>> welcome to the san francisco city and county board of supervisors regular meeting this afternoon at 2:00 pm., tuesday, may 21, 2024. madam clerk please call the roll. >> thank you, mr. president. by supervisor chan present. >> supervisor dorsey present. >> supervisor engardio present. >> supervisor mandelman present. >> supervisor melgar address the commission on matters that are within the commission's jurisdiction present. >> supervisor preston present and supervisor ronen present. >> supervisor safai present. >> supervisor stefani present.

>> and supervisor walton present. >> mr. president all members are present. >> thank you, madam clerk >> thank you, madam clerk unceded ancestral homeland of the ramaytush (rah-my-toosh) ohlone (o-lon-ee) who are the original inhabitants of the san francisco peninsula. responsibilities as the caretakers of this place, as well as for all peoples who reside in their traditional territory. ramaytush ohlone community and by affirming their sovereign rights as first peoples. colleagues please join me in the pledge of allegiance. i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america

and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> madam clerk could you please start with item 2 our regular agenda. >> yes. the item in overtime in fiscal year (fy) 2023-2024, as required per administrative code, section 3.17. >> i'm sorry madam clerk why not start with our communication i apologize. >> the board of supervisors welcomes interested persons to attend in the chambers city hall second floor 250 watch open sfgovtv channel 26 or view the live stream. if you would like to submit comments you can send an e-mail to excuse me - to bos

or can write a letter and send it to the san francisco board of supervisors at the number one, dr. carton place room 244 san francisco, california. >> to make a reasonable accommodation under the ada or to request language assistance please contact the colors by calling. thank you, mr. president. >> thank you, madam clerk >> colleagues is there a motion to approve the minutes madam clerk a roll call. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye.

>> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> president peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> mrpdz, aye. >> and supervisor safai, aye. >> there are 11 asia. >> as presented after public comment madam clerk read the 2:00 p.m. approximately order. >> special order 2:00 p.m. - mayor's appearance before the board. to engage. >> welcome mayor london breed my opening remarks you'd like to share with us. >> good morning to members of the board and members of the public. yesterday, we celebrated an incredible new investment in san francisco. $3.4 billion to

help bring caltrans onto the heart of the downtown and eventually high speed rail through the city. i want to thank supervisor speaker nancy pelosi and the champion and our president joe biden for investment in our extra to san francisco. this is not just to fund a transit center but jobs and economic activity downtown really exciting we are two-thirds of the way clour closer to the founding make this project with 11 transportation options throughout the bayview possible that is a commitment to downtown sfta san francisco and a commitment shows this city is building a brighter future one of the things from i didn't do

one message of forget all the people and people 0 who are trying to put our city down. i'm proud of this city and proud of workers and proud you have values and proud of what i know we can accomplish when we work together. i know you heard this a lot from me but i'm going to keep urging to keep on hearing this this city's best days are definitely ahead of us and, yes we confront our challenges and deliver results and delivering results we are attracting transformative investments making the city for welcoming for all and people are noticing i was at the r s a conference two weeks ago had an opportunity to talk to the united states secretary of state and secretary of the interior but many of the

people had come to the conferences for many, many years and nothing but great things to say about san francisco and how excited to be here we are represent types of from 10 black colleges and universities interested in being part of we anticipate a cohort of students will be living at the university of to san francisco and going to class downtown to make the opportunities students working and living downtown feasible. this is the future we're building one of accommodation we celebrate who we are so let's keep hard working of making san francisco the best it can be. >> thank you. >> mayor london breed. >> madam clerk please call the first topic. >> the first topic.

>> xhrnlz ask our opening question. >> thank you mayor london breed for joining us today as you recall i believe and many of us have talked about the need more a full continuum of care for those in recovery with the sober housing for formally incarcerated one of living communities in a supportive environment to receive the assembly programs during last year's budget process i prioritized my ask working with the compare and your team to secure $3.6 million to build now sober housing in san francisco. my office made multiple attempts reached out following your lead

like to collaborate. so we tried to do that own that important initiative we've leading e led in the unsquare therapeutic working with the adult probation we were not greeted are collaboration. and instead of greeted with that the mayors money and we'll let you knows. >> and what happened during chinatown chinese new year we found out an announcement to create sober housing and unfortunately, that was met with significant community push back. myself and stakeholders wanted to be part of the solution and not landlord what is going on with the money and the new site we're heard maybe a new location but again as being one of my top priorities like to collaborate with our office and team we

understand that is a difficult each year given the one billion dollars i deficit (bell ringing) still a top priority for the need for sober housing to my question whether i collaborate with my office and your team finding a location for opening up sober in our city and mayor london breed you may respond to the question. >> i can't control what you on you heard directly in terms of saving this is not the mayor's money the taxpayers money i know all too well as a person responsible for the city so i doubt it seriously that was communities to you, however, we have over the years clothed on a number of programs and other

things that helped to provide support to this community fantastic. i of the in the south of market neighborhood as a place calls her house for women that are in recovery who have children, who wrap around post services and extending the number of beds from 18 to 39 and a sober living environment to assist women in recovery and support for children that is caregiver. i am definitely committed to doing this work and sorry not familiar with your involvement in those resources. um, but i will touch bases with my staff as we start to work on the possibility of identifying another location to get it on as soon as possible i have invested over $20 million no space

recovery programs. and that includes 7 locations which in many cases includes housing i'm committed to the work and i'm open to working with anyone who is interested in working with (bell ringing) but as you can see not necessarily the supervisors doing the heavy lifting but the staff of the departments and my preference we're going to collaborate we're treated with respect and come to a conclusion to identify locations and the appropriate organizations manage those facilities. >> thank you supervisor safai you may ask a follow-up question. >> that sounds like a yes. yes. you're willing to work in collaboration i would love to know where the $3.6 million and the new location and how to collaborate seeing how we led on

the t rp union square and working with the model you know i'd like the opportunity to collaborate with your office sounds like you're willing to do that but have your staff reach out we'd like to do that. >> that's not a question. >> is that a collaboration. >> i'm a little bit confused i'm trying to understand what this has to do with our district nevertheless,. >> (multiple voices). >> the people that do heavy lifting on the specific departments under my direction i'm concerned about what your role or involvement will be since the supervisors don't necessary do the heavy lifting to implement the programs and i'm just - i guess i have a question supervisor.

>> mayor london breed has a question. >> (multiple voices.) >> help me to understand when role you're willing to play in the operation and how do this has to do with with our responsibility as a district leveling supervisor i'm i'm trying to understand. >> respectfully member of the board we're citywide and responsible for the charge of the entire city as i did with the t rp in union square directly involved with the probation and working with the nonprofits and working with the property owner to collaborate to make that happen this supervisor is ready to had had heavy lifting if you're willingly we're willing to collaborate. >> now you are asks each other a question madam clerk question time a over thank you, mayor london breed for your lovely

attendance attendance please. >> call the next item. >> yes. >> call the next item. >> yes. >> call the next item. >> yes. departments' projected increases in overtime in fiscal year (fy) 2023-2024, as required per administrative code, section 3.17. you colleagues seeing none, names on the racist. >> same house, same call. (gavel) ordinance is passed on the ordinance is passed on the first reading. >> >> 3. [revocable permit to enter and use property agreement - mission neighborhood centers, inc. - children's waiting room - hall of justice, 850bryant street - $1 annual base rent]resolution approving and authorizing the director of property to enter into a revocable permit to enter and use property agreement (“permit”) for 355 square feet of city owned space at the hall of justice (hoj) located at 850 bryant street with mission neighborhood

years effective upon approval of this resolution, at an annual permit fee of $1; finding that the permit furthers a proper public purpose sufficient to - >> same house, same call. the resolution is adopted (gavel) >> call the next item. >> office of economic and workforce development to accept and expend a grant increase in the amount of $1,404,844 for a total amount of opportunity act (wioa) program, during the grant period of april 1, 2022, through june 30,2024. (department of economic and workforce development). >> same house, same call. the resolution resolution is adopted. >> call the next item. >> . >> 5. [agreement amendment - carahsoft technology corporation - not to exceed$20,625,109]resolution approving a second amendment to the agreement between the department of technology, office of contract administration, and carahsoft technology corporation for salesforce enterprise products, increasing the agreement amount by $10,900,109 for a term for an additional five years from june 30, 2025, for a total term of july 1, 2016, through june 30,

