first of all, when every government came, including the previous government , this is the 13th government, i have devotion to all these friends whom i really love, that is, mr. dr. i know what hard work they do and how much effort they put into that tax organization. well, mr. dashto khandozi, i like him very much, i say that you should see this, i say that we should go the right way to reach a goal, we must say the production path, it is a policy package. we have to work on the production path. the last discussion. my last sentence is that if we at least allow that in the discussion of inflation, i am not to blame as a rich person in my society, i didn't create discontent , i want it, i just want my wealth to be preserved , to be preserved, and hello, let the tax be adjusted for inflation , that is, id is lost in inflation.

there is an average inflation, we say 40 42, we just know that some of these are inflation, of course, some of the capitals , i have seen , there is no problem in having an id higher than inflation, you tax the gap, but we have to preserve the originality, this is the right of the people, sir, so here it became clear, dear mr. bozor nasib, that dr. shaghaghi's view is that because gambling and speculation are not the main cause of inflation, therefore inflation is produced from another place with a different origin and channel, inflation, so we have to take out this inflation and then calculate the tax for the id of the capital, so the main point of my argument and actually my claim, because it is the opposite, i have to let me argue, dr. tax on capital id in 187 countries. the world is running in 187 countries,

most of which are countries with very , very low inflation. after the value added tax, our most popular tax is the capital id tax, in the countries of some african countries or even argentina, which right now you you can see that iran has high inflation, there are countries like these that have formed due to the lack of capital, in my opinion, due to one of the most important factors. in england, we have had a capital id tax since 1965, to deal with speculation in the housing sector, to deal with the increase in housing prices, one of the things that actually seems to be that you and i agree on a method that i will tell you about the service tax next. from world war first, by the way, inflation

in britain is very, very mature. in the short term , if our inflation was 20% in the year that dr who was high? when did we experience the capital income tax that we have after that ? we are talking about this as a controlling factor . we are talking about england. i say that 187 countries in the world have capital. why are we in the middle of the street ? an analysis that refers to the discussion of base increase money and from the area in this field

is going to justify this liquidity. liquidity wants to have an effect. i have another important factor that creates liquidity. this is when we say capital id tax. the lack of this tax means speculation , it is like a game. it means that the price of assets is growing. it finds when it grows, it means that to i am motivated by mohadi, if you get money , go buy property and housing because it is growing , so a loop is formed here, a cycle is formed. it does, therefore, the increase in the price of inflation again in fact shapes the price

. what is the second point? the second point is that when this price increase i have the motivation to go and get this, i don't have money or i have money, but i need to make as much profit, this greed allows me to go to check the facility , i want to get this facility from the banking system, how many facilities did we provide last year , all those facilities what percentage of what we presented went to production, did those things that went to production bring us economic growth? it shows that we have a leak, mr. doctor , what is our leak, our leak is that no matter how much our banking system, the connections of the banking system, the facilities of everyone if he wants to get an education with a higher profit and in fact with a higher return of the interest of the facility, he will

provide it to him . anyone who has a higher credit will give him the education . you can imagine the super-wealthy people that i have presented to you. are the people going to buy these ? they are not the people. 50% of the people do not have cars. 50 % of the country's households do not have any cars. 50% of the people of this country are bored, so they are not the subject of our discussion. the subject of our discussion is a series of companies. there are those who are abusing this space and you can find a series of super rich people who are the ones who are creating this space now. so, the discussion that i want to talk about is that we should come and examine this work , this work of liquidity. it is produced in

economic studies based on an assumption that basically those countries do not deal with this issue because they themselves have this tax for capital. because practically conditions. it has occurred to them that this kind of game should not be formed, very well , if you agree, before we have the answer of mr. dr. shaqieh , i will prepare a report from my colleague in the economic cave of the tv news agency , let's see it together, let's go back to the consensus of the viewers and continue our conversation. vahid shaghaghi, an economic expert, should not be taxed on all the capital assets of individuals , in other words, the country's inflation should be subtracted from the overall profit to obtain the net capital assets. for example, if a person buys a car for 1 billion tomans and within 6 months due to high inflation if the price of the country increases to half a billion tomans , then to calculate the tax, the inflation amount should

be subtracted from the total id and the net id should be used as the basis of the tax. mohammad darza yazdizadeh is an economic expert. inflationary adjustment in capital gains tax is a big mistake that renders its entire regulatory function ineffective. considering the exemptions granted to convert the assets to the best inflation adjustment, there is no justification. mohammad ghasemi, head of the research center of the chamber of commerce, if inflation adjustment is not included in the capital id tax law, not only will there be no deterrent for speculative behavior. had rather, with its implementation, the principle of tax justice will be further distorted and the perception of injustice in the society will deepen and the gap between the layers of the society will intensify. ali malekzadeh, an economic expert , adjusting inflation in capital id tax is against

