in fact, he generalized a lot, there are various reasons , in fact, the costs of treatment , after all, there is a question of continuous retirement, maybe these are people who do not work continuously, they are only insured, i want to say that the reason we are looking for or supporting this is that in fact we must definitely go in this direction that if it doesn't happen this year , we should be able to provide maximum coverage for different industries in the following years . in any case, it was his experience last year, which was 57, finally, there were employers who actually had one person, two people or three people. to have employees, because the cost of the finished price in services is higher than in the industry, they should reduce their workforce , or have fewer hours, or at all fire employees to become workers themselves, mr. tajik , what do you think are the disadvantages of setting the minimum wage regionally, it is repeated again and again. if we simplify the problem , it will be understandable for the dear viewers of the program.

demarcation is very easy. well, in the regions, we divided them into 6 regions. in the meeting we had at the ministry of economy, tehran and albort provinces were definitely placed in grade one. the cities with higher inflation were placed in the second region. i have a question for you. let's say then that there are 6 regions, the whole country has 6 regions. the question here is which regions and what are the types in terms of inflation and living expenses . it was an expert work that the respected experts of the ministry of economy did with a very positive view, but it means that the country is zoned between 1 and 6 according to whether the costs are higher in those cities or should be. a higher tuition fee or i said a higher housing allowance is an example. it is easy for tehran, the border line with

the central province is on the tehran freeway, you can go there after the new city of parand, the border line between tehran and the central province. saveh industrial co. is working, or even two kilometers away, they are working in a workshop on the border of central province, the resident side of tehran province. he is paying the expenses according to the tehran province. in which province is he working? central province, the difference in the level of expenses with tehran is how many floors. he works in that factory and says that i live in tehran. every morning, for example , i drive 40 kilometers with 50 and 30 kilometers. or even your 5 km

the border line of tehran and central province is a very simple example . we have this issue in all cities. well , he saw the zoning of central province a few hours down. the employer wants to pay the young unskilled workers according to central province. where does he live in tehran province? is it possible that the first objection is correct, that is, i pay the expenses of tehran province , i pay them in central province, and i get handouts. the second problem is that people who have two years left of their work are retiring in the same way, it is impossible to assume that it is not impossible, the same person is retired, he is gone , where does he work, destan central says i am 28 years old. i had a good insurance coverage in tehran province, now my salary has not increased according to the framework, so as a result, i will not live until the end of my life.

my pension should be low. respected experts of the social security organization are the first opponents of the anti-regional opponents. i was very interested in this issue. what is the opposite, for example, someone who lives in the same border lives on the other side ? well, that's why they are against this discrimination. yes, thank you. i wanted to explain this issue in the third step, let me ask mr. javani for the answer. look at it regionally, i would like to say that there is still a discussion about my regional wage research. this meeting was the first day of my friends . we are debating whether it actually happened, let's defend it or reject it. now we are discussing the province that mr. tajik gave as an example. see, this analogy is empty

, just like we say, for example, the party is working in tehran, he lives in central province, or is there a photo of me, naturally, it's about housing costs. the housing that is in tehran is different from that there. when it is determined, it is possible for the party to work in tehran province and receive tehran wages and tehran housing rights, but he is a resident of central province. in other words, i can give many examples in violation of your words, but this is not our dispute at all, or it is your argument that says let's move forward step by step . characterized as a representative of the workers present i am in the supreme labor council, my goal is that the best things happen to the community under my coverage, but

i have a higher goal, you and i, sorry, we are all under the same flag . the events that are happening in my country , or i can be one of the influential ones , sorry, this is discrimination, i was exactly the issue here , i wanted to get to the same point in the third case, sorry , why should a person work in another place and get the salary of a province ? no, i want to say exactly what i want in the third step let's get to the same issue. well , we should have answers from mr. javani. housing, for example, is one of the good discussions. which happened, if it happens, i don't know how agile the government will help us , it happened in the meeting on november 8th, the discussion of article 149 of the labor law was brought up, that we should come to a camp, in fact, workers' housing to jumpstart the discussion of work housing , one of the discussions we had another discussion about the context

