line item for dpa director's report discussion report on recent dpa activities and announcements. commission discussion will be limited to determining whether to calendar any of the issues raised for future commission meeting. executive director henderson thank you. uh, we are currently at, uh, 20 cases that have been opened, so far this year, and we've closed 16 cases, uh, on the current caseload and docket at dpa. we have 317 cases that are open and we have sustained three cases so far this year. uh, in terms of cases who have investigations that have gone on beyond, uh, nine month period and are continuing, we have 26 cases and of those 26 cases, 19 of the cases are told, uh, currently we have eight cases whose decisions are pending that are with the commission. and we have 87 cases whose decisions are pending, uh, with the chief terms of the weekly trends. uh, this week we received 51 cases that have come in, uh, and the highest percentage of those cases have been for an allegation for allegations of conduct unbecoming of an officer. uh, again, the full breakdown of the 100% o

presentation and discussion on sapd and dpa sparks report fourth quarter 2023 discussion sapd and dpa. good evening, president elias. uh, vice president carter stone. um, i'll defer to sarah hawkins because paul henderson seems to be out. uh, chief scott and commission uh, deputy chief peter walsh, uh, of the administrator bureau. i'll be conducting the presentation, uh, with the assistance of officer duarte. um, for the sparks report. okay slide. thank you. um, i know that you know the history, but just for the public, uh, the sparks resolution 2706 requires quarterly reports from both sfpd and dpa. uh, and we provide the police commission with policy, uh, development awareness. currently, um, the status updates on 19 dgos are actively going through a developmental process, and approximately i should say, 71 department notices are set to expire within 120 days. and again, this is for the fourth quarter next slide. one of the um, more important dgos, uh, that we wanted to update is 7.01, which is, uh, juveniles. um, it's been posted for the 30 day public review process. it concluded i

presentation and discussion on sapd and dpa sparks report fourth quarter 2023 discussion sapd and dpagood evening, president elias. uh, vice president carter stone. um, i'll defer to sarah hawkins because paul henderson seems to be out. uh, chief scott and commission uh, deputy chief peter walsh, uh, of the administrator bureau. i'll be conducting the presentation, uh, with the assistance of officer duarte. um, for the sparks report. okay slide. thank you. um, i know that you know the history, but just for the public, uh, the sparks resolution 2706 requires quarterly reports from both sfpd and dpa. uh, and we provide the police commission with policy, uh, development awareness. currently, um, the status updates on 19 dgos are actively going through a developmental process, and approximately i should say, 71 department notices are set to expire within 120 days. and again, this is for the fourth quarter next slide. one of the um, more important dgos, uh, that we wanted to update is 7.01, which is, uh, juveniles. um, it's been posted for the 30 day public review process. it concluded in

that's dpa, meaning we. my other question was on page eight, you indicated sfp, pds procedures for disqualifying field training officers based on their misconduct. history was outdated. didn't we just pass the dgo on field training officers and i had asked this question, so that might come down to a timing issue. i think depending on the publication date of the report. okay. yeah. this the dgo and fto was just passed a couple of months ago. so yeah, exactly. okay. i think it was this month. uh, okay. commissioner benedicto, didn't you have your. yes okay. you cleared me. um. thank you very much for that audit from our award winning audit team. um i, i will echo what president elias said in the consistent improvement of the quality of dpa's audits. and, frankly, just the existence of dpa's audit function was not was not in place under its predecessor agency. when i first started. and, um, sitting on the other side of the dais working with the commission 2015 and the creation of the audit function and the rest

yeah one i'm looking at dpa's chart. um, this thing um, and looking at the department's comment and then dpa's comment. so just if concurrence is wrapped up in may, what's the why hasn't there been an extension? we discussed this in october. the october 18th commission meeting as well. um, this is one of those dgos where when concurrence has concluded and there was a dpa meeting that designated timelines within the simultaneous concurrent section of the dpo had concluded. so there were no more timelines. uh, then after for the meeting with dpa, um, it was kind of in this area where we were having, uh, edits, added, um, written directives, was seeking those edits from the chief. uh, we did receive them. and so now we have moved it forward to blue folder. but unfortunately for us, the 301 does not have, um, while it does have this, uh, area where for there, the chief gets final approval. it doesn't put a timeline on the chief for that final approval. so it is a non designated timeline. um okay. 2.07. so wait before we move

