above, in this part of this program, we want to talk about the budget ceiling for football clubs and have a debate with the supporters and opponents of setting the budget ceiling for football clubs. i invite you to join us in this discussion if you are interested. follow from khabar network. thank you. the importance of elections in electing a strong parliament. the key is in the hands of the people . iranian coach sharaf iran. we do not agree that high is higher than any or higher today wherever we are.

you are special for the election program. the leader of the revolution in his recent meetings called the real competition one of the important pillars calling elections means that the field is open for the presence of different political, economic and cultural views, so that everyone can express their different views, and in the big election race, in this field, an active presence and in this great record, a real competition. the formation of the body is one of the topics that experts disagree about in the field of sports, and the topic of this part of the program is higher, and those who agree are those who agree to be invited for this debate. but it was implemented once he withdrew for some reasons, but for this year's league , the current league, as you know, this has been implemented and is being done now. i want to give you a very simple service. this is that

every sports club and football club has a ceiling that should not be exceeded, that is, all the players it buys, all the expenses it spends must be specified within that ceiling and not higher than that, which is between 250 and 300 billion. some clubs rejected this ceiling, some clubs were fined, this did not happen to them, of course, as i told you, this decision and this incident happened. there are pros and cons. the pros are for the reason that now, in order to be more fair , in order to be more monitoring, to prevent me from inviting you to attend, and also to have clubs in an ideal situation , to have a more equal competition with each other, this resolution i know that it needs to be implemented. the opponents of this matter say that there is too much possibility of avoiding it , as it happened in the past years. it is common in this way. it is not a special companion to the election program

keep the debate going, thank you. well, here in our studio mr. esadi, the secretary of the football federation, mr. noursharq, the head of the committee to determine the status of the football federation, who naturally agree and mr. esadi opposes the issue that i presented to you, but before we start the debate, the report of colleagues in the ready sports group. i invite you to see the report together, let's come back and start the debate. one of the most brilliant, best, and most appropriate things that the federation has done in this period is that it has created this ceiling in accordance with the country's conditions, even if it is the best and most brilliant law. do when there is no enforceable guarantee, it means illegality of the law. the football federation, which

had put fear into the lives of the teams, was broken in the appeals committee and the budget limit was increased in the middle of the year. i don't know if these events only happen in iranian football. we don't really see these events every year. financial problems are taking place and new laws are being enacted . we have formed a working group in the football federation, which concluded contracts in the clubs. of course, football players are not strangers to these rules, laws that only increased the margins of football, for example, the ceiling of the contract. players in the 90s, i

can honestly say that my contract was not 350 million tomans. that year, i went to the federation, and at that time, mr. kakhvashian, mr. taj, mr. aziz mohammadi, and mr. haj, mr. alipour, approved our contract or the law prohibiting the recruitment of foreign goalkeepers, which many opposed. had a rule was also added that indebted teams do not have the right to recruit foreign players, which was removed before the end of the season. if we are on equal terms we should definitely prefer domestic players over foreign players. we also had a law to attract good foreign players. in this rule, teams are only allowed to recruit. asian national players and working in european leagues. a rule that some teams avoid. you are coming to a street, it announces that it is one way. now, one or two of them may pass and some like golghar will pay a heavy price for it in the bagnama case.

riyal contracts were also written next to the rules specific to our country's football, which even some domestic players did not follow. our football is full of rules, connect in the morning and become defective at night it has been and we will probably have more of these laws. now, according to the implementation of the budget cap law in clubs, is the contract cap law mandatory for players? mehdi ali moradi, sada wasima news agency. you are a special companion of the higher program . allow me to start with mr. asadi and this question , mr. asadi, why do you fundamentally oppose the contract ceiling for football players, where does the reason for this opposition come from ? blessings to amir

al-mu'minan ali bin abi talib and to all the shiites of the world and today's people. congratulations to all your loved ones let me say that entering into the discussion from here seems to me to be somewhat marginal. if we create a general rule in our minds , based on which we will discuss when we come to this question or the answer in this discussion. did we give it, or is there no question at all in this area? if we look at it from above, this is what we want this football for, that is, this is football, and every activity that exists in the country should become wealth in the field of our education . every activity in the country should become

wealth. as a social phenomenon, it must be it should have this rule, otherwise it will definitely fail in the long run. and we will not have the things we expect from football in the social, cultural, economic, and political fields. one of the issues that is currently being discussed in our football is that it must be said clearly that our country's football is completely broken. when a country has no income from football , what is the meaning of the ceiling? we have to go in the same direction as football. we are turning from a traditional field into an industrial one, and for it to turn into an industry, you must pay attention to its products in the planning strategy of these officials who come to be at the head of the federation or the ministry in other places that i see

