heritage capital president paul schatz. pawcialg okay, so i've always wondered about the 2%.the '70s, where it was 3% was de facto. but here we are, policy is built around this. you're suggesting that maybe within the halls of the federal reserve they'll learn to live with 3% even if they never officially say so. >> right. and, first of all, i agree with you, i don't think they've ever done one of those academic studies that the none of us understand and they conclude some number. charles: always take the abstract from them. i can kind of understand that a little bit and build a whole story around that. >> it's above my pay grade. [laughter] i think that in the general sense powell and his e friends say, look, we need a buffer away from deflation. deflation's way worse than the inflation. and 1%'s not a big enough buffer. i truly believe they just said, look, 2%'s a nice number, i don't think people will be that up happy, disappointed with 2% inflation. charles: right. >> but i think they're going to have to realize they're not getting there anytime soon without recession. ch

schatz. ice. mr. schmitt mr. schmitt mr. schumer, mr. scott of florida. mr. smith. ms. stabenow, mr. sullivan. mr. tester. ■r mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. mr. young. the presiding officer: on this vote, the yeas are 51, the nays are 47. the motion to table is agreed to. the presiding officer: the senator from oklahoma. mr. lankford: i move to concur on the house amendment to 1713. 882 with further amendment the presiding officer: the clerk will report. the clerk: the senator from oklahoma, mr. lankford, moves to concur on the house amendment to the senate amendment to h. h.r. 2882 with further amendment numbered 1713. the presiding officer: we have two minutes of debate equally divide. the senator from oklahoma. mr. lankford: mr. president, i rise today to ask my colleagues to support my amendment that would strike ear marc funding for -- earmark funding for a hospital that does chemical barringses well into the fifth month of pregnancy.

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch.[c mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio. mr. sanders. mr. schatz. mr. schmitt. mr. schumer. mr. scott of florida. mr. scott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. firm is firm is -- senators voting in the affirmative -- blackburn, boozman, braun, budd cassidy, cornyn cotton cramer ernst, grassley hagerty, hoeven johnson, kennedy, lankford lee, lummis hawley ricketts risch, rounds rubio, scott of florida, scott of south carolina wicker and young. senators voting in the negative -- baldwin, blument, booker brown, butler cantwell capito cardin kraerp collins, durbin, fetterman, fischer, hassan, hooirn -- hooirn king kelly, lujan, markey mcconnell, menendez merkley, moran, murray ossoff padilla, peters reed sanders, schatz sinema shaheen stabenow teste warnock, warren wellch and whitehouse. duckworth, no. mr. wyden, no. mr. thune,

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio. mr. sanders. mr. schatz.hmitt. mr. schumer. mrsc mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. eh. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. mr. young.■y the presiding officer: on this vote the yeas are 47. the nays are 51. the motion is not agreed to. a senator: mr. president. the presiding officer: the senator fromlina. a senator: thank you, mr. president. let me be clear. the amendment i'm offering prevents illegal aliens who commit the crime of burglary, theft or shoplifting from being granted legal status or citizenship. this is particularly relevant in the case of laken riley where the illegal alien w murdered her had previously been arrested for those crimes. mr. budd: the american people need to know who stands on the side of preventing tragedies and who will now, i know my democrat colleagues are fearful, perhaps squeamish to prevent immigration issues from being voted on

