i have to work, i'll take it, i'll buy the land , you tell me this is id, well, iran doesn't have it, i say sir , i'm not rigid and extremist at all, i want to buy land so that my wealth can be preserved, the government, the government from the beginning, when every government came, the previous government and this government thirteenth, i am devoted to all these friends whom i really love, that is, mr. doctor, i know how hard they work and how much they try . i want to say about the production path , we should work on a policy package for the production path, sir doctor, do you want us to keep that package, i don't want it, the last argument, my last sentence is that if we at least allow it, in the issue of inflation, that i am.

i am not to blame, as a rich person in my society , i did not create the discontent that i want, sir, i just want my wealth to be preserved, to be preserved, and hello, let the tax be adjusted for inflation . of course, some of these are inflationary , of course, some of the funds, i have seen , there is no problem in having an id higher than inflation, you

have to remove inflation and then tax for let's calculate the capital id, so the main point of my argument and actually my claim is the opposite, so i have to argue, mr. doctor, capital id tax is implemented in 187 countries in the world, 187 countries, most of these countries are countries with very, very low inflation after the tax for added value is our most successful tax is the capital id tax. among the countries, there are some african countries or even argentina, which you can see right now with high inflation . iran is like these countries, which, in my opinion, due to the lack of the reason is one of the important factors the lack of capital income tax has been formed. we

have had capital income tax in england since 1965. to deal with speculative speculation in the housing sector, to deal with the increase in housing prices, one of the things that actually seems to me is that you and i have a common method. i would like to offer you the tax. after the first world war, by the way , the inflation in britain was very, very high. let's say that the inflation is not short-term at all. i am mr. d. it has been 50 years since mr. dr. egerman's inflation was 20%. when did we experience the tax for capital id? we have this as a control factor we are talking about england. since 1965 , england has had a capital id tax. america has had a capital id tax since 1917. pay attention . when we talk about these countries and many other countries, they say that 187 countries in the world have taxes. for those who have capital, why

are we in the middle of an alley ? to discuss increasing the monetary base and from the area of ​​zarif fazaandeh is supposed to justify this lack of liquidity. liquidity wants to have an effect . i have another important factor that creates liquidity. besides this, when we are talking about capital id tax, the lack of this tax means that the game is tight, the game is going to happen, it means that the price of assets is growing, it is growing, it is growing , whether your property is land, real estate, or a car. and what a shame it is growing. when it grows, it means that it motivates me mowahdi says, if you get money , go buy real estate because it is growing. a loop

is formed here, a cycle is formed that i am going to the property because its price increases and because its price increases, therefore the increase in the price of inflation. again, it actually shapes the price , it shapes the price increase in that basket of goods that it affects, and actually the inflation calculations are based on that basket of goods . this increase in assets directly and indirectly increases that basket of goods. the second point is that when this the price has increased and i am motivated to buy this. i don't have money or i have money, but as much as i need to make a profit, my greed allows me to go to the cash facility. i want to take this facility from the banking system . how many facilities did we provide last year? all the facilities that we provided went to production. what percentage of them went to production? did the things that went to production bring economic growth to us? it shows that we

have a leak, mr. doctor, what is our leak, our leak is that no matter how much our banking system, the institutions of the system a bank that provides education to anyone who wants it with higher interest and in fact to anyone who has higher credit. who can get these credits from the companies that i mentioned to you, the super rich people that i mentioned to you, you can imagine now. do people go and buy these? they are not the people. 50% of the people do not have cars. 50% of the country's households do not have any cars . 50% of the people of this country are renters, so they are not the subject of our discussion . the subject of our discussion is a series of companies that are abusing this space. they do, and a series of super-rich people you meet can confirm it find out that these are the ones that created this space now, so the discussion that i want

to talk about is actually , let's examine this effect, this effect of liquidity , who has come and reviewed an article. you found it, mr. doctor, because all the literature that is being produced in economic studies is based on a presupposition that basically those countries did not deal with this issue because they themselves have this tax for capital because they have actually had a situation where this is a tough game. it 's okay if you agree before answering mr. dr. shaqi, let's have a report, my colleague in the karan economic group of sed and sima news agency will prepare it . vahid shaghaghi, an economic expert , should not be taxed on all the capital id of individuals, in other words, the inflation rate of the country should be subtracted from the total profit to obtain the net capital id

. for example, if a person buys a car for 1 billion tomans and within 6 months, due to high inflation in the country, the price will be reduced to 1. if half a billion tomans increase , the amount of inflation should be subtracted from the total id to calculate the tax he made the so-called pure id the basis of the tax exemption . mohammadreza yazdizadeh, an economic expert, adjusting inflation in the capital gains tax is a big mistake that renders its entire regulatory function ineffective. due to the exemptions granted to convert the assets to the best inflation adjustment. there is no justification. mohammad ghasemi, head of the research center of the chamber of commerce, if inflation adjustment is not included in the capital id tax law, not only will there be no deterrent for speculative behavior, but with its implementation

