0
0.0
Feb 1, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
this jury is made up of people from this community, oxford, pontiac, michigan. so, that is something to take into consideration here and so a lot of jurors may say, my husband handles the guns. i do understand that. so, they may say that's the way it is done in our house, too. >> is it incumbent on her to -- since it is in her house and she has the awareness of the purchase and of the use -- to take more of an active role? >> you would think. obviously, there isn't a law that says if you have a gun in your house you must do this. but it's curious to me that she says guns aren't her thing. she knows that her son has a gun. she doesn't know where the gun is. she testified the gun may be in the bedroom where the lock to the case may be in a beer stein in the kitchen. she wasn't clear about that. it strikes me and i think jurors sitting there are going to wonder, how come this mother didn't mention to the school in this meeting? we did get that gun for even for christmas and we want to make sure that given these drawings and what you have told us that the gun is sti
this jury is made up of people from this community, oxford, pontiac, michigan. so, that is something to take into consideration here and so a lot of jurors may say, my husband handles the guns. i do understand that. so, they may say that's the way it is done in our house, too. >> is it incumbent on her to -- since it is in her house and she has the awareness of the purchase and of the use -- to take more of an active role? >> you would think. obviously, there isn't a law that says...
0
0.0
Feb 1, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
. >>> we continue to track live developments out of this courtroom in pontiac, michigan where jennifer crumbley is now going through facebook posts with the defense who is trying to describe her relationship with her son and family activities that they shared. we are of course going to keep monitoring what is unfolding in court, but we want to get some perspective now. we have with us cnn correspondent jeanne casarez who's been tracking this case very closely. jeanne, what stands out to you about what the defense has shown so far? they've asked a lot about her personal life. >> front in center showing the other side of the story, showing that this was a normal family. you've got jurors who are watching this inches away, and many of them are parents. watching this about the holidays and what they do, and what their son did, and the disciplinary -- not disciplinary, but he wouldn't do his math work sheet, and things like that. it's relate-able. and as far as her demeanor, she's not emotional. we saw her very emotional this morning but she appeared to be very honest to talk about, she was
. >>> we continue to track live developments out of this courtroom in pontiac, michigan where jennifer crumbley is now going through facebook posts with the defense who is trying to describe her relationship with her son and family activities that they shared. we are of course going to keep monitoring what is unfolding in court, but we want to get some perspective now. we have with us cnn correspondent jeanne casarez who's been tracking this case very closely. jeanne, what stands out...
0
0.0
Feb 7, 2024
02/24
by
KPIX
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
the montana and 49er coming out super bowl was at the pontiac silverdome. >> san francisco, what a remarkable was and still remains the highest rated super bowl of all time. >> cbs sports brings you super bowl xxi. >> let's go to 1987. our guy, phil sims, rose bowl in california. >> sims. there's mcconky's touchdown. >> we talked about how you can't be perfect. that's about as close to perfect as anyone could ever come. 22 of 25 passing that day. this was the debut, by the way -- where are you going, phil? i'm going to disney world. >> phil sims, you've just won the super bowl. what are you doing next? >> i'm going to go to disney world. >> reporter: phil was the first person to ever utter that phrase. >> he was the friend setter for that? >> he was the very first. >> super bowl xxxviii, the carolina panthers and the new england patriots. >> tom brady and the patriots. this helped kick off. >> from 41 years. looks good. >> we had them down in houston at super bowl xxxviii, and the brady dynasty, whatever you want to call it, was really starting to rev up its engines. oh, my gosh. who's this g
the montana and 49er coming out super bowl was at the pontiac silverdome. >> san francisco, what a remarkable was and still remains the highest rated super bowl of all time. >> cbs sports brings you super bowl xxi. >> let's go to 1987. our guy, phil sims, rose bowl in california. >> sims. there's mcconky's touchdown. >> we talked about how you can't be perfect. that's about as close to perfect as anyone could ever come. 22 of 25 passing that day. this was the...
0
0.0
Feb 1, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
we will take a quick break and on the other side we will get into the very latest from pontiac michigan and what could be a historic trial. stay with cnn. >>> breaking news into cnn, we have been tracking a case that is testing the limits of potential criminal liability for parents whose children are involved in school shootings. jennifer crumbley, the mother of the michigan high school shooter has been testifying in her own defense, some really revealing moments in court about her personal life and her thoughts about what her son was going through in the months before the shooting and the same day that the shooting took place. >> so much of what she is saying, it certainly looks very different through the prism of what we know now. there are questions about whether she knew enough, right? that she could have intervened at the time and there is this question of the access to the gun, which she has been very much been pushing off to her husband. who will face trial next month. ignoring the mental health needs of her son, ethan crumbley. the meeting at the s
we will take a quick break and on the other side we will get into the very latest from pontiac michigan and what could be a historic trial. stay with cnn. >>> breaking news into cnn, we have been tracking a case that is testing the limits of potential criminal liability for parents whose children are involved in school shootings. jennifer crumbley, the mother of the michigan high school shooter has been testifying in her own defense, some really revealing moments in court about her...
0
0.0
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> trevor ault abc news, pontiac , michigan a federal ruling affects affecting ivy league athletes may have major consequences in college sports. >> that ruling says dartmouth men's basketball players are school employees, meaning they can join a union unionizing would allow them to negotiate over salaries and working conditions and other issues. the ncaa and college officials have maintained that athletes are are students. >> actor jacob elordi is the focus of an assault investigation in his native australia. elordi is accused of pushing and then putting his hands on the throat of a radio producer. on monday. the incident reportedly happened after the actor, as a prank, was asked for some of his bathwater, a reference to a scene from a lord's movie. saltburn elordi's representatives have not commented publicly on the reports coming up. >> the annual rite of passage in the countdown to the super bowl, some of the most notable antics from this year's opening night and later, the crazy antics involving apple's newest gadget. >> wait, what? yeah, could this be a sign of things to come
. >> trevor ault abc news, pontiac , michigan a federal ruling affects affecting ivy league athletes may have major consequences in college sports. >> that ruling says dartmouth men's basketball players are school employees, meaning they can join a union unionizing would allow them to negotiate over salaries and working conditions and other issues. the ncaa and college officials have maintained that athletes are are students. >> actor jacob elordi is the focus of an assault...
