i categorically did not want to see ukraine in nato, i think that if ukraine was in nato, they would have completely gone off the chain, and then in the united states, you said correctly that everything depends on the conduct of the united states, but in the united states i don’t need to tell you, you have been involved in transatlantic diplomacy a lot, you know that in order to convince the united states to support someone, it is very important that this is done not only.

when they are so bullying all the time, i think that they are behaving contrary to all traditions diplomacy, that a small country, when it borders a great power, does not necessarily have to submit, kneel and so on, but to constantly bully, to constantly create problems for a great power, it seems to me that this is very unwise behavior, if they do not find the strength to stop, i think that they can run into very painful problems. it was a big game, we will meet tomorrow on air. lies reach people in the elevator, but the truth goes up the stairs. against fakes

truth versus lies, this is the anti-fakes program, as always, we are waging our own fight against fakes and disinformation here, dense fakes from the baltics about our public transport, why ukrainians in europe are surprised by the bus and tram schedules, all life is a game, let's analyze a fake for the creation of which the american special services had to kidnap a russian it specialist, well, we will start with the rubric people's anti-fake. fakes do not go to the people if they meet our viewers on the way, this is the kind of people's anti-fake we have today, connections with the studio alexander ermolchev, viewer of the antifake program. alexander, hello, did you come across some interesting but dubious news on social networks, what was it? yes, i accidentally came across a video by blogger oleg zelenok, who was saying that in russia there are no scoreboards in russian cities and, accordingly, they cannot

use transport so that it is convenient for them and track the scoreboard where for public transport, is it in stops, metro or whatever it is, that it is stops, stops, let's get acquainted with his video, then we'll figure it out, only in in europe, guys, there is such a thing, look, you see, you can look at the bus schedule and see what trams are running, in russia there is no such thing, who needs employees to work in germany, contact us, i mean we don’t have it. printed bus food, i when i saw this video, it seemed to me that this is well , stylb, it seems to me, we have always had paper ones, but if we talk, let’s say, about the technologies of the new era, then in principle now in many cities of russia, not only in moscow, in the literal sense of the word from kaliningrad to vladivostok, especially since i literally just got back from kaliningrad a few days ago and i saw with my own eyes how there are electronic boards at bus stops and people can come to the stop.

look at this, by the way, a very interesting character, i would like to draw attention to his last phrase, that if you want to get a job in europe, contact me, that is, the person, what does he do in general, that he offers ukrainians to move across the border to help them with work in europe, so if you allow me, i will still be a little conservative, after all, it’s good to sit in europe, in the baltics, to talk about the greatness of ukraine, when your favorite tc-men won't put you in another paddy wagon and in the same...

that's why stories about these announcements at bus stops with schedules fit very well with these ideas, that is, to convey to the average ukrainian the idea that... in fact, the quality of public services in russia is much higher than in ukraine, it is impossible, for example, residents of our new regions are faced with this, when simple things for the average russian in the service sector, medicine, in the field of transport, in the field of housing and communal services, it is simply shocking, even with public transport, when i know in the zaporizhia region, on the instructions of the president, more than 100 buses were provided there, i think, for the first time, people...

and you stand, wait until the entire cabin is filled, yes, this is a common, unfortunately, practice for ukrainians, they do not imagine that it can be any other way, the average ukrainian understands this very well, he believes, because he himself does not have this, i i'll tell you this, in kiev, not every public transport stop has a timetable in kiev, let alone some smaller cities, now it's clear why this ukrainian european is surprised by the timetable at the stops, and also by the fact that transport can run on time, have you seen a minute-by-minute timetable for trams and buses in any country, yes, that is, in estonia, for example, 620, in short. 26 and it will go now at 8:26, you see, it's written there, yes, guys, i'm surprised, well, i just haven't seen it for a long time i went to kromaychiki, so this system has been here for 20 years, so you understand, probably the third video he will be surprised by the water from the tap, it runs, there is a whole series of such things

