therefore, in law, we call it effective supervision. the meaning of effective supervision is the same as your opinion. it means that the supervisor is not supposed to just look or look, obtain information and give it to someone else, and that authority , for example, will come to determine the task himself, if you commit a violation somewhere, he will either prevent or prevent it. it prevents the effect of the violation as a result, or cancels it, or prevents the entry of people who do not meet the requirements of the law . minus the referendum, it was the same even before the revolution , in all the 39 elections we had, now the first two elections held in iran. since the constitutional period, we have had a monitoring association with the same qualifications, and it is the same in the world because there is no logic other than this, after all, someone has to match those conditions with the candidates, tell them to determine whether these conditions exist or not, and the same regarding the organization . elections and the correctness of holding

elections should make the decisive and final decision. therefore , we have no choice but to monitor effectively . there are only a few countries that have an observer who provides information because they have two observers. kane gives his opinion to that higher authority and that the higher authority as the final observer will say the decisive and final word that what our taste is now, what we like is the right thing, but we come to the legal system to understand what we should do, we determine our duty through the law. and secondly, it has been explicitly mentioned under article 62 that the conditions of electors and elected officials and the quality of elections are determined by the law . that was approved in 142. but maybe doubt

please read it, mr. engineer. i brought a few copies of the same laws that are in place in 1959, 61, 62, 63, 64. these are the things that he said exactly based on the constitution that was submitted to the parliament, in the same procedure that was criticized by mr. hashemi. it is mentioned in the law. it is also mentioned in the law. now i can read it from the method. it is also mentioned that we have a central supervisory board in addition to the guardian council. this is a famous law. the ministry of guardianship over the elections of the islamic shura majlis approved 16/6 thousand 359 with the signature of the late mr. hashemi rafsanjani was submitted to the guardian council and then approved. the guardian council is also established in the same law as the law that is being implemented now . it has the same procedure. it is the same. the central supervisory board has been formed . then it has been said that in the city and in the provinces , the central board in each province has a board composed of five people. he attributes such and such conditions, then he said

that the provincial supervisory board appoints a committee of 3 people for each constituency to supervise the elections of the respective constituency, and the same structure that we are facing today in 1402 for the parliamentary elections is the same thing that in in 1959, it was approved in the same way, that is, in the same law let's do it without mentioning this word, but the same concept means that it is effective and that the opinion of the guardian council is decisive . regarding the examination of the qualifications , i will read the third part of the article . the qualification of the candidates for supervisory representation is again mentioned in article 6, and the methods of this supervision are mentioned again in article 20. the legislator has also clarified that any law and regulations and any supervisory decision that is contrary to or contrary to supervision or to the decision of the guardian council has no legal validity . it is a law that in 1959 we wanted to go further

the historical arrangement again in 1962, the resolution of the parliament regarding the elections of the islamic council approved in 181162 again stated exactly the same arrangements, and now i said because it is a repetition, until now , the amendments made in the laws have focused on other issues, and the conditions of our volunteers have not changed much . we didn't have it, unfortunately, it might have been good in the general election policies announced by the supreme leader on 24 mehr 1395. the parliament should do 30-40 tasks, one of them is the issue of improving the conditions of volunteers so that i can be volunteers worthy of the islamic republic. adding another condition to the three conditions that have been in place since 1959 is not very interesting in my opinion. i said that i have 5 years of work experience, either in the government, in the private sector, or in the public sector . they may have a different opinion or i may have a different opinion, but the duty of the model

of holding elections and the model of monitoring the elections is determined by the law, and i ask you that the constitution gave this order to the parliament, and the parliament also said this, and you could not have said anything other than this. was. i said that it could be better, but regarding the monitoring model, according to the interpretation of mr. engineer astababi my interpretation of effective supervision has nothing but this legal logic and we are not faced with it anywhere . it might not be a bad thing to state that this law that i read belongs to the year 1959 and was assigned to the internal regulations commission of the parliament and i agree to attend. you, the members of this commission , have been approved. now, i can read the names if we want to, because at that time