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch.mr ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio. mr. sanders. mr. schatz. mr. schmitt. mr. schumer. mr. scott of florida. mr. scott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune.; the clerk: mr. blumenthal, aye. the clerk: ms. lummis, no. mr. murphy, aye. mr. cotton, no.>@ the clerk: mr. hagerty, no. mr. johnson, no. the clerk: mr. mcconnell, aye. mr. cardin, aye. the clerk: ms. ernst, no. the clerk: mr. hoeven, no. the clerk: ms. hassan, aye. the clerk: mr. warnock, aye. the clerk: mr. fetterman, aye. the clerk: ms. stabenow, aye. booker, aye. the clerk: mr. young, no. mr. paul, no. ms. murkowski, aye. ms. cortez masto, aye. mr. sullivan, no. mr. van hollen, aye. mr. moran, no. the clerk: mr. lujan, aye. the clerk: mr. rubio, no. mr. schmitt, no. mr. barasso, no. vote: the clerk: mr. risch, no. mr. cruz, no. the clerk: mr. brown, aye. mr. scott of south carolina no. ms. rosen, aye. the clerk: mrs. blackburn, no. the clerk: mr. manchin, aye. mr. graham aye. mr. schatz aye. the

schatz, aye. the clerk: ms. stabenow aye. ms. collins, no. the clerk: mr. scott of south carolina no. the clerk: mr. paul, no the clerk: mr. ricketts the clerk: mr. no. the clerk: ms. sinema, aye.:b the clerk: ms. hirono aye. mr. murphy aye. mr. vance, no« the clerk: mrs. blackburn, no. the clerk: ms. murkowski, no. mr. brown, aye. the clerk: mrs. gillibrand, aye. the clerk: mr. sanders, aye. the clerk: mr. hagerty, no. the clerk: mr. moran, no. the clerk: mr. sullivan, no. the clerk: mr. lujan, aye. the clerk: mr. scott of florida no. mr. whitehouse, aye. the clerk: mr. manchin, no. the presiding officer: have all senators voted? does any senator wish to change his or vote? if not the yeas are 50 the nays are 49. the nomination is confirmed. under the previous order, the motion to reconsider is considered made and laid upon the table and the president will be immediately notified of the senate's action. the clerk will report the motion to invoke cloture. the clerk: we, the undersigned senators, in accordance with the provisions of rule 22 of the standing r

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch. mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr.hatz. mr. schmitt. mr. schumer. mr. scott of florida. mr. scott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. mr. young. senators voting in the affirmative -- butler, coons, hawley, lujan, schmitt, and wyden. -- mrs. blackburn, aye. senators voting in the negative -- cornyn, cramer,s kennedy, paul, and wicker.éÑ the clerk: mr. merkley, aye. mr. grassley, no. the clerk: ms. sinema, aye. the clerk: mr. crapo, aye.u vote: the clerk: mrs. gillibrand, aye. the clerk: mrs. fischer, no. mr. peters, aye. the clerk: mr. marshall, aye. the clerk: ms. rosen, aye. mr. rounds, aye. the clerk: ms. cortez masto, aye. the clerk: mr. moran the clerk: mr. tester, aye. ms. klobuchar, aye. the clerk: mr. blumenthal, aye. mr. ossoff, aye. the clerk: mr. welch, aye. mr. hagerty, aye. mr. whitehouse, aye. the

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch. mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr.. mr. sanders. mr. schatz. mr. schmitt. mr. hu mr. scott of florida. mr. scott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen.6ç ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. mr. young.■e ■k the clerk: senators voting in the affirmative -- baldwin, bennet, blumenthal, cantwell, carper, casey, cortez masto, durbin, gillibrand, hassan, heinrich, hickenlooper, kelly, king, klobuchar,, murray, ossoff, padilla, rosen, schatz, schumer, shaheen, smith and wyden. senators voting in the negative -- barrasso, blackburn, braun, capito, cassidy, collins, cornyn, cotton, cramer, daines, ns hyde-smith, johnson, kennedy, lankford, lee, mcconnell, murkowski, rubio, scott of florida, sinema, thune, tillis, tuberville, and young. mr. sullivan, no. lankford vote: the clerk: mr. crapo, no."4 the clerk: mr. marshall, no. mr. schmitt, no. the clerk: mr. tester, aye. t

