please watch us on the news channel . thank you . well, i want to start with mr. manaqbi , mr. mousavi, mr. molaki. please, let's go to the main point very quickly. why do you agree with saturdays off? first of all, i would like to say hello to you, dear guest, and all the people of fahim and your respected viewers. you see, we cannot say that we are a taffeta separated from the majority of the world. today, we cannot say the world because the world is a small village. that all human beings are living inside and must interact and exchange with each other. let's go back to the topic

what we are talking about today is that on thursdays, half of the country is closed, half of the country is closed, almost now, offices are closed, banks are open, schools are closed, some are closed, some are open, so actually thursday is our holiday, which means if we want to look at it from an economic point of view, it will be closed later. we are not only dealing with economic issues and conflicts that the country has, but only with our own country. in order to be able to have more interaction with the world , to have more exchange, we are required to have more companionship. therefore, the way we look at it, two days are holidays in our country as soon as we want to go to work, two days in other countries, that is, the majority of the country, like the majority of the countries of the world, are closed on saturday and sunday. or some countries are closed on friday and saturday. so we we can do it with this route that

we have made. if we take thursdays in our work route , our communication with the majority of countries in the world will be cut off for one day. therefore, this is something that we must pay attention to , for the general well-being of the country and to find economic improvement. what about us in the sector? in the country's import and export sector, we need to communicate with other people in the world we should use the maximum possible time in this direction so that we can use a better time for commercial and economic exchanges, which is related to the comfort and well-being of the people . we are going to close two days a week, so let's do it on friday and saturday. from my point of view, of course, i say that we should take the path towards, i don't

know if we should call it religious issues or special thoughts. the benefit of our society is the benefit of our country, do that let's give it, so this is the first step of starting my discussion with the argument that according to you, saturday will be more beneficial for us, it is definitely beneficial for us because our interactions and exchanges with the world will increase . today we want to do some administrative work with another country, which is closed on saturday and sunday. with the world economy of money, this is the work that should be done if we want to do half a day on thursday , we will reach our own friday, which cannot be done inside our own country because.

it's a complete holiday. we will arrive on saturday when we can work. saturday and sunday are closed. actually , it takes 4 days for this to happen. in financial transactions, it is not that if something happens today , this transfer will take place an hour later. usually , it may take two or three days for the fever. if you can do something on thursday, you will definitely go. by tuesday next week, this connection will be established. do something. thank you, sir. mousavi. please tell me what are the reasons why you are against the closing of saturdays. in the name of allah, the most merciful, the most merciful , i would like to say hello to all the viewers, dear guest , and your excellency. the fact is that you should ask the defenders of saturday whether this change is on saturday. what is the change of closing from friday to two days, friday and saturday, are these arguments believable or not?

the fact is that most of these arguments are ideological and they are hiding an ideological argument behind a series of hypocritical economic and surprising arguments.

the main dimensions of the country's export and import are on the shoulders do not kill now the main import and export. in a way, it creates an image in the market that we want to go to the market to buy a dress. sir , if this item of mine doesn't come on friday , i probably won't be able to buy and sell it. you know that usually the process of international buying and selling is a one-day or two-day process

is not a process of several months, and i am saying that the arguments are hiding something, an ideological lawsuit, an ideological lawsuit, which happens to be trying to de-ideologize at the very beginning of their speech. they turn their backs and say no, no, by the way, we should not have an ideological fight, otherwise, if a certain number of people there is no problem with international trade . they also say that there is a problem with the clearance of goods. sir, there is a problem with the clearance of goods . you want to do customs every day, 7 days a week , customs 7 days a week. if you want to remit dirhams to the uae , you can do it from this market in tehran on friday. make a transfer , the money changers work for themselves. my interesting point is , by the way, what is this proposal looking for, if he knows or does not know what to look for. this is that in the year of the production leap, it will break the back of production and destroy the food markets of the country. how do you suppose now that thursday is a half-day off, as they say, another day? these days, add the market on saturday. naturally , i will correct the lifestyle with just me in parentheses

