we will continue to develop the nuclear triad and maintain its combat readiness, since the nuclear shield has been and remains the main guarantor of the sovereignty and territorial integrity of our state. we will also increase the combat capabilities of the aerospace forces in terms of the operation of fighters and bombers in the area of ​​​​operation of modern air defense systems and in terms of improving unmanned aerial vehicles, our immediate plans are to expand the arsenal of modern strike weapons. estonia may become the first eu country to decide on open theft, frozen russian assets, according to bloomberg, the country's authorities expect to find legal grounds by the end of the month that will allow russians to pocket about 20 million euros in blocked accounts. ukraine intends to transfer to kiev an insignificant amount against the background of three hundred billion frozen reserves. the central bank of several billion euros of private individuals who fell under western sanctions, brothers, are dreaming in

brussels. however, they can figure out how to circumvent their own legislative norms while maintaining while the face. it is clear that the estonian authorities want to become an excellent student in this field and set a precedent for this. whatever actions are taken in this context. they will absolutely. uh, insignificant and illegal from the point of view of international law and certainly. they will have consequences for those countries that at least somehow identify with such a one. over 400,000 copies of prince harry's controversial book sold in a day. it contains unpleasant details of his personal life, as well as complex relationships within british royal families. harry talks about how he tried drugs and killed people in afghanistan about how relatives did not accept his wife, megan markova, an actress. yes , and a black daughter. in general, i took the skeleton out of the closet. now anyone can look behind the scenes at buckingham palace.

harry's memoirs have already received a fee of 20 million dollars, these revelations were rather critically received by the uk members of the royal family. they didn’t officially speak out, but books, but it is already known that harry’s participation is in question at the coronation of his father charles iii in may of that year. such news to this minute. see you soon. tell me, please, here is a question, you can even talk about a panacea in this. no. that's psychologically how how to deal with this oppression? yes, how to get away from this ideology, that this is kabbalah for life? i'm hanging shit yermo. i have a mortgage. you know how we'll go and have a drink there. i don't have a mortgage. yes , here, how psychologically, yes, you don’t need a mortgage if you spend more than 40% of your family money on loan repayment total income, for example, if you

get together with your spouse 100,000 rubles. and uh, they took a mortgage, then here's 40,000 rubles. for a fee. yes, it's comfort it's comfortable. and if it's 80,000, and you have 20 left to live, then it's very risky, it's mentally abnormal. you live the time in this light 'bout they forget that they should have no other loans. so it turns out, that is, we are talking about the total credit burden. let's be right, let's put it in this wording. write down what your total credit the load of all your loans on the blouse of your beloved woman and so on should not exceed 40% of the total income. if i, respectively, you are the only breadwinner in the family, then your income, returning to the topic of credit holidays. still, is it profitable or not? or is it just a pause. if you have increased your work and you don’t have an airbag, of course, go take a better credit vacation until you get

the strength to earn money there and start going to the schedule. because if you didn't take a credit holiday, and you delay. and it ruins your credit history. this is very much reflected later, because if there are several delays, the bank can ask you to ask for a loan, or sell an apartment, that is, you can’t joke with this and the second. e unpleasant. yes, in this that, and you will wind up singing fines. and, well this debt is just going to increase. therefore, if you cannot pay money, no, none of the neighbors or friends have borrowed there, then it is better to take a loan. well, another 20 or 30 years. it's just one time therefore, here for everyone, in fact, loss of work or envy, either with health problems and at this time lacquer. yes, we have these tools. they used it a lot, because, well, there was a difficult case, that there was a lot of insane amount of information to collect, not all banks

accept no, or the procedure was quite simple, as we used to, there are my documents. yes, with e- government. it was simple or not a discovery. so, whether it was simple or not, the rules needed to send an e-mail to your manager that you sick, and well, roughly speaking, yes, but if er people forgot about it for some reason and then says, well, i was here in the hospital. well, as it were, but the bank did not yet know about this and the singing of fines. oh, unfortunately, even through the court it is already impossible to return. yes, therefore discipline is still needed for the borrower. look, the borrower should give no more than 40% mortgage loves discipline, because all people. really, even if it's easy money, you know, like, uh, it's easy to go, it's easy to come. yes, something like that was not money. this also such a hack. what is lateral? yes, off topic. eh, please, despite the fact that our money program is called easy money. yes, money is

still serious, it is a serious tool, and they really do not like a frivolous attitude towards them . that is, as soon as you news on your own, you probably know, as soon as you start to take money lightly. they also start to you with a frivolous and leave. yes, well yes, yes disciplined and likes extroverts. and now, when you return, you want to take out an extrovert mortgage, available in mind, you should rather come to work ask your employer. in which bank is he, uh, the salary project has yes, because the salary project is very often minus another 1%, that is, so you can take under 10% , let's say. please write the salary project of the bank that you take. the bank knows that this company is good. it pays your salary on time and is ready to support employees. and there are some moments right at many banks on salary projects, mortgages are cheaper. at 0.5 1%, and this savings is enough serious. yes, accordingly, you must communicate with the accounting department, because if you

take out a mortgage, you can save money, and on the return of income taxes. if you take an apartment once and buy it, well, once in a life a person is given a benefit, you will also receive personal income tax back on the cost of the apartment. that is, you should generally talk, yes, with your accountant, so that he will tell you in this case. uh, when we say extrovert, that is, we say a person of communication in all areas of finance, which are institutions. yes, sorry for the difficult words in institutions that surround you dear viewers. eh, that is, first of all, this is your bank, where your experience works. this is your accounting department, which the legislation will tell you, maybe lawyers, yes, which the bank and he tells you, and now you need to insure your object. and accordingly, he will roll out to you, there are 10-15 insurance companies, his beloved, his beloved, he will tell you if it is not

credited, he won’t, well, you won’t be able to, but out of these fifteen, he can tell us. here come on in this one, but you should better ya i recommend calling. all 15, because the difference between insurance premiums can reach 15-20 percent or more. how do you know how. well, i don't think it's some uh russians. yes, i think that any person, he does not like extra fees on the cool ones. yes, here it is like this. well, there is this, this is the first thought about how to remove all this. yes, i want a percentage, yes, and find out what i need here now, insurance there is an estimate there, i don’t know even insurance, it can be like death taxes. it's something you can't avoid here. yes, and an estimate. that you can't avoid if you take out a mortgage, right? i’ll give you a life hack from myself to make it easier for you to cope with this load. i, uh, recommend doing the following

, here we sounded. this is irina's words. uh airbag. let's have a few words, i 'll tell you what an airbag is, which will help you deal with these unforeseen expenses a little easier. so you're here, do you think, uh, the housing meter is inflated or not? that's exactly the same. take the last year. it is not difficult. don't take any extras spending vacation from him vacation. here, take your average month. yes, let's say that, maybe there is some kind of march or well, no, in march, there is march 8, there are gifts for september october. let's take october for some month there, let's say, and, uh, april. well, there is nothing there but the day, laughter. yes , there, well, laughter, it is inexpensive and only breaks through life. here, take a few months when you don't have an extract and just count your family's expenses. all expenses. that is, you bought something, i don’t know there. well, not without major purchases without refrigerators. it's just wednesday. costs without any medical surgeries here are the average expenses of your family on this whole family.

that's all for whom you are responsible, yes, financial, that's where your children go. children from the ex-wife are there, if there are parents, the wife's parents or you, if i am alone, then only you are there and your beloved girl does not matter. so you multiply this amount by six. and this amount should be at home in cash in rubles or in a bank. as you wish in the cell, but in the cell is not on the account. you must come to terms with the fact that this money should be they will not bring you any income. they won't ask for food. forget inflation. here they are just there and at any moment that arises you know how we say contingencies, let's talk. so these are the mortgage costs. they are not foreseen when you consider the interest rate. you always forget about them. here. actually, including on such expenses, you will spend your airbag. hope it will a small amount, which then you will be able to fulfill what else to look at. the agreement is somewhere else. that's what now supply you know some. well, what are your pitfalls? yes, good question. and if you take out a mortgage,

journalists very often ask, but is it worth paying attention to which bank. uh, what kind of credit rating, forget it, when you lend money to a house bank, of course, check all licenses, uh, deposit insurance and so on. but when you take the money, you don't care. well, if the bank rolls you out later , i apologize for my french claim, yes, and take the apartment. the bank will never take the apartment in this situation, if you fulfill your obligations, the bank has lost its license. so that's his problem. this bank already has a lender who will buy. there is never one here in our country, and the lender of this bank will not be able to change the terms of your mortgage agreement, which is registered in egen. that is, it is generally simple. well, here is the constitution. well, although they are changing it, but once again, change the loan agreement, no one can, except you, what who gives and well, then here, we are not

capricious, we take from those who give less give less interest. and here, it doesn't matter to you. yes, something happened to him. so that's his problem. you and i figured out that the bank cannot worsen our conditions, let's say, our bank. hey lender. we ourselves in the back we simplify easier. you and i can let's that's why about emergency yes, and about the fact that even if you took a mortgage for 20 years, relax, stroke you took 13%, for example, there is some kind of, well, not i know in the seventeenth year, and already the rate was 6%, and in the secondary market it was possible to refinance at 7%. so you could save from 13 to seven. and well at 6% by half, almost reduce its credit burden to refinance. yes, and what banks

did it, did everything, and do it now, almost all banks have, uh, a refinancing program. if you show them that you have been paying for six years, you are normally solvent borrowers. and if you translate with great pleasure, you are embarrassed to be extroverts, urgent, go to the bank and find out if they have the opportunity to move, well, the bank is reluctant, of course, of course, then i recommend that you go to another bank and take a loan decision, that is, changes. this can be done normally, see you can repay an early loan. e after six months on average 6 months are only given. well, when you took it, the question is how best, how best to make better early repayment or systems or you have a payment amount, this is very individual, for example, you want to reduce your credit load? well, that is, you paid 40% there,

but now you want to relax more often than before? yes, and you better reduce 40,000 to thirty there and you have some amount. you can repay and pay yourself for the remaining 10 years. yes, but already 30,000, not 40 or vice versa. you want to reduce the term, but leave the amount the same, that is, depending on your personal moment, all the main hits of the nineties, my cover. ice, nobody takes me to my only light pen.