0
0.0
Feb 6, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
we actually have some fresh sound in from pontiac, michigan. craig schilling, the father of 17 year old justin shilling, was just speaking to reporters. justin, was, of course killed in the oxford high school shooting. let's listen to this father talk after this verdict. >> it was a long time coming, but it's definitely a step towards accountability, like what we were talking about. it's kind of been our goal the whole time. it was tough, but waiting out, for sure. there was a lot of emotion back here, in the courtroom, it's definitely going to resonate with me for a while. and i hope at all be able to come down and get some sense of good feeling, but it's not really a good feeling. it's not really about winning or losing. it's about making its apparent that all of this has to stop in society, and you know what? it's going to go all the way now. there's no way to look the other way. you have to address things at every level. and it's very clear now. >> what do you think the messages to parents, as well as school officials across the country? >>
we actually have some fresh sound in from pontiac, michigan. craig schilling, the father of 17 year old justin shilling, was just speaking to reporters. justin, was, of course killed in the oxford high school shooting. let's listen to this father talk after this verdict. >> it was a long time coming, but it's definitely a step towards accountability, like what we were talking about. it's kind of been our goal the whole time. it was tough, but waiting out, for sure. there was a lot of...
0
0.0
Feb 6, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
nbc's adrienne broaddus is outside the courthouse for us in pontiac, michigan. paul butler, former federal prosecutor and msnbc legal analyst, also back with me is msnbc's lisa rubin. adrienne, what do we know? >> reporter: well, we know we got the 15-minute warning at 1:13 and it has been 15 minutes so we should hear that verdict from members of the jury at any minute. this after two days of deliberation. on friday, we heard the closing argument. the members of the jury are six men, six women, one black person. yesterday we know they had two questions, there were no questions from members of the jury today. you see on your screen right now, jennifer crumbley walking into the courthouse, where she will learn her fate. she is facing four counts of involuntary manslaughter. and there was a question from members of the jury yesterday about the definition of involuntary manslaughter. there was also a question about how the shooter obtained the gun. and for those of you who may not be familiar with this trial, prosecutors laid out a case, and showed evidence, tried t
nbc's adrienne broaddus is outside the courthouse for us in pontiac, michigan. paul butler, former federal prosecutor and msnbc legal analyst, also back with me is msnbc's lisa rubin. adrienne, what do we know? >> reporter: well, we know we got the 15-minute warning at 1:13 and it has been 15 minutes so we should hear that verdict from members of the jury at any minute. this after two days of deliberation. on friday, we heard the closing argument. the members of the jury are six men, six...
0
0.0
Feb 2, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> nbc's maggie vespa is joining us from pontiac, michigan.k to us about what we expect today. >> reporter: yeah, so ana, as you said she just took the stand moments ago. essentially what we expect is first thing prosecution will begin their cross examination of america's first parent to ever be charged with crimes tied to the mass school shooting committed by their child. the prosecution expect to kind of drill down on their core argument. it's been their core argument this entire time that jennifer crumbley willfully ignored and they say flagrantly ignored criminally they believe clear warning signs that their son was strug wlg his mental health, he was having violent thoughts, exhibiting violent behavior and decliing to get him when he asked. yesterday it was the defense's turn. she was their first witness called. she was on the stand being questioned by her attorneys and essentially she said that she and her son had a close relationship. i thought he could come to me about anything. he had come to me about his concerns about anxiety but ab
. >> nbc's maggie vespa is joining us from pontiac, michigan.k to us about what we expect today. >> reporter: yeah, so ana, as you said she just took the stand moments ago. essentially what we expect is first thing prosecution will begin their cross examination of america's first parent to ever be charged with crimes tied to the mass school shooting committed by their child. the prosecution expect to kind of drill down on their core argument. it's been their core argument this...
0
0.0
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
it took him several years to transform a pontiac firebird trans them into the night industries 2015 color c and the other parts are handmade or do i bent and welded all the metals best. the hardest part about duplicating the car was always making the parts the scale. if you had thing was a, you can't get any construction plans. get off all i had to go on were screenshots from the series stand, freeze frames, rulers and excel tables. to calculate the measurements of the car. ok, that was it. as you see, a pond has recreated a 1000 movie, cars and steel and 10 from popular movies and tv shows adding more every year. he's got the full support of his family for projects that are always experiments. also challenges taking on something new and overcoming new, limited email. everyone asks me if i've got a plan, how i proceed. i tell them no plans. well, can i just take a piece of metal and a welding, torch of flex, predict, and see what comes of the most comfortable. what comes of it? our faithful reproductions, especially of cars that wrote film and t. v. history in the 1980s, like the cadillac
it took him several years to transform a pontiac firebird trans them into the night industries 2015 color c and the other parts are handmade or do i bent and welded all the metals best. the hardest part about duplicating the car was always making the parts the scale. if you had thing was a, you can't get any construction plans. get off all i had to go on were screenshots from the series stand, freeze frames, rulers and excel tables. to calculate the measurements of the car. ok, that was it. as...
