we should have nuts and bolts as variable rate so that we can reach the desired state , we can adjust the market to some extent, but if we want to see the areas of the digital economy with a legislative approach, we have to stop and see, measure the risk , determine the framework, approve, move forward, sometimes we see it. meanwhile, the changed concept of a changed entity 2 years ago, there was no news about nft. last year, there was no news about web shooting. today , what do we want to do in web shooting technology, which in my opinion is the most important concern in the field of digital economy? its main basis is blockchain and currency codes, without the idea of ​​metaverse, without the idea of ​​artificial intelligence, without the idea of ​​blockchain, how are we going to go about web shooting, and if we want to legislate, we should do it in the same way as mr. doctor says, in my opinion, we just

wasted an opportunity. until today, with the method we have taken, we have missed opportunities, which i will mention, mr. karani, how much do you agree with mr. ashrani's statements? look at product legislation, legal policy, legal policy , a subset of general policy, we must have a methodical intellectual discipline. because the system for example, we don't need to regulate finances in every field for every unit of economic, political , and social transformation of the law. if the parliament of the islamic republic of iran has not done anything since the beginning of the revolution, and if we really do this as a warning to all those who are concerned about this , they will appear in the parliament as representatives of the nation and help pass legislation. i want you to know that once and for all, if you are appointed as a member of the parliament, god willing, think about the concept of community legislation , if we have a community legislation in the field of economic law. it's enough, we don't need to come face to face 5 years at a time to see what's happening with today's technology? it happened that the legislation of the society, if

it is observed in its scientific meaning, it answers everything . for us, the legislation of the society has many, many requirements. i will suffice that, for example, if we had written the law on computer crimes in 2088 and in the form of a society law, we should not have to do it today. we were worried about the fact that this law has even wrongly defined theft, the law of 2008 has even wrongly defined computer fraud. they are working in the field of crypto-currency, they are worried that if my information, for example , is hacked in some way, the information is not property at all. if it is stolen, what is the status of the follow-up now, what crime am i facing now , our current laws do not answer this , because we do not have legislation in the society , unfortunately, our approach is a very sloppy, undisciplined, undisciplined approach. for example , we look at the issue from the angle of the election, as the famous saying says, it is from the angle of propaganda, so we have to leave these things aside and speak very scientifically logically. from a scientific point of view, if we have an economic society legislation, whether in the cyberspace or in the normal and classical space

, we will not have any so-called problems in the next 20 years in the face of the modern technological world, because the society's legislation extends to everything, so to speak. all the criminal economic and financial laws of switzerland have not been equivalent to the laws passed by the government of the islamic republic of iran from the beginning of 2014 until now, when we are at the door of bahman 402. well, this is self- explanatory. setting the society and perhaps to some extent with your discussion, this case is compatible have it means

what we are worried about today is for the country, why am i? in the space we have created for the country , in the field of regulation until today, that is , what has happened until today , we stopped the growth and development . why did we stop an active business? in

fact, develop the appropriate tools for this field, and it has made the iranian person able to find a beautiful technical competitive position in the foreign platform in the field of ramreza affected. unfortunately , this is one of the biggest damages that we have seen in the cryptocurrency field in 2018, a foreign platform for all iranian cryptocurrency assets for iranians. before that, in 2013, a platform like amtigax suffered a fracture. no one's hands were tied anywhere, especially if it is from iran. this is one of the things that actually holds our national wealth. when we accept that this is it is an opportunity that has arisen for the people and for the country that we have this kind of limitless wealth in the future boundless world and the boundless digital economy that is unimaginable without this kind of wealth .

we, the people , read the report with an approximate level of influence, almost equal to that of russia it was about 10 and one tenth percent penetration rate, we have a definite penetration rate among the population of our country in the area. in fact, when we have such an opportunity, our user does not remember, in fact , he chooses a foreign business and a competitor with new tools . the case with a special type is actually a good regulation that we could not do in this field. what is the reason for this? this is one of the damages and the lawless and unregulated situation , the lawless and unregulated situation is another one of

the lack of development of our educational field . in my next part, please let me complete this, the field of education is almost not in our universities, the field of arithmetic. we had a total of 5 scientific articles from our university professors in the field of blockchain, cryptography and other things , so far there has been no proper account of this situation in our country after all these years and so many users. it's a bit strange, this is due to the shortness of the crying arrangement , which i think is worthy of criticism , and the fact is that it's my own fault. thank you , mr. karuni, mr. ashtiani . your suggestion regarding the legislation is that growth and development are prevented and that there is no such regulation . yes, look, this really needs to be clarified. honestly , i agree with this , that is, it is logical. this is the correct statement. economic and functional, as