, you should be in the direction that the price of the land, in fact, for a house, will reach zero, which means that the government has so much land, or many of the industrial units that are looking to the government can do this. it is not a regional issue at all, in fact, in central province, the land that is there now can happen in tehran or in different places, and the same issue that i am talking about, recording our livelihood, if we really want to help, it is not for us and you to sit there, i am on this side. let me sit at the table, i say, sir , let it be enough, you will be more, then the government and the government won't help us , we have to help each other . .

the report prepared by my colleague in the welfare and cooperation group of sed and sima news agency is a review of opinions supporters and opponents of this determination, at least regionally, let's see it together and come back to a discussion. asghar ahaniha, representative of employers in the supreme labor council. determining the regional minimum salary of workers is a legal task that was blocked and ignored in the last 20 years. the labor law emphasizes two issues of wages for different regions, wages for different industries, and the determination of regional wages instead of the same minimum wage for all according to this law. it has been suggested by ali khodayi, a labor member of the supreme labor council , according to article 41 of the labor law, determining the minimum wage should be based on the cost of living and the inflation rate. if we really want to comply with the legal obligations , first

we should raise the basic requirements and then other legal obligations. first, the minimum living expenses, ie the workers' livelihood basket, must be determined. fatemeh aziz khavani, an expert at the majlis research center. because in determining the national wage, the cost of living in all regions is calculated equally, both the workers of big cities and the workers of deprived areas are discriminated against. workers in big cities cannot make a minimum living. employers in low-income areas cannot pay the approved minimum wage. this species to recruit informal workers take action that is not in the interest of the workers. hadi abui, secretary of the high center of trade unions. wherever the workers are paid more wages, the workers migrate to that place so that they may live better. these decisions currently have nothing but increasing problems for the government and the people. first determine the national minimum wage and then determine a higher percentage of the minimum wage for some regions.

jamal razaghi, head of fars chamber of commerce. the regional wage does not reduce labor force. many of the costs and rates of items in cities and villages are different from each other. definitely the house rental rate in big cities are much more than small towns and villages. fethullah bayad, the head of the union of contractual and contractual workers of regional rights , is the employer's escape from the responsibility of labor rights. even now, the minimum wage is not sufficient for the workers. in this situation, bringing up the regional banana means exploiting the workers of the less privileged areas , because with this policy, they employ workers with any salary. well, let's see my colleague together. mr. javani, i will ask you a question and i will get mr. taji's answer later. i think that

i should answer to mr. javani and say, eat halva with halva the worker is not happy when we say that the housing camp has one meeting in the supreme labor council. you know, i know . before, we went to discuss housing , should we set up a housing camp for workers to get houses, should we hold 10 meetings for workers to get houses , i agree with the discussion of livelihood packages, mr. jovani , i am ashamed of the country's workers, we are discussing wages 1402 in the supreme labor council, if the presence of mind you know, inflation was not supposed to reach 434. 45 mr. javani is correct, the promise that mr. khandozi

, the minister of economy finally gave, i expected the government to difficult situations should come to the aid of the labor community . at least this help could have been the livelihood packages, which the government is obliged to in the constitution . well, i

will give a reminder once again. it faded away, that was the demarcation issue, the issue that i repeat for the last two years, that worker is retiring, and considering the possibility of defamation, it is the opposite issue. it was the attribute of the social security experts themselves. our third discussion regarding the determination of pensioners' salaries in young countries , don't you agree on which salary and which province? take a break? the next issue was the issue of discrimination . we say that the law should be done correctly. god forbid, we are not representatives to do right and wrong , mr. javani, my duty as a worker's representative

is to make the correct demand for workers' rights . regions discriminate, that worker has a motivation , it is one of the reasons for migration for the workforce. this is a regional discussion, so mr. javani, please tell me look at the 1928 minimum wage mechanism convention, let me tell you the experiences of other countries in rome. tell me if this is the way it works . the 1928 international labor organization's minimum wage mechanism convention emphasizes its members and those who can accept these conventions and the lowest wage standard. it means that it should fully meet the special needs of workers and families, this is the issue of livelihood

