Skip to main content

tv   2020  ABC  February 9, 2024 9:01pm-11:01pm PST

9:01 pm
>> deborah: from a car wreck to a murder for hire plot. >> david: so much of it caught on home surveillance camera. what it reveals. an all-new "20/20" starts right now. >> it's one of the most complex investigations i've ever seen. lust, greed, betrayal. this is where it all start. this was it. >> what we initially had thought was the vehicle traveled down the embankment. >> you could tell that they had gunshot wounds. william had been shot in the head. then holly was shot. >> she was also worried and scared. >> there were unidentified males
9:02 pm
going up to miss williams' apartment in the days leading up to the murders. >> hey, holly. >> "we're not here for you, we're here for william." >> she apparently already knew this was danger. this was somebody who was possibly a threat to her. >> she is frantically walking through the apartment, pacing around. then you see her take the bar and strongback the door on the inside. >> this case is all over the place. nashville, tennessee. austin, texas. hollywood. you've got blackmail, escorts, double murders, hitmen. >> so it's obvious it was from someone that was hiding? >> the person had used the name "agent 47." a name for an assassin in a video game. >> the world's finest professional hitmen -- >> and the absolute planning of this murder is something you will never have heard before. >> this one is unlike any other homicide case i've ever worked on.
9:03 pm
nashville, there's something going on, all the time, every weekend. ♪ i had me a boy turned him into a man ♪ >> nashville's scene is interactive. so, there's a lot of dancing, jiving. ♪ one two three they're gonna run back to me ♪ >> listening to country music. >> the city here in nashville is just -- it's such a beautiful, magical place. ♪ they always want to come but they never wanna leave ♪ >> but on march 12th of 2020, just a few miles away from the downtown scene, in a much quieter part of town, a mystery with far-reaching implications was developing. >> this was like a script out of a movie, just the way things were unfolding, and it was just -- it was hard to believe. >> metro national 911. what is the address of your emergency? >> somebody drove off the road and hit a tree.
9:04 pm
>> a construction worker at the address at 497 old hickory boulevard discovered a white acura sedan crashed down an embankment at that location. >> are you with the vehicle? >> yeah. there's two people there. they're pinned really bad, that's what i'm saying. >> okay. i'm sending the paramedics and the police department to help you now. >> you come right down here to this spot and look over the edge, and there you saw this -- this vehicle. >> a male subject was obviously deceased in the passenger floorboard of the car with his face down into the floorboard. >> just stuffed on the floor. >> yeah. and his feet were up in the -- into the ceiling of the car. and then behind him in the back passenger seat, you see a female obviously deceased the backseat -- on the floorboard in between the backseat and the front seats.
9:05 pm
>> police determine the victims are 33-year-old holly williams and 36-year-old bill lanway. ♪ happy birthday to you ♪ >> the two were well-known fixtures on the nashville strip. >> bill and holly did used to come to my bar together a lot. they always seemed to be having a good time. they were out together a lot when they were with each other. >> they were always playing jokes when i was around, with each other. >> holly grew up in murfreesboro, tennessee. her family says she loved christmas because it was the season of holly. >> life wasn't always great. her parents divorced. she had a difficult relationship with her biological mother, and over time it was out-and-out estrangement.
9:06 pm
she lived with her father and stepmother. >> holly eventually made the move the big city and met marie carroll. >> this is it, huh? this is the town? >> they both became skincare specialists and close friends. they made the most of the vibrant nashville scene. >> how would you describe the city and your time that you spent here with holly? >> a lot of people come here to accomplish their dreams. >> your life with holly here, what was it like? >> we just loved to spend time with friends. we loved to watch football games together. >> what are you doing? what are you doing? >> it kind of reminded me of marilyn monroe, several men would come by and light her cigarette. that's exactly how it was with holly and being out with her. >> people gravitated towards her. i mean, i did. i instantly thought she was amazing. >> she was a good person. she would give you the shirt off
9:07 pm
her back if you needed it. >> the second victim in the car, bill lanway, worked as an auto mechanic. he was often seen socializing with holly and was known to have as much fun energy as his girlfriend. >> bill lanway, life of the party, had this favorite watering hole he'd go to on the weekends where he knew everybody, kind of like a "cheers" episode. his childhood friends said, "never a dull moment with him." >> i grew up in clarksville, tennessee, and known bill since he was probably 6 or 7 years old. went to elementary and middle and high school together. he's always been a staple of nashville since i can remember. >> living here, people go down to broadway, midtown, gulch area, and bill was always out in that scene, too. he loved it. >> at first, it looks as if holly and bill were the victims of a tragic car accident.
9:08 pm
but when the vehicle is pulled up from the embankment, police discover clear signs of foul play. >> from the outside, it looked like a car crash. when you looked inside, it wasn't a car crash. >> the passenger windows were broken out, but there was no glass around the vehicle anywhere to be seen. typically on a traffic crash, you'd see glass on the inside and on the outside. >> and when the bodies are removed from the car, police discover that holly and bill had been brutally shot to death. >> once we got the -- the victims out of the car, we could tell that they had gunshot wounds to their heads and torsos. william had been shot in the head at least once. then holly was shot in the head at least one time, and shot in the torso on the left side at least one time. >> for detectives, this criminal investigation is still a blank slate. they've got to figure out why would anyone want this
9:09 pm
fun-loving, well-liked couple to be gunned down? they need to find out more about bill and holly. and they find out something that's a bit of a red flag about bill lanway. >> we could see that there was a lot of history, like, domestically. he had still had open court cases where he was out on bond for a domestic violence situation between her and him. >> holly's relationship with bill was what i would say is toxic. i was very worried about her in the relationship. i know at times she wasn't happy, and she was also worried and scared. >> this tempestuous relationship between bill and holly finally came to a head following a deeply disturbing incident involving holly's beloved dog, max. >> tell me about the dog.
9:10 pm
>> she had texted me that she came home and found her dog dead. and she said, "i know it was bill. i know it was bill." >> when news breaks in nashville about holly and bill's deaths, some of those close to holly are sure they know who was behind the shootings. >> i thought that bill had -- it was a murder/suicide, and i know a lot of holly's friends felt the same way. >> i mean, assumed was that it would be a murder/suicide, especially with them found in her car like that. >> but you thought, no matter what, that this was bill lanway? >> yeah. >> holly was so afraid of bill that she installed several cameras inside her apartment. >> there's no way in hell i'm leaving my apartment knowing that you can disable my lock. >> did those cameras capture her killer? >> holly?
9:11 pm
♪ jardiance! ♪ ♪ it's a little pill with a big story to tell ♪ ♪ i take once-daily jardiance ♪ ♪ at each day's start! ♪ ♪ as time went on it was easy to see ♪ ♪ i'm lowering my a1c! ♪ jardiance works twenty-four seven in your body to flush out some sugar. and for adults with type 2 diabetes and known heart disease, jardiance can lower the risk of cardiovascular death, too. serious side effects may include ketoacidosis that may be fatal, dehydration that can lead to sudden worsening of kidney function, and genital yeast or urinary tract infections. a rare, life-threatening bacterial infection in the skin of the perineum could occur. stop jardiance and call your doctor right away if you have symptoms of this infection ketoacidosis, or an allergic reaction. you may have an increased risk for lower limb loss. call your doctor right away if you have symptoms of infection in your legs or feet. taking jardiance with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. ♪ jardiance is really swell ♪ ♪ the little pill ♪ ♪ with a big story to tell! ♪
9:12 pm
long after guests leave, viruses and bacteria linger. air fresheners add a scent. but only lysol air sanitizer helps erase the trace, eliminating odor and killing 99.9% of viruses and bacteria in the air. scent can't sanitize. lysol can. (luke) what about “homes is where the homes are?” (marci) s“where homes live?”. (luke) “home sweet homes?” (marci) no. (luke) something, something “phone homes.” (marci) no. (luke) “website full of homes...” (marci) “home of the homes.” (luke) “we've got homes to write home about.” (marci) “what's up, homes?” (luke) “we know where you live... we know where you will live.” (marci) sounds like a threat. (luke) “homes for sale website, dot com.” (marci) “ding-dong. it's homes...” (janitor) wow, you two have done your homework. (luke) yeah, what he said. what he said. what he said. (marci) oh...okay.