a-a on friday on the first, look here, let's go then. let's go back to the first question again. to take or not to take? yes , to take or not to take a mortgage. that is the question, as the great playwrights said. yes? uh, from one nearby island or distant, and so, in fact, i'm here for myself. and you know, he brought out such a very interesting psychological form. i, too, can be recorded as a life hack. here you tell me, please, as a professional, how true is it? uh hmm, when people ask me, uh, well, because i'm also very seriously involved in finance for a long time. at they ask me. here, uh, after all, mikhail doesn’t take a mortgage, but there are acquaintances of mish , well, tell me that it’s clear quickly. i say this

is how true the answer is. i say look here. here you take for yourself a certain amount, which you pay as a monthly installment to repay the loan. so you must very clearly imagine this amount on one side of the scale, and here on the other side of the scale. unfortunately, again, paper is indispensable. you write out all the advantages that you have, but from the fact that you already live in a new apartment. well, do you live there? separately there with their older children who grew up there, either they resettled their parents or improved their living conditions, or they changed paradise, or there they just came closer to work, that is, i say, here you are compare this amount, and here is this list with e , preferences, which, well, there are benefits, uh, the joys that you received, and here's a very simple question. you are ready to pay this amount for this list. let me simplify here. there is a list, of course, maybe,

everyone has their own individual there, and so on, but there is, uh, such a form was banal. real estate usually rises in price and inflation, at least. if it rises in price, you know, if you said it should rise in price, i would ask you, who should find it left, only there it rises in price at times. of course, it fails, but in general it overtakes inflation. how else can you save your savings. suppose you are not a player in the stock market and so on. and you have some kind of income, that deposits, they are now two times lower than inflation. how do you save their purchasing power difficult question about inflation. after all, we have our own bond. i think most of her know russian narodnaya sreda. the best pension fund is odnushka near the tochka metro station. therefore, if your financial situation now allows you to take out a mortgage and buy real estate. do it, but before that, i still wanted a little

theory. okay, let's just ask a question. that is, you think that the mortgage let 's take a term. i'm not talking about 30 years. this is a lot, but let's say 10 years, that is, a mortgage for 10 years in its growth. overtake. e inflation. so that it will also pay off your interest on the loan, that is, it will also surpass the interest on the loan. but we all know what the stock market is. and if you want, so yes, i 'll send you a wonderful slide one, a respected brokerage company has done an analysis you've kept since the year 2000 for 22 years. you kept money in rubles in dollars on the stock market, various stocks, bonds or in real estate. what is russia and real estate in moscow the focus of the question? who do you think won? i think we won, well dollars

won, no, no, moscow won, moscow real estate, real estate, which is always in price. of course, it gives a drawdown, so look when you want, and make the right strategic decision for yourself to enter now or wait, for example, yes, here is the market, yes, the mortgage market. he is so you know, he is based on three pillars. and the first whale is actually. the real estate itself. yes, as far as there is a choice. now. i’m saying that it’s not that there is an outlier, yes, but it still won’t withstand the buyer, of course, investors haven’t left yet, who invested in the previous fat years, when they were buying, and now the real estate market has everything from this. yes, that seems to be good, right? well, one more time. let's get out of this market. the big second option is actually the mortgage itself. how

accessible is it? well, in general, 8% given that inflation is 12 1/2. well, and so on. yes? in general, in principle, affordable mortgages. agree. in america, i have an american friend, he bought 7.3 terribly, how they live there, that's america and you are under six, he says you the best mortgages, but they all you buy a new building and pay six percent for 20 years. that is, after all, now there are six for all; we had six for all there a year ago. there are seven now for 80 a year ago. well, now you . if you have a minor child, so take it, big markets are dripping normal rates in relation to inflation. they are normal, they are lower than inflation, which, in principle, is also quite interesting. said from the start, look at your employment, because if you lose your

source of income taxi previous two hits, let them float away. they are not for you, because if you can't, yes you can't fast within 6 months. as long as you have credit holidays, when you group up and find a job with an income no less than it was, then this is too adventurous a risky operation. and well, you may find yourself without real estate, or you will need to sell it. perhaps there, again in the market, when there will be a recession and fix losses, that is, here is the third whale about your profitability. maybe he is the most important even yes? let's let's talk a little about the market. now i will finish. that's when the three whales is fine and the market is normal. uh, you can choose yes there is another form, if you are not tired of writing down, i recommend. look, you made a 20% deposit initially. and the bank tells you that for 10 years you will have, uh, some kind of monthly

payments. well, let's say there is 50,000 rubles. for this apartment. go a to ads. and look how much it costs to rent the same apartment, if the payment after you paid, however, 20% is the same plus or minus another 10%. take a good time to invest in real estate in march february you want to buy an apartment so here. uh, look now, because so many citizens now sell urgently. the number of urgent sales has increased, uh, there by 30% of the state. we are waiting for something. here you are as a member of the law enforcement group. i believe that the state is now quite well supporting both developers and young families with maternity capital, because the president promised everything has already been

done, that is, all the statements of the state everything that the state can do in terms of developing real estate demand has already been done. of course, i would also recommend that legislators still develop individual housing construction, because individual housing construction. somehow, it stays on the sidelines all the time. it is this and investments in building a house and a mortgage on a fence are very difficult to get and rates. there are very unfriendly, so here is this market. i think it still needs to be supported, because here is one-story america yes, here it is. it 's the same with fertility. well, in short, people even we don’t expect anything else from the state, i would like our state to support those who want to live on the earth, build their houses, and ennoble the plots. well, because once again this is development. eh, our

cities there. well, there are not necessarily large ones there, yes, a and the suburbs is an increase in the birth rate. here we are now being born. well , then the opportunity for people. in the house, not sorry, we are now mainly talking about those who are going to buy a house. let's turn our eyes a little towards those who are going to sell their homes, because among those who are going to buy a home. yes , they are actually the same citizens do not sell their previous housing. yes, because someone takes a down payment from this. someone there is not really originally there for the most part. yes, for sales now, in the context of what you said, that the market is overheated a little, yes, that is, the prices are not a little bit, but they are twice as high . now is a good time for sale, that is, to sell old apartments or hold. that is, we take a mortgage on this apartment, we leave what we we do, yes, and the sellers are all divided into two categories: first they sell in order to buy something else. so for such exchange chains there is no difference, e always spring

everything is fine. if you want to sell with the market, which is more profitable to leave it and buy you will grow , for example. you need to leave, i have money for a down payment. eh, according to the current situation on the market, this apartment that i live in is better to leave the old one to take a mortgage, that is, it is more profitable to take a mortgage. see if you want to leave like this hmm i can tell you time is such that it is better to sell. if you want to leave, for example, renting it out can upset you. and there is no profit there, especially from renting out. that is 4%. it's ridiculous, it's better to put this money under 80 now on a deposit, you know, and grow. she is unlikely to be there for years to come. yes, this is even at best, it is simple without taking into account taxes and so on. this is very, because our prices have risen a lot per square meter. they are 30% you said in 10 years. we are already talking about

what you need to twist now. yes it is in next 2-3 years. there, you are unlikely to earn money in russia, and again. why is it better to sell? and immediately make a down payment and take out a small mortgage, if it’s not enough, because your credit load is still turbulent times in us. e extra. you know, you don’t have to take on debts, or what if you suddenly have a dilemma, what to do with an old apartment to sell? that is, we take a mortgage, sell an old apartment, thereby killing. there are two birds with one stone, the first we, uh, get the money for the down payment. and not only a large amount on a sharp sharply reduces loans and sharply reduces the credit burden. great, thank you very much for those stories for those life hacks. i hope that we are together. well, you helped, uh, and you, especially our viewers, to understand this issue, but uh, let's focus, after all, in such a way that we already hoped for god, and

god has already given us the entire state in practice. now it remains for us not to say it ourselves, but to be extroverts to follow the numbers, as we have told you and actually. discipline to hold and try to take easy money really seriously so that it brings us happiness and joy. thank you i am sergey tomysh, i will tell you today about films and series that i think can help you fill your time if you have free time. you'll want some quality movie because the series. i am also into cinema. just a movie long and unusual by and large, when the series were just starting to come out and we

remember these old series, then, but the series differed all the same, well, the pictures in the cinema were a better picture than the series now the series. eh, they increased it so much and so it is, as they say, in the trend, that by and large the picture they have is in no way inferior. and we, of course, must remember the house of the dragon. and if you, for example, love the game of thrones, but if you love the game of thrones, most likely you have already watched the dragon's house, but still i can't help but say about it, because it is very interesting and a twist. and when we all thought that there would be a prequel to the game of thrones. we thought he would. what a sophisticated one, just as cruel and full of events, but it turned out to be a completely different series full of intrigue, but this may make it intellectually much more exciting , not to mention the fact that some acting work is simply perfect when we talk about series that we can review. in fact. there are

