[000:00:00;00] as far as i know, most of the countries in the scandinavian region and the region where the people who have the most tax revenues in the country provide their income from their tax revenues, the policy debate, in fact, why return the same amount in their own work area. in those fields of work, why is this successful in those countries and you are declaring here that it cannot be successful? the comparison you are making is not a very good comparison. in other countries, the desired capital is very high, tiroja. the book is not at all comparable to the circulation in iran studying in iran is unfortunately low. the circulation of books is decreasing. at one time, the circulation of books in iran was 5,000, then 3,000, then 200, then 1,000. now it is less than 1,000. sometimes there are 500, 300 copies of books, this is worrying. legislator to prevent this process of

financial exemption in the past you scandinavian countries. i would like to tell you that the wrong effects of our policy discussion , if this point that you said is true , applying the exemption will give positive results, because we applied the exemption that i said, all our laws show that we are in the field of publishing. we exempted the press by explaining to your excellency if

this policy is correct. you have been in this case and it is not possible to open this issue that because the tax exemption was zero, it is unfair, so it has no effect. it definitely has its own image. you cannot tell the effect of the tax exemption based on the number of the card, because it cannot be seen, but it is very helpful, very oriental. it can be a party that, instead of coming , has a big store, instead of coming, well , now the big store is part of the stationery department

. this will definitely have an effect, but if the sales of the book go down, then there are other reasons it has nothing to do with tax exemptions or unfair distribution, i don't know the budget, i don't know subsidies, etc. so, with this problem , should we increase the exemption or decrease it? i will tell you the number again, so that all of you can see it. i told you that more than 8,900 people in this field of activity have chosen their own publishing activity and they have submitted a tax return to the tax administration. actually, their own activity code is the subject of paragraph 139 of article 139 in the field of publishing

to choose we had 39 billion tomans, 39 billion tomans in taxes from this field of work , if only in the field of business in 1402 , the tax we received was 32 thousand billion tomans. i do that from 116. 10 hammat exemptions that the lawmaker has granted 8 and 8 tenth hammat, and if there is any doubt in this statistic, please, i will definitely present the cases to you, you should tell me the cases of doubt. so, in view of this issue, i say again, not only in the field of publishing, which is now decided

by the government and the government, and until today , the decisions of the government have been overseeing this issue, which is the field of the press. let's give it is possible for me to find out how many people are working in this field, why the tax declaration is registered in our systems, we investigated and applied the exemption, so in compliance with article 146 of the regulation, who is not exempt from tax in the field of publishing ? if someone does not submit his tax return in addition to his publishing activities, for example , an activity like last year in the budget law of 1401 , this part is not exempted in the tax system and

according to the law, otherwise, the rest of the dear ones who are active in the publishing field and get permission from the ministry of culture. and the islamic guidance or its authority to separate

the tax declaration from the material affairs organization. i mean, there is a law, but in practice they are paying these taxes, they are paying these taxes now, more or less , in a way, they are on their own. let's follow up and i will certainly follow up on this point that your excellency said from the general directorate of tax affairs of tehran center, but please allow me, but we

have put a authority under the title of tax proceedings authority, which is completely independent from the organization. i received the tax 3 times, 3 people who had been changed , i asked them not to draw up the vote tax symbol, let the representative of the judiciary draw up the votes in a systematic way . i have talked about this matter many times, i went to rasa, and the draft is in you the meeting should be written in presence. all three representatives, but the drafts will be written later, and then many times i didn't know about my vote, and that ray was signed by the signature system without a signature, that is, your physical signature

. make sure you give me a case. i will follow up on the matter from the prosecutor's office. yes , please give it to me . i will be very happy to take the matter to the prosecutor's office. because i have tried so hard to resolve this matter and it has not been done. there is no vote, but that vote it was issued with the signature of his excellency, it will be issued later , then he will say that you are not the drafter, and unfortunately, even in the tax case , there is no final opinion of the law, this law is not considered a tax exemption, it is the opinion of the honorable auditor, that is, if he writes a single digit, the representative board try to adjust the tax, that is, give a discount for a percentage of 10%, 20% according to your own opinion