9:13 pm
♪ sure, mcdonald's breakfast is good. ♪ but getting that mcdonald's breakfast two minutes before it stops being served... that tastes even better. ♪
9:14 pm
detectives are trying to unravel the mystery of a young couple who are gunned down and found in a crashed car in a ravine. once they take a deeper dive
9:15 pm
into the relationship between bill lanway and holly williams, they discover some disturbing information. >> he had been arrested for assault of her. >> in nashville's thriving nightlife scene, bill lanway was seen as the life of the party. but friends say that was a mask for a much deeper, darker side of bill lanway. >> bill was dealt a really bad hand in life, and it's really tragic how his life started. >> in november of 1986, when bill lanway was just a toddler, his father lyle held bill, his babysitter, and bill's mother hostage for hours following a marital dispute. afterwards, his father was arrested and taken to a hospital for psychiatric evaluation and care. then, six days later, while on temporary release, lyle lanway
9:16 pm
violated a protective order and returned to the house. and right there, he stabbed his wife, in front of young bill. >> his father had killed his mother on thanksgiving day in front of him. his dad went to prison for that. >> the one fortunate thing was that he had a loving aunt and uncle who took him in and raised him and stayed very devoted to him. >> bill got voted best personality in high school. it's probably because bill was just a funny guy. >> he's very social, and he always was, since -- since he was younger, it seemed like. >> what was he like in high school? >> he was very friendly, everybody's friend. >> dana jones was four years younger than bill in high school. the two began a romantic relationship just after dana graduated. >> we actually met at a party that was at his house.
9:17 pm
it was more of a fun type relationship. you know, we just hung out with friends, basically. and then i found out i was pregnant six months after dating him, so. >> and what was his reaction when he found out that you were -- that you were pregnant? >> we were both excited. he said he had always wanted to be a father. this is her baby book that i tried to put together. >> little princess? >> oh, she wanted to be a princess. >> for bill lanway, the future looked so bright with a family of his own to nurture and care for. and then fate would deliver a second horrific blow. >> i know this is really uncomfortable. can you tell me the story about maddie and what happened? >> she had flu-like symptoms for about three weeks, and that's
9:18 pm
the night that we found out she had cancer. i mean, there was -- there was nothing else they could do. >> you knew she was going to die? >> yeah. >> what was bill's reaction to all of this? >> um, he -- he was upset. i mean, he -- he really was. he was devastated. >> the cancer came back stronger, more aggressive than ever. >> lanway spoke out about his daughter's death in a documentary he participated in to help cancer patients. >> it did feel like the whole world came crashing down. maddie battled cancer for 16 months. i hope one day i'll see my daughter again. >> according to dana, the tragic illness and death of their daughter changed bill's personality and their relationship for the worse. >> it was just pushing and
9:19 pm
arguing to start with. he would damage my property. he would pick a fight, and the day after the funeral i had packed him a little box of some of her things and that's -- that's when i told him, "never -- never contact me again." >> he never did? >> he never did. >> i think a part of the way he hid emotions came from gaining relief by drinking or by partying. >> by the time bill met holly at a music festival in nashville in 2018, he had developed a reputation as a fun-loving man around town. >> they seemed to click. they were bubbly, they loved to laugh. it seemed like everything was perfect. but it didn't take long for the cracks to develop. >> they had an on again, off again relationship where he was -- he was abusive towards her both verbally and physically. >> according to these police
9:20 pm
reports from 2019, holly claimed bill punched her in the mouth and broke her windshield. holly declined to press charges and refused assistance for domestic violence from the police. but in january of 2020, holly requested a restraining order against bill, accusing him of covering her mouth, causing her to hyperventilate. it was during that same incident that she accused bill of going into her apartment and taking her dog, max. the court date for this incident was pending at the time of their deaths. >> nobody knows if he stole the dog or just let the dog out. because she found the dog several days later on the side of the road, dead, right over by her apartments. >> did holly think that -- that bill killed the dog? >> oh, yeah, yeah. she did. >> friends say holly was so scared of bill at this point that she installed security cameras. >> so she had three cameras at her apartment.
9:21 pm
one of them was on the exterior looking at the walkway up to her door, and there were two on the inside. >> one of the images found on one of the cameras installed in holly's apartment -- >> holly? >> bill lanway walking through her bedroom, looking around. it's really creepy because he's breaking into her home, and she hasn't given him permission to be there. >> bill decoded the digital lock on holly's apartment and got inside. she was in the process of getting additional protection for her apartment. >> is there any way i can get a deadbolt -- traditional deadbolt lock? because the door lock wasn't changed, he was able to come in and assault me. >> so it was very apparent that their relationship wasn't good, and it was suggested initially that it could have been a murder/suicide. >> while some of those close to holly are convinced bill killed her and then took his own life,
9:22 pm
detectives are not so sure. they're finding clues at the accident scene that make them suspect the car crash might have somehow been staged. >> the car wasn't meant to be there. if it went straight down, it would go off of a cliff maybe 50 to 60 feet tall with some trees, and it probably wouldn't be found for a very long time. there was no gun seen in the car, no cell phones, and no murder weapon. >> and the when detectives take a deeper look at the footage captured on holly's surveillance cameras, they see something that catches them by surprise. >> there were three different men at different times that would approach the door and ask for holly and ask to talk to holly. >> hey, holly. >> who's there to talk to her?
9:23 pm
it effortless to bring joy into our home. go and stick it to any surface, adjust the spot with zero wall damage. i just uploaded my photos to mixtiles.com, picked the sizing and style and they arrived quickly, straight to my door. it truly has become the center of our home. order now and get up to 50% off. (vo) for over 50 years purina cat chow has been helping cats feel at home. with trusted nutrition, no wonder it's the number one dry cat food in america. come home to cat chow. feeling ughh from a backed up gut? miralax works naturally with the water in your body to help you go... ...free your gut.
9:24 pm
and your mood will follow. for 8 grams of fiber, try new mirafiber gummies. ♪ ♪ ♪ oh, i'll have another. make it a double. dad, mom thinks she's at a resort again. yeah, she told me. when you'd rather not resort to a virtual resort. this is much better in real life. it matters where you stay. lookin' good, babe! hilton. for the stay.
9:25 pm
you must have blown your budget. not exactly. you have great wine, name brand snacks, tons of meat. and where did you get this imported cheese? hello? grocery outlet bargain market getting ready to watch your team play the big game? or still sad they didn't make it? either way, scan to save big.
9:26 pm
♪ when you take into consideration bill's volatile relationship with holly williams, it made perfect sense that so many people
9:27 pm
believed that he was responsible for holly's death. he shot her, then turned the gun on himself. >> if you knew bill, you couldn't possibly think that he could murder someone. but if you knew holly, you had to think he killed her because you knew that she had reservations about their relationship based on domestic disputes. a lot of people didn't attend his funeral. as much sympathy as i wanted to have, it was hard for me to come to grips with going to a funeral of somebody who could've been a murderer. >> holly's funeral was also sparsely attended. it was such a horrific set of circumstances that people don't know how to act, they don't know how to behave. >> i think i was in so much shock that i didn't want to see her that way or remember her
9:28 pm
that way. >> while many of holly and bill's friends believe the motive behind the killings has also been laid to rest, detectives just aren't convinced it was a murder/suicide. but so far there isn't a single obvious suspect. >> at this point in the investigation, we didn't have anybody in mind that we thought would harm or want to harm william lanway or holly williams. >> in the search for clues, detectives decide to take a closer look at the footage from those security cameras that holly had set up in her apartment. >> this is the hillmeade apartment complex. just right outside of nashville. this is where holly's apartment is. >> so you found these cameras. >> yeah. it's something that you don't see a lot with investigations. there are several hours of video, so we just start watching it.