0
0.0
Feb 29, 2024
02/24
by
COM
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
must have been wild cutting class to snort car grease in the abandoned pontiac factory. >> michael: ohu guys had it so good in the west. selling tulip bulbs so you could buy tickets to minor league west michigan whitecaps games. >> you take the name of the west michigan whitecaps out of your mouth, thumb boy! >> michael: okay, jordan, let's put our obviously universal michigan references aside for the moment and focus in on the primary. it seems like a lot of democrats expressed dissatisfaction yesterday. >> true, michael. but that embodies the beauty of our democracy. no matter who you are or where you come from, in our country, you will be heard. as long as you live in a swing state. [cheers and applause] states? that's only, like, ten states! >> not at all. five max. michigan, wisconsin, pennsylvania, georgia, and sometimes arizona. everything else might as well be canada. >> michael: okay, well, what about people who live in new york? >> they can shut the [bleep] up. no one gives a shit what those people think. >> michael: okay, i see what you're saying. so really we michiganders h
must have been wild cutting class to snort car grease in the abandoned pontiac factory. >> michael: ohu guys had it so good in the west. selling tulip bulbs so you could buy tickets to minor league west michigan whitecaps games. >> you take the name of the west michigan whitecaps out of your mouth, thumb boy! >> michael: okay, jordan, let's put our obviously universal michigan references aside for the moment and focus in on the primary. it seems like a lot of democrats...
0
0.0
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> trevor ault, abc news, pontiac, michigan trevor, thanks very much. >> wall street will be paying's say an unexpectedly weak report that could push the fed to cut interest rates soon. >> also today, apple's new vision pro headset goes on sale. the apple store on new york's fifth avenue adding a special neon display to its famous cube exterior for the release. the headset is apple's first new product category since 2014. yes, it has been that long. more than 200,000 of them have been sold since preorders started. remember they cost $3,500. you guys getting one? getting a pair? >> absolutely not. >> at least not yet. devices. that's all i need is my screen right here. my eyes 3500 bucks. >> also. >> that too. >> all right. now to northern kentucky. and a case of persistent. it's paying off. >> you know what? maybe they can get some apple vision pros. yeah. >> now that they won the lotto. >> years of hope. finally ended with a big payday for staff at a middle school. danny, new. had they do this well by forming a team, which is what we need to do. >> you need a cool name though for y
. >> trevor ault, abc news, pontiac, michigan trevor, thanks very much. >> wall street will be paying's say an unexpectedly weak report that could push the fed to cut interest rates soon. >> also today, apple's new vision pro headset goes on sale. the apple store on new york's fifth avenue adding a special neon display to its famous cube exterior for the release. the headset is apple's first new product category since 2014. yes, it has been that long. more than 200,000 of them...
41
41
Feb 6, 2024
02/24
by
KPIX
tv
eye 41
favorite 0
quote 1
cbs's elaine quijano reports from pontiac, michigan. >> we find the defendant guilty of involuntary manslaughterorter: jennifer crumbley closed her eyes at times as the decision was read. kreg schilling was there. his son, justin, was killed in the massacre. >> with this verdict, i mean, it will carry a lot of weight with it. it will definitely get people thinking. >> reporter: the jury foreperson said their decision came down to a single factor. >> the thing that really hammered it home is that she was the last adult with the gun. >> reporter: it was in november of 2021 when crumbley's then-15-year-old son even shot and killed four students at oxford high school. madisyn baldwin, tate myre, justin shilling, and hana st. juliana. seven other people were wounded. after the shooting, crumble and her husband fled. they were found hiding in a detroit industrial building, as officers closed in. >> we have a mountain of evidence. >> reporter: prosecutors had argued jennifer crumbley failed to address her son's deteriorating mental health before the shooting, allowed him to have a gun despite signs he
cbs's elaine quijano reports from pontiac, michigan. >> we find the defendant guilty of involuntary manslaughterorter: jennifer crumbley closed her eyes at times as the decision was read. kreg schilling was there. his son, justin, was killed in the massacre. >> with this verdict, i mean, it will carry a lot of weight with it. it will definitely get people thinking. >> reporter: the jury foreperson said their decision came down to a single factor. >> the thing that really...
0
0.0
Feb 7, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
from pontiac, michigan, jean casarez. cnn hearing from the jury. >> reporter: that's right. it's interesting what the foreperson is saying. the jury deliberated over ten hours. this is a community that's lived with this mass school shooting for two years now. cnn did speak with the foreperson as she was coming out of the courthouse yesterday. she said several things. first of all, she said that both sides were very well represented in that jury room. that is obvious, there were two sides to this. people for not guilty. we know what happened in the end. she said lives were in the balance with this verdict. lives, plural. that's interesting. as to the question of, how did you reach the unanimous verdict of guilty? here's what she said. >> the thing that hammered it home was she was the last one that had the gun. >> she was the last person that had the gun. now, remember, she and ethan went to the shooting range on saturday, practicing with the gun. james was delivering door dash. she he was not able to go. remember that jury question they had. it was, can we infer evidence tha
from pontiac, michigan, jean casarez. cnn hearing from the jury. >> reporter: that's right. it's interesting what the foreperson is saying. the jury deliberated over ten hours. this is a community that's lived with this mass school shooting for two years now. cnn did speak with the foreperson as she was coming out of the courthouse yesterday. she said several things. first of all, she said that both sides were very well represented in that jury room. that is obvious, there were two sides...
0
0.0
Feb 5, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> jean casarez in pontiac, thanks very much. >> so we're very much waiting for the jury to come out speak. joining us now is legal affairs commentator areva martin. i know you've been following this. how much will jennifer crumb p be jennifer crumbley's testimony affect the jury? >> typically defendants don't take the witness stand out of concern that on cross-examination they may be hung up with respect to certain testimony. i think her testimony in this case will be critical, but i also think that the witnesses that were not there on her behalf are also going to weigh into how jurors think about this case. you had 21 witnesses presented by the prosecution and the defense only called one person and that was jennifer crumbley. i think some of those jurors will be asking how come there weren't other people that came into court to testify to some of the things we heard about jennifer, particularly as her lawyer pride to paint this picture of her having this very, very close relationship with her son. >> that choice by the defense team of having jennifer crumbley be the only witness ca
. >> jean casarez in pontiac, thanks very much. >> so we're very much waiting for the jury to come out speak. joining us now is legal affairs commentator areva martin. i know you've been following this. how much will jennifer crumb p be jennifer crumbley's testimony affect the jury? >> typically defendants don't take the witness stand out of concern that on cross-examination they may be hung up with respect to certain testimony. i think her testimony in this case will be...
