let's refer to the amount they expressed themselves, so basically the tax administration is different . the tax administration is handling the cases based on the documents. i already have this information from you, this information that you used to request from me, now i have these commercial bank accounts in which you used to carry out your business activities and you are now in my possession according to the rules and in fact the use of artificial intelligence rules for trading information when we identify people, and we identify the person who is in the real interest of doing the transaction, we provide his information . it is observed that the tax affairs organization is talking based on the documents. i must say that what what happened in the tax affairs organization, i definitely want

our dear people and economic activists to be aware of this. it is that in 1402, when there are 1401 tax returns, the remaining 600,000 , we processed the increase in our taxes for sure with the declaration of insiders. which is more than 60% of this the certainties in the stage of processing and notification of the diagnosis form have occurred, more than 6 times the declared tax to the certainty tax of this article. as you said, for now, the existing agreement has no place for nashman and booksellers , because the coefficient of nashman and faran books is zero, and article 100 has no place in the agreement, because it is your system. books are 3 and 8 and publishers calculate 2 and a half on it and don't calculate zero , that's why some books can't use 100. yes, but in the process, please

please also note that at the time of the actual submission of the deadline for the submission of the tax bond forms , we had given an authority to our honorable heads of tax affairs in all general departments that if a publisher applied and documented that his activity is publishing, it is published, and because of it , it is actually possible to exempt and apply permission. their activities are subject to a zero rate from the ministry of culture and islamic guidance, just as we did this activity in the discussion of free zones , we also gave this authority to our tax officials for business areas in this way. make sure that your tax was not included in the sale of books . if you go and it is not done, please let me know and i will follow up and see if i can tell you something about the tax exemption rules. we

are not talking about the numbers that are taken. i asked you before the program started. you said that 5% of the tax revenue of the tax department is 5% . it is very small for the tax office, but the same small amount for those publishers or booksellers who are struggling to work. you see, in the past two decades, all that direction was the front of knowledge. it used to be a barber shop, all of these were added together and turned into a bookstore, and you know that you would go from revolution square to university street . there were very few stationery items, or they were all booksellers, but look now , the bookstores are helping me. they are decreasing and these shops are being handed over to other businesses, now they are becoming cafes

, they are becoming stationery again, or they are having a problem, and this is a bit worrying. it means that the legislator has put this law in order to be an incentive for a business unit. instead this plan does not allow the business unit in the neighborhood that is related to publishing and bookselling to find employment in another trade. keep in mind that he should come and start reading the book. now there are less stores in front of the university that if it is bought or rented out, the person who is doing the work will think whether this book will be sold or not . i will ask mr. mustafa to come back to you, why is it being focused, mr. ali naghi , they point out that this number is very small

, why are we disagreeing with each other? the exemptions that are being applied in the country, and i did not say that i am against it, i said that anyone can see the positive effects . who is working in the field of publishing , he can prove to the ministry of culture and guidance that according to the criteria they set there , they can subsidize them from the source of the subsidy and from the same tax that they pay, and expand their field of work, by the way. it is excused, because the same tax is actually happening, and i emphasized again, just as mr. ani naghieh said, i am obliged to comply with the law , the legislator is also in the issue of publications and... the press. emphasizing that in the latest law, which is currently being implemented and usable as the budget law of 143, tax officials have exempted the field of press publications, but they

have made the discipline of the department the main condition of their work, so i can't. in fact, as a governing body, we would like this to happen and we certainly support it, but how profitable is this small number that mr. naghi himself said in the field of comparing the profitability of the activity that is happening in front of tehran university in the discussion of the cafe? how profitable is it in the field of publishing? you see an economic activist, an economic activist, not someone who loves culture, be sure, someone who loves culture , someone who likes the discussion of culture and the economic discussion of the case is placed in the second aspect of the issue , that kind of activity is not suitable in any way. dear mr. mousafi, if you agree with the fair explanation, the help you are saying is much more unfair for this tax. you see , the better a bookseller or a publisher works, the better they produce better books, and

the better they have a better sales policy, the more successful they will be. it will be more, he will have more income and spend that income on the production of titles makes more it plays a very important role. now think about taking this money from the publisher and giving it to the government . i did not say that the government should divide it. let them say that in the government's budget , this is what you are talking about. how should it be divided? well, this is the kind of merit and worthiness of a publisher who can produce better books and have better sales.