so that's resolved itself at and for dpa. the aggregate trends were failure to activate body worn camera and inappropriate language or comments. i'm just going to note that we're going to probably just speak because the slides are showing up, um, in a not user friendly format for reviewing on a screen. so we'll just we'll just talk. and then the third item that was touched on is the board really got into depth about what is the definition of aggregate trend. and you'll see that in recommendation number one. so i'm going to use to share a little bit of that language at that time. um, as it relates to that. and i'll definitely have sarah jump in as well for the second quarter, the iad closed cases in the second quarter resulted in zero failure policy failure findings dpa had three policy failure cases in the second quarter, one of which also resulted in a sustained complaint. um, the first was regarding an incomplete booking search, which resulted in officers not locating contraband and a weapon possessed by an in-custody perso

on recent dpa activities and announcements. commission discussion will be limited to determining whether to calendar any of the issues raised for a future commission meeting. executive director henderson. good evening. uh, so currently we. uh, so currently we have, uh,

so that's resolved itself at and for dpa. the aggregate trends were failure to activate body worn camera and inappropriate language or comments. i'm just going to note that we're going to probably just speak because the slides are showing up, um, in a not user friendly format for reviewing on a screen. so we'll just we'll just talk. and then the third item that was touched on is the board really got into depth about what is the definition of aggregate trend. and you'll see that in recommendation number one. so i'm going to use to share a little bit of that language at that time. um, as it relates to that. and i'll definitely have sarah jump in as well for the second quarter, the iad closed cases in the second quarter resulted in zero failure policy failure findings dpa had three policy failure cases in the second quarter, one of which also resulted in a sustained complaint. um, the first was regarding an incomplete booking search, which resulted in officers not locating contraband and a weapon possessed by an in-custody perso

uh dpa had paul henderson and chief scott. um, i am i'm commander. i just demoted myself. uh, deputy chief peter walsh of the administration bureau. so, um, next to me is tj chow. uh, tj works in the staffing and deployment unit and has worked tirelessly over many months to put the staffing and, uh, deployment report together. that's mandated. um, he's going to do the presentation on, and we'll both be here for question, but i cannot say enough about tj's work. um, he is the glue, the wheel, whatever adjective or metaphor you want to use that put this together. and if you've seen the actual report, it is a lot of work. um, so i will hand it over to tj. so tj put together the powerpoint to absolutely. i can barely turn on a computer tj welcome. good morning commissioner or good evening commissioners. um one moment as i just pull up the powerpoint i thought it'd be ready for me. but i know good help is hard to find. huh? is it on here? it's on there. good. all right. so here, let me pull. uh, good evening, commissioners. uh, chief scott and members of the public. my name is

in those cases if the chief disagreewise dpa, the case is over and dpa does not have any recourse.f the chief decides that misconduct occurred, and to impose discipline, an officer has a right to a hearing before that decision is final. >> what happens if a dpa complaint turns into a commission level case? >> if the dpa determines a 11 day suspension all the way up to termination is the appropriate outcome for a misconduct case, a trial is held in front of the police commission. normally, one commissioner presides over the trial, then the entire commission will read the transcript and vote. if the commission determines misconduct occurs, then the commission also determines what the penalty will be. if you are stopped by a police officer you should follow the officer direction, keep calm, keep still, and do not make sudden movements do not reach for anything, especially in your pockets, keep your hands visible at all times. you have the right to remain silent. this means you do not have to say anything. tell the officer i want to remain silnts. you have a right to a attorney. tell t

that's according to the german press agency dpa. the frigate fired on 2 targets, the 1st engagements of germany's reds, the mission to secure a cargo ships against recent attacks. the jury in new york has found 2 men guilty of the 2000 to murder of hip hop pioneer, jason moselle, better known as jam master jay, of the group. run dmc, the men convicted were one of them. is those childhood friends and his gods, prosecutor say the 2 killed the run dmc founder and in dispute over a cocaine distribution deal football caught a petal volcano in central, mexico has begun spewing gas and ashes following a mile or as quick. several towns have reported light as fall and authorities say it could reach mexico city. mexico cities international airport said several airlines have canceled flights due to ash jordanian mil military has released footage showing king abdullah, the 2nd helping an air crew drop aid packages over the guns and strip 6 cargo aircraft, including 3 from jordan took part in the air drop which delivered food and other 8 items.