happening, alexander, tell me, what city are you from, i am from the city of nizhny novgorod, our city is actively developing, and for a long time now the electronic scoreboard has not... of course, this is touchy, i agree with you here. as far as i know, you filmed a video response for oleg zelenga, but not only you, but also other residents of the cities of our large country. let's watch together. my name is alexander, i

resident of nizhny novgorod. our city is developing very actively , an electronic board has long been installed, on which it is very convenient to look at the information, when it arrives to open, various additional information inside a. transport installed a temperature sensor. we are in molgograd. pay attention to what electronic boards we have in our city. each passenger waiting for a bus can find out the route number, the route, as well as the time, how long it will take for the transport to arrive. moreover, the temperature in the cabin itself is indicated transport, and the next stop. hello everyone! my name is kristina and i am in the city of sochi. this is what our bus stops look like. this is our board, electronic, by the way. now i am in moscow, ostankinsky district. and this is one of the tram

stops, from where i would like to say hello to a ukrainian blogger. oleg zelenko, especially for you i am showing what a modern board with a public transport schedule looks like. what is your attitude to the electronic board? i am generally cool, what is the coolness, what is the coolness convenient, there for now, while you get into the phone, while after he leaves, once you looked at everything there, convenient, of course it is convenient, mobile applications take care of the convenience of passengers in russia, here on the smartphone screen you can... quickly see not only the schedule of flights at the selected stop, but also in a matter of seconds you can also plot a route to get to the desired point by public transport, here in some places virtual assistants appear, for example, a digital stand that uses artificial intelligence, and here you can plot a route and even top up a transport card, let's see

how it looks, click on buy products, select a bank card payment method, thank you very much for paying attention to this, as i understand it, your professional sphere was also affected, so it was difficult not to pay attention to this. a huge hello to nizhny novgorod, i certainly wish you good luck in implementing those very plans that you... we will talk about the younger generation very soon, and of course this happens in our former partner countries, in general in the baltics let's move. this is what is printed in the estonian history textbook for ninth graders about the second world war.

eastern europe, in russia, naturally, in the post-soviet space, it was the ministry of culture and the ministry of education, where, starting from their youth, as they say, people were re-educated in their systemic approach to work, here is the result, now we are seeing, everything was prepared for this, it was prepared for this. well, if we reason about the presented thesis, in fact, that estonia, that lithuania, that latvia, these three countries, like three twins, who simultaneously stepped on the same rake, in their countries, not only do they work, they operate western, starting with soros and ending with smaller gangs that reorient local consciousness, it must be recognized that certain... separatist sentiments and rejection of the central government were there even in soviet times, in general, there have

always been difficult relations with these republics, therefore the soil for such, let's say, theses of narratives, was initially extremely fertile, by the way, what you are talking about, this goal is clearly voiced, let's listen, we need to solve the issue of responsibility, also in relation to russia, accountability, after the second world war... such things did not happen in russia, it did not happen, they define themselves in the categories of empire, imperial thinking, and they like dictators, there are no obstacles, so how to get out of this cycle of history matters. our history textbooks were rewritten after independence, this did not happen in russia. we must put an end to this vicious circle, she cleverly glosses over somehow the question, yes, it seems the tribunal convicted, yes,

everyone found out, and then, for some reason, russia appears, there was also this author of the question , he is an extremist, a deputy of the verkhovna rada of ukraine, alexey goncharenko, a deputy from odessa, by the way, yes, for a very long time he was a very pro-russian politician, in the fourteenth year he turned around and was one of the participants in the tragedy in the house of trade unions in odessa, but here she says that... to completely change the russian consciousness, look, they consider themselves imperialists, they generally believe that they have a country, that they have a homeland, and this region is not bad from their point of view, yes, now the historian mark leshkevich is in touch with the studio, hello, mark, let's show you the quote from the estonian history textbook for the ninth grade again and analyze this quote, and do i understand correctly that they are trying to convince us, well , and their younger generation, that there is no estonian ss legion... of course, they are hushing up the schoolchildren who are unpleasant for them, they do not see the full history