it considers everything you do within those frameworks do it, the merit and the type of the book, the type of translation cannot be placed and this becomes unfair, so this type of tax benefit is given by the law. for nashina, books have been considered the best possible situation because everyone earns that income according to their own merits and spends it on themselves. as far as the countries that we have in the whole world , there are 33 countries that have an exemption area, which as far as i know, most of the countries in the scandinavian area and the area where those who have the most the tax revenues of the country are their revenues from the place. their tax revenues ensure the policy discussion, in fact, the return of the amount in their own work area , why is it successful in those work areas, why in those countries, and you declare here that this cannot be successful, sir, the analogy you are making there are not many good comparisons. you see, in other countries, the study is very high. the circulation

of books is not at all comparable to the circulation in iran. unfortunately, the capital for studying in iran is low. the book in iran was 5 thousand, it became 3 thousand from 200 to 1000, now there are less than 1000 , sometimes there are 500 to 300 copies of books. this is worrying. to prevent this process, the legislators have exempted the scandinavian countries or the country. let's set an example. i want to convey exactly this point to you, that the effects of our policy discussion are wrong in the implementation. if this point that you said and the exemption was supposed to give positive results, 5 thousand of us, because we applied the exemption , that's all. our laws are showing that we exempt the field of press publications with the explanation of your excellency, if this policy

was correct, it would have been 5,000 instead of 9,000 to 20,000, but you yourself say that this number is a process that the financial benefits of this process should be allowed. the coming of the book has nothing to do with this topic of taxes, this is related to the economy. and if it has been decreasing

, there are other factors influencing this case, and this cannot be opened, because the tax exemption was zero , so it is unfair, so it has no effect, it only affects itself . say because you can't see it it is very helpful, very encouraging, it can be a party that, instead of coming , has a big store, instead of coming, well, now the big store is a part of writing equipment, a part of intellectual equipment, and a part of books. if the store sells 30% books, 40%, 50%, this will definitely have an impact, but if the book sales go down, it is due to other reasons . it has nothing to do with tax incentives or social justice, i don't know the budget, i don't know subsidies, etc. approach. let us increase the exemption how can we reduce it with the explanation that you gave because of the small number in the field, i

will say the number once again so that all dear ones can see that we said that more than 8900 people in this field of activity chose publishing activities and it is difficult to give us a tax declaration to the tax affairs organization, or there are booksellers who have this activity code. they chose themselves as the subject of article 139 in the field of publications. we had 39 billion tomans, 39 billion tomans in declared taxes. from this field of work if only you in the field of business in 1402, the tax we received was 32 thousand billion tomans. well, i want to. let's compare the shares with each other, and i emphasize again that since the 11th of hammat

, the legislator has granted the exemption that they themselves expressed on the 8th and 8th of hammat , and if there is any doubt in this statistic, i would like to submit the cases to you. i want you to tell me the suspicions. yes , this will definitely happen, so i will say it again, not only in the area. it is published that now the decisions are actually made by the government and the government, which until today are the decisions of the government as the supervisor of this matter, the press field , i respectfully emphasize that if we were to serve you again in another program, god willing, we would be able to give statistics, it would be possible for me to find out how many people are working in this field, why the statement paying tax is registered in our systems , we processed it and applied the exemption. so, according to article 146, who is not exempt from tax in the field of publishing? if someone

does not submit his tax declaration, in addition to his publishing activity, for example, an activity like last year in the budget law of 1401, if he has deposited interest there was a bank in a group of legal entities, this part was not exempted from tax, what is it now in the field of publishing , if we had a legal entity that was active in the field of publishing, or a person. we knew that he was working in another field. this part of them is not exempted in the tax system and according to the law, otherwise , the rest of the dear ones who are active in the field of publishing and get permission from the ministry of culture and islamic guidance or its authorized authorities, submit the tax return to the tax affairs organization, submit my documents on time. the provision of surrendering must be exempted, no, it is not like that at all, your honor you can

well, they also don't have much information. the auditor should ask for documents from maadi, which they don't give a proper meaning to, and they say that if you didn't provide them, the coefficient is zero. if someone is taking action outside of his legal authority or in some area , it is definitely necessary for us to follow up, and

i will definitely follow up on this point that your excellency said, from the general directorate of tax affairs, tehran center, and i will provide you with examples. i will send, but please allow me. but we put an authority under the title of tax proceedings authority, which has gained complete independence from the tax affairs organization. he doesn't have a chance, unfortunately he definitely has one because he doesn't have one at all. now i am his name according to the documents . now he is the judge responsible for issuing decisions in tax dispute resolution boards and when you have a judge , you accuse a country

judge of i have talked about this matter many times , i went to the presidents to have a draft written in the meeting in the presence of all three representatives, but the drafts are written later and then there were many times that i did not know about my vote and that vote was signed by the signature system without the signature of shamale. please give me your physical signature direction. and i am very happy because i tried so hard to solve this matter and it was not done , i promise you that by forming this program, this is a matter for you. after the decision is issued , it will be issued later, then they will say that you are the draft of that letter , it is not a draft, and unfortunately, even in the

tax court, the final opinion is not the law, this is the law. tax exemption is not taken into account . it is the opinion of the respected auditor, that is, everything in the boards that you say is independent, not the auditor's opinion, if a single digit number it has been written that the tax representative board will try to adjust , i.e. give a discount for a percentage of 10 %, 20% according to its own opinion , to help the bookshop, which is all documented, and the books are sold. we don't have work tax. a person who is working next to a furnace above 1000 degrees in zubhan, isfahan , is paying taxes

