present them from other parties. naturally , we have guests that i will introduce to you . if you stay with us until the end of this discussion , follow us on khabar. please, thank you. you are watching the economic table here. in our studio, mr. seyed amir siyar, the head of the national center for the improvement of the business environment, is present . we also have internet connections and another image that i will introduce to you soon. mr. siya's presentation. hello, please give the details of the letter clearly what does it refer to, what business practices have changed and what harm has it done to the commercial activities of the country?

such sudden changes bothered the economic activist a lot. he put his law in the parliament . it was not implemented for almost 12 years. the law of this government was written by him and it attracted his determination to implement it. and they can not implement the law. we have warned the late shaheed raisi several times. reminding but still sometimes

suddenly, according to their old habit, they suddenly changed their changes. for example, on the eve of eid, the ministry of jihad suddenly changed the date export regulations . i will raise the definition so that the dates are not exported. in the market, we said that the regulation law says that you do not have the right to change suddenly, my dear, you must change it some time ago, and it is you, for example, 6 years ago , you used to change and say, and for example, in mehr, you said that it was the night of eid. i will change it, it will change if you want now you can't change it, and they changed the export regulations for potatoes in ardebehesht month . what did they do suddenly, saying that it is forbidden to use naga onions ? it is exactly overnight. it means the future. yes, yes, yes. they still

do not adapt themselves to the new conditions , they think that the conditions are old and they can change the regulations overnight, they will trap economic activists. now let's bring surveillance to the middle and we have created a system, the 243 system they should dial 24 dot yes, 24 dot 30 dot yes.

see what has changed, call the device and if it is wrong, if he was really telling the truth, maybe he made a mistake. can't collect, will send. the supervisory body of the inspection and justice organization and they get into the story . one of the cases that got into the story was piad sibzmini. we warned piad sibzmini . it was around may. closing with other countries that export potatoes suddenly said to cut potatoes. we said

, brother of the ministry of samit, why did i cut off the land suddenly, was it jihad or samit said that the answer was interesting , the answer is that the apple of the field has not stopped its export of 25 tomans per kilo. you are right with this card that maybe you can prevent it from becoming more expensive, but you are making our exporters poor first. some exporters are worse than that . you are sending a message to the economic active public that in this country the law is under my feet whenever i want. i said, "i can put it aside , you have no such right." we dragged this process of courting and pulling the regulatory base in the middle, and recently, unfortunately, in the last month, the side has done this again in another place . it is disturbing the import process. you can't import them, they are so forbidden, we say, sir, what

are you doing, brother, you are not paying attention, we have article 24 , we have article 30. if you want to suddenly change the tariff , change the definition, change the definition, you have to announce it in advance , for example, you announce it now. it is very important and we have no excuse this time or the limited width of the country, i shouldn't have to wait in long queues for currency. we said that it is legal to go somewhere else and make it , go to the place that has two rates and make it . in short, you have to implement the law . it was the order and procedure of martyr raeesi that the law must be implemented,

my informant. they insist that the law should be implemented , the dear ones resisted. we told them that the producer means the businessmen of the country, later the producer of the country who wants the raw material, bring it . you are sending a bad pulse. now suppose you didn't let the country's land be forbidden for importing goods, but you should have thought about it before. for example, in july or june, imports will increase. with this situation, i will go to the so-called currency rent . i will think about it now. you cannot change the region overnight . you are right, but you will deal a bigger blow to the country. you are giving a pulse to the people that you are an economic activist. do you want to invest in iran ? i, the government, whenever i decide or see fit , i can change the regulations and make you poor. this loss is much worse than if the width of the country increases or decreases, or potatoes, for example, become expensive. unfortunately, listen. not thinking about them belongs to time

the qiblah does not belong to the recent developments, the recent developments are that article 24 and 30 is being implemented and has been implemented. dear madam, in the middle of the inspection, you know that the head of the government is standing firm . before, you used to think that you can't violate the law, and the parliament was aware of it, and the law writer was aware of it, which is why he says you want the tariff. dear friends, it is very important not to pay attention and say no, and mr. khandozi wrote a letter and the minister wrote a letter i do not pay attention to mr. mokhbar writing and i hope that this trouble they are having will become economic activists