0
0.0
Feb 6, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
joining us is jean casarez in pontiac, michigan, and with me in new york in the studio, defense attorneyth of you. i'll start with you, jean. what can you tell us about what the jury -- they've only deliberated six hours, but six hours is something. now they're going into day two. what do you know? >> reporter: i can confirm we just learned they are deliberating, so this jury has started their second day of deliberations here at the oakland county circuit courthouse. and the questions yesterday, there were two of them, and they were really smart questions, sara. i mean, they were going to the heart of the material, and they really wanted to understand the legalese of all of this. you know, involuntary manslaughter is the only charge. there are no lesser-includeds at all. but the prosecution has two theories of involuntary manslaughter, and jurors don't have to be unanimous on what theory they believe beyond a reasonable doubt for its conviction. they just have to be unanimous that they all believe there should be a conviction here. the first theory is gross negligence, and the first elem
joining us is jean casarez in pontiac, michigan, and with me in new york in the studio, defense attorneyth of you. i'll start with you, jean. what can you tell us about what the jury -- they've only deliberated six hours, but six hours is something. now they're going into day two. what do you know? >> reporter: i can confirm we just learned they are deliberating, so this jury has started their second day of deliberations here at the oakland county circuit courthouse. and the questions...
0
0.0
Feb 5, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
jean casarez is in pontiac, michigan, for the jury instruction and the verdict watch, which will begin right now. jean, what are you seeing? >> reporter: pivotal moment, pivotal day, john. what's happening right now, jury is coming in, the judge will instruct them on the law so that when they go in to deliberate, this is law they must follow. was there gross negligence on the part of jennifer crumbley of a known risk that her son could commit a mass murder. was it foreseeable. should she have realized her son could commit a mass murder. the judge, before the jury came in, told the attorneys that the gag order that has been in place from almost the beginning, will stay in place until after james crumbley's trial. i want you to listen to some of those very strong -- on both sides -- closing arguments from friday. >> what i prove is not that she knew her son would shoot up the school. i have to prove that she had a legal duty, she negligently performed that legal duty, she negligently did not take steps to take care and protect the other children in that school when there was a reasonable
jean casarez is in pontiac, michigan, for the jury instruction and the verdict watch, which will begin right now. jean, what are you seeing? >> reporter: pivotal moment, pivotal day, john. what's happening right now, jury is coming in, the judge will instruct them on the law so that when they go in to deliberate, this is law they must follow. was there gross negligence on the part of jennifer crumbley of a known risk that her son could commit a mass murder. was it foreseeable. should she...
0
0.0
Feb 1, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
all of that as this new poll from pontiac university shows president biden with 50% in a head to head general election matchup trump with a 44%. that's a six-point lead among registered voters outside the pole margin of error. and more than a month after the same poll found the race, quote, too close to call. one big factor the poll says more women now support president biden. >> legendary democratic strategist, james carville is with us now. james, great to see you. >> thank you, man, thank you. >> you've been nervous. to say the least, about this election. how nervous and -- >> i was pretty good. that's the first good pull of seen in a while. of, course you'd like to see another. one that's to kind of come from. it, but given the recent events with president trump's legal issues, and some of these economic numbers that we have, seen it is not unreasonable to assume there could be a turn in the political opinion. i can wait to see some confirming polls here but it's pretty heartening. >> some people have speculated that one trumpery comes the clear republican nominee which he is more
all of that as this new poll from pontiac university shows president biden with 50% in a head to head general election matchup trump with a 44%. that's a six-point lead among registered voters outside the pole margin of error. and more than a month after the same poll found the race, quote, too close to call. one big factor the poll says more women now support president biden. >> legendary democratic strategist, james carville is with us now. james, great to see you. >> thank you,...
0
0.0
Feb 7, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
our jean casarez joins us live from pontiac michigan.is a verdict that not only is significant there but really for the entire country, right? >> reporter: absolutely. you know, poppy, this community has been through so much. they have experienced a mass shooting. and all of the emotions that go through that. this jury is from this community. and they spoke loud and clear. an historic verdict. >> we find the defendant guilty. >> reporter: in the manslaughter trial of jennifer crumbley, the mother of a teen who killed four students at a michigan high school in 2021. the jury unanimous in their verdict, after more than ten hours of deliberation. >> juror number 12, was that and is that your verdict -- >> yes. >> reporter: jennifer crumbley pleaded not guilty to four counts of involuntary manslaughter. one count for each student her son murdered. she faces a maximum of 15 years for each count which would run concurrent. ethan crumbley killed madison baldwin, tate mere, justin shilling and hana st. juliana at oxford high school using a gun h
our jean casarez joins us live from pontiac michigan.is a verdict that not only is significant there but really for the entire country, right? >> reporter: absolutely. you know, poppy, this community has been through so much. they have experienced a mass shooting. and all of the emotions that go through that. this jury is from this community. and they spoke loud and clear. an historic verdict. >> we find the defendant guilty. >> reporter: in the manslaughter trial of jennifer...
0
0.0
Feb 5, 2024
02/24
by
KNTV
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
>> jesse kirsch for us there in pontiac, michigan, jesse, thank you. >>> well, in just over two yearscup final will be played at metlife stadium, home of the nfl's new york jets and giants, just a short ride from where we sit right now that final is scheduled for july 19th, 2026 the u.s., mexico, and canada are all co-hosting the tournament. the game is in 16 cities across north america. if you are wondering about the u.s. men's team, they will play june 12th in los angeles, june 19th in seattle. then back to l.a. on june 25th and, of course, the final right here in new jersey yeah. >> that will be huge. >> i mean, i don't know if they will get to the final, but that's what we're rooting for. >> they will. >>> coming up, guys, it is our super bowl commercial kickoff. we're revealing two more big game ads, including a hollywood a-lister donning a sweet stash for a good reason. >> and vicky nguyen here is for money saving monday. maximizing your rewards, and how to give back to yourself just by paying your rent that's up right after these messages getting my business off the ground was
>> jesse kirsch for us there in pontiac, michigan, jesse, thank you. >>> well, in just over two yearscup final will be played at metlife stadium, home of the nfl's new york jets and giants, just a short ride from where we sit right now that final is scheduled for july 19th, 2026 the u.s., mexico, and canada are all co-hosting the tournament. the game is in 16 cities across north america. if you are wondering about the u.s. men's team, they will play june 12th in los angeles, june...
