment and everything is fine with them, this is a guarantee of their future. in the professional community

, the decision of the grand chamber is called harmful, because the list of unscrupulous judges who will now be able to avoid evaluation includes dozens of odious names. this is, in particular, natalia prytul. the judge of the shevchenkiv district court of the city of kyiv, the judge of the maidan, volodymyr serdynskyi, the judge of the brovarsky district court of the kyiv region, was exposed to nabu for a $400 bribe. viktoriya dzharty, economic judge court of kyiv, loves luxury items and owns luxury real estate. oleksandr lutsenko, judge of the obolon district court of the city of kyiv, judge of the maidan. serhii chvankin, head of the kyiv district court of odessa, his family's firm owns luxury apartments in maya. pavlo gorbasenko, the head of the commercial court of the kyiv region, owns elite real estate, sky-high fortunes and practices fictitious divorces, passed illegal decisions that had signs of raiding. judges dmytro kostenko and andriy fedorchuk, district judge administrative court of the city of kyiv. fedorchuk

is particularly known for canceling the nationalization of a private bank and suspending the renaming of the uoc of the moscow patriarchate. it is the same, for example, judge dzyuba, regarding which there is. the information that the wife has russian citizenship, this is judge otrosh, who allowed herself to say at the meeting of the quali commission that these are actually ukrainian bodies, not you. in the fact that they did not ensure the inviolability of the borders in crimea, which has millions, well , millions of unexplained property and so on, all these judges with such a position will be able to avoid completion of the qualification assessment and keep their positions to themselves. there is no doubt in the anti-corruption center that by making a decision in the case of judge usatoy, the grand chamber played along with the entire so-called judicial mafia. in 2000, the judge-reporter in this case, oleg kryvenda, himself received the opinion of the state administrative court about non-compliance with the criteria of integrity and professional ethics, however, this

did not prevent him from receiving a positive decision of the supreme administrative court. mr. krivenda also received a negative opinion of the public integrity council, ah, to which there were also a number of questions regarding the origin of his property and assets, and of course, it is clear that with such an approach, the presiding judge in the case... must, let's say, well, at the very least, is biased according to this category of case, and therefore we can be talking about a certain kind of such conflict of interest, where the judge, being dissatisfied with his own conclusion of the public integrity council, is ready to play along and help. to other judges who have the same problem. the grand chamber of the supreme court tried

to explain its decision, but did not do so very well convincingly. in particular, the judges indicated that they are changing the practice because the legislator changed the law, and the vkk - its own regulation. such reasoning is a manipulation by the grand chamber, insists the anti -corruption center. after all, in this way, with each new change in the law, decisions made in the old edition will have to be recognized as illegal. unfortunately, for. we see the result of this, when, in particular, the speaker in the case of lusato, who had a negative conclusion of the state administrative court, adopts, well, writes a decision, the grand chamber accordingly approves, agrees, renders it, and we see a situation where they turn their position by 180°, at the same time very unreasonably and do not meet their own criteria, which were previously established when it is possible to change the position, because all the previous decisions were completely different in similar situations. currently

, about 1,800 ukrainian judges have to pass the evaluation qualifications, including representatives of the odious oask and pechersk district courts of kyiv. according to the anti-corruption center, certain questionable members of the supreme council of justice and the supreme court of justice may try to interpret the decisions of the supreme court yes, in order not only to help the unscrupulous servants of themis, but also to undermine the future procedures of the evaluation quals. it is very important , in fact, that these two institutions continue the qualification assessment in the same order as it was before, and that the decision in the case of judge usatovoy be considered an individual decision, specifically in this case, which should not be applied to absolutely all cases, but come on it is clear that there are also members in these institutions who believe that this is the solution. but apply to the rest of the judges, so here there will be a kind of struggle, and what will be

