look, i believe that education in our country is not competitive. if a student in basic sciences , technical, technical in azad university is studying even at the doctorate level , he is studying with the same student in the government evening course, this is a competition. the type of equipment, the type of training , we are not monopolistic. when you say monopoly, it means that you become a monopoly when what you supply is less than the demand, and because you have a customer, you can set any price, any tuition, under any condition. you wanted to get it, now you double my doctorate fees the customer is asking, this is becoming a monopoly, that means there is no other place for him to turn to and say, "i'll go with half of this price, no, why, no, no, see, it's an argument that you 'll see him say once in a while." azad university

has a monopoly on the doctorate course. you see once . no, this monopoly is not only in the hands of azad university. government universities also have evening courses. the same course is the monopoly of all doctor's courses. the private sector is very weak. it becomes a monopoly of the government. what it produces says that azad universities send the nightly light of tuition fees they should increase their master's and doctorate by 10 times. is there any other solution for those who have to study too much? no

, you have to go and read this. this is a monopoly. well, this is true. no , yes, look, this is true. this means monopoly. for example, how many public universities, azad university, payamour university , they have doctoral programs, but i say that there is competition between these courses. the monopoly is that there is no collection . there is no new entry, a group is doing something exclusively and says that i am doing this work with a price. azad university, payamonoor university, state universities, and universities of applied science are competing in this competition we have, which means that we do not have a monopoly in the field of education , but what is the problem now.

they provide services, the type of receipts they have, the fees they charge, and the type of receipts they have, the monopoly of each university determines for itself. this monopoly must really be broken, a collection under any title . let someone else organize this country's education system from the pre-friends course to the doctorate course . and categorize these into items , pay attention to the type of training they give, even the type of workshops they have in the technical field like you you should know that training in the humanities is cheap, but in the technical part it is very expensive . as a result, these should be carefully considered, and the type of service they provide should determine the price for it . i would like to add one point. what

i want to say is that you see, i don't mean that the tuition fees of non-governmental institutions are high or low, that is our second issue, which should be discussed . it is not a question of high or low. make an argument that it is not possible to present anything lower than this . this is not our discussion. our discussion here was that is this a monopoly or not, and with the current method , if the prices have been increased or if there is any other solution, i will say no. you should come now. for example, say, i am a phd student. i want to take you to this city . i want to get this. so, does a person who wants to study here have a solution? i say that the total capacity of postgraduate education in the country is clear, the applicant is also clear . yes, finally, someone who has more talent, more time, may have studied in the government, and now, but in the end, the demand is much more than it is offered in

graduate school, so it should be in such a place really, the price that is reasonable and appropriate to the quality of education and the unnecessary overheads that different universities may have, which for this reason is not related to the student who wants to study , should really be paid to places like the competition council or the ministry of science or any organization that regulates this is supposed to be fine, and this cost should be removed from the student's shoulder . so, if we agree, let's go together and see a report together, let's review the opinions of other experts , see what the rest of them think, let's go back and follow our views, mr. mustafa taheri. representative of the islamic council in some universities non-governmental companies cannot operate, this is the reason why a monopoly is created, and as a result, the entry of the competition council must be done. mr. ali omrai, a member of the transparency and

justice watch training commission. currently, the determination of tuition fees by non-government universities has caused protests by students, and there should be a device. sometimes a regulatory agency such as the competition council should enter this market, mr. morteza zamanian , an economic expert, due to the limited offering of post-graduate courses in some fields by a number of private universities, monitoring pricing or even price guidelines by regulatory bodies. it seems necessary. mr. hassan hassan khani , an economic expert. wherever there is a trace of monopoly , the competition council must enter, but because it knows. we have various universities and services in the country , there is no need for the competition council to enter the tuition fees of non-government universities. mr. seyed abolhassan mousavi, professor of azad university. the student is free to go to any private university. and this has caused some non-government universities

to be empty of students. this means that universities are competitive. mr. jabar kochchinejad, a member of the islamic council of iran there are many actors present in the higher education market and there is no question of monopoly and this market is completely competitive and there is no need for the competition council to enter. yes, we saw and heard the report of my colleague mohammad elhari. mr. taheri , according to your opinion, these markets are competitive markets, well , we have in the law that the competition market is a monopoly market. entering the exclusive market is for the competition council, but you said that you do not accept the competition council , what structure do you believe in? i agree with the competition council, not that i don't

agree . it's not just about education. in all the issues that have come up so far, i said that i don't give an acceptable score to the council's performance . there are reasonable people and a high score in it, but the structure it has is iranian, for example, what is wrong with it? technical in the competition council is weaker than the legal debate generally, they are from the judicial branch, both in the case of the original case and the case of renewal. in my opinion , even after they have a resolution, the court of justice can enter and in the end, even where they have entered , they do not have much enforcement guarantee. of