9:29 pm
i'm really concerned of what happened just before they died. >> and what detectives suddenly see captures on those cameras takes them by surprise. >> when we're watching the surveillance video and we see men approach her door, they're doing things to hide their identity, they're wearing long sleeves. they're wearing darker black clothing. >> one of those individuals then tries to move the camera so that it's not capturing the action in front of ms. williams' door. that attempt was really unsuccessful, because the video still shows the two individuals knocking on her door. they say they want to speak with her. >> meanwhile, the camera inside the apartment shows holly's reaction to the men at her door. >> she is frantically walking through the apartment, pacing
9:30 pm
around. and then, you see her take the bar and strongback the door on the inside so if someone tried to force the door open, it would have a harder time getting inside. >> she apparently already knew this was danger, this was somebody -- >> yeah. >> -- who was possibly a threat to her. >> right. >> there's one guy that, as he approaches, the camera gets a pretty good look at his face. the other guy that's there, you can see his face, but he's got a huge beard, and it covers up a lot of his facial features. >> so you got this video of these men that came up to this house where you knew that the victims had lived, but you didn't really have any idea exactly who they were. >> right. >> to try to figure out the identity of these mysterious men showing up at holly's door, detectives decide to do a much deeper dive into holly's background and make another
9:31 pm
startling discovery. >> holly williams, she was a licensed esthetician. we discovered that she had a second career, which was, uh, serving as an escort in nashville and other and other cities as well. >> when holly advertised for her escort business, she used the name layla love. she didn't use her real name, which is common and smart. if she has a client that she may not want to have contact with this person outside of work. so you wouldn't want them to know your real name. you wouldn't want them to be able to look up your address. >> holly started in the business when she was 18 or 19. she would be upfront about it, you know, with the boyfriends. they would pay her, like, $20,000 for a weekend to go with them on vacation or whatever. >> she would express the material benefits of being an
9:32 pm
escort, whether it's getting money or furniture or clothes, going shopping. so i think for her at the time, it was a lavish lifestyle in a way. but the dangers that came with it, she wanted to get away from. >> now investigators are starting to think that holly's profession as an escort could play into the identities of those strange guys caught on her home camera. so the next step is to gain access to holly and bill's digital devices. >> we were very interested in that because of her line of work and the type of clients that she had, like high-end clients. >> a third unidentified man came to the door. he was speaking to miss williams. >> hey, holly. >> this is about a client, we
9:33 pm
want to make sure you're safe. >> it's all right. i'm not here to cause any problems. just got a couple of questions to ask. >> the nashville police department puts out an alert, asking the public for help identifying the men, but get no leads. >> cops still don't know who those men are at holly's door. it's still a mystery, but then detectives uncover another very key detail. someone by the name of jimmy green is not only texting bill, but he's also trying to reach holly on her personal and her escort phone. and the startling revelation into the true identity of "jimmy green" would lay to rest that murder/suicide theory and introduce a whole new set of possible suspects into this investigation. >> it's the biggest break in the case. >> it was huge. we had something we could actually go on. oh, charades! - okay! - love it! umm... first word. - tonsillitis! - nostril! uh-uh... bill! uh-huh...
9:34 pm
- hip-hop! - limping! mmhmm! medical bills! uh-huh! - pancakes! - cash! who pays you cash when you have medical bills? grrr! no idea. [tapping] gap! the gap left by health insurance? who pays cash to help close that gap? aflac! oh, aflac! get help with expenses health insurance doesn't cover at aflac.com pictionary?! ♪ zyrtec! ♪ works hard at hour 1 and twice as hard when you take it again the next day. so betty can be the... barcode beat conductor. ♪ let's be more than our allergies! and for fast allergy relief with a powerful decongestant, try zyrtec-d. at oofos, we don't make footwear. we make shock absorbers. fatigue fighters. mobility maximizers. this is the science of active recovery. revolutionary oofoam technology absorbs impact and reduces pressure. it's the foundation of every pair of oofos, and the key to recovering faster. this is
9:35 pm
not a shoe. this is oofos active recovery. activate your recovery with oofos. when you have chronic kidney disease... ...there are places you'd like to be. like here. and here. not so much here. farxiga reduces the risk of kidney failure which can lead to dialysis. ♪far-xi-ga♪
9:36 pm
farxiga can cause serious side effects, including ketoacidosis that may be fatal, dehydration, urinary tract or genital yeast infections, and low blood sugar. a rare, life-threatening bacterial infection in the skin of the perineum could occur. stop taking farxiga and call your doctor right away if you have symptoms of this infection, an allergic reaction, or ketoacidosis. when you have chronic kidney disease, it's time to ask your doctor for farxiga. because there are places you want to be. if you can't afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help. ♪far-xi-ga♪
9:37 pm
9:38 pm
♪ this is the hillmeade apartment complex, this is where holly's apartment is. >> this is where it all started. >> this was it. this is where you can see on camera the footage of the two men outside of her apartment knocking on the door. >> but you didn't really have any idea exactly who they were? >> yeah. this was before we had any clue who anybody was or what they wanted. >> to figure out who those men were, detectives decide they need to start looking through some phone records. >> we're looking at call detail records of just before their death. who is contacting them? is it mom? is it dad? is it a cousin? is it a family member or a friend? who are these people that are contacting them? >> they notice a phone number that was on both holly's and william's phone records, and that was interesting. >> so this is the voice over ip
9:39 pm
number here, the one that he was using to mask -- try to mask his identity. >> detective willover is suspicious about that number -- a voice over ip telephone phone number, which works like any other number except it goes through the internet. most of these internet phone numbers are purely legitimate, but detective willover knows that sometimes people use them because they don't have to reveal their true identity. >> so it's obvious you knew that this phone call was -- was from someone that was hiding? >> yes. >> did not want to be found? >> correct. >> but good detectives can still find that identity. willover subpoenas the telephone provider for the subscriber information behind that particular number, and what they get back is an email address -- jimmygreen34@gmail.com. >> jimmygreen34@gmail.com. >> that's all you know? >> that's all we know.
9:40 pm
>> somebody that used the address? >> right. >> so at that point, investigators did not know who jimmygreen34 was. they subpoenaed records for the email account associated with jimmygreen34. >> they want to know, is this "jimmygreen" even a real person's name? the information from that subpoena only adds to the mystery. >> and one of the things that i found for the jimmygreen34 gmail account was the person had used the name "agent 47." >> you are agent 47, the world's finest professional hitman. >> agent 47 is a moniker, a name for an assassin in a video game. i thought that was very interesting. >> an assassin in a video game?
9:41 pm
but considering that nashville detectives always thought that the murder of bill and holly had sort of hitman characteristics, it makes them wonder, did jimmygreen34 have anything to do with their murders? >> whoever it is, that voice over internet phone line he is using leaves a trail, a list of distinct computer codes called ip addresses, and the detectives know they can follow it. >> every time they send a message, it logs their ip address. every time they make a phone call, it logs their ip address. it's like an address to your house or the tag on your car. i just compared phone numbers that used all of those ip addresses. it comes back one phone number. >> what was that phone number? >> adam carey. >> wow. so you identified who jimmygreen34 was? >> yes. adam carey is jimmygreen34. >> adam carey is the real identity of jimmygreen34.
9:42 pm
it is the first actual name the investigation has uncovered. and things get even more interesting as they learn more about him. >> investigators learned that adam carey wasn't from nashville, but he had an address in north carolina, who was a former united states marine with special operations training, who was working in the private security industry. >> you're under arrest for impersonating a law enforcement officer. >> carey has a bit of a criminal history. in 2016 he had been pulled over for impersonating a police officer. >> come over here. i'm going to sit you in the car. >> and was caught possessing pipe bombs and other illegal weapons. he was convicted and served four months in prison. >> i get the crazy idea that adam carey might have himself issued a driver's license out of north carolina, and he might have a photo attached to that,
9:43 pm
that i might want to look at. his picture pops up, and it's clearly one of the guys from the video. it took a nanosecond. i just looked at it and said, "that's the guy." you wouldn't even need facial recognition software to know it was the guy. it's the biggest break in the case. >> it was huge. we had something we could actually go on, someone's life that we could look into to see who he was associating with and who he knew. >> once we identified adam carey, then we started trying to connect him to anybody else who was involved in all this. >> it would take a long time, but investigators would eventually figure out that someone had hired adam carey in the first place. that person is a critical new name in the developing case -- bryon brockway. >> bryon brockway was also a former marine. >> bryon had spent several years overseas. >> in iraq and afghanistan? >> in -- in the middle east, yeah. >> bryon brockway's brother chad
9:44 pm
told me that after bryon left the marines, bryon did some top-level security work for the government. >> so he was there to protect extremely important, high-end people from the united states? >> and assets, that's correct. >> a really strange picture is starting to develop. brockway and carey both have elite military backgrounds. both work in private security. and now both are interested in holly and bill. >> so it was a real task to put together why these individuals had come to nashville, how they knew each other, how they were connected, and then figure out what that all meant. >> it's a mystery. what is going on? well, investigators eventually make a huge breakthrough in the case after more digital sleuthing. they're able to unearth this critical document hidden on the cloud that sounds like something out of a spy novel.