series like poirot that everyone likes or a series like miss marple yes they are with different uh different whole big series and they are always good for the holidays because there is not much scary not murder. they also exist, but not like this. at least no one likes them. agatha christie started. this is the order, defined in some direction hmm in detective stories, which are very seriously supported. she was generally an amazing woman full of wit. you know, she told her friends, girls, marry archaeologists, the older you stop, the more interesting they are for you , and she was a completely outstanding writer and why and her detective stories that formed the basis of the series, which i remembered are very good and everything looks. i call it an escalator. you got up and left. yes, that is, the film carries you by itself. i need absolutely no effort from you, but by and large, when we

talk about the series. i say there are completely different tv shows, yes, from different countries, and someone loves asian tv shows, someone loves turkish tv shows, who loves indian tv shows, but who loves french tv shows and even italian tv shows, there are not so many of them, but they are always very elegant dedicated there when they devoted to fashion, this series happens. eh, completely different. i wanted to draw your attention to documentaries and specific series and the age of cinema one of the producers of which is tom hanks tom hanks is a big movie buff himself. watch the movie, that is, he tries to keep the audience in the present and and probably that's why they got such a wonderful action. this is the history of hollywood in six episodes. and i would like to dwell on it a little more, because it will enable me to remember several films that can really make you happy. if you love movies so when we talk about hollywood

hollywood uh amazing place in california and in america they made movies in big cities before 1910, they made big cities and movies. you were filming with him for 2 days and there were problems with the weather, because if you were filming some kind of west there in the fresh air near chicago, it started to rain, you would lose shooting shooting days, and at some point the group that filmed the film the montetist count got to california and they stopped telegram from there that everything needs to be filmed here, if the weather is ideal, oranges grow, everything is fine and whole, as they say, a whole delegation at the head asks him griffith there griffith is one of the four main navators of world cinema directors and mary here or angesh, they went together and understood, that this is an ideal place to create a cinema capital there and slowly the studios moved there, and here are all these famous studios. like warner brothers or mgm and paramount universal uniteds. a columia picture serco that is, uh they were such major powerful studios

that created cinema in the beginning, not mine, but in the twenty-eighth year sound came and appeared, but sound cinema and i would like to pay attention when we talk about holidays or generally irradiate the mood in the twenty-eighth year in america the great depression hit and all the uh, movie moguls called washington and said that now they need to make three types of films or comedies. to laugh, or melodramas, to cry over strangers, or american action films. these are mostly westerns, and on that and they also decided this golden period of cinema, about which the first series of the documentary series i was talking about is dedicated to, but after all, the movie just lasted from 28 to forty- one years, sometimes it is extended to the fifties, but honestly it is the forty-first that is cut off, because it's america's entry into the war and therefore, uh, a movie theme. everything changes. it was a period of absolute takeoff. hollywood is made by top

stars. that is, there appears probably a garba, which if you want to see a real melodrama, you must watch the lady benches greta garba, but you know, no one rose from such a bottom, she was the youngest daughter of a stockholm garbage man and became the main star of engineering. and i, perhaps, could have had much more time to tell her biography, but believe me, if you look at the lady with the camellias. it makes a very big impression, just in the era of cinema. very interesting sharon stone talks about this harvard. well, there is also marlin dindrikov for one russell calligrand. well, there are many actors and actresses. i would like to draw your attention to several films, first of all, the fieldelphian story, the fieldelphian story, beautiful picture that cattenhamber plays. hay grand and james stewart and katherine hamberlain are famous for having four oscar title roles in their career, no one has that many, that is. she is an absolute record holder, languages

​​said that she was given oscars because she never came to the ceremony, which is true, but of course not because she was an amazing actress and beautiful in both dramas and comedies, so i really appreciate it i recommend the fieldelphia story midnight stock, no matter how it is absolutely amazing and very cute, the picture is full, but unforgettable jokes. eh, it is from there that each cinderella has her own. ivanovich is a walk with a jaguar or raising a baby, this is again more like a grant, we are for this, these are such wonderful comedies that you should watch or, for example, wife against the secretary, where you can see the great jin harla exactly the woman that she taught the women of the world to become blondes, she was the first to lighten her hair before the movie platinum blonde. and after that as they said company representatives. max factor hydroperite is out of stock. it was so big and very bright. jean harla's very short career died at the age of 26 from torture

insufficiency, but, until now, films with her participation look very lively and very bright witty no longer against the secretary. she plays with the peaceful loy hmm the world in him and about her it is necessary to remember especially, because when in the fortieth year they conducted a survey among americans who is the king and queen of hollywood, then, of course, they recognized the king clark gable. this was after the success of gone with the wind. and the queens sent mirny loy and recognized her as a milanula, which, alas , they don’t know in russia, but she is a wonderful actress, the whole series of a thin person behind a thin person is the shadow of a thin person. am. these are absolutely charming detectives, very witty, so i recommended you about golden hollywood uh comedies that will brighten up a couple of hours each of them and of course, if, for example, i remembered gone with the wind, then there is such a wonderful mini-documentary. i don't know movie series from several parts, the history of creation or how gone with the wind was filmed. and that's also

extremely exciting, actually, if we go to the fifties, we 'll see. and of course the appearance of slowly monroe or forget taylor and audrey helbert actresses who are still the rulers of thoughts, an actress who endlessly continue to release books. they are long gone, and write magazines. and, of course, um. you have to watch because there are so many fans. drehaber, especially among the younger generation, oddly enough, young girls are very do. well, that is, they talk a lot about her style about how they love films with her, for example, there is such an amazing drama with her, however, i warned you that this is a drama children's hour, where she played william wyler, and hmm such a very difficult dramatic role. they sewed mccain together there, almost no one saw him, so it seems to me that any holiday and at any time can be spent on watching some pictures with your favorite stars that you haven’t seen before, well, or

revisiting any movie deadly monroe be it how to marry a millionaire. or gentlemen prefer blondes. she was very indignant. she was paired with jane russell and jane russell got double the pay because she spoke slowly, but that 's not fair. the gentleman prefers blondes here, i was absolutely true . the fact that some people like to watch hotter the film that was in the russian box office in the soviet box office under the name jazz, only girls. wu aan, of course, very witty and you can watch it again in any company, and there alone at any time of the day, and he always wanted to star in a very dramatic relationship on the set. all were difficult. they made the funniest comedy in the history of cinema. and when we talk about beat whiter. uh, there is a rare director who knows how to shoot, and pictures, but the lion genre.

we must remember the apartment was sewed makleinut by jack lem, which i highly recommend to you. there, too, miraculously the new the year of christmas and this is probably one of the most poignant films that golden hollywood has ever created. and just this series, the age of cinema, it takes place throughout the year. he recalls the sixties, he says, there i don’t know the actress of the actors that we don’t know, for example, hmm at some point the highest grossing star in america was dorisday, and then julia andrews well, julia andryush, we somehow because of the sound of music you know in russia or for mary poppins because families with children usually have this disc cassette, there you can call it whatever you like, but before cutting. we do not know at all, and she was a hyperstar of her couple for a hudson term. these are just one of the most famous romantic comedies that, again, existed there in the fifties and sixties. uh, so if we are talking about the fact that there are a huge number of films to watch, it may seem to you

that i am talking about old cinema. i'm just talking about the movie's proven time, because when you watch '68 the lion is in the winter. this ain't harvey is where anthony's movie debut hopkins and debut, but timati dalton, and there are beautiful petra from there, just in time for this khyber, the third oscar she received for this picture the story of how henry ii does not celebrate christmas together. family, but it is impossible to break away. there is such a text that at some point you just can’t perceive it, it’s so accurate, thin , bright and unusual, so, for example, you know, it’s amazing, of course, this is not a completely non-holiday picture, but if we remember the silence of the lambs one of the three films in the history of cinema, which received five major island. it was just a movie. this happened. one night we arrive as a cuckoo's nest. we didn't even win an oscar for best film of the year for directing, for best male female acting for screenwriting. so their silence was not written for jamie erens. michel feuer jamie said that if he plays another

psychopath his wife won't let him go home and michel feuer said he never does scary movies because he doesn't sleep well and we got an amazing pairing of anthony hopkins and jodie foster but that's a completely different movie exactly just like his completely different pictures, and in the godfather, instead of alpachins, nicholson should have played, for example, and instead of marlon brando, lawrence or i, it's always very interesting, who is who? for their careers, and which actors refused? what roles did they regret about it, for example, julia roberts turned down a lot of all sorts of films, starting there from an obscene proposal, ending with a basic instinct and always says in an interview that listen, i was absolutely right, these were not my roles, the girls did a great job. and there are those who say that they really sorry, really. we now see actors of major actors more, and in the series they appear quietly. now there are series about actors, as i said about how films are made, but this

documentary series of the film era, it can amazingly help you. well, that is, it will be such a little guide. you will know for sure. and what to miss, and what to focus on? a? will it be about elizabeth taylor or the leopatra. and you know, in principle, you can’t be a body destroyed, but modern cinema by the fact that she received the first million in the history of cinema. and everything was like that, and she was taking a bath and she called, the head of the xx century studio fox a and her then husband defisher picked up the phone. ah. and, and vote asked, tell me where and elizabeth to play a leopatra with us? go shouted. lisa you will play cleopatra she said. except for a million. that's how it's paid. first million. so they turned into fees in these huge fees that exist now, the budgets of films that are close to 100 million. and everyone is afraid of films. make simple films because they are afraid that they will not pay off. actually this

year. oscars will be awarded soon. and there is certainly something to see about this year. i'm not going to talk about previews now, we're talking more about tv shows and my long speech about the history of hollywood is connected with the fact that documentaries and good tv shows. especially those that can be world guides. movies are rare. but we, uh, should remember about them, not to mention the fact that if we still remember that we have new year's vacation, then of course we have to remember important pictures, such as it's an amazing life. it's an amazing life. frank capra was busy in 1946, according to the story of a writer who was refused publication by all publishing houses, and he sent out this story about how an angel comes to earth and shows a man. how sad the world would be without this man, and hmm he sent out a story to two people got in front of grant and grant said he was ready to play in it. in the end. played by james stewart but it doesn't matter. in general, when the picture came out