attacking the red sea by humans who the mill militia that is, according to the german press agency dpa. the frigate fired on 2 targets. the 1st engagement of germany's reads, the mission to secure cargo ships against attacks by the ran back to militia militants or the georgia damien military has released footage showing king abdullah, the 2nd helping air crew drop 8 packages over the gaza strip. 6 cargo aircraft, including 3 from jordan, took part in the air drop, which delivered food and other 8 items. jordan says king of bill of participated in similar error operations earlier this month. public a type pethel, a volcano and central mexico has begun spewing gas and ashes following a mild earthquake. several towns have reported light ash fall, and authorities say it could reach mexico city. mexico cities international airport said several airlines had canceled flights due to the ash the city of browser la in western and brazil has been completely cut off by flood waters. heavy rainfall caused the acre river to rise to near historic level. 30 say, 11000 people have lost their homes or b

file with dpa online asfgov.org/dpa or (indiscernible) in person at the office located at 1 south vanthe 8 floor or any district police station. there are key pieces of information that anyone filing complaints should provide, including your contact information, so we can ask for follow-up questions, the location, time and date of incident. officer name and star number, and specific details including words and actions by all involved parties. it is important to remember anyone can file a complaint and you do not have to be a witness or victim to initiate a complaint. this next slide provides a overview of dpa mediation division. mediation is alternative to dpa investigationing a complaint. the goal of mediation are improve the relationship between the community and sfpd. mediation allows both parties toprint perspectives that resulted in a complaint. may request mediation when you file a complaint or referred to the mediation team. mediation is voluntary for the person making the complaint and officer. both must agree to resolve through mediation. unpaid volunteers not dpa employees t

today in the same tune as bernst, he had a big press conference today with the chief editors of the dpa argued his refusal of the taurus, but there what is interesting is not only what he said directly, but what was said between the lines. they asked him a few questions there , they asked him: well, are you giving up taurus? he says: firstly, i am surprised that you constantly ask one question same question: don’t you see that your chancellor is saving his nerves in order not to react to those questions that are initially provocative, which in principle lead to the fact that i have to answer you: yes, we will put it all, and thus we are being drawn into a war, i am not ready for this, i say: no, they tell him: well, fine, but if you are not ready for this, if you refuse this. you make such a decision, well, what does it involve? well, he says, well, because we stated unequivocally that these systems, they are long-range, they are capable of hitting targets at territory of the russian federation, we cannot be sure that ukraine is not using them the way they want, and not the way they pro

dpa is somewhat different than what was described. >> can talk about the that interest costs? i am not sure i point understand. it doesn't look like we are projecting that in the long run for the industry to be different. i guess what i'm saying is the term premium had gone up. to say that that episode will conclude that in the future so that premiums will be more elevated -- does that make sense? >> i got it. everyone else got it. if anything is unclear, we can come back to it. we do have higher rates in the forecast embodied in these projections than we did in the previous budget projections. of the impact on big interest outlays. you can think of that as two thirds resulting from the higher rates. there is a lengthy footnote in the report that goes from the two thirds, the one third. both the we can find it. if you look at our economic chapter, chapter two, hopefully that is very handy for everyone by the numbers document. you can see we do not get paid by the click for this. i hope everyone including our viewers on c-span be able to download it and look at it. it is a very

file with dpa online asfgov.org/dpa or (indiscernible) in person at the office located at 1 south vanness on the 8 floor or any district police station. there are key pieces of information that anyone filing complaints should provide, including your contact information, so we can ask for follow-up questions, the location, time and date of incident. officer name and star number, and specific details including words and actions by all involved parties. it is important to remember anyone can file a complaint and you do not have to be a witness or victim to initiate a complaint. this next slide provides a overview of dpa mediation division. mediation is alternative to dpa investigationing a complaint. the goal of mediation are improve the relationship between the community and sfpd. mediation allows both parties toprint perspectives that resulted in a complaint. may request mediation when you file a complaint or referred to the mediation team. mediation is voluntary for the person making the complaint and officer. both must agree to resolve through mediation. unpaid volunteers not dpa emp