, most of them are my friends who, like mr. engineer , are more critical of this form of supervision . it is also correct, that is , the logic that exists for this law is a rational logic that can be reached everywhere in the world therefore, we take the election management, the model of holding and the quality of the elections, the conditions of the candidates and how to monitor the elections from the law . yes , engineer hashem, do you still believe that these two supervisions are an obstacle to competition? yes, if you remember , the meeting we had with mr. madari was basically based on the leadership's talks about how to increase our participation and competition in the elections and security and safety. let's go to the elections and then we will talk about the effect the performance of the guardian council was

brought up, which resulted in our special discussion today. it is important to see what i saw yesterday, mr. haddad adel, on the first page of the program , they pointed out that it is good that the guardian council should avoid extremes. and do something so that we can see a higher participation than in the past, that is, even he believed that the guardian council acted in an excessive or extreme manner, in any case , what is in our society now, no matter how legal scholars or put forward that he has guardians of the law act and nothing is better than action according to the law what is characteristic of society is that there are contradictions that make people doubt the functioning of the guardian council and it is necessary to discuss these contradictions. if you look at the guardian council during the time

of the imam, people like ayatollah safi from the authority that was in the guardian council at that time , there were so many differences between the parliament and the guardian council. that the imam supervises the resolutions of the assembly, that the imam, by planning and giving orders, decided that where the assembly and the guardian council could not reach an agreement if there was the same issue in the same issue, two-thirds of the votes of the parliament should be taken into account , and from 1964 onwards, that two-thirds became the system's expediency assessment assembly, and finally the members of the guardian council were held accountable for their statement in the expediency assessment assembly. they should defend their point of view, and there should be a vote, and whatever they voted for, that means those six members of the jurists became members of the jurisprudence assembly at the time of reviewing that law , which was a dispute, so this was the method that the imam used to hold the guardian council accountable, and then another imam. this did not happen, unfortunately

, the guardian council looked at the issue in a very one-dimensional way he has not responded to public opinion in any way regarding some of his decisions, which i can mention some of his contradictions here, for example, one of the contradictions that is very clear, for example, the qualification of mr. mehrallizadeh , well, i am not saying that they are not qualified , they are certainly qualified, but they are also our friends. in 2018, they were rejected for their parliamentary representation, and a year and a half later, 1,400 of them were approved for the presidency , the same 1,400 that passed in 2018 for the parliament, where 300 people are supposed to be active in the parliament. they will not be approved, but how can a person who is a fake job for the parliament not be approved, but 1400 of them his qualification will be verified if he should

have a much higher status in the case of the presidency, or in the case of mr. alavi , you will see that his leadership will be approved for representation in the assembly of experts, but he will be disqualified again for representation in the assembly, and later we will see that he at the suggestion of the president , he will be introduced to the ministry of information, which you know must be led by the leader of the ministry of information. they will give approval before they are introduced to the parliament, and then he will go to the parliament and be defended, and there he will eventually become a member of the minister of information. going to with his letters, comment on the qualifications of many people , or for example, i remember the same experts we had in the election of majlis experts, ayatollah hadavi tehrani or ayatollah hosseini as acting qaim. both of the representatives of the supreme

leader's position are confirmed in writing, that is , they get a letter of confirmation of their qualifications, even a tv program is put on them and they go to record me, but immediately after a rumor that these two people may be on ayatollah hashemi's list. if rafsanjani is appointed , they will be disqualified once. now this is what i heard, maybe they will reject this issue, but this was a fact. at that time, he was seriously corrected, or at all , the most outstanding performance of the guardian council was regarding ayatollah hashemi rafsanjani himself, who you saw that he was not expelled or disqualified, then how would he respond to this disqualification or disqualification ? and coming to vote for the person who was approved by them and showing with this vote that they do not accept the opinion of the guardian council in any way and finally such contradictions. of course, there are many other examples, for example what happened to mr. sadeghi or what

happened to ali motahari and what happened when a senior what happened to mr. larijani , what happened to mr. jahangiri, what happened to about seven or eight people who were disqualified in the presidential election in the same 1400 election, and of course, many of them did not protest , some of them protested, and it is interesting that now the protest of mr. lalijani can be checked. the important thing is that the effect of the activities of the guardian council has been so great that people like mr. haddad adel, like mr. pomohammadi, who are now the secretary of the clerical struggle, and among others, for example, are seriously protesting the lack of verifications. this movement of the guardian council. armed revolution is not in the expediency of high participation