0
0.0
Feb 2, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
because the community, obviously, to have this mass shooting in oxford, michigan, which is part of pontiacsuburb of detroit, was huge. so, yesterday on the stand, jennifer said, you know, we were going to turn ourselves in, and i was texting with my attorney, you, she says, shannon smith, and we were taking your advice on what to do. we were going to turn ourselves in on saturday around 8:30 in the morning, but the prosecution doesn't believe that. they thought there was -- that they were fleeing the jurisdiction, and so they want those texts. the judge says, look, the attorney/client privilege is absolute, in my opinion, and i don't want to do this, but i feel i have to review these texts. there aren't too many of them. early morning hours of december 4th. sara, it is right before law enforcement stormed in to arrest them, and the judge said, "i won't take long if there's not that many to look at." we're waiting to see what the judge says and what will happen next. >> these are two almost unprecedented things happening at the same time. the charging of the parents in this case and now the
because the community, obviously, to have this mass shooting in oxford, michigan, which is part of pontiacsuburb of detroit, was huge. so, yesterday on the stand, jennifer said, you know, we were going to turn ourselves in, and i was texting with my attorney, you, she says, shannon smith, and we were taking your advice on what to do. we were going to turn ourselves in on saturday around 8:30 in the morning, but the prosecution doesn't believe that. they thought there was -- that they were...
0
0.0
Feb 27, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
will say i have been with large groups of democrats from troy, michigan, into bloomfield hills and pontiacrongly united behind this president. they don't feel like they need to vote uncommitted. they want to stand up for democracy. they want to stand up for a woman's right to choose. maybe some people are going in with a protest vote. i believe this president's been doing a great job. we have a large jewish population in michigan. they're also very afraid and have gone through tremendous amounts of pain. october 7th was israel's 9/11. look, israel hasn't received any aid yet since this war began. ukraine has received a lot of aid. we need to do more aid for ukraine. i believe in standing up alongside our democratic allies. look, that's one piece of puzzle here. we have other issues on the line. we'll be able to do more and analyze. we're a big tent party. we need these voices alongside us in november and joe biden is exactly that type of leader, compassionate, handling tough issues with grace, with love. you see that radiating out of him last night when he made the surprise appearance on s
will say i have been with large groups of democrats from troy, michigan, into bloomfield hills and pontiacrongly united behind this president. they don't feel like they need to vote uncommitted. they want to stand up for democracy. they want to stand up for a woman's right to choose. maybe some people are going in with a protest vote. i believe this president's been doing a great job. we have a large jewish population in michigan. they're also very afraid and have gone through tremendous...
0
0.0
Feb 7, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
nbc's maggie vespa joins us from pontiac, michigan, now. in that jury room? >> reporter: yeah, ana, it was really interesting, that forewoman telling us while it obviously ended with a unanimous verdict, juries in michigan have to be unanimous, it definitely didn't start off that way. she told us yesterday that both sides, in her words, were well-represented, meaning some jurors went in thinking that this should be a not guilty verdict. others went in thinking she was definitely guilty. she also told savannah in that exclusive conversation this morning that everyone's reason for voting guilty, she said, was different or at least there were different reasons among the jury. for her specifically it was that point that she raised about the fact that jennifer crumbley was the last adult to have possession of the gun that ethan had. it was the one that had been gifted to him, and it was the one that he used in the shooting, and then following up on that point, savannah asked this question this morning, take a listen. >> there was a point where s
nbc's maggie vespa joins us from pontiac, michigan, now. in that jury room? >> reporter: yeah, ana, it was really interesting, that forewoman telling us while it obviously ended with a unanimous verdict, juries in michigan have to be unanimous, it definitely didn't start off that way. she told us yesterday that both sides, in her words, were well-represented, meaning some jurors went in thinking that this should be a not guilty verdict. others went in thinking she was definitely guilty....
0
0.0
Feb 5, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
nbc's jesse kirsch joins us from pontiac, michigan.considering actually? >> reporter: there are two legal theories that the judge has laid out that the jurors will be krk. they don't have to all agree on which theory has been proven, but the underlying historic question these jurors are considering is can the mother of a high school mass shooter be found guilty for involuntary manslaughter because of a shooting rampage carried out by her son? this morning a michigan jury is preparing to answer an unprecedented question, at what point can a parent be found guilty for their child's deadly shooting rampage? >> we didn't just hand him a gun as a here you go, son. it was something he could use when we went to the range as a family together. >> reporter: after jennifer crumbley testified in her own defense, prosecutors cross examining the oxford school shooter's mother friday, attempting to undercut crumbley's defense that her husband james was in charge of storing their son's handgun. >> it's pretty clear you didn't trust james with much. y
nbc's jesse kirsch joins us from pontiac, michigan.considering actually? >> reporter: there are two legal theories that the judge has laid out that the jurors will be krk. they don't have to all agree on which theory has been proven, but the underlying historic question these jurors are considering is can the mother of a high school mass shooter be found guilty for involuntary manslaughter because of a shooting rampage carried out by her son? this morning a michigan jury is preparing to...