9:45 pm
it's a military-style document with a bizarre sounding name -- the tennessee sitrep. >> sitrep refers to a situation report, a military term for what's going on on the ground. it illustrated there were people who were getting paid to be in nashville to look for holly and william, and it was sent to essentially ask for further instructions. >> it turns out that mysterious document was sent to another name on this growing list of people, a man by the name of gil peled. and just like carey and brockway, gil peled is not from nashville either, he's located in austin, texas. >> but who is gil peled? what's he got to do with all of this? and why on earth is he standing next to charlie sheen?
9:46 pm
i'm getting vaccinated... ...with pfizer's pneumococcal pneumonia vaccine. so am i. because i'm at risk for pneumococcal pneumonia. i already got a pneumonia vaccine, ...but i'm asking about the added protection of prevnar 20®. if you're 19 or older with certain chronic conditions... ...like asthma, diabetes, copd, or heart disease,... ...or are 65 or older, you are at increased... ...risk for pneumococcal pneumonia. prevnar 20® is approved in adults... ...to help prevent infections from 20 strains of the bacteria... ...that cause pneumococcal pneumonia. in just one dose. don't get prevnar 20® if you've had a severe... ...allergic reaction to the vaccine or its ingredients. adults with weakened immune systems... ... may have a lower response to the vaccine. the most common side effects were pain and swelling at the injection site,... ... muscle pain, fatigue, headache, and joint pain. i want to be able to keep my plans. i don't want to risk ending up in the hospital with pneumococcal pneumonia. that's why i chose prevnar 20®. ask your doctor or pharmacist about the pfizer vaccine... ...for pneumococcal pneumonia.
9:47 pm
jordan's sore nose let out a fiery sneeze, so dad grabbed puffs plus lotion to soothe her with ease. puffs plus lotion is gentle on sensitive skin and locks in moisture to provide soothing relief. a nose in need deserves puffs indeed. america's #1 lotion tissue. what is cirkul? cirkul is the fuel you need to take flight. cirkul is the energy that gets you to the next level. cirkul is what you hope for when life tosses lemons your way. cirkul, available at walmart and drinkcirkul.com. what makes l'oréal paris? hyaluronic acid serum loved by so many? our highest concentration of pure hyaluronic acid. wrinkles are less visible by up to 47%. validated by dermatologists. revitalift hyaluronic acid serum. by l'oréal. ( ♪ ) feel the power of osteo bi-flex®. taken every day, it's clinically shown to improve joint comfort in 7 days, with significant improvement over time. ( ♪ )
9:48 pm
politicians... "he's bad. i'm good." blah, blah. let's shake things up. with katie porter. porter refuses corporate pac money. and leads the fight to ban congressional stock trading. katie porter. taking on big banks to make housing more affordable. and drug company ceos to stop their price gouging. most politicians just fight each other. while katie porter fights for you. for senate - democrat katie porter. i'm katie porter and i approve this message. is it possible to count on my internet like my customers count on me? it is with comcast business. keeping you up and running with 99.9% network reliability.
9:49 pm
and security that helps outsmart threats to your data. moaire dida twoo? your data, too. there's even round-the- clock customer support. so you can be there for your customers. hey billy, how you doin? with comcast business, reliability isn't just possible. thanks. it's happening. get started for $49.99 a month. plus, ask how to get up to a $1000 prepaid card with a qualifying internet package. don't wait, call and switch today!
9:50 pm
♪ the investigation into exactly who was behind the brutal murders of holly williams and bill lanway now shifts nearly 900 miles to the west, to austin, texas. so the detectives know a man here named gilad peled, also
9:51 pm
known as gil, who got this report about the surveillance going on in nashville, and they just want to know more about it. >> god, i've known gil for probably 20 years. he's just a -- a good, warm-hearted person. >> maybe 6 foot tall. he's dark complected. he definitely works out. >> oh, gil, he is something. he's very handsome. when he would smile, he could light up the room. >> many people, even if they met him, didn't know much about him. he was still kind of an unknown entity in the austin area. >> he was born in israel, went through the military there, like everybody does. >> he had said that he was with the mossad as part of the idf, and you know, he was special forces. >> do you believe it? >> i did at the time. >> the mossad is israel's elite intelligence branch. remember, that report sent to gil about what was going on
9:52 pm
nashville involved people who had military and intelligence backgrounds themselves. >> peled first comes to the united states back in 1999. and his story is, he came with only $500 to his name. he chooses southern california, and there he sets out to turn all that experience in the military into a career in private security. >> he looked the part. he acted the part. he fit every aspect of what you would think of when you think of a bodyguard or a protective security person. >> as peled is building his life in california, he meets a woman named jana who is working in a salon and is an accomplished hair stylist. >> i love the girl parties. girls getting their colors with their friends, color cuts, all that.
9:53 pm
>> jana worked in a salon that specialized in blondes, there in manhattan beach. she's a superstar. >> so if you want awesome blond hair, she was the one to go to? >> she's great. >> that was the woman that he ended up marrying, still married today, having two wonderful kids. >> meantime, gil's private security work is taking off. he figures out a way to move into the world of celebrities and hollywood. >> one of peled's clients was charlie sheen. >> gil was with him, protecting him all the time, pulling him out of the fire before it got out of control. >> you know, following someone around and, you know, clearing areas and making sure that, you know, the subject is safe and protected. >> according to reports in 2014, sheen fires peled. part of a number of staffing changes to sheen's inner circle. its unclear exactly what happened, but regardless, soon after, peled and his wife jana leave southern california
9:54 pm
entirely and move to austin, texas. >> i really think the move was to have a better -- better surroundings for his wife and kids. >> it was a change of scenery -- maybe a new start. his parents, i believe, and his brother lived there. >> in austin, he sets up his own security company, speartip, and helps his wife start a hair salon called level 12. >> when i heard the name, level 12, i was like, bing. cause what it means is the highest level of blonde. i love this name. >> i love being with people. i love clients, and they really become part of your little family. >> but for whatever reason, the security business isn't really taking off. and by march of 2020 when covid hits, gil peled is in some trouble.
9:55 pm
>> he appeared to be doing very little of the work that he actually wanted to be doing. >> his business was not doing very well. he was in a real financial bind. >> and that's when a fateful relationship is born. a local car dealership is having a problem with homeless people on the lot. gil peled begins a consulting arrangement to handle that issue. >> he was excited to have had a client that was a business, you know, that maybe he could get more work out of, like a client that had reoccurring business. >> the maund name was well known in austin. >> charles maund toyota, let's be friends. >> you know the name because of commercials that have rolled on local television for decades in austin. >> maund toyota was really a fixture business in the austin community. >> erik maund managed maund toyota. the maund family had become very wealthy because of the dealership. >> erik maund and gil peled are
9:56 pm
about to cross paths, and when they do, it will eventually lead to murder. >> but how on earth are a rich auto dealer and a security consultant from his business in austin linked to that murder in nashville? >> this was like a scene out of a movie. it was hard to believe. it was surreal. >> no one could have guessed just how twisted this story would be. when moderate to severe ulcerative colitis takes you off course. put it in check with rinvoq, a once-daily pill. when i wanted to see results fast, rinvoq delivered rapid symptom relief and helped leave bathroom urgency behind. check. when uc tried to slow me down... i got lasting, steroid-free remission with rinvoq. check. and when uc caused damage rinvoq came through by visibly repairing my colon lining. check. rapid symptom relief... lasting steroid-free remission... ...and the chance to visibly repair the colon lining. check, check, and check.
9:57 pm
rinvoq can lower your ability to fight infections, including tb. serious infections and blood clots, some fatal; cancers, including lymphoma and skin cancer; death, heart attack, stroke, and tears in the stomach or intestines occurred. people 50 and older with at least 1 heart disease risk factor have higher risks. don't take if allergic to rinvoq as serious reactions can occur. tell your doctor if you are or may become pregnant. put uc in check and keep it there with rinvoq. ask your gastroenterologist about rinvoq and learn how abbvie can help you save. liberty mutual customized my car insurance and i saved hundreds.
9:58 pm
that's great. i know, i've bee telling everyone. baby: liberty. oh! baby: liberty. how many people did you tell? only pay for what you need. jingle: ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ baby: ♪ liberty. ♪ ( ♪ ♪ ) start your day with nature made. the #1 pharmacist recommended vitamin and supplement brand. ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ (upbeat rock music) ♪
9:59 pm
(♪) [phone rings] hey, jim. i'll definitely get those to you first thing monday. bye. conquer the weekend, in the all-new hyundai santa fe.
