nowruz 1403 with haft sin and haft sarai, full of variety and discounts in the great iranian palace , full of haft sintan table and saadat saadat nowruz.

this time, on the occasion of nowruz and the holy month of ramadan until eid al-fitr , get an id with every purchase from the city of home appliances and the city of carpets, the specialized reference for carpets and home accessories , the iranian coach, sharaf iran, has a telegram playing with the country, why are you setting prices in this month? no, your question is an interesting question . we don't want to be a football manager .

i am here in our studio, mr. janjan, an economic expert, agreeing to pay the consumption aid the finalist in our other studio, mr. mohammad. mr. hassanlui, an economic expert, is present and agrees to pay subsidies to the production chain, mr. jan. let me start with mr. mohammadi and this question, mr. mohammadi , why do you agree to pay subsidies to the production chain and not the end consumer? granting subsidies to producers is both non-inflationary and a cause of prosperity. it is produced and the goods reach the people cheaper, and some nobles say that these policies are aimed at the goal.

the chicken uses market regulation and goods like this are used by the rich. unfortunately, some friends. we are sitting in the closed thinking environment of their think tanks and their research teams and they are doing debates on paper that are different from the reality of society . today's meeting was about a very interesting topic. maybe it is not tangible for us in tehran , for example, it is a matter of subsidized frozen chickens and

market regulation that we want to go to the shops at any time, at any point of time in tehran , there are people available at an approved price, but also some people violate some of the trade unions have three or four repeated words that we have subsidies of 400 million instead of 80 million of iran's population , which means that smuggling is happening or we say. which goes out of the way in the chain of these subsidies, but this phrase is not a reason for us to oppose the granting of subsidies to the beginning of the chain, mr. janjan , please tell me that the reasons for saying this are that you agree that the subsidy should be paid to the final consumer, what is it and how much i agree with mr. mohammadi's statements. in the name of god, i also say hello to you, dear viewers, and mr

what mr. mohammadi puts forward and actually claims is that we have a number of very, very clean people at the beginning of the chain , and if billions of dollars are given to them, they will not betray it as a subsidy . the image of armenia, god willing, will be like this, but i want to remind the people that since april 2017, which

we have witnessed, the payment, allocation and supply of 420, which actually provided food, dong, etc. , which is approximately 85 the price is over, but how much did the chicken increase, something in size increased 7 times while 4,200 tomans were allocated, while there were 4,200 tomans, as we are seeing now , 28,500 tomans since birth. has chicken become cheaper or more expensive since the time of 28,500, has meat become cheaper or more expensive, so i believe that we had 124,000 prophets, dear mr. mohammadiyeh, and in short, the end of the messenger

was also the prophet, may god bless him and grant him peace, and we no longer think that there are any we have the betrayal of trust. they don't do it. you should explain that when we are the head of the family, our consumption of chicken is actually 30 kilos per year for each person, which means roughly two and a half kilos a month, on the other hand, we buy 100 1000 tomans is a subsidy, 250,000 tomans per year for a family of four , which is 12 million tomans . in fact, the price of meat or chicken, white meat or red meat has not increased. i think it is a kind of fallacy of pahlan pahlan, and let's talk to each other with numbers and figures based on the documents to

see what the condition of the chicken is like. we are now in the cia . we are buying chicken from brazil for one and a half dollars, so you can tell me how do you actually want to receive the subsidy , but we don't see the increase in the price of chicken again ? thank you, mr. mohammadi. we are at your service. in addition to those 124,000 prophets and other 14 innocent prophets , i would like to add that i would like to ask you first about the cleanliness of the agents. let's compare the production or the people that exist first. the people of this period , especially the people of iran , were in a much better situation than the people of the prophet's or imams' period . let's not discuss these issues in this way. if it were

not for these producers, the situation would have been much worse. do in this process. we said that we will allocate the width. previously, the government had a problem with the width of 420. it was not allocated to the width specialist . whoever approached him , the width was not resolved because you cannot give the width without clearing the width obligation, and what did these people do? these same people , their money came to the stock market. at the same time , the dignitaries told us that you do not know the technical chart of the top and bottom of the month of the same year when the stock market was falling . we said that the stock market will fall, invite people like this they don't accept it because their technicalities didn't work, but the current situation of the discussion we are doing is not like the stock market