tax justice. if there is to be an inflation adjustment in the capital income tax, it should be adjusted for inflation in order to maintain the fairness and efficiency of the tax system. other incomes that are subject to tax should also be adjusted for inflation . in the provincial tax of production adjustment to have inflation because it has no meaning at all. vahid azizi, an economic expert, despite the wide exemptions that are intended to preserve capital in the capital id tax. who are not aware of the approval of the commission and its extensive exemptions , believe that the amount of inflation should be deducted from the id of people who have non-productive activities. this work is against justice and against the efficiency of this tax base, and

they actually turn the tax into an ineffective and harmful tax. we reviewed the opinions of the pros and cons of the discussion we are having today, mr. dr. shaghaei , mr. moodi points out that i have a distinction. between people normal people and people who are more wealthy now or speculators or companies that are looking for speculators , how much do you differentiate between them? yes, look, i believe in wealth. and we all enjoy it. the second problem is that you can see that in asad's portfolio, that is, the assets

of our asset portfolio , there is something called a car. you have at least one entry, but the car is a consumer product. why do the people of iran khodro praise it? well, i calculated that in 1989-1990 i was using a foreign car. now it has increased 50 times. i went there two or three times in the last 12 years . we went there two or three times. the house i bought was 35 to 40 times . there is almost a convergence between the increases, i.e. you

buy dental cash and toothpicks. during an inflationary period, there is a convergence . instead of buying a car, people go for another product as capital. it is assumed that people go for a specific product at some point during their monetary history. it is considered money until the end they reached silver and gold because of the features of the beginning that they do not go for gold and silver , they take a durable storable commodity as monetary unit money, so see, i want to say let's assume dollars and gold, let's assume housing and land and the capital market, of course, you excluded the capital market from this issue, which means that the capital market is exempt from this contract discussion. i agree that the capital market is also included in this. no, now don't put the capital market in your head, because the situation is so hot now that

people's greed is in it. we can't find the conditions, that's the problem now, everyone has taken their money in this 56 last year, he sat on the black soil at all. don't talk about it at all. no, i don't at all. look , i don't have money . i have nothing to lose. a university professor has nothing to lose my money. they know that we don't have any other income except for the salary we teach. the same teacher is really entitled to his salary, but i want to tell you that you should see that i am talking about the car. let's talk together , a car is a consumer product, like toothpicks, like cash like a toothbrush, any product, like medicine, if we have the root , what caused it, mr. doctor, what happened to the car. why is the car capitalized

, mr. doctor? well, and the second question is, why did all the other goods increase during the last 12 years? i focused on this one , that is, 40-50 times, for example, the year 1990. you have a collection of 400 items of domestic goods. and foreign 400, consider 400 consumer basket items of the same cpi index. and the assets are the same 5 that we mentioned, we can see that in a period of 12 years, they have all increased by 50 times, so they are all due to inflation. there are and i also know what factors shape inflation . the second point is the car. why is egypt out of the consumption mode of capital goods? can you guide me? tell me why . let us understand why. why is a car a consumer product ? in fact, it should be a consumer product. housing

is also the same, that is, anyone who is housing, by no means , by no means, mr. doctor, is not like this. right now, you should check the tax reforms of canada to see how many tax reforms and tax reforms canada has implemented in recent years, when in fact it has been so-called immigration-friendly. from the id tax itself capital and others. he has assumed the tax rights to control his housing market and in fact approved it and moved it forward . i gave you the example of england. about the countries , i would like to serve you now. first, let's make this clear . why is the car a hybrid? previously, the nation used to go this way and that with horses. 200 years ago, 300 years ago, now it has become a hybrid, for example, a four-wheeler that

should be let's ride it and go this way and that way some time ago, i went to buy a car. we entered a so-called parking lot. this parking lot was full of cars and these cars had about half an inch of dirt sitting on them . it is a parking lot in the middle of tehran. for example, in tehran and qom in the middle of tehran, there are so many cars next to each other with half an inch of dirt sitting on them. what happened to make me buy a car? i don't want to buy cars, all kinds of cars the cars that i can actually buy the various international winners in this mr. d. you can put the

hoarding of the car. when we say that land is an adjective, look, it is not someone who wants to keep a 50-meter piece for himself or a 100-meter piece for his child. until the child, if he gets married, the house of life actually has a shelter, not those people who happen to buy the car, who sell it. with a shock, they will sell this at a higher price . why do you think that the medicine is not economical with the problems we have? no

, the medicine may not be economical . there is very

little milk powder in the market right now. as you also said , i will confirm that there are a series of problems. our production has fundamental problems. our production has fundamental problems, so we have to talk about it in a complete package , but we want to talk about inflation . look, i say, if i believe in the long term , yes, if someone keeps a car for a long time. 6 it was kept for a year, it was kept for 5 years, you have to adjust for inflation, there is no problem, our dispute and our scientific discussion, our debt dispute, so

to speak, short-term, under one year, let's assume two years, this is one or two years that a person is on his own. he buys a product so that he can buy this capital asset in order to sell it later. i say that if they carry out this inflationary adjustment, not only will i create an economic benefit for him, but he will continue this cycle again and again, but it will also create conditions for him. i brought it so that the party does not find motivation to make a production at all, to think about the production at all. that, sir, i should open a shop, open a workshop , go to a technician, learn a technique, i don't know a technique , have a professional technical workshop, choose a professor , and so on. it doesn't work for him, because we didn't allow him to work because we left the space so open that you, sir, can take your money . take a certain amount and use it. you are in a fight with us and that is our scientific discussion here