2030.(department of technology). >> same house, same call. the resolution is adopted (gavel) >> call the next item. >> >> >> 6. [loan agreement - 1005 powell street 1005 powell street quality act; finding that the loan is consistent with the general plan, and the eight priority policies of planning code, section 101.1; and - and colleagues before we vote on this i want to really thank and acknowledge the mayor's office of housing and community development that has been pursuing this extremely low income project for a number of years and undertaken by c cbc as great financial risk and not to get ahead of ourselves we'll discuss there the subject of an article in today's chronicle

that is precisely a perfect example why we have extremely low income um, funds in order to make projects like this pencil in we're going to come close to meeting our state mandated goals and morale goals of affordable housing to the existing population have to pursue affirming policies like this with that, seeing no names on the roster. >> same house, same call.. (gavel). >> the resolution is adopted next item. >> designating a portion of the sidewalk on 24th street between sanchez and vicksburg streets, adjoining the noe valley farmers market, as the site of a future market, as the site of a future application materials and the approval of the plaque design by the design review committee of the arts commission; waiving permit and permit and

as defined herein; and affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act. >> same house, same call. the ordinance is passed on the location and terms of an easement reserved in a 1957 subdivision instrument, for vehicular and pedestrian access and section 101.1; affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act; and to - >> same house, same call. the resolution is adopted (gavel) madam clerk read items through 9 madam clerk read items through 9 there there there

there 11. >> 9. [liquor license issuance - 429 castro street theatre, located at 429 castro street (district 8), will serve the public convenience or necessity of the city and county of of - of - >> 10. [liquor license issuance - 2948-16th street - the lab]resolution determining that the issuance of a type-64 on-sale general theater liquor license to the lab sf, doing business as the lab, located at 2948-16th street (district 9),will serve the public convenience or necessity of the city and county of san francisco, in accordance with california business and professions code, section issuance of the license. (public safety and neighborhood services committee). >> same house, same call. these recesses are recesses are adopted. >> call the next item. >> approving surveillance technology policy for human services agency use of call recording technology. (human services agency) >> same house, same call. the ordinance is passed on

administrative and business and tax regulations codes to change the frequency of the housing needs overview for seniors and people with people with (das) consistent with the charter and make other non-material corrections. (department of disability and aging services). >> same house, same call. the ordinance is passed on ordinance is passed on first reading next reading next reading next reading next reading next reading next item. >> 14. [ethics commission regulation amendments - campaign

finance regulations]motion vetoing proposed regulation or office fundraisers), adopted by the ethics commission on april 12, 2024. (rules committee). >> supervisor ronen colleagues thank you. i'm the one that called for this motion to veto those resolutions and a hearing at rules. last week or this week? last week. >> the times lead into another - when this if you look at the plain language of those rules that was confusing because crossed reference another log that looks like for the first time that forever in san francisco that we were going to consider people holding a house party in their living room a contribution the pro-rated rates of a living room anyone is owned or rented by a business and providing for the first time would be subject to a campaign

contribution that was really worrisome to me. um, as you can see there is millions of dollars being thrown into local raise races and oftentimes this money comes from bill narrows hide behind expenditures and acquit all of the the, you know, unfortunate rules created by the citizens united to buy candidates in observation. one way that candidates still represent the interests of our billionaires is knocking on doors and talking to as many people in the community i was worried about those new

regulations. during the hearing, the ethics director and policy advisors couldn't answer many of our questions i was worrisome considering this is a potentially big deal. and because they couldn't koefgz answer the question for example, whether or not a room mat or pious of a lobbyist or city incarcerating or someone seeking a permit whether or not that person could hold and house party that was really war memorial to us that means for example, someone on a board of of a nonprofit organization was married to a school teacher that school teacher couldn't hold and fundraiser that was programmatic on may 17th the ethics commission sent us a written

memo that relieved most of my concerns. and in the memo the ethics commission has made clear spouses and coworkers and room mats of candidates can in fact, host or the incarcerating can't participant in that effort that is what a - one of my main concerns. the others points that the ethics commission has clarified in writing is that the cost of, you know, hosting an event in our living room and the refreshments under $500 exquisite and contribution for the candidate and an issue i was

worried about so i'm satisfied by the memo that the ethics commission sent to us i must say i have not loved this process it would be nice the ethics commission figured out the rules how this works ahead of time and given us that information and passed on that didn't a cross reference another part of code that drawing out and explaining i asked do ethic and policy director do do things differently next time but satisfied with the response and i like to make a motion to table this item i'll be happy to answer any questions you may have. >> if anyone is still confused. >> thank you supervisor ronen tabled by supervisor ronen seconded by supervisor walton colleagues you without objection the item taebld (gavel) madam clerk will i go to

committee reports item number 18 was recommended as committee report. report. report. report. of consistency with the general plan and the eight priority policies of planning code, section 101.1. >> seeing no names on the roster we'll take that item. >> same house, same call. the ordinance is passed on first reading that will take us to the. >> special order 2:30 p.m. - recognition of commendations.

and it is 2029 so if we wait now 2:30. >> first up is district 2 attorney fee i didn't say jennifer here. >> great. >> it gives me great joy an exceptional impact has been profound touching the lives of our entire community for the past 23 years jennifer as a committed attorney reaching the district attorney's office but the wider bayview and jennifer along with the city attorney's office has played a role in

begin ordinance removing firearms from those a danger to themselves and others between the code enforcement and the san francisco police department has been crucial in into pointing thanks to jennifer and code enforcement san francisco has filed 13 are this year and recently elevated to the chief trial deputy he jennifers expertise continued to have positive outcomes and justice one our city the impossible work the code compliant may not national attention but makes a difference in our community and jennifer recalls here climate action plan with the san francisco police department in a six months undercover operation resulting in a law enforcement against the owners of a lions share afternoon after that got

calls for gratitude for the improvement in the neighborhood if several families and residence in the tenderloin. jennifers tenure on the team is marked by many similar stories depicting her commitment to championship the rights of those who are marijuana listed from shooefld tenants from landowner to come baltimore poor living conditions in sros. jennifer embarked on the legal journey from san francisco in 1996 and before joining the city attorney's office jennifer was a criminal prosecutor at san francisco and san mateo district attorney's office experiences i can laid and solids foundation for her career and jennifer story is a remarkable achievement and as a first generation immigrant from korea

was the first to arena law degree the public education is important her legal career is a sense of duty and a great commitment to serve the public as we celebrate this month highlighting the contributions of park and planning americans in our community. >> jennifer thank you for your tireless dedication to the district attorney's office but to san francisco as a whole we're privileged to recognize you for your it's been a long time coming. contributions for painting and justice in san francisco. >> congratulations jennifer. >> i've seen that door on the roster. >> (clapping) and having deputy city attorney dorsey i've work in the city attorney's office for years and

add to my appreciation i've that that the san francisco city attorney's office is a terrible place to work if you need to be the smart i would person in the room there are a lot of great talented attorneys and you're one of my favorite to congratulations. thank you very much. >> it has been an honor and privilege to work at the city attorney's office i've been given to many - by this country so a honor and privilege to give back and continue to serve. thank you very much. >> thank you. (clapping.)