of the estonian legion, where they were recruited in august of 1942, when the germans took the city tallinn. as it was in fact, in the winter of 1943, the arva battalion became part of the tank division, and every estonian volunteer, in fact, we need to understand this, who went to fight against the soldiers of the red army, was an ss man, then this legion was reformatted more than once, but ... it always remained an appendage of the ss. historians also know the propulk of the twentieth estonian ss division. it was also volunteer and carried out the execution of about 2.0 people on the territory of the kolaaga camp, and this camp was located right next to stalin and is this and many other camps mentioned in estonian textbooks, of course not. the fact is that when the germans came to the baltic countries, estonian collaborators, whatever they were called, regiments, divisions, legions, ethnic police or self-defense forces, whatever they

were called, took part in the mass extermination of the unwanted. for example, from... jews, the use of slave labor, the cruel treatment of prisoners of war, in fact, he participated in the genocide of the entire soviet people. it is also known that, for example, the estonian region participated in anti-partisan punitive operations in the pskov region in the autumn of forty-three, and this. thank you very much for this historical excursion, all the best to you, let's move on to our next column, and from it we will learn what games tsypso's employees like to play, don't switch, you want him to

hug us. address, how good, pretty, smart i am, i had the feeling that he knew everything, well, naturally, i immediately heard in my perspective and so on, they each other see, hear, feel, attract, i understand that a special operation is being prepared, he had an open p i need oo, unfortunately, i agreed, andrey sends me documents according to which it turns out that he is not andrey, eduard, premiere, manipulators, on saturday on the first, he is such an actor, wonderful, he can play anyone, and can seduce any woman, maybe

he is playing his best role with you. this is an antifake program and we continue. will ukrainian tsypts manage to fool his fellow citizens with a fake video. we will find out about this in in the "lying to their own" section. a video has spread across ukrainian resources, claiming that ukrainian pilot e in an f-16 allegedly successfully attacked a russian attack drone. let's see.

yes, what do they call it, it is clear that the speeds also do not correlate, since the gerai 2, for example, moves at a maximum of 180-200 km / h, but can the f16 fly at such a speed? the f16, as far as i know, can fly at a minimum speed of 350 km / h, that is, we see a difference of almost two times, which does not correlate with this video, where they fly

practically at the same speeds, here f16 would have fallen in this case, because the speeds are low, correctly f16 fell, it can move like that, that is, there are many inconsistencies here, plus, as i initially said about the paint, the paint still reminds me of the su-57, here again many questions arise about the realism of the collision of the seventh with the f16, in any theater of military operations, firstly, it would not be subject to such video recording, because these two objects simply would not have been recorded in the horizon of optical control, this is a remote combat with the use of high-precision. missile weapons, in general, in this video you have the opinion that everything is a complete fake, this is an attempt at gamification of the media space, it is obvious that this is an unreal video gamification. media space, this is an interesting term, of course, yes, let's connect skype now, stanislav louk, dubitsky, producer of game projects, is in touch with us now

, hello, and we are glad to welcome you to our studio, we are discussing now this rather strange video, in which the f-16 supposedly shoots down the russian geranium, when you look at it, yes, what do you see first, upon closer inspection, of course i understand. that this is a video from the game, moreover, this is a digital combat simulator game, and accordingly, and if we watch a video on youtube from this game, we will immediately understand that there are a lot of similar nuances, but the question is why the creators of this fake could not use the available free model of gerani took the su-57 instead, while officially in the game there is neither gerany nor su-57, this and modifications that were made by the user themselves, there is a kind of answer, yes, that this is either amateurism, and crooked hands, or it is intentional, probably because of a huge desire to pay yes there are their fantasies about