, there is no such vision at all, and this is a cause for concern. when you don't have the resources to manage your financial balance, which is negative, when you want to do it, you should go in this direction by yourself. there is no need for a law . if you don't have money in your pocket, you should buy a benz. why are we looking for a benz player? why? the reason is that we have this macro understanding of the program our macro and strategic are affected. my problem is, i would really like to get the answers to my questions in this meeting or any meeting. of course , dr. noorsharq is one of our very good friends in the legal field, maybe my main audience is not dr. noorsharq at all

. agree with me , they can't do much now as an agreement, mr. noursharq , why do you agree with this, how does it help if we have a contract ceiling for our football players , and a budget ceiling for our clubs. in the name of god, i want too. amir al-mu'minin imam ali (peace be upon him) i congratulate you and the dear viewers and also on father's day to all our dear fathers. let us first of all make sure and bless our program with a hadith from amir al-mu'minin who said, "before you find sorrow and opportunity, find opportunities." before they bring sorrow, i hope this program will be an opportunity for more clarification regarding this issue. and to provide proper information and analysis about this, i borrow from the statements of mr.

dr. asadi, who mentioned the bad financial situation of our clubs, which is not a new issue and has been for years. this issue has been affecting our football for years, and when mr. esadi himself was the general secretary of the federation, they were closely involved with this issue. i think that they have a job and the reason they mention this issue is their exact information about this issue. well, if we are faced with a problem called the unfavorable financial situation of the clubs, which has various reasons, and in my opinion, in an independent program or programs, we should the pathology of this payment is why our clubs are in a financial situation. they may be inappropriate and i am not sure about the interpretation i don't use it because, well, he

has a special right, i think we should talk about it separately , this is a very important issue, what is the root of these issues and the current situation, but if you think that he is facing this challenge of the bad financial situation, according to your interpretation, it is not true. this is the most important issue if you pay all this program and some other programs. it is appropriate to use different experts from their opinions on why our football is at the club level despite the fact that they have the so-called professional title and why i am in this situation. to enter this topic, i think the best entry to enter this topic is the administrator's entry. that our club ownership system

is run on the basis of independent legal companies, that is, we have an independent company, which is the company that manages the cultural and sports club, now there are different ones in the country, in your corporate system , you have different pillars, the highest pillar of the company is its public assemblies, which have different powers they make major decisions for the management of that company and these decisions are naturally communicated to the board of directors , and the board of directors manages the management of the company in the form that the assemblies approve the issues for them. the managing director, which is characteristic of us, today's discussion is about the first financial challenges of our club, we want to say why you basically agree and decide that if you are a club, your expenses

are not commensurate with the sources of income that you can expect, what do you expect, that is, it will not happen except that it will go to hell. you will face financial problems, this is what has happened many times in the football of our country, and this is where the expectation is from the football federation to enter into this. it is a thoughtless solution for us to enter a financial discipline system. thank you how much does mr. esadi agree that the federation? if he comes and puts a ceiling in order to be able to manage the income and expenses of the clubs , it may be acceptable as a housing, but during the management time, when this happens again, this housing will not work. because we have a state of resistance, like medicine, we have a state of resistance. he finds that in relation to this story and this disease, it turns from an acute state to a chronic state, and the difference is that in a chronic state