>> our next odor of commendation from supervisor preston. >> thank you president peskin colleagues today it is my honor to recognize founder and director got some fans in the house founder of the creative writing department at the school of the arts and we're honoring her on the occasion of her retirement from teaching in the san francisco unified school district and in time before the school year end i'm glad we're here to do this fell in love

with literature when she was 15-year-old and attend uc berkley with an undergraduate degree and wlarnt received here mta creative writing 23 san francisco state university in 2007 haesht got national connection and joined in 1997 and taught there ever since in 2001 she founded the creative writing department. and serving as a invariable resources for students in their academic purts. her commitment to the long-standing involvement with what honored no not and additionally my heart goes out

to you received and gotten apple philip from the ed fund to devote she crafted a film for 10 and 11 grade english students she's and leaveer of the arts imparting that will have to her students a force of nature of the creative writing department 100 percent knitted to. >> commissioner rubin: and encouraging and challenging and empowering young writers to share themselves and their unique voice and talent led the department for over two decades and students learn the community of feeling safe and connected and being connected to others writers when engaging in the

work and creation. haesht sees every student as - agency as leader encouraging the peer review more akin to would be that might find in a college and through artists and residents students expand their horizons and my heart goes out to you cultivates this in the community connecting her students with poetsdz and the rich tap destroy or artists and events in san francisco and beyond my heart goes out to you knows the value of creative writing and understand this calling and in every way possible dedicated her entire professional career sharing that path with as they develop their passion thank you,

heather woodwork for our decades of service to youth in the san francisco and wish you the best in retirement as you relax to travel and visit you're one year old grandson and thanks to you for you're a decades to san francisco my honor to present with with a certificate of honor i believe one of my colleagues has something to say before you take the microphone. >> (yelling) (clapping.) that is supervisor engardio thank you for this honor to bring this to haesht i have the honor to attend the year-end performance and the performance you put on was an amazing there

or technical difficulties and offering could go wrong and is performance was underwayless i came out and i wouldn't have known the difference shout out to the congratulating senior a child my- >> (multiple voices). >> so soto to has a wonderful program and great honors to you. thank you. >> (clapping.) (yelling). >> thank you, so much president peskin and. thank you very much. i feel honored because i feel that the demographic it demographic makes our city proud. the variety of individual in my department are incredible human beings and they are going to right the world whether or

not literally or through their actions a they're wonderful people i've been privileged to send since we say students spend time with their teachers and the teachers with students i got the best family i believe possible have it in crew and thank you very much. and thank you, guys you're just i'm glad i'm going out with you, you and hi husband who put up with and absent on many, many occasions now he's coming. thank you very much. >> thank you for your service (yelling). >> (clapping) and -

(clapping.) our next order of commendation if supervisor mandelman. >> thank you, mr. president. come this is a bittersweet commendation i'm prefrptd to nicole departing as director of the mayor's office of disability i'll wait for clearing out to

complete. >> ready all right. >> nicolle is in my view wonderful. she is passionate about access but problematic and lazer focused on the levels of ev collaboratively and with empathy looks for the win-win and tries hard to make sure in the difficult conversations all voices get heard. nicole more than thirty years workers on disabilities and accessibility in san francisco and holds a master in counseling and ms a if the university of san francisco and begin as crisis counselor for individuals with disabilities and he previously worked she managed the commendation and served as

director of disability programs and resource at san francisco state university lead the efforts and built programs for accessibility nicolle was selected to least the mayor's office of disability for the city and county of san francisco and overseen the compliance for over 96 thousand visitor and people with disabilities she has advised city departments and the mayor and the board of supervisors and on policies and initiatives that effect the residents and visitor with disability she leading the push to create the disability culture center the first center in the united states. and she played a critical role to make sure the remote public comments for the john fitzgerald kennedy and the limitation for section 504 of the rehabilitation act and

advocated for the autonomous vehicles and during the pandemic leading the key responses effort to get vaccines for people with disabilities and taking on a new role the executive director rights and education and a national civil rights group for advancement of people with disabilities and the advocacy training and education and legislation. we're going to miss you very much nicole but i'm excited for you and very, very excited for gretta on behalf of the board of supervisors, i want to commend you for the city and county of san francisco. and before you get to speak i believe that our city administrator carmen chu. >> ma'am, city administratorly me confer about the commitment

and just generally being very good to work with. with that, stiffer chicago the floor is yours. >> thank you, supervisors and thank you for having me, i'm pleased to recognize an exceptional colleague nicole so many of the accolades and contributions to the city have been said by supervisor mandelman so i'll say i think i talk to you about some of the challenges we have running the city and trying to figure out how to keep things moving and the city administrator one of the tough thing to recruit good people but losing great people i assure that's the situation i'm excited for nicole for the continuing her advocacy at the federal level we'll miss her darryl not only a fierce

advocate but someone work together to make sure they enters access and i want to say as is city administrator working with nicolle over three years incredibly blessed to see here ability i know your inspire team will miss you and at deputy jennifer will miss you and your colleagues watching thank you, nicole many more words to come and celebrations thank you, on behalf of san francisco. >> thank you very much. (clapping.) (yelling). >> (laughter). >> i'm going to try to say something and not cry. thank you

very much. >> for - for this recognition of me, for the recognition of importance in the ongoing importance of disability assess. so when i started this 7 years ago part of the reason why i took the position was because as a resident who really loves this city i saw things we needed to do better and hopefully in the last seven years we've been able to make progress towards making things berths for people with disabilities and i want to thank you and i want to thank to our unsung heroes how do this owners this resolution, this law

i want to impact impact people with disabilities and if you for those of you who don't know take the time to find out and thank you, first year taking the time to do that and for taking disabilities seriously and so - san francisco is known as a place a destination for people with disabilities. in particular because of the legacy that the bay area holes we have a reputation of do the right thing the anti choice by san franciscans and hope that i've been able to help educate a all continue to do that. you have much more work to do as you know gaps that still exist in assessable affordable housing. and employment in effect communication especially for

individuals and this is just the tip of use berg and pleased and privileged to have the opportunities to work on it for a little while. >> thank you for this honor and continuing to prioritize assess for 0 people with thank you. >> thank you. >> nicolle. >> (clapping)

(yelling). >> (clapping) colleagues last last but not least give that today is the last board meeting no may i'd like to close all apa in recognition of the san francisco asian police officer organization promoting career development of advancing the safety by building trusts there service with our neighborhood and our neighborhood organizations and residents and businesses in neighborhoods throughout the city. the s f an asian police officers organization established back in 1980 for apa law enforcement officers throughout the country at a time law enforcement

agencies hire organism with an apa heritage there the critical language skills and culture diversity in san francisco. 18 percent of our sworn members identifies asian to serve were approximately twice that many residents identity as a api to make sure the police force matches the community they serve the sf ppo a encouraged kids to join the force and protect the communities they grew up in and the sf poa line distancing to promote the hiring and promotional law enforcement. and i can say as the supervisor had the honor of representing the historic chinese in the country chinatown i have been a proud

proponent for the logistically committee officers no chinatown and the surrounded communities and under the guidance of rose pack who encouraged oefrltz to take the test and promote into upper ranks and the command staff and working closely with the housing project residents after experiencing decades of neglect by the housing authority back in the days chinatown advocated for a dedicated team for chinese speaking to patrol where the golden gate bridge live and. >> (calling names.) >> who are here and others poa i understand general park is here doing the work. and the results of that has been greatly

greatly they know the name of shopkeepers and residents so i want to take the opportunities to honor the a poa we have they're not chiu present before i the floor is yours. >> accessibility i would like to take the opportunity to play a 30-second recruitment clip why he became a officer no the first time madam clerk. >> these are memories i remember my moms reaction she was not thrilled when i became a police officer italian u asian hate crimes were up and many i was born in the city i was

raised in the city. and now i'm protecting the city. come join us. >> president chiu the floor is yours. >> (clapping.) thank you, supervisor mandelman and the rest of the board of supervisors. i thought i forget about the commercial i can't believe you pulled that back up when it first played i got crowned i think everyone forget about that but (laughter) i think right now our academy is more fully but chalk it up to that commercial and but thank you for recognizing the work this a poa has done i know we get recognition from the elected officials and makes our work seem more beneficial like we're going the right direction i want to close out we're going to keep advocating for the poa members and look forward to having the

support from everyone here and rain and shine we'll call answer the call for service thank you for the recognition. >> thank you president chiu and at the for the and for the