. thursday is not supposed to be a holiday and saturday will be three days, which means that it is supposed to be thursday or saturday, with life and offices in the capital being more closed . we have a half-closed state in the city. this is not a closed day. yes, there is a half-closed state. even in tehran , thursday is not closed. in other words, people in the market are not waiting for the government to issue an order to close on thursday, and they are closed. the market has its own life naturally on thursdays and fridays, by the way , the market is open on friday afternoon. many people start working between work. the main thing is that when you can't fix the common point of public life , the market will suffer. it can be rotated, that is, on the one hand, you include saturday in people's lives, and until people cook , it is not a one-day or two-day phenomenon, until saturday is included in people's lives, until thursday can be removed from public life as a working day. at least you assume that we enter public life with mechanical means, which i am very sorry

that social understanding is not in this story, that is, mainly with we want to think about economic tools. did we think that people's lifestyles will change so easily ? the main thing will be that instead of two days off, we will have a day off. instead of one day off, which is friday, with this proposal, we will have 3 days off, and in fact, not only will we destroy the economic boom, but we will also cause the market to go bankrupt , after the corona virus, the market is just recovering. the other day, people are wandering around the market holidays, i don't know if today is a holiday or not. in fact, you have to look, even in tehran, where thursday is considered as a relative holiday. practically, the main day of public holiday is friday, and usually the second day of the holiday is considered the main day . actually, this wandering is more than this between these days. well, my first question is to you, mod, the reasons for your opposition to saturdays . registration of orders, customs , ports and transfer of po. unfortunately, i have to say something here that the dear ones of the field and in

fact the scholars comment on everything and do not allow others to comment on their own affairs . this is very bad because it is a discussion green order, you don't have the green order position there. we do not discuss at all it's not religious or ideological issues, why do we slap people in vain, we are talking about peace and ease . you say that people can live in any way according to the law of changing the state of the body. in people's lives , because when people's work path is open, people will definitely be at work, which means no one can say, "i don't go to work on thursday." on the working day, their work must be done. the discussion of international exchanges and interactions is what you say.

it can be moved on friday. i want it. i want to transfer, i want to pay the rial, how can i pay with 100 million tomans that can be transferred in the system , is such a thing possible, then why do we stigmatize people, why do you think that people like me who think that we are in the minority, this irrational discussion, you should give your arguments based on your expertise. i will not interfere in your expertise , knowing that i can, if someone knows me , know my background, they know that i can have some comments, but i will not do this because my appearance is not the same, and my request is to register an order for foreign exchanges. with unless you say let's answer the card. are our business exchanges taking place outside of iran or not? you usually do your main buying and selling from the uae . where does iran go? how many countries have i written in front of you right now? i am dealing with england .

do you do financial exchange? you send money from an iranian bank to mr. mansabi. i have a question for you . where should the order be placed? usually, in your economy, you have a business card. in the name of god , tell me which one you have. no, you have a transaction. you have a business. do you have an economy? please tell me if you do or not. i will tell you that you have tell me, i am explaining. today, if i want to make a trade exchange, what is our export sector, what are our emirates , what are we doing, so you won't let us talk, i am not doing anything in the uae, i am iranian , i am here, you rest of china, what are you doing now in the uae

, what have you done? you have created such a situation that in my emirate , if you, sir, explain to me once , what kind of person do you look like now , for example, mr. sir, why am i one of the people in the field who know how to do this? take it, this is acceptable, i want to import today, the first thing i will do i will get a proforma from a foreigner. i have to bring the proforma here, go to the trade society system , register the order . it has nothing to do with foreigners. they have to do this. from here , they have to go to the ministry and subordinate organizations to comment on this and confirm it. inside iran , it has nothing to do with onur. well done, it has nothing to do with onur . it is here. yes, you said that the order registration is there. i say no, it is here. yes, this work must be done here . it is done. then we will go to the foreign side, to the foreign side you want to go, what should you do? correspond with them

, communicate with them, you have money interactions with them , that's all you have to do. on thursday and friday , thursday, we are open for half the day. our bank is not our organization. on saturday, sunday, they are completely closed. there is no bank, no people, no one answers. he won't pay you, so we don't have two days there. we have a holiday on friday , so you say we work on fridays. this is the economy of the society, it means that the shop is not all of my shops, for example , you are projecting a minority, i agree that this is a minority problem, but why do i want to see the duty of all the people, the duty of the people to them, the difference is that you are all people, because you are the majority, i said, i did not say, i am the majority, unlike you, i said no, i am the majority, not my minority, i am the economic part of my country , you are not the majority of the economic part of my country. no, you don't treat someone like me . look at the people i work with. those who stick with you , if they are in the market

