Skip to main content

tv   Fault Lines  Al Jazeera  June 7, 2014 10:00pm-10:31pm EDT

10:00 pm
>> we're here at the darrington unit, which is a maximum security prison on the outskirts of texas. >> jimarquez holland is 20 years old. he's been imprisoned here for three years. >> to me, i feel like what i was doing was petty. petty crimes - i never thought in a million years that i would be 17 and in prison. never thought. whenever the judges said, we send you to prison, i couldn't even believe it. >> his criminal record began when he was in just sixth grade.
10:01 pm
police officers in his school gave him tickets for misbehavior, including smoking cigarettes. >> just hanging out with the wrong people. just not thinking with my head when you're young. >> he's here because of a burglary charge. when he was sentenced, the judge factored in his juvenile record, which included his misbehavior in school. >> instead of dealing with troubled students in traditional ways like counseling and detention, more schools are enforcing zero tolerance policies - and depending on law enforcement to carry them out. >> it's known as the school to prison pipeline. >> we've taken the same failed policies that have led to mass incarceration, and we're using them in schools throughout the country. >> in this episode of fault
10:02 pm
lines, we travel to texas - one of the top states in funneling students from schools to jails. >> for many students, the journey to prison can begin at the start of the school day. in texas, if you're late to school three times, that's considered an unexcused absence. under state law, a student with ten unexcused absences faces fines up to 500 dollars, and a warrant to show up to truancy court. if the student can't pay the fine by the time they turn 17, they can face time in prison.
10:03 pm
jennifer torres is in her last year of high school. she owes more than 7,000 dollars in fines for truancy. she said was late to school, in part, because she worked nights as a janitor to help support her family. >> the other night i didn't leave work till like 1. >> so you get home and you're in bed by what, 2? >> i still have to shower, yeah. >> 2? yeah. and then what time are you supposed to be at school in the morning? >> well, i wake up at 5 just to get ready and stuff. >> 5? >> yeah, so it's really not that much sleep. >> can you walk me through how many classes that you've missed, or how many absences that you have? >> a little over a hundred. but it was in the last 4 years. >> over a hundred over four years? >> yeah, they actually came to school, they pulled me out of class and they got me and they told me to come with them and i was like, i was surprised. because i didn't know about this. they told me they had 2 warrants out for me and i was like, for what? and they said truancy. and they kind of took me to jail for a while. >> i mean if you're trying to
10:04 pm
get somebody to go to school, why take them out of school. why put them in jail to miss more school, you know? i think it's pointless. >> jennifer's family can't afford to pay the fine, so she is doing community service to discharge the debt. if she doesn't, she may have to spend the summer in jail. >> we try to work hard for pay bills, house, pay taxes, and extra 7,000 dollars is crazy. statistics show that zero tolerance polices target the most disadvantaged youth. black students are more than three times as likely to be suspended or expelled as their white peers. hispanics and those with disabilities also face harsher
10:05 pm
punishments. students routinely get police-issued misdemeanors for things that used to mean a trip to the principal's office >> we're seeing an over-reaction to childish behavior. we're seeing racial profiling in our schools, in our hallways, of young people of color who are seen to be threats, so all of these kinds of over reactions push us to have these policies and practices in schools, that lead to pushing young people out, pushing them into the juvenile justice system, and into the criminal justice system. >> many of the criminal citations are handed out for minor infractions, like dress code violations. these cases happen all over the country, and often the most absurd ones make the news. >> small children cited for
10:06 pm
throwing paper airplanes flipping the teacher off criminal citations for cussing in class 14-year old girl charged with disorderly conduct for repeatedly text messaging during class. small paring knife in lunch box gets north carolina student suspended for the rest of her senior year. one teenage student arrested for pouring milk on his girlfriend more than a thousand tickets were issued to primary school children over the past six years in texas several districts ticketed a six year old at least once. >> critics say resorting so quickly to the criminal justice system alienates students from the school system, makes them more likely to drop out and end up in prison. >> we're in north houston right now. we're just going to meet a young man. theo is the guy's name and he's had all sorts of run-ins with the justice system starting in school.
