. >> commissioner christian present and commissioner giraudo present. >> vice president guillermo and commissioner chow >> 2. approval of the minutes of the health commission finance and planning committee meeting of april 2, 2024. we have before you the minutes are there any any additions or deletions to the agenda? for the commissioners. >> seeing none, motion to approve the minutes. >> so moved. >> do i have a second? >> second. >> any public comment. >> let's see - any public comment in the room on this item? >> we have a public comment remotely and take public comment and have a statement to read after the comment everyone has limited to 3 minutes per speaker and i'll unmute you caller are you there? >> yeah. >> on the minutes called. >> yes. please given you have limited to 3 minutes per speaker mr. shaw. >> thank you. >> attorney advise regarding the lawsuit against - >> here we go we - here we go here we go. >> the minutes report that great just before the health commission met to levy attorney advise for the lawsuit concerned about the expert opinion in the executive director