wants to return his honorary degree from youngstown state.. >>> o'neil will join us next. >>> o'neil will join us next. >> this is a hot flash. this is a hot flash. but this is a not flash. ♪ i got a good feeling ♪ there's big news for women going through menopause. veozah - a prescription treatment for moderate to severe vasomotor symptoms - the medical name for hot flashes and night sweats. with hormone-free veozah, you can have fewer hot flashes, and more not flashes. veozah is proven to reduce the number and severity of hot flashes, day and night. for some women, it can start working in as early as one week. don't use veozah if you have cirrhosis, severe kidney problems, kidney failure, or take cyp1a2 inhibitors. increased liver blood test values may occur. your doctor will check them before and during treatment. most common side effects include stomach pain, diarrhea, difficulty sleeping, back pain, and hot flashes. ♪ i got a good feeling ♪ ask your doctor about hormone-free veozah and enjoy more not flashes. take a moment to pause and a

, ed o'neill wants to return his honorary degree from youngstown state.o. mark that one. that was nice! i think you're supposed to stand over there. oh am i? thank you. so, a couple more? we'll just...we'll rip. we'll go quick. libu smeebo. libu bribu. limu bibu...and me. doug: he's an emu! only pay for what you need. jingle: ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ the ball is out and there's a pile-up. -let's go! -get in the pile! ugh, i'll deal with this tomorrow. you won't. it's ripe in here. my eyes are watering. i'm a busy man. look how crusty this is. shameful. ugh, it's just too much. not with this. tide. tide can tackle any pile. that a tackle pun? just clean the pile, ron. okay. this too. that was easy. when stains and odors pile up, it's got to be tide. your heart is the beat of life. if you have heart failure, entrust your heart to entresto. entresto helps improve your heart's ability to pump blood to the body. don't take entresto if pregnant; it can cause harm or death to an unborn baby. don't take entresto with an ace inhibitor or aliskiren,

he is not wanted youngstown. i don't want him as a former student that graduated with a masters degree. this is all about race. all of these ivy league institutions have ways been embeddedith white supremacy. i want to know where stefanik's outrage about the genocide going on in palestine right now. host: ohio republican bill johnson set a takver youngstown later this month. this is barry and hkins, south carolina. caller: good morning john, i am a graduate of the university of south carolina. my daughter has a nursing practice and attending the university of south carolina. last night we were talking about her student loan and she said i will be 80 years old when i pay off my student loan. my daughter does have a student loan and my wife and i were blessed to not have one. my comment this morning i have two. as a black man i benefited from college protest. i remember us a little boy, the college students coming to ou church and we would raise money to give to them to fight for the cause during the civil rights m

the prime example that have is a the youngstown case.he steel mills. the court coming in and reviewing that. we see that all the way through to the president. it's hard to see any world in which the court just says, we can't intervene here. we do see -- the court's, judge henderson, the distinction between ministerial and discretionary acts. compliance with the law is not discretionary call. it is something that -- i fully endorse or agree with the idea of the paradox of a president's on the one hand having article 2 take care of the responsibility. on the other hand, seeing the laws as compliance with the law as optional. judge henderson: how do we write an opinion that would stop floodgates? your predecessors in their o.l.c. opinions recognize that unavoidably political. mr. pearce: a couple of responses. for one, of cours was with respect to a sitting president. the analysis is extraordinarily different with respect to a former president. which o.l.c. in that very same -- judge henderson: with respect to being necessarily political. m

he is not wanted youngstown. i don't want him as a former student that graduatedith a masters degree. this is all about race. all of these ivy league institutions have always been embedded with whe supremacy. i want to know where stefanik's outrage about the genocide going on in palestine right now. host: ohio republican bill johnson set a takeover youngstown later this month. this is barry and hopkins, south carolina. caller: good morning john, i am a graduate of the university of south carolina. my daughter has a nursing practice and attending the university of south carolina. last night we were talking about her student loan and she said i will be 80 years old when i pay off my student loan. my daughter does have a student loan and my wife and i were essed to not have one. my comment this morning i have two. as a black man i benefited from college protest. i remember us a little boy, the college students coming to ou church and we would raise money to give to them to fight for the cause during the civil rights