shooting down a f16 serviceman, yes, but despite the rough execution, every year it will be more difficult to distinguish such fakes from games, and of course, as if the gaming industry, and this situation is alarming, so my colleagues need to look for technical ways to solve this problem. for example, you can agree and develop mechanisms for hidden marking video from games with random changes in some physical parameters, for example, changing the refraction of light in the game is imperceptible to the player, but noticeable for a professional program, or adding one extra shade in the sky, impossible for a specific time of day and many other options, this is real and inexpensive and cheaper than a tarnished reputation, but now i want to explain why exactly the digital combat simulator is used for fakes with airplanes, this is originally a russian game, it has highly realistic graphics is famous photorealism of landscapes, equipment and effects,

and then these are the most highly detailed maps of russia and ukraine, a wide selection of aircraft, including official ones with high authenticity and detail, this is the ability to use free aircraft models, buy them or make them yourself, and then realistic... real and this raises the second question, the absence of a similar level of gaming product in our country with all the technical capabilities. you said that this is originally

a russian project, when it, this project, when lost contact with russia now, who owns it, who runs it, supervises it, sponsors it. this is a very interesting story, because the developers are from moscow, the company is old in the nineties, for a long time the product was russian, but then the head of the company was detained in america. after some time they released him and he fled to switzerland, and after that the game became international and the company too, so everything is murky there. apparently, the enemy is actively monitoring such products and goes directly to the owners of these products, in order to include it in those information operations that are currently being implemented mainly in the russian direction, it turned out well, we need it, yes of course, plus here is an expert from... the fact that the landscape is highly detailed there, and indeed, this is very significant from the point of view of practicing and simulating specific combat operations as part of the training of the same

flight crew, because, firstly, they adapt to specific conditions, they begin to recognize this area, and if it is really highly accurate and geo-referenced history, then this is already acquiring a dual-use character, we need to be very careful in general about such developments to their access to the open. market, in principle, this is a very important story, and as i have already indicated, gamification is not only the media space, but also the gamification of war in principle is happening, the theater of military operations is becoming digital, a lot of people are now watching these, of course, of course, and we can even see separate evidence when we see the results of the means of objective control, defeat specific objects, to make such copies, digital, virtual, absolutely easy, because the accuracy of the video image it leaves much to be desired. special equipment is used and to fake multiple different results of the defeat of any types of weapons, including supposedly russian ones, the defeat of any objects, to create a whole...

series of similar injections - our enemy does not need successes on the battlefield, a very serious media campaign is enough to supposedly broadcast in the public space their successes. stanislav, right now, looking at this picture for our viewers just so that they can roughly imagine it, yes, how can you understand that we are looking at a computer game and not real events, what you need to pay attention to, what should be on the alert, an ordinary user will not distinguish, because he has never seen anything like this in his life...

him, but this requires, i don’t know, of course, to be a very cool operator, operators would definitely figure it out, 100%, yes, for a situation that was filmed just in the moment, that is something is happening, everything is too much here, as if everything is in its place, everything is done, a game of amateur filming, but this is not amateur, yes, exactly, stanislav, thank you very much, all the best and certainly success, thank you too, and we will remind our viewers that if you saw some kind of bright, colorful picture... unusual, it confused you in some way, be sure to send it to our editorial office, we will also certainly analyze any suspicious and questionable news, discuss it with experts and tell the truth to you, all the best to you.

hello, my name is dmitry bak, right here and now we have another episode of the literary podcast, which, as you probably remember, is called, let them not talk, let them read, we have a good reason today to talk, to read, you ask, well , what is the reason, there is no round date, but brodsky, of course, is worthy of conversation on any date, books have been written about him, his poems from...