officers. thank you. >> madam clerk with three minutes left go to roll call for introduction. >> new business is supervisor safai thank you, madam clerk. >> colleagues today i'm introducing a common sense amendment to the charter will significantly benefit our brave members of san francisco fire department. this measure reduces the retirement age if 58 to 55 for the firefighters and paramedics hired after 2012 of their senior counterparts in 2011 passed proposition c a massive reform that addresses side financial status at the time and for employees of the san francisco fire department prop c raised the retirement ages that 70 sfpd hired during and after 2012 can get the

highest. >> prop c raise the rates to the epidemic for employer and employees preventing contribution holidays and tying the rates to the liability and it has - raising from covering 72 to over 92 percent of liabilities importantly the fund is nearing one 100 percent of liabilities. it is clear to me that the xofdz pension house a result of contribution rate not the increased age of retirement not truly felt until three 7 beyond the financial enacts the increased firefighters age projects they're and three years between 55 and 58 as this board

recently recognized an ordinances mann chemicals and fire department employees are not solely sublthd to immediate health risk with with responses to trauma but face long-term health complications the city is seeing the consequences that our brave members of fire department face since 2006 fire department has lowest over three thousand firefighters to cancer and female firefighters 6 hers over bus transit district in the united states many firefighters and emergency medical services staff endue the results of trauma and the fire department is a unique workplace. san

francisco fire department has limited positions that are not directly in the field only approximately, one hundred and 80 out of 18 hundred positions in the fire department are not on front line those jobs are didn't have on promotes not seniority time as a result the risk of severe injury for the firefighters over 56 and demonstrated by data for the depth of high-rise that shows a positive correlation between age and number of mayors' office of economic & workforce development means for more and more increased cancer and offhand trauma for members hartley road after 2012. as san francisco firefighters local 798 present want fire and the dangerous with that profession know no

distinction neither should we. this measure is both morally rights this is initiative is projected to save the city millions of dollars in cancer costs and by not changing the rates we make sure the health of fire departments retirement pension is not compromised with that change. by passing this amendment we and the voters about empower the brave firefighters to enter retirement without facing health risks. please join me in supporting the heroes i know will save countless lives the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor stefani mr. president. >> it is 3:00 p.m. madam clerk why not go the. >> special order 3:00 p.m.

>> special order 3:00 p.m. item law enforcement practices - may 21, 2024, at3:00 p.m.]hearing of the board of supervisors sitting as a committee of the whole on may 21, 2024, may 21, 2024, may 21, 2024, police department; scheduled pursuant to motion no. m20-125, approved on september 15, 2020. (clerk of the board). >> supervisor walton. >> move to continue to the july 16th board of supervisors. >> motion to continue to july 16th made by supervisor walton and seconded by supervisor safai any public comment on item 15 and the motion to continue to july 15th? >> make sure you make that better. basically. >> thank you and serging not other members of the public

public comment is closed and we'll take the motion to july 16th without objection the item is continued until july 16th madam clerk read items 16 16 and 16 and and fees pursuant to the provisions of building code, sections 102a.3, sections 102a.3, sections 102a.3, 102a.4, 102a.6, 102a.12, 102a.16, 102a.17, 102a.18, 102a.19, 102a.20 et seq., delinquent charges for code enforcement violations and associated fees pursuant to building code, sections 102a.3 - >> okay. >> colleagues, we are now board of supervisors sitting as a committee of the whole for code enforcement the hearing is now open first hear from the

building inspection. >> thank you president peskin mate a 28 year the building inspections for code enforcement trans piloted and prior to today is hearing held two hearing on the list to sdwus they're fees. the department precious our report of diligent charges for cost recovery of time spent.

thank you. >> thank you. sir, open up for public comment on item 16 and 17 in your here today for those items but don't want to provide public testimony either what have an opportunity to speak with the staff outside of those chambers to attempt to resolve our issues any members of the public would anyone like to comment on those items? >> unusual have someone. >> go ahead. >> sorry i'm very inexperienced. >> to problem what item we have a list here. >> (turning page). >> that is before 627 p r e n ti f. >> i've got to item 260.

>> i'm not sure how much times but the projects are 2018-2019 and started with a contractors shortly after unfortunately, we found that john was incompetent so our project took underpin our neighbors properties. and in doing so the neighbor asked to work with one engineer underpinning. >> i want to let you know on the updated lift under the department of building inspection that property is dropped; is that correct? >> what does that mean. >> not taken off the list you so i have to pay the fine? >> if not paid needs to be paid to the department not on the list. >> it is my protest the amount of fine. >> understood and let you and

the departments are those conversations but for the on the list before his so you can still have if conversation and okay. how do i do that. >> we'll come out. >> appreciate your time. >> next speaker. >> (bell ringing) >> good evening board of directors. >> i am here for order number 2, 016. 926 61. and 20177341. and . >> do you have an and we have. >> i do 451 - 45 three, 23 avenue. >> one moment. >> got it. >> i'm not here to protest the fees i just simply want an extension without paying any more penalties. >> i'm going to ask you to sit

down with mr. l and come back and figure out anyone else for items 16 and 17 what you have a comment about two. >> two addresses. actually. and 56514 could actually made a mistake of sending the check to the wrong apartment and tell apply those two, aye. >> >> again. >> it is 5 - three 0473 three 01 the lot number. >> i need the address as oh.

>> 5 hundred i'm sorry. >> v da d and the other one 114 - >> i see within this burglary 14 talk to mr. l. >> any other - yes, sir. >> hello, i'm that on prospect, 254 prospect. >> got it. >> and that has been dropped from the list. >> i want to fight those fees well, well. >> perfect. anyone else for public comment on those items

seeing none, public comment is closed (gavel) president green something you want to add. >> i have a question for staff. >> go ahead. >> thank you. i'm looking at page 245 in district areas 7 has been in the blighted list forever over 16 years a small amount we're assessing had point this is get resolved other than accepting and fee for a violation were probably looked at 15 years old but list the property and quite a bit it was originally put on the list. >> that was cerritos that was removed from the list that two. >> it's on the list i have in front me. >> page 80, 81 and 82 those

are in red they're stricken. >> i have to look at the specific cases in the code enforcement process could be the initial bill has been paid and that's the violations are tony or the violations have been corrected and this is the final bill. >> okay. so what we'll do is give you and the speakers >> members of the public may address the commission on matters that are within the commission's jurisdiction >> with apologizes i didn't connect but any information i see 11 hundred address on here he put two and two together this is a church there and is there any additional information on that provide with two large assessments? >> i don't have any information right now i can look

out look up the information and get back to you i don't have this information. >> great. and apologizes i would flag that before the hearing but didn't connect the address. >> thank you. >> okay. when you come back in we'll come back to this item madam clerk why not back to roll call for introductions. >> we left off with supervisor walton. >> thank you, madam clerk >> i - i don't have any thing to introduce by updates on board caltrans electrification is making progress. the project on schedule and them budget and earlier this month the project

reached the completion with all major construction work mreldz will be 8 electrical trains on property and testing from san francisco to santa fe and more trains continue to arrive and each train has 1,000 miles of testing before certified for passenger service and earlier this month caltrans hosted the third tour of the trains and over 5 thousand people clearly everyone is exciting about this cleaner and more efficient way for the trains to move and september 21st for launch the electrical if i did service between san francisco and santa fe. >> caltrans caltrans is facing a if anything cliff the caltrans board it engaged from the measure discussions to continue to find funding for the agency.