10:00 pm
start with the murder of two young people in nashville. >> it's rare that we have audio from an actual kidnapping and murder. >> you hear the car starting, then you hear glass breaking, a man screaming, and a woman screaming. >> through the passenger side window, they shot him from that side. >> what sounds like a living nightmare. >> this indictment read something like a movie script. sexual indiscretions with violence and a murder for hire plot. >> this is the first description
10:01 pm
of the details of what happened that night. >> some of the problems that we ran into, we had a [ bleep ] taken at the same time. >> the absolute planning of this murder is something you will never have heard before. >> got a problem with one of the shooters in nashville. >> i'll pay the guy $25,000, but i think it goes away after that. >> so we need to take care of him? >> do you regret it because you just killed someone? or do you regret it because you were caught? metro nashville 911, what is the address of your emergency? >> somebody drove off the road and hit a tree. >> two bodies were recovered from a car down an embankment outside of nashville. >> the victims' names are holly williams and bill lanway. >> but when you looked inside, it wasn't a car crash. >> it was a murder. a murder with some tantalizing clues. suspicious men caught on home security video.
10:02 pm
>> outside of the victim's apartment apparently surveilling the house. >> but no one could figure out who would want to harm this couple and why. >> this one is unlike any other homicide case i've ever worked on. >> investigators learn those men in nashville are linked to a security consultant in austin, texas. and that security consultant is working for a very rich man named erik maund, a car dealer whose grandfather charles started the business way back in the '50s. >> if you live in austin, you know the name because of commercials that have rolled on local television for decades. >> you hurry to charles maund toyota and get our best savings on our best selection of barely driven toyotas.
10:03 pm
>> the name became synonymous with car buying in austin. >> the name was out there all the time. >> hurry to charles maund toyota. >> the family is a really nice family. >> anita ashton belongs to the austin country club where erik and his family have been members for years. >> the men, i know, you know, they played golf with him. >> so he was a hell of a lot of fun and very popular at the club? >> staff all loved him 'cause he tipped with $100 bills. >> erik maund is wealthy. his family lived in a 7,000 square foot home that was valued at about $5 million and had ten bathrooms. >> for years, maund had enjoyed the good life in austin with his wife and two kids. but in early 2020, that all changes. maund goes to visit his son who is attending college in nashville, and while he is there, he makes an appointment to see an escort. >> what's your thoughts about
10:04 pm
that? >> well, i don't think that's being a very good dad. >> that escort turns out to be none other than "layla love," whose real name was holly williams, and their rendezvous would lead to everything that followed. >> there were email and text communications between him and holly about meeting for an encounter. he had stayed at a hotel in downtown nashville, and they met at the bar of this hotel. the fact that he had had this affair with an escort was something he wanted to keep private. >> but it turns out that his secret is out. investigators say that out of the blue, on march 1st of 2020,
10:05 pm
maund gets a mysterious anonymous text message. >> it was a message asking erik maund for a sum of money in order to protect erik maund's family from finding out about this relationship. >> the extorter was asking for $25,000. >> erik maund was really concerned about those facts being revealed, not just to his family, but also because of his position as, you know, a decently high-profile figure in the austin area. >> and that's where gil peled enters the picture. now remember, peled has been doing security consulting for maund toyota. erik maund learns that peled has experience dealing with extortion. so he asks for his help. >> mr. maund showed mr. peled the extortion texts on mr. maund's phone, and mr. peled said to mr. maund that they should go to the police.
10:06 pm
mr. maund said that they were not going to the police. >> so peled then sets out to figure it out. who is actually sending that extortion threat? and what is the real identity of the woman maund knew only as an escort named layla love? well, to do this, gil reaches out to that man who you may remember, bryon brockway. he was a former marine highly skilled in surveillance and intelligence, and now working in the private security world. >> bryon brockway has extensive history in the military. he knows a lot of different contacts, a lot of people who are skilled in this type of work. >> to find out who layla love really is, peled also contacts bryon brockway's brother chad, who had his own intelligence background and worked in private security. but the story gil tells him isn't entirely truthful. >> gil began to explain to me he had been retained by a family in
10:07 pm
nashville who their daughter was missing and that she worked as an escort. >> so, you learned her real name, holly williams? >> we learned her real name. we issued our report, and then that was the end of it. >> and now, with that information his brother chad has gathered, bryon brockway then hires adam carey, that private security man from north carolina with military training. he then sends carey, along with two other operatives, to nashville to try to find out what they can in person. >> and that's how adam carey and the others end up recorded on those security cameras at holly's front door. >> their first goal was to figure out where miss williams lived, if she was living with anybody. >> the team is able to determine that the person making those extortion threats to erik maund was none other than bill lanway, holly's volatile, on and off
10:08 pm
again boyfriend. >> william had logged into her account that she used to contact clients and taken screenshots of the list. >> investigators say there's no evidence holly knew what bill was up to. bryon brockway himself arrives in nashville just as things hit a boiling point. march 11th, when lanway actually makes a phone call to maund at his home. >> he was concerned that his wife could have answered the phone. and the threat of erik maund's family finding out about this secret was significantly increased. >> soon after, those home security cameras record holly and bill leaving her apartment. and the question is, what exactly happened next? (vo) if you have graves' disease, your eye symptoms could mean something more.
10:09 pm
that gritty feeling can't be brushed away. even a little blurry vision can distort things. and something serious may be behind those itchy eyes. up to 50% of people with graves' could develop a different condition called thyroid eye disease, which should be treated by a different doctor. see an expert. find a t-e-d eye specialist at isitted.com
10:10 pm
the right age for neutrogena® retinol? that's whenever you want it to be. it has derm-proven retinol that targets vital cell turnover, evens skin tone, and smooths fine lines. with visible results in just one week. neutrogena® retinol when you smell the amazing scent of gain flings... time stops. (♪) and you realize you're in love... steve? with a laundry detergent. (♪) gain flings. seriously good scent. there's something going around the gordon home. good thing gertrude found delsym. now what's going around is 12-hour cough relief. and the giggles. the family that takes delsym together, feels better together.
10:11 pm
(guru) you give. you give. and you give. the family that takes delsym together, this tax season, you get... with straight talk wireless. you get unlimited data! (crowd) yeahhh! (guru) you get america's most reliable 5g network you get a samsung galaxy a15 for only $99! so you can give your janky phone to your kid! (woman) yeaaaaaaaahhhh! (guru) good talk. (vo) turn your tax refund into a youfund. switch to straight talk for plans starting as low as $25 a line. find us at walmart and straighttalk.com
10:12 pm
it's march of 2020, and there have been mysterious figures lurking outside holly williams' apartment in nashville, tennessee. these men were sent there by security consultant gilad peled,
10:13 pm
who was hired by texas multi-millionaire erik maund. >> so far, despite their efforts, the operation has not been fruitful. >> the individuals on the ground had had no success, then on march 11th, william lanway called erik maund's house. and that's when everything changed. erik maund was upset, he was freaking out. the situation had gotten out of his control. >> this was really significant to erik maund, because he was concerned that his wife could have answered the phone. >> according to investigators, that march 11th phone call launched a deadly plan. authorities say soon after, bryon brockway told gil peled that he and adam carey would murder bill and holly for $60,000 each. >> gilad peled is relaying that information directly to erik maund, and according to gilad peled, he jumped on the idea of having a murder committed. >> earlier that day, brockway had flown to nashville to join
10:14 pm
carey on the ground. at this point, the two other men on the surveillance team had already left, having no idea about the alleged murder for hire plot. by the night of march 12th, the deadly operation was under way. >> on the security video of holly williams' apartment door from the night of march 12th, around 11:40, you can see the victims walking out of camera's view. holly walks out of her apartment and goes off camera. william goes back in briefly to the apartment to get something, and then he comes back out. >> and into what sounds like a living nightmare. this is not far from her front door. and the door camera picked up the audio of what happened in the parking lot. >> this graphic audio may be difficult for some to hear. [ car starting ]
10:15 pm
>> you can hear the car starting, and then you hear gunshots, glass breaking, a man screaming and a woman screaming. >> seconds later, you can hear her screams get quieter and quieter. and then we don't hear anything else. >> detectives believe that the shooters ambushed holly and bill while they were in holly's car. incredibly, no neighbors reported hearing gunshots. >> they shot will through the passenger side window, they shot him from that side? >> we believe that the suspect opened the door and began firing upon will, and while he was firing at will, he had struck holly in the chest. >> authorities say the suspects then drove the victims to another location about three miles away. >> so this would've been the route to the dump site, or the construction site where we located them. >> investigators say surveillance video from this
10:16 pm
nearby gas station captured holly's white acura being driven by one of the alleged hitmen. it's trailing a black car where cops say the other suspect is behind the wheel. >> there's two cars in a row. >> right. holly's vehicle was following that dark-colored sedan. here we are at the last little stretch. we're getting ready to pull into the construction site here. this is where they would've stopped the car, put the car in neutral. the vehicle veered off to the right here and down this embankment to your right, and into a tree. when we discovered the car, the car was in drive. so somebody popped the gear and let it roll. >> so the engine was running? >> yes. >> here's what the nashville police know at this point. they know who adam carey is. they know who erik maund is. and they know that this erik maund in austin may be the victim of an extortion attempt, possibly by bill lanway.