, they are not a basic commodity like the issue of the stock market or other financial markets that can be joked with or take a big risk. the situation of allocating 420t width or preferential width or any other rate would be much better, that is , we should reprimand the presenter and supervisor, not the producer, we should not punish the people because some people came and committed a violation. that we have now in the goods basically, people have access to these goods, but if we don't give them the same ram subsidy , it will be out of their reach. why, if you want a number , the number came up several times in the same program, and we did the calculations . for example, if the government wants

to give a subsidy of 100 units, if you give it at the beginning of the chain, and if the initial price of that product is 120 units, if we give 100 units, it will be 20 units . if there are 3 stages, for example bread wheat . if he wants to take it, let's assume that it is 20 d. end of the chain the money that people have to pay to buy that product is 34 units, while if we don't subsidize the first 120 units, the beginning of the chain is the same three steps and 20% of each step comes from this number , it will be around 175 units if the government wants it to be 100 units. give the subsidy, how much people have to pay 75 wah, that means people have to pay at least twice as much for the same amount of goods . in an abstract example , we can talk in this situation, but

what will happen in the reality of your society? you don't consider the war between russia and ukraine in some basic goods and inputs , which raised the prices of basic goods and other conditions. if we take these into consideration, we can see that in this situation , most of our producers are struggling to produce despite this situation, although we agree that there should be more supervision, you can do whatever you want, give subsidies with any intention. if there is no effective supervision, effective supervision, not ineffective or inaccurate supervision, if effective supervision is not done, corruption will occur.

i have the idea that this thing is actually subsidized when i, as the final consumer , get the possibility, i myself will decide how to use it. you claim again that in fact the war between russia and ukraine, the war between russia and ukraine was actually a part of the effects of the peso-coronavirus, the return of demand to the world markets , there was a growth, the prices came back , and the prices went down. i look at the price in may 141 , the average was 42,000 tomans . what are you looking at? you claim like this , 285 28 and 500 for one kilo of chicken, well one and a half

dollars in brazil, i actually checked my different safes , what does half a dollar mean, we also consider 1 and 6, you multiply by 28 and 500 , now the chicken should be 4560 tomans, not 50 thousand tomans, why 80 thousand tomans, why you the dam market , well, you who act as a consumer, in fact , as a producer and the beginning of the chain , you get your dollar, you get your width from ardibehesht 401, why did the chicken double? they encourage to invest in the stock market, and none of the funds that i got from the people his memory

basically, with a few incomplete figures and arguments and media frenzy, you should not pretend that you are on the side of the people. once again, if you want a number , i will give you a number. first of all, you said that half a dollar is the price of chicken in brazil, we have set a price. we are doing the path, how much has been allocated, the characteristic numbers are less than this every year. billions of dollars have been given for basic goods . now it is possible to discuss whether tea is one of the basic goods of the people or not. it can be argued that from my point of view it is not just a basic commodity, but from the point of view of other experts, maybe it is just a basic commodity i have to give an argument

and explain which product groups are included in the group , the relevant authorities, but how is it given to the input, and how is it given to them? we need the input , he has to provide the input at a higher rate today because he can't wait for the chicken, i got the transfer, i'll let you know that he has to give it now , he will buy this and these things will be corrected, this is the process if people there are people who are disturbing rent they are doing something wrong , so it should be dealt with. we should ask the regulatory bodies to answer and be accountable . i am not your servant. people should reject this subsidy, not that people

should be burdened with more burden . is it other than helping people's livelihood, the government has resources it wants to use to improve people's livelihood , not that it has resources it wants to explain. people can use it wherever they want, some of you say they like to take it, no, the bottom line is that some people may want to take it to the stock market, so it's better to bring it to the stock market, people will come, we will introduce a package to you, we will give a signal, come to the stock market, and now there too. we won't answer again, we don't want people's livelihood. it would be better to provide basic goods, not all goods, and to monitor more closely. let the bread become in the hands of the people, give 100 units to the beginning of the chain, and give it to the producer to monitor

the chain at the bottom of the chain, there should be 34 people, so that they can buy it, if they don't give it. for 120 units, 20% of the cost of the first stage and the second stage will cost 20% more. the method should be completed with 170 units. the government should pay 100 units, while the people give 70 units. there are two to four specific things, i.e. twice in one example, what should be expected? for the benefit of the people, i will give you 100 wid, but the finished product price will be higher, you should buy less, you can buy half of that amount. why do numbers cause inflation? when figs with the lowest rate need to be financed first, for the producer, in the next stages , it will require less cost and capital for production. if you don't pay this, in this example, you have to finance more one of the damages that inflation causes to producers is that they will need more working capital than yesterday