in 406. she did not have incredible success, but in the seventies, thanks to confusion in this department, which is responsible for the rights, she was recognized as a public one. well, you don’t have to pay for it anymore, they began to show it on all channels and now it’s impossible to imagine christmas without a movie. this is an amazing life of frank and actually there are amazing films there is uh a movie that we call the old new year actually it is exactly if it is translated, it will be the canon of the new year, that is, new yes if and they play there all whom here whom you want sarah jessica parker michelle feiffer zach and fron. ah, there's halle berry, uh, robert de niro. that's who you won't take everyone is playing. this is such a picture dedicated to what is happening in new york before the new year, many, many little stories intertwined. it looks great just like the much- maligned 200 cigarettes movie, but

it has such a cast, from courtney love to christina's speech. not to mention the hafleg brothers. ben decided to play in this film agreed to support the pension, which received a big role. and this picture is just dedicated to new year's eve, which is rarely known, that is, such films as the irony of fate, so that seven was dedicated to their new year's eve, and not so many in the world, so there is more, but the film, well, there is a lot of amazing pictures just to catch, if you want to see snow in the frame, and some studios in america just, and on this, but they specialize in making some films about christmas and about miracles that happen, when we talk about miracles, we should generally remember that miracles do happen to people, and we love by a miracle and believe in a miracle. and for this. we often watch movies, because we want something wonderful to happen in the cinema, and therefore what

should we recommend, if we want to pay attention, in the direction of russian cinema and russian tv shows. in fact, there are an infinite number of them, and among them there are very high quality ones. well, for example, clean. if we talk about film gourmandism, we can talk about an ordinary miracle, which is an ordinary miracle by mark zakharov and there is a screen version of the same play of the sixty-fifth year, which the iranian made with his wife. eh, and those are two completely different productions. i 'm just saying everything is very interesting to compare by and large, you can review any picture and look all the time for new ones, what to recommend? in fact, you know it's hard to say, because we hmm talked about the fact that it's important not only what you like and only your preferences in terms of the country of origin, but some kind of genre. and also what you need now, because, and we live, and in such a fast time that we sometimes need to

be different. we want to be in demand in different ways and we want different topics, and we want some different knowledge, so you just need to watch very high-quality films, because when you tell, it's interesting and i call cinema a story. it's impossible to get away from it. there are also drug addicts prostitutes in the history of these simply. how did this happen in your clinic under your nose you answer? i won't leave it like this. well, at least be silent already, yes, they were already silent in the small town of small children. there people will start eating each other. let's go through the newspapers.

explain everything, you will be naive or stupid with us , if the virus gets into the donor blood bank, it will infect thousands through them millions. do not come any more, by the way, look at the conversation about children. this virus is the most dangerous enemy. and hiv itself is a dangerous virus zero pns, a big premiere on january 16 at the first to find the source of infection of patient zero. when we talk about hollywood - it's never ending the source of all sorts of amusing stories, and they are given just by the stars who played a lot in the movies. and uh, you see, they didn’t have

pr people, then they had to get out of everything themselves, and there were very exotic stars, for example, there were two of them. uh, tanning sisters eva kabar. they were hungarian by origin and did not learn english very well, so they usually played either foreigners or aliens. and his gabor once went up in an elevator with a man turned around and said, listen, from somewhere i know you for sure. he told eva i was your husband. in general, the gabbro was also a woman, and as they say, she is very witty, but, that is, she quotes endlessly, a women's magazines. she was married nine times and was asked what you think about sex. he said that i know about sex in the eyes. and by and large hollywood stars were very witty. it was when they talked about their personal lives that few people know that, and scarlett haru was supposed to play talo, benson tolobekhen herself was from atlanta her dad was the chairman of the us senate and from all sides. she was very proud of this role, but by and large. she was prone to

falling in love and at some point she fell in love with a rider and left with him for the ranch, thus losing him. and hope to play scarlett hara and she was, an outstanding actress played a lifeboat in hitchcock, they highly recommend this picture to you. hitchcock is generally good for tickling the nerves of the holidays. the fact that, and once she entered, uh, the ritz hotel restaurant, saw her senator lover, who was sitting with his wife not turned his head. she approached him and said. listen to me that you are already dressed and do not recognize even approximately. uh, here is the book, when i read her biography she consists of endless jokes like her, everyone dreamed that the ticket would never remember them, she lived a really bright life on both sides of the atlantic she played in the theater and in am in america on broadway and in london a. it’s just that

when we talk about stars, it’s some kind of system and context for creating any picture, it’s very interesting, because when there are films that were played in actors who didn’t talk to each other in my frame, for example, the famous wuthering heights, where merle burron plays florence olivier. you see, i still remember golden hollywood because, of course, there are many stories from there that did not fall under the censorship of squeakers, and there are prices when they run across the heather field and he turns her to him and kisses her after each take. for a long time he said your teeth are uneven, you peck anyway, imagine, and again they offended and again they hugged. this speaks of the outstanding talent of those actors who nas still make you cry, no matter what happens. in general, when we talk about hollywood of course, we can't avoid talking about awards, in general, fair and unfair oscar awards are the main topic usually in march. yes, when the ceremony

takes place in march. in the beginning, we wait for who will receive, and then we discuss and say whether it was worth giving to these people. you know, there was such a great actress sheli winters, very very famous and she was told every year that she would definitely get it at some point, and she sits at the ceremony. yes, of course you exactly this year you will definitely be given the person who leads the action. he says that patricia neal and at this moment or on her internet, maybe sit down, it's not you. and she says that it was with the equivalents she wrote that this is the most terrible moment that she experienced in her own life to go up to go after oscar when you were not called. this is generally quite interesting. there is a wonderful picture, which is called i called how many where everyone sits and talks about how they received an oscar just when we remember new year's films it's great to remember in the power of the moon sir, and in this picture the documentary

wool is very cool, he says. he says that he handed over half a newm and shows us this piece, and along with cher , meryl streep and glenn close and holly hunter and shir were nominated. speaks. i was very nervous, and he opened the envelope and breathed in, and i realized that it was not me, because in order to say wool you do not need to inhale. eh, there you know these little details, after which you watch the movie differently and listen to the story differently, at all. uh, there is a shera, in general, a great career of 60 years. every decade her music has been at the top of the charts for it's ability to be reborn all the time. it is generally very important if you work in film production or directors and for screenwriters. and oddly enough for writers, probably even more so, because you have to be relevant if we're talking about tv shows how can you reach out how can you reach out to young people? if, for example, you are not able to live with their problems, but i am sure of the opposite,

that if the session is of high quality or the film is of high quality, yes, then everyone will be able to watch it with interest, and i have watched this more than once, because there is a concept of a wife such as film therapy by and large, for example, michael is a famous english director who filmed one from harry potter, from whom he shot four weddings one funeral. here's another great picture of british comedy in general. yes, there is notting hill, for example, with the same julia, roberts hugh grant and hmm, which are very cool to review on holidays, as well. about real love, i don't even i say yes, and i highly recommend you, if you suddenly watch real love. look for a long version. it's an hour longer if the director's cut, a and that's, well, even funnier. there are a lot of entertaining pieces that were not included in the official version, in general director 's cuts. this is an interesting topic of conversation. because if you suddenly want

to see something obscene on new year's eve, then, of course, you can, but turn to ritli cattle. well, that is, you can watch old films of the ashes genre, as it is called films on historical, that is, ancient or biblical themes, which were filmed with a huge number of extras. and it's just very interesting, but also for scott filmed the kingdom of heaven, which was very cut when it was released, and after a while he made a director's cut. i highly recommend, firstly, and radish. that's basically all he does. it's very high quality, if you want. a romantic comedy is, if you ask me, i think the best date scene in a movie. it's in a good year. mm exactly. here's to the cattle. she is completely amazing. if someone has not seen, i will not do a spoiler. look, and, please, here, therefore, completely different countries. not to mention the fact that the same french comedies want, what kind of comedies do you want. and you can watch the comedy i love you, where she

gathers all her ex-husbands at the christmas table, namely, four of them play one. gianni plays the second. and the same dean collection of the third is played by jarre depardieu. this beautiful picture is very witty, which i'm afraid women will like more than men. the french have a lot of comedies comedies with louis de funes and by the way, he has a wonderful film oscar and at some point sylvester stallone i decided to reshoot the oscar and put his actions in america i think that it turns out no less funny than vic allo. funesa, by the way, you know, he is an amplification pianist by training. he played jazz, and he became an actor very late. it is very interesting his fate. his one time assistant director, accidentally noticed his reaction. he caught the handle of his coat and was in such a rage that he appeared got a tryout and he became a big star, so the big walk is watchable

the big walk was france's top-grossing film until the titanic came along. well, the titanic had a great story, too. again, i probably shouldn't recommend it for the holidays, because hmm it's a drama, but i want to tell you that titanic has an alternative ending. if you dig around on the internet, you can find it. it's very entertaining. see how titanic a ends in a different version, but they filmed it hmm funny and kate will come out very worried that she would have to undress. and in the scene where dc draws in front of her and she came to dc in his hotel room and said left. i will be very nervous all the time thinking about this scene. may i undress now? he said, of course he said, it won't get any easier. and as you can see, they then played perfectly well , by and large, when we talk about cinema, in general, the context of the whole movie is very interesting. and if i write these, but for example,