ridership is thank you, sir, your time is up. >> up and agency is continuing to be creative of services and examples include 25 percent they're in riderships since last year and $1 youth fairs. as far as the bayview as of may 1st board meeting the board of directors to direct a significant portion of the money collected 80 towards benefits in the community where the violations occurred. and in regards to the senate bill 617 the hunters point steering committee will host the meeting at 5:00 p.m. and focused on the cf c principles of the community reduction plan and continue to it mapping activity. as far as

the juvenile justice council council approved the comprehensive multi agency juvenile mainly for the california government code and looking for juvenile hall facilities and workforce investment san francisco what is is our local workforce annual report was released and available on the websites the citywide plan the committee on the workforce alignment adopted 5 years citywide workforce development plan that outlines strategies and recommendations coordinating the workforce programs by the city and the next was submitted on with the war memorial from 9 to 11:00 a.m. and the rest i

submit. >> thank you commissioner walton we're supposed to report outside our assignments so what i'm going to report back today is i'm grateful to our colleague and i'm a little nervous. and also commissioner on the local agency forms commission last friday um, i sit down down as chair and really pleased to have mvrnldz to step in and elected to be the chair and commissioner at the vice chair i believe that the commission will be in great hands and for reallyable and awesome leadership and the only green banking as well as storage and, of course, clean power sf a

critical time and tackling pg&e escalating cost will be in a critical play a critical role for san franciscans to maintain a level of accountable utilities to. thank you. >> thank you. commissioner walton and supervisor dorsey thank you, madam clerk. >> colleagues, i'm introducing a charter amendment for the november 24th general election will reestablish the police staffing levels in san francisco created deferred retirement to aid the police retention and lateral recruitments and the deployments to patrols and for the next 5 years. i'm very grateful to my two elective co-author for they're leadership that is is president peskin we

face to have is consequence if city hall for 6 supervisors this solution is cost effect and thoughtfully at a later date to speed the public safety and it will set minimum police staffing of 2 thousand full duty officers beginning in 25 and require paralympic adjustments over three years based on the workload with the chief of police and this builds on the charter amendment replaced the staffing member for 25 years with a thoughtful data driven process and establish and now voluntary option program or drop for eligible members of san francisco police department and that will be open to sworn

officers that transpire to u.s. pd and provided they have eligible serve credit what means historically in the retention strategy holds benefit as a police recruitment because officers require less academy. >> special order 2:00 p.m. - mayor's appearance before the board. for a this plan will accelerate and that is intentional the drop will require that the participants be assigned to patrol investigations whether to any of the stations for patrol functions or the investigations bureau to conduct investigations and solve crimes and will enhance the progress on recruitment and retention with reporting requirement for civilians and the 35 - by 20

thirty for those familiar with the last deputy director if 15 dwroorgz this a african reforms lessons and best practices from other jurisdictions and ferry building if a variety of experts this plan b will limit that and requires prarnlt to be active to be working to continue participating. pausing drop payments during a long term leave of absence and limits participation to patrol or investigations work that is to sure the public those enhanced benefits will directly advance the front line and the police departments will holds order but to benefit our city and reducing the needs for police over time

like the appropriations in item 2 and police over time is a situation we spends more money for less policing that goes over burdening our officers and heightened risk to officer safety grateful for supervisor stafani and deliver on the process of the community policing and 21st century reform thanks well to other other co-sponsors that have joined supervisor melgar and others i welcome it to discussing discuss with all my colleagues and as was move forward and the rest i submit. >> thank you, supervisor dorsey and supervisor engardio submit. thank you. >> supervisor mandelman. >> thank you um, madam clerk. i

have some brief updates from outside boards. on the transporting i serve as vice chair we talked a few times about ptosis of portal projects have been in the engineering phase of capital investment and this action the mta had the project and very good news also a significant gap we're going to need help in the state and closing between 2 and $3 billion the staff presented the fiscal year 2024-25 for approval in june and the same meeting we considered a presentation on the

portals that funding plan and schedule reflecting the fta announcements and considering a set of options for an updated target date for securing the city of los angeles and continue talking about this observe the sewage as we think through the timing that is just now going to take longer than as we try get the rest of the money. open a bag a potential regional go bonds more affordable housing. and there was unanimous approval of a plan at the april meeting at same meet of executive board approved the board a 9 county ballot measure in an amount not-to-exceed - for november 24th ballot and the

board heard an update on future changes with the conservation to help make priority xhefrn areas degrees more conducive the year-long process had an expands conservation place types to better reflect in may the executive boards a bag and staff will work on evacuating to line them with the new framework and at the last board meeting we approved the proposed biggest and voted for cac for one of the 55 percent for left lane affordable housing act and ac a protect the vote act and the chairs from each the boards 5 policy committee provided brief reports the rest i'll submit.

>> thank you, supervisor. >> supervisor melgar i don't have any outside digs but have two it piece of legislation the first is i'm introducing a charter amendment today with a co-sponsorship of commissioner walton supervisor ronen and others that seeks the responsibility for funding to children and youth. we are very fortunate that we have a dedicated movement of child advocates in san francisco had the foresight to have groundbreaking polly like the children and youth set aside have the god mother to thank for that and fought for basic funding to make sure the children and youth and services have funding and we authorized

the children fund in 2014 with the voters at that time established the children and youth i'm sorry our children and families council what was bringing to the the unified school districts to come up with one centralized plan. for children and families of san francisco and a coordinated system of services the council mrishld great work with analyze and in an initial framework that helped the priority for the department of children, youth, families and even the mayor and children and families recovery plan. this was for every city agency to center children in their. >> (repeated.) >> the constitution of the united states. of day to day with so many players and very few tools for staff to hold anyone's feet to the fire and

not realizing the potential so a few years ago we talked to the departments staff to discuss how we can improve the structure we need to not lose community and public transparent for that expenditures. the department of children, youth, families does have a very robust 5 years planning process as dictated by the charter on how to expand the children and youth fund a lot of public outreach. service providers were awarded are subject to review and beeshgd, however, our city agencies are for the held to the same standards or the same level of scrutiny or budgetary discipline do we know what measurable outcomes despite the many

investments we unfortunately, have failing my children when it comes to social and emotional health and education like literacy and math the city send money to the unified school district for public enrichment funds we don't closely track those dollars to make sure they're really impacting this chapter by making that a citywide policy that the departments are lyon with the existing 5 years planning cycle we'll have stronger coordination and a spiraled way to measure once a plan in place on 3457b annual base consolidations or 7 members and reevaluate this and

provide recommendations together mayor and the board on the funding or whether it is moving the needle for outcomes for the children and youth. this aims to get us more information during the budget process and enforcing the discipline the board will hold and hearing during the budget and pass the resolution attesting the dollars are in fact, for the contributing and lots of needs for the families and we need to be held accountable and hopefully make impactful budgetary decisions i recognize this is a big shift on we are providing a very long run way in the 5 years cycle that is starting in fiscal year 25 and 26 and grateful for the staff of

the dcyf dcyf many of the providers and advocates helped for this charter amendment and to greg our controller who also helped us with this resolution so with that, owners thank you to my co-sponsor. um, i also have today a resolution that i am introducing with supervisor ronen and supervisor chan and others to implement a full strategy to expand investments in caregiver to support our children's workforce and economic reverberation efforts. as you know, we made history with at latter department in setting the building blocks of an early care and for low income

families raised the wages for women of color and invested to renovate listened centers to serve the three but still an unmet need for babies and toddlers and we have the funds to do that now we need to have the will to do it the promise was to build out an infrastructure regardless of income that means expanding the subsidies you were to two hundred percent of ami but insuring there are slots for families not needing a subsidy and in the meantime, a staffing crisis but impacted impacting you are essential workforce like our police department and recent survey by the status of women assess studio caregiver was

cited by female police officers as retention in recruitment we have unfilled commitment to build a children center we promised this during the collective bargaining agreement and have a downtown core that is joint new life but still didn't have as many workers coming back to work after the pandemic this moment we're in when we need to be investing fund we have a unique opportunity to make sure we leverage our existing dollars to help reinvigorate to reimagine our downtown. san francisco's future can't function without a robust early care and education workers returning should be offered

caregiver subsidies and where they work taking advantage of the vacant commercial properties and lower rents to expand that and thrill to here with an the managers at the embarcadero center is converting one of our commercial spaces to caregiver if you haven't seen the plans their fabulous and this resolution urges deck to develop and 10 year spevendz plan to help determine how to ram up slots for subsidized and unsubsidized kids and particularly to focus on areas of workforce growth. um, the resolution also calls to dedicate on like the laguna honda hospital and also to provide technical assistance and expertise in the effort that we

have been promoting to provide 24/7 caregiver for the city police first responders and nurses and essential workers i'm grateful to the staff the deck phone call for their accomplishments and eager to support them and the next initiative to roll out baby plans i also want to thank the carr and advisor council for their advocacy and the women's affirmative the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor melgar and madam clerk run to item 16 and 17 the special order at 3:00 p.m. >> item 16 has been heard and new filed (gavel) i believe the department of building inspection staff have returned and they have updated reports on or report on the property mr. l.