the famous saying means the real capitalizer of this matter let's see, there can be no objection at all, we need this issue, we honestly need it. can our society help people? i believe in a person. look at the civil law. we define property. we say that property must be something or an asset that has a legitimate and rational benefit. this is our entire definition of property in our civil laws . therefore, we can call whatever we want as property or property. it should have these parameters in a cumulative and cumulative way. the land code has this parameter. i think our problem is that we have to sit at a scientific table next to each other. this. let's make it clear, sir, now you see, considering that we can't talk about the issue at the moment, nor the prescription, the government has taken a position that, in my opinion, someone is saying that there is a so-called horseshoe, which means that the government is actually coming from a different angle. he accepts that the crypto currency has legal restrictions

. on the other hand, he takes a kind of guard that the audience has asked me many times if the government says that the crypto currency is legal, even now we have an exchange that is operating in this field. let's look at it . there is a structural intention of the government in this case that the government does not clarify its position on this i am criticizing the lack of transparency of the government 's position. we really need to see a fact, that is, the government knows that if the central bank says openly that even the central bank of iran is prohibited from transactions in the field of cryptography, which is now the deputy of the judiciary's crime prevention, this fall, this issue will be made official that any activity in the field of cryptocurrency, of course, with a stipulation that it takes an organized aspect. it is forbidden to hire a member who declared any crime, of course, they meant the activities of the temple, doctor, i will say the same with a condition that they state that it should be an organization in some way, yes , they added the pyramid sentence to it, but the problem is this is where the problem is, so there was not much point with the password, the fact is that

you should see one point, mr. doctor, one point we should pay attention to is that the nature of this field based on the blockchain platform is unmanageable in the whole world. encountering a phenomenon . which had a golden point. the way the government deals with any part of the password can turn its opportunity into a threat or its threat into an opportunity. that is, as soon as a government starts limiting it and restricting its people , the experience of china, the experience of nigeria and many other countries. of course, maybe china is much stronger than us in this field, the restriction had the opposite result , that is, it led to the strengthening of the underground market or the migration of people to platforms outside their country, and therefore today they have reached maturity and an understanding that this field should not be promoted and it is recommended that the method should not be restricted without restraint.

today, our country has reached an ecosystem of regulation in the world , but there was an irreparable delay, and i hope that this delay will not last longer. country of departure what do you think of capital from your country? if you allow it out of respect for the listener that maybe. he expects to hear the answers to the questions that are being asked , so i will answer the previous question because the answer to the previous question is incomplete, and considering that i personally do not have the habit of talking to the audience, and as the famous saying goes , people in front of me remain silent, but your previous question remained unanswered. that is, in question 3 , it was left in the question that it is necessary to answer whether we really believe that the password has an economic function or not . for discipline let's make a compromise . i firmly say from your podium that you can see as a

scientific statement that you cannot fight with technology . you should fight with technology and its elimination . i had it with me in the argument we had with foreign social networks, our argument there was not with the fact that, sir , our social network does not need it, we say that it is a controllable social network accessible to a network that respects the legal system of the islamic republic of iran. if the prosecutor general of the islamic republic of iran wants follow a case and see the text messages sent to him, that data center should be responsible and that the custodians, so with that logic, i also entered into this discussion that we will accept the technology if it really works economically if a think tank is formed. he said sir, this is for the system of the islamic republic of iran, within the framework of our goals, the policy of our words is functional , we should vote to approve and prescribe it, so we should not lose sight of the issue that we do not discuss its functions because it is not my job. i respect the economic society of the country and i will not step in their shoes i will leave it to an economist to explain

more whether the crypto widths and the quality of their activities have an economic justification or not because you know that the activities resulting from the added value of these currencies are now behind a think tank of a world-class institution. he doesn't have one, there is no think tank that can set the price today, you can see it at the highest level . let me give you an example of one of the violations of cryptocurrency fans. it is not bad that it is related to your recent question. to multiply the price of a product or the costs of using a tool a payment is not considered as a double asset . now we will not enter into this discussion. that it is necessary that, for example, tax experts be with us and we use

words, so we respect and we will go through this issue, but at the moment , you see, we need the position of the land code in the form of a macro-economic legal policy. clarify in our country's legal system , clarify in our economic system, before thinking about this , we should think about what approach the central bank should take, what the government should do, we need our legislative apparatus in a macro dialogue, for example i say in a dialogue. if they are implemented and used within the framework of a certain law, or with a certain function, or for a certain purpose, their presence and use are prescribed and have legal validity, we no longer need to come to masadi, for example, to come to bitcoin and make an independent law about it. in other words , let me come to the famous saying, independent legislation, not a big proposition, while i would also like to point this out and pay attention to it, it is necessary for the problems of governments at the global level. but the government and at the global level