, that is, we have addressed this in article 41 of the labor law, and we also accepted it. in fact, we are part of the country. in fact, i was accepting that at one time, the problem of having a strongman was to have competition to at least raise your hand . and the large and small workshops are supported by the government to raise reasonable wages or different industries, it does not mean that we are actually less generous to the workers. small workshops are more vulnerable from the sources of loans and facilities and assistance from the government. well, naturally, if the law is implemented , finally, the three factors, the three factors, the work , the labor government, work, and help must also come . we cannot ignore the law because it is not

happening. in the salary of 1401, which is actually 57. i explained that there are several factors , including, in fact, the factors that the sovereign government is responsible for, which is not only the employer, or this year, which was actually set at 27%, again, it was based on inflation, it was not necessarily inflation, so we cannot say, because article 41 says that this is a misinterpretation and abuse of the law mr. no, how about that? excuse me, the requirement of the legislator is to look at inflation in the livelihood , not that you are lower. in the meeting of the supreme labor council and other dear friends of the government

, i said that the livelihood is the red line of the labor society because it is what they live on. no one lives with the percentages . your words where he said 57 i don't accept it, it had an effect and caused an increase in insurance. well , it's official statistics . if we want to cite the statistics, we can cite it. if it was bilzam , it would come in the law. look at these systems that have been launched, one month is enough for karfa to pay his insurance with a discount for any reason. he says that your sir is not entitled to health insurance now because he has violated social security. the statistics are wrong. the statistics are no longer wrong . the number of insured people disagrees don't believe that your study didn't work and make it now your supply work has nothing to do with it being a system , you can come and

make some changes based on the system you have designed , we can't fix much because the theme expert came to a meeting without studying and objected. so it's not impossible, we can't. my personal belief is that i read the 1928 convention of the international labor organization about 100 years ago and said that the organization should be such that it provides the minimum for a family. we don't have any differences in the discussion of my livelihood, but we say that the registration of livelihood is the responsibility of the employer no, you say registration of livelihood, ok, we totally agree with you. did we come this year? we said that the sabbath of the mosque is 18 million tomans. do you think you are the employer of a workshop? a small one can pay 18 workers, there is no problem with a big worker , now he pays much more. let's meet, we, the workers, and you, the workers, should take our request to the shaali work meeting, where there are four members of the government, and tell mr. government, anyway, the assignments that we said here are from i didn't write that he came and said

that it is the duty of the government, housing is the duty of the government, health is the duty of the government, education is the duty of the government, when you see a young man, if the goal is to relieve us of the burden of responsibility, forgive me, this is a chicken and egg story , we will never reach a conclusion. i worked as a laborer , i brought added value to the employer, i want results. i'll take care of myself, it's asking too much , i'm sorry, this is illogical, your worker signed it, the government signed it , i apologize for 7,300,600, his insurance should be reduced , he should live 6,800, or should i say, sir, according to law 18

give me money, which one is not in my area, do you want us to make an agreement, we do not, in fact , i am a worker according to article 41, i am saying that i completely agree with the implementation of the law, but it is true that the law is not in one corner, you brought up the issue of housing, i said that there is no problem that we should let's find an exit so that the worker is not in housing, which i can't say . let's have 100 expert meetings. let's set up a housing camp . this house owner will be a house owner. dear sir