, there is time to fix it, provided that there is also the will, now i don't give this will much , but in this part if my federation wants to come , do it in a partial way and not to the main form should be the main resources that exist in the country and the main abilities that exist in the country and these rules exist in all countries, but in our country we cannot use these, that is, we in football are an industry of this football industry in the world. from the beginning, we do not want to go to the wheel and invent that we should be able to take advantage of this industry. one of the sources that generate income for football is what is the right to broadcast television for the clubs? the field of communication with the government of the parliament

in my opinion, the ceiling of the contract is an apartment. no, is it the duty of the federation or not, no, yes, yes, the federation is one of the things it can do, this is regulation, monitoring and setting regulations. it is one of the capabilities of a federation to regulate that work , that is, the rest of the federations of other countries. so, do this if their conditions are like this, if their conditions are really like this, they will go in this direction, but it is temporary, that is, you can do this once, twice, three times, on the condition that you set indicators that those who are your members and the sub-category of the federation is not allowed to violate . for example, a club comes and says how much is the fine for the contract

. i will break the ceiling . they know that management in the field of management is not worthy at all, so what should the federation do? my tools are the same , and our tools are not the tools that can bring the system together , that is, don't let it reach the point where it can balance the justice that exists in the discussion of football. be aware that the tools are very limited bigger work. the most important thing that can be done is to consult with the state assembly and those who can help the structure of football in this area, the issue of spectator attendance, the issue of ticket sales, the issue of sponsorship, the issue of economic resources that can come in football, and the issue of communication that we can pay attention to through football.

it brings a lot of resources to the system, thank you mr. nursharq . yes, of course you agree that the supervision of the football federation and the clubs was confirmed in the orders of mr. dr. asdeem. the guarantee of his performances and his exact performance, in my opinion, they indicate that we must agree with this issue , see that they indicate that we are not reinventing the wheel, this is definitely the case in the world. there is, and different issues can be raised about it. since 2010, uefa has seriously entered into the issue of financial discipline, which was known as financial fair play, and found these important developments after the corona pandemic and the economic issues caused by corona. fairplay's financial developments

became much more serious due to the club's economy and led to a change in the regulations, i.e. what was previously under it was referred to as financial fair play or financial balance. in 2022, it underwent a major change and was based on three axes. now, in order not to make the program boring, i will talk about these three axes in the next part. my intention is that it seems whether in the football fan community or in the department. the management of the club or the federation is not against the discipline-oriented monitoring of the financial issues of the clubs. you see, one of the pests that threatened our clubs in the past few years is the rulings issued

by international authorities. proceedings against the club we issued and frequently closed the club's transfer window or considered a stricter executive guarantee for them. the expectation from the football federation is to intervene effectively in this matter and other financial classes of the clubs' bad performance, and to point out a point that it is profitable for the teams to pay a fine for this violation, and set an example. yes, this is the supervisor. look at the effective implementation of the regulations. let me give you an example from uefa. there, there are also various performance guarantees, monetary fines and points deductions. or even being banned from participating in european competitions now, since the opinion of this meeting is the directive regarding the ceiling of contracts and the budget, which

was raised recently and you saw that the football federation was seriously and decisively seeking to implement it, it is good to know that this directive is for the current season, that is, the title is the same season. current 1402 143 and even. for the next season, based on the many suggestions received from the clubs , we will examine this issue in the relevant working group, and the recipe for the next season will be submitted to the federation. it is not for players, what do you think? every shower means that you own most of the resources that the club spends. you know, this ceiling is more when it is considered for the club, it is for the highest amount of expenses, which leads to the contracts that

are signed with the clubs, what seems to me that now this discussion of making mr. doctor is a correct discussion, a supervisory discussion. the football federation is on the contract, now the main issue is how we can get out of the clubs that you are looking at now, what percentage of them are private clubs. they usually spend their resources like this because they have no income many of the things i said are bankrupt , when the financial balance of a company is negative for several years, you can change its name, if from the legal point of view , if they give a different name now, i don't know the method, but this process will certainly not be a good process, and in the end, we we want to say something , we will take this budget and turn it into. we are making a plan , we want to release the output of our product, that is, what do we want to do, that is, in a one-year activity process called the final league, the clubs

ask what their story is, i think we can continue the discussion here with a question and that that we if the order there is a circle between this option that the football federation has an effective and efficient supervision to improve the situation, which you will definitely approve. the positive effects of this directive on the budget ceiling in this season cannot be denied, and the second option is to negate and not have this supervision and leave the matter independently and exclusively to the clubs . it was very good, because the answer to this question is raised like this, since when is this ceiling limit the same thing as in europe. it was mentioned that their income and expenses are completely specific, i.e. profit you have to show the end of their structure, otherwise they will not be allowed to participate in the competitions from the federation