>> thank you. >> departments department of building inspection so since is time we spent this afternoon we had 14 items come off the list i'll read those by line. line three 419 street coming off. >> got it. >> line 25 and 26. 2478 to be 21st street and 298 to 2992 street coming off. >> got it. >> lines three 1 and three 2. >> 3 third avenue. >> coming off. >> line 74, 117 cane avenue. >> coming off i got it. >> okay. >> so lines one 20, one 21 and

the one 2 three and 24. >> one of those folsom streets stays and correct. >> and one 25 is? >> got it. >> line 170 as 450 and other 450 jones stay. >> one 70 one and through 74 come off. >> one 70 through one 74? >> all right. >> one 78 and 79 and 149 jewels avenue come off. >> okay. >> line one 8 three and 1751.

>> lasalle avenue. >> got it and that's everything. >> okay. >> and what about oh, presence it's was off. >> we don't have anything other this time. >> but we can reach out for more information. >> you, you guys can follow-up. >> offline thank you, president peskin and colleagues, a motion to amend this 17 and removal the properties that were identified motion by commissioner walton and supervisor mandelman take that without objection and have a motion to approve the item as amended motion made by

supervisor walton and seconded by supervisor chan and take that. >> same house, same call. the resolution is adopted as amended (gavel). >> ma'am, thank you, mr. l and the diagonally and all the individuals that tested without objection item 17 is adopted as amended and madam clerk back to roll call for introduction a you're ready to introduce yourself business. >> thank you today colleagues, i'm introducing a number of charter amendments that seek to address two crises drafting affordable housing and gathering good neighbor policy and while rooting out consumer price index has continued to plague our government as many of you say as leaks city plan or arguing lack

therefore to meet the 14 thousand units of extremely low income household we have a crisis of affordability in san francisco. our affordable housing policies currently exclude tens of thousands of seniors and people with disabilities. all of who fixed incomes and powerful ami is creating barriers to accessing affordable housing. in terms of we have to make affordable housing affordable to those that who that need it those are not a homeless san franciscans but without access to permanent housing will end up on the streets in 2019 my colleague and former norman yee create is a one time dent in the crisis for at least some seniors with the creation of the senior operating subsidies s o s and provided

subsidizes that enacted ev to set rents for one hundred and thirty united that seniors can affords was an overwhelming success and to skin in the game to expand that after years working to try to find an approach for e l i funding i'm creating the affordable housing fund for seniors and families. which it frankly is a irish-american modified effort if gets us 21 e l i household a critical step in the crisis should be a universal city priority i know a tough budget year but invest in the concrete solutions for those affordable housing stepped up can't support

of acquisitions of older sites or single-room occupancies hotels without a e l i and like i said 1,000 plus perfect examples of seniors not housed by way of example the e l i see 47 percent of total projects i want to thank my staff sunny and others mayor's office of housing and community development and a number of the community organizations seniors disability network and chinatown and corporation meta and without walls and corporations and san francisco community land trust and many more for the partnership and vocabulary and

welcome discussion in the days and weeks ahead with all of you. >> today, i'm introducing a ballot to tackle corruption by empowering an inspector general and those who do business with the city the strong i g model do gold standard of dignity and used in negotiation and philadelphia and chicago and new orleans and many more san francisco is the only major city in united states of america would the an inspector general and needs one of the most the climate of corruption and pay to play politics has plagued us too long and time to stop relying on the fbi and clean up our ore house this proposal historians the best packs the i g model by dignity experts and evaluated

mandate public accountability and independence this position will live with the audits eliminating their best practices and functions as no additional costs to taxpayers and without creating an elected post inspector general will lead and coordinate investigations regarding policies involving fraud and waste or misconduct and complaints from the checks and balances and report on investigations twice yearly to the board and the mayor without the - seeing offhand first hand and seeking the counsel and guidance of formerer controllers and the city attorney's office and experts i look forward to earning our support colleagues

and finally, a charters amendments pleasure in response to what i consider being the streamlining resolution about the teams of 501 center piece packs for civic engagement in a democratic process by happy ev our charter the sheer amount of unregulated money poured into removal sunshine and everyday people right out of government is staggering almost 3 million with ron latest donations an extraordinary amount of the money to silence people from youth and others advocates and immigrants all seeming without a rational base without - their interests so many ways we can make government work better for the people without cutting out

the people or their access to government i want to acknowledge supervisor mandelman who undertook with the controller before formaler and current controllers my office and many of your offices to move forward in a gather good faith and sf didn't take the suggestions i'm appreciative of this collection or collaborations so today introducing and charter amendment to form an independent blue ribbon panel and not streamline people out of our city government we make changes should be done pubically not in a backroom with public hearings and streamlining our city commission is timely and it is warranted but keep the sunshine

in government that is our central focus and sf no public oversight and no public process has drafted in essence a amendment to the constitution behind closed doors and to keep san franciscans in the dark about the government and measure eliminates the health commission the library commission the commission on the status of women to name a few with no plans for how to improve they're function and removes civilian oversight for the police commission to public health and fooufrtd our department of justice mandates this will take us backwards no forwards the amendment will keep the structure of the government and lets the voters decide how we'll

operate and pulls those in retrurg the government to improve efficiency and cut costs i actually think an exciting opportunity to embark on hard conversation and do it in a way that looked at what is actually working and what our community stakeholders deserve and introducing two to make we have the best approach making the government more effective and the rest i will summit. >> thank you president peskin. >> and supervisor preston at the submit and i'm a little nervous. >> thank you for the outside boards this quarter the oversight committee worked with the bso for a plan that includes labor and reporting reminder for permanent and extremely low income housing as the

$20 billion affordable housing bond the labor was approved and the gobld will come for a final vote on june 22nd as a reminder this unprecedented housing bond will preserve 72 thousand new homes with unlocking over 40 thousand homes we already have isn't pipeline today and regarding m t c in april our manual two day workshop to discuss the perez issues face to face us the major quarter including the workshop has been sb 10 three 1 by senator wiener and others a regional transportation revenue measure at establish the bayview regional network manager and recognize the cellists challenges transit operators are

key points of argument with guarantees and competition and whether to conclude do highway projects and note that my fellow commissioners and i are advocating for the transit riders and transit systems not expanding the highways. second colleagues, i'm introducing a resolution to support senate bill 1975 will require the inclusion of food and nutrition intervention as benefit under the medi-cal property programming that bill is part of a food bill initiate and makes california the first state to provide covered food prescription intervention and examples of this will be the permission of produce and other healthy foods to people with

chronic illness and medical nutrition to prevent and treat illness and more are for communities of color and the same residents have food inner security this is health and improving the outcomes for patients will benefits from such program. >> thank you to a skylar and staff for bringing this to my attention and to supervisor walton and others i urge all my colleagues to support this baby for 1975 the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor safai. >> thank you, madam clerk >> thank you, colleagues. today, i'm excited to introduce and charter amendment aimed and improving the retention and

recruitment of our fulfillment san francisco nurses and 9-1-1 emergency dpafrnz to improve the public health. san francisco is facing a severe shortage of any any operators i heard earlier talking about the police officers and along with the other charter amendments with the firefighters the row tainting and keeping them safe and san francisco is the shortage is over burdening our healthcare system and delaying our entering response times and vacancy rate 20 slots are empty we're not meeting our mandated 9-1-1 call response time to required time only 71 percent of calls are respond to in the mandated time and established one hundred and 70 full-time registered nurses positions are