0
0.0
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> reporter: for "good morning america" trevor ault, abc news, pontiac, michigan. >> erielle: now,alestine, ohio. it's been a year since that toxic train derailment and some residents still reporting health problems. abc's alex presha has been following this from the very beginning, and is in ohio with the latest. good morning, alex. >> reporter: hey, erielle, we're getting a new look at new drone video released by the ntsb of that derailment site and toxic plume, and it's only amplifying questions raised by this east palestine community over the last year. this morning, new video showing the toxic plume one year ago in east palestine, ohio. today, the town is still shrouded in a cloud of uncertainty. authorities insist the soil and tap water are safe, but many residents simply aren't buying it. >> i have headaches, a metallic taste in my mouth. >> reporter: wayne and lori o'connell live about three miles from the derailment. months after both tested positive for vinyl chloride, a carcinogen aboard that train, and weeks later wayne was diagnosed with breast cancer. >> wayne, do you
. >> reporter: for "good morning america" trevor ault, abc news, pontiac, michigan. >> erielle: now,alestine, ohio. it's been a year since that toxic train derailment and some residents still reporting health problems. abc's alex presha has been following this from the very beginning, and is in ohio with the latest. good morning, alex. >> reporter: hey, erielle, we're getting a new look at new drone video released by the ntsb of that derailment site and toxic plume,...
0
0.0
Feb 2, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> reporter: nbc's adrian broaddus joins us from pontiac, michigan. good morning.t did we hear today? >> reporter: a very extensive and detailed cross examination by the prosecution. the defense rested its case as you mentioned just moments ago. that cross examination lasted about an hour. there were questions pointed and directed at jennifer crumbley, about her son's mental health, her vigilance as a parent, and text messages exchanged between jennifer crumbley, and her attorney, shannon smith. before we talk about those text messages, let's hear some of that cross examination that just wrapped up moments ago, jose. >> it was a surprise to me they went to the gun store that day. it was not surprising to me they purchased a gun that day. >> it didn't upset you they bought a gun? >> no. >> it didn't upset you that it cut into your christmas tree shopping time, but didn't upset you that they bought a gun. >> correct. >> he showed you how to use the gun? >> correct. >> okay the stance he took, you saw from the oxford high school video was the same, you saw that, right
. >> reporter: nbc's adrian broaddus joins us from pontiac, michigan. good morning.t did we hear today? >> reporter: a very extensive and detailed cross examination by the prosecution. the defense rested its case as you mentioned just moments ago. that cross examination lasted about an hour. there were questions pointed and directed at jennifer crumbley, about her son's mental health, her vigilance as a parent, and text messages exchanged between jennifer crumbley, and her attorney,...
0
0.0
Feb 19, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
so i was like, i -- i used to date a mechanic, because i had a 92 pontiac with 283,000 miles on -- itessage? >> be nice to yourself. because, the relationship you have with yourself is a long relationship, the longest you'll ever have in your life and being like, what we say life is short now it's, not being alive as long as than you ever do if you live for a day, or hundred years, that's all your life so, the relationship you have with you is the one that's extremely important so, be nice to yourself, give yourself grace, and don't be mad at yourself or decisions you made when you were 25 or when -- your 40 because that's not going to help, because we haven't invented a tie machine yet so, you've got to live with this, it is what it is. >> it is a very important message, be kind to yourself -- thank you so much for making time, hope to have you back on the show. and congrats on this important book. thank you. >> thank you so. much >> all right, thank you at-home for making time for us to make sure to catch ayman back here on msnbc saturdays and sundays at seven pm eastern. follow us
so i was like, i -- i used to date a mechanic, because i had a 92 pontiac with 283,000 miles on -- itessage? >> be nice to yourself. because, the relationship you have with yourself is a long relationship, the longest you'll ever have in your life and being like, what we say life is short now it's, not being alive as long as than you ever do if you live for a day, or hundred years, that's all your life so, the relationship you have with you is the one that's extremely important so, be...
0
0.0
Feb 7, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> nbc's adrienne broaddus joins us from the courthouse in pontiac, michigan. good morning.s next there? >> reporter: jose, what is next is the trial for the shooter's father, james crumbley. it is scheduled to start march 5th. already before that guilty verdict was delivered, attorneys representing james crumbley filed a motion to block some evidence in his trial, specifically his attorneys are asking for the judge to deny showing surveillance video from the shooting, and photos of the aftermath. meanwhile, jennifer crumbley will be sentenced in april. the juror, the woman who led members of this jury in deliberating said something that came up repeatedly was what jennifer crumbley said on the stand, that she would not do anything differently. and that is something that has weighed heavy on the heart of the father of the youngest victim killed. listen to what he had to say. >> when she testified and said they lost everything, and that she wouldn't do anything differently, what went through your mind? >> the first part of they have lost everything, no, that answer is a simpl
. >> nbc's adrienne broaddus joins us from the courthouse in pontiac, michigan. good morning.s next there? >> reporter: jose, what is next is the trial for the shooter's father, james crumbley. it is scheduled to start march 5th. already before that guilty verdict was delivered, attorneys representing james crumbley filed a motion to block some evidence in his trial, specifically his attorneys are asking for the judge to deny showing surveillance video from the shooting, and photos...
0
0.0
Feb 5, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
joining us now in pontiac, michigan, is maggie vespa.katy, we are six hours, almost on the dot, by started around 9:50 this morning into jury deliberations. the morning started off with jury instructions. jurors since then have had some questions about kind of the crux of what prosecutors are required to prove. in short, jennifer crumbley on trial for the deadly 2021 shooting at oxford high school carried out by her son. she faces four counts of involuntary manslaughter, and this morning in the jury instructions, the judge told jurors that prosecutors in this case could basically prove anonymous beyond a reasonable doubt through one of two avenues. and this is important, basically telling the jury that they had to decide whether the prosecutors proved that jennifer crumbley did one of two things. one of them showing gross negligence in the way she locked up the gun that they had given to her son, that he used in the shooting, also locked up the ammunition, and through that gross negligence allowed him access to the gun, which then caused
joining us now in pontiac, michigan, is maggie vespa.katy, we are six hours, almost on the dot, by started around 9:50 this morning into jury deliberations. the morning started off with jury instructions. jurors since then have had some questions about kind of the crux of what prosecutors are required to prove. in short, jennifer crumbley on trial for the deadly 2021 shooting at oxford high school carried out by her son. she faces four counts of involuntary manslaughter, and this morning in the...
