elections are the key to electing a strong parliament . the key is in the hands of the people. iranian coach sharaf iran has a telegram playing with the whole country. why are you pricing this month? your question is an interesting question. we don't want to be a football manager. we don't agree with any kind of treatment. higher. you are special about the election program . in recent meetings, the leader of the revolution has named real competition as one of the important pillars of the election , which means that the field is open for the presence of different political, economic and cultural views, so that everyone has a point of view. they can express themselves in different ways

the big election contest and an active presence in this field and a real competition in this big contest is one of the issues that experts disagree about in the field of sports, which is the subject of this part of the program, and those who agree with it are invited for this debate. if you remember, this happened a few years ago . it was implemented once, but it was withdrawn for some reasons, but for this year's league. currently, as you know , this event has been implemented. it is being done now . i want to tell you very simply that har sports clubs and football players have always had a ceiling that they should not exceed, that is, all the players they buy, all the expenses they make must be within that ceiling and not exceed that ceiling, which is between 250 and 300 billion tomans. the clubs reject this ceiling. some clubs are fined . this has not happened to them. here in our studio, mr. esadi, the secretary general

of the esber football federation, is also present, as well as mr. noursharq, the head of the committee to determine the status of the football federation . naturally, he agrees, mr. esadi, and opposes the issue that i would like to present to you. along with the special program you are above me, i want to start with mr. esadi and the question, mr. esadi, why do you fundamentally oppose the contract cap for football players , where does the reason for this opposition come from, in the name of allah , rahman, and rahim. i congratulate you on the blessed birth of amir al-mu'minan ali bin abi talib and i congratulate all the shiites of the world and people's day .

let's create a general rule in our mind to discuss based on it when we come to this question either we have answered it in this discussion or there is no question in this field at all. if we look at it from above, it will look like this : why do we want these footballs at all, that is, this is football and every activity that exists in the country should be in the field of our education. it should become wealth. any activity in the country should become wealth. football as a social phenomenon must have this rule, otherwise it will definitely fail in the long run and the things we expect from football in the social, cultural, economic, political fields. and we will not have one of the issues that is currently being discussed in our football is that it must be said clearly that

our country's football is completely broken. when a country's football has no income, it is broken . what is the meaning of the ceiling ? the tradition that is now turning into an industrial industry, and for it to turn into an industry , you have to pay attention to its products, in the planning strategy of these officials who come to be at the head of the federation or the home ministry or other places that i see, there is such a vision at all. no, and this is a cause of concern for a person, yes, when if you want to look at it objectively, my opinion is that when you don't have resources, you can manage your financial balance, which is negative, and when you want to do it , you should go in this direction by yourself . there is no need for a law if you don't have money.

this is that we have this big understanding of the big plan. our strategy is flawed. i would very much like to get the answers to my questions in this meeting or any meeting. of course, dr. noursharq is one of our very good friends in the legal field, maybe my main audience is not mr. noursharq at all, and we are very much on the same page. stop talking agree with me, they are speaking at all, now as a supporter, you can't do much, mr. noursharq , why do you agree with this? what help do you think it will help us to have a contract ceiling for our football players, and a budget ceiling for our clubs, in the name of god? i also

congratulate you and dear viewers on the birthday of amir al-mu'minin imam, peace be upon him, and also on father's day to all dear fathers. let us start by blessing our program with a hadith from amir. it is not, and for many years this issue has plagued our football and when mr. esadi himself is also the secretary the whole federation was in charge of dealing closely with this issue, and the reason they mentioned this issue, i think that this is their exact information about this issue, so if

we are facing a problem called the unfavorable financial situation of the club. there are different reasons and in my opinion. in an independent program or programs, it is necessary to address the pathology of why our clubs may be in an inappropriate situation in terms of finances and sources of income and expenses, and i do not use the term broken because, well, he has a special right to i have a different opinion about it now it should be said that this is a very important issue that is the root of these issues. what is the situation, but if you think that you are not facing this challenge of bad financial situation, this is really the most important issue that if you pay attention to this whole program and several other programs, you should use different experts. from

their opinions, why is our football at the club level despite the fact that they have the so-called professional title. but why am i in this situation? if i want to enter this topic from a so-called window, i think the best entry to enter this is the subject of the entry is the management of clubs. you understand that our club ownership system is run on the basis of independent legal companies, that is, we have an independent company that is run by that company. there are various cultural and sports clubs in the country. in the company system, you have different pillars. the highest pillar of the company is its general assemblies, which

take major decisions for the management of the company with different levels of authority, and these decisions are naturally communicated to the board of directors, and the board of directors is responsible for the management of the company in a free format. for them , the managing director manages the approval of issues our characteristic is that today's discussion is not about the first financial challenges of the clubs, we want to say why you basically agree and what is your decision for the clubs to have a contract ceiling. well , one of the reasons is that when you are at the management level of a club, your expenses are proportional to the resources. you cannot expect an income, what do you expect , it will not happen except that you will fall into the abyss of financial problems. this is an incident that has happened many times in the football of our country and it is from here that the expectation from the football federation is to enter into this issue and think of a solution so that we let's introduce a financial discipline system. thank you, mr.