they could produce with 100 units, now they cannot produce with 100 units, they must have 150 units. where should he get funding from the banking system and education, what will happen if he receives education an increase in liquidity happens as if mr. mohammadi, you recorded this tape and play it from the beginning . when i speak , you rewind and play again. what's the use of this ? you said the same things you just said in the first part, while what does the stock market have to do with we are talking about the economy if you have exactly. you act like a zinef, like a zinef zinef 30 billion dollars, half of the entire country's budget, say something that is acceptable to you , talk with numbers and figures, why forgive liquidity, in which textbook do they say that it can actually be directed? where did you write in which book, why

do you bring up something that no one has any claim about . he did not read about it in any book. those who guide do not guide liquidity credit . therefore, if we are going to talk scientifically, it is as if you came to yourself, in fact, i am saying that you memorized a series of sentences for yourself, recorded them, built a bridge, went back, or at least started again . i asked you several questions. i said that if you claim, see that this is a total subsidy. you know, mr. mohammadi's friends say that you should give it to us who are producers, we are very good children we are, god willing, we will not be tea drinkers , we are very good, good people. that is, as much as we subsidize

, we want to give it to the people at the beginning of the chain . why should you take the money? come and sell a part of it in the market, and sell the rest in the back of the market . haven't we seen enough of these things? are we children? we do not see it, we are repeating it, it has been repeated , the nation cannot take their fajran. you talk in such a way as if you live in zagun iran or preim iran. where do you live

? you say we are defending the interests of the people. when was it 420 or when it was 2850? why didn't you see the answer to my questions? well, those people who want to put 4,200 investments in their pockets and leave this country , you gave me an excuse that they are actually giving anything , they are giving anything, they are giving it to my chicken , they are giving it to anything. they give me meat, but it shouldn't be chicken, it would be 6 thousand tomans, 40 thousand tomans , 42 thousand tomans . what is this aside? well, this is aside. from 28 and 500, you chicken is 42 thousand tomans, now it is 90 thousand. 100,000 tomans has been allocated, your allocation has decreased. no

, the people of iran should know that in 2019, we had a basic cap of around 10 billion dollars. mr. mohammadi , please answer the questions. if you don't want to build a bridge again, can you tell me if it is the population of iran? it has doubled, that is, for example, now mr. nasr, i think, for example , 85,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 . mohammadi to raise about the subsidy payment of mr. mohammad, allow one minute mr. janjan, if you have the time left , please give him his answer. he said that if we pay at the beginning of the chain, we will pay less than you will see that it is wrong for the consumer. look at that calculation, your

fixed costs, your energy costs are all free, mr. mohammadi, if he wants to talk about technology, he should learn to talk about technology with numbers, he should say why we feed chickens and all food and... in fact, you are importing knowledge. like who is like turkey, but what is the difference between us and turkey ? turkey has free energy, gas and electricity it's free, the cost of transporting everything is free, we have free gas here, in the beginning it was 300 tomans , it's 600 tomans, and why is it expensive now? look, now those who know the beginning of the chain of that nation, when a mobile phone cost 28,500, well, a thousand dollar phone

costs 28,500,000 tomans, not 32 million tomans , it should reach the end consumer, not 70 million. you say that sir , we are very good people at the beginning of the chain we are, no, you are not good people at all, because if you wanted to do something for the nation, you should have come with this money. it means that its volume is not supposed to increase or decrease. this bowl is to be presented to the people who have enough money , mr. mohammadi, please start with the kiss first. again, the technical discussion and the discussion of the figures will be discussed where they will accept. the finished price of the product. the number, if there are 3 stages , each stage requires 20% profit, the number is 3 , which means it must be repeated, the number will not change, like me now if i count four times, it will be the same number as you said.

consider a number, for example, hypothetical and economic, not hypothetical, if 120 units , the price is 120 dollars in the initial stage, and there are 3 stages for production, for example, wheat, put real numbers , move the percentages, then the logic your calculation is like this

, wheat should arrive, bread should reach the people, there are 3 main steps you should do. the proof is given, well, you can't say that it is not, sir , and many experts at the beginning of the program , at least a few experts gave their opinions, at least 3 programs have been held in this special program above , numbers and figures have been said about the fellows, and

they don't know how to reason. you. you know, it is far from the basic principles of the discussion. we have to accept some preconditions that you say that the producers are not clean and the producers do this. you are insulting a large community of producers, while they are the same. they are supplying people with meat and chicken it is available in the market.

the same person is doing these things while the arguments of the other side, the ministry of jihad and the central bank, should speak and defend their actions and explain their actions . thank you, mr. janjam. i have a question . i 'm begging you desperately, i'm really begging you, you who know a lot about debate, you know literature , you don't discuss personal arguments, you don't bring up beer debates , you talk with a lot of numbers and figures, your calculations you say, please provide the answer to my same question . my question is why despite receiving 420 dollars from farordan.