vacant and impacting the pc safety system you, you recall a couple of months ago we are asked to transfer almost $40 million of funding nurses positions to over time and our city much like the police department much like the fire department, our nurses and 9-1-1 call operators are definitely asked to serve in overtime sometimes mandatory over time as a that is over burdening our system and they're exhausted and understaffed and absolutely under-appreciated. our department is still unappreciated our department of public health is 85 millions on traveling nurses costing 14 percent hiring full-time nurses

need to address the nursing shortage without burdening the taxpayers and this ballot measure does that i spoken with front line nurses and 9-1-1 call operators across the city and excited to get people into the system and dealing with they're real exhaustion and frustration. this is no disrespect to any temporary traveling nurses but as a proud san franciscan i'm supporting this local workforce. every nurse loves their job and every 9-1-1 call operators they're on the front lines and passionate about caring for patients and passionate about insuring we respond to our emergencies. during those tough

times but absolutely reaching a breaking point and staffing shortages and unsafe it conditions are they're seeking other positions in so the city and counties this incentives and allow full-time nurses previously worked as temporary nurses to buy back up to three years of that retirement time and new nurses can qualify after a few year in the full time nurse it insures also that our 9-1-1 dafrnz receive equal retirement benefits to emergency personnel in many cases and legally classified they don't receive the same retirement bin that amendment changes that by that concludes my report. our nurses and 9-1-1 dispatchers we can retain dedicated and

attract new talent and we owe it to our nurses and 9-1-1 call parties operators i want to thanks seiu local and david and others want to thank bert and haesht for partnering with me on the ballot measure and thank my co-sponsor supervisor walton and commissioners and others supervisors have supported in measure thank you for that and look forward to others co-sponsors and want to thank you are city attorneys for diligent work and working under stressful conditions to beat those timelines and thank you, city attorney for her hard work and thank you for getting back

to me and cecil and our controller greg wagner for his assistance in cost 12e6789s and cfo c o o and karen for their initial response in analyzing the cost and colleagues, a nice compliment to the other charter amendments were put for the or forwards for the firefighters and police officers shows this board is taking seriously public safety delivery system in the city and saluting respectfully and honor and privilege our first responders and all they do in our system. and the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor safai and mr. president that includes the introduction of the new business. >> thank you go to general

public comment. >> as make your way to the raise your right hand of the room we're setting the timer for two minutes our welcome to talk about the mayors appearance and discussion with commissioner chambers the april 16th meeting minutes and on the items on the denounces would the reference to committee 21 through 26 all other matters have had their public comment fulfilled and my speak to others general matters walk through to the first speaker. >> this is extreme i have no choice but to comply with that - the mayor is out i told you several times on critical thinking that's all you get safety that's the way it works the more you wait, to apply what

i told you you to pay attention every time he spoke the more i think so everything this is - so the more you wait the important you're going to go down will be extremely difficult to face i can't (unintelligible) as you can't fit beauty it didn't work you can't effect bottom so, now what is going on. didn't need our six power you see it says to suffice only (unintelligible) power that why is of the it creates ugliness. end of story i understand everything if you see seriously (unintelligible) 2

thousand years. to impersonate themselves i don't know what you're thinking here except you don't like me that's normal (bell ringing) . no-brainier now, when you see (unintelligible) a i need to read absolute incompetence to add challenges with that whenever so no time besides whatever or wherever you read a i incompetence you'll love it. >> thank you for your comments (bell ringing) next speaker. >> okay. i'd like to preach on the sign of bus and this comes from my isaiah we read in the year that when the king of syria

figure out at that time spoke how much go and loss the sack cloth from off my lines and put off the shoe from the foot and walked naked and barefoot like i's work hard upon egypt so should the king of syria lead them off and the capita actives were had their button butt index and signs that the butt is actually happening in front of us parallel in the united states with guideline woman and the

butts they're so skintight they're not christens or, you know, not wearing modified apparel but a civilian judgment upon the nation calls do sign the butt what i's safe walked naked that the god was going to - with tom read avenue in the 9/11 we'll build about human stones and the sick 340rz will - read that in context was actually a sign on us we're being genocide by god by our since we'll not listen to god (bell ringing) >> next speaker. >> and we've been coming here

for years just to get judicious but not able to get justice this is ruining our businesslike uber in the shutter at the airport to run the shuttles i don't know but if you got to skip us like that always for years and keep coming and there is a god all right. on top of us, we trust in god if you'll not think of us because we people so if you golden state warriors guys think like you'll not help us i wear to good idea that god will take back around you and bring it individually to you guys we've been suffering for years to please we're begging you to take time wearing deeply, deeply in

rut we need our help otherwise so we are not happy we've been coming for years. >> thank you for your comments next speaker. >> hi hello supervisors and city officers i'm medallion and 624. we are having a big trouble right now because of we have only chance resources to pick up the fair at the airport and right now the airport is fixing the runway one runway only working 50 percent of flights are off by the runway fix we're wasting time is longer than than before and have 50 percent revenue of income. and then we don't know what to do and should

have some kind of program to help us, please. and then i feel like we are dying and we are going waiting for is collapse and pick up the uber and - but it is unfair to pick up the uber with the app - would not the same regulations. if you want us to pick up the uber fair in the uber then we should have the same regulations and have a hefty regulation by the city of san francisco and overhead from uber drivers i don't know we are (bell ringing). >> really have a bad time right now please help us.

>> thank you for your comments. and next speaker. >> good afternoon. >> my name is - i'm speaking on the i chartered many cities so many cities is really nice. san francisco (unintelligible) treat us like a dunk and why strike everything like taxis and brutally slaughtered us, we are dead. and (unintelligible) is going in her mind she enjoyed access and taxis and uber is a big lie and blunter and you use us as slaves to pick up short fairs at airport and left offer

in the city and sutro the disabled we can't rely on this business we are ready to file bankruptcy we don't want our children will never drive taxicabs and if i don't bail us out you'll have no more taxis we don't know whether you want us to help or not if you really want us to help then treat us like new york treated their taxicabs and why (bell ringing) should we pick up at the airplane and city also will ride shares are equal to taxicabs the city left - rights. do not take

any advice of people off ride share and don't take (unintelligible) (bell ringing) city needs and thank you for your comments and thank you for your comments. >> next speaker. >> good afternoon. >> board of supervisors (clearing throat) my name is richard petersen i've spoken here before. on topic i take municipal on friday um, i took for the first time a geary express bus which was very crowded. i had to exit backdoor with my dog. and i reached ill

up to hold on to a bar with my a cane and dog in my other hand the closed disclosed upon me and krushdz my hand and took the driver to stop the bus and come around and pull the door open to relieve my hand which was relatively that is painful injury. and in any event i met the city - went to the city attorney's office not to file and claim but apparently, you, only file a claim am of the university in the mechanical engineering and there is a design underway in the muni rear door bus. so i want to have that have that corrected one way or another and willing to

participate in having that underway corrected but it is very simple (bell ringing) anyway, i hope that i can get more coordination from the city attorney's office you have to file a claim or is entering service that required you to give your name to them um, and if i did i go to the hospital but if you didn't could continue on your mission which mine was to retain old fish for my mosquito pond event. thank you. >> thank you for your comments. >> welcome to the next speaker. >> my name is jim. i'm here seeking liability andus for my partner and laguna honda for laguna honda. >> randy went to uh-huh and my right to visit was cut off i

asked for the prognoses and dialysis for my domestic partner and so they solicited remands and rented him unconscious and sent him to laguna honda and sent his - without telling you we didn't know that after that randy does a durable power of attorney for laguna honda and got another letter couldn't do a power of attorney that he was able to go ahead we tried to get and the transaction from the pay

yes we find out that his pay yes was not sending the cost to laguna honda and his dad embezzled 8 thousands of hi cost to laguna honda (bell ringing) and with the help of this doctors and the eligibility working at laguna honda i have one. 2, three, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 documents here i'd like to present to the board of supervisors. my bark has a bite and randy has been victimized (bell ringing) thank you for your comments. >> any other members for general public comment? >> seeing none, public comment is closed. i'm sorry are you coming, sir?