let's talk about brodsky, here is my first question: i think that brodsky has the same problem as pushkin, well, he is absolutely great, that's what everyone says, but why, if i were to say it very briefly, literally in one formula, in one phrase, here's brodsky, why is he needed by a modern person, yes, because he fought the regime, because he is honest, because he is lonely, because he is what? first of all, brodsky succeeded in what can be counted on the fingers of one hand, as a poet. is given in the life of the national, of course, of every literature, he changed the sound of poetry, that is, after him people write, they cannot write the way it was before him, well, this is a wonderful formulation, i am addressing our interlocutor on the other side of the screen or earphone, yes, viktor kule has a good formation, it is impossible to write poetry anymore, just as it was before brodsky, nikrasov once wrote that it is impossible to write anymore as it was before

pushkin and it is impossible to write.

and there it was visible, there are wonderful poems at the end of a beautiful era, departure ones, but there was no new sound, if he had not written anything at all in emigration, he would have already remained in the history of russian but. here was a part of the speech lullaby-shaking mysa - it was high-quality, but the sound, yeah, it was vaccination here is a little bit of english, we will discuss this later, tell me, please, here is such a strange question, and why in a certain circle of people it is customary to call brodsky joseph, well pushkin is called either a little officially alexander sergeevich pushkin, or in the publishing house alexander pushkin or simply pushkin, as is customary, and why brodsky is called joseph?

a special sign of some kind of involvement, the fact that yevgeny borisevich reyin calls brodsky joseph is one thing, but when people in general rarely met him or did not meet him at all those who saw him call him that, it testifies to some kind of, i don’t know, kinship, and did you meet brodsky, well, you did, but very tangentially in london, when i was at a conference, the lotmand one, yes, at hill university, then stayed for the summer. with my translators, at that time the composition of the book god preserves everything by correspondence was being discussed then we will show this book, it is amazing, it is wonderful, maybe we will say a few words about it now, it was compiled by viktor kule, this was 1991,

the very dawn of perestroika, the book boom publications, here are two issues of the same magazine , but differently named, at first it was called literary review, then... the old literary review, when the new one appeared, these are two issues in memory of brodsky at the time when viktor kule was the editor-in-chief of the magazine, well, about this book, a few words, please tell me what is important here, so, the thing is that this is the first book, not only of poetry, but also of translations, and brutsky, when he left, they didn’t allow him to take anything with him, not even photographs of his parents, he left without a clutch papers, accordingly a huge amount of typewriters wrote, there is a classic photograph of a suitcase. yes, yes, yes, that's all, that's what was filmed, but he couldn't bring anything with him, that day of brodsky's departure, accordingly, volodya maramzin collected, compiled, also already deceased, yes, that famous samozdat collection, something else, here i dug up - then

all this is stored in a public place in st. petersburg, the moramzin collection of manuscripts hidden, there is a crazy number of translations there, which he considered lost, in general.

about ardis's books, i wanted to talk about that of course, participated in the formation of the corpus of texts of iosif aleksandrovich, this is an unusually important story, you mentioned to talk later, but since we are talking, then i will tell you a paradoxical thing, which i tell students, that there are well a million as an ordinary graduate student or dissertation candidate, and collected works, yes, of varying degrees of authority, there are books in the poet's library. which lev losev prepared did not have time to complete this work, but nevertheless, but i consider these six collections, which were published by the ardis publishing house, to be the standard, then they were reproduced in petersburg, by the late

gennady komarov, the pushkin pound publishing house, yes, that's all, i spied it, that 's it, here are the books, this is the second edition, eh, these titles sound like music to everyone who knows and loves brodsky. a stop in the desert, the end of a beautiful era, part of speech, new stanzas of kavgusta, a poem called, well, sort of by byron's title, urania landscape with flood. these six books are what brodsky himself left us in the form and composition he wanted. yes, that's it. i can add, when i was already sorting it out.