, the principle of tax justice will be further distorted, and the perception of injustice in deepening society and the gap between the layers of the society are aggravated, ali. malekzadeh, economic expert, adjusting for inflation in the capital income tax is against tax justice. if inflation adjustment is to be done in the capital income tax , it should be adjusted for inflation in order to maintain the fairness and efficiency of the tax system. other incomes that are subject to tax should also be adjusted for inflation. there should be capital income tax, and i do not agree that in our country, vahid azizi , an economic expert, despite the wide exemptions that have been provided for the preservation of capital in the capital income tax, some people who, during the approval of the commission and

they believe that the amount of inflation should be deducted from the ids of people who have non-productive activities. this is against justice and injustice. this is the basis of the tax and effectively turns the tax into an ineffective and harmful tax. we reviewed the opinions of supporters and opponents of the debate we have today. mr. dr. shaq and mr. maaoudi point out that they make a distinction between ordinary people and people who are now more wealthy or profiteers or companies that are looking for profiteers. how much do you think of this distinction? yes, look, i believe that wealth is necessary for the economy, and the super-rich in general. and iran is a problem it doesn't matter if our country is rich , we should have a lot of rich people. so, the problem

is that we are rich now and you have seen the car in this bill. i don't know where in the world the car is capital. well, if you know, at least i will import the car as it is a consumer product, why do people of iran khodro claim that it is right? well, i calculated that in 1989-1990, i was using a foreign car. now it has increased 50 times. i

went there two or three times in the last 12 years. we went there two or three times. the land that i had bought or the house that i had bought has increased by 35-40 times . there is almost a convergence between the increases, that is, you can buy dental cash and toothpicks. in inflationary period, there is a convergence. instead of buying a car , people consider another commodity as capital, just as people in their monetary history once went to a certain commodity and considered it as money until they reached silver. and gold was considered a durable storable commodity due to its characteristics that did not go to gold and silver. money monetary unit so look, i want to say that let's assume dollars and gold

, let's assume housing, land and the capital market, of course, you excluded the capital market from this issue , that is, the capital market is exempt from this economic contract discussion, i agree that the capital market is also included in this, not now the capital market don't let it get to your head that the situation is so hot now that we can't handle the greed of the people in this situation anymore, that's the problem now, everyone who took their money in the last 6 years has been sitting on the black soil at all , let's not talk about it at all, not me at all. i don't want to lose that a university professor has nothing for it is halal to borrow my money, halal, well, whatever it takes , first they reduce the tax, they give us a certain amount, and then they give us a certain amount, because i am a doctor and a member of the university, they know that we have no other id than the rights we teach. a teacher's salary is really halal, but i want to tell you to see that i am talking about the car, let's talk about the car

issue . why is the car an investment, mr. doctor ? in the last 12 years, in that increase, i have come to the conclusion that

no, not at all, not at all, mr. doctor , it is not like this. right now, you should check the canadian tax reforms to see how many reforms canada has made in recent years, when in fact it was so-called immigration-friendly. he has taken over tax and tax reforms from his own side, tax on capital id and other tax rights to control his housing market , in fact he has approved it and moved it forward . i gave you the example of england. we are feeling this way right now

many countries, i will tell you now , i will tell you now, let's make this clear first, why the car? another car used to go here and there with the nation's horses 200 years ago, 300 years ago, now it has become a car, for example, a four-wheeler that we have to ride and go here and there. it is a consumer product. i went shopping some time ago. one car, we entered a so-called parking lot, this parking lot was full of cars , and these cars had about half an inch of dirt sitting on these cars, a parking lot , we don't say what happened in the middle of tehran. tehran and qom, in the middle of tehran, all these cars next to each other with half a centimeter of dirt sitting on it, what happened that made me buy a car, not just a car, a car that i use myself and go this way, not that way? i buy cars, all kinds of cars

, cars that actually win different international. i will buy it in this mr. d. no, no, i don't call it hoarding. i call it a car game . let 10 years of his life pass , they say that 10 years have passed since he lived, he will not let 10 years pass again. the car needs a shock, it wants a shock. look, mr. doctor , when a car or a property or land, when we say open, who is the adjective? look, there is no one who is 50 meters away . does he want to keep it for himself or a 100 meters away, he wants to get it for his child and keep it until his child , if he gets married