the violations committed by the competition council, which have not been resolved, i think a separate meeting is needed to review the performance of the competition council. now , different genders have entered the competition council, for example , one of them is the industry in the automobile issue, which is very characteristic of all do you mean there were other topics that we discussed in the discussion? very well, the lack of independence that is seen in the law, which should not be dependent on the forces or divisiveness , does not exist, or the performance of the competition council is weak , i said that i do not give an acceptable score . in this area too, if it enters , it might make things worse than it is. in your opinion, you

want a new law. in short, the conclusion is that in the discussions about non-governmental centers , there is a need for a regulator and monopoly. we must have input, that the council competition can now be done with this structure, not according to the current law of the competition council, but it is definitely needed there is a revision in the rules and structure of the competition council, mr. kochaki. what do you think about which device should enter, you who believed in regulation? yes, you see, in relation to the discussion of education and the value of education, the pricing of education is a highly specialized task because the education is very diverse and different departments are involved in these educations. for this reason, i believe that there must be a council. for example, in the entrance exam department

, we have a council called "attaf" which means that it is a council that examines the assessment and academic department. in the field of flight training, we have a council called the council that determines the tuition fees of students in private schools , i believe that we have different councils in these educational sectors. the assembly of these councils can be a supplementary council, the competition council, the competition council , you can see how they manage the car market, in fact , there is no opinion on the car market . the council of the educational council is a specialized council, there must be expert people and skilled people, people who are involved in educational systems, in this council, we can.

we should have a combination of the fields of the ministry of science, the ministry of medical sciences, the ministry of education, a combination of these, with some of the supervisory bodies and other bodies as members , and we should have a council under the name of the council for the supervision of the education of the country , and that council should come up with policies. he should set the rates almost by hand and a floating rate for the departments that give special training or extra -curricular training outside of the training program . this will make us flexible in all the departments that they have. education works, both the government and other universities government, applied science university , education field, we can organize these and in that organization, the rates that we set and

the monitoring devices can monitor the set rates, now the monitoring of the monitoring device is very weak, the inspection organization, i don't know. other agencies, even the accounts court, since these are the revenue of the agencies, the accounts court should also have an opinion on the type of expenses, there is some lack of order in this department, i believe. the combined council can manage the education system of the country and set the rates for specialties according to the type of services in the departments various basic sciences, humanities, art sciences , and engineering technical departments can be organized very easily, and people will definitely welcome it when they see that there is a rule of law.

the law on the implementation of the policies of article 44 of the constitution has been declared prohibited, according to article 62 of this law , only the competition council. dealing with anti -competitive procedures is the subject of cases 44 to 48, that is, where it should actually be dealt with and this council has the authority in case of impeachment of any of them. there were two points here. first, whether it is anti -competitive or not, it is up to the council itself to compare it with what he does it according to articles 44 to 48, after he recognizes that the so-called monopoly should actually enter

, and when it enters, if it is a violation according to the article. 61 makes a decision and actually announces it, but because all the approvals of the competition council can be so-called revised, my next point is that in the revision of the 7 people who are members, 3 of the 7 members are actually most of the food and it has a weak technical composition, that is, in the end, the thing that comes out of the seven -member renewal after the revision is one in which 3 of them are ghazadas. it is economic, any other topic, you want to talk about education now , you can say many small points about it, one time you want to talk about the car, one time you want to talk about the internet issue, a group wants to decide, 7 people vote. in

my opinion, they should announce the final decision about this issue in the appeal. it comes to the background of our conversation today and many points that may not have been done well in the country in terms of pricing and ultimately harmed the supply and demand sectors. in my opinion, it is the structure of the competition council itself that needs a serious revision, so you do you believe in the revision of the competition council to see a new council, if it is ok, it is acceptable, no , i accept the revision of the law. the so-called article 44 of the constitution, however, i think that the competition council itself and its article 62 must be revised, and if it is necessary to change the law , the law must be changed, if not , it can be amended with a regulation or a circular and instructions. be reformed so that we can

see productivity in the field of education, which is our discussion now, and in other fields. regarding the receipt of these fees, the status of the financial statements of these universities is what you told them yes, it is not transparent and it is not very clear what the cost of income of these universities is. now, in my opinion, this requires a delay in investigation or reporting. because i am not used to commenting on something that i have no knowledge about, it may be this, but entering . i didn't get a report to confirm or deny this, but it is possible. yes , in any case, the fees charged to the students are the university's own expenses, considering that i mentioned both in terms of quality and salaries for board members. it was scientific, obviously