esadi, how much do you agree that the federation should come and set a ceiling so that it can manage the income and expenses of the clubs as one. the painkiller may be acceptable, but during the management time, when this happens again, this painkiller does not work because it is a state of our resistance, like our medicine. we are becoming resistant to this story and this disease is turning from an acute state to a chronic state, and the difference is that in a chronic state , there is time to fix it, provided that there is also the will. in this regard, if my federation wants to come , it should be done in a partial way and not in the main way, the main resources that exist in the country and the main capabilities that exist in the country , and there are these rules in all countries, but in the country

of the country we can't use these things , that is, we in football are an industry, this football industry in our world, we don't want to go and invent from the beginning , that we should be able to use the resources of this industry. what is one of the sources that generate income for football? tv broadcasting rights for the club. that is, the work i mentioned is a duty is there a federation or not? in the field of communication with the government of the parliament, yes, the right to broadcast television , no, the ceiling of the contract that i put , the ceiling of the contract is for a house, in my opinion, no , is it the responsibility of the federation or not? regulating the rules is one of the powers of a federation

, because if you set indicators that those who are members of the federation are not allowed to violate . this as a management art in the field of management they know it's not appropriate at all, so what should the federation do? they say that 's all my tools are, that's all. it means that it should not reach the point where

it can maintain the balance of justice that exists in the discussion of football, its tools are very limited, but the bigger and more important thing that can be done is to consult with the parliament and those who can help in the structure of football. what is the issue of attendance, the issue of ticket sales, the issue of sponsorship, the issue of economic resources that can come in football, the issue of communication. i think the supervision of the football federation and the clubs it was approved in the orders of mr. dr. esadi , mostly the so-called feedbacks and guarantees of his performances and his exact implementation. in my opinion, they point out that we must also agree on the same issue , you see, that means you agree that

it is our phase, yes, pointing out that we are not reinventing the wheel , it is definitely the same. since 2010, uefa has seriously entered into the issue of financial discipline , known as financial fair play, and found these important developments after the corona pandemic and economic issues that corona brought about these financial fair play changes became much more serious due to the economy of the club and led to a change in the regulations, that is, what was previously referred to as financial fair play or financial balance got a major change in 2020 and on three axes. it was established that now , in order not to make the program boring, i will talk about these three axes in the next part. my intention is that

it seems that both in the football fan community and in the management part of the club or the federation, there is someone who is against the supervision of law and order. it is not discipline-oriented on the financial issues of the clubs one of the pests that threatened our clubs in the past few years is the rulings of the international authorities . issued against our clubs and frequently close the club's transfer window or consider a stricter performance guarantee for them . the expectation from the football federation is to effectively intervene in this matter and other financial classes of the clubs' bad performance, and

to point out a point that it costs the teams to pay a fine for this violation . yes, this is the supervisor. see the effective implementation of regulations again, let me give you an example from uefa, where different performance guarantees are applied, fines, deduction of points or even exclusion from participating in european competitions. that the federation. football was seriously and decisively looking for its implementation , it is good to know that this recipe is for the current season, that is, the title is the same as the current season 1402 143 and for the next season, based on the many proposals received from the clubs, especially this

issue we will check in the relevant working group and the recipe for the next season will be prepared by the federation. mr. esadi, one point that is raised is why the budget limit is for the team and not for the players. what is your opinion? in any case, it means that most of the resources that the club spends are the player's, which means that the ceiling is higher when it is considered for the club, but it is the highest amount of money that leads to the contracts that are signed with the clubs, which is what i think. now this discussion that the doctor made. later, there is a correct discussion, a supervisory discussion of the football federation on the contract, now the main discussion is what we look like from this, let's go out of the clubs that you are looking at now, what percentage of them are private clubs, which usually spend their resources like this because they do not have any income

. i do n't know how to give it another name, but this process will certainly not be a good process, and in the end , we want to say something . we want to output our product, what do we want to do? let's do it, that is, the clubs will study in a one-year activity process called the final league , whatever their story is, i think it will be here. he continued the discussion with one question, and that is, if it is a matter of choice between the option that the football federation has an effective and efficient supervision to improve the situation, which you definitely confirm that this directive regarding the budget ceiling in this season can have positive effects. there is no denial and the second option is

to deny this surveillance and not have it directly. and let's leave it to the clubs , mr. asadi, which option they choose exactly it was a very good question. i am raising the answer to this question in this way. when did this ceiling limit come from ? it is what was raised in europe. their income and expenses are clearly defined, which means that the profit must be shown at the end of their structure, otherwise they will not be allowed by the federation. they are not allowed to participate in competitions, but in the system of our federation , it is not like this at all, that is, from in a club with a negative balance even so much now, i don't know how to say this in this media because it will be broadcasted live, later those who are with fifa can get a ball from this . i don't want to get too involved in this story, but it happened. that our clubs' financial indicators

are not at the international level and it was the duty of the federation to take care of this before and not let this happen at all. what is the result? the result is the same as these regulations. which one do you choose? i say , let's take time for this issue, we don't have it right now, so let's do some curtailment, and then when the resources are ready , we'll take this curtailment, i promise you. this will never happen until something big happens in the field of politics , what are those fields? we have no sources of income for the clubs we don't have i felt that every time mr. esadi asked about the sources of income and the issue of right

of return, the discussion changed. no, please. well, if you don't get your answer, please tell us. we don't have a point. it's not my question, but what he said is that you asked a question and got an answer . i imagine that it's between those two options. who chose the same option as desired by the federation and the football community . in order to get better from this disease , we cannot save a serious disease with stampe, we can reduce the patient's pain a little