, the house of life will actually have a

shelter. housing and cars to see who owns what they buy and what they sell something and it is profitable in our economy, why don't they go to production because of the many problems that you mentioned, i will confirm that there are a series of problems in our production, our production has fundamental problems, so it should be closed. let's talk about it completely, but

we want to talk about inflation. look, i say, if i believe in the long term, yes, if someone keeps the car for 6 years, keeps it for 5 years , you have to adjust for inflation , there is no problem with our dispute. and the discussion of our scientific discussion , our debt dispute, so to speak, is short-term, under one year of assumption let it be two years in one or two years when a person buys a commodity so that he can then buy this capital asset to sell it later. lupe, give this bad cycle again, but i have created a situation where the party does not find the motivation to make a production at all, to think about production at all, sir, i should open a shop , a workshop, go to a technical school, learn something. i don't know if they have a professional technical workshop , they choose a professor and in the end it doesn't help them at all why, because we didn't allow him to come, because we left the space so open that, sir, you can

take your money, yes, a land, if you had a land , sell it a year later for a certain amount and use it . take our main fight and that is our scientific discussion here. this should be clarified, and after how it swells the effect, i still insist on hearing these reasons to see that you see, mr. doctor, i still have the same opinion, because now the numbers and numbers, maybe we should sit together, there is no problem , for example, you the ministry of economy should hold meetings with numbers and figures for the long term to make estimates let's estimate some models. see, i have not yet seen that gambling or speculation is the root of inflation or has a significant contribution to inflation, the doctor

says. they are working on the same issue, the effect of speculation, liquidity, demand for inflation. we have been working on inflation for 50 years . look, there is nothing wrong with a group of experts who are working. the trustee will inevitably put pressure on the budget, such as the mismatch of pension funds, which was inevitably the 17th general budget this year, which was the government's contribution to the funds.

the budget deficit will go up. this will be financed by the channel or the central bank or the banking system . i want to say that there is no problem with inflation. let's take this as an opinion . i still believe that speculation cannot be a factor in inflation. it can be a factor. expectations are fine, but what share does it have , you should see everything . we have to value everything according to its share, priority and importance . in our own country many times with tek'. politics before let's go, mr. moderator, he wants a policy package . well, we just

think that everyone has their own mentality from one area to another. he argues for you that this work should have been done, but when you have a circle. check the effects, you will see that yes, it was useful , but it was harmful to another area. the cost- benefit analysis you do, you can see that the benefit was less than the cost, so no, i want to say this when you look at the problem. you are useful when you sit there in the tax organization or the ministry of economy, you analyze from your own point of view, you say it is very good, but. no, for this issue , i want to say that i have different devices. well, did the minister who made this notification believe that he did not have an expert and proved and proves that he should have done this, or

is he the one who orders pricing? he who is an expert should explain it to me, but mr. doctor , you can see that it hits one place , it brings a benefit, it creates thousands of costs, so from this point of view, i want to say that we are a political package. we asked tax is still there. i believe that tax requires a policy package, not only on capital id requirements. i will say one more thing. now is not the time to open it. i believe that although i agree with the tax system, increasing tax revenues, the government's reliance on taxes, and increasing the share of the government. i am concerned about the increase in production tax, but i do not prescribe this drug for this period of iran's economy, even though i know that this drug exists , but different economic conditions, like a doctor , you prescribe one doctor at a time.

he examines the patient and says that this medicine is effective i know, for example, the heart part is useful for his heart system , that is, it is used, but now is not the time because, for example, his diabetes is high, so the analysis of the patient is also important. in order to prove this, by the way, if the ministry of economy can prove it with numbers and figures, it can come to you, mr. minister, come to this same radio station, mr. dr. sopanyan , come and say, look, we sat down with 20 or 30 economists and proved that the speculation of special shares it is coming in taxes and this tax unadjusted capital can

have this effect on inflation. when you see numbers and figures , once we talk with numbers and figures , our work becomes much easier and the acceptance becomes easier. ministry of economy and taxation organization, i want to make corrections here. i came here as an expert so that i can report freely. to those experts in the field of taxation , i used to follow the capital id that i had before the tax affairs organization, this is for you let me tell you this, when our game quality is zero , how much will be the tax on our game quality? zero tax on capital id is a tax against itself, which means that it is reducing itself less and less. the game is reduced to zero, we don't have any income at all, which basically means targeting us in

the organization of affairs. tax and ministry of economy to move towards tax for capital. by the way , i don't have any income at all. i said that there is no income at all. i mean, we are aiming for income. let's prove it, that's actually my first proposal

, to see if the extreme tightening effect has an effect on inflation or not. how many years has it been now ? the root of speculation is one of the most important, important, important, important roots of inflation. we say that if you pay taxes without, that is, with no adjustment, that means inflation should be included in it, this is the need for a s

in the name of allah, the most merciful , the most important, the most important, the most important, the most important, the most important, the most important. the content was adjusted in the resulting income. according to this document, which is approved by the supreme council of cyberspace. manufacturers content, such as active users in platforms and social networks, specialized and professional content producers , as well as small local social media , will share in the income from traffic sales. the president of this document is an effective step for job creation and development of people's activities.