0
0.0
Feb 1, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
joining us now in pontiac, michigan, is nbc news correspondent, adrienne broaddus.ery emotional day in court. what about the moment where she's describing what happened with the text messages, where she was telling her son it's okay to search for things like ammunition, just don't get caught. how did she explain that? >> reporter: you're talking about the text message that authorities who were called by the prosecution have described. jennifer crumbley's response when ethan crumbley was spotted in class looking up bullets and ammunition. she said, lol, you have to learn how not to get caught. she says this surrounds conversations they have had in their home, dating back to her childhood. listen to her explanation. >> he was worried about he was going to get in trouble. i said, next time don't get caught. >> reporter: what did you mean by that? >> there's an ongoing thing in our house. somebody always asks me the trouble i would get into in high school, my friends would do the same thing, and i would always get caught. it was kind of referencing to that. >> that was
joining us now in pontiac, michigan, is nbc news correspondent, adrienne broaddus.ery emotional day in court. what about the moment where she's describing what happened with the text messages, where she was telling her son it's okay to search for things like ammunition, just don't get caught. how did she explain that? >> reporter: you're talking about the text message that authorities who were called by the prosecution have described. jennifer crumbley's response when ethan crumbley was...
0
0.0
Feb 27, 2024
02/24
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
so if you go to a pontiac car meet, that's what you want to see. that five trans-am, firebird with that artwork on it. now, if you look at the franchise that follows. yeah i mean if you look at this i mean what you see is that smoking about $4.3 million to make it today's adjusted inflation dollars, it has made over 521 million. the the entire franchise as we now call it, made three quarters of $1,000,000,000. to be clear, smoking the ban, it was, the second gross highest grossing film of 1977, i think you could probably guess what the highest grossing film of 1977 was. star star wars. so, okay, so this is to give you an indication just how big this film is. and what's very carefully here is, a southern dixie, right? so what we're seeing here is just as john is pointing out, is the of the film vision of rebellion with not only regionalism on the south, but also an emergent new political culture. well, the cannonball films, beyond gumball, cannonball cannonball run, 1981. i more stars in one film that i can ever think. reynolds roger moore, farrah f
so if you go to a pontiac car meet, that's what you want to see. that five trans-am, firebird with that artwork on it. now, if you look at the franchise that follows. yeah i mean if you look at this i mean what you see is that smoking about $4.3 million to make it today's adjusted inflation dollars, it has made over 521 million. the the entire franchise as we now call it, made three quarters of $1,000,000,000. to be clear, smoking the ban, it was, the second gross highest grossing film of 1977,...
0
0.0
Feb 27, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
just three weeks ago, has expanded to count progressives and young voters among its supporters, like pontiac city councilman, mikel goodman because we are often told many times that the power that we have assistance in the us is through the power of the ballot and this is us using that power or no one who his voting uncommitted wants trump they want was happening in gaza to stop more than 30 state and local elected officials endorsed the campaign, as did rachida to leave the first palestinian american woman to serve in congress? >> if you want us to be louder, then come here and vote uncommitted >> organizers safe for most today's message is about the primary, but there's a lingering warning. >> it needs to call for a ceasefire because it will save lives and because it's the necessary thing to do politically otherwise, you president biden will be handing the white house to donald trump. >> the biden campaign has acknowledged michigan's importance in this election, but allies of the president aren't quite sounding alarms over the uncommitted primary strategy yet i'm hoping and expecting that
just three weeks ago, has expanded to count progressives and young voters among its supporters, like pontiac city councilman, mikel goodman because we are often told many times that the power that we have assistance in the us is through the power of the ballot and this is us using that power or no one who his voting uncommitted wants trump they want was happening in gaza to stop more than 30 state and local elected officials endorsed the campaign, as did rachida to leave the first palestinian...
0
0.0
Feb 18, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
going to stay inside gene means night football who's told me putin the core with op chicago at the pontiac. it's elude genuine. poison says she taught, say >> and the most pride was >> coming up brighter but donald convoy need some station now could is a filing see really cool private, is but moishe jim brushy >> what she told always of kryvyi >> we've comes to the conclusion that judging by the fact that we're noses founding in his blood or other biological materials. he has a metabolic disorder. lowering your blood sugar levels to be specific >> we hearing state news agencies here that are backed by the kremlin suggesting that hallucinogenic drugs may be involved, but not poisoning his new premier >> the on the eve of stoner communion primo got it done. his words, and need to pitch. they all got only going to give his sunni liberal bring in my head president strain is certainly rishi antidepressant >> we're going to block above what was it also has not yet yeah, it goes pushing when you she knew she come >> you want you moses deal growth could be moved, divided >> dahlia wash law la wher
going to stay inside gene means night football who's told me putin the core with op chicago at the pontiac. it's elude genuine. poison says she taught, say >> and the most pride was >> coming up brighter but donald convoy need some station now could is a filing see really cool private, is but moishe jim brushy >> what she told always of kryvyi >> we've comes to the conclusion that judging by the fact that we're noses founding in his blood or other biological materials....