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch. mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio. mr. sanders.. schatz. mr. schmitt. mr. schumer. mr. scott of florida. mr. scott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. mr. young.tors voting in the affirmative -- brown, butler, cantwell, carper, casey, durbin, hassan, king, klobuchar, menendez, murphy, padilla, peters, sinema, smith, stabenow, warnock. senators voting in the negative -- britt, budd, cassidy, collins, cornyn, crapo, fischer, grassley, hagerty, hoeven, johnson, kennedy, lankford, lee, manchin, marshall, mcconnell, moran, ul, ricketts, risch, schmitt, scott of florida, thune, tillis, vance,■á ms. lummis, no. ms. duckworth, aye. mrs. murray, aye. ms. warren, aye. ■8■■ the clerk:blumenthal, aye. the clerk: mrs. hyde-smith, no.: mr. welch, aye. mr. heinrich, aye. the clerk: ms. hirono, aye. the clerk: mr. lujan, aye. the clerk: mr. reed, aye.

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch. mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio.mr. sanders. mr. schatz. mr. schmitt. mr. schumer. mr. scott of florida. mr. scott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden.ung. the clerk: senators voting in the affirmative -- baldwin, booker, duckworth, fetterman, heinrich, kaine lujan, murray, padilla schatz, sinema tester. senators voting in the negative -- cassidy, fischer, hager hoeven manchin,s romney, tuberville. the clerk: mr. menendez, aye. the clerk: ms. ernst, no. the clerk: ms. butler, aye. the clerk: mr. hawley, no. the clerk: mr. welch, aye. the clerk: mr. barrasso, no. mr. ossoff, aye. the clerk: mr. marshall no. mr. kennedy, no. the clerk: mr. vance, no. thnson, no. the clerk: mr. gillibrand, aye. the clerk: ms. hirono, i do not. -- ms. hirono, aye. mr. reed, aye. mr. grassley, no. the clerk: mr. ricketts, no. the

paul. mr. ters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch. mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio.ott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. the clerk: senators voting in the affirmative -- blumenthal, casey, duckworth, heinrich, hickenlooper, markey, menendez, whitehouse. mr. lujan, aye. senators voting in the negative -- britt,■6■! budd, cotton, graham, lee, rounds, schmitt, tillis, tuberville, and young. mr. ricketts, no. mr. king, aye. the clerk: ms. collins, no. mr. risch, no. vote: the clerk: mr. reed, aye. the clerk: mr. warnock, aye. the clerk: mr. no. ms. stabenow, aye.Ñ the clerk: mr. boo a■ mr. fetterman, aye.og■"■x the clerk: mrs. gillibrand, aye. the clerk: mr. lankford, no.9p ms. cantwell, aye.+u mr. sullivan, no. the clerk: mr. cornyn, no.1z the clerk: mr. merkley, aye. mrs the clerk: mr. crapo, no. the clerk: mr. coons, aye. mr. scott of florida, no. the clerk

schatz. mr. schmitt. mr. schumer. fda. mr. scott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms.mith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. mr. young. senators voting in the affirmative -- boozman,braun, britt, cortez masto, cotton cramer grassley kluchar, lankford manchin, murkowski, rubio, schatz smith, tuberville and young. butler heinrich kaine, mendendez, murphy, stabenow and warner. mr. booker, no. . collins, aye. the clerk: mr. scott of florida, aye. mr. vance, aye. tillis, aye. the clerk: mr. romney, aye. ms. hassan, aye. rounds, aye. mr. reed, aye. mr. wicker, aye. the clerk: ms. ernst, aye. mr. crapo, aye. the clerk: mr. cassidy, no. e clerk: mr. casey, no. mr. merkley, aye. mr. hoeven, aye. mrs. gillibrand, aye. the clerk: mr. welch, no. ms. hirono, aye. the clerk: mrs. hyde-smith, aye. the clerk: mr.risch, aye. the clerk: mr. marshall, aye. u" the clerk: mr. durbin, no.(ú the clerk: mr. the clerk: ms. aye . the clerk: mr. peters, aye. vl the clerk