, their financial statements are now one of the serious discussions which we have in private universities. the difference between the salaries of faculty members in these and public universities, well, this affects the quality of education, and unfortunately, sometimes this number may not be very accurate, but it can be approximated to the minute, which is close to half, and this seriously harms the quality of education as well. the injustices against these dear ones, mr. kouchini nejad, mr. taheri, say that we should reform the structure of the competition council and strengthen it according to the original. 44 you said that we should have a new education supervision council and all of them should be consolidated. see, i believe that now that mr. taheri himself has agreed to a system of opinions on the type of education provided in the country, you would have taken a number. it

is not the principle of the chal principle, but the principle of article 44 of the constitution. the private sector has been given permission to enter the economy, the service sector, the country's education sector, this is also a matter of transparency. look at us and the law that the parliament decides, the permanent laws, the laws have their place, and this competition council, when it was approved by the parliament , was the view of that time. that this council should enter more in the field of economy, if this council is going to enter in the field of education as well, with a variety of attention, definitely we should amend the law, that is, the law should be passed by the shogh islamic majlis, again, or the government should give a bill , or the house of representatives. we should be able to change the entire structure of the competition council and make it more flexible in order to monitor or make

policies on the country's education . let's integrate in a council, in my opinion, nothing good will come out , that is, the necessary expertise and that elegance. it is not necessary in these councils, after a while, instead of correcting the work, we spoil the work for this reason, we believe that a new council should be created in the field of education in the country from the pre-university period to the doctoral period, and this council can make policies and supervise the policies that the government announces within the framework of those policies. let him write and create his own path. i am a servant. yes, see. alhamdulillah , we have reached a good common point

, that there is a need for regulation . now , there was a dispute about whether this is our work on the exclusive side of a yes subject, or in the way that the doctor said. it must be reformed , now or those reforms in the competition council must be done for this and other tasks , i am satisfied with the competition council in its performance in the so-called de-monopoly and its entry into various sectors, i am satisfied that it did not get a good average score, now that it has started not done or the doctor's suggestion is that it should be seen in a more specialized way under the supervision of the ministry of science or another department that has a proposal

to do this. now this is too much. in the opinion of the competition council , we have a law above us, and until today the law that exists in the country is also a strong law of the law of principle 44 of the recognition of monopolies and entry, leaving it to the competition council to do the work. i think it is possible to follow that path as well. thank you. mr. cook had a point about monopoly. please look at monopoly . let me tell you that it is customary and in science that something is done by one person and no one else can do it. it is the authority of a group. there is a team, it becomes a monopoly when we have diverse we provide training from the ministry of science to the ministry of education until the medical sciences. as a result

, we do not know this monopoly, dr. now , we do not know how many hundreds of automobile manufacturers we have in the country. now, my question is, suppose that this glass is produced by a thousand factories. they do, but the total number of glasses they produce is 100, and the country's needs are 1,000. i don't have variety. look, the entire automobile industry in iran today is monopolized by two big automakers , no, it's not like this, and the small automakers, those who

make these single devices , are also under the control of these two automakers, which means these two automakers are monopolies. even another year that khudrus becomes an azad university or a university, it does not matter if it produces diverse products with different qualities. we need to produce the doctor's training exactly on this subject, thank you. well, mr. kochchi nejad, you are summarizing , for example, yes, yes, you are summarizing your paragraph . you have two minutes, but one minute is necessary.

it means that the necessity of the country is that the country, i.e. the islamic council or the government, should enter as necessary regarding the issue of regulation and this regulation , according to the law, it should be given to the parliament to enact a law. if the government does not do this , it should definitely be done through the commission of education and research. the discovery of a city that, god willing, will reach a destination, and the quality of education should be monitored more. thank you very much, mr. taheri, and all the good viewers who have accompanied us until this moment, god bless you and protect you. either ali bala is higher than anyone or higher today, whatever you are.

please it happens, it happens, it happens. who is the person who says to negotiate?

god meant an empty and vague hypothesis for prayers and personal pleasures, imaginary and illusory . in such a situation where the big world was reduced to a small world, one of the meanings that changed was the meaning of woman. the meaning of woman has changed.

in the past, in the eastern culture, in the traditional and original culture of the east, a woman as a wife, as a mother, as a companion , as a sister, as a neighbor, as a companion and all these things that were considered with a kind of respect for dignity, but in the secular culture, women and men as well. it meant manpower. a force in the row other forces that exist in nature and must be employed. he should be hired by certain people or classes to use up his energy. women's energies and men's energies are at the service of economic systems.

to be at the service of industrial economy in this sense, the family has changed its form and meaning, human relations have changed , human relations have changed , in the name of allah, rahman rahim, with blessings on muhammad and his family , your presence, sports news enthusiasts, hello , good morning, representatives of iran, boxing competitions starting the world championship with a victory on the second day of these fights hosted by italy daniyal shahbakhsh , our country's boxer weighing 57 kg, will be placed in the 3-time u-finol boxer from venezuela and the holder of the transfer medal.