have sensitivities towards cryptocurrency activity it helps us a lot in solving these problems. mr. ashtiani, how much do you agree? the fact is that now, the point that the doctor mentioned about the ability to be observed and that it can have the ability to apply the recipe , we have adjusted it today. this has been done to some extent in the world and in iran, and this ecosystem that has been formed has provided this capability, and this was one of the most important points that the activists in the field of crypto exchange have. it has been done to always have them in front of them, and well, there are a lot of files, a lot of queries and a lot of things other issues that resulted from the judicial order , from the point of view of fraud or iranian involvement, could be implemented due to the transparent nature of this area. one of the most important features of

blockchain and crypto assets is the transparent nature of the blockchain technology they are on . this is almost the reason why, according to the statistics that i want to say from 2017 , which i know for sure, 997% of the crimes related to the financial sector were actually committed through the traditional banking system, 30%, and today, as we are talking, this is still the case. a very, very small number and it can be ignored, the reason is that this field is transparent , and as a rule, the criminal does not use this field so easily, because somewhere, eventually, he wants to become a criminal, and he becomes a criminal. in fact, the judicial order can be applied to it . the second thing i wanted to say about our current situation is from 5-6 years ago in our country. in the talks of even the head of the

food department at the time, mr. central bank, why doesn't the central bank regulate this area? leaving the central bank alone in this way has its inherent duty and natural concerns and concerns regarding the inflation of our country and many other sensitive issues that were also in the question of his highness, but on the other hand , addressing the central bank and expecting it and leaving it alone. this is the only thing that mr. sadrabadi pointed out. in my opinion , this was not intentional. finance means our ministry of economy and finance, unlike other countries in the world , has not entered this field yet, and everything is expected from the central bank we were under a lot of pressure, and it was natural for him to react and behave according to the nature and nature of his performance

. of course, i also know that a working group consisting of several regulatory bodies in the country has been formed in response to the notification of the supreme council of cyber ​​space and they are taking over the regulation of this field . they are definitely following up on the definitions legally. the working group for organizing the exchange of assets encrypted is active, and among its members we can mention the ministry of economy, police, fata, ministry of central bank and the regulation of these chambers. they are making very good progress , but the situation of the delay that has arisen until today is not favorable and has caused damage to me, including the field of teaching other subjects, so agree on a report, let's go and see, let's go back and follow the debate, homayoun darabi. the economic expert of iranian companies who

are having trouble receiving bank notes and bank accounts due to sanctions can spend a few minutes and having an electronic wallet to receive their funds safely. for this reason, for economies like our country's economy, which is under sanctions and we are under pressure, cryptocurrencies create a great playing field in order to strengthen the country's economy. masoud sharifi, economic expert. if the government creates support for the use of cryptocurrencies in small financial transactions, it is possible to create capital and especially its equivalent money, even on a small scale, and international exchanges due to the boom in production , especially with neighboring countries. farzad hashemi economic expert cryptocurrencies can capacity create good for the country in the conditions of sanctions, therefore , this economic activity cannot be treated negatively and filtered, filtering

domestic collections active in the field of cryptocurrency will increase the number of users of foreign sites, which in addition to leaving the country. there are also challenges regarding the protection of people's assets. hossein mahmoudi, an economic expert, the crypto market is more than a market for circumventing sanctions , it is a platform for exiting the market, because through this market, rials are easily converted into dollars. mohammad mani yekta, vice president of payment systems department of the central bank, the risk of the land market is only fluctuating it's not the price, but because of iran's sanctions , the wallet in which we put the password may be blocked, and there is no place to complain about fraud in this area. cryptocurrency owners believe that the government and banks should not interfere in the creation of money. interfere, and in this area, the account owner's details of the destination account are unclear, which is not acceptable. salman kanani, economic expert, with

the legalization of the cryptocurrency market, we are placed in a very wide range of international interactions, and it is not possible to confine it to the geography of iran , because it is a completely interactive technology at the global level. is. in my opinion, they don't write because of the lack of law and because of the width of the code. for me , they are a non-existent thing for iran today and i consider it absurd to write legislation in this area. well, we saw the report together . i had one opinion from you. cover up the legislation . by the way, it was interesting. i wanted to say how good it is. of course, your friends are definitely technical. in choosing the title and removing the content, i was very happy that this was the sentence and when he spoke. it is true that i expressed these words completely, but it was in this context that we believe that cryptocurrencies are an active market and