, give it a discount to help him, and finally , the bookstore, which is all documented , has sold books. asudam has brought me covertly, but i don't have any comparison. we don't have work tax, one person who lives next to a furnace is over a thousand. she spends the money she spends on buying books

and earns that money from her taxes, just as it is for many women in other places, you can consider this for a simple worker. if you agree, let's reach an agreement in this section. let's see the report, let's see the opinion of other experts about whether people of culture and art should be exempted from tax or not. let 's go and see it together . hosseini, university professor and cultural researcher. naturally, incomes in different fields there are commercial and industrial and cultural and artistic areas that must pay taxes. for example, in germany, publishers' tax is almost half of the rest of the world, or the postage of books is free in all of germany. mohammad mehdi esmaili, minister of culture and islamic guidance. we are in favor of tax justice. anyone can earn substantial income in any job. must pay its taxes.

there is no difference between an artist and a non-artist. what is wrong with an artist whose work is prosperous to pay taxes? it is the right of the people and the government to tax him. we also agree with this. jamal sadatian, producer the cinema. cinema should not only pay taxes, but also receive incentives. cinematographers can be the most helpful in explaining and culturalizing the tax issue. it is appropriate to review the tax exemptions for this group with effective measures. shahin mustafa, director of the tax audit department of the tax affairs organization. if an economic activist, regardless of whether he is a publisher or an actor, the expenses he makes according to the law are more than what he earns, by applying the tax exemption that the law considers as a livelihood exemption for all sections of the society.

received, he must come and pay taxes on his profit. it will be more than what it brings to the government and it will degrade the quality of the works of art. cinema critic khosro dehghan. tax is based on income. whoever earns must pay taxes. but the issue that we must pay attention to is that in the cinema, the incomes are not the same. must according to the statement. everyone's income should be taxed. khazaei, head of the cinema organization. tax exemptions and amnesties are not limited to the culture and arts of our country, but many countries that do not even have a cinema industry, by creating incentives, exemptions and loans cheap ones have tried for the prosperity of this industry. seyyed mohammad hashemi, deputy minister of culture and islamic guidance sh. clarification in the tax system and

the need to collect funds. which should be done, but the account of the few artists who have billions of income should be separated from the ranks of the artistic community. well, we saw the report together, mr. alinqi, please tell me that you are opposed to the principle of collecting taxes, because most of your objections are to the procedure and methods that , for example, taxes are being collected now, that audits, but in practice this does not happen, with the process that exists in the tax department, this does not happen. and still most of the time, at least in the city of tehran, because i don't know much about other cities, this tax is a picture

. i agree with the law, but they have a problem with the process of investigation and tax calculations of the tax administration regarding this discussion. really, if an economic activity becomes famous for a day or four , there really is no economic justification for books and publishing, because the same capital , the same time, and the same effort that is spent on the publishing bookstore will be much easier to answer in

saniki. if you have it, its sales can be compared to a book sale there is no book, it is established, it is very fragile, it means that it is produced, it is priced, other goods that are produced, you said that before the meeting, you said that other trades are the same way, with the increase in the price of the dollar or inflation , but the book is like this. no, you can't sell the book at the same price, you have to sell it at the same old price, and when your investment comes back, you will see that

you have to add something else to that investment. this has no economic justification at all. it is true that you yourself paid taxes this year ago . no, i know the rules are enough. thank you for being so clear that if your information is correct and you go to the tax authority, they will know about the rules . i say it because i am aware of the rules, and this is a bit of a matter of taste, for example, i know that i am aware of some rules, but. with the same condition , modi and my other colleague went and had a license from the union, they said no, because you are selling other books, the only license is obtained from the ministry of thought and publishing. there was an explanation and the tax department said that no, you must also have a book license