. it is not in the expediency of creating competition and the opinion of the leadership. even the leadership is implicitly protesting the way the guardian council and the guardian council act. they say that no, they did not mean us , it was not the guardian council . it should somehow be resolved in the public opinion and they should be accountable, and if they don't do this, the way we are going forward, it will cause us to find a lack of participation , and this lack of participation has also lost the rights of the candidates because the voters cannot vote for their desired candidate in the form of voting rights the donors have been wasted and the same statement of the supreme leader proves that the right to vote and spoiling the people's vote or ignoring the people's vote is a human right and god will surely punish and they should take this into consideration or at least this much. be quiet and explain so that a consensus is created and people accept the explanations

. now, perhaps according to the law , there is a prohibition for them to explain the reasons exactly because the reputation of people is at stake and such issues must be found in a way that the problem of persuasion is provide the famous people about the global debate that i have raised now because i have run out of time. later i will say that later , what is this type of surveillance like in the world and how is it dealt with? now , this issue of the guardian council is an indicator that it is not implemented anywhere in the world in this style . thank you, mr. bahadur jahra. yes, i will mention a few points. it was related to a series of historical events regarding that two-thirds vote of the parliament and then

the formation of the assembly in 1964. the first sharia law and the constitution consider that these are the reasons the parliament agrees with this or it does not agree, but what is the source of the judgment of the assembly in the assembly is not these two indicators. for the sake of the resolution that the guardian council has correctly objected to, the assembly cannot enter into the investigation of the correctness and validity of the guardian council's opinion . the constitution has not given it such authority . imam, not giving them the assembly is merely an assumption that the guardian council's objection is reasonable. and it is in accordance with sharia and the constitution, but the parliament insists, saying

that it seems to me that the approval of this law ensures the expediency of the system, the assembly is the final judge here. the assembly will check whether this resolution really fulfills the expediency of the system or not, if it is not closely related to the expediency, the guardian council will announce its opinion and say that it is against sharia and sensual law, and in most cases, the majority of the cases that the assembly entered the parliament has commented on the transparency and accountability of the guardian council, by the way, we can measure it from other places and with other criteria, including one of them , which is the guardian council. it is one of the institutions that are among the most transparent institutions among similar institutions in the world in terms of monitoring the problems and the parliament. what is the reason the reason for this it is possible that the guardian council publishes the discussions that took place in the meeting of those 12 people that led to a conclusion. we do not have this in our world. if mr. engineer now says that they have an example of internationalization studies

, we will use it. i checked that we don't have it ourselves, but it is prohibited in most countries of the world. the debates they do in the meeting about whether what the parliament did was right or not, or it is forbidden to publish it, or even a crime is criminalized in many western countries, so one of the members of their guardian council should come out and say it. what we discussed is that he is guilty of a criminal offense and can be punished and prosecuted, but the guardian council is publishing all the topics that it is publishing these topics, the volume is very large , and by the way, in line with accountability, i am a law student. i can go and read these discussions and then criticize the guardian council and say, guardian council , why did you make this decision in these negotiations? this reason is weak, incorrect, wrong, one point in which western countries has been criminalized. i may be wrong, but in america, in italy, in germany, in australia, these there are some things that you have in your mind

, it doesn't matter if it is prohibited or a crime, now crime means the more severe form of prohibition, but it is forbidden in france. a few years ago, the law was changed, saying that after 25 years have passed since that meeting, a summary can be published. france was also on the same list until a few years ago. there are many countries. these negotiations, why is the opinion of the guardian council published, what is our opinion , positive or negative, or sometimes a report is published in the form of an abstract, but if you come, that's all. i said the discussions that took place in about a year. this page can be put in front of the elites of the people . you can visit the website of the guardian council . it is available in law school libraries. go to the discussion. there are many thick and voluminous books available. sit down and criticize it, and this accountability transparency in this way , i think it is possible to judge

whether it exists or not . i will finish the program tonight . thank you very much, mr. hashemi , mr. bahadrami. let's say and dear sir, as the daughter of a martyr, give a short introduction to martyr moghfouri. what do you say about martyr moghfouri, martyr abdul mahdi moghfouri, born in 1335 in kerman, on the fourth of december 1365 in

the karbala 4 operation , because haj qasim has a very special phrase about these martyrs say that we are proud that the deceased whose grave is the imamzadeh of our city today is ours. today, the grave of the imamzadeh of our city is ours