10:07 pm
>> theo holmes is 19 years old. he served 3 years in a juvenile facility, mostly because of tickets he received from cops at his school. >> i think my first ticket was minor possession of tobacco, i believe. after that ticket i was like man, what you all going to do to me, ticket was $300 i ain't going to do community service. 14, 15, years old, you know what i'm saying? what you going to do to me? yall going to take me downtown or take me home? >> he says his mother kicked him out of the house at the age of 12. and his father was not in his life. the punishments at school didn't help theo get back on track. he ended up in juvenile detention. now, when he's ready to get his life together, his juvenile record stands in his way. >> so can you tell me how having the probation and the record is affecting you know? >> it's affecting me a whole
10:08 pm
bunch because it's like i can't get no job. you know what i want to do, i want to be in international business, but at the same time i can't get nobody to even hear me talk or hear my story. they don't want to hear me out. now they looking at me like damn you a hoodlum. i can't hire you. >> so when you go back and you think about where it all started, is it fair to say that it did start with the infractions in school that you got ticketed for? >> man, it been started. it been started. in texas, if you a minority in the state of texas ain't nothing for you. or you come from poverty you got no one that, black, white brown, pink blue, ain't nothing for you. you know what i mean. it wouldn't nothing to help us prepare for the real world. it helped us prepare for jail
10:09 pm
10:10 pm
next on techknow. the earthquake business, it's similar to the weather business. understanding our earth. but everything happens faster.
10:11 pm
limiting disaster. these are the guts of the early warning system. saving lives. having 30 seconds of advanced warning is like a lifetime. techknow, every saturday go where science meets humanity. this is some of the best driving i've ever done, even thought i can't see. techknow. we're here in the vortex. next, only on al jazeera america. >> with every horrific school shooting in the u.s., there are calls for more police officers in schools. but more police means students are more likely to be written up for misbehavior...and eventually end up in prison. the federal government provides tens of millions of dollars a year to fund these officers in schools across the country. >> every time we have a school shooting ,we actually realize that there was a young person in need and they weren't in need of
10:12 pm
a police officer. they were in need of an adult who could have talked to them, who could have counseled them, who could have deferred them to resources that they may have needed that weren't available in the school. >> across texas, police officers like javier alvarez, spend their days patrolling school campuses. in 2013, they wrote over 100,000 misdemeanor tickets. >> how do you make the distinction between a group of kids sitting around a vehicle harmlessly hanging out and something where you're actually going to roll up and talk to them a bit? >> these kids right here they saw us, they saw me turn away and i saw them when we turned into this alleyway. it was obvious they were not trying to hide something or start walking away. it's the ones that when they see you they turn around and start fiddling with their fingers. those are the ones you want to talk to >> what do you think of
10:13 pm
the school to prison pipeline? is that reflected in your experience? >> what's being said that kids that get in trouble with police in school are more likely to go to prison later, well how can that be? if you're destined for a life of crime, then that's in your system. that's in your blood. a lot of this stuff comes from the families. >> chief of police victor araiza is in charge of security at over 100 facilities in the el paso school district. he says teachers and administrators rely too much on police to solve their problems. >> children that can be problematic on a campus, the objective sometimes from faculty and staff is to have them removed, have them disciplined, have them sent to alternative schools. and the mechanism, the tool to accomplish that, is a police report, or some type of a
10:14 pm
document that says this student is so unruly that he can no longer be kept at this campus and he needs to be cited, he needs to be charged with a criminal offense and officer, you need to do that and help me. >> we tried to talk to dozens of teachers in texas, but only one agreed to speak with us: anna sifford - who has taught high school social studies for seven years. >> i see that teachers have neglected to figure out a way to handle a lot of problems on their own that they used to. things that were up to the teacher before are now a phone call away. >> how many of your peers are just picking up the phone and calling the school resource officer? >> i'd say the majority of teachers are doing that. definitely 75% out of all of us, if i just want to make a rough guess doing that, because they go in with a set lesson plan and when the kid doesn't want to do it , what do i do i get him out of my classroom. >> one thing we sort of heard as a criticism is that well, they are cops, you put one in a school they are going to start policing and all of a sudden they will start ticketing
10:15 pm
things, enforcing laws in a way that wouldn't normally happen and so you have a higher likelihood that the young people in school will be criminalized. is that something that you've seen borne out? >> there are sros that i've heard from colleagues of mine that write them every five minutes. you know, if there's a problem, write a ticket, problem, write a ticket. and that's where the kid ends up in court, and the tickets are being written to families that are not going to be able to afford them to pay them. that's why the kid ends serving the time. >> getting troubled students out of the classroom often means sending them to what's euphemistically called an "alternative school." at lincoln middle school, it's just a group of classrooms that are segregated from the rest of the school. >> alternative is here from morning until the afternoon when they leave. >> so they don't change classrooms? >> they don't change classrooms. they have one teacher.