0
0.0
Feb 26, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
just three weeks ago has expanded to count progressive than young voters among its supporters, like pontiac city councilman, mikel goodman because we are often told many times that the power that we have assistance in the us is through the power of the ballot. and this is us using that no one who his voting uncommitted once trump they want what is happening in gaza to stop more than 30 state and local elected officials endorsed the campaign as did rachida to leave the first palestinian american woman to serve in congress if you want us to be louder then come here and vote uncommitted >> organizers safe for most today's message is about the primary, but there's a lingering warning. >> you need to call for a ceasefire because it will save lives and because it's the necessary thing to do politically, otherwise, you, president biden will be handing the white house to donald trump. >> the biden campaign has acknowledged michigan's importance in this election. but allies of the president aren't quite sounding alarms over the uncommitted primary strategy yet. >> i'm hoping and expecting that these
just three weeks ago has expanded to count progressive than young voters among its supporters, like pontiac city councilman, mikel goodman because we are often told many times that the power that we have assistance in the us is through the power of the ballot. and this is us using that no one who his voting uncommitted once trump they want what is happening in gaza to stop more than 30 state and local elected officials endorsed the campaign as did rachida to leave the first palestinian american...
0
0.0
Feb 25, 2024
02/24
by
CNNW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
just three weeks ago, has expanded to count progressives and young voters among its supporters, like pontiac city councilman, mikel goodman because we are often told many times that the power that we have assistance in the us is through the power of the ballot. and this is us using that power or no one who his voting uncommitted wants trump. they want was happening in gaza to stop more than 30 state and local elected officials endorsed the campaign, as did rachida to leave the first palestinian american woman to serve in congress if you want us to be louder come here and vote uncommitted. >> organizer safe for most today's message is about the primary, but there's a lingering warning. >> you need to call for a ceasefire because it will save lives and be because it's the necessary thing to do politically. otherwise, you, president biden will be handing the white house to donald trump. >> the biden campaign has acknowledged michigan's importance in this election. but allies of the president aren't quite sounding alarms over the uncommitted primary strategy yet. >> i'm hoping and expecting that
just three weeks ago, has expanded to count progressives and young voters among its supporters, like pontiac city councilman, mikel goodman because we are often told many times that the power that we have assistance in the us is through the power of the ballot. and this is us using that power or no one who his voting uncommitted wants trump. they want was happening in gaza to stop more than 30 state and local elected officials endorsed the campaign, as did rachida to leave the first palestinian...
0
0.0
Feb 2, 2024
02/24
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> nbc's adrienne broaddus is outside the courthouse for us in pontiac, michigan. bit i was able to see and hear, it sounds like she took a bit of a grilling. the stakes here are tremendously high, not just for her but for future cases including her husband's. tell us what you saw and heard today. >> reporter: the stakes are high, and at the start of her closing argument just moments ago, the prosecuting attorney acknowledged that, and she told members of the jury as she makes the case it's their last opportunity to make a case in front of members of this jury that she does not want to sanitize the truth. she doesn't want to sanitize what happened on november 30th, 2021, at oxford high school. now, the prosecutor's saying and reminding members of the jury that the gun ethan crumbley used was a gift given to him by his parents for christmas, that jennifer crumbley, the prosecutor says taught him to shoot and even bragged about it on social media. and during that cross examination, chris, what you talked about, there was more discussion about that gun because yesterd
. >> nbc's adrienne broaddus is outside the courthouse for us in pontiac, michigan. bit i was able to see and hear, it sounds like she took a bit of a grilling. the stakes here are tremendously high, not just for her but for future cases including her husband's. tell us what you saw and heard today. >> reporter: the stakes are high, and at the start of her closing argument just moments ago, the prosecuting attorney acknowledged that, and she told members of the jury as she makes the...
0
0.0
Feb 7, 2024
02/24
by
KNTV
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
but, first, maggie vespa is at the courthouse in pontiac, michigan. good morning. >> reporter: good morning. this case took exactly two weeks, with those jurors, most of them parents, deliberating for less than two days before reaching this landmark verdict. victims' families saying they hope this serves as a wake-up call to parents across america. >> we find the defendant guilty of involuntary manslaughter. >> reporter: jennifer crumbley silence and stoic as the jury announced her fate, guilty on all four charges. as she was led away in handcuffs, prosecutors embracing the families of her son's victims. juliana lost her 14-year-old daughter. >> it is a wake-up call for people to realize they have to take a bit of responsibility. >> reporter: crumbley is america's first parent to stand trial for their child's mass shooting. the defense arguing in court she was unaware of any mental health issues with her son. >> i lost my son because i wouldn't have done anything differently. >> reporter: prosecutors painted her differently, painting her as a negligen
but, first, maggie vespa is at the courthouse in pontiac, michigan. good morning. >> reporter: good morning. this case took exactly two weeks, with those jurors, most of them parents, deliberating for less than two days before reaching this landmark verdict. victims' families saying they hope this serves as a wake-up call to parents across america. >> we find the defendant guilty of involuntary manslaughter. >> reporter: jennifer crumbley silence and stoic as the jury...
0
0.0
tv
eye 0
favorite 0
quote 0
trevor ault is at the courthouse in pontiac.od morning, george. so the jury had the weekend to process two weeks of testimony including hearing from this mother herself. now all that's left this morning is for the judge to explain instructions on these four counts of unvoluntary manslaughter and they will decide if jennifer crumbley is guilty. this morning jury deliberation soon set to begin in the trial of jennifer crumbley. >> that was the hardest thing i have had to stomach is that my child killed other people. i wish he would have killed us instead. >> reporter: if convicted she could be sentenced to as much as 60 years in prison charged with four counts of unvoluntary manslaughter for the four classmates her son murdered in november of 2021. a group of 12 jurors and five alternates will decide her fate. ten women, seven men, several of them parents and gun owners, all of them have been in the courtroom hearing evidence and arguments the past two weeks. >> i am asking that you find jennifer crumbley not guilty, not just for
trevor ault is at the courthouse in pontiac.od morning, george. so the jury had the weekend to process two weeks of testimony including hearing from this mother herself. now all that's left this morning is for the judge to explain instructions on these four counts of unvoluntary manslaughter and they will decide if jennifer crumbley is guilty. this morning jury deliberation soon set to begin in the trial of jennifer crumbley. >> that was the hardest thing i have had to stomach is that my...