yes, there, i don’t know in the telegram channel. to me it seems that everyone should just be wondering who was supposed to play. who came up with the story. why did she move? why is the ending like this? and what happens on the set by chance and not to mention the fact that, of course, there are interesting relationships between the clans. the directors shoot very specific actors, they like to work with some specific actors. well, you know, like tandem, for example , at the end and december. i believe that dicaprio did not get an oscar for so long precisely because he sat in films with carter, and he showed only a very specific one. well , his talent, everything is just extremely interesting. you are actually i say, if you look and look for something for yourself at the holiday. you can watch the smiles of summer nights, the only comedy that the great norbergman made, and it's a really funny comedy. although it seems like the swedes are not very strong in terms of comedy, as such they are kind of under the frame and, of course, bergman himself is the greatest director you can watch? eh? i say any movie. the main thing is to watch it. the main

thing is to skip it and not treat it like something random, because by and large . well, every film here imagine yes , you catch it with your eye, but hmm, only less than a certain number of frames, imagine, when they edit a movie, how accurately they want, then the people who make the movie, as i say directors, and the editor-producer to convey to you very a certain thought. here are russian films. uh, great number and talk now about what to see. you need some specific ones, probably not worth it, but then again , if you get into the history of russian cinema of soviet cinema, this absolutely amazing absolutely amazing seventies, some beautiful paintings. e with margarita terekhova and like, who will go to truskavets or the night train, uh, which still looks very good. well, in my opinion, by and large , therefore, arrange such a movie

holiday for yourself and see, for example, there are four adaptations of hamlet in one yes, there, who plays with koktunovsky there in the second million plaster, the third there is kenneth brana. it's very entertaining. and most importantly, it's fun . and hmm to develop yourself, because you you begin to see very subtle things that have been laid down, but, of course, the holidays are given to us in order to relax and laugh all the time, so you can watch a funny comedy in the theater like crazy stage or go back to review it. series friends and any number of seasons, because strange as it may seem, it still looks quite fresh. here, well, what happened on this set, probably, well, not to mention the fact that there were so many. well, the stars. and it's very interesting state when you do, well, by and large, the list can be applied indefinitely. because everyone loves different

characters, everyone loves different actors, you know, it's just, for example, the same kim basinger, when we talk about her career, and no one thinks that there is no such career, no one else had her a girlfriend, bonda she played in the main erotic comedies of the eighties. i mean 10.5 weeks of adrenaline. she was batman girl and she won an oscar for l.a. secret. who even starved the strip is not, such a line there is an oscar, but there was no batman girlfriend, and even the king kong girls didn’t take it, so by and large. and hmm pick your favorite actors. look, find rare paintings, and we will help in this, and serials and films will save us. and if another wonderful film, rob reiner usually remembers about reiner when they talk about the rain man and some countries of the pictures that he made. and i, for example, really like to turn it on. and the american

president is a wonderful film about the american president he is raising a widower one daughter and michael douglas will win and he wants to make a date with a girl who is a lobbyist and is right. it's green and struggling to reduce carbon emissions. he needs to make an appointment. he doesn't find anything better when so there is a date at the moment when the president of france arrives. hmm, you know, this is such a touching film, everyone is crying in it. that is, the brightest tear, you know when. well, in general, there are some kind of romantic comedies, and we must, of course, remember them today. and here, well, the american president such. here's a great commission. you don’t think, of course, that this can happen to you, but it’s very pleasant for you to feel and see how things happen, how the hero fights for his relationship when we talk about, and such classic stories, that is, of course, films and how when we talk about hollywood, which were very seriously

in demand, and therefore they were filmed several times with different compositions, such as, for example, a star was born, which was, and the first film adaptation in the thirties was jenner gainer, and then josh kueker did. on my look, an outstanding film adaptation with judy harmonde and then there was a film with a woman, streisand and now here with lady gaga. uh, yes there, that went out enough. recently, i recommend you to look at the jigar of the fifties, it's really well done. a just like a romance that can't be forgotten, a or a love stories. sanya otbening hmm to beat with a horn. it's an absolutely touching story, just the last movie appearance for this, a very beautiful, very heartbreaking story. and this she will be. take it to him, this is a remake of the film by skyrigrant. remember in unholy everything loops. again, if we're talking about the movies that ahh, holding our hearts in our hands, these

are mcgray movies from a very specific period. this is a letter to you, and that's just it, but in the movie sleepless in seattle, the girlfriend of the main character. all the time she is retelling the film, this is a film novel that cannot be forgotten, and i understand that i call them so spontaneously, but believe me, they are all good, that is, they are good for the whole film adaptation. that is, i have, but in different years. do you like it is possible to find how you even prefer one film adaptation, and then another film adaptation, but there are just some more stars like well, the bar itself would be. and when we talk about hollywood, for example, the sixties, it's the studio system that is collapsing, because the system of contracts comes from the young . this is the scorsese generation of lucas spielberg's hooves yes, all of them, but at the same time some films continue to appear on the screens, which, but become hits for centuries, there is an institute that

revises. how much did the picture earn, as i already said and, for example, one of the leaders is the film the sound of music it is believed that the film the sound of music has no less fans than? ah, i mean, star wars, i mean, there are people who watch the sound of music once a month, and in london there is entertainment like that. there is one cinema, where the film sounds of a monster is on, you start from the sixty-fifth year. and you can come sing along as an actor on the screen, it's such a special attraction. and when we talk about how to shoot, there is no cinema, the secret of success, but uranus olivier jan wright said how great it is, he said at one bor festival, what a creative failure. this is the price of creative freedom, if you do the same thing all the time , you will do something very high quality, but you will never do it. you will not accomplish anything great, a breakthrough, you will not force people, but truly believe. this is the miracle of what is happening on the screen.

well, i propose to talk about christmas today, in fact, to something else. well , probably, yes, because, by the way, i was surprised. uh, i recently took an exam in the history of religion and the girl says that christianity arose there and something was happening again with dates. i say listen, well, a simple question. he says, well, yes, simple, i will help you , help. i say what year is it? 2022 and why and the first few seconds. that is, a person has a dead end, yes, then and it’s like semyonovich’s stirrups. well, listen, really, because the events divided the entire history of mankind before and after. here

i turned to you. father rules. i think we still need to introduce you, what if someone confuses you with the florensky sexual father, as i often do. yes well, naturally fine and well are familiar. we'll start with clergy archpriest. pavel giants is a professor of the moscow oven, which means that you will be a professor, usually in such cases they say, well, alexey nikolaevich you. today i want varlamov, a writer, a philologist, a philosopher, a culturologist, i will stop a step away from ours, from ours, and the rector of a literary institute. i am very glad to see you, dear friends, especially on this night. well, let's go back. yes, the events divided human history into before and after,

it's like i guess the most important thing here is that for the first time god announced himself so clearly, what? everything turned upside down. of people a lot of people thought about god and, probably, there was no such period when people would not imagine god in one way or another, and here something completely wrong happens obliquely. and well, from no point of view it can be said that this is what, in general, people expected. here, well, by doing this, god shows what is primary for him, what is secondary for him, what you know for me this year somehow christmas well, it opens in such a perspective, going wild for me, i don’t know why this year. what

relatively speaking, imagine there in the place of the mother of god, uh, some modern girl? here, well, somehow i think, everything would be very complicated and there is no place in the hotel, and some kind of bread and full there and everything else, but about christmas yes, yes, yes, everything is somehow everything is somehow . well, not as we would like, and now it turns out that call the manager. yes? yes, yes, yes . that 's what shocks me so far in some commits. but what do we know about god the son of god, he incarnates only once, that is, there

will be no other format of incarnation for him. he will not be able to replay this some kind of computer game. let's have this option. and let's go to such a scenario, that is, it turns out that for him this is not some kind of accident, this is extremely important. that's to enter into people's lives in this way, absolutely crooked, absolutely wrong, absolutely not pretentious. yes, uh, without a chariot at all, accompanied sideways sideways. and you know how it used to be, well, for me it's not was noticeable. i didn't see it. i didn’t feel it, but this year i don’t know what it is connected with. well, somehow this, in my opinion, is expected to be lived in a special way. what impressions? well, i must say that i have a feeling that e christmas created an amazingly beautiful legend, an amazingly beautiful story that excites adult children, because, well, abstracting from

whether there was a place in the hotel or not, but this plot itself. here the woman appears the baby and the shepherds and magi come first. this is a story that really amazes. how much for was a poem written on this topic? how much is written for each wire. as a writer, from this point of view, i watched how many paintings , how many a wonderful music, an inspiring story, and i somehow recently caught myself thinking that in fact the magi and the shepherds could not come at the same time? that's for sure. it just didn’t happen to you, because in fact you came to you much. later they did not come to the cave at all. yes, they came, as we know, because after christmas there was a circumcision of the lord, then there was a meeting lord, only many, many months. well , maybe a little, well, for a certain amount of time after tu came, uh, the magi and then , uh, in a dream, joseph was given an indication that herod wants to kill and they left, but to egypt and yet in our minds, after all, the magi and the shepherds, but they coincide, and this is

such a mythological legendary. eh, the idea of ​​this story it defeats some kind of logical factual basis, and it seems to me that it perfectly said that god is coming. this is how they would say modestly. yes, but the question is still what kind of god. come on, they left in different ways, but here we philosophize. this is god transcendent. and that is, it is god who is generally outside the world, like the space of time, he created this world, and again the world, like space and time for the jews, yes, that is, there is time for us before our meeting. here we are now talking about the present and then the future will end, which we do not know when we say that god knows in the future. we do not mean that he now knows what everything is. it will end, but not for him in general of this time he is out of time, and here i recall tertullian, with whom we are often reproached and reproached. well, pulling out one phrase from his reflections, i believe because it is absurd.