. that he doesn't have the tools and he doesn't have the ability to go to the bandit to solve his problems, the problems are not at the level of the federation, they are higher than the federation, but it is important to think about it, mr. noushraf, at least let me point out one thing about my personality . let's talk about its implementation at the world level. i said that in uefa in 2022, these regulations were changed and some basic pillars were found, what is known as the so-called changes in financial balance from 202 onwards and there came, for example, in the drama department of clubs' expenses is under serious supervision

bringing and saying in your income section, if the club has a wealthy owner, what the club receives from the pocket of the wealthy owner cannot exceed a certain ceiling, so to speak, and the club must have its own sources of income and its expenses are proportional. it should have a relationship with its sources of income . well, there too, of course, up to a certain limit , clubs are allowed to spend up to one percent more than their sources of income. well, this approach has actually been localized and nationalized, and in accordance with the requirements of our country's football, this is the order. it is an action that you are observing, in any case, we cannot deny that a number of clubs. we have government subsidies and they are using government sources of income . you expect that

there is no supervision of the sources of income and the expenses that are made. no, i asked which country. now, since i did not get an answer from you, i will ask mr. esadi which countries are you. they are making it difficult in this way . i don't believe the difference of opinion. see, this discussion is very difficult. next to us , saudi arabia, the club does not have a hard time. our entire league has a fee, that is, it takes a player who is not in line with our league, that is, the club at all they have one player , and we, if we say our whole league, it is worth 6 thousand billion, and if they sell it to you, maybe a player will come, now messi and that is in his place . it has to work together, it doesn't work at all , they get it from underground resources

, they don't have any problems between their people, they explain that they have a policy in order to make history for themselves. they can only solve a problem like this they can solve it. now you can say, for example, in one of the american states, for example, where iran is. do you mean iraq or not like this, but now when you say qatar, they say yes , that is where the world cup was held, that means they are making history for themselves, now what are the policies of their own country , what are the europeans, which countries have a ceiling for their players, they look at the club at all, nothing at all. they don't have any financial turnover , they will tax it no matter how much it increases, they never want to assume any limit for them, why should they assume such a limit, the economic open space is included. anyone who can attract more fans will make more money and sell more. in general, his target society is trying to expand economically

. we do not think so. we don't act like this. who are the directors of our club now ? what are all the appointments related to football? nothing, many of them, nothing . what do you expect? who knows about it?

i tell you that it is so old with the structure of football our country doesn't have them, i don't want to say that it's not possible, i know i want to say because. they are not familiar with football in the clubs, they don't know the problems of football , that's why if they make any decision , they are not responsible for the expenses of this football in the material, spiritual, and moral field . they will eventually resign. the national debate that we will follow , we will hold a field for a year, what do we want from

it, a result of mr. esadi's orders, more monitoring is necessary , it seems to me that he is agreeing as the opposition, not me, not me, you. i'm right you say, look, i have a field of competence in the legal field. i have a box called the supervision of the committee for monitoring the state of the game. you call it a coach, and you are a special person . you know the law. i also have a manager's sweat because i have a soccer player's sweat.

i have another idea that since i am not in the football federation now, it can be used as a platform to say a series of words that people should know. of course , you should not be responsible for these words. sit here, of course, you will not lose your values , my dear, you will grow up. you know that i like you, you are my friend and i am very knowledgeable in the legal field, but the discussion that is being discussed here is big football and there is an item that you have a special sensitivity method. we are doing our job well, i say yes, but i am telling you this, exactly, i am telling you that even though you are doing a good job, the output of the football structure that you agree with me will not be a good product. thank you if you agree before ordering it. let's have mr. nursharq let's take a look at the opinions of other supporters and

opponents. we will continue this debate . in favor of mansour qombarzadeh, vice president of the football federation, the managing directors of esteghlal and persplis thanked and said that if it were not for this ceiling and the recipe, we would have reached the border of bankruptcy with this debt situation and economic conditions. i am under contract. teams should hire players and coaches according to their needs. we should learn how to make money, not to prevent spending money. saudi arabia and nasr brought ronaldo, who paid 100 million dollars. we if we give 2 million dollars to one of our players , everyone's voice will be heard. great clubs must have great players and coaches. according to ehsan usoli, a member of the board of the president of the football federation. the issue of the contract ceiling of premier league football players has been raised by the head of the league organization. 14 premier league clubs up to