i commissioner epler i. so that motion carries 5 to 0 and the appeal is denied. we are now moving on to item number six. this is appeal number 23. dash 053. bushra khan versus department of building inspection, planning department approval subject property 218 union street appealing the issuance on november 2nd, 2023 to john votruba of an alteration permit to comply with notice of violation number 20 2181 083 and planning enforcement case number 2021 006592. legalize the installation of privacy screens and seating on existing roof deck. urban garden approved under separate permit per 2015 018220 certificate of appropriateness. this is permit number. 202109239006. and we'll hear from the appellant's attorney. first, welcome. you have seven minutes. yes. my name is george benetatos. uh, commissioner lopez, vice president lindbergh, commissioners. uh, miss rosenberg, miss huber, uh, i'm representing, uh, bushra khan, the appellant here. uh, we're asking that the permit that was issued be rescinded. basically for two reasons. the first one is that, uh, mr. uh, mr. vo