of precedents or cases that the supreme court has reviewed cases of the president, and the case of youngstown where the supreme court reviewed harry truman's seizure of the steel mills in the korean war and the case of little bahrain where president johnson restricted the vessels, and where there were nationals from certain nationals of foreign countries and how does that square with the position that the judiciary cannot review the presidential action. >> all of those are fall with the exceptions of the ex parte of young, and those are judgments against subordinate officers -- >> these are presidents. harry young was president when he seized the steel mill and how does that comport the theory? >> he was the secretary of the commerce and not the president, and this court has confirmed recently that you cannot issue an injunction against the president and the court does not have the authority to do that as with the robertson, and the court -- >> and they can review presidential action if on paper they direct their judgment to a subordinate officer -- is that what you saying? because these are

of precedents or cases in which the supreme court has reviewed actions by the president the case of youngstown, where the supreme court reviewed hair are you truman's seizure of the steel mills during the korn war. there's the case of little bahrain, where chief justice marshall reviewed thections of president adams when he seized certain vessels. trump vs hawaii was president trump's order restrictingnt of the united states of nationals from certain foreign unies. judge pan: how does that square with your position that the judiciary can never review executive action? mr. sauer: all those cases fall scarilyithin the establishment of ex parte young where the dial can issue judgments against subordinate officers -- judge pan: these are psints. harry truman was the president when he seizethsteel mill. how does that comportityour theory? mr. sauer: itasn injunction against the secretary. e court has no jurisdiction to do that. it cannot enter -- strongly incas that the court can't -- judge pan: review presidential action if on paper they dict their judgment to a subordinate officer. is that what y

theme example that have is a the youngstown case. that was is president truman clthe steel mills.he court coming in and reviewing that. we see that all the way through to the pre. it's hard to see any world in whichourt just says, we can't intervene here. we do see -- i accept the court's, judge henderson, the distinction between ministeri and discretionary acts. compliance with the law is not someof discretionary call. it is something that -- i fully endorse or agreethe idea of the paradox of adent's on the one hand having article 2 take care of the responsibility. on the other hand, seeing the laws as compliance with the law as optional. judg henderson: how do we write nion that would stop the your predecessors in their o.l.c. os recognize that criminal liability woulde unavoidably political. mr. pear a couple of responses. for on course, that was with respect to a sitting president. the analysis is extnarily different with respect to a former president. which o.l.c that very same -- judge henderson: with respect to being necessarily political. pearce: i think there is a politic

the case of youngstown, where the supreme court ried hair are you truman's seizure of the eel mills duringhe korean war. there's the case olile bahrain, where chief justice marshall reviewed the actions of pridt adams when he seized certain vessels. trump vs. hawaii was president trp's order restricting entry of the united states of naons from certain foreign countries. judge pan: how does that square with your position that the judiciary can never review executive action? mr. sauer:llhose cases fall scarily within the establishment of ex parte young where the judicial can issue judgments against subordinate officers -- dgpan: these are presidents. harry truman was the psint when he seized the steel mill. how does that comport with your theory? mr. sauer: it was an injunction against the secretary. the court has no jurisdiction to do tt. it cannot enter -- strongly indicates that the court can't -- dgpan: review presidential action if on pape they direct their judgment to a subordinate officer. is that what you're saying? these are presidential aions. mr. sauer: the court can enjoy the act

prime example that have is a the youngstown case. that is president truman closing theteel mills. reviewing that.g in and we see that all the way through to the president. it's hard to see any wor which the court just says, w can't intervene here. we do see -- i a the court's, judge henderson, the distinction between ministerial andiscretionary acts. compliance with the law is not some sort ofcretionary call. it is something that -- i fully endorse agree with the idea of the paradox of a president's on the one hand having article take care of the responsibility. other hand, seeing the laws as compliance with the law asptional. judgederson: how do we write an opinion that would stop the floodgates? your predecessors in their o. opinions recognize that iminal liability would be unavoidably political. mr. pearce: ae of responses. for one, of course, that was with reso a sitting president. the analysis is extraordinarily different with respect to a former president. which o.l.c. in that very - being necessarily political.t to mr. pearc i think there is a political process whichs impea