10:17 pm
now, because these crimes are ostensibly interstate, it's time to call in the fbi. >> enter fbi special agent david som, who starts by following the money. >> we were looking at erik maund and his financial transactions. and we determined that all the sudden he makes a very large financial wire to gilad peled on the day of the homicide. >> how much was that? >> $150,000. >> investigators are now working with a motive, a theory of extortion, and they have a money trail, but what they really need is a confession. >> so you had smoke, but you didn't have any smoking gun. >> correct. i would have to transition from determining through circumstantial evidence who the probable people were to now being able to determine what they did when they were there. >> in their own words? >> in their own words, yeah. >> special agent som has a clever idea. he wants to go to one of the two guys who dropped out of the original surveillance plan.
10:18 pm
>> he left before the homicides. he had no idea that anything like that was going to go on. >> so special agent som convinces this man to go undercover to see if he can get the suspected killers to incriminate themselves. >> he made the decision that it's the best interests of everyone involved to assist. -- he wanted to catch them? >> he did. >> the idea was, let's send in this person with the proposal that he has a new murder-for-hire plan. >> "20/20" has agreed to alter the voice of the undercover operative. he first calls adam carey. >> what's up, man? >> i'm just going to run by -- run you through this little thing. >> yeah, go ahead. >> adam carey says that he's willing to participate, that the cost is $60,000 per shooter, per victim. victim. >> i would do 50, no less than 50, 60k per one of, per each of us. >> the tools that you would use,
10:19 pm
all the things that you would need to commit a murder for hire. >> find those weak spots. bring gloves. subcutaneous injections. if you're gonna do a long shot, let's say 50 yards, you could simply get a .22 long rifle. >> it's startling to hear those details, but investigators want more. so they decide to send the undercover operative to meet in person with bryon brockway in austin. >> the undercover met with bryon brockway at a restaurant bar area, and the beginning part of that conversation is guarded. it wasn't until bryon brockway and the undercover went into bryon brockway's car where we really got clear information. >> this time, prosecutors and investigators just can't believe what is revealed. brockway describes the ambush in nashville. >> some of the problems that we ran into last time is we had to [ bleep ] take them at the same time, dude. i took the big dude, he's a
10:20 pm
[ bleep ] fighter, man. he [ bleep ] caught my hand in the [ bleep ] door and everything. but i still got him. >> this is the first description, the details of what happened that night? >> yes. >> he admitted to it right there, uh, right there on the recording. >> finally, investigators feel like they've got enough, it's time to round up the suspects. but in order to catch erik maund, there's just one more clever ruse in store. >> erik maund is driving back from his hunting resort to home. and that's when the phone call was made. >> i'll pay the guy $25,000. honestly, i think i'd rather take care of it permanently. we got help to push back—with lybalvi. once-daily prescription lybalvi is proven to treat manic or mixed episodes of bipolar 1 in adults to help you push back. elderly patients with dementia have increased risk of death or stroke. do not take lybalvi if you are taking opioids or are in opioid withdrawal.
10:21 pm
the samidorphan in lybalvi can cause severe opioid withdrawal that can lead to hospitalization or increase risk of life-threatening overdose. get emergency help if you have trouble breathing, become very drowsy with slowed or shallow breathing, feel faint, very dizzy, or confused; or have a fever, stiff muscles, rash, swollen glands, or problems with your liver, kidneys, heart, or lungs. other serious side effects may include high cholesterol, weight gain, potentially fatal high blood sugar, uncontrolled body movements which may be permanent, dizziness upon standing, or falls. are you ready? ask your doctor about lybalvi. you may be eligible to save with the lybalvi co-pay savings program. visit lybalvi.com what is cirkul? cirkul is the fuel you need to take flight. cirkul is the energy that gets you to the next level. cirkul is what you hope for when life tosses lemons your way. cirkul, available at walmart and drinkcirkul.com. ♪ upbeat drum music plays ♪ sfx: [engines revving] tacos. sfx: [horn music]
10:22 pm
sfx: [dirt bike engines buzzing] ♪ ♪ upbeat banjo music plays ♪ can billy come out to play?! yesss! wooohooo! ♪ sfx: [taco crunching] the all-new tacoma. toyota. let's go places. nature's bounty hair growth. help grow thicker, fuller hair with just one capsule a day of advanced hair complex. conquer hair thinning... ...and fall in love with your hair all over again. only from nature's bounty. six days a week, when you steal a fry from your friend they could say, "hey, i paid for those!" but on free fries friday,
10:23 pm
they can't. free fries friday, at mcdonald's. ba da ba ba ba. [♪] your skin is ever-changing, take care of it with gold bond's healing formulations of 7 moisturizers and 3 vitamins. for all your skins, gold bond.
10:24 pm
♪ december 2021, almost two years after the murders of william lanway and holly williams, erik maund posted an intriguing five-star review of gil peled's security company. >> "speartip is very professional and on top of it. they get the job done in an expedited time. couldn't imagine using anyone else." okay, what? talk about audacity.
10:25 pm
>> a few days later, federal prosecutors and the fbi launch a highly orchestrated plan to arrest the four men they believe are responsible in the nashville murders of bill lanway and holly williams. >> four defendants in three different states that needed to be arrested within a couple hours of each other. >> 4:00 in the morning near richland, north carolina, adam carey was arrested by a specialized tactical team. bryon brockway was then arrested in san diego. >> at the time of his arrest, bryon brockway was attending his son's marine corps boot camp graduation along with his brother, chad, and his family. >> i saw that they pulled my brother aside. i saw that they had my brother in handcuffs and were taking him to a police car and putting him in the back of the car.
10:26 pm
we're trying to figure out what happened? what's going on? >> next up, gil peled, the point person with the alleged boss. he was returning from a security conference in las vegas. >> we knew he was arriving at the airport that day, and that's where we arrested him. we had not arrested erik maund yet. we need to know whether erik maund had knowledge of the homicides, whether he was part of the conspiracy. and again, we felt the only way to do that was to do a recording between gilad peled and erik maund. >> first, they needed to convince gil peled to help nab their biggest target, erik maund. >> the last piece of the puzzle at that point was gilad peled. getting him to make the phone call with erik maund so that now we could determine what erik maund's knowledge of the homicides was.
10:27 pm
>> tell me how it was you were able to get, you know, peled to cooperate on this. >> he learned how much evidence we had against him. explained to him that, regardless of what you do at this point, you're getting arrested. but what you could potentially do is assist us in making the phone call. >> at the time, erik maund was driving back from a hunting retreat in texas, and the fbi was surveilling him. >> erik maund was driving with a friend, and he gets a call from gilad peled. he pulls over to the side of the road because he knows that he needs to speak privately. >> you could hear a pin drop in the room, because the tension was palpable. >> the idea was that gil peled would call erik and tell him
10:28 pm
that one of the shooters from nashville was back, and that he wanted $25,000 from erik maund to keep quiet, basically. >> we got a problem with one of the shooters in nashville. >> uh-huh? >> he found out that you were the client that, uh, paid for this. for the job. >> mm-hm? >> and he didn't say, "i don't know what the hell you are talking about." he just said, "uh-huh." >> but then he takes it further, and he talks about, you know, what he wants to do about this, the solution, which is another homicide. >> i'll pay the guy $25,000, but i think it needs to go away after that. >> so, we need to take care of him? >> he did a solid for me and i appreciate him for that, but i just want to make sure it's, you know -- in six months down the road, he's not gonna pop back up. honestly, i think i'd rather take care of it permanently.