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch. mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio. óh vote: p% the clerk: mr. sanders, mr. schatz, mr. schmitt, mr. scott of florida. mr. scott of south carolina. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. mr. young. the clerk: senators voting in the affirmative -- brown, cardin duckworth, gillibrand king lujan, markey merkley, rosen, shaheen, smith, van hollen warner whitehouse. senators voting in the negative -- blackburn, britt, cotton crapo, grassley hagerty, hyde-smith marshall moran, murkowski, paul romney rubio, tubervillewicker. ms. collins, no. the clerk: mr. tester, aye. mr. scott of south carolina, no. fischer no. mr. daines, no. mr. welch, aye. mr. kennedy, no. mrs. capito, no. ms. ernst, no. the clerk: mr. murphy, aye. mr. carper, aye. tillis, no.cornyn, no. mr. hawley, no. the clerk: mr. johnson, no. mr. thune, no. mr. the clerk: mr. barrasso, no. mr. coons, aye. the clerk: mr. ma

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch. mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio.a. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. the clerk: mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. mr. young. ,f vote: the presiding officer: senators voting in the affirmative -- cardin, coons, cotton, duckworth, kaine, manchin, markey, menendez, reed, ricketts, shaheen, sinema, tester, warner, welch. senators voting in the negative -- crapo, grassley, kennedy, mullin, rubio, scott of florida, vance. the clerk: mr. merkley, aye. mr. heinrich, aye. mr. casey, aye. mr. cantwell, aye.n ms. cantwell. aye. the clerk: mr. tuberville, no. the clerk: mr. carper, aye. the clerk: mrs. blackburn, no. the clerk: mrs. gillibrand, aye. the clerk: mr. tillis, no. mr. schatz, aye. mr. graham, aye. the clerk: mr. cornyn, aye.fisc. ms. butler, aye. the clerk: mr. daines, no. the clerk: mr. van hollen, aye. the clerk: mr. thune, no. the clerk: ms. cortez masto,

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch. mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio.llivan. mr. tester. mr. thune.p÷ mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. the clerk: mr. wyden. mr. young. senators voting in the affirmative -- butler, duckworth, merkley, reed, rosen, rounds, te te tester. nato grassley, paul, vance, wicker, young. mr. romney, no. ms. ernst, no. mrs. capito no. mrs. fischer, no. mr. barrasso, no.1i the clerk:r. daines, no. mr. mrs.britt, no. the clerk: ms. cantwell, aye. mr. hickenlooper, aye. the clerk: mr. lujan, aye. the clerk: mr. tillis, aye. ■3 9 the clerk: mr. peters, aye. the clerk: ms. hirono, aye. mr. johnson, no. the clerk: mr. hawley, no. the clerk: mr. wyden, aye.■ú>7■< the clerk: mr. carper, aye.■k the clerk: mr. budd, no. mr. markey, aye.■0■" the clerk: mr. cardin, aye.■ the clerk: mr. van hollen, aye.k the clerk: mr. graham, aye. mr. kaine, aye. mr. mcconnell, aye. the clerk: mr. marshall, no. the clerk: ms. collins, aye. mr. tuberville, no.mr. heinrich. mr. ricketts, no

schatz. mr. schmitt. mr. schumer. mr. scott of florida.ina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith.ille. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. mr. young. the clerk: snirm snirm bennet, booker, butler, cortez masto, gillibrand, hassan heinrich, king, manchin, merkley, padilla, smith, welch, and whitehouse. senators voting in the negative -- braun, marshall, scott ofvance, and wicker. mrs.cg capito, no. mr. durbin, aye. ms. warren, aye. hickenlooper, aye. mr. warnock, aye. mr. peters, aye. the clerk: mr. tuberville, no. the clerk: mr. schmitt, no. the clerk: mrs. blackburn, no. mr. cassidy, no. mr. warner, aye. vote:bi the clerk: mr. schumer, aye. the clerk: mr. blumenthal, aye. mr. barrasso, no. mr. cotton, no. the clerk: mr. kaine, aye. mr. wyden, aye. mr. reed, aye. the clerk: mr. the clerk: m. the clerk: mr. kelly, aye. mr. graham, no. the clerk: mr. mendendez, aye. mr. carper, aye. ■n the clerk: mr. lee, no. the clerk: mr. rubio, no. mr. rounds, no. the clerk: ms. ernst, no. mr. ossoff, aye. the clerk: ms