, the working group will have a house owner. we should give 10 sabbaths. when it is not implemented, when the government helps the community. no workers come, i am a worker, how should i spend my days and nights? i'm sorry, this will be bread for the laborer . my point is that unfortunately, that is the social position in general, which means that each of us as an iranian can take my decision. you know why we are against the regional wage because i can't see the consequences . it has become our country, try to plan a plan. let's implement it, don't answer, please forgive the people in the middle, let their rights be lost , let the people's rights be lost, what's the matter, we came, we gave a plan , what issue did i raise in the previous meeting of the supreme labor council to serve the honorable members, mr. javani? i said that the governments, at least, do not agree with themselves on the regional position, well, the ministry of labor as the head

the supreme labor council is discussing wages . it raises the issue of social security under the sub-category, mr. javani. there is no sub-category . the sub-category of the minister himself came to the official meeting of his representative and said, "i am against it because i do not have the infrastructure. when the social security , as you say, violates and fails like this, it cannot accept what the consequences will be for the worker later. forgive me, you will pay for the consequences. well, mr. javani, because you are referring to the infrastructure, what kind of infrastructure do you need? i do not accept it because we we do not know the answer to the problem we don't know your answer. let's erase the problem. you say that because i don't know what the implications are, it's trial and error. we disagree with the principle of the case, not us.

let's put aside the main point of the matter, we need to study the research work and the countries that are actually adjacent to us and see the weaknesses and strengths of the countries that have been implemented. in general, iran

is a country, from your personal perspective, which country can you go to iran ? we don't act, but now we have an island, do we pay or not, finally , we have to localize this work that happened, come and check it in our own country. wherever it is implemented, there is no need to reject all of them. let's all implement it at once . for example , i would like to say that there was a proposal regarding the increase of housing rights or the discussion of labor rights . we can examine a few cases one by one. do you agree at all with my law, i can't with the law, we accept the law , we accept the discussion, especially the different industries, and we believe that by determining the national issue of the same issue, we are turning the small industry of the employer into a worker , the employer criticizes it for the workers.

there is a duty, he said, sir, the workshops with less than 10 people can be removed from part of the labor law according to the reformer . this was implemented for a while. by the way, last year it was 57. our concern was this. i'm sorry for any problem with your youth. i don't know anymore. i'll remind you for the umpteenth time . if possible, talk about the regional wage. the benefit for your workers is that i have written four factors here. let us know that we accept the unofficial workers of the underground workshops of the workers azadkar, these are the things that we are neglecting . by approving, we will make these workers that we say

are worth how many millions. now, because they don't have official statistics , i can't give official statistics here, but this is not from the point of view of us saying that we will be paid 3 million, see 4 tomans. payment is fine, we say the minimum wage with the explanation i gave, the convention of the international labor organization and the minimum living wage must be determined according to what i explained , how much is the minimum living wage in the lowest level of iran, we examined this issue last year, this year you are finally as an expert, you are present in the committee you can do this

, yes, sorry, it will make the jobs unofficial, i say what number is a good salary, we should determine the number to make the jobs official, you tell me a number, we can, instead of it being a number, we proposed last year, article 19 of the law. the work says that part of the workshop below can be exempted from part of the provisions of the labor law. we can do the minimum, which means that you are actually exempting the workers from the minimum that we who do not have a job in iran , well, we have one minute and 30 seconds for you to summarize. do it for 30 seconds, sir. yes, i am the same width. first of all, i would like to say that the employer community and the labor community are two wings that fly together as a bird, they cannot be separated. if we have a discussion, our discussion is not that, god forbid , mr. tajik 's work should be improved. i repeat again that they agree with the full implementation of article 41 of the labor law . in my opinion, if the right action

is not taken by mr. javani regarding wages, surely in 1403, we will have a decrease in the purchasing power of workers, a decrease in the supply of labor , we will have an inflationary stagnation, and finally a shutdown. we have workshops, anyone else with these numbers? i am not working, thank you to both guests of the program, all the good viewers, especially the higher program, who accompanied us until this moment, thank you very much , god.

5 o'clock: the opportunity to register the candidates of the 12th term of the parliamentary elections: in the television advertisement system was extended. according to the notice number two of the election headquarters of the broadcasting and broadcasting corporation, candidates for parliamentary representation to use the possibility of television advertising until tuesday. on february 3, they have the opportunity to write a letter by referring to the system of the election headquarters under the symbol em 1402.r. radio in order to create an advertising opportunity.