, they will do the same interactions that i explained about it, and it will not add two days to them. look at that person who ate in the market, if his macroeconomics does not take place a small piece can't do its job , it has to have its facilities, a production unit needs a foreign country, ordinary people need a unit . you see, a wrong thing that has come into our brain is that we have to produce everything, so we can't think this way. what is the reason we are seeing today mr. mousavi , what are your reasons for being against the saturday holiday? the fact is that i am against the two days a week holiday in general . according to the government's bill, yes, yes, the government also has evidence that there is no evidence for the legislator, why do you believe that one day, i will explain now

. i am not looking to solve the problem. not what has been stated, because now we want to go the right way in our discussion, what has been stated is that we are among the countries that have long working hours. per week, for example, between 30 countries, for example, 20 countries whose working hours are more than 44 hours per week, and because the productivity of some countries now that we are doing this work , let's increase the productivity, we will reduce the working hours , if you increase the productivity, the private sector, which is not the government , wants to comment on the utilization of its own employees, so now it's really between us , between god and the government men. say, let's pay the time

, it will go up, now the problem is this in our government , the inefficiency is because of this, not the problem of this , they say mr. do. that the private sector is not willing to increase the annual wages in line with the inflation rate, and it is increasing its capital gains in the same way, and finally it wants to defend my rights by raising a the next day, saturday, i will tell you about my days off. sir , if it is going to be added to my day, there is no problem. i am ready to come to work on thursday as well . please increase my days off by one and a half months instead of one month.

i can't go on a trip to the city and other places , but why is this happening in tehran because the independent capitalism has done something that the tehrani worker has to go to? he has to go to shahryar , he has to go to ramin from there to come here and come back, of course he says, sir, i can't come back at noon anymore, otherwise i have to go to work. he would be at home, he would be closed , he would eat lunch at his family's table, this is important , we are earning money, why do we earn money to live, well , if we ruined life, then what is the problem , eating lunch with family, getting together with family is important, yes, after being tired again you left, you get up , you go to work, something else, even friday is not islam, friday should be closed, islam says that when friday prayer is done, go to work on friday afternoon , there is no problem, by the way, the market has a very wise life, compared to the government, the market says sir, he works on thursday, even anytime the client is working. it's a friday morning when he wants to rest. on the other hand, we are facing another problem. only you

are talking about it. i think we only have the shop . we call it a factory. in the case of my factory, i would say that it is a factory that if he is really looking for it, he is even willing to work the night shift in the production line. you and i will go together, we will go to the government , we will not go to the people. sir, i am not talking ideologically here. i am saying that this is our problem now we both have to go to the fat government . on the other hand, you also want to add a day and see that saturday and that saturday as thursday. let's close friday and work on thursday. don't you understand that in the world game, this is exactly it happened in turkey , sorry, it happened in pakistan. first, say friday and saturday, then make it sunday, then add it to it . exactly the same thing is happening in saudi arabia right now . it's okay to say thursday, friday first . it's a saturday . let's add now

again with the same argument that it is closed on saturday can it be closed on friday as well ? they will remove it and leave it on saturday. in these countries, let me explain what happened in pakistan, uae and other islamic countries. after a while, you will become a government that wants to preserve saturday and sunday in your own authority. he accepts you because of his own life , there is a gap between the general life of the people, and the people do not accept this. please tell me what is your argument that the people do not accept this. this is the problem. you think , with your opinion

, i should know one month to register in iran. to order how do you solve the problem of placing an order? he says , "i want to transfer money to my bank account . how do you want to transfer money to your bank account in a world that has basically removed swift from your exchanges?" let's say, if you agree, let's go and see a report together, let's take a look, let's see what other experts think about the weekend closure, we'll come back , we'll find out the continuation of the discussion. let's think about saturday's holiday. we on saturdays, we only deal with internal work and