10:16 pm
every middle school has an alternative... >> so out of a thousand students here, there's never more than say... >> right now we have about 12... >> what's with the most wanted and the mug shots? >> funny you may have to mention that. two of those kids used to be here in alternative. it's to let these kids know that hey, you know. this kid was always getting into trouble. >> critics say alternative schools can actually backfire because they're grouping together troubled students, labeling them as "bad" and isolating them from their peers. students can also fall back academically because the lessons aren't as rigorous. >> this is just a mild form of incarceration and we let those kids know that. >> school districts have to make choices. they have limited resources and unfortunately we see too many
10:17 pm
school districts rushing to get a police officer with a gun and a badge instead of a counsellor. >> now inroducing, the new al jazeea america mobile news app. get our exclusive in depth, reporting when you want it. a global perspective wherever you are. the major headlines in context. mashable says... you'll never miss the latest news >> they will continue looking for suvivors... >> the potential for energy production is huge... >> no noise, no clutter, just real reporting. the new al jazeera america mobile app, available for your apple and android mobile device. download it now
10:18 pm
10:19 pm
>> as civil rights and education activists sounded alarm bells about the school to prison pipeline, the federal government eventually took notice. >> in january, the obama administration released new guidelines intended to curtail overly zealous discipline policies in schools across the country. >> the report found that minority students were far more likely to face disciplinary action or arrest. it also cited schools for widespread use of out-of-school suspensions, 95 percent of them for nonviolent offenses like
10:20 pm
disrespect and tardiness. >> a routine school discipline infraction should land a student in the principal's office, i think, at worst, not in a police precinct. the guidelines followed a study of almost 1 million texas which found that students who'd been suspended were more likely to fail academically, drop out of school and face arrest. this facility in houston texas is called a rehabilitation center. but in reality, it's a prison for boys under the age of 17. this sixteen year old got caught with marijuana starting when he was 13 years old; he also got in trouble for truancy. under state law, we couldn't film his face. he's 2 months into a 3 month term. >> do you feel as though you've changed? >> yes, sir.
10:21 pm
>> how about now when you get out. what are you going to look to do? >> he's unlikely to get into the armed forces with a juvenile record. so for many kids with behavior problems, it's another way that early criminal records set them up for lost opportunities. >> we were just outside at the basketball court. and then we came inside because all the guards came running. apparently there's some sort of fight inside this juvenile facility. still not sure what's going on
10:22 pm
but you get the sense that things do happen, young people do act out. >> young people who are sentenced to juvenile facilities are 37 times more likely to be arrested again as adults. often, the additional charges and longer sentences begin here, for infractions like fighting with other inmates. i'm wab. >> cr is in for possession of marijuana. his father is has been detained for immigration violations, and his family is struggling with losing that support. >> what happened to your eye? >> okay.. >> yeah. >> how long does a fight like that happen for before it's broken up? >> and then the guards are right there? >> yeah >> so that fight you got into this week, is that going
10:23 pm
to make it harder for you to go home? >> how do you feel about that? like, is that a big deal to you? >> studies show that grouping delinquent youth together actually has a negative impact on their behavior. facing pressure, texas tried to cut down on the number of students being ticketed in schools for disruptive behavior. last year, the legislature passed a law that barred police officers from giving misdemeanor citations to students for disrupting class or acting up on the bus. this truancy court in the
10:24 pm
capital of austin is also trying to shift away from the criminalization of juvenile behavior. >> the approach here is more about making sure that there's a positive result. let's go check it out. >> we talk about school to prison pipeline. we don't want students to become accustomed to going to court, to having a case, to having a warrant out there for your arrest, even though it's a class c misdemeanor. it desensitizes those folk. i purposefully don't want to feed into that. >> alright next case we have here is jordan hearn. >> rather than fine her or recommend a stiffer penalty, judge williams has decided to send this student's truancy case back to her middle school: where she will be tried by a jury of her peers.