, and his night was not interrupted on any night . haj qasim did not use the irgc motorcycle, well, they are very nice. it was the family of the martyrs, how much they looked after you and your family, very much, the one who was always by our side in all moments of sadness and happiness , he took care of us and really knew himself from our family, they are zainab khanum, your daughter. how old are you? i am 17 years old. we wanted ms. zainab to be in this frame without compliments to narrate a memory. it was also an impressive memory that the leader of the revolution mentioned

a valuable work done by haj qasim, the grandson of one of his martyred friends wanted to undergo surgery. he went to the hospital and stayed until the operation was over . i had come to follow up on zainab khan's condition and how much surgery she had. yes, and i thought that they would just come to see zainab and ask us how she was and visit us, but i saw that they were not standing in the corridor like that and there was no rush they don't have time to go

either, the child's mother told him that the operation is over, haj agha , go to kardon bersi, he said no, your father, that is , the grandfather of this child, went to be a martyr in my place , and now i am standing here in his place. and these sentences that i heard from mr. haj, i was very transformed and i remember that i leaned against the wall and so on. i'm crying how many hours did haj qasim stay in the hospital? about 3-4 hours, that is, from early in the morning from 7:70 a.m. they came until around 11/11 and how long did they stay? it took about 45 minutes, 50 minutes for zainab to regain consciousness until zainab regained consciousness. i went over zainab's head when zainab jan was brought to the recovery room, they talked to zainab and asked her how she was doing, uncle jan, everything

went according to their dreams . i was sleeping, for example , i was in a state of sleep, but i realized that i am really awake i had a very good weak moment because of this, but that day i was really happy that haji came to us and after the martyrdom of haj qasim , you can see these pictures that haj agha is waiting for you in the hospital until you come to your senses. how are you , zainab, mrs. haji? he was a very great person, and you know this exactly , it became clear to me after his martyrdom, and i was really surprised, because i am not a special person, i am an ordinary person, or a humble person, or a person

after you, a pilgrim had come for me. haj qasim, what are you saying , haj mr. i wish you were here, i wish i was here were you. well, the most important feature of haj agha, who made hajji a hajj, haj qasim soleimani, definitely confirmed his sincerity and this sentence that they themselves say , that you should not try to be seen, the one who should see , sees , is exactly a clear example of the character of haj qasim himself. he paid attention to some details in his life. the same details have now been enlarged. may the souls of the martyrs be happy, god bless their souls. oh god , bless muhammad and his family.

here is one of the exhibitions in tehran called ferangiye retail show . you can see the facade and the ferangi letters. you could not write farsi. our brand was like this. who did you write this for ? i came here now. i didn't understand. well, you need to improve your english or the poem that everyone knows is more english . now there is some discussion about brand design

. you wrote it in english, why didn't you write farsi next to it, now there is a problem , we will definitely note this, we will have a program , some exhibitors also talk about the international aspect of the exhibition , why did you write english so boldly everywhere, why didn't you write farsi ? we have a lot of international visitors and feedback from other countries we are forced to act internationally, and this is why, according to the executive regulations of the law prohibiting the use of foreign names and terms , it is mandatory to use persian script and language on signs and headers, and if the international aspect is involved, the ratio should be 70%. 30% cultural persian should be observed. we followed up the issue with the officials of the ministry of culture and islamic guidance. it was decided that the honorable ministry should be informed that there is an exhibition and it should be held in accordance with the relevant regulations and the relevant institution should be in

this ministry. to hold an exhibition and give the permission of the exhibitions will definitely pay more attention to compliance with the farsi language. it was a point of interaction, but the legal criteria were not announced to the exhibitors. did the officials of the exhibition tell you not to write an english word? no, unfortunately not. did the officials of the exhibition tell you not to write in such rough english? no, there was nothing in this regard. some visitors also need farhan. in this regard, rangsazi said that our language is a luxurious language, a complete and perfect language, and we really do not need to use other languages ​​from now on, but we can do better and let's use our own language more, he really wants to build culture, not in this exhibition , we see such things in many other exhibitions , so it should be placed in a place to build culture , first of all, the culture should be made, dear parsi, introduction.

however, it should be valued, its culture should be created , the hope of the people of sed and sima news agency. yes, this is free . yes, this is free. yes, this is also free

. this is free. this is free. yes, all of this is free . the nation of housing, welfare of workers and agriculture they were obliged to pay facilities to 350,000 rural applicants. mr. jodi said 122 thousand billion tomans to pay for the facility.