the result and what will be the consequence, in fact, it is difficult to predict at the moment, the precedent set by the grand chamber in terms of a drastic and groundless change in its own practice indicates that there may be other decisions of the supreme court ahead, which in as a result , they simply bury judicial reform, take over the center of anti-corruption, and therefore cleaning the supreme court and restoring trust in it should... become an urgent issue for society, because in recent years the supreme court has been distinguished by numerous dubious practices and dishonesty of its individual representatives. in general, i consider this a signal that both the supreme court and the grand chamber, in principle, need to be cleaned, on the contrary, because if such an approach to work becomes systematic, then in the future it will be possible to make such strange decisions, depart from practice and... to change the law in any way, because the great chamber actually has a lot of

resources and opportunities for this. we hope that individual members of the supreme judicial council and the supreme council of justice will be able to master the desire to play along with the so-called judicial mafia and not will begin to automatically apply the decisions of the grand chamber to all judges with negative conclusions of the grand chamber, giving them the opportunity to retain their positions. be that as it may, this will be a real test for both institutions. on integrity and checking the ability to work impartially. and for today i have everything, it was judicial control and i, tetyana shustrova. if you know the facts of corruption in the judicial system, or you want to report an unscrupulous judge who makes illegal decisions, write to me on facebook or to the e-mail address you see on the screen. it's all good, we'll meet in exactly one week. greetings,

dear tv viewers, today we have a conversation that is worth hearing, on the tv channel we will talk with the head of the ukrainian greek catholic church, vladyka svyatoslav. i congratulate you. glory to jesus christ. glory forever. independence day, plus the third year of the full-scale invasion of the russian federation. if at the beginning of the invasion there was a tendency for people to run to god, that is understandable. understandable things, many people came, some were converted, came from with prayers, came with requests, now there is such a trend that somewhere people either do not come as often, or pray less, or maybe someone loses hope, and are there any, do you observe something similar, if we talk about your church , or maybe in other churches, having, having communication with your

brothers and sisters in the faith, and how to explain it, or how to keep the patience and hope that should be present for such a difficult situation that exists today. well, we, as pastors, keep our finger on the pulse of, uh, our people, really, or else comparison, we listen carefully to the heartbeat of our people, and i can say that it is really the beginning of this full-scale invasion. became a great upheaval for everyone, we have all changed radically, although the war has been going on for more than 10 years, but perhaps so personally this calamity touched everyone, er, every ukrainian, every citizen of ukraine, only with that full-scale invasion, and i do not

observe any, let's say so . many people, for example, from other fields of human knowledge, doctors, psychologists, noted that when the war began, all human relationships were zeroed out, a person's relationship with himself... himself, with his personal life, relationships between people, even relationships with those closest to him people, the attitude towards the state, towards the church, all this is in a state of rethinking, including when a person is looking for god, or has already had

a certain spiritual, religious experience, war. sharpened a person's search for meaning, a person asks himself, why did this happen to me, god, where are you there are when we are killed, how to choose the right path, landmarks during such great disorientation, and all this, let's say, pushes a person to look for these er these... answers to such very difficult questions, and we all understand that no person on cannot answer these questions, the answer can only be given by the one in whose hands lies the fate of man and the whole world, eh, and man, even a non-believer, he is looking, looking for those eternal values ​​without which

his life has no meaning, and obviously, that reevaluating... all his spiritual, moral guidelines, a person in one way or another gets closer to god and to the church. i want to tell you that we have experience that certain of our parishes, in particular in central, eastern, southern ukraine, have changed by 100%, but there are such communities where 100% of people were evacuated, but came. new ones this year, for example, all our simple, pilgrimages that we had, we could not organize them. but to carry out, because we live in conditions of martial law, but everyone was very crowded, people are looking, people,

people are thirsty for god, and that christian community, which feeds people with real spiritual food, it enjoys today huge popularity, so i can say that today the ukrainian people are in a state of war against... some kind of special spiritual conversion survives, then that thirst for god is especially acute, and all our churches are full, and there is not a single priest who feels unemployed, we all really work at the limit of our strength and capabilities, but we serve the lord god and our ukrainian people with great joy, if in the christian sense, at least in the evangelical sense, what is the freedom that christ gives, christians