10:29 pm
and then i'll just run 150 through speartip. like we did last time. >> it showed his understanding of what happened in nashville, and it also cut against any kind of argument that erik maund didn't want this murder to happen. >> immediately after gil and maund hung up and i said, "take him down." >> almost immediately after that call is recorded, maund continues to drive. he's pulled over by texas state troopers, ends up right about here. they're ordering him to get out of the vehicle. just then, a bunch of federal agents surround it all, and then they tell him to get out, they cuff him, and they take him off into custody. >> federal investigators say a prominent austin auto executive orchestrated a $1 million hit job. >> the news of maund's arrest hits austin like a bombshell. >> senior reporter tony plohetski spent the day unraveling the allegations in this case.
10:30 pm
>> ashley, this murder-for-hire plot led to the arrest of four men across the country, but of course, here in austin, a prominent name associated with that plot is erik charles maund. >> this indictment read something like a movie script. sexual indiscretions with violence and a murder for hire plot. and then when you put the name maund at the top of all of those details, the story spread like wildfire. >> as prosecutors gear up for the federal trial of the four men in nashville, there's another shocking twist. gil peled makes a deal. he pleads guilty to murder for hire, conspiracy to commit kidnapping, and kidnapping resulting in death. he agrees to testify against his alleged co-conspirators. but will his testimony help make the prosecution's case, or sink it?
10:31 pm
>> one of the defense arguments was that gilad peled had somehow bamboozled erik maund into this whole situation. >> i think gil would have done anything he needed to do to save himself. i told myself i was ok with my moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis symptoms. with my psoriatic arthritis symptoms. but just ok isn't ok. and i was done settling. if you still have symptoms after a tnf blocker like humira or enbrel, rinvoq is different and may help. rinvoq is a once-daily pill that can rapidly relieve joint pain, stiffness, and swelling in ra and psa. relieve fatigue for some... and stop joint damage. and in psa, can leave skin clear or almost clear. rinvoq can lower your ability to fight infections, including tb. serious infections and blood clots, some fatal; cancers, including lymphoma and skin; heart attack, stroke, and gi tears occurred.
10:32 pm
people 50 and older with a heart disease risk factor have an increased risk of death. serious allergic reactions can occur. tell your doctor if you are or may become pregnant. done settling? ask your rheumatologist for rinvoq. and take back what's yours. abbvie could help you save. always dry scoop before you run. the hot dog diet got me shredded! the world is full of "health experts"... it's time we listen to science. one a day is formulated with b vitamins to help convert food into fuel. science that matters. not flossing well? then add the whoa! of listerine to your routine. new science shows listerine is 5x more effective than floss at reducing plaque above the gumline. for a cleaner, healthier mouth. ahhhhh. listerine. feel the whoa! ♪ you must know what it's like ♪ ♪ baby, you must know what it's like ♪ ♪ to love somebody ♪ ♪ to love somebody ♪
10:33 pm
♪ the way i love you ♪ people claim “my butt's perfect” oh yeah? then why does “normal to wipe 37 times” auto-populate? cottonelle ultra clean's deep cleaningripples™ make it easy to get clean. because this is crazy... when you could just do this.
10:34 pm
i'm peter dixon and in kenya... we built a hospital that provides maternal care. as a marine... we fought against the taliban and their crimes against women. and in hillary clinton's state department... we took on gender-based violence in the congo. now extremists are banning abortion and contraception right here at home. so, i'm running for congress to help stop them. for your family... and mine. i approved this message
10:35 pm
because this is who we are. ♪ on november 3rd of 2023, the trial of erik maund, bryon brockway, and adam carey began in nashville, tennessee, federal court. >> the defendants were charged with conspiracy to commit murder for hire with death resulting, conspiracy to commit kidnapping, and then kidnapping with death resulting. >> all three of the codefendants pled not guilty. i was one of the only members of the media who was there from start to finish.
10:36 pm
of all the cases i think i've covered, this ranks as one of the most complex. you had so many defendants. each defendant had his own defense team. robert mcguire has to figure out a way to thread the needle so that jury can make the right decision. >> when i gave the opening statement, i wanted to make sure that i was clear that erik maund had a problem and he solved it with murder. we felt very strongly that the recordings of the defendants were going to tell the jury what really happened. >> during the trial, federal prosecutors wanted the jury to see that home surveillance that showed carey right outside of holly's door. >> what do you think was in their mind when they realized that now they're on trial and that there was a camera that shot carey's face? >> they're probably kicking
10:37 pm
themselves right now. >> fbi special agent david som told the jury about the undercover sting operations that he designed and orchestrated, which eventually broke the case open. >> i believe that was the only way to really understand what happened in nashville. >> on that undercover audio tape, you can clearly hear bryon brockway talking, almost bragging to the undercover informant. >> i took the big dude, he's a [ bleep ] fighter, man. [ bleep ] caught my hand in the [ bleep ] door and everything, dude. when he did it, bent the entire frame of the [ bleep ] door. >> everything that i interpreted from the wiretap was that he was bragging -- he was attempting to create his own business line, run his own company. and i think, in this particular case, he probably said things that were not true. >> that tape was corroborated by much of the evidence found in the case. >> when you have the undercover
10:38 pm
recordings of the defendants' words themselves, there is no other type of evidence that is as compelling as that. >> now, the man i'm waiting to hear from is the prosecution's star witness, gil peled. remember, he's the guy who, according to prosecutors, put all of this together. >> i argued to the jury that, yes, gil peled is a liar and a profiteer, but in a criminal conspiracy, the only witnesses are criminals. gil peled is a lot of things, and ultimately, he did a very terrible thing, and he tried as hard as he could to make up for it. and that's what he testified to the jury. he knew he had done wrong, and all he had left was the truth. >> gil peled told a bit of a sob story to the jury. that he was down and out. covid had basically sunk his security business. he had two children to feed and a wife, so money was a motivation to get involved.
10:39 pm
he really needed money. >> but perhaps the part of the prosecution's case that had the most impact was when they played for the jury that footage of bill and holly being shot. >> when prosecutors played that footage of the murder of bill and holly, everyone sat in stunned silence. >> that footage is some of the most difficult footage i have had to look at and listen to as a prosecutor. it's rare that we have audio from an actual kidnapping and murder. >> prosecutors also played another key piece of audio evidence for the jury, that undercover tape of bryon brockway apparently talking about how holly was killed. >> some of the problems that we
10:40 pm
ran into last time, it was just, we had to [ bleep ] take them at the same time, dude. >> it confirms everyone's worst fear, that holly was not dead when they drove away from her apartment. she was alive, injured, and in a state of terror when they reached that dump site. >> on the recording, brockway says adam carey was the one who then shot holly to death. >> she wound up still breathing, and he finished it in the back seat. he got my -- he totally got my respect for that, dude. >> yeah? >> a lot of guys with females, yeah, you'll [ bleep ] have a bleeding heart, man. >> we asked the jury to imagine what it must've been like for holly williams in the moments before she died.
10:41 pm
>> and prosecutors are not done. they're going to play another piece of video for the jury -- erik maund's reaction to hearing those chilling shots and screams. >> what you're gonna hear is, this is outside holly's apartment. >> okay. >> this is how it went down. >> but when it's the defense's turn, they have some video of their own to show the jury, and they use it to call into question whether holly's real killer has been identified. >> holly? i know what it's like to perform through pain. if you're like me, one of the millions suffering from pain caused by migraine, nurtec odt may help. it's the only medication that can treat a migraine when it strikes and prevent migraine attacks. treat and prevent, all in one. don't take if allergic to nurtec. allergic reactions can occur, even days after using. most common side effects were nausea, indigestion, and stomach pain. relief is possible. talk to a doctor about nurtec odt.
10:42 pm
[♪] looking for a moisturizer that does more than just moisturize? try olay regenerist for 10 benefits in every jar. olay visibly firms, lifts, and smooths wrinkles, by penetrating the skin, to boost regeneration at the surface cellular level. try olay.
10:43 pm
you can make money the hard way as a bullfighter or a human cannonball... or save money the easy way, with xfinity mobile. existing customers can get a free line of our most popular unlimited plan for a year! not only will you save hundreds, but you'll also be joining millions who have connected to america's most reliable 5g network. sure is a lot safer than becoming a stuntman for money. get a free line of unlimited intro for a year when you buy one unlimited line. plus, get the new samsung galaxy s24 on us. two leading candidates for senate. two very different visions for california. steve garvey, the leading republican,
10:44 pm
is too conservative for california. he voted for trump twice and supported republicans for years, including far right conservatives. adam schiff, the leading democrat, defended democracy against trump and the insurrectionists. he helped build affordable housing, lower drug costs, and bring good jobs back home. the choice is clear. i'm adam schiff, and i approve this message.
