>> skylar neese. >> what were you feeling at that point for your little girl?> i was scared to death. i didn't know where my baby was. how would you feel? it was horrible. >> nothing would ever be the same for dave neese, and his wife mary after that call in july 2012. >> that was one of my favorites, that was number one, had to be. >> or for the small suburban community of star city, west virginia, who would grapple with the mystery of skylar neese's disappearance. >> star city is a small little city off of morgantown. it is a great place to live. it is a wonderful place to raise your family. as much as we have this real small-knit community, we also have a university. >> morgantown was more college town, so your crime was more college, property crimes, college kids having parties, typical stuff that any other college town would have, but nothing really serious. >> it has that college town shine and bounce. it's not a podunk town, and it's not an urban metropolis, it's a combo, and it's breathtakingly beautiful there. >> a blue-collar middle-class town with wo