yes credo to the viabsurd mest. but why does he speak absurdly, he says god, this god, he incarnated became a man, and this does not fit in my human head, so i can only bow this head reverently before this miracle. this is what has always amazed me. here you can even tougher question to stand. and remember the poor man's house, like a miracle altar, where the eternal becomes poison, this image of a baby washed down. or lying in a manger, that is, in fact, why are you gonography? well, somewhere around the 6-7th century appears. uh, if not just somewhere on the floor, they suddenly find themselves on the throne. thus showing that he is not born in order to live. that is, friends are already a symbol of sacrifice. yes, that is, god comes here in order to die and really

become food become nourishment become the one who will pump this new blood again about all of humanity. and this, of course, well, it’s also a completely different angle. yes, you and i are still born first, then we live, and here is the story, because you see the other, the son of god priest of us. he is already there. passes into birth in order not to live so that it can be killed, so that it can be sacrificed, thereby destroyed. here is a wall between humanity and god about a wall. need to talk. here, this is the great universal joy that we find in christmas. she became necessary, because once upon a time there was a great universal catastrophe, and it is not like this, i also say to students, but they read it. we really don’t say that we

have read now, but still. well, yes, ladies, we know everything about the euro, yes, and we always have this one. that's what you are not the story of the life of one family, that there was a peasant, when his aunt eva ate something, or god took it and got angry there and kicked him out. yes, this is a global catastrophe. a person has lost contact with the creator , not even what he has lost will lose the consequence. yes, this person is so distant choice. strictly speaking, after all, the prohibition of eating the tree of knowledge. passed, uh, he was deeper than just obedience, disobedience. why was there not some kind of tree of obedience, for example, yes, namely the knowledge of good and evil, everything is very elementary here, because a person makes this choice, thereby asserting himself as the only criterion of good and evil. that is, he denied god gives birth to evil, in a sense in this. yes, you can say yes,

because from this moment on, god, he no longer determines what is good. and what was lucky myself man determines what is good and evil. this is indeed a universal tragedy. this is the emergence of the complete autonomy of a person, which was laid down as a potency as an opportunity, but before the master there was no one in the lead. and if a person can say absolutely no to god , then the question arises. and if it doesn't have that kind of power, the twisting spiral really does. on such a vector was asked. how many meanings are gradually unfolding in culture? here we are talking today, childhood culture of childhood was not in the ancient world of childhood culture, well, it was not, but after all, look, and the holiday of christmas appeared quite late. as far as i understand, yes, but at first it was an epiphany, yes, that is, like christmas and epiphany, although chronologically, again, it separates many, many years. they were spending at all. first there was easter at all, then there would be an announcement. yes, yes, the

gospel describes christmas and childhood the adolescence of the later life of jesus is left out of brackets. it's also a big mystery. yes, but here is the tone than here. i don’t even know, art should intervene in this situation, art should to add a plot here, as far as i understand, is not really there. well, it's challenging. well, keep in mind that this is a segment that is not described in any way in the gospel. actually, as far as i understand, well, in the world. the absence also doesn’t come to my mind so much the plots that are, these, as it were, infantile plots, they are, but these are one more thing. i remember incredible. and the impression that this bethlehem temple made on me, yes, in palestine, yes, because they showed us there, here is an icon. look at the smiling virgin more. you will not find the mother of god anywhere for her to smile. yes, because more grief is already everywhere, already the knowledge of what will happen next. and here is the first minute, when he was just

born, she holds him, and she smiles. it is, of course, exactly like that. uh, the amazing feeling that you, uh, have in this city. and so i say, this is amazing. you believe in it. now , when you look at this, you understand that it really happened, and when you see these shards of babies that herod ordered to be killed right there. yes, you also know what it is. not some kind of artifact not something invented and this is what it was . it's called the holy land. why, that's exactly where you understand that all this was and the flight into egypt was and nazareth was. well, there were debts, and, of course, there was, yes, and that’s all. this service and shrovetide mountain, but it all began bethlehem began. and all since christmas and read somewhere else such an interesting thing. i don't know, of course, you are more experts than i am. actually. uh, why did christmas come later than the others? holidays, because for the first christians it really didn’t matter, it was important

exactly. here is the lord after the god of manifestation. that's when he appeared and traveled through er palestine through judea, like the lord, and then when all sorts of, er, heresies arose, gnostic, yes, when some idea arose. and what, maybe there was no god, like a person, but there was some kind of substance, there was some kind of symbol, there was some kind of knowledge. that's when it was important. no, he was and so he was born. this is how it should be remembered. we must celebrate it, and it is all these related circumstances. with the fact that there was no room in the hotel and the child in the manger and the shepherds came, that's all, this is the most important part of christian history, and it seems to me that a huge number of people, christians, did this. now, i'm just sure that when people thought about it, when they imagined it, when they told it to their children. this is how it affects, uh, the psyche, the consciousness. what do you understand? yes? so it was, that is, this is the very case when the gospel becomes a work of art, how many here we have right now the topic. i just

want to finish with academic tediousness. we started talking. yes, that there would be no god of incarnation, if there was no fall into sin, yes, in fact, so that the angle of incarnation would make why god becomes a man? how about just saying it? this is a mystery, it is not comprehensible, how, in general, is the main thing in religion? yes, we really can only bow our heads before her, but because, in fact, the meaning of e is not that christ was crucified, suffered with everything in the fact that he was resurrected yes, that is that death. naturally yes, but that there is no death, that death is not the end, there is the life path of every person. yes, that is, a man, he cannot, like a baron munhaus, take it for himself and pull it out. e for the hair. and here it is after losing the smoke. here it immediately begins, again, the plot of world culture is melancholy pddemu. yes, all all the lost paradises, here is a person trying to jump. here, he tries to pull himself out. here, he draws bashkov for himself. here are all kinds of animals and everything, not that and everything, not that and but, because you can’t pull it out himself yes, and that time and a continuous projection of himself

. yes, you do it everywhere. yes bam, he comes so-so recognition. wait, well, well, well, god can't come like that. that's guaranteed. yes? 100%. yes yes. god won’t come like that, won’t come, yes, and god can’t really die like that for him, and yes, of course it was, yes, as if these two stories echo the beginning and the ends. and here, by the way, let's talk about culture here. this is the famous concept. i just recently had a lot of conversations with ivan andreevich, esaulov. yes, in yours. i'm sorry, instead i even started and he has e he i understand, he thinks in terms of what is a culture, easter and christmas, yes, so i want to say right away that there is no theological component here, because once someone said that you know when it comes to the primitive level. we are orthodox there, the main thing for us is easter for catholics christmas is nonsense, of course,

nonsense for any believing christian. easter is understandable, yes, but indeed in the culture there is something that can be called christmas cultures, and which they focus on the fact that god has come, which means that the world has been transformed by this coming. yes , something has changed, and those who say, but the main thing is that he has risen and what will happen to us later. yes, and as i understand it, within the framework of this concept , we are talking about the fact that, uh, western christians are more precisely the culture of western christian countries. that's more accurate. not a theological concept, they are so christmas. well, i'm not talking about what it degenerated into. yes, already there in the sale there it is a separate big one. theme and i think, on such a wonderful night, we probably won’t will be very interested. but there is an easter aspiration there, and therefore here somehow we are not very interested in this world. how do you feel about this concept. it is clear that like any intelligent design. yes, it is not a reflection of reality, but an attempt to comprehend it. better worse. there really are some. she's productive, that's the idea.

well, perhaps it is productive in order to ask ourselves again the question, if we are not a christmas culture, then what are we if there is something in our life? well, here are the professors. a what exactly is in our culture, if something is so direct, penetrating, here is life in the first place, here is the way of life of a person, what has echoes associated with easter? this is a good question. not ready, but without this, everything else will be. well, of course, interesting designs are mental, but how they respond. yes, i understand that when we say that we explain easter by this rather, why do we have underdevelopment, there is no emphasis on social transformations, because we understand what it is. well, here it is on the economist's life. yes yes, you know, it seems to me that here a slightly different view was offered. oh good. and what

is the christmas culture christmas or is it a culture? eh, the key figure of the modern european christmas is not christ, listen, no, in the form in which it is presented today. it's no frost. it's not even santa claus well, somewhere, maybe nothing good, as it were, yes, but at least as it should and not have the slightest relation to be recorded in the protocol from behind. it has nothing to do with christ christ there no. there is no christ in this christmas. that's the problem. wait and in what is not present, where is not present in life i am interested in the everyday life of human life. here in this routine, christ is somewhere outside the brackets, because there is now a congratulation there is christmas the christmas tree is a holiday. there are holidays and so on. well, actually, what

makes christmas christmas is still christ if christ were not there christmas was not there either and that's all. the rest, of course, this ten is of gradual importance, and here here. it seems to me that there are stronger tensions. this is not a tension between a easter and christmas, but a tension between christ inside christmas and anti-christ to those who are likened, as if to christ yes, because the antichrist is, of course, replaced, like christ yes, klaus himself is replaced by himself, then christ who should be in the center, which is in the manger, and to which the eyes are riveted. this is realizing that here the siagne lies in order to become the source of your life, one american orthodox priest told in ninety there the third year on the 1992nd, he was invited to come to some place for christmas, they say, it’s such an expensive big center, there, he says, there will be children. well, there, yes it is, and he says, yes, well, of course,

i’ll only come, he says, three conditions cannot be pronounced with them, not jesus christ, which means you can’t talk about god and generally emphasize the religious nature of the holiday, he says, what should i do? then? we are talking about culture. look, what an interesting thing, it seems that i somehow understand internally, this is easter culture, christmas yes. but fyodor, our dear mikhailovich dostoevsky , writes a boy near christ on a christmas tree, which, according to some, is dostoevsky. the vedas are generally the quintessence of fyodor mikhailovich's christianity, and this, i'm sorry, so to speak, christmas story. and how to explain this? well actually, see really the tradition of the christmas story. it seems to me that it is so much stronger and richer than the tradition of the easter story, because it seems to me that it’s still possible to fit in the head in the mind. here is this easter culture. exactly,

what what like it, it seems to me, it's a little bit higher than culture, yes, more and more complicated than the culture of christmas frames. it said a breakthrough there, but still christmas is a more intelligible thing hmm and so it seems to me that here, well, any artist somehow understands what and how to do, but you are right and the story is about nastoyavsky. and by the way, here i would just say that it is possible to find common ground between european and russian culture, because both our writers and european writers christmas has often been associated with such a blatant, but rather a critique of social norms. why , how terribly arranged life is, that this holy sconian night is here, suffering children, freezing starving people remember anderson yes girl with deakins matches. you can remember, you can remember. eh, kuprin , he has such a story, the poor prince, you can remember the marvelous story of leonid andreev, an

angel. yes, remember the boy there when he was. well, that's it, they are all wonderful writers , you can blame them for something, but, but it's cool. this is a different work remembered. yes, i understand, yes, well, angel is just a cool story, like a boy. so i saw this angel, how he changed, and how he brings this angel home, hangs it near the stove, and the wax angel melts, well, just super superza. and now i'm talking here, here we see what exactly christmas evokes in artists. this is the feeling of the wretchedness of our life, what is life? well, such an appeal to people is terrible, but remember, but here around you, yes, as it were, do not close around your christmas geese around your that is, and contentment, remember where the lord really came into the world. think of the poor poor sires. and this prompted. yes, in life she called to life. these are such wonderful works. and, of course, in dostoevsky it is a boy near christ

on the christmas tree. winter. it is also very important here that christmas is the contrast between winter cold , cold blizzards and warm houses with fire and comfort. they can all be there. here's to the writer. he feel it. yes, not everything is this universal cold, which also challenges and which also appeals to our conscience. easter is completely different here, a completely different story, so it cannot be said here that there is a christmas culture. this is below culture, easter is not the point. they are just different, like these two different events. and when there was a pandemic, we all sat at home, and i tried to read to the children. e. well, actually. i read christ on the tree to the boy , but i got it. everything is here. and i didn’t get it that way, apparently, with age you become sentimental. do you agree with that this is really. well, if i understand correctly, i read from someone that this is

almost quintessence. here is the christianity of dostoevsky, which is roughly speaking, in order to understand dostoevsky one does not need the brothers karamazov. well, more precisely, the brothers of course. and here is the boy at christ on the christmas tree. here is his philosophical, religious philosophical, theological here, i would not argue this and would not argue with this, because, well, in others you can also find a director. well, maybe this is really a very cool story, after all, dostoevsky bridge, as a novelist, we perceive him. yes, but here it is concentrated in the story, it turned out, what’s interesting, here is the christmas tree the christmas tree is, in general, not quite, as it were, a christian thing. yes, they didn’t have christmas trees at first, christmas trees appeared there somewhere, which means in the damned west, well, that’s what it is. probably, the responsiveness of a russian person took it, he took this christmas tree, it is a religious symbol and yet this is religion. she assumes, like the culture of the moment of enrichment, the moment of assimilation, so he, uh, i understand that santa can be klaus is bad. i don’t know, well, santa claus, i would

n’t give it away either, and we’ll take the snow maiden. they are not anti, they really are too. uh, part of that culture, and again. i think it's attractive. this attracts to christianity attracts to this holiday. and let some inquisitive child think through santa claus. and what's next, and who's where, how is it all in the soul of the west, if santa claus will be a stepping stone to christ well, how does he stand opposite? i don't know, maybe not for all kids. but here this petka came and saw, an angel, too. well, what kind of angel is there, some kind of susal. yes, there, and yet in the heart of a child. something somehow moved, and with santa claus, maybe the snow maiden is beautiful, but this is, again, a question of culture. it's like for many of our contemporaries, yes, master and margarita is absolutely absolutely not canonical to forgive. yes, forgive me great, uh, that means

bulgakov for a great novel, indeed, great brilliant, but with religiously quite simple such flattened primitive, eat it the truth is that you have a headache psychotherapist. it's better for me to explain than yes and and jesus christ superstar well, completely non- canonical, but they thought about it. gratitude is kept in the heart, and i will tell you more. here i studied at the soviet school. yes, i am the growth of a soviet family. there was no gospel in the domini at all; there was nowhere to buy it. yes and so i heard with my hand about jesus christ - superstar and she had such an effect on me both with music and the hero and the plot. there is an english special school, i began to somehow listen to understand, and i really that's it through this hand opera i found out who is uh, christ pilate there mary magdalene apostles. let them be completely different than in the gospel. but it's really a step. as you say, so for many people. for many, including my dear teacher and channel one host

yuri pavlovich vyazemsky, jesus christ superstar master and margarita is also understandable. these are expensive. eh, heart images and therefore, by the way, to me, sometimes it’s a little strange, when today they start this fight , don’t understand why it’s incomprehensible. why shouldn't i claims that this is some kind of canonical version. yes, what is it that you can read there instead of the gospel well, like a step? yes, anything is possible. can be? and now the kingdom of heaven has just died. eduard artemyeva watched several programs there when he had an anniversary. he said a very interesting thing, that when he heard the beatles somehow he seemed to him in our doorway also on the guitar. i'm here i love the beatles but he said that's when he heard jesus christ - superstar ruper. he hasn't done anything for a year. could do. yes, and he is still a guru. he is a master. yes, that is, this musical richness. it can't. this is a musical wealth to take. there is no place, of course, that talents somehow feed on some kind of good energy, as it seems to me, you know nikolayevich. and here is my

impression. e, now at once here at me all has stirred up. we also talked to him. and here is his genius, and i don't know it. well, he's such a evangelical child. here too. by the way, this is a question. yes, and theological and cultural why? here i am now i describe it this way, yes, because i can’t write it differently. is that be like a child? i don't listen. yes, it's perfect. such a childish open soul, you know, i was completely shocked. when i invited him, uh, well, it means to interview the injectors. yes, i couldn't call him. well, that is, there they called dada and that's it and he says to me, call yourself. well, i call, he does not answer, then i watch the call. he returns the call to me and says, but we do not know each other. he says, hello, and this is the artist. hello. he says, sorry, i'm in intensive care. they just tell me they just had surgery. i'm coming off drugs . i see that you called me, i'm sitting

thinking, lord in our time, when the standard answer. i don't take unknown calls. he m to whom here to anybody in general is not present at it mine. he calls me back and apologizes for disturbing me. here you are looking for me. this. well , by the way, you know this, for me personally, it ’s still from the series that christianity brought to the world. yes, i'm trying to say as a student. here it may seem to you that some categories, which i was operated on today kindly, there is a relationship with the elders to the children, that they were always not there, they were always not there, and that's it. yes, when, well, we're talking about christmas today, but when she said to the cross, forgive them, because they don't know what they're doing. but then began, so to speak, the era of mercy, but mercy. e, how can gleb zheglov convince us to explain the priest's word, it's true, already the priest's. the ancient world does not know such an attitude from childhood. he is, of course

, very interesting very difficult, because on the one side. today we are talking about the cult of childhood, but on the other hand, this is not a cult of childhood. this is just the same infantilism, this is a cult, rather such a phenomenon as sophism, when they try to create an absolutely safe living environment around a person in order to designate all triggers, all painful points and so that he cannot stumble anywhere, experience spiritual discomfort and so on. and this is a terrible thing precisely because it destroys at the very foundation the principle of life that we grow only by overcoming ourselves, as once again, breaking through pain through death, a person becomes a full-fledged person. and just maxim the confessor says that the most important thing is what christ brought to earth. this is

a victory or over the fear of pain and death, that by the nativity of christ, by the crucifixion of the resurrection, death becomes tamed, it ceases to be the main problem of human life. to interact with this conditional security in 60 years to remain well, this is absolute anti-christianity to be bizarre is also connected with a real desire to get away from the topic of death in general, of course, yes. or turn it into this very attraction, or either or now, such a topic as overcoming death through crowds, humanism is also very gaining momentum. yes , yes, yes, i know that you love this topic

very much. well people are more often a brilliant idea that no one can confirm and no one can scare you. how philosophical is that. eh, not that, of course. naturally, without the development of science. it will inevitably lead to the fact that we will be able to transfer human consciousness into such carriers that will already be not subject. naturally. these are also variations, or our mind is transferred to some technical devices that can, accordingly, reproduce endlessly. themselves or a person is frozen after death in the hope that some amount of time will pass now we are horrors then a man hop, but in the manner of mr. makli's escape with vysotsky according to napoleon. this is how the movie was. i don’t know, it’s not for me anyway, all this is at the level of fantasy. there scientific not scientific, that's all

, i don't take this seriously. although with the other side. of course you can object. who would come up with this. there is a certain number of years ago, what will happen. here it is eco yes artificial insemination, nevertheless. it has already become a fact of our lives. so god knows. the point here is that after all, sunday is christ's. this is not just a return to the same life in the same capacity. why is the easter theme for us so it seems to approach it, well, with trepidation we do not understand. how can one be resurrected in the body this body, can eat food. and while passing through the wall there, they appear in the book. uh, the apocalypse that there will be no more time. if we also talk about time to get out of here and nothing is clear at all. well , understandable. here it is clear just that there is one who has become so and, accordingly, each of us can be like in the world. in general, it’s interesting, it’s all once again the word mystery yes, i’ll smash it, but how much but how a

modern person reacts to a secret is scared, scared , of course, scared. we have in general, you know a lot of such internal tensions, most likely more of a psychological nature. and even more existential in nature, when something doesn't happen the way we want, we again return to the same story with adam and eve. each of us plans a safe environment , plan what should be in my life so so so so when things start to fall apart. we are indignant at us , frustration begins, yes, dissatisfaction with the murmur of specialists. yes, so that you do not leave, having paid off unsatisfied, yes, but in fact, specialists, so that we come again, yes, but in fact, this is also an escape from the most powerful tool for growth, because faith overcomes this tension of uncertainty, when a person

has a god, when a person has a relationship with god, then , accordingly, he can afford such a space of uncertainty, which otherwise, you will simply break, he will understand, but what can i rely on? who else is here? another interesting twist, like which of the greats had the idea that god it is not the scale of our requests that surprises, but their petty in my opinion. yes, yes, they are pouring. yes, so that the lord, he says, i ask you what you want, we say, maybe a brand new apartment , right? or a newer machine. yes , it's definitely red. i'm still getting back to the cultural echoes of christmas. here's some more, uh, cinematic stuff. yes , uh, well, let's say the fulff gang. uh, it's a wonderful life. franco drops. yes, even such a classic classic christmas

story. yes, a person decides, but finish, because everything is bad life is suicide. everything is terrible there. there, an angel appears to him and sees what kind of drunkards there are, if i don’t confuse anything, well, that’s all, too, because it’s interesting. how long does it live in culture. it's actually the forty- sixth year, in my opinion, or the forty-eighth of the last century . yes, it is not necessarily present, it is already much further, but it is still there, yes. well, a person can't live without a miracle, really can't. and uh, exactly the word miracle is associated with christmas starting. by the way, of course, uh, starting with the uh history of the seed. yes, after all, this is what simeon yes heard when he was copying. yes, this is a well-known story, but at the heart of the average underlying holiday is the candlemas. yes, a virgin will give birth. yes and so he thought there he corrected or wanted to correct and it was sent to him. this is longevity. yes and so he lived to this day, when

the mother of god came with the baby in this game i remember very well. e, i was at a sermon by father dmitry smirnov e about the holiday meeting. he says, just imagine the hugeness of this jerusalem temple. here they come, so the mother of god is watching. there are many people there, no one sees her, and no one, and no one knows, a woman with a child came. you never know there comes not only two people. here are semyon who have been for many, many years. yes, and lives for centuries. so, a widow, who is an honest widow there, who is also already contemplating, only now they saw with their hearts. yes, with their spiritual eyes, they saw her ; yes, he refers to the baby. i mean, here's more in this story. after all, what is striking about christmas is that and also the annunciation, yes, that is, how is it all, how is it all prepared? it's amazing how it all fits together. so why am i saying this, that the charge is a miracle, which is embedded in this story? seems pretty simple. but, well, she came, but she gave birth, how all

the grinds, but such, as it were, an absolutely natural thing, but the most this great miracle occurs, never there any aliens flocked with him. and when will you things familiar and it is clear to everyone that something happens, which is wonderful and here is art here art and just feels introduced and longs to react to it. yes, that is, and the gospel is a provocation, in fact, in such a cultural sense. yes, here she is, she is abandoned, yes, in the world she cannot. to put us e calm, we interpret it differently, we react to it differently. but it's really such an eternal holiday. here the bolsheviks wanted to ban it there, but anyway, they maybe yes, well, replace it, but anyway, i remember there was a soviet an atheistic child, but still a miracle, but still the feeling that there will be some kind of miracle, yes, the christmas tree is a miracle santa claus, a miracle is still a star. oh well, it would seem the kremlin star then. she's not a kremlin star, guys. it 's a different star, but it's still a star. that's what's

cool, right? here is how it is all this pale atheistic sickness, how it is conquered by this evangelical light. i wanted to say something else that is also an interesting thing. see, uh, i'm all about the ancient world. birthdays were not celebrated, and i did not check how much i i understand the tradition of celebrating a birthday. she, apparently, is also associated with the nativity of the gospel, there is also a romantic type of salami, the head of the baptist. they also celebrated his birthday as a gift. yes, well, it means already, yes, he says, it’s rare, after all , they didn’t celebrate very often, because we know the dates of death there. well, when they were born there, no one ever wrote it down, but i think for a christian it's still hmm your birthday. he immediately inevitable. yes, you do . you understand very well that the very date of christmas it also refers to of course, first of all to the essence of what is happening to the fact that it was not winter. yes, it's a car crossing. here is the most.

the main thing, this is the most, of course, this annunciation and the fathers have already appeared from here. there different people were not clear, so today we did not go in this direction. yes, maybe even. it should be, too, in fact. it is very strong that e god comes into this world, like light, yes, here god comes into the world, how light there is light, there is darkness, and what can not be in force? and it's not easy. well, some kind of visual. you are an image. this is actually the visualization of the main commandments about love for enemies that not well, defeat evil, evil evil, yes, and be defeated by evil, but defeat evil, good, do not try to eradicate the darkness. uh, in some other way than bringing in a light source. hey and behold, this is a christmas themed light motif starting with a christmas

star. and ending here, uh, i don’t even know how to end. he, here he is, all christmas is bright, christmas time is the light of holiness, but in the slavic language and in other languages. these are also same-root concepts, but holiness is holy-light. and here is alexey nikolaevich here i really like your idea that the gospel is like a provocation for the artist. yes , but what the artist wants to do with it. here he is, he responds to this, too, probably, maybe in different ways. maybe to somehow show this color, yes. or perhaps there is no other way. well, this person is already dependent. everyone has their own, as it were , personal story. everyone has their own attitude. yes, that is, god gives us a supply. we have to take rebounds there. you could say god gives you a coin there. you can to bury a midge is to invest it somewhere yes, some book is written about it. that's

why i think it's probably completely different things. but here's something else i thought. but look, it means that we really have a period from christmas to the appearance of god, this baptism is called svetka. yes, and at the same time. we're talking about one read somewhere. maybe it's not very theological because he's such an accelerating force, and then only when god appears . it means that everything is not purely the strength to remain silent, all sorts of years there. well, pushkin yes classic eugene onegin, yes, that is, it turns out that this is still an e period, when the lord is a child and before god appears, although here i say, well, too, an interesting time is moving, yes, that is, in earthly life. it 's been almost 30 years, but in food, well, in our calendar, there are 12 days, uh, and it's very interesting that it's 12 days on one side. this is solid time. there without without a post. yes, that is, we rejoice, we walk there along the strictly forbidden excellent formulate excellent. just uh, strictly prohibited on the other side.

can we play pranks like children? yes, we can afford what we are, that is, i want to say that christmas gives an impetus to some such incredible freedom of the human spirit of mood, and all sorts of crowns. i also loved these masquerades so much , and there the noble culture also reacted in its own way. and on christmas there, the kolyadovan was rather such a folk tradition , and all sorts of noble balls and so on, and these points were important. they met there, future married couples formed there. that is, really. uh, christmas is here and life and culture, uh, and politics and a lot of things and a lot of things, therefore, that's it, of course, the earthly projection of this holiday. why it is very important, because the same thing about the light tit after easter yes, let's say, yes, everything will be different there, but now, returning to this topic of our conversation. eh bread also added that here the

rhythm of the rhythm of life is of great importance. yes, exactly what, uh, after all, uh, the life of a russian person. it was woven in the liturgical room there, and behold, he set certain such periods of the ultimate voltage. there was a christmas post, after all, just more than a month. it is too. well , this is serious. in recent weeks it's strong it's orthodox, huh? well, listen, well, catholics are a little different there, they also have their own, as i would say, catholics have other ways of serving. yes, yes, here, and then a deep breath. here is an exhalation from vyatka. the vyatkas have just ended, and here the preparatory delicacy is already starting, just quietly, we also begin to breathe in, breathe in, extreme tension, passionate, deep exhalation of the week. easter segments everything and understanding this rhythm. you know, i remember with great gratitude the years of study at the moscow theological academy, when, well, they

could fall out, we just couldn’t go home, it was so organic. and look forward to the next few moments. you are already living. you don’t even know what is more important for you what is happening now or the fact that this is close approaching. you don't know why you'll be rejoicing in the coming he built through the leading easter here it fills life so much with some others. well, not i know by vibrations, or something, which before church life. it's not even close to understand them, never expect to sleep, but very interesting. i've been honored to participate here, which means i'm on the jury and the competition. remember last year. you and i were oratory. but wait, i arrived at the academy and you know what we celebrated last year, it seems that it didn’t happen , or does it mean, uh, that there are 10 finalists talking on a free topic of competitive skill, and we sat with colleagues jury. and noted that this is the standard

well, this is standup. i'm talking about these walls of the seminary of the academy, they seem to be in a completely different world, but at the end i came out, er, to share my impressions. well , they are wonderful, the guys are very cool. guys walking around the stage is not necessary to keep the audience. yes, the tone is not necessary there. and now, it seems that there is a rhythm, they live and that's it. but i don’t have a phone with me, but this little thing, it destroyed all the barriers uh-huh because they are there anyway i see they they are normal good beautiful seminarians, but this cultural and historical environment and atmosphere. what will scare you? no, it doesn't scare me. i'm just sorry, i'm from a nasty culturologist. is it like an observation? yes, this is a very important observation, because it says that this is so, but no, there is someone . i can say that it is, and this is wonderful, because it says that the church is alive, if the church were dead,

it would have a hard, boundary between the body of the brothers. yes, i think that there is something good and right in understatement. i mean, let's, so let's dwell on some innuendo. perhaps uh, they will gather us and go to talk. my friends happy holidays thank you all merry christmas