that is, according to the german press agency dpa. the forget fired on 2 targets. the 1st engagement of germany's red sea emission to secure cargo ships against attacks by the auron fact militant to me url hopefuls in the mexican city of mount of b. i to have been gunned down within hours of each other. everything pointed toward organized crime syndicates being responsible. the current mayor said the murders come ahead of national election set for june, which civil rights groups have warrant could become the most violent on record. the us state of texas has issued a disaster declaration for dozens of countries as a rapidly growing wildfire doubled in size and one day the national weather service was meanwhile, posting the fire danger alerts for several other states were strong winds. dr. agitation and warm temperatures have made conditions right for wild fires, or you're watching dw news still to come on the program, the tiny fish that makes a lot of noise. scientists here in berlin had been figuring out it's see correct. the western nations have largely rejected a

quality of education, this is imagination, the one who conducts the zano, the one who conducts the dpaill be unified across ukraine, then there will be fewer chances for that, if it is still local, then there will be more chances, it will depend a lot on who conducts, who analyzes, but from all the discussions we had, and the key is with international partners, and with obladsmen, so that there is no discrimination , then this is the best... method that is currently proposed, i cannot say that i am calm and confident that it will work 100%, but it is the best option that exists today, so that really need, well, if we need scientists, because they usually win in the game those who come up with the best military technologies that are capable of using a new type of weapon, so if we really need it, or we often need cooperation with our partners, because you will set up production in ukraine even underground, and we are from... what were the hits military enterprises, even those that are underground, are very difficult, so we need to think together with technology partners here and often im

that's according to german press agency dpa. the free gets fired on to target. the 1st engagement of germany's red emission to secure cargo ships against the tax id around back to militias and germany is among the western nations. pushing back after francis president a menu on my call and suggested that allies might need to consider sending ground troops to assist ukraine and it's fight against russia. mccomb was speaking following a conference in paris to drum up support for ukraine. following those talks, german chancellor, all off showed stressed western ground troops were not an option the to opt out of a discontinued, we obviously discussed. we used to arrange for the support of this type of data by it's not enough for a very good debate. we decided that what was agreed from the outset does, does also applies to the future and conflict on the physically for miss. namely that there will be no ground troops at least as kind to know soldiers on ukrainian soil, and i'll send there. but europe and countries or need those dates and stop and we'll go from not the

the same tune as burnston, he had a big press conference there today with the chief editors of the dpary interesting conference, in which he fully argued his rejection of the taurus, but what is interesting there is not only what he said directly, but what was said. between the lines, they asked him a few questions there, they asked him, well, here you are from the taurus refuse, he says: firstly , i’m surprised that you constantly ask the same question, don’t you see that your chancellor is saving his nerves in order not to react to those questions that are initially provocative and which, in principle, lead to to what i have to answer you, yes, we will put it all together, and thus we are drawn into a war, i am not ready for this, i say: no, they say to him: well, fine, but if you are not ready for this, if this... refuse, if you make such a decision, well, what's the point? connected, well, he says, well, because we have stated unequivocally that these systems, they are long-range, they are capable of hitting targets on the territory of the russian federation, we cannot be sure that

i spent all dpa talking to the voters in t dearborn, and they e very animated and motivated to vote for the president's uncommitted ballot line because they wanted to sendot a message about what's happening in gaza right now. but you're not going to see that replicated across the country because obviously the arab american population is significant there. as steve kornacki was laying out there's also significant uncommitted vote with college campuses. we know the bind campaign has struggled with younger voters. you're going to see that on college campuses across the country. he was holding an event on student loans in california. hein didn't do it on a college campus in part because there were concerns about protests emerging at these events. he's going to win the state. he's going to show some strength among the key voters he wanted to highlight, but shows warning signs they need to address, but they do have time to address it between now and november. >> mark, those uncommitted voters are voting against the president for now. as max put it an expression vote because they are not happy

