tv NEWSHOUR Al Jazeera June 29, 2018 4:00pm-5:01pm +03
4:00 pm
constitutes shameful behavior and steve check out on this episode a one on one east we look at the mysterious disappearance of four young women were they killed because they clapped their hands. northern pakistan a place where not much has changed for the locals in a long time. but then technology the mobile phone shook their world. a video of four girls and two boys went public. it doesn't look very dramatic girls clapping boys dancing. around or they never appear together and the girls are fully covered. but here that was more
4:01 pm
than enough just you just if you. wait a minute citizen. but in english filthy afzali stanny is the brother of the two boys in the video. and a lot of men at the. gate of the house are engaged jana and appears in the case of the most of the many of us to see what. islam abad based reporter. saw the video he realized the precarious future faced by the girls in a place ruled by strict customs separating men and women he decided to travel to coaster to talk with the locals about the case.
4:02 pm
of decay. or someone who just that he has. no the deal with your clothes mr. jealous other. didn't get out of got of this thing and. it is either get out isn't it i said that about the yellow lab now it was a decade at the end of the book at them that they yell out of syria. they get in the end get you in a lot of it. because it's a little bottle is. a matter like i mean but i sometimes at the beginning today is that really this i think and that is that i get them out of either. so i'm not a mound you will both bought it because i think that it is just plum on when they get sick but i mean to be in a. but has seed found the younger residents hold different views. the
4:03 pm
main the city to khaled put him up he put on the order can you see how large. or what to do you got down to school much wouldn't my journey if i look at it he hand . in pakistan tribal decisions are made by a group of male elders known as a juror. well controversial giorgos are often used to resolve disputes adjuvants power can be deadly. one young man has the interview described what he says happened to the girls in the video. there. that are very early. to say well you. know sure. all the people you know know what they were in there were always.
4:04 pm
there if you will come whenever one particular. record. or in a. very kewl. cib returned to islamabad with his new story but he knew this was not going to be the end of it. they're going to get hurt but they're going to make do go on with monica or appeared to see you yeah nice in there to kill them and get in there gotten good will be family. or are. going to get in there don't matter there. were found on look and you were there you but they. you were just on the run down but now where derek's a home to put on dances with. since i've solved brothers were in the video he now fears for his own life yet in your own no. show he would just think you would just do all that lovey out of west and. get. out if that
4:05 pm
was you what do you want it maybe at which it wouldn't last august. afzal is convinced the girls have been killed by a get out going to. be about me i'm going to get on i don't know if you were funny but i know what i'm going to be yeah when i see them but i'm in trouble and happy because the first time in like a minute you back up to say i was the bad guy i've been through from the plant and i've been good at the name and there's i'm done with. government but women's rights activists didn't believe it immediately or something like that people like us the knee jerk responses. because these are the violations . all that. the supreme court ordered the girls in question be brought before them the local authorities insisted that the girls were alive but they would not present
4:06 pm
them to the court so the judge ordered a team of investigators to fly to the region to meet the girl's people just like does. a helicopter. farzana bari and other members of the fact finding commission traveled north from islamabad to coerce there should be no was one of them on the helicopter. that he would have. to run if he was brought in the phony bismillah party was elected i think he had bought it a twenty a disk in that one can lead to nowhere got a nomination or a body due to some. of. the investigators talk to the locals about honor killings. every person had restored it will that you'll see that i'm. going to have a minivan beside. me. the want to devour the ridiculous opposite the sauce story the city gave a whopper to i said that just anomic
4:07 pm
a common goal in your dollars a gram do it that you had to sit it got to me though why blister. local administration will request he could be upcoming which the sweden but you're going to be here so what about enjoying it i'm going to convene a bill i'm a living i'm guessing i'm quite an defecating to give me but yeah but they were very very election. all right. the next morning when they went to the girl's village they found several empty mud huts the. garden kittens turned scarlet on any a move going to get him yet far as such from a casino celtic was look at me with. the investigators say the locals tried hard to dissuade them from meeting the girls. insist he again little to do not accuse them in life gone on as if they had
4:08 pm
a couple bag he is far better at the new face part of it the only piece this far but if you think about michelle absolutely done but the women insisted finally they met a girl on the mountainside she was wearing a red shawl like the girls in the video she was lucky that excuse but of course like the last and don't let us know when we should be you know speaks little bit of the language the pit. you're looking when you get to. that ik communication on lithium disheartening. they were told she was called a meaner the investigators asked her about the video. but then they hound dog i think they're on the. up and got a million americans journal bird. barbara will give. to our being we're gonna be shoe bomb was like a hog here may dear how many. here would your brother
4:09 pm
a year. they compared the girl they met to the one in the video when we saw this look at the food to look at all three of us say she seems the same but she was the only girl they met. when the team asked for more time to meet the others their police escort insisted they had to return to the capital immediately they did not let us tuesday. what does that mean helicopter just back to the supreme court and we will be putting that we have only met once and that seems to be a light. that . this is good.