cryptocurrency as an exchange process that can offer a function such as business speed for us to our society or not, i am against this issue and i still believe that it is still beautiful and correctly mentioned in the previous conversation. if we can solve these two words, i will vote for their legitimacy and say that i will use them myself. one is that mediation is the key to satisfaction. why do they want to talk about mediation and the presence of governments? why is the key to satisfaction with the presence of governments means the legal control system is a problem. they have the code of satisfaction in the sense that it is being raised today and in today's world, other than the code of national widths, which is the interpretation, if we consider that if they can clarify this issue , i think the answer is clear, so i personally. the area of ​​opposition that i can have about the erza code is that the codes are not in terms of the philosophy that was introduced to them, but their own philosophy and essence, what is called the erza code in iran today, at least, has been introduced

with the legislative system and the values ​​of baiseh in the system. our legislation has obvious inconsistencies, until we solve these, we cannot legislate let's think twice, mr. ashtiani . please, then i will go to mr. sadroudi. see, the reality is that the matter is much more complicated and we will not see the problem of the iranian people anymore. now, in a questionnaire that was conducted once, more than 95% of the people simply the goal is to avoid inflation and maintain the value of the capital, facing them and having nothing to do with the philosophy behind it and the technology behind it. this was an asset class that people are moving towards . we need to regulate this area . yes, there should be regulation. one protection of people's rights should be two preventions the growth of the fraud environment should be 3 possibilities of opportunity in the field of web shooting in the field of international markets . we are facing this type of property that now anyone who says that it does not work internationally

is surprising to me. by the way, we should appreciate this opportunity . we and the government should also. appreciate these opportunities , we have one type of property , we accept that this is unsanctionable, now what i am saying is that among these 26,000 currencies, for example , there are some that cannot be prevented in the international arena, we have no doubt about that. technically, our country has some of this wealth we have burned a trust once in the matter of land accounts, where we told people that you can deposit your currency in the account, and on the day of settlement , we gave them the equivalent of rials, and this trust was burned. now, in the field of cryptocurrency, when we have this type of international wealth, which i definitely mentioned in international payment , international payment for funds for micro

and small needs, such as student loan, medical loan, this can take the burden and pressure off the shoulder of the official provision of the loan. the country has taken it to some extent, this is not something that can be hidden, our country should know this. people saw this as an asset class in case of a wrong confrontation with this area , a confrontation which i do not say is a prescription . foreigner of our country, dear friend, i have a very important point for 30 seconds . let me tell you. look at this. i ask a question to all the noble people of iran and all the dear marketers, because i want to speak very elementary. suppose we accept this sentence right now. yes, the

cryptocurrency philosophy is that the government. because in fact, there is also an accusation of tax evasion a woman from a woman, my dear friend, see, let me, as a matter of courtesy, i do not enter into your conversations and i was not used to it, and please do not jump into the conversation. see, i am talking to the people of iran. if iran is in the parliament, the legislation of the parliament is better than now, this is from my point of view as a lawyer, so my argument was something else. cryptocurrency holders

cannot claim that they are paying taxes. not paying taxes is also tax evasion. they must be tax evasion by nature, because the presence of the government in this market is ruled out . that's why i say that there is even an issue with sharia legitimacy. and the illegitimacy, i would like to tell you that what has been until now, in terms of legitimacy and regulation, in my opinion, the procedure followed by this field has been correct . more than. for years, they have been paying their taxes in a clear and legal manner with a specific inta code. in fact, i hope that your tax friends will discuss this with them . they accept taxes there. not even defined in the tax affairs organization today, not yesterday, two years ago, intakada has been defined, and businesses active in the field of cryptocurrency exchange and even the issue of taxation in the field of cryptocurrency mining

have also been determined. the field of people active in the field of crypto currency exchange and the persons involved are known and they are actually busy with the requirements of combating money laundering in this field, thank god. i can boldly announce that crime prevention and money laundering in this area is at the lowest possible level at the moment, and this part of the legislation, if i call it , is current regulation. regarding capital flight, i must also tell you that capital flight has a definition like this. that if the wealth leaves the country, his or her profit will not return to the country. when our people are currently buying cryptographic assets, first

of all, we need to know that the origin of the buyer or seller actually exists . i wanted to say that this second is very important. what may cause the flight of cryptocurrency capital from inside the country to the foreign platform is not restricting the activity of the foreign platform inside our country or creating restrictions that will make people move from our domestic market to the higher market. that we up at this moment, we will keep you together.

at 4:00 p.m., the judiciary said that the trial of various factors in the friday incident last year in zahedan will be held in the second half of this month after the defects in the case have been resolved. honorable salih court has taken care of a defect in the case in dealing with the relevant case