10:45 pm
♪ the jury has just heard exactly how holly and bill were shot outside of her apartment. now the prosecution shows the jury just how erik maund reacted
10:46 pm
to that video during his interrogation with fbi special agent david som. >> i want you to understand what we're talking about here. and what you're going to hear is, this is outside holly's apartment. >> okay. >> this is how it went down. this was about the time she's getting shot and he's getting shot. this is someone i think you cared about. i wanted to get him to understand the gravity of the situation. i wanted to see if he had a reaction. >> do you think he gave you any sense of regret of what he had done? >> i would hope at some level he might. but the question is, why does he regret it? do you regret it because you just murdered someone? or do you regret it because you were caught? >> when it's time for the defense's case, they go right after the prosecution star
10:47 pm
witness, saying gil peled can't be trusted and he's lying about the murder plot to save his own skin. >> the defense hammered peled on cross-examination, pointing out that he lied about being a former israeli intelligence agent and that he initially lied to the fbi by downplaying his involvement in the murder for hire plot. the defense also accused him of getting a sweetheart sentencing deal in exchange for his testimony. >> his sentence will ultimately be determined by the judge. so mr. peled doesn't know what sentence he's going to receive from the judge, and neither do i. >> all arrows point to gil, right? gil was brought in by the fbi. he was pressured. he was threatened. and he was essentially given no other option than to cooperate. >> the defense calls bryon brockway's brother chad to the stand.
10:48 pm
remember, peled had asked him to do an initial background check on holly and bill. >> chad testifies that peled lied to him from the get-go. remember, he says peled told him the case actually involved a client whose daughter was a victim of sex trafficking and was trapped in the escort business. when did you realize this was not anything about sex trafficking? >> when we read the indictment. gil peled cried on the stand and left all of them out to dry to save himself. >> during the trial, the defense brought forward a couple of ideas to try to plant seeds of doubt in the jurors. they tried to say that what happened in nashville happened outside of the knowledge of erik maund. >> the defense tried to cast doubt on that undercover phone call between maund and peled, saying there was no clear admission of guilt.
10:49 pm
>> we got a problem with one of the shooters in nashville. >> uh-huh? >> so we need to take care of him? >> he did a solid for me, and i appreciate him for that. but i just want to make sure he's not gonna pop back up. >> but brooke's got her own response to that. she says maund's words speak for themselves. >> he talked about how it wasn't really about the money for him, and he wanted to take care of the problem permanently. >> when the jury listened to that call, we argued that, you knew who was the boss and who was the help. >> the defense wants the jury to consider that there could be another explanation for the murders. >> jurors are shown that video of holly setting up security cameras in her apartment. remember, she installed those cameras to protect herself from her on and off again boyfriend,
10:50 pm
bill lanway. >> is there any way i can get a deadbolt -- traditional deadbolt lock in? because the door lock wasn't changed, he was able to come in and assault me. >> jurors are shown video of bill caught on camera entering holly's apartment and looking for her in her bedroom. >> holly? >> but investigators had eliminated bill as a possible suspect based on the evidence which they say confirmed that he was a victim of the murder for hire plot. >> it looked like a mob job, and there was no gun to be seen in the car. >> the defense raises another possibility. perhaps one of holly's clients might have been responsible for the killings, implying that that's what got her killed, not erik maund, essentially blaming the victim. and that did not sit well at all with prosecutor robert mcguire, who angrily protested in court. >> i'm passionate in trial.
10:51 pm
the defense has a job to do, and i respect it. but i didn't want the jury to receive an imperfect picture of who holly williams was. >> so the defense closing arguments were interesting because you had three different defendants and different attorneys stating their case to the jury. but there are some consistent themes here. you cannot trust star witness gil peled. he was the one who capitalized the most on this by receiving, in the end, a total of $905,000. he was the main guy. >> through the course of the trial, i actually started feeling a lot better about what the verdict was going to be. >> people closely following this case wondered if erik maund's defense team was going to be able to pull off an acquittal.
10:52 pm
>> after a 14-day trial, the prosecution calling 20 witnesses and using 200 exhibits to make its case, it finally goes to the jury. and the feeling in the courtroom was that, well, it could go either way. >> i think you're always worried when the case goes to the jury you're always nervous. always. ♪ wipe ♪ [sniffs]
10:53 pm
♪ wipe it ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪ wipe ♪ okay, so here's my most requested hack for stubborn odors. you'll need vinegar, a large salad bowl and... oh, hi! have you tried new tide fabric rinse? it works after your detergent to fight deep odors 3 times better than detergent alone. i love that. try new tide fabric rinse. ( ♪ ♪ ) start your day with nature made. the #1 pharmacist recommended vitamin and supplement brand.
10:54 pm
only unitedhealthcare medicare advantage plans come with the ucard — one simple member card that opens doors for what matters. what if we need to see a doctor away from home? we got you — with medicare advantage's largest national provider network. only from unitedhealthcare. pain hits fast. so get relief fast. only tylenol rapid release gels have laser drilled holes. they release medicine fast for fast pain relief. and now, get max strength topical pain relief precisely where you need it. with new tylenol precise.
10:55 pm
♪ three years and eight months after holly williams and bill lanway were found brutally gunned down in nashville, there's finally a verdict in their murder case. >> i've had over 100 jury trials, and my heart is always beating out of my chest when the jury is about to announce their verdict.
10:56 pm
>> after about seven hours of deliberation, the jury found maund guilty of conspiracy to commit murder for hire, but not guilty of kidnapping resulting in death. >> district judge william campbell dismissed the conspiracy to commit kidnapping charge against maund at trial, finding there was insufficient evidence to support it. >> then they went on to bryon brockway and adam carey, and they were both guilty of all three counts that they were charged with. >> when that verdict came back as it did, it was definitely a little bit of a shock to all of us. there's no way possible that my brother is guilty of the charges that they have brought against him. >> in this investigation, the motivation was -- was greed. plain and simple. another motivation we had that knowing that someone with so much money and so much power,
10:57 pm
they could just write a check and expect something just to go away. >> maund's defense team sent "20/20" this statement, saying, "erik maund is not guilty of the charges in the indictment. mr. maund and counsel intend to pursue appeals on the remaining charge for which the jury returned a guilty verdict." attorneys for adam carey and bryon brockway declined comment. >> the families, both families, they -- they didn't deserve this tragedy and this trauma for both of their loved ones, being killed the way they were killed. >> bill definitely had his demons. traumatic situations. but he was a guy that tried to push through everything. >> bill lanway, through his entire life he, you know, was just met with tragedy after tragedy. he's not innocent in all of
10:58 pm
this, but yet he didn't deserve what happened to him. >> if you think about bill's whole life full circle, one of the first memories of his life is probably trying to protect his mother from his father. and the last living moments of his life were trying to protect his girlfriend from a murderer. >> holly was a victim of circumstance. the evidence that we presented at the trial was that holly did not know anything about this extortion plan. >> what are you doing? what are you doing? >> many people see holly williams as a woman who was repeatedly victimized and victimized at the end of her life. >> i wanted to protect her, because i felt like i saw some pain in her. and just seeing how sweet she was and just quiet, i just knew the world can be harsh towards
10:59 pm
people like her. ♪ happy birthday to you ♪ >> david: you know, there are so many layers to this mystery. when gil peled is sentenced this june, the judge will take into consideration his cooperation at trial. >> deborah: while there's no sentencing yet, all three are facing mandatory life sentences. that's our program for tonight. i'm deborah roberts. >> david: i'm david muir. from all of us here at "20/20" and abc news, good night.
11:00 pm
date and i'm dan ashley, thanks for joining us. that breaking news is at uc berkeley. there was a shooting tonight near the student union and sproul plaza police blocked off the area of bancroft way and college avenue. >> abc seven news reporter tara campbell is at the scene. she's been speaking with students tara. yeah dan and ama. >> as you can see behind me at the student union here, most of the scene has cleared. plenty of students walking around now. cars are starting to pass by, but you can still see there is some police presence behind me. the first call for this incident coming in at around 840 tonight at first, when they got on bancroft on campus.

314 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on