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch.ey. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio. mr.anders. mr. schatz. mr. schmitt. mr. schumer. mr. scott of florida. mr. scott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville.llen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. the clerk: senators voting in the affirmative -- baldwin, cornyn, crapo, daines duckworth graham grassley hassan heinrich manchin, merkley, ossoff reed ricketts schatz sinemane and tillis. mr. tuberville voted in the negative. ms. collins, aye. when whitehouse, aye. -- mr. whitehouse, aye. mr. casey, aye.dé the clerk: mr. rubio aye. mr. smith aye mr. wyden aye, mr.clerk: mrs. capito, aye. the clerk: mr. johnson, aye. mr. vance, mr. warnock, aye. the clerk: mr. cramer, aye. the clerk: mrs. shaheen, aye. the clerk: mr. brown, aye. the clerk: ms. butler, aye. mr. mullin, aye. mr. lujan, aye. ms. warren, aye. mr. mr. lee, aye. mr. tester, aye. mr. lankford, aye. mr. schmitt, no. m

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch. mr. romney. ms. rosen. mr. rounds. mr. rubio. mr. sanders. mr. schatz. mr. schmitt. mr. schumer. mr. scott of florida. mr. scott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. rville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wyden. mr. young. senators voting in the affirmative -- baldwin, ben blumenthal butler cantwell coons cortez masto, duckworth, durbin graham hassan heinrich, lujan murray padilla peters schatz schumer, smith, and welch. senators voting in the negative -- barrasso blackburn britt, capito cotton crapo, cruz daines ernst, hagerty, kennedy, lankford lowell miss mcconnell, ricketts, rounds scott of south carolina thune and wicker. mr. tester, aye. ms. warren, aye. the clerk: mr. tuberville, no. mr. brown, aye. the clerk: ms. murkowski, aye. the clerk: mrs. gillibrand aye. mr. booker, aye. mr. warnock, aye. mr. carper, aye. the clerk: mr. king, aye. the clerk: ms. klobuchar, aye. mr. ossoff, aye. the clerk: ms. rosen, aye. ms. hirono, aye. the clerk: mr

paul. mr. peters. mr. reed. mr. ricketts. mr. risch. mr. romney. ms. rose mr. rounds. mr. rubio.mr. sanders. mr. schatz. mr. schumer. mr. scott of florida. mr. scott of south carolina. mrs. shaheen. ms. sinema. ms. smith. ms. stabenow. mr. sullivan. mr. tester. mr. thune. mr. tillis. mr. tuberville. mr. van hollen. mr. vance. mr. warner. mr. warnock. ms. warren. mr. welch. mr. whitehouse. mr. wicker. mr. wyden. mr. young. the clerk: senators voting in the affirmative -- bennet blumenthal booker cardin cassidy, collins, coons cortez masto, durbin heinrich, hickenlooper smite smith, king, merkley, murray ossoff, peters, romney rosen, sanders, schatz sinema smith, stabenow tester, van hollen warnock, warren welch, wicker and young. mrs. menendez -- mr. menendez aye. ms. cantwell, aye u senators voting in the negative -- barrasso braun, budd crapo, cruz daines, graham hawley kennedy, lee, lummis paul rubio, scott of florida tuberville, and vance. ms. hassan, aye. ms. butler, aye. the clerk: ms. duckworth, aye. the clerk: mr. schmitt, no. the clerk: mr. kelly, aye. mr. johnson, no. th