4:10 pm
and this is being. as you know i. mean is being merely because of the game is something that he still does in the way he just sat there listening to the minute he says i think it was the best because if i give it. to the french if they just get down there. what if you look at their vietnam if you look at the one they are going to do just looking well give it a pretty good. even though that has been the source of a good. joke. let's get between these eight which is a good joke you're going to get in the. journalist . disagrees you do see some of the shots a score and skip
4:11 pm
a beat me when i think about it but i'm going to have to provide you can't give up because they can mark you're going to scare me so people are to be are you going to call you what you will not people and you haven't even read your stand each other not that you get in here where you have our style where we have need to package the rules of football at the end next week when you buy any drug money off you because you might use it to you to be here. i'm. ok but i got lucky. tries calling one of the brothers in the video. oh hello oh goodness that one has brought only slumbered sejanus to the bob do you were brought in by people. enjoy when they began hand in there's an audio on the family one called john do up
4:12 pm
there was going to be with us now to go back to. oh my. god. i. are. good to go but it was. a jumbo up. a tell you any of you up nearly by night at some more highly of local net but not of your likin opcode you dance while they are mean much to me. while i do clipping other won't get past guess aboard. your name in milan it can be evident that guessing me no name no more clip them in the end it can wind up on their to do an article give you a going to what obscene is in the guess it. was. the brother sticks to his story that the video was fake.
4:13 pm
meanwhile one week after the first investigative team returns from coaster their job unfinished a second team is sent. the team again includes farzana bari this time joined by a parliamentarian and a judge. a local government minister addresses the religion in a jirga like setting. yes a daughter marrying your aunt courtside if they were getting there. they can already but. i just are going to get myself a great now i. get sad if i just thank you said you don't care like ikea you're insane if you don't believe the idea you're our society do you have someone here you care i'm john ordering. all of these tacky jenna gotta keep.
4:14 pm
the investigators met two more girls who claim to be in the video. the team tried to verify if they were. put on the credibility as sick as you might be to go to my pupils an. attempt. now on. the other machine bush. doesn't care about her. but. he. learned a lot of. this is what her. last. words this girl. was this girl syringe are far isn't a bari did not believe that they were the girls from the video i told them that these are not those two women afaik but she was overruled by the other team members
4:15 pm
by the time the team headed back to islamabad they were no longer speaking to each other they were team members of the committee i am saying they are the same in further investigation as to why these two other women are saying you know all the he met the girls and they're saying they think their thing has happened they submitted their report to the chief justice of pakistan soon after the supreme court closed the case months later the fate of the girls remains unclear the boys are in hiding but their family has become the target of deadly revenge jargony those are the you know who really was going to be as it were they were one of those at the mo you're go there if you're going to. be a car. i know to be from there. but if you get that. e-mail you can assume they have both the. afzal is that breaking point.