understand, and independence, spiritual freedom, as where the spirit of the lord is, there is freedom, jesus said that i give you freedom, see that, well, and there further, the truth, that your freedom is not an excuse to please your flesh, but the essence of that freedom, the independence that... the ukrainian state is marked by political, cultural, spiritual, however you would characterize it, we are independent from what, and how, as they say, this independence relays us, how to explain it, well, let me use take this opportunity to congratulate all our listeners on independence day of ukraine, this day is personal today. a holiday for every ukrainian, every ukrainian family, because we feel that our lives directly depend on whether we will have a free, constitutional, independent state, the question

of our independence, our freedom, it is a question of life and death for the entire nation, that is why it there is a personal holiday, i remember when we first got this independence. in the 91st year in all our churches spontaneously on august 24 it was a spiritual almost religious holiday, i remember how in those first years of independence, that day people put everything aside and the first thing they did that day was go to church to pray, it was something very spontaneous. movement, this independence, first of all, had a spiritual meaning, and here there are several dimensions of this spiritual meaning of our state

independence: first, we all understood that ukraine's independence is a gift from god. at that time, we saw how at the dawn, let's say, when this independence was just, just, just... it was shown like the sun rising from the horizon, the ukrainian greek-catholic church came out of the underground, which became, as it were, this stone that hit those clay feet of that soviet colossus, it simply crumbled, we understood that independence, our state is a gift from god, a gift, like god's answer to our eyes. the summer competitions of our people, which we call today national liberation, the crown of these competitions was the martyrdom of the ukrainian greek catholic church, in particular

during the communist regime, for which the people thanked, but this gift had to be kept, we all saw that this state , which was born after the collapse of the soviet... of the union, it is still a post-soviet state, that freedom is a multi-meaning concept, it has not only some legal or political meaning, but first of all a moral one. uh, in christian philosophy and theology, we have always been used to talking about freedom in this double sense: freedom from... and freedom for, so when we talk about our national freedom, this is how we talk about the independence of the beginning,

this is freedom from... from enslavement, freedom from those neo-colonial encroachments of moscow, which today especially manifested themselves in all their bloodlust during this full-scale invasion, but it is also freedom for, this freedom still needs to be properly used, we as christians, many times before... it was proved that freedom is the ability, the opportunity to do good. if we use this opportunity, the opportunity to choose good for evil, then we can easily lose this gift of freedom. therefore, let's say, this period, which we call

the young, independent ukrainian state. in the 1990s, the way of transition of visas from post-soviet ukraine to real ukraine opened before us democratic state, and this period was very difficult, marked by several revolutions, when the people did not want to lose their independence, but took responsibility for their freedom. true freedom is always associated with responsibility, and here it seemed that we all really want to use the fruits of that independence, but not everyone is ready to take responsibility for it, and here i think that the role of the church and churches in this is very important during the process of transformation of ukraine, er, in particular, our church immediately ... began

to educate its people, education to dignity and freedom, to responsibility for one's country, i recall the words of my predecessor, blessed lubomir, in the first days of the orange revolution, because some in power said that a crowd had come to the squares, otherwise lubomir said: "no, it's not a crowd, it's a response ". responsible citizens who not only exercised their free and free democratic choice by coming to vote, these are citizens who are ready to defend their vote, i remember his speech on the second maidan of dignity, and when, oh when did this event happen, which we will call the revolution of dignity, well, this

from... responsibility for dignity, it manifested itself at an even higher level than during the orange revolution, it is obvious that educating citizens to realize their dignity is already a revolution, therefore this process of transformation of ukraine from post-soviet state, to a free democratic state, as construction. a society that is not only free from, but free for, that process is still going on, i think that the er war that we 're going through today is another stage of that process, but i have the feeling that all those previous years of building an independent ukraine were

just preparation. to the exam, the real exam, unfortunately, was this terrible war, and watching how my people take this exam today, well, we all thank god for the fact that our people today, even in the context of this tragedy, uh, they are doing political nation. of a new type, and today our independence is evaluated in a new way not only by the ordinary ukrainian, not only by ukrainian society, but also by the world community. how will you explain, well, now about explanation, vasper, that during these more than 30 years, the moscow church had a huge influence on the minds of ukrainians and so.