at the savings banquet, the big premiere at kinopoisk is so dark, just different. we are already in the kinopoisk subscription for season 2 online cinema number one pay cards to ozonbanks with a cashback card up to 25% open for free in the ozon bank application. dad taught mom chili and the kids spit when the family has a bee and pick up a bonus 50 gb for the whole family in the beeline side app.

yandex.plit split slab alice rest then interest-free solution for every day from vtb that does not miss the most important moments with a free debit card. this is an opportunity make the house comfortable in one step without commission. to please loved ones with convenient transfers across russia

frequently the door rang, and we do not notice the distance when we hurry to our loved ones. for friends we go into the lights into the water, we temper the character. we light and not childishly. we see the future, learn how to create it and share knowledge, we succeed and live with a smile, no matter what happens.

we are different, so it's good that there is someone who understands each animal for each his own for 160 million. when we arrived, we found a rather sad man lying in bath, his head was there with one hand on the sides. music gives me confidence makes it easier to express myself he was one of the first to rush into the auditorium. it became a brand, he owned the mood of the crowd.

hide in the tents, sink into sleep tomorrow we will go to where i was born i want to be ready jim morrison the last days in paris on friday on the first and we are back again. this is a free program podcast. i am maxim tronkov and my guest is a wonderful russian singles champion mikhail kolyada, so lambill told me. eh, what, i constantly

i'm running somewhere. that is, apparently my character is laid down by the fact that i am constantly late for something. i constantly do not finish something, having worked. uh, well, weaker or there with raf. so i relaxed a little, and at the same time, productivity did not fall. i think wow, well, maybe, maybe, so go back to the question of what has changed. uh, when i came to nikolaevich, i probably just relaxed a little. that is, he threw himself some unnecessary anxiety. i realized that i just need to work and that's it. and what was the anxiety responsibility that you it made this one run, as stefan said, it’s hard to say, maybe you just grew up, then maybe you started to grow up, maybe, yes, maybe it’s uh and it was worth doing before, maybe, i would have matured earlier, how to develop unless

you try new ones. the philosophical question is difficult questions, but difficult questions, and in fact you don’t know how to do it right. you can uh understand, it's only after you've done something or not, it would be great, of course. if someone whispered there what is there yes, do it, it will definitely work out, or there, for example, we use such a technique or such a system will definitely shoot in the eighteenth year after a short program in a tournament team. i know that the press scolded you very much and someone in the team was also unhappy. yes, and he directly expressed some of his unpleasant things. even from other sports who supported you at that moment. that's the most who hmm someone could call to speak out, or maybe directly, but in the olympic village was a man, which yes? this man and i lived in a room. this is dima solovyov. oddly enough, it’s morozov and sasha albert, so we all lived together and thanks a lot, guys, because

oh, but if it wasn’t for them , it would probably be worse for you , in principle, directly very strongly supported and the truth. i am very grateful. well, it's all the guys, who skated in the team tournament? yes, you represent. not everyone is evil, it turns out. it seems to me that this may be the strength of our team somewhere, that we can compete with each other as much as we like, not be friends, but in some difficult moments. uh we are always a team we are always so no. well, perhaps, yes, because indeed, when there is support from the team. it's actually something. this is different. that's why , by the way, i like the channel one cup is that when you skate you sit there in the stands your team. and this, of course, in general , these are different sensations, therefore, in a way

, i envy you that you are not skating alone in a pair, well, you were skating. when you go out, and you understand that you are not alone on the ice. i would be interested in trying. it's probably somehow adds responsibility, but at the same time , as if due to this, you become more confident. itself probably, so misha, now i am grateful to you that you always answered me unequivocally to my blitz interviews, because now such a frank conversation probably would not have happened, because i always knew that i did not know such a person. i thought that you weren’t such a single ice wolf at all, who generally sits in the locker room there inflated and like a beech and does not communicate with anyone. and in general, and you, it turns out, are such a team player. well, you understand, this is a certain mask too. that is, when they understood me, well, i'm telling you now in a calm environment, that is, not in the locker room, when i'm so puffed up, right? because yes , it is really very important for me that we

have such a kind. the team spirit is precisely here in the entire team, and our team is very good , very strong, friendly, however, that is, no matter what happens, i'm sure everyone will understand everything. you are from a large family, right? tell us a little about the family, mom, dad, brothers, what your sister does. how many of you are there four four. yes, you are the eldest, yes, who else do you have a younger sister for 2 years even younger. that is, we are going down stairs. yes, a brother, and even a younger sister, and you are engaged in figure skating, only you, yes, and no one else has ever tried to do this, two sisters tried to do this business and their older brother skates cool. well, by the way, i don’t know why they quit, but , apparently, the parents thought that one skater in the family would be enough for us, because, well, it’s very hard when it’s there in the morning, well, you’re also skopina

right. no there is. peter is like this error. and why does everyone say that well, because i lived there for some time, and that is, you just lived in kolpino well, you just moved. well, you went to practice. yes , i went, i went for 3.5 years. that is, not all the time i grew up and was born in st. petersburg, all the time i was born. in st. petersburg, they are in this there some like fedor klimov and who brought you to the skating rink, in general, how did you turn out to be a figurine. just on the anniversary yes, on the anniversary there i was in kindergarten. usually parents come late in the evening. and then my mother comes, there was no dinner yet. mother already arrived. i think what happened. all she got me lucky somewhere i think. well, okay, then a memory failure. so, do you remember this moment? yes, i remember, then it means you were years old. i was 5 years old then it means a flash. i ’m already on skates,

everything is in some kind of balloon suit and then i remember the first competition. as i know, the fourth is the last. and how did your mother even understand that you have the future of a cool single skater. you didn't talk to your mom about this. mom says why didn't she give me to zenith. i almost quit football. but i was asked 10 11, probably and that is, you went straight to the section. yes, i studied there, not far from yubileiny, now this school no longer exists, of course. now in its place is the theater of boris eifon. what school is this 91? i also studied there, but it seems to me that everyone studied there. zhenya plushenko and i are in the same class very well. well, you see how he studied, well, of course, well, he studied anyway. i was listed yes, and i really like it there, petrogradka, in principle, in general, as if the area is so cool. yes, somehow, here's something i either skipped school there, or training was no longer remember. in general, i wandered into some kind of yard and there was some guy, but somehow i met him. everything, he was there with the ball. he

says let's go. i'm training now. well, i'm always in sneakers, as if i walked everything, well, we went to training, the coach looked at me like that. well, that's great, you're good. let's go over there, roughly speaking, we have training there on monday, wednesday, friday. i am like that. yes, all is well. before meeting you at home , i was looking for mom, i think i want everything in football and she is so something strange. well, okay, in general, on the next day. i took things from the anniversary and said to everyone goodbye and everything, and there i went there a couple of times and then, why did you end up at the rink again. pulled. well, i don’t know whether they somehow forced me, or threatened me, i don’t remember, and now i would sit on the bench somewhere in voronezh, i would receive a couple of hundred thousand euros a month. what did i change for? yeah well, how about what? she's beautiful, are you talking about me? to be honest, i don’t regret at all that i stayed in figure skating, because because you never regret anything, we already figured it out.

well, yes, what has been done, yes, well, i try, as it were, to build on what is here and now, but there is something that you regret, what you did not figure skating. for now, because as soon as we paused, the quad jumped axel damn , i always thought that you would do i have a video of one with a maximum of a quad yes yes , probably because i would really like to jump. well, at least for this you will have to reanimate, at least for the show tournament, your career in the jumping tournament. maybe not at all train programs only jumps. you know, in fact, i think it's better to train the program than just jumping. yes, why well, the joints still don’t always stand up to me, that is, you jump over everything a little, as if you feel that you need to slow down, which i don’t even know about terskaya. well , when you came to the cross group, nikolaevich mishin, there were a lot of already young to

hot single skaters there. and you seem to be a veteran, but at the same time a newcomer to the group, as you put yourself. how did the hut enter without demand. well, how did i have to catch up to catch up? yes? you're the champion of russia as and what's the difference, what was it was? i'm out of shape. i'm not the champion of russia, i am. all right, when was that? i had to redo everything . and how did the guys react to the fact, well, to you in the group with whom you can be friends or not? in general, i have a normal relationship with all the guys. we kind of got it right. that is, well, that is, you understand that i am not a conflict person, and how would i find contacts with people, well, quite simply, then there was no such thing that you supported the boss and said everything nikolaevich this infuriates me, take him away to another no, no. we, on the contrary, somehow had such a healthy competition right, and you never thought about a coaching career.

well, i thought about it, but i think it’s still too early, but it’s just that now you have such a chance, for example, with alexei nikolayevich mishin, let’s say you become an assistant to learn a lot from him with coaches, because i’m a very big difference when we are athletes you think? yes, i had coaches, i i can use it. i just worked there under someone, let's say. so i teach so much i didn't know so much at all, of course, but only, look, i believe that memory has such a property. if you don't use it, you forget it. yeah, if i let it be now, well, i’m very rude, but i grab experience , they will be there. you know, well, you won’t get out a lot later, but now i’m kind of working as a coach, but it’s not interesting yet, yes, it’s not interesting yet. but when it will be interesting, when it will be relevant for me personally. naturally, i will look for information there and consult with our comrades there, well, and so on. that is, of course, when i think that a spoon for dinner is good, but still i'm listening to you now family. yes, i don’t climb there, i don’t know

if you are planning little carols. cool by the way, it sounds here, especially since from a large family. you've got experience, uh, raising kids. you are the older brother. here. eh, well, i didn't try anything. i'm just saying that you still have a family now. yes there, maybe the foreseeable future. she will get bigger. maybe you need to make money. uh, something for bread, but blogging to do that now. so i 'm just looking for myself in the search for my business. or maybe not a single one, well, it is most likely, because you are a creative person creative people ordinary there there there it is on its own. well, yes, yes. and we are back again. this is a free program podcast. i am maxim tronkov and my guest is a wonderful russian singles champion mikhail kolyada and your wife is she what does she do, and she is doing aerial gymnastics now on

marsh on dense. uh-huh, but that is , he does it in order to participate in the show or for himself. well, it all started, as for myself, that is, to try myself in something new. so, and then little by little it all turned into a sport. hmm even participated in competitions. and, that is, she participates directly in competitions, and figure skating remains in life. she's a boyfriend, but she sometimes trains children. yes, that is , well, not on a permanent basis . walked. i came to training to take pictures of all this, and then they watched it. this, of course, is all very beautiful, but it's so , well, for me it's generally different. that is , i tried to climb the canvas there , to do something, and what is the idea for the next tournament? show programs? wow it's a good idea to fly the quad axel, then you fly, well then you can finish everything, then life is good, for sure. you'll be next season while

you're on hiatus to follow figure skating to see what's going on well not on the world stage well, at least we have to cheer for someone on the inside, perhaps i will, probably the time has come, because when i was in sports, i tried not to watch anything at all with my life. i had to lose a lot, so, of course, it's unpleasant, but on the other hand, you become from it. well , just somehow invulnerable. yes, that is , your defeats really made you stronger, of ​​course, because when, well, let's just be honest. who else, because of russian skaters, fell under such a flurry if you take the athlete and duration, perhaps criticism? yes, you ate a single spoonful. i usually say another word, yes, the taste of defeat. i know it right. here i go, i criticized you very much, lyokha and we will yes, it was the case, and now you

are skating with him in the same show and dakha is like your relationship. yes? as normal, that is no offense, he explained. why he didn't was not explained. well, i'm somehow not interested, i'm not going to ask him. why well, that is, and did not take offense at him, no, because sometimes it seemed to me directly, well, it was too inflectional there were some. you see, not without a reason, you see, but the point here is not even the reason , the point is that the way i feel about it, of course, is unpleasant, but on the other hand, i secured myself by the fact that i simply did not look, that is, not just so i don't go online. now i'm going. no, i never read comments either. here, well, not comments, it ’s not the same thing, that is, if i’m interested in watching my performance. i just turn off the sound and watch my performance. that is, because, as if to the music, i clearly know where it is, that i don’t have music be sure to listen, ingeniously possible without, i never thought that without sound you can

look, but during the sound - this is ordinary does not talk. you can turn on. here, as soon as the poses are usually given to us by the commentators. i'll tell you the secrets since you've never watched with sound. we are not talking during the performance now. this i know too. this is how they started recently, so i became uninteresting in commenting and i don’t have time to tell anything, therefore, sometimes i leave the button on. we all make mistakes. anything happens. tell that to my superiors. it's clear. what are you like yourself? can you say it like that ? why is there a champion in defeats, but do you have any competitions that you will remember. here , after 20 years, sitting in a rocking chair in the country and you will think, here i was standing on the podium. and this is my most important thing, probably the first championship of russia, i don’t know why. so like this. do you remember him, how did you skate? no, i don’t remember the feeling when i stood on a pedestal. this was expected. well, there was hope that is, yes, rather it was expected.

it’s just that mark kondratyuk was visiting me and he told me that it was very significant for him. and in general, that is, he always directly remembers this tournament, when he was the first, russia starts you second, and he says, i didn’t believe, that it’s possible to beat misha at all, that he’s so cool, but i kind of beat misha and now i have this recollection talking, right with trepidation he says that there is respect, and he says, i had a feeling of an impostor. are you presenting the phrase? wow. well you know i love you i will say mark kondrachok, in fact, very cool and the fact that he was standing there. it was absolutely deserved. how do you feel about the fact that you skated with your lines with your skating for many years , then baba yaga then, wait a minute, it was a cool program, but then somehow all these cartoon stories you had. and i always thought, damn it. yes, he rides like that, and this is my period of waiting for your path from well, wait until i'm a white crow. i have already managed to sit and finish riding, and finally, i waited for the kolida. here's the one

what the hell can he do. why why before you couldn’t do this forever, i ’ll explain to you now, because for 20 years i walked along the same path along her woman. you know, by the way, here is the baba yaga - it was indicative, i still remember, so i also had an indicative chaplin, i had a lot of indicative ones, but for some reason everyone was surprised by the beans. in fact, the image is the original image. a cool idea is cool, but just in the amount of this of their similar programs. he was already like that, but i understand when as usual. what is your favorite program favorite. listen, i have all my favorite programs, because i put a piece of myself into each one, and i don’t have a direct entrance to myself. here's the one you don't like to ride it. no, i've been here since childhood. that's the way that i somehow stand the program. i have to feel it directly, if i don't mind. yes, i, as it were, just

come up, i say, well, not mine, and what kind of man can i remember this one. here. well, for me, of course, there are memorable ones. well, probably so straight, so that the brightest is a white raven, of course, yes, it’s straight. here you go, well, she is like that. heartbreaking so said, i would say they are such a non-soul tearing story. you see that is. i somehow felt it all in my own way. well, maybe the viewer interpreted it a little differently, as if reading it differently. for me, it is so you know, the story of the phoenix, which seemed to be reborn, you know, from this battery into a beautiful one. yes, from the ugly duckling , nurievich read maybe a film and watched you prepared somehow yes, you prepared thoroughly and read and watched films and because i am a film i haven't looked, but i've read a lot of books. uh, before that many years ago. we are still nikolaevich, we went to the vaganov school. there we met, er, with nikolai maksimovich

tsiskaridze, and he sent me a tour and told me in general what kind of person you were, but he made it clear to me who it was. what habits did he have in life manners? that is , that's what he was like just a person, that is, not how cool he danced in ballet. namely, just like a person, that is, in fact, you really prepared, like a rabbit, like like roles in a movie, they are for a free program. yes, this is a very serious professionalism. i mean, that's just how i've always done it, too. i always knew that an artist, if they took you, uh, to a ballet school, would realize himself in childhood, or you would be like a ballet dancer. oh, i don’t know, i know one, but the soloist, and the mikhailovsky theater seems to remember his last name vasiliev. he jumps so much, it’s just that in general we came to watch the performance. well, as if i don't know him someone

is there for the strings. this is how it is supported from above. but he's not tall. well, so are you spring straight. well, here he is, in general, i , by the way, we were sitting quite close to me, so i liked him. listen, it seems to me, if now tanned jumping. here, in principle, growth is not important. oh, and you're very bouncy. that is, i still remember you as a little boy, although i saw this house, damn for a single skater. it’s cool growing that it’s been so straight jumping since childhood. okay mish thank you very much. thank you for coming, that we had such a nice chat, that you withheld exclusive information, that you are taking a break. of course, we are waiting for you in any the key to all the country's skating rinks in the show in competitions. eh, in the tournaments of our show programs of the first channel jump, come anywhere, because well, without you, really boring competitions are not competitions. you always please the eye with your skating with your smile. you have so many fans and i'm one

of them, so you know, therefore, we will miss you and wait for you back in our ice. thank you for calling. maxim thanks to everyone who watches and listens. we will definitely catch up. we will definitely see each other said mikhail kolyada and i support him, we will definitely see each other here. on the podcast, i’m maxim trankov and today i was visiting, three-time champion of russia, bronze medalist of the world championship, the last in the history of our team so far silver medalists of the olympic games, winner of the world team championship, medalist of the european championships , the smile of our team mikhail kolyada thank you misha for coming to you ? thank you.

how to judge you according to the law or according to conscience , the german will say according to the law, the russian will answer according to his conscience. hello, today we gathered our thoughts about law and russian legal bishop of culture, zelenograd savva deputy administrator of the moscow patriarchate candidate of theology expert in canon law smiles at us andrey aleksandrovich klishas head of the federation council committee on constitutional legislation and state building. i uttered all this doctor of historical sciences. hello dear friends. well, the topic, i see. i want to continue . this one, it seems to me, is such an indicator of legal culture, someone once said to me that an italian would say according to the law. we we can agree, but the american will not understand. the question is, in fact. my first question is to what extent this characterizes the legal culture. and what do you generally think about this? well, andrey ivanovich don't look at vladyka. let's start with you. parts,

probably, characterizes, because in itself the opposition is according to conscience or according to the law, but quite artificial. in general , legally it should reflect people's idea of ​​justice. and if the law somehow deviates from this idea, then, yes, it arises in people. e desire to be judged somehow not according to the law of conscience. yes, yes, you need to deal with your conscience. what is conscience? uh-huh, because, well, and in law they are discussing this, there is conscience, as a purely subjective idea, yes, of a person of justice, and there is as a kind of collective idea of ​​\u200b\u200bwhat is now right and should uh-huh yes, and if our law is approaching this ideal, let's just say that such opposition does not arise, and it really looks quite artificial. and if people believe that the law

is somehow trying to regulate some relationship, then yes, and i probably agree with you that, unfortunately, while we have most people to question. if here i put it like this, as you put it at the beginning of the program. eh, they will say that you judge me according to my conscience, but look, vladyka , after all, antimia, law and grace. yes, it is even in general such a biblical one. yes, the old testament the new testament is there the word on the law of grace of metropolitan i larion. if we are talking about russian culture, perhaps this is not such an artificial opposition, as andrei alexandrovich is now saying, how do you think the laws of grace and the laws of conscience are, after all, different pairs, but i continued andrei alexandrovich's thought, what? well, look at the law - this is a chipper. yes, which prevents us from flying beyond what is possible if the bump stop is held in the middle of the road. he obviously doesn't belong here.

am the law, in fact, that the church law, that the secular law is intended, in theory, from the very beginning to make it so that it is good for society as a whole and for each person individually, so that people's lives are for the better if the law prevents this or leads somewhere in the other direction, it means that he does not quite fulfill his functions, but more than that, if this is a well-known one. eh, the patristic saying of the monk sahak. sirin is very brightly expressed in almost the same way, well, almost just a little differently, but nevertheless also an amplifier to chrysostom that if the lord judges us, uh, in justice, yes, justice is with us. nothing good will happen, therefore, we are talking about the fact that everything happens to a person in truth. yes, in fact , initially our law in russia was called true. yes, and this is true. let's talk about this some more. i just want to ask you, how does a person who grew up in french culture, and here is a frenchman. i will not answer. i still lived there, i already

live in russia for most of my life, i don’t remember how i left the answer. ok then. let's continue. here is a famous story. fyodor nikiforovich spitter is a famous russian lawyer lawyer, famous, by the way, for his long rather lengthy lawyer speeches and one of his most famous speeches was extremely brief. the priest was tried. the priest was at fault. the jury comes out spitter and says, lord juror . yes, the priest is to blame. he himself admits it. i want to tell you, only one thing in front of you is a person who for many years in confession forgave you your many sins. i ask that you forgive him one sin once today, unanimously, i believe, or whatever it is that he was justified. vladyka it's like is it right or not? man is called to forgive. yes, we have them, when we count, i say to the lord that forgive us just as we forgive

the sins of others. well, these are not legal categories. this is legally us, actually forgiveness. eh, this category is divine. i'm sorry. it means, uh, to actually say that this is something we don't consider in his past. as part of his life. although part of life was the forgiveness of conscience laws - it's all from different categories can be forgiven completely, that is, by a jury. he was found not guilty. hmm, he was found not guilty or exonerated. as far as i remember it, remember how much he was the exact question. i will say this, if we talk about some such specific examples, then i am afraid that we will not have such an interesting meaningful conversation, because each time we will have to go deeper, there is matter. i want to tell you what you need. uh, speaking of a specific example, always analyze two things, if it's a crime, right? uh, objective subjective side subjective

side is different. yes, there is intent , there is negligence. and then there is such a thing as the degree of public danger. yes, here in this case if i don't know the details there. i know this is a joke, but yes, well-known historical, but i believe that the jury proceeded from what is the public danger yes, what he committed and whether this person can commit such a crime again, and therefore, yes, he was more likely to be released from responsibility. although in general, the jury assumes guilty is not guilty precisely. yes, look, here, we actually wanted to. i wanted us to talk about legal culture as well, yes, and usually when this uh anecdote recalls a historical, yes or example, and this recalls him, as an example that characterizes russian legal culture. here. let's define a little theory what a legal culture is. here, by analogy, correct me, if this is not the case with the political culture of a political scientist, and i will say from the fact that there is a set of values ​​of representations, yes, which affects , let's say, how political culture. political processes and political institutions , and therefore in our different political

cultures the same political institutions will work differently, and the parliament american french e, great britain there, any other country called democratic, so the political processes will go differently. even if formally everything is very similar, because different political cultures have different value systems, legal culture, as i understand it, as a similar category. yes, this is a system of ideas, yes, attitudes towards the law in society. yes, then i have a question. here is the political culture, while we are not talking about the extent of its influence on legal institutions and processes. how much great huge huge because the law. of course, this is such a kind of material expression. yes, the state’s idea of ​​how to regulate some kind of relationship that arises between people, but the problem is that laws are not a product. yes, if you compare

how this or that product corresponds to your ideal idea about it. you will always be a huge gap a huge distance. and here is the size of this distance. it allows you to do. this is the opposition according to the law or according to conscience. yes, in some ideal model , the law just reflects the idea of ​​justice that exists here and now. well, let's tell. at the same time, that this is still a representation of justice, it is changing in society, too, and the idea of ​​​​justice, which there were on this 100-200. or are there 500 years ago different from what people are considered fair today. yes it is there, uh, god has no volatility. yes, but for people in our kind of world in society in a state, these ideas change and therefore the law also constant changes. in a sense , always catching up creating this gap. this is one

reason. why can you always say that either by law or by equity, and the second and this is probably here for me uh-huh as for a lawyer practice and for commentary parks. it is very important. mostly injustice arises as a result of the right application. yes , therefore, when people say judge me according to my conscience. yes, you apply the law to me in good conscience, yes, in the way you need to apply it more. there is such an expression, taking into account all factors, yes, again, everything that we have said, taking into account all the circumstances. yes, you will apply legally. apply it the way you should apply it to me. yes, vladyka's phrase may be helpful. uh, who is the author? i met her in several sources that the use of speech for other purposes is a sin. yes, and so that's the wrong application of the law, but in the sense there is. sin yeah, uh, and that's why people worry, it's when

, in general, it seems to be formal, well, good rules that are developed taking into account these ideas of justice begin use against people against the interests of people, and then people say it no, well, according to conscience, it should be different, yes, and this is the gap between the law and the right to apply. he unfortunately, always exists in the state and there are mechanisms that are aimed at ensuring that the mechanism. let's talk. that's all the same russian legal culture. vladyka as a whole, russian culture as a whole. it took shape under the influence of orthodoxy enormously unconditionally. here is how russian, legal culture and orthodoxy influenced her, how she approached the law applies i will quote. this is a phrase that has been heard many times in the meetings of the highest church court, in which i work as the head of staff. this is the court of appeal. us he can be with the trial court . basically it's an appeal. functions for priests who do not agree with the decisions of the diocesan courts, and now

such a priest comes for various reasons , found guilty and sentenced to a certain church punishment, as a rule, the decision of san i have seen many times, both judges and already wise bishops, gray-haired listen listen to speak. well, yes, of course, he is there scoundrels yes , he also did something there, but you need to help him. it is necessary to preserve it for the church, for god, perhaps such an approach is possible for serving in secular courts. well, we generally capture. here it wait. in general, we initially lay down freedom for the judge, the discretion of the judiciary. yes, that is, the judge still applies the law based on his own inner conviction. this is the intention precisely in that, well, i mean, returning to how the intention is perceived in the church in helping a person, in fact, there is such a theory. e in ecclesiastical law, that ecclesiastical punishment. yes, there is a prohibition . deprivation of dignity is not a punishment.

this medicine is true, because , uh, it’s not so indicative, there is also a component in church punishments, but uh, in general , we are talking about the fact that a person can help there are situations when judges, well, they chopped hard, there, for example, when the priest there left the family went to another woman in other situations in the case rarely happens. i just uh, still wanted to oh ecclesiastical canon law a little later to say, and that's it about the influence of the context, but the religious philosophical cultural right. well, let's say in law textbooks. we will read that the russian legal culture is concentric, which, probably, can be made of. that's what not every right-wing culture is these eccentric. here, we once talked andrei alexandrovich. he explained to me about continental rights there. and that in similar situations, let's say continental law makes such a decision. likely to be accepted. yes, this is also about the origins in legal cultures. so simple and the idea of ​​justice is different, yes. no, this is not necessarily connected exclusively with

religious issues there with some peculiarity of development. here we mentioned the court of the pressed. yes, because the jury itself. we have 150 of them. yes, i don't want to criticize this college student. but still, if you look at the history of development, then still the jury is not aimed. on the search for truth, yes it is an adversarial process and in this adversarial process, pay attention to the word wins. yes, it wins in the process the one who best presented his position of evidence brought a witness, and so on in a sense, what was there, in fact, is a feature of the adversarial process. pay attention there is often no one interested. what is the truth in the case? who's to blame? really not guilty. how, then, does the law relate to justice, apparently there is an idea that the one who is right yes, he has