donald trump dpa gave james lankford his complete and total endorsement and said that james lankford was, quote, strong on the border. so thanks for your service, james lankford? anyway, this is a conservative bill. if republicans were actually focused on the policy here, they would support it. republicans say they want a quote-unquote secure border, but they do not, not really. >> what they actually want is chaos. because that's what donald trump says he wants. >> joe biden's approval rating is at 33%. why would we do anything to try to help improve that abysmal number with a border bill? >> i want to secure the border that's what i told my voters i would do. >> the truth is the republican party has ceased to be a party of principles or even much of a party really. the gop's sole reason to exist in this moment appears to be the re-election of donald trump. and if you needed further proof of that late tonight we got the news from "the new york times" that the chairwoman of the republican national committee plans to step down. "the times" reports that ronna mcdaniel plans to step down

we want to make sure that as they come to and from they feel safe and live their every dpa lives. we will continue to work with per ins to get this work done. other thing briefly is to warn our most vulnerable community members about blessing scams this is a time of year where people try to that i can advantage of numbers of asian community knowing is a time when they offer guests to loved ones. i want to encourage everyone to avoid having contact with strangers about the gifts you are giving. we are working hard to per merwith self help for elder low. chinese new comers and organizations to educate and inform the commune about the dangers of blessing scams and also inform of when than i need to report when something happens. we will be there it make sure we prosecute those arrested for enengaging in the scams. again, help new year. so q.ed to be here now i will turn it to david chu. >> good afternoon. upon i think it is entirely appropriate after weeks of stormy weather the sun is shining on china town today. my son second grade class is visiting china town the first time this ho

we want to ensure that all of us, all of our dpa contracted providers and dth services, as well as otherservices are working together either to raise awareness about treatment that's available to raise awareness about the effects of treatment and work together to double down on our efforts to get people into needed and life saving care. experts say it starts with methadone, which can drastically reduce the risk of death, especially when there's fentanyl involved. the city is working to make it more accessible through primary care providers. new federal rules expected to roll out in the next six months, would allow patients to take methadone home while they wait to get into opioid treatment programs, new data finds san francisco is making some progress when it comes to changing people's attitudes about where the city is headed. the annual city beat poll from the chamber of commerce shows 72% of respondents feel the city is still on the wrong track. well, that's actually an improvement. the same poll last year found 77% of voters felt san francisco was not on the right track. >> the signs

officials say the key is treatment, and we want to ensure that all of us, all of our dpa contracted providers and df services as well as other city services, are working together to raise awareness about treatment that's available, able to raise awareness about the effectiveness of treatment and work together to double down on our efforts to get people into needed and life saving care. experts say. it starts with methadone, which can dramatically reduce the risk of death, especially when there's fentanyl involved. the city is working to make it more accessible through primary care providers. new federal rules expected to roll out in the next six months, would allow patients to take methadone home while they wait to get into opioid treatment programs, new data finds. san francisco is making some progress when it comes to changing people's attitudes about where the city is headed. the annual city beat poll from the chamber of commerce shows 72% of respondents feel the city is still on the wrong track. that's actually an improvement, though. the same poll last year found 77% of voters felt san f

unpaid volunteers not dpa employees trained and experiences in helping people resolve differences in a conductive manner. because mediation is voluntary, there is a greater chance of parties want to resolve the problem mutually agreeable fashion. not every complaint is eligible for mediation. cases can go to mediation include those involvingcocts and not (indiscernible) that concludes today's >> that i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of penalized paddled for all. >> i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of penalized paddled >> good morning it is >> welcome to the san francisco fire commission regular meeting this morning at 9:00 am., wednesday, february 14, 2024. >> 9 o'clock this meeting is held in three minutes per item. >> public comment call-in: 415-655-0001 meriting id: 2664 334 2654 webinar password: 1234 webinar password: 1234 limited to 3 minutes per to 3 minutes per to 3 minutes per to the queue. the system will notify you when you are in line. callers will hear silence when waiting for your turn to speak. operator will unmute. >> you may al

europe will be frozen and will be subject to restrictions, according to information from the german dpaes above 200 individuals and companies will also export dual-use goods, here is a ban on the import of russian aluminum into there will be no europe, because this metal is extremely important for the aviation industry and construction, but while european officials are practicing taking new restrictive measures against our country, the economies of major european powers are not in the best position, this is not our statement, here... the minister finance of germany, mr. lindner, says that his country is becoming economically uncompetitive, and people are getting poorer. the minister of economy says that we are no longer competitive. otherwise they made themselves known, so let's go to let's see the best shots, last night large protests took place in several countries at once, the netherlands burned brightest, farmers blocked the highway on the border with belgium, this is actually footage of farmers blocking a major highway, the picture, frankly, with a light, there are fireworks and wh