. nothing like this is written in the law. well, god's servant, i said that if you do not have a book method license, you are not exempt. you also mentioned in your statement about smart exemption and smartness in provincial tax, mr. ali naghi also mentions that sometimes audits or in different processes of taste tax are applied. how will this smart process happen ? according to these exemptions, the minimum applies let them see the end of the tax system according to the law of the tax affairs organization. set up a store and, god willing, at the end of 1403 and at the beginning of 144, anyone who is active in any business field must come and

issue their invoices electronically through the systems of modian system and store terminals, so if god willing, at the end of 143, our loved ones who work in the field of publishing will be recognized. their goods, which will definitely happen , register the sale of their goods in the modian system and issue their account speed, that's the problem. now, mr. ali saying that it cannot be identified, it cannot be traced, the taste of tax officials in this field is the criterion of action , it will not happen at all, i emphasized that this happened in the beginning of the year 1400 and the use of databases for that we can emphasize a part of our people without bothering them , a part of our people don't know how they should collect their documents. it is debatable that in this meeting because the documents

you don't have any documents that you can present to me so that i can control it . surely, our dear people will express more satisfaction by issuing electronic invoices in the mining system at the country level and at the community level through the fair payment of their taxes to the omar tax organization. you have two minutes to summarize , please. i emphasize again. in my organizational position , i am obliged to comply with the law in applying tax exemptions in the field of publishing in compliance with legal regulations and all my colleagues. they should act in the same direction, but the topics that are discussed in this meeting are not that the issue

of tax exemption should be removed, but that it should be targeted, that is , the same countries that have a positive performance in this area, my suggestion, not in the area of ​​publishing, in all areas of activity is that we should make the exemptions more targeted. thank you, mr. ali naqib . how much do you agree with this proposition that, for example, let's check and see how much effect this exemption has had in the field of publishing, increase or decrease it ? the exemption has definitely been effective and has helped the deaf booksellers. it is not without influence and i i also agree that we must obey the laws and one of my issues is the correct implementation of the tax laws, but now there is a difference of opinion that it will be implemented correctly, according to me

and mr. mostofi. promote them for reading books, and this is what the government wants and what the government wants. this is the most targeted situation possible for people and their books, because it depends on the type of work they are doing, and i said that depending on the merit, those books are produced. it will be placed and my profit is for that. it is more targeted. i agree. when we have to control, i will share the same point.

i asked if it was really profitable. he goes outside and uses it there. do you still believe that it has come into the field of consumption leakage? i have many, now if you like,

there are many documentaries. professional publishers mainly consider their income for development and even booksellers for the development of their own work. that is, if the bookstore has an area of ​​100 meters and has a good profit for it, then it should definitely look for a bookstore of 150 meters or 20 meters, or have two branches or three branches. ok. i mean, you or the publisher should go and buy a building with three floors it is allocated to publish a floor, assuming that the directionlessness of the content production, i dare to explain, if this happened, now the statistics will be reduced based on the point you said. you accompanied me

, may god protect you, ali. it made a difference, it didn't make a difference, it made a difference, it didn't make a difference

, it made a difference. no, it didn't matter. yes, it made a difference. with

optimal energy consumption together. we have built a house for you to come and see, this is called an installment purchase, it is available as you wish

, different accessories of each model and name, don't worry. don't buy different prices, come to the house, come to the house , come to the house , come to the house, come to the house, come to the house, come to the house, come to the house, come to the house, come to the house, come to the house. blow some more air to cool down , blow some air, be ashamed , we will perish in this house, why don't you buy an air conditioner, the account balance is not enough , this is the reason, it is not the reason, it is not the reason, we are going to the city of household appliances, buy a gas air conditioner in installments, it is a good offer

to buy a gas air conditioner, good conditions is. in the name of allah, the most merciful, the most merciful, greetings to you too dear and respected compatriots, we are here in egypt . the commander of the protection and security corps of the country's nuclear centers brings you the news of 16:00 together with our colleagues. he said: the country's nuclear centers are completely safe. saying that the zionist regime violated all international regulations in a criminal act by attacking the consular section of the iranian embassy in syria, sardar ahmad haqtalab said in response to the threat of the zionist regime to attack the nuclear centers of our country: revision of the doctrine and the nuclear policies of the islamic republic of iran and deviation