our external work is closed. mohammad hossein asfari, vice- chairman of the internal affairs commission and councils of the majlis. we have 10 million private workers, and we have to see what happens to these people with thursday's holiday. because we should not approve the law for two and a half million employees, but we should decide for the general society. daniyal shamsian, a member of the board of representatives of the iranian chamber of commerce, when we consider thursdays as a holiday, we actually put the country in a situation where it has only 3 days of business contact with the world. reduce working days with the world leads to a more difficult banking relationship. hosseini, parliamentary deputy of the president. it is surprising that some people suggest that saturdays should be closed. it is practically closed on thursdays in tehran. schools and universities are also closed on thursdays and some. provinces are also closed on thursdays . abbas gudarzi, deputy chairman of the parliament's social commission , today's economy is digital and does not take time. we have our own business procedure in tehran, and

closing on thursdays does not cause disruption. abdullah izadpanah, a member of the parliament's agriculture commission , approves the plan to close on saturday, it is possible for people's lives and i think that confronting the people's culture is not a good thing. yes, we saw the report together , mr. morabi first. in general, i want to say that we are talking about reducing work or adding closures from the point of view of the real private sector, the private sector that is struggling . today, the economy is in the hands of the government. is this a communist country ? we have a free country in the constitution that the work of free people should be in the hands of the people. why has the government taken over this work? why the government? it has become so bad that today because you came and said that i will reduce my energy

, i will reduce my consumption, that i will only give my salaries, whether they are closed or not. in relation to the discussion of labor rights and these things that you said, this is not in our power. today, we are talking about the private sector, if we close the week even for one day, it will benefit the comfort of the people, but this is the world. in order for people to be able to work better for the next 5 days, they should have a day off and rest because their work efficiency will increase. even if we say that the working hours are short , we can add those four hours on other days. let's provide four hours so that we don't deduct , but people rest for two days. people are trying to live. what we say is disturbing people's lives. people, when you say thursday is work day, work. let's say that saturday is a holiday, they are closed , let's say the same thing happens, we are talking about communication with the rest of the world, now you

are talking about ideology, we are not talking about ideology because we have a friday prayer on friday for the holiday thursday and friday . everyone should go to the friday prayer and perform the friday prayer . we can close the door for 3 hours during the prayer time what will happen if people go to friday prayers ? nothing else will happen except jama'ah, which is closed now. i will say it is closed. the only thing we can say is that there is a problem here. it does not have a jurisprudential issue, it does not have a shariah issue, and there are no verses and hadiths about thursday is friday, don't we stick to it, today we are talking about the economy and we are talking about people's peace. they say that people's lives are getting mixed up. it is definitely not. people who leave the country go somewhere else. definitely, in that one week, 10 days, 20 days, we adjust ourselves. they give and there, well, they can adapt here. problem it is not possible to create a social culture . social culture. thursday is closed. thursday is closed . saturday is closed. saturday is adjusted, but the main issue is the discussion of economic exchanges. the places that

we are going to name, we go to a place that may be lower than us, we talk about it, a place that we have to attach ourselves to, high, high, it will be bad , well, no, we have to go, if we are human beings who understand and are wise, we have to see what to do. we should do that for the benefit of the society and not accuse each other. when we accuse each other , we will definitely take a stand, and this is iran's stand. it is found that in the final decision today , the wise people of the country sit in the government and in the parliament , this is the case because the representatives of the people could not come to this conclusion, but if they really come to this conclusion, shatali's words are correct , they say very bluntly, mr. saturday, they should not. if it's a holiday , friday and thursday should be a holiday or something else and nothing else. today we see that the parliament is throwing balls in the government's land, the government is throwing in

the parliament's land. the truth is, we are seeing something that is my work from the sun, which cannot be said even if one is fasting. so, that's why the discussion is here. if the experts of the people are really sitting down, your highness will understand that we are a minority . well, i don't know. this minority that you are talking about is not a minority, at least to my eyes . let's come back later, we will understand what you mean by these things .

if the government of the majlis means that the majlis should say, for example, saturday is a holiday, how much do you think the market will accept, no, the fact is that people adjust their lives based on their own interests, and according to what mr. manaqbi meant, if, for example, you close the bank on thursday. close the bank on saturday. the bank is in the hands of the government. the bank is in the hands of the government . that's it. i will give it to the people on the same basis. no , it's not necessarily like this. because you, the reality

of public life will not change as easily as it means that the government can dictate and people write the way the government wants. in accordance with, for example, the wishes and advice, you saw that now some people in the bazaar's room are a minority of those who are trading in the bazaar , because they are a respected minority, let me tell you that you are a minority of undergraduates. yes, i am commenting as a student. i am an expert