dpa is somewhat different than what was described. >> can talk about the that interest costs?doesn't look like we are projecting that in the long run for the industry to be different. i guess what i'm saying is the term premium had gone up. to say that that episode will conclude that in the future so that premiums will be more elevated -- does that make sense? >> i got it. everyone else got it. if anything is unclear, we can come back to it. we do have higher rates in the forecast embodied in these projections than we did in the previous budget projections. of the impact on big interest outlays. you can think of that as two thirds resulting from the higher rates. there is a lengthy footnote in the report that goes from the two thirds, the one third. both the we can find it. if you look at our economic chapter, chapter two, hopefully that is very handy for everyone by the numbers document. you can see we do not get paid by the click for this. i hope everyone including our viewers on c-span be able to download it and look at it. it is a very handy document. you can see we do hav

>> i think what he wants to know is what governor kemp may have known from other participants in dpa.alled brad raffensperger in that infamous call on january 2nd or 3rd. we also now know that donald trump reached out to then georgia speaker david ralston, who has since passed away, and tried to get the legislature to do something. think what they want to know is what did you know about those conversations and to what extent did he try to reach you too and get you vfled in some sort of scheme to overturn the will of the people in your state and to send to congress an alternate or fake slate of lek torts that they could use to keep donald trump in power. >> i want to read just a little bit from the january 6th report on trump's pressure on kemp. on december 5, president trump traveled to georgia to headline a rally, but the president's day started with a call to brian kemp, during when they discussed reconvening the legislature in a special session. after the call, kemp took to twitter saying he had spoken to the president and told the president he supported the idea of and have alread

we have an inspector general, we have dpa, they're investigators, and we are a quasi, um, judicial body. so i don't want to cross particular lines. and i think when we get to particular comment later on that, um, an area that member wants us to look into, i'm going to cover that, um, with the investigation administrative versus possible criminal. so there's a lot of things that we can't necessarily draw conclusions from. and then there are particular things that preceded this particular administration. so i don't want to mix things up. and i want to be very clear about timeline and particular things and where we go, um, with this current administration and moving forward. and, and in light of the recent article about the arbitrator's decision, i'd like to see a presentation from the sheriff. well, we're going to get into that. get into that. and member mango already is has a particular comment, and i'm going to comment on that afterwards. okay. um, so those those items are noted. um, anything else? um, member nguyen, i know you had made submissions particular from the law enforcement, u

we have an inspector general, we have dpa, they're investigators, and we are a quasi, um, judicial body. so i don't want to cross particular lines. and i think when we get to particular comment later on that, um, an area that member wants us to look into, i'm going to cover that, um, with the investigation administrative versus possible criminal. so there's a lot of things that we can't necessarily draw conclusions from. and then there are particular things that preceded this particular administration. so i don't want to mix things up. and i want to be very clear about timeline and particular things and where we go, um, with this current administration and moving forward. and, and in light of the recent article about the arbitrator's decision, i'd like to see a presentation from the sheriff. well, we're going to get into that. get into that. and member mango already is has a particular comment, and i'm going to comment on that afterwards. okay. um, so those those items are noted. um, anything else? um, member nguyen, i know you had made submissions particular from the law enforcement, u

we want to make sure that as they come to and from they feel safe and live their every dpa lives. we will continue to work with per ins to get this work done. other thing briefly is to warn our most vulnerable community members about blessing scams this is a time of year where people try to that i can advantage of numbers of asian community knowing is a time when they offer guests to loved ones. i want to encourage everyone to avoid having contact with strangers about the gifts you are giving. we are working hard to per merwith self help for elder low. chinese new comers and organizations to educate and inform the commune about the dangers of blessing scams and also inform of when than i need to report when something happens. we will be there it make sure we prosecute those arrested for enengaging in the scams. again, help new year. so q.ed to be here now i will turn it to david chu. >> good afternoon. upon i think it is entirely appropriate after weeks of stormy weather the sun is shining on china town today. my son second grade class is visiting china town the first time this ho