, but in our federation system, it is not like this at all , that is, if a club with a negative balance even so much now, i don't know how to say this in this media because it is broadcast live. later, those who are with fifa can take the blame for this. i don't want to get into this story too much, but it happened that our clubs raised their financial indicators at the international level, which were unrealistic, and it was the duty of the federation to take care of this before. do not let this happen at all, what is the result? as a result, these regulations are very good in the form of housing. if i had to answer your question , which one would you choose, i would say that we don't have time for this matter right now, so let's do some curtailment , and then when the resources are ready

, we will remove this curtailment. i promise you, this will never happen until that happens. it should not be done in the area of ​​policy making. what are those areas ? we don't have any sources of income for the clubs, so let me see the answer to the question, mr. noorshaq. to get it or not, i felt that every time mr. asadi entered into the sources of income, the subject of my right to appeal it has changed, no, please. well, if you didn't get your answer, please let me know. we don't have a point. it's not my question, but their words are better . you asked a question and got an answer. between those two options, i imagine that choosing the same option as the federation and the football community wants, it definitely means, sir. in any case, the executive work at the higher level in the federation and the clubs know what conditions we will face without this supervision, see

if you agree to the supervision and let us reduce it, what should we do, let's buy an opportunity . he can't use it because he doesn't have the tools he has absolutely no ability to consult and solve these problems. the problems are not at the level of the federation, they are higher than the federation, but it is important for him to think that mr. noushraf should at least spend money on my character. let me mention one thing here . it is better to see a live and implemented example. at.

let's talk about it at the world level. i said that in uefa in 2022 , these regulations were changed and some basic pillars were found, which are called the changes in financial balance from 202 onwards , for example, in the drama department of cost control. the clubs are doing serious monitoring and you say in your income section if you are a wealthy owner. for the club, what comes from the rich owner's pocket cannot exceed a certain ceiling, so to speak, and the club must have its own sources of income and its expenses must be proportional to its sources of income . clubs

are allowed to spend up to one percent more than their revenue resources. this approach is actually localized , nationalized and in accordance with the requirements of our country's football . i definitely have this expectation on the implementation of these regulations and i hope that we will see more positive effects from this recipe in the future . we are implementing, for example, they have a ceiling. the principle of the matter is the principle of the matter. a principle has been accepted. you saw a few months ago that the asian football confederation communicated this to the member countries of the confederation that you should move in the direction of the financial pepper. well, this is based on the transparency of the sources. revenue, cost transparency and maintaining balance between clubs is being implemented as a regulation, for example

let's say that in european clubs and in asian clubs, their federations come and say, for example, this club should not sign a contract for more than this amount , its budget should not increase more than this amount. let's discuss, the viewers will be fined and this. i would like to say that it is being implemented in both europe and asia. this is an inevitable issue for our country's football for many reasons. it is definitely in the interest of our country's football. we can deny that some of our clubs have government subsidies and are using government sources of income. you expect that

there will be no monitoring of the sources of income and expenses. no, i asked which country now because i didn't get the answer from you, i'll ask mr. esadi , which countries do you have that have such a difficult disagreement, i don't believe that this discussion will be very difficult , i'm next to saudi arabia, it's not difficult for the club , it doesn't have a hard time, it takes as much as it wants, it takes a player, the whole view of our league is the cost. hashe means that he gets a player who is three times as good as our league and has no line at all which means, at all, their club has one player, if we say the whole league, 6,000 billion, one dutch one, if they sell it to you, maybe a player will come, now messi, and this is not the case at all, that we can win our country with these formats. let's compare, because the indicators should match each other , it doesn't match at all, they get it from underground sources , they don't have any problems between their people, they explain in one

episode.