4:16 pm
was very nice families don't just look when buying go near the head of the new you can name this acknowledging name but you know that there won't be news in the about me jamie mediate already knew you know that it was going to sound it out we do. catherine who rolled is another journalist who took up the kates first i thought of me was that these are you know. obviously i can verify that because you are saying it in a certain views trip so i had to go and talk to the women who'd been sent by the supreme court to investigate this. and one of them gives photographs of the women that they maps and that photographs us all supplied under katherine sent both sets of photos to a british facial recognition company. the experts then studied the two sets of big
4:17 pm
jurors. they said that this was very unlikely to be the same woman for one thing that you might notice is that here she has a mole just above her lip maybe a couple of millimeters above her lip here the mole appears to have moved and flattened. much higher her facial structure also seems to be different. so the question is if. these two women are not the same. why did this woman meet investigators returning to the small one possible explanation is that some interest that. it's technically he's honest there is technically most he can do something about it to be evidence i.e.
4:18 pm
they will be having with this new evidence from the facial recognition experts farzana bari now believed she could get the case reopened then get things i could get published and i had that every good spirit it was through and that there you know it was forty percent resemblance it was those the feet but they died three brothers of you know those boys that also and i got the statements from the police stations bit by these people reported because they were at it as were my going to his voice saying that he had killed these boys because they had made videos of the men. she was advised to take the case to the district. boys because of the doll who did the big chunk of wood yard to join awful followed by the body of. the dog in a cubicle in the bones that. i'm going to cuba pile up was i got by double job on
4:19 pm
with the book on cost of value or done a good job it. what did you know you were getting office like of mine had a lock box. nearly two years after the video was first leaked mazhar akram the lawyer for the national commission for the status of women presents the case when i did go to bed or eastman haitink and that do it or did your boss who are going to your boss yak it take to know that you hand your will not to one go adalat an official. i got a bulls in then he had the on good dead bodies drab or bored to have produced. determined to keep the case in the public has turned to social media. focused on you know how to show that you know how. you have. to look ok who you just know so it's really easy but if you're not just your last night. it touched
4:20 pm
a nerve. that . was that said that. i. was ok that. was. the one who. understands you but i thought one of your own is about going to be a noticeable difference as you probably know about that your problem about young women. in those that are in there it's just it's a funny thing is just pretty open not the one that i did the dots got me to. write that. was placed on the school khaki hump and the mamas i can show on the coast there you just do it just them so i think you can meet institution the spectacular just it was part of what that would include softening. but after months
4:21 pm
of legal wrangling the high court reverses the district court order that the case is closed again. the girls were never seen in any court you're looking at it was obvious that the movie you're just guessing that you can't get it for five years was simply if you have it if you look to the left of the study something needs to look at the be. made to go to school the top to get you break it will get you what it was going to be what i'm here to get it out but you will be other what other got not yet let's look a look at the well but you don't get stuck you know i'm a dog i know what i'm going to be i'll give you good deal look when you're going to get your looks interesting. i'm going to get up now mr tongue out of the book that you will get to see much richard in which we're going on you to make sure that you sell your absolute. but that's not how
4:22 pm
those who hold the power in this remote region think of men like jurgen member move mark move don't get marry might be busy we get behind you we hear about it make a whole other look justifiably proud to be needy you know. i got i thought i saw that did it i've got a side i'm saying they've got. nothing to do they can with your hundred percent. to me was silent you happen if there's a day that is the automatic bell it sounds like i'm the. this is the house where brothers are hiding. bin nasser explains how the video has turned his life upside down. has put in better medical me.
4:23 pm
because he. he's sure the girls have been killed. but. the brothers see no escape from the death threats also hanging over them. they can't even plead their case to be jirga. they get. the numbers in the name of. the mediator you have to give him a letter you send it out as you know you but you didn't get to live and. again i'm with you. of course which means. that he. cannot deceive me that you.
4:24 pm
4:25 pm
4:26 pm
business updates brought to you by qatar airways going places together in an exclusive documentary series al-jazeera reveals the full story that changed the face of the middle east this is not a war to defeat this is a war over the way for the promise of the final episode of a three part series explores the impending threat to global superpowers and uncovers why the conflict continues to this day the war in october the battle and beyond this time. the law. this is al jazeera.
