okay, let's find out what our uh next guest thinks eman mckinny rejoins us, he's a eminent cynologist and nobel prize nominee who has written for the financial times and the economist he'. kenny, welcome back to the program, i guess there talked about a pretty dark scenario for israel in terms of recovery, if it can even do that, um, you have many different negative economic indicators that are impacting israel's economy, what are the chances of this recovery and what form you think it will take for israel to actually bounce back, i mean the groundwork is not there right now as we see it, yeah, well the the issue of the migrant workers is of course uh uh direct and critical because israel dependent uh paradox. on daily cheap labor of the palestinian sa the west bank and with crossing and i think also on on gaza and for for in the construction and service and what they will do and what they're already doing is just change the palestinian workers for people from india, sri lanka whatever they will look for other country bangladesh the will look for other countries and because that will