i must say, he is a young poet who did not know what publications he was talking about,

abroad, he did not think about it, he is 25 years old, yes, he writes something, scatters it somewhere, leaves poems, and there was such a wonderful person in st. petersburg, a poet, a cultured person igor kostya kuzmilsky, who remembered hundreds of thousands of lines by heart, when iosif sannovich was already sitting in norinskaya, kostya reproduced this entire book from memory, and this... he passed on the matter, naturally, there was something he could remember a little bit, that's not even the point, i think it's not even about the mistakes in the texts, in their layout, it's terrible, that goes without saying, he simply called many things of that period kindergarden, kindergarten, children's, yes, early things, it's a special question, did brodsky become great right away, when did it happen, i'll show you these two books again, this is the original ardis book, and this is its... eh, petersburg reproduction, and the composition and

even the division into pages completely reproduces the original. tsypso is frightening, the fact that they are giving this out does not convince me, it's not clear. the ssu allegedly captured a nuclear facility and even published video footage of confirmation. it is unlikely that a man with a graceful figure like mine would have been among the stormtroopers. the mine, the icbm, in the open, you will not see it. the feeling is complete that this is a museum. exhibit and how ukrainian bots are trying to convince the world that russia has run out of tanks? the joy is that the western audience sees this and refutes their own fakes. antifake, season premiere. tomorrow on the first. don't tell me only about men, that they fall in love. valentina titova is one of the most beautiful women of the soviet screen. she always gave the impression of a socialite, a woman who is surrounded by care. and love of her famous men, but it turns out

that the impression is deceptive: men were always afraid of me, and my husbands had no influence on me, get away from someone else's husband's wife, how basov reacted to your pregnancy, disappeared, who accompanied you to the maternity hospital, i don't know, his assistants, everyone pitied me in the maternity hospital, how valentina titova left vladimir basov and what the director wrote in statement to the court, filed for alimony, why didn't you take the children? oh, where, just mother sarcastically, yes, you want to ask me now, where did i put the money? confession of valentina titova: mother cuckoo or victim of love, can a beautiful woman or actress be happy at all? no one can stand it when a person hunts only for you, a knife in his hand. exclusive with dmitry borisov. premiere. on saturday, on the first. so, we. continue our conversation about joseph brodsky, and

today we are talking with an expert on brodsky, poet, translator, literary critic, viktor kule. what do you think, when the capital petersburg mainstream, whatever you like, line of poetry, well there the akhmatova bloc, the silver age, through such names of people who survived the revolution, mikhail seevich kuzmin, for example. or fyodor salagub continued to live, already in petrograd and even in leningrad, when all this suddenly became the leningrad note, the leningrad current not... according to censored poetry, how all this was transformed into the poetry of elena schwartz, the brilliant viktor krivulin, the deceased, to unfortunately, sergei stratanovsky, evgeny rein, lev losyev, i am calling now both those living now and those who have already passed away mikhail eremin,

after all, how did it all happen, and what is this leningrad note, what circles, well, of course, it is necessary to mention the opposition of the two.

for example, to lydia yakovlevna ginsburg, someone was hanging around aranzon, here it is mentioned, schwartz, kryulin, then the storage chambers you mention for the first time, important, this is also a poet, a wonderful poet, actually, from him here is the bypass canal in large part degrees, then the st. petersburg chamber of security, this is already oleg yuriev too, a lot of circles, but what unites them, they are united by the fact that few were published and few...

7 years, because he heard krasovitsky, saw the young brodsky, of course, i remember the poem that viktor borisovich krivulin read to me, the late, i will say again, a brilliant poet, leningradsky, here is a fragment: over the plains prigov flies, rubenstein flies, the leviophan floats, four trumpets and many-eyed, but completely indistinct, clarity, he says, is lacking, wolf, this is... such a harsh definition of informal muscovites, that is, there is official literature, there are two informal literatures, they do not converge and brodsky is born, after all, who was brodsky with? well, of course, he was one of akhmatova's orphans, as they say, or orphans, yes, this is and...