. first of all , i apologize to them. there is work, he doesn't allow that and he corrects himself, that with the sudden change of regulations , the economic activity is caught. thank you very much . we are talking about this article 24-30. let's go see what happened together, we will return to our conversation we will continue with a product that is exported to 14 countries of the world according to customs statistics, but a circular made its export more expensive. on the 8th of may of this year , a 60% deviation was imposed for the export of potatoes. regarding onions, there is no letter. it means announcing. now we

asked our friends what is the reason for this. our internal folder said that the code should be closed. we cannot issue this quarantine now, if according to the resolution of the government board in article 30 of the improvement law. the business environment basically, if there is a device like this on the portal of the laws and regulations of the country, which is on everyone's phone and so on they can refer, do not place, it is not mandatory , it is not null and void. but this notification was implemented even earlier than the date stated in the letter. 8. they turned the letter and said that it should be implemented from the 15th , earlier than the 15th, i.e. the 13th, a series of ports, for example , to implement this despite the prohibition of issuing overnight directives, the planning of traders. the businessmen want to export, the businessmen say no, sir, give it to me, i won't change the rules of the game in the middle of work. and this issue led to the center for improving the business environment writing to the iranian customs and declaring this restriction illegal

to announce according to article 3, there is no regulation that creates rights or duties towards economic operators and before publication in that portal , economic regulations must be implemented. any of the economic activists who have a complaint about the circulars and regulations and instructions of the business field, which has a device that obliges them to do something that is against the law of business facilitation, i will surely come as the public prosecutor and help the work. we will be the producers of the country , now 3 months have passed since the promulgation of this ministerial law in a letter to the acting president, economy has complained about the non-implementation of this law in some institutions and the registration of 3 complaints from the private sector, according to the law.

it is against uploading in the legal system the regulations of the presidential legal vice, that too two weeks before the implementation of narges mozheshadi of the sed and sima news agency. your field of work has caused in the process of your business and business. in the name of allah, the most merciful, the most merciful servant of mohsen, the active walker an economic importer and producer of industrial renovations. first of all , i would like to offer my condolences to all the viewers of your program on the martyrdom of sarwar salar shahidan, and

i would like to congratulate them on the presidency of dr. pazeshkian. we had many problems regarding the circulars for creation of hours and overnight that are being carried out in these cases, from the issue of overnight rationing in the nine months of 140. 2 that all the economic operators and all the importers of raw material equipment and machinery of the country were taken by surprise overnight under the pretext of being in reality width restrictions friends of the ministry of poisons told us that the registration of the orders we had and it was even confirmed had an 8-digit number on the width allocation page, and even sometimes the width allocation. having the contract

and registering their orders was postponed overnight, there were very heavy losses, the hats were deposited in the customs, many bidders could not fulfill their government contracts, their bank guarantees were implemented, several meetings were held with friends of the ministry of trade development organization with the deputies. dear minister , we appointed the senior assistant to mr. minister. at that time, we warned all private sector activists that this is against the law, he said at that point in important 140 that this decision was due to the fact that the land of the country is equal to the amount of registration. the paving has not been done. with this work, we will actually manage the width allocation process, which sometimes

takes up to four or three months , to be reduced to a few days, and you can buy land at least as quickly as the width for which you will be allocated a quota. do it and do your cartoon better that we are talking about . in the open month of march, again a very confidential circular 77 writing in 17 pages, which is all about the environment. and the work and entry of equipment and machinery is in fact, the friends of samand ministry claim that it was written with the cooperation of the private sector, while the requirements of article 24 and 30 of the law on improving the business environment are not observed at all. it didn't happen at all, if

he wanted, articles 24 and 30 of the law on improvement of space. the business should be implemented, the circular would not be very confidential . if it was like this, the heaven of the month would not be seen from us until the economic activist and once again on the 5th of april, the quota for the registration of the orders made in the winter. we had given and sometimes 3 months had passed from the winter quota and still the central bank had not given the tax offer, and we had not been able to buy from our spring quota, unfortunately, in none of the decisions of the last year, the ministry was at all in the position of implementing article 243. the business improvement law cannot be done, we are constantly being surprised, and we are constantly experiencing losses, and these losses are in the form of inflation in goods , the lack of goods in the society, the reduction of production, and

the increase in prices will affect the people . thank you very much, mr. rahrova. one of the commercial activists of the country is in contact with mr mr. qadri, vice chairman of the economic commission of the parliament, mr. qadri, hello to you, please tell me why , considering that this law exists , it cannot be implemented by some of the institutions that have been mentioned , in the name of allah, the most gracious , the most merciful. siya , i'm sorry, my voice is echoing again . i want to serve the dear and respected viewers and thank you for the interest that sada vasima has in programs like this. it is not ranked 178 among 195 countries in the world

and it is ranked 120 for business space. we have two laws in order to solve these problems and problems, one is the law on improving the business environment and the other is the law on the issuance of licenses and business by parliaments . i was present and it was approved by the 11th parliament that we can solve these problems and problems that we have to attract capital and to maintain capital inside the country, and one of the problems that exists in this connection is the issue of information rent that some people for access to this round information sources earn huge incomes for the general business and market and economic activists because they do not have access and these information rounds usually cause huge losses in order to avoid problems in article 24 of the law on improving the business environment

, article c3 of the law on improving the environment business that is in the licensing law. it has been amended that exactly these tasks have been placed on the shoulders of the executive body, that before they read the section letter and issue the regulations and instructions , they should post the draft exactly on their own website, and the economic activists would find out and have their opinions. next from taking the opinions of economic activists and at a certain time that is determined by the government, which apparently i think has been determined for two weeks, it can be implemented after two weeks. it is not the case that the head of the executive body or those in charge of the matter decide and change the regulations overnight. well, in this report, just like mr. dr. sayah , the honorable president of the business monitoring center, they have announced exactly the information that exists or exactly the complaints. what exists is that the executive body does not comply with the matter and this causes serious problems

. i think that anyway. mr. dr. sayav himself and also dr. khandozi, and now in the future government, the people who are in charge of this work, must deal seriously with the violations of such an executive body. why should an economic activist suffer because of his procrastination and inaction ? when he comes to adjust his contracts based on the current conditions of the statutes, regulations, and the so-called current directives , he suddenly exposes an economic activist to black soil. in order for these things not to happen to anyone now, in the laws that he has enacted, the legislator has put the tasks on the plate of the executive apparatus, which is the apparatus.

we are talking about the statement of work of these articles that we have, and you think that now that it has been approved and the regulation is complete, why are they not implementing it now? if there is a violation in this law , we have come to criminalize the issuance of licenses . if the law enforcement agency is to analyze the duty of the inspection organization and the duty of the deregulation board to deal with it and the manager and executive officer of the executive body. they will be prosecuted, perhaps one of the reasons is that in the previous law, the law on improving the business environment, there is some discussion of criminalization. it has not been taken seriously, but in this new law that completes the law on improving the business environment, this criminalization has been seen seriously, and also in

the will and determination of the executive branch. let's find out the exactness of the production jump commission, the establishment of this commission from the image of the last parliament, god willing, in the coming weeks, we will be able to identify its members, who are serious and committed violations. let us follow the executive branch with the help of the ministry of economy and the business environment monitoring center . god willing, if there is any delay, we will be able to use our monitoring tools, which are questioning and warning, and bringing the executive branch official to judicial bodies. can i think that in the meetings we attended in the 11th parliament, dr. sayav and his colleagues, or the reports we gave, the issues and problems, unfortunately, the judicial branch has not reacted to the reports we sent from the parliament. need now ok, we in the parliament

should modify our monitoring tools a bit so that we are no longer waiting for the action of the judiciary and through the court of accounts or through the accuracy of the criminalization that is done so that anyone can enter and the judicial system is obliged. deal with the violators , maybe if this is done , it seems that in this parliament, we are talking about the implementation of the right laws, we are not responsible for the implementation, but we are responsible for the implementation of the laws, and wherever we see that the law is not implemented, we must see what it is, whether it is criminalization. has it not happened or is there a so-called escape route? whether the executive body can escape from it or not , we must see these things exactly in the so-called legal reforms, which is exactly what you mentioned.

god willing, the habit of making sudden changes in regulations at night, something comes to their mind early in the morning, and the front means the habit, the process and the regulations, and they change them . that the economic operator must work to earn tax.

i hope that the new government will instill this mentality in the brains and minds of all managers and behind government desks, god willing institutionalize them so that they don't bother these dear ones who are fighting for potatoes, onions and plain. because they are making me suddenly or this is how they are causing trouble for our importers and economic activists , is he not aware that if this means, you know, we were an oil country for decades, 50, 100 years , we were an oil country, it has always been oil, and i am a bureaucrat . the government used to say that my salary money comes from oil. if we feel that there is no oil in the business and the economic activist should make a profit to pay taxes so that i can sleep at night, then our behavior with the judicial activist will be fine, then we will not bother him so much. then

we won't suddenly change the regulations so much that the poor person will think that this is just a habit or not. we can imagine other reasons for it. let's look very pessimistic . let's count together so that they will remove chubo. this is very good. we are in good contact with mr. shahbazi . secretary of the economic commission of the government, mr. shahbazi. hello , please tell me why despite the fact that we are talking, the 13th government tried very hard so that after 10-12 years this the regulations should be implemented and approved, why are you alone now? from device government agencies do not comply with it. yes, in the name of allah , the most merciful, the most merciful. i have a good time . thank you, dear guests, for actually convening this meeting . i will give a report. that in spite of all these considerations and finally the concerns that the government has made this decision, what

were these concerns? for example, the devices say, sir, sometimes we have unpredictable conditions, for example, i don't know, we have conditions where a problem suddenly arises in the field of agricultural jihad, in the field of industry. we have to make some decisions in order to manage that area, for example, we have to, in fact, the argument against and from the government's point of view was that if this is the case, we have to change the regulations every day. and practically , there is no stability and predictability in the regulations. in fact, an interim summary was made, in the sense that in reality, we do not close all the devices from 0 to 100 and no device can function if something happens. there was a problem for consumers, for example, they could not make any decision, for example, it was stipulated in this regulation that the highest authority of the device must be a force majeure

or a change. it is really necessary and should be decided quickly, not by the general manager, and i don't know by the deputy of a group, and whoever comes to announce a regulation, so i wanted to say that this observation and concern has always been in the governments that one is actually two. the other side of the story is that we should generally say that no recipe or regulation should be changed unless it has 3 to 4 months of time, from that point of view, the hands of the executive and the government would be completely closed. therefore, we must see both sides of the issue. what is seeing both sides of the issue? this is our consumer rights for example, if there is a product in the market, there will be a deficit. well, the ministry of jihad has been like this before, sir, to ban its export and impose a duty. we discussed that in the government , you have to plan the devices in advance. it means to see that, for example, in the field of

basic needs, basic goods, farmers. what is going to happen in the next month, what is our forecast for the market in the next 6 months? well, for example, for this case of agriculture, for example , for dates, it was not predictable that the time of ramadan is known, why is it like that, by the way, we have many laws, for example in the field of basic goods and agriculture, the ministry of home affairs assigned us in the 5th plan, we had the 6th plan, and we had the task to remove the tools , for example. you want to buy, you want to regulate the market, very well, buy now, in 6 months, the market demand is high, direct supply by the government companies is too much, and it's not that we don't plan, we want to see, for example, there is a shortage of dates, i don't know , there is a shortage of onions. i wanted to say that when people ask why 11 or 12 years were left, one of the concerns was that the machine said, sir, finally.

our hands are tied and they consume these. what should we do about it, not all of them are producers, so the answer is yes, we have to see things through, for example, if something really necessary happens, if the minister decides that this should happen, for example, then the deputy director general and a directive from the director general of a province and so on. the business environment in the country is really deteriorating . finally, the government took this decision with all the considerations and concerns, the government of martyr ayatollah raeesi, and it was a brave decision to finally approve this by-law. and i'm totally in actually, i think this is a good thing, but we really need to look at it from the point of view of the government and the government .