10:25 pm
>> so the name is jordan. cause is tru... i don't know how to spell truancy. i'm going to put "not at school." >> it's a kind of intervention that hopes to help young people avoid a more serious involvement with the criminal justice system. offenders who go through a youth court are half as likely to commit another infraction as those who go to a formal court for the same crime. despite these efforts to cut down on the number of youths with criminal records, for many people, it's too late. >> we've come here to the darrington unit on the outskirts of houston. this is where the school to prison pipeline terminates, at
10:26 pm
maximum security facilities like this one. >> we're getting buzzed up to go to the classrooms right now. >> we were invited to observe a class which focuses on life skills, like anger management. >> with a show of hands, how many have actually been suspended from public education - from school? elementary, middle school, high school that you got suspended from school. >> every time i messed up i'd either get kicked out or put in some kind of disciplinary that didn't make me want to go back... instead of just sitting down and working with me. >> when i was in alternative
10:27 pm
school, it was just a bunch of gang members you know just gang-banging or doing drugs. it really led me for the penitentiary. >> what was it about the environment there that you feel prepared you for the pen? >> it was the same as the penitentiary. >> how so? >> gang banging, people doing their time the way they want to. we weren't learning anything or whatever. same thing. >> donald matthews is 35 years old. he was arrested for arson in 2008, but he said his problems began when he was still in school. >> i had an attitude - i'm add, i can't sit down too long. not paying attention in school, go to school when i want to. different things of that nature, just being rebellious. >> this is what my everyday
10:28 pm
life is, man. got my bunk. that's where i sleep at. >> like many of the men here, he says never received a real education or one-on-one attention until he came to prison. >> what was the environment like when you went to the alternative school? >> to me it was just prepping individuals just for- it was like just an isolated place, off to where you can be around people of your kind. you know, that we can relate to each other. i'm a disobedient child, you're a disobedient child, you do what you want to do, i do what i want to do, so we get together and we're going to be even worse. it didn't help me in no kind of way. the one i went to, there wasn't no one trying to actually teach. all they were doing is just
10:29 pm
doing something with you at that point in time because you're a kid, they can't just kick you out of school or get rid of you. that's for bad kids, like a babysitter or something. >> do feel like anything that happened there helped you avoid ending up where you did? >> no, no. i think with me going there, i think that helped me end up where i am now. >> i find it immoral to destroy something like this >> an epic fight to preserve a way of life. >> we ask for strength as we take on one of the most powerful forces on the globe >> a battle for the very soul of this state, but is time running out? >> it's a wholesale effort to buy government fault lines al jazeera america's >> ground breaking... >> we have to get out of here...
10:30 pm
award winning investigative documentary series wisconsin's mining standoff on al jazeera america caltech this is "techknow", a show about innovations that saves lives. we explore hardware and humanity in a unique way. this is a show about scientists by scientists. let's check out the team of so-called nerves. lindsay moran, an analyst - new technology can make guns safer. does it work. we put it to the "techknow" test. kyle hill is a science writer with a background in engineering. tonight - earthquakes. they are frightening, devastating and can strike