>> okay. we'll reopen public comment go ahead, sir. >> go ahead.

>> is there a way to turn this on? >> are you having trouble finding your video. >> i'm not showing that. >> again to our room or if you're unhappy with the way things are run around here go to your room or - >> i guess the problem that i'm having like we have case

management that thinks they have the privilege to talk to us like this i feel like they're violating civil right a talking about down and dehumanize nicks us and the program direct thinks this is acceptable we should tolerant and deal with inferior services that are dehumanizing and like out right abusive i guess i'm asking how we get to the city to have better investigation next week's create a system where the the subcontractors hire better staffing i feel like the behavior of those cases managers

are out lane dish and abusive i say protections. is homeless once they get into those (bell ringing) housing programs we need stronger protections and we need like an omni businessman what there is problems so they can go to the city and get complaints going to the rights people to investigate. it seems a big vacuum i got more videos (bell ringing) >> thank you charles. >> mr. president. >> public comment is closed. (gavel) madam clerk read the adoption without community reference calendars. >> items.

>> here we go. >> items 21 through 26 introduced without committee reference and unanimous vote and other resolution on first reading a member may require to go to the committee. >> any member like an item or items severed and commissioner walton. >> president peskin 22 and 23. >> madam clerk on the balance of items 21, 25 and 26. >> same house, same call. those resolutions are adopted and motion approved (gavel) madam clerk read item 22. >> this is a resolution to support california assembled

bill 2655. assembly bill 28 three 9 and introduced by essential member gail and senate bill three 211 by assembly buffy and senate bill introduced to address technologies of artificial intelligence on may 13th and rules committee and thank you, supervisor ronen held a meeting on artificial intelligence that our hearing discussed the growing concerns around elects and nationally how we protect our local elections as to the greatest extent one

thing the urgently address the laws for gaps right now in regulations to prevent false and shredding election material we had the hearing think monday the next day we transferred this roses supporting a bill package and while a lot of different pieces of legislation in sacramento that touch on this issue those were some bills that were highlighted in particular by the advocates who experts at the hearing including david the faculty member at advisors to common cause and the center for justice. n y u law and bills seen as keen state bills harris discussed local policies to talk about the local elections how to better prepare for the november

elects and some of the recommendations out of a announced report from the brandon center that is called how election officials responder to i threats the four bills in the resolution are pevenld in the assembly a key times for the bills to get out of their house of origin over the next 10 days and looking forward to this and putting san francisco on record thirty these records will lgbtq the use of artificial intelligence to promote misinformation in our elections. i also want to note we're working with the city attorney's to address the local laws and have nomination on that soon but

didn't want to wait on showing our support at the board for the state bills pending in the time in sacramento. thank you. >> okay. so we'll take that. >> same house, same call. i'm sorry commissioner chambers you want to speak to this. okay. >> same house, same call. the resolution is adopted and item 23. >> a resolution to condemn racism intimation of williams family and urge to have an investigation and support for the family and president peskin. >> supervisor preston thank you, president peskin and colleagues first of all, thank you. the boards for co-sponsoring this resolution and join me in condemning the racism threats against terry williams and his family and outpouring of support from

friends and neighbors and good to see this board joining as well in supporting the family but things have taken and turn for the worst really a horrible turn today. i want to update you um, on this situation. amend the resolution to reflect where i was before this meeting without at the scene at the williams families home. um, where there was a fire day a major fire to remind you see this is a family that has now withstood weeks ago of direct threats i described before as racial terror the kind of this thing we hear about in the worst of the k k and the deep south kind of what is

happened to the family of threats delivered directly telling the family to leave the neighborhood because they're black delivering a black disposal with a notices around the and next. and reported to federal authorities with that context a major fire they williams family home. fortunately someone thank you to the 9-1-1 caller and to an incredible response from to fire department, and our ems workers and everyone else out there there was a rescue fortunately

no one lost their lives today and injuries were in stable condition. it is truly horrible what this family has gotten and add today is events was major damage to the family home and i don't want to go ahead ahead if we don't have obviously the fire department doing they're investigation they will and sfpd's make without announcements have to make along the way we don't have um, any conclusions regarding the cause but i think we also are aware of context and the timing here and to say this is alarming would be an understatement i want to i've spoken with family members and on scene with them today. um,

and been fielding a lot of calls from family and friends and neighbors horrified the community came together behind the family and any thoughts with terry and hi entire family and mom that received medical treatment in stable condition the amendment i'll read them they're literally complicated minutes before so sorry to give you no notice but talking about all of what this family has been through without including the fire that occurred literally on the day we're hearing this so. the amendments you'll see in our in boxes i'll for the record or read into the record agreeing a whereas, clues as page 2 line 16 whereas, the

major fire occurred on may tuesday, may 21, 2024, that is currently investigated and displaced all occupants and traumatizing the family and adding the clause in addition to the clauses that urge sfpd and our variance departments to support the family and to identify an app apprehend the prepare translators and experiencing adding a clause after that that on page three line one further revolve san francisco to expect an investigation of major fire an tuesday, may 21, 2024, and urges the maurice agency and all the departments to urgely provide necessary support for the family like to move those, too

amendments. and update but let me close by saying this this entire situation is um, a real test of our city and whether we walk the wake when it comes to taking a stand against anti brake racism this is so 0 extreme what is happening. to this family. and i'm encouraged by the unanimous co-sponsorship by the conversations with the board members who have basically sent the message, however, this body can help this build is ready to help and i also want to thank james colorado well on scene and work together to make sure there is temporary housing for the family but good

samaritan beyond temporary solutions make sure this family and others are safe that this investigation is included with the suspect identified and beyond that this family what return to this home could not allow what has been happening to this family in recent weeks to drive people out of our neighborhoods especially a neighborhood that has already experienced so much trauma and displacement to the black communities. so i want to thank you all for your support and co-sponsorship and like to move the amendment. >> motion by president peskin to amend and seconded by commissioner asianian-williams colleagues without objection on the item as amended. >> same house, same call. the resolution is adopted

(gavel) madam clerk read item 24. >> resolution to urge the mayor and department of children, youth, families to solicit depositions and philanthropy to restore the $25 million for the dcyf funds for fiscal year 2024-25 and to urge the officers within the legal limits of behested owner to accept donations to offset those reductions on working families and youth citywide. >> cumbering. thank you. mr. president i would like to make a motion to send this to the oversight competent i'll appreciate that. >> motion to send it to refer. >> a single privilege. >> yes. >> supervisor. >> a motion a-

>> (multiple voices). >> single privilege the item should be referred to the government oversight committee madam clerk, any in memoriams. we are adjourned he (gavel) [meeting adjourned] [music] welcome to the ethic's commission introduction to gift rules. we will discuss why the city and county of san francisco and the

state of california have rules regarding give and accepting giftss an employee or officer. as city officers and employees we serve the public. everyone who lives, works or plays in san francisco trusts us with important decisions every day. this trust is honored boy making decision for the public good. if someone gives you i gift than i miexpect manage in return. if you accept i gift you mifeel pressureed give something. even if you don't feel pressured, members of public could perceive it different low. creates the appearance of i conflict of interest real or perceived. to foster an environment gentleman decisions are fair and in the based on person interests tr are restrictions on giving and receiving gifts employs well

wellace reporting requirements. these may include refusing gifts the people you serve or those doing business with your agency. only accepting gifts below a certain value or public low disclosing the gift you received. because gift lus and limits vary depending on circumstances, it is always important it seek guidance before accepting i give to avoid violating the lu. rules support the trust tht people of san francisco have put us. had our decisions are fair and transparent and we are accountable we live up to ideals. for more information visit the san francisco ethic's commission's website at sfethics. org or phone, e mail or in person. thank you for watching.

in cases where there is a [music] >> hi. thanks for coming today. really appreciate you coming out. this idea of a round table actually i have been wanting to do for many years especially it talk with fellow veterans. i'm excited for today. we get into it.