>>> youngstown's ed o'neal gets tonight's last word. the 11th hour with stephanie ruhle starts now. >> tonight, on to new hampshire, after donald trump's victory in iowa last night. the remaining campaigns shift focus through the next race, but is there a lane for all three candidates? then, the former president makes a pitstop between campaign events to appear at another civil trial. and chasing the youth vote, how maga republicans are trying to win over young voters, as the 11th hour gets underway on this tuesday night. good evening, once again, i am stephanie ruhle. today, the republican presidential race is moving to the state of new hampshire. all the candidates are now in the granite state to's evening. donald trump is basking in his iowa victory and focusing's attacks now on nikki haley. >> as you know, nikki haley, in particular, is counting on the democrats and liberals to infiltrate the republican primary, you know that. that is what is happening. a group of people coming in that are not republicans, and it's artificially boos

emily and youngstown, ohio, republican. >> trump on super tuesday. watching the people in new hampshire, they are new englanders and will go for the more establishment republicans. governor dewine, who i am very disappointed in, donald trump is an outsider obviously and my county voted for trump in 2020, the first time they voted republican since nixon. i am hoping to see my county re it is a democrat stronghold but ohio is going to go read and new hampshire definitely trump is going to win it. >> the latest poll released tonight by emerson, we spoke with the pol director about who is supporting who, what type of voter is backing the former president and nikki haley. listen. >> what we have seen since march is the republicanh trump, getting about 66% of adding one t4?hird ode spirit a lot like what he thought of independence in 2016 but the lead among republicans has doubled in that is why he is newest pole and nikki haley at 35% and desantis was 8% in our numbers. >> trump and haley both saw their numbers go up since the last polstriie dropping out

it isdz youngstown, democrat stronghold but it is going to be red. red and new hampshire definitely, i believe trump is going to win it. >> you may be interested in the latest poll released tonight by emerson. we spoke to the polling director about who is supporting who. what type of voter is backing the former president and nikki haley? take a listen. >> what we have seen since march is the republican party is lined hup with trump. he is getting 60 6% support of registered republicans and out of independence hethat is a lots getting in 2016. his lead among republicans has doubled and that is why we now have him at 50% in newest hole. nikki haley trails with 35% and we eliminated ron desantis, who was at 8%. >> the former president and nikki haley saw their numbers go up since the last pole. explain. >> nikki haley's incree is probably due to chrisdrawing --. he was at 12% and now nikki haley has picked up seven points between those two poles. even when candidate drop won't f those votes but she picked up a good chunk of it. donald picked up about si

johnson of ohio announced that he will resign come january 21st in order to become the new head of youngstownr one bites the dust. normally, a single capitol hill wouldn't be that big of a deal, but recall that johnson's departure comes after the expulsion of everyone's favorite self made man, former representative, george santos, and former house speaker, kevin mccarthy's retirement before the holiday. when you put all three of these three departures together, it means the gop in the house is gonna shrink to just a mere 219, that's just one seat more than the bare minimum necessary for a majority. all of this has major implications for party leaders. not only would maga mike johnson and company have to walk a proverbial speech to find the most necess order to keep the government open an operatiol. but also to secure funding for the border, israel, and ukraine. this year, l shrinking, it will tu 2024 i a quote, barr burner, as built by t gop leaders will need to be more pragmatic and more selective when choosing what seats to protect and flip, especially when considering major redistricting p