. do you believe that this is short-term and long -term? do you think that you should be threatened with taxes? not me, i am speaking in general . look, mr. doctor, i still have the same opinion, because now numbers and numbers, maybe we should sit together with numbers and numbers. for the long term , let's sit down and estimate some models. see, i have never seen that gambling or speculation is the root of inflation or has a significant contribution to inflation. i would like to point out, mr. doctor, prominent economic experts in the country and even abroad. i can name for you that

the commercial bank imbalance and the capital account imbalance recently, the imbalance of electricity, gas, water, and gasoline, and these are all the engines of inflation, because when an imbalance occurs, the government in charge inevitably puts pressure on the budget, such as the imbalance of pension funds, which was inevitably the 17th general budget of this year, the government's contribution to the funds. the budget deficit goes up by the channel or the central bank or the banking system. let's take this as an opinion and see that extreme speculation. i still believe that i am not saying that

speculation cannot be a factor in inflation, it can be a factor in expectations, but what share does it have? we value its priority and importance, we cannot leave something for later. let's go to that feature of that agent or that german who has a small share . the second issue is again, i believe that in our own country, we go forward with a single policy many times . mr. moderator wants a package of policies. everyone has their own mentality. for example, i said two days ago that we saw a dispute about refining, if you invite that minister, he will argue for you that

this should have been done. check it out you can see that yes, it was useful, but it was harmful . when you analyze the cost and benefit in another area, you can see that the benefit was less than the cost, so you should not do this. i want to say that when you have a partial view of the issue, you who sit there in the tax organization or the ministry of economy analyze it from your own angle, you say that it is very good , but not for this issue , i want to say that i have different institutions, so is it the minister? the one who issued this notification was aware of not having an expert and proved and proves that he should have done this or the one who paid the price. if he is an expert , can he explain it to me, but mr. doctor, you can see that he hits a certain point, it brings a benefit , it creates thousands of costs, so from this point of view

, i want to say that we wanted a policy package, taxes again. doctor, i believe that tax requires a policy package, not only on capital gains, even if i say one more thing, now is not the time to open this , i believe that even though i agree with the tax system, it will increase. tax revenues, the government's reliance on taxes, increasing the government's share of taxes, increasing taxes on production, but this medicine for by the way, i don't recommend iran's economy at this time. even though i know that this is a medicine, but different economic conditions, like any other doctor, a doctor examines the patient in his time, says this... even though i know, for example , that it is useful for his heart system, that is, use it is possible , but now is not the time because, for example, his diabetes is high,

so analysis. the patient is also important. i still believe that if there was no tax , i would have mentioned the entire tax system, and i still believe that there is nothing wrong with spending time to prove this. to prove it, you can come here, mr. minister, come here, mr. dr. supanyan, come and say, look, we sat down with 20 or 30 economists and proved it. it is good that you can see numbers and figures . once we talk with numbers and figures , our work will be much easier and it will be easier for me to

accept . and the tax affairs organization, i want to make a correction here. i came here as an expert so that i can freely compare those experts in the field of taxation in id that before i was following the tax affairs organization . i would like to tell you this. when our game quality is zero, how much will the tax be on our game's hard game? zero tax for tax capital.

in fact, my first proposal is to see if extreme tightening has an effect on inflation. i have been discussing various topics with different professors and economists for a few years now. yes , it has been many years. and by the way, we see many examples of different domestic and foreign economists who actually agree on this issue. i have time to confirm this. i have a minute to talk about it. it is very good. i will say that you, who took this trouble, now have no problem. you, as a doctorate in economics, are in the tax organization. it is not a problem that you are speaking now as my bachelor's degree. let's do it. i can say from the experience of all this that there is no problem, but i say that you should take this trouble. it is very good . invite economists from different fields and prove it with numbers and figures in the ministry of economy. if it is proven that it can be the root of speculation.

this needs a proof, i haven't seen it yet, and my little study is just a theoretical analysis in my own mind, i thank you very much, thank you very much to both the guests of the program, all the good viewers, especially the higher program, who have accompanied us as always until this moment, god, keep us safe , wherever we are today, we will be higher tomorrow.

in the name of allah, the most merciful, the most merciful, may god bless muhammad and the family of muhammad and hasten their fate. greetings and good morning to you, dear and respected viewers. welcome to the sports news of our country's national football team with a victory over the uae with 9 points and as the leader of the first-team group. it was the eighth final of the asian nations cup.