. my book might increase , if we want to go with this literature , yes, why not a bookstore that makes money they can pay taxes. for now, i am not a lawmaker who works for a respectable worker who is working hard, but the lawmaker can deduct the money he spends on buying books from his taxes , just like many others. this lady is in other places in a different form, i can do this for a simple worker. please take this into consideration and tell us that you are opposed to the principle of receiving taxes, because most of your objections are to the procedure and methods that are now taxed, for example , that the auditors sometimes do not do their work well, or other things that i mentioned. you don't have a problem with the principle , you have a problem with the procedure. basically, you generally say that no, i don't have a problem with the owner's approval law. many of them agree, but

in practice this does not happen. with the process that exists in the tax department, this does not happen and the process continues. i agree with the law. but they have a problem with the process of investigation and tax calculations of the tax department regarding this discussion of economic activity that you said

, if an economic activity does one day to four, as the famous saying goes, there is no economic justification for books and publications, because it is the same capital, the same time, and the same effort. which is drawn on the bookstore sedike answers much more easily if the party , for example, has a mobile phone shop, sir, selling it is not comparable to selling a book, a book that is newly established is very fragile, that is, one must mainly love this work to start this work, if not, it is an economic activity. it will not enter this field at all. you see an economic activity, a holding company, which has come to the publishing field and started working because they have very strong financial calculations. when they get the calculations of a publishing house or a bookstore , they look at it, it has no economic justification , because the book passes through checks. a long time, as the saying goes

it is refined and when a book is produced , it is priced and other goods are produced. you said that you said before the meeting that other trades are the same way, with the increase in the price of the dollar or inflation, but the book is not like this, you cannot buy the book. with the increased price, you have to pay the same old price. thank you for stating so clearly that if your information is correct and you refer to the financial affairs organization, yes, i am aware of the rules. because i am aware of the rules, and this is a matter of taste, for example, i know

that i am aware of some rules, but with the same condition. modi and my other colleague went and asked if they had a license from the union. they said no, because you are selling books other than those licensed by the ministry of rifles . the tax department said: "no, you must also have a book license." it is not written in the law. that servant of god, if you don't have a library license, we don't have an exemption. i say that there are various reasons that this law is not considered. mr. mustafa, you also mentioned in your order about smart exemption in provincial tax. mr. ali naghi also mentions that sometimes auditors or in different processes photo of taste tax is applied. how does this intelligent process happen? he said that if the publishers are going to comply with any number, these exemptions should at least be applied to them. you see that the tax affairs organization

has set up a store closing system according to the law, and god willing, at the end of 1403 and at the beginning of 1404, anyone who works in any field of work. it is working, it must come through the stomach and foot systems. our loved ones who are active in the field of publishing , knowing that their products will be recognized, which will definitely happen, sell their products in the maadian system. they should register and issue their account speed. the problem that mr. ali naghi said now is that it cannot be identified, it cannot be traced, it is the taste of the tax officials. in this field, the criterion of action is placed. it will not happen at all . i emphasized that this happened in the beginning of the year 1400 and the use of

databases so that we can identify a part of our mines without bothering them. some of our people don't know how to collect their documents. regardless of whether this happened in the field of publication or not, it is discussed that in this meeting , because you do not have any documents that you can present to me so that i can control it, we have come to kill a part of maadian regardless of the documents and documents. we determined the implementation of the note of article 100 of their tax in the form of possible tax, but since the beginning of the year 1404, with the issuance of electronic invoices in the maadian system , our dear people will definitely be more satisfied. at the level of the country and at the level of society, by paying their taxes fairly to the tax affairs organization, it will be expressed in minutes do you have time to summarize? i

would like to reiterate that in my organizational position , i am obliged to comply with the law in applying tax exemptions in the field of publishing in compliance with legal regulations, and all my colleagues must act in the same direction, but some issues in this meeting, it is not that the issue of tax exemptions should be removed , but rather the issue of targeting, that is, the same countries that have a positive performance in this field, my suggestion, not in the field of publishing in all fields of activity, is that we target the exemptions. thank you very much. from both honorable guests of the program from all viewers well, the higher program that you have accompanied us to this moment, may god protect you, ali.

i have a problem with lesson planning advice , but i don't have a good guide. this is gilnas publications, and we have made this problem easy for you. to get 60% of these resources for free , send the number 5 to the system 30485 right now.

get 60% of gilna publications as a gift right now by sending the number 5 to 3008 55, we will announce the news of this news section at two o'clock. we will come to your presence. united states security council plan to give full membership to the united nations he vetoed palestine. according to news agencies , the vote in the security council meeting on the draft resolution proposed to grant palestine full membership in the united nations was postponed until next week due to the obstruction of the united states. permanent representative of algeria in the united nations said: the failure of the draft resolution proposed to the security council on admission.