the hardworking men and women who call the sixth district, old and new, home, from youngstown to portsmouth from st. clairsville to zanesville are proud and patriotic but they are too often disregarded by america's elite, be they political, media, corporate, and/or academic. these blue collar communities like countless others in flyover country were critical in building our great nation and will play a pivotal role in our nation's future. i am extremely humbled to have been repeatedly elected to serb them. signed, sincerely, bill johnson, member of congress. the speaker pro tempore: the chair lays before the house a communication. the clerk: the honorable the speaker, house of representatives, sir. i write to respectfully tender my resignation as member of the budget committee effective today. it has been an honor to serve in this capacity. signed, sin seriously, stephanie bias, member of congress. the speaker pro tempore: without objection, the resignation is accepted. the chair would ask that all members and staff present in the chamber and throughout the capitol please rise in a moment o

youngstown, ohio. that happens. >> dana: he graduated from ohio u? >> bill: i love it. >> dana: bring in ohio, oh yeah. >> bill: your daughter is having a great time there? >> too much. >> dana: check this out as well. traces of cocaine found on hunter biden's gun pouch and a navy officer jailed for 500 days and he is freed. he and his wife join us to talk about the tragedy and their return and triumph. because aspen dental has the latest technology and equipment. with a staff that goes out of their way to provide exceptional care. plus free exams and x-rays for new patients without insurance and 20% off treatment plans. making it easier to get started with quality care. it's one more way aspen dental is in your corner. i feel refreshed because i am not struggling with cpap anymore. she looks great. i got inspire. great sleep at the click of a button. did she get implants? yeah, i got an implant, sheila!! it's inspire. learn more and view important safety information at inspiresleep.com choice hotels is a family of brands that helps you get the most

taking's ball and going home, and a backbench congressman johnson just left today to take a job running youngstown university. you need 219 members to pass anything. these guys couldn't do anything before, they can't do anything now without democrats. if johnson works with democrats too much, the gates of the world will give him the same treatment again mccarthy. so it's a tight situation. >> given those numbers, roger robert, that tim laid, out it's thinner majority than kevin mccarthy had and kevin mccarthy had a lot more experience with votes and where he with federal fellow members of his party and democrats and johnson, does do you think we're gonna end up seeing more chaos? if that's even possible? >> i think it is possible. i think we're definitely going to see it. you step back from the budget for a second, we don't even have the top line spending. to set a budget you have to figure out how much you have to spend and then underneath that, on what things are going to spend it on? congress is a month away from a partial shutdown. it doesn't even have the top line spending. as tim points out,

guys because of all the republicans who left, kevin mccarthy who left, retired, the guy who went to youngstown state, they can't -- they have a want to pursue majority, they can't take any post offices. these gusher a second can pass a complicated budget. to get anything, pass don't need democrats, so for mike johnson to be able to get democrats on board for anything, well, he's got that the mixture that there is not a man standing over his shoulder saying that he has a motion to vacate. that's the question. they give mike johnson the least to make a deal with democrats. and then i guess i would defer to elise expertise, having come out which brian whether these guys are ready to select another speaker. >> it's not going to be to, brightening. >> really, it's going to be the puppet master donald trump telling them exactly what he wants congress to do. we'll leave it there. i don't know about you, ron, but ali and tim definitely deserve to go to bet right now. thank you all for being here. you've had a long 48 hours. when we come back, donald trump wasn't person for the start of another civiltr

johnson of ohio announced that he will resign come january 21st in order to become the new head of youngstown the dust. normally, a single lawmakers leaving capitol hill wouldn't even be that big of a deal. but recall that johnson's departure comes after the expulsion of everyone's favorite self made up man, former representative george santos, and former house speaker kevin mccarthy's retirement before the holidays. when you put all of these three departures together, it means that the gop and the house, their seat total is going to shrink to just a mere 2019. and that's just one seat more than the bare minimum necessary for a majority. of this has major implications for party leaders. not only will maga mike johnson and company have to walk a proverbial balance being to find the votes necessary in order to keep the government open an operational, but also secure funding for the border, israel, and ukraine. but this year, a magical shrinking will turn 2024 into a quote, barn burner, as put by the wall street journal. gop leaders will have to be more pragmatic and more selective when choosing