4:27 pm
well i wish i'll carry this is the live from doha coming up in the next sixty minutes later claim an agreement on migrants but details are thin on how they will put it all into action. the parents desperation as hope fades of finding missing teenage footballers trapped in a flooded cave in thailand. five people are dead after a gunman targets journalists at a newspaper and the u.s. . the world trade organization backs australia's plain packaging of tobacco products and this lead to global laws against smoking. european cooperation has won the day the words of french president after a year leaders agreed to a compromise deal and that controlling the influx of refugees that's despite cracks
4:28 pm
already beginning to emerge on the actual details after negotiating through the night you leaders agreed to give turkey an extra three billion dollars to take care of syrian refugees they also pledged more money to north african countries to stop sea crossings within the e.u. the joint communique speaks of sharing responsibility for refugees rescued at sea and restricting their movement across the block and it gives governments the option of setting up asylum centers some place in. europe is not an island and we must be able to face up to this challenge was for many loyal to have values and protect our people and national cohesion tonight we took an important step many predicted the impossibility of an agreement many predicted the triumph of national solutions tonight we have succeeded in finding the european solution and a way of working in cooperation here but the deal it is being criticised for its lack of detail italy's. interior minister has called for concrete commitments all it's unclear whether german chancellor angela merkel's coalition partners will even
4:29 pm
accept this compromise are in place been following all these talks in brussels and he joins us live from there so lauren says many sad some people thought it was impossible that any type of agreement but caddis so now obviously something has but it's still not totally clear what what tell us how this played out. well i mean certainly back home was putting a gloss on it not least because some of the ideas were his but if you boil it right down basically what they were faced with as they went into these talks overnight was a choice between either upholding dilute the rule of law and humanitarian values inside the european union at the risk of collapsing the book because of internal divisions or appeasing the hard right populist inside the european union by jobs and greater measures to keep people out and in the end they chose the second of those two options and so the final communique is full of ideas about strengthening borders
4:30 pm
working with the libyan coast guard in turkey and returning people all the sort of thing that the breakthrough bits of it which i mention that macro to come up with is the idea of these control centers in european countries in which migrants and refugees might immediately have to go and it's a majorly apparent determines whether they've got the right to stay or whether they haven't and if they haven't they majorly get sent back assuming that anybody knows actually which country you might send them back to but that was enough certainly to appease the rebellious italian government here and it seems to have potentially lead to angela merkel's political career being salvaged as well because the signals it seems so far from her coalition are that they might be happy to accept this and so a success for the right wing but deeply controversial those ideas for example i mentioned about working with the libyan. god already condemns by people like the school hello
4:31 pm
the leader of the greens in the european parliament who told al-jazeera a short time ago that this would mean european money going to the groups in libya. the libyan coast guard is very well known to mistreat people to beat people we know the how the situation in libya is there is horrendous human rights violations happening people are raped people would be to be tortured and this is something that you can you certainly should not supports but this is exactly what we're seeing right now and i mean there's not even a state in libya basically giving money to militias that who might fight against each other to morrow with european money and maybe european weapons so orses are not small concerns are not small details the devil is in the details so yes they have this idea and in abstract but actually executing it particularly with concerns like that could really be a challenge. it's yes i mean if you read the communique in
4:32 pm
any detail it's extremely vague. i mean it talks about for example a consensus needs to be found on reforming the dublin arrangements which is the thing that demands that a refugee or a migrant is sent back to the first european country they go to well there have been a red line for the italians they said they would veto any arrangements that didn't involve a really goes out of dublin at this event for the time being they rolled over on that but clearly there is no absolute agreement with angela merkel pointed out when she left the talks of dorm there is no common asylum policy inside the european union whatsoever so in the end if the point of this was to stop the collapse of the bloc in the shortest term that is what they've accomplished but what they haven't addressed have got their heads right in the sand is what the european union is supposed to be does it actually want to continue to be the world's leading proponents of human rights abuses or as donald tusk the head of the european
4:33 pm
council says should it be europeans rather than people like the united nations who decide what migration policy is and if so are they are those european thoughts being led by supporters of hard right populist governments and what is the implication of that all those questