[000:00:00;00] death occurred as a result of mechanical asphyxia, an ordinary suicide, an ordinary suicide, an unusual place , experts said that there are signs of forced entry on the lock in the uniconovo apartment , wow, this is the death of a mannequin investigating, the books are dead rinses, there are from writers to diplomats, there are no committee games , everything is impossible, but calm down , the criminal investigation department, it was not by chance that he drove into the mayor’s car,

they wanted to kill him, you don’t understand who you contacted? dear, you can’t scare me, i immediately go wild, sergei bezrukov, in a serial film valery todorovsky, bison, the work of a fashion model, the premiere, from monday, on the first, we have always admired you, those who break the horizons, not forgetting about loved ones. those who build not a business, but the future , you who know that business is more important than big words, who know how to give more than they receive, who choose faith, hope, love, not just

as names, who invest in their future. living in a huge country on which the sun never sets, there are already 38 million of you , those who trust us, and we are doing everything to have the right to say, tenenkov, bank of koto in russia, my loved ones love pie with maheev jam, it’s really very tasty, makheyev jam is one hundred percent natural. anxiety can be treated with a new probe. gradual release of the active substance. just one tablet per day. afabozole anxiety can and should be treated. 24 months installment plan with hova. buy any goods from partners or pay off your credit card debts in installments for 24 months. purchases and refinancing credit cards in installments with holva. season

of big premieres. on kinopoisk, let's go, well hello, sounds tempting, kinopoisk, premiere today, tomorrow, always, look, this is azonbank, and you have a lot of clients here, already more than 25 million, they also return cashback up to 100% to the lucky ones, pizza for the whole office! azonbank up to 25% in rubles, the opportunity to return up to 100% of expenses and free card service, you urgently need to find interesting content, an application for children, the children are happy, the parents are calm, back to work, a new task, go to the bcs investment level, your

own media awaits you top... and social network for investors, open an account number one company, bcs world of investments. find out your credit rating for free on the website sravni.ru, we will help you choose a loan taking into account your current payments of your credit history and check that you have no overdue payments and no one has taken out a loan in your name. if it ’s a loan, then on the website sravni.ru. find out your credit rating for free on the website sravni.ru. fashionable winter, outerwear is yours from 799 rubles and discounts up to 50% on baon jackets and down jackets. one day we decided to open an eco-farm. stop, stop, first, let's open the documents and rummage through the invoices. why for is there a document designer for this? focus on taxes, interest, deductions, and vtb has digital accounting. can you handle legal issues? yes, you open a current account with ttb,

you receive it. more than thirty business services , you do what you love, not routine. vtb - we help with action. for any business. free sofcom bank debit card. cashback up to 5%. or income on the balance up to 15%. select order online at sofcom.ru. any business begins with a desire. i wanted a comfortable chair. and to do what you need, gather a team and do it yourself. but sometimes development stops, but does not stop with support. let's expand further. national project for small and medium entrepreneurship. our job is to support

yours. season premiere, voice. no longer children, tomorrow after the program time, this is my secret estel, the court decided, on the basis of paragraph two of part two of article 302 of article 306 of the procedural code of the russian federation, to recognize citizen berezina af, accused of committing crimes under part two of article 167, part three of article thirtieth: ukr, where the victims are lebedev, ilya ilyevich, ivanova, ekaterina sergeevna, isakova, tatyana aleksandrovna grineevich, yuri danilovich are innocent. we will complain. i ask for silence, to refuse to satisfy the civil claim against lebediy velelich, to recover moral damages in the amount of 1 million rubles. ivanova ekaterina sergeevna, recovery of moral damages in the amount of 1 million rubles. isakova and tatyana alexandrovna, moral. alla fedorovna cancel, send the head of the interdistrict investigative department criminal case to conduct a preliminary

investigation to identify persons subject to implicated as accused. the acquittal can be appealed in the moscow city court within ten days from the date of its delivery by judge kalachkovy aleksandrovich. colleagues. today a decision was made in the case of the burned dreamwest shopping center, a tragedy occurred, allow me, your comment on the court decision , a fair decision, it came as a surprise to you that alla berezina was completely acquitted, by no means, the court should have acquitted my client, she is innocent, but is n't it a crime that she herself gave away the keys to shopping center for teenagers, even if she... didn’t set it on fire, which means if the court pronounced an acquittal, and liberezina didn’t set it on fire, as for the keys, there is no connection between the handing over of the keys and the fact of the arson, we are convinced that the arson was committed by gleb

berezdin, our client, had nothing to do with this, and now the task of law enforcement agencies is to conduct an investigation in order to identify the perpetrators of the crimes, that’s all, sorry, i leave you with the team, i’m late, the shopping center manager is going out of the way, he’s being punished, the one who set fire to dreamvest punished himself, let's go, hello, i want to make a statement, i was acquitted, but i consider myself obligated to at least somehow help the families of the children injured in the fire, i will sell

the property and pay compensation, thank you, address, well, i worked as a lawyer, now i’ll work as a taxi driver, otherwise why are you here? maxim anatolvich, the escaped judge in the dream west case, in the case that you , marta sergeevno’s defender matveev, won cleanly, for which i congratulate you, it was worth it to escape. max, please see, i'll be late,

no, i knew that you would win this case, it was important that you win it yourself without me. happiness, if i had not escaped, as you say, you would have doubted all your life, did you win this case or did i play along with you, this doubt, it would have destroyed everything for you. everything we have is destroyed, max, we have nothing, stop, please , let's talk, i'm late, where, to court, another court, our own, sasha, i'll share, i'm going with you, please, if you win the court, let's talk , mother!

sash, what are you doing here? dad brought it, and what about school? he said we should skip today, today is an important day, why is it important, the judge will ask me my decision , i need to say what to say, really, i really want to live with you, i miss you very much, dad thinks that i’m fine with him, but i want to you! what is sasha doing here, do you always behave like this in court? i'm asking you, why did you bring the child here? yeah, i defended another criminal, and was almost late for my own trial. sasha is no longer little, she is able to express her opinion on the most important issue. this needed to be discussed, why?

this? we haven't discussed anything for a long time. the main thing is how to do this if you are never there, you see, even here you were almost late, i would not be surprised if you did not show up at all, take a seat, i ask everyone to take their places, court hearing in a civil case 2:1243, poiskumanov dmitry vladimirov to matveeva. third party guardianship department on determining the child’s place of residence and procedures for exercising parental rights. olya, meet me, this is max, he is a judge. hello, did you know that your mother is a great fellow? what has arrived is not i just came, and i came after i saved a person. i myself saw and heard that one woman was not guilty. but they wanted to put her in prison for 12 years. and her mother

saved her? won't they put her in prison now? no, they won’t go to jail, she was completely acquitted, your mother proved to everyone that she had nothing to do with it. nobody believed that she would be released, but she was released. and you didn't believe it? i believed. your mom, but she's the kind of person you can trust. is it true? good day, in general she is the best defender i have ever met, and i have met many defenders. yes, olya, do you hear that maxim speaks? plaintiff, state your claims. dear court, i will be brief that i was forced to ask to leave the child with me, only one thing: concern for the well-being of my daughter. recently, sasha lived with me, martak came to us whenever possible. there is one serious problem. mom, martha's job is incompatible with

caring for a child. martha is dedicated to her work. she is a fan of her work, and she cannot give it up. yes, dad and i talk all the time, but you are silent, looking at your watch. are you late? i don't understand, i don't care work by 9, did you want to be a mother? so be it. no, marta tried to communicate more with the child, to come more often, but all this ... was associated with great difficulties and overlays, and my mother and i decided that we could skip math, why am i not surprised, at least i learned my lessons, yes, there, then she taught at the table, still in the hotel room, but it’s true that mom kept getting calls about the shopping center, when marta found out that there would be a trial soon, she took sasha to moscow, unfortunately, she deprived her of her daughter. favorite school, clubs, usual communication with

friends, mother, i heard everything, i heard that i i’m not suitable, forgive me that i turned out to be such a weakling, i know you don’t like people like that , i want kolya back, olya always praised me, did marta want the best, sasha, or did she want to prove to herself that she was a good mother, in any case, the desire to become a good mother, and opportunities. don't always match. in addition, martha's work involves various and often unpredictable situations. i wouldn’t want sasha... to become their hostage, the last time martha brought me a child, because what is this? with galina nikolaevna came home from school, well

, the door was inserted, mom, who is this photo, because the situation began to get out of control. and my ex-wife will tell about this herself. thank you! defendant, state your objections. your honor the plaintiff is distorting the facts. sasha's current routine is the result of our joint work. sasha is 9 years old. and i was forced to organize my own company just a year ago. and i do not consider my actions reprehensible, a child should have an example of his mother not only as a family member, but also as an individual, she is capable of developing, and sasha made the decision to move to the city herself; in the city, i provided her with suitable living conditions and excellent conditions for her

education. in this case, explain why you returned the child to the father, what situation, which began to get out of control, was the plaintiff talking about? your honor, my work sometimes requires complete immersion, the cases are various complex, wouldn’t you know, it’s very good when in such cases the father has the opportunity to back up, i am forced to turn to you, what kind of situation are we talking about, it is necessary explain, for the sake of our daughter? sasha, we need to provide security for a while, can you? what, what security, what happened? dear court, when martha brought

sasha to me, she was threatened, representative of the guardianship authorities, state your position on the case. dear court, when we visited this family, the child’s mother was always absent, we observed that the girl gets along with her father, the family created favorable conditions for her to live, our opinion is that we see no reason to change anything in the rhythm of the child’s life, that’s all i have. the plaintiff requested an interview with a child psychologist, who works with the child. i ask you to. the father of the child , dmitry, contacted me as a psychologist; after talking with sasha, after conducting a series of psychological tests, i can conclude that

the situation in the family is non-standard. the father plays a huge role in the girl’s life; he is completely and completely devoted to sasha’s life. as for the mother, unfortunately, her role is episodic, dmitry will confirm that i predicted that if sasha tries to live with her mother permanently, she will return. sasha, i'm coming for you, let's go? no, mom, i'll stay here, at home? there is only one reason: with a father is psychologically more comfortable for a child. do you have everything? yes, we heard from representatives of the guardianship authorities, we heard from a specialist. plaintiff, representative of the plaintiff, do you have anything to add? yes, dear court, the materials of the case speak about everything so eloquently that i just have to emphasize that the most important thing for a child is a sense of security,

home security, financial security, and physical security, the child has the right to demand this and the parent owes it to him give, otherwise, why start a family, so my client is endless reliable, dmitry is able to provide security, financial, housing, and physical. as for martha, i would say that the safety of the child is not her priority, otherwise she herself would have offered to live with sasha. with his father, well, in light of his employment in the light of his specific work. dear court, if...

mothers are not indifferent to the safety of the child in this family, then the child must live, this is obvious, i have everything , defendant, you have something to say, your honor, when in a family children do not see their father all the time, he works a lot, this is considered normal, when a mother works a lot, it is condemned, and condemnation is the fate of all work; views, stereotypes do not keep up with reality, and the reality is that today women often work more efficiently than men, and what can we take away from all their children? revenge, punishment, why? or is it time to rethink reality, a working and professionally accomplished woman can give a child no less than a mother, a housewife, so... i intend to create a comfortable, comfortable

life for sasha, this is commendable, as if, but i, i don’t i want my daughter to grow up as a helpless girl, a woman, what can i give to sasha as a mother, i ask you, please hear me, as a lawyer, i defend women, and i know that men often either raise... their daughters to be princesses , they are either eliminated from the family, or act as an aggressor in the family, and this, unfortunately, is also our reality, i would really like men to protect us, but at best they don’t protect, well, they have lost this ability, at worst a woman has to defend herself from a man, so sasha must live here now in the modern world, be strong, be flexible. be able to defend yourself, stand up for your rights, so i’m sure that as a mother, i’m able to give sasha

exactly this protection, to be an individual, wait, i didn’t quite understand something, if you come down from heaven and speak specifically, but what can you give to your daughter, if you are busy all the time, society encourages the father to be busy, which is why the court most often awards the child to the mother, but your situation is the opposite. the court puts the participants in the process for discussion the question of the advisability of hearing the child’s opinion about who he wants to live with. naturally, do you support your petition? yes, i support my petition and believe it is necessary to listen to our daughter. representatives of guardianship, i believe it is possible to listen to the child’s opinion, but we leave this issue at the discretion of s. yes, uh-huh, defendant, i object to the petition of the court, there is no need to touch sasha, sasha is at that age when she

cannot make a reasonable decision, she can only repeat after the adults who are dear to her , the child loves mom and dad, and like sasha make a decision about who she will live with, and who will then bear responsibility for their words, i am categorically against questioning my daughter, that’s all, nothing more... you want to say, for sasha this is all stress, this whole situation, understand , and there is no need to aggravate it, there is no need to torment the child, you must decide everything yourself and act in the interests of sasha, naturally, do you have a response to the defendant’s objection? dear court, i think you, like me, understand that the mother of my child is simply afraid. it’s not unreasonable

that the child will say, i don’t want to live with you mom, i want to live with dad, damn, idiot, defendant, you control yourself in court, excuse me, after listening to the opinions of the participants in the process, we take into account the presence of sufficient evidence in the case, as well as the risk of causing psychological... trauma to a young child, putting him before choice between parents, the court on the spot determined in the plaintiff’s petition, and the need to hear the child’s opinion, to refuse, the woman who saved the mother, who is she? maybe you’d better ask your mom, if she wants, she’ll tell you, but at least better than me. but at least she has there are children, i just thought, if she

is imprisoned, how will they live without her? you know, it seems to me that she has no children, but she will, in general, everything will be fine with her, in the name of: the russian federation, the district court of the city of moscow, consisting of presiding judge zueva with secretary kharina, having considered in open court a civil case on the claim of dmitry vladimirov romanov to matveeva marta sergeevna, with the participation of the guardianship authority, on determining the place of residence of a minor child , determining the procedure for the participation of the mother and raising a child, decided due to the complexity of the case at the court hearing to announce the operative part of the decision: guidance on articles 194-198-199 of the civil procedure code of the russian federation, articles 8, 61, 65, 66 of the family code of the russian federation, the court decided, the

claims of dmitry romanov vladimirovich to matva. the place of residence of the minor child alexandra dmitrievna romanova with her father is satisfied to determine the place of residence of the minor alexandra dmitrievna romanova with her father romanov dmitry vladimirovich. determine the following order of participation of the mother, marta sergeevna matveeva, in raising the child. every week, from 17:00 friday to 17:00 sunday, the child is with the mother with the obligation of marta sergeevna matveeva to return the child to the father’s place of residence at 17:00 on sunday, to recover from marta sergeevna matveeva the cost of state duty in the amount of 400 rubles to the budget of the city of moscow. the court decision can be appealed to the moscow city court in the appellate court within a month from the date of

the final court decision. azueva, secretary kharin, thank you, what kind of nonsense are you, what are you doing? you have the right to appeal the decision in the moscow city court, well, i promised that everything will be fine if anything is needed. please contact me, yes, thank you, where are you, it’s all over, i’m waiting for you at the courtroom, i’ll file an appeal, you can’t buy everyone, dear, your right, i don’t care what you do, you, it’s you, and we we're flying to the sea, you

and sasha are flying to the sea, we, me, sasha and olya, we're flying to the sea. when tomorrow, how long? i don’t know, according to a court decision, i have to see the child twice a week, let’s decide the issue, i ’ll decide, and now it will always be the way i decide. sasha needs to rest, you won’t interfere with her, will you? sasha. sasha, let's go, and mom, she will stay, but mom

has to go to work, sash, everything is fine. we 'll see you soon, yeah, that's it, let's go, let's go, please, let's go. anechka, yes, my friend, they made a young girl out of a girl, we are professionally engaged in ethnography and folklore. the whole company. our mission is to build a bridge and modernity into the cultural environment of our

ancestors. let's play wedding. on sunday on the first. mahave jam is made from pieces of berries and fruits and helps make my dishes truly delicious. jemohei 100%. this video lasts 20 seconds, it would seem so short, but not for orvi viruses, once they enter the body, they begin to multiply, time works against us, but there is an orbidok, it prevents the fusion of the virus with the cell, and the mechanism of virus reproduction is disrupted. orbidok is ready to fight influenza viruses and other acute respiratory infections. i will pay, i have cashback up to 25% rubles bank, yes, look, you have a lot of clients here, already more than 25 million. you have 100% cashback.

well, yes, you can return the entire amount of purchases, wow, pizza for the entire office, mini pizza, amazonbank cashback up to 25% in rubles, the opportunity to return up to 100% of expenses and free card service, one of my friends has a difficult relationship with the internet, great blow, now damn it, it’s the wrong file, how can i cancel it? no way, artyom, this is a megaphone, everything flies with it, switch to a megaphone, download the megamarket application, buy with discounts, for example, baking parchment lambert for only 77 rubles. megamarket, at bigfest a cheeseburger for 39 rubles and other offers at a very competitive price. magnet, dumplings caesar 269.99. magnet, price. what is needed. pentalgin extragel: it contains a special component for better penetration of pain and inflammation into the stomach. pentalgin extragel against pain and inflammation in muscles and joints.

is routine distracting the department? open a vtb current account. get a document designer, digital accounting, legal support and other services, get busy with business, not routine. vtb - we help business. dancing, yours a bag of popcorn, for discounts, swelling is the norm, from october 19, order goods in a scooter with discounts. check out osaka and compare savings. number one in service in russia. ready to develop innovative products. get involved. and get into a strong team and grow even faster. join, if you want your work to be useful to millions of people, come work with us, we are waiting for new colleagues in sberbank at rabota.sber.ru. everything you are interested in is collected in the vkk video. even

the whole shostun show? yes, even my shows, and not only mine. even gifts. and thousands more films and tv series. and even fresh seasons. all seasons. everything you are interested in is now in the vk video application. each organism is unique. everyone needs it. your unique approach to health pharmacy, necessary medications at a discount of 450 rubles. one of my friends has a difficult relationship with the internet, great blow, i’ll post it now, damn it, it’s the wrong file, there’s no way to cancel it, artyom, it’s a megaphone, everything flies with it, go to the megaphone, find out your credit rating for free on the sravni website .ru, we will help you choose a loan taking into account your current payments of your credit history, that you have no late payments and no one has taken out a loan in your name, if a loan, then on the website sravni.ru. find out your credit rating for free on the website

sravni.ru. each organism is unique. everyone needs their own unique approach to health. sber and pharmacy. we will deliver medications that are right for you. сbir epteka, necessary medicines at a discount. 450 rub. for the anniversary of the great actress, girl, are you dancing? are you coming to me? of course, are you surprised? hello, do you want to act in films? i want, but what? for so that life is full and joyful. you are my falcon, so he’s married, why did they even hire you to play in a movie, and not some actress, she’s a jankestrata

, the reaction is the same, the temperament too, beware, filmmaker, but this is pasha, pasha, pasha , why, pack your things, get out. sign, no, no, no, no, no, jean dark, some kind of hooligan, i girls will leave my mark in art. markazh will then admire me, he will return to me, inna churikova

in the film begins, on sunday on the first.

well, congratulations to everyone, you are great, cheers, hello, finally, hello, come on in, come on in, come on, thank you, if it weren’t for you, i would be in a different place now, and i didn’t believe that anyone could help me, i didn’t give up just because i believed martha, the best. lawyer and thank you very much to the team, you won a case that is simply impossible to win, thank you, for martha, for martha, for martha, hurray, hurray, for you, he’s defeated, perhaps i’ll be late, martha, we have another victory, zhenya

is delayed, thank you very much, i lost, i couldn’t even imagine what i can we help and what now, the operation is ready, yes, thank you again kir, listen, maybe we’ll go, then somewhere, we’ll continue to celebrate, but thank you, where, thanks to you, i’m here, well, i don’t know, invite me somewhere. okay, i’ll invite you, you have a very beautiful suit, we always set it up, thank you, you know, there was one case , i wore it to prom, thank you, thank you, or maybe we’ll come here, zhenya, pasha, call, uh-huh, pasha for

a second, uh-huh , pasha, where the envelope came from, i don’t know , i’ll find out now, marta, i’m sorry, you have some problems, i can help, yes, it’s unlikely li, sorry, everything is fine, thank you very much, goodbye, goodbye. marta, and i also wanted to tell you, urgently, no, it’s just that when we met for the first time, and you said that you would protect me in any case, i knew that it wouldn’t be like that, it was i who approached dreamvest, i hated gleb and his wife, people who are ready to

do anything for money. i wanted gleb to go to prison, all the best, it seems i need a good lawyer.

there's a big game on the air, a special analytical issue, today we have a conversation with alexey konstantinovichkov, chairman commission alexey, we welcome you, good evening, well, today it is obvious that the main topic is president putin’s speech at the volday club, what, from your point of view, was the most important of all the president’s statements? i think that there were a lot of important things, always when such a voluminous speech is also accompanied by an answer to questions, it is difficult to single out any one pressing aspect, but from the point of view of what permeates all discussions around the ukrainian crisis, which,

as far as i know are thought everywhere in the world, from beijing to washington, this is the topic of nuclear weapons, in my opinion, vladimir putin expressed a very... sensible and rational position when he said that there is no need to lower the nuclear threshold, the so-called nuclear flaw in russian military doctrine, let's, let's listen to what exactly the president said, let me remind you that in russian military doctrine there are two, two, two reasons for the possible use of nuclear weapons by russia. the first is the use against us, that is, in response to a counter strike, so we call it, but in practice, what does this mean, the missiles

launched, our spr system detected, ah, recorded, let us know that the target is the territory of the russian federation, all this happens in seconds, so that everyone understands, and... already understanding, knowing the information that a strike is being carried out on russia, we, for our part, are responding to this aggression, and i want to assure everyone that today the response is absolutely unacceptable for any potential aggressor, because from the moment the missile launch is detected, from where would it not come from from any point of the world's oceans or from any territory, in response to an oncoming strike, so many hundreds of hundreds of our missiles appear in the air that not a single enemy

has a chance of survival, and in several directions at once, the second, second reason for using this weapons - this is the russian state, if even conventional weapons are used against russia, but the very existence of russia as a state is threatened, here are two possible reasons for the use of weapons that you mentioned, do we need to change this, and why? everything can be changed, i just don’t see the need for this, well, there is no such situation in which, let’s say, today something would threaten russian statehood and the existence

of the russian state? no, that means i don’t think any sane person would have a clear memory. use nuclear weapons in russia's relations? alexey, your opinion, i would like to draw your attention to the fact that the president used the expression today that this is not required today, that is, he did not completely close the door to some changes in russia's approach to nuclear weapons, if circumstances required it. it is impossible to predict 100% how the situation will develop , now everything looks like nato does not... want and is not going to engage in military action against

russia, let’s say on the side of ukraine, but is it possible to 100% exclude such a scenario? well, it’s probably 100% impossible, given the combination of some irrational circumstances, maybe even ecstatic in some sense, someone may make the wrong decision, that russia will retreat... if the nato military machine comes into action, let’s say, yes, in this case, they should know that this is an option, as they say now, this possibility is open, that’s what the president means, but he also said that to use nuclear potential now for the purpose of intimidation, for the purpose of psychological pressure without the use of nuclear weapons, but even... psychological pressure, in order to bring the situation to the level of nuclear

confrontation, he does not see such a need, he does not believe, what's the situation so dangerous. let me remind you that we had an experience that should be very usefully studied, this is the experience of the caribbean crisis. and then remember, the escalation occurred almost instantly, precisely because the nuclear factor was involved, the american military put pressure on kennedy, pointing out that in cuba... russian missiles with nuclear warheads appeared , plus, in my opinion, 150 units of tactical nuclear weapon. and kennesi was put in an extremely difficult situation. he needed to either escalate the situation, yes, or urgently to look for some way out, but at first everything went along the path of escalation, along the path of escalation , the head of the committee, the chiefs of staff of the united states of america convinced kennesi to strike at the council... before it was too late, that is, what do we have?

in the event of a transition to a nuclear confrontation, we have a very rapid development of events, which, in my opinion, may be accompanied by a distortion of the psyche of those people who make decisions, and the emergence of certain irrational principles, when it is necessary, well, how to achieve one’s goal in order to avoid it, to overcome the enemy , so to say, you know, to prove to those around us that we are the bravest there, well, in this case, i ’m talking about a... but thank god kennedy resisted this pressure and khrushchev also decided, so to speak, that the game was becoming too dangerous, but they came almost directly, we know this story with our submarine, which was attacked by an underwater, and the commander had a dilemma whether to launch a nuclear missile from a submarine or not, he made the second decision, the second commander of the boat convinced him not to do this, that is, you understand , how much, where

the level of decision-making has moved to a submarine located 200 m below the surface of the ocean, that’s what’s dangerous, in these situations, so i believe that vladimir putin’s position is the position of a very responsible statesman, and responsible not only for his country, but for global peace, because i repeat once again, the transition to nuclear confrontation is an instant escalation in response ... a reciprocal, mirror escalation and then the situation becomes difficult to predict, and the way putin responded to this question, i believe that he calmed the world of our partners, our allies, but i do not believe that he created an indulgence for western countries, that is, there is a warning here, you quite rightly noted that in the current situation he does not see such a need, well, in addition, he also said that he is not ready to change the military doctrine, as you emphasized, because today he does not see

the need for this, but he also said that he may have to consider the possibility of russia withdrawing from the nuclear ban treaty tests, a treaty that was signed by both the soviet union and the united states, but moscow ratified it, the united states. no, you know, when, there is an american saying, you know it, if something isn’t broken, don’t try to fix it, and indeed, when there is no real need to take any new radical measures in our nuclear rhetoric, of course, it’s better not to do this, but when you think, a little more distantly. i want to understand your position: from my point of view, nato

is already taking part in the war in ukraine, the most direct and immediate nato military advisers , nato military equipment is arriving there in ever larger quantities, nato is repairing weapons for ukraine, helping ukraine restore those tanks, those artillery installations that were damaged by the russians. troops, the united states not only provides weapons to ukraine, directly, the united states provides ukraine with intelligence information, and not only of a strategic plan, but right on the battlefield, where a specific russian ship is located,

where a specific russian tampa is located, without this ukrainian drones and missiles could not exist. a military hospital in germany, an american one, has now begun to accept americans who are at war, actually in ukraine, this did not happen before, because it was believed that these people were like volunteers, they arrived in ukraine on their own initiative, now the official military hospital is accepting them , the new york times reports that at least americans have already died in ukraine, so tell me what else nato must make sure that we say, facing the truth, that nato is fighting in ukraine, and the real opponents of russia in ukraine are nato, you know, in assessing this issue

there are a lot of emotional principles, and this is apparently inevitable, but when i told the author of this ideas that he understands his feelings, but at the state level , rationality should prevail over feelings, which means that everything you mentioned, i have a counter-question, which of this deserves the use of nuclear weapons, i’ll tell you, none of this - not deserves, vladimir putin named two reasons why it could be used, this is the use of nuclear weapons against russia , we do not see this, and i think we will not see this , i am almost sure, the second is if conventional weapons are used in such volumes that can threaten the existence of the russian state, we don’t

see that either, i won’t argue with you that nato is participating in the war in ukraine, but i don’t want to. but we must also state that regular nato forces are not moving towards smolensk or st. petersburg or rostov on donna. there are different forms of participation. as i understand the biden administration, it wants to participate, but not cross a certain line, beyond which a very dangerous zone will begin for the security of the united states itself. that is, they want to support ukraine. to participate in the war in such a way as to remain safe, that’s their creed, so to speak, but can we somehow dissuade them from this, let’s say, with some kind of threats, i don’t think, i don’t think, i think,

it’s like a tug of war now, right? two sides are engaged in a tug-of-war, this is the side that... has more strength, perseverance, and determination, the ability to withstand the load, pressure for a long time and for whom the stakes are higher, this is the side that wins, and my deep conviction that ukraine is a false topic for the united states of america, it is not false for this administration , which has relied on it, everyone is already deep in this crisis, biden, blinken, salevan, they are all already deep in this crisis, they cannot give - retreat and give back, but let's imagine, this was also discussed to the president’s speech that as a result of the elections there will be some kind of change in the configuration of power and people will come who, for whom this is not their war, they did not start it, they may sympathize with ukraine, they may not completely stop helping it, but they can take much more

a flexible, healthier position because they haven't invested in ukraine to the extent that the biden administration has, so... i think this is a long-term confrontation, when i say long-term, i don't mean 20 years, i mean several years probably this will not be avoided by such a long-term confrontation, in which there will be a lot. this is where europe’s state of the economy comes into play, but if russia maintains economic stability, which it manages to maintain despite the sanctions, this line will continue in europe, at the expense of the european economy, and this is what is happening, by the way, italian prime minister miloni has just admitted, that the ukrainian crisis is costing italy a lot, and half of europe thinks so, in fact, then we will see a decrease in appetite for supporting ukraine from the outside. everything you say makes sense, i agree with 49% , that’s why i don’t think there is a need

to change russian military doctrine now and generally limit it to nuclear weapons, but i think differently, we are like-minded when you said, that you don’t need to be guided by feelings, emotions, you can’t, you can’t, i think so too . one of the emotions that plays a role here is the emotion of fear of nuclear weapons, and the fear is largely justified, but sometimes very exaggerated by people who do not understand that there are different nuclear weapons, who do not understand that a lot depends not only on what you hit, but on whom you hit, and what concerns... but in

general, so far they have a happy feeling that this war it doesn’t concern them, and that since there are many of them, more than 50 countries support ukraine, and their economic opportunities are very, very large, they have the feeling that russia will be the first, so that’s it. let's look at the facts, just a year ago, most of the weapons systems that are supplied to ukraine today were in categories of the unthinkable, then they said that this would be crossing a red line that cannot be crossed if you want to avoid uncontrolled escalation, uncontrolled escalation is already taking place, only it is one-sided, nato on the part of russia’s opponents. secretary of state blinken just said that, in general, the united

states does not recommend that ukraine use american weapons systems against russian territory. but in general, this is for ukraine to decide for itself. ukraine must decide for itself, despite the fact that these systems are supplied by the united states and are largely directed, because they cannot be used without the help of american technicians and without the regular supply of american intelligence information, i want to remind you that the centers of command and control are largely located in that part of russia, which is becoming increasingly and more accessible to long-range ukrainian missiles. so far they have had enough common sense not to attack such objects, because