then kevin turkeys marbles and went on, bill johnson became the president of youngstown, states are tardyge johnson by the same standards you adjudge mccarthy, because he doesn't have the same majority mccarthy had, in part because mccarthy left. >> you kicked mccarthy out of his job. you've got to say that part. >> only four of us were willing to do the job without -- being >> just one last thing. you're saying you cannot hold speaker johnson to the same standard, but he is now passed to continuing resolutions, which you said was unacceptable when kevin mccarthy did it. is speaker johnson's job in jeopardy? if only for that reason? >> no. again, as i said, it wasn't one thing with mccarthy. it was an accumulation of misrepresentations, lies, in the sense that we were being sold, out time and again in these negotiations. with johnson he's been very clear upfront when he has a one seat majority to balance the needs of a diverse caucus, trying to get this into a fighting posture. it's my hope, my expectation, that we get into that fighting posture before taking the third strike of a third c

congressman bill johnson of ohio resigned from the house in a few weeks to start his new job as president of youngstownepublican majority gets even slimmer as they try to pass key spending bills this year. johnson's visit nation follows the departure of former house speaker kevin mccarthy in the expulsion of former congressman george santos, leaving the house with 219 republicans, 213 democrats, and three vacancies. this means republicans can only afford to lose two votes on any piece of legislation. the republican debate that is taking place just 12 days before the iowa caucus will feature only two candidates. cnn announced florida governor ron desantis and former u.s. ambassador nikki haley and former president trump made the cut, but trump is going to skip the debate of course, opting instead to buy dissipate and a town hall with fox news the same evening. willie? >> joining us now in the studio, publican presidential candidate former governor the great state new jersey chris christie. governor, good to see. you >> get to see, you. happy new year >> you miss the polling threshold on the debate stage

bill johnson became the president of youngstown state.s hard to judge johnson by the same standard as mccarthy because he doesn't have the saima jordan mccarthy had, in part because mccarthy left. >> you kicked mccarthy out of his job. you forgot that part. >> 434 of us who are willing to do the job without being speaker. >> just one last thing. you're saying you cannot hold speaker johnson to the same standard. but he has now passed two continuing resolutions, which you said was unacceptable when kevin mccarthy did it. is speaker johnson's job in jeopardy if only for that reason? >> no. again, as i said, it wasn't one thing with mccarthy. it was an accumulation of misrepresentations, lies in the sense that we were being sold out time and again in these negotiations. with johnson, he has been very clear up front when he has a one-seat majority having to balance the needs of a diverse caucus, trying to get us into a fighting posture. it is my hope, it is my expectation that we get into that fighting posture before taking the third strike o

the case of youngstown by the supreme court reviewed harry truman's seizure of the steel mills during the korean war. there is the case of little buream where chief justice marshall reviewed the actions of president adams when he seized certain vessels. how does that square with your position that judiciary can never review executive action? >> all those cases fall squarely within the well established exception and ex parte young where the judiciary is allowed and does frequently issue declaratory judgments and judgments against subordinate officers -- >> these are presidents. harry truman was the president when he seized the steel mill. how does that comport with your theory? >> that case was an injunction against the secretary of -- not against the president. this court reaffirmed recently you cannot enter strongly indicates that the court -- >> we can review presidential action if on paper they direct their judgment to a subordinate officer. is that what you're saying? these are presidential actions. >> the court can definitely enjoin the actions of subordinate officers that violat

let's go back to our phone lines and talk to sandy, calling from youngstown, ohio.dy, good morning. caller: hi, good morning. i support trump, because he is not owned■s by all the lobbyists and politicians. so, therefore, he does not have to destroy this country because that is what the elitists want to happen and that is what they are doing now. why do you think they are overrunning the country with illegals constantly? who was it that said about future voters -- exactly. desantis said that trump did not build a wall. he was fought the whole time. he tried and was fought a lot. he almost had it done when he lost the election. so -- nikki haley did say that she wanted to raise the, 65 was too low. i agree with trump, they will not just stop at the young people. also, desantis as good -- is for florida as a governor, but also, where is he getting his money? lobbyists. he has done some -- i think sold some land to chinese in florida. so, wait a minute. yeah. well, anyway. it does not matter what republican gets in the office. republicans are always attacked by democra

let's go back to our phone lines and talk to sandy, calling from youngstown, ohio.dy, good morning. caller: hi, good morning. i support trump, because he is not owned by all the lobbyists and politicians. so, therefore, he does not have to destroy this country because that is what the elitists want to happen and that is what they are doing now. why do you think they are overrunning the country with illegals constantly? who was it that said about future voters -- exactly. desantis said that trump did not build a wall. he was fought the whole time. he tried and was fought a lot. he almost had it done when he lost the election. so -- nikki haley did say that she wanted to raise the, 65 was too low. i agree with trump, they will not just stop at the young people. also, desantis as good -- is good for florida as a governor, but also, where is he getting his money? lobbyists. he has done some -- i think sold some land to chinese in florida. so, wait a minute. yeah. well, anyway. it does not matter what republican gets in the office. republicans are always attacked by demo

dan is next from youngstown, ohio. good morning, dan. go ahead. caller: ok, i want to start out by saying any of these republicans, any of them, will be better than joe biden. what the democrats have done to our country is an absolute sin. i want people to understand we are involved in two wars that we were not involved in before joe biden took office. also, whether democrats talk about threat to democracy, give me a break. the democrats are the ones that will limit who could run against joe biden in the primary. what they did to kennedy is a shame. he was a good candidate who should have been heard. host: as a republican but do you have a republican that stands out today and iowa? caller: yes. now they are attacking their opponents. as i said, i thought any of the democrats would be better than joe biden. but the reason i am going for donald trump is because the way that opponents attacked him and the rules they are making to keep him off the ballot, what you see how badly they want to keep him out of the election, that is all the reason that we

dan is next from youngstown, ohio. good morning, dan. go ahead.aller: ok, i want to start out by saying any of these republicans, any of them, will be better than joe biden. what the democrats have done to our country is an absolute sin. i want people to understand we are involved in two wars that we were not involved in before joe biden took office. also, whether democrats talk about threat to democracy, give me a break. the democrats are the ones that will limit who could run against joe biden in the primary. what they did to kennedy is a shame. he was a good candidate who should have been heard. host: as a republican but do you have a republican that stands out today and iowa? caller: yes. now they are attacking their opponents. as i said, i thought any of the democrats would be better than joe biden. but the reason i am going for donald trump is because the way that opponents attacked him and the rules they are making to keep him off the ballot, what you see how badly they want to keep him out of the election, that is all the reason that we sh

bill johnson of ohio will resign from the house in a few weeks to start his new job as president of youngstowneparture, the house republican majority gets even slimmer, as they try to passkey spending bills this year. johnson's resignation follows the departure of former house speaker, kevin mccarthy, and the expulsion of former congress manning, george santos, leaving the house with 219 republicans, 213 democrats, and three vacancies. this means republicans can only afford to lose two votes on any piece of legislation. the republican debate that's taking place just 12 days before the iowa caucuses feature only two candidates. cnn announced, florida governor ron desantis and former u.s. ambassador, nikki haley, and former president trump made the cut, but trump is going to skip the debate, of course, opting instead to participate in a town hall with fox news the same evening. willie? >> joining us in studio, former new jersey governor, republican presidential candidate, chris christie. you missed the polling quota, so what are your plans for that night? >> to make the polling threshold was not

youngstown state university.hallenge i felt i must working with our young people to shape the future excites me and gives me hope and zeal r the work ahead. this brings me to my main message today. it might seem out of step in today's culture, but it's something everyone must hear. the message is simple. america is exceptional. the founding fathers knew it.any declared it out loud, the rest of the worldoon found out that it was true also. they knew it too. those men laid down a foundation on the principles of personal liberty, free enterprise, and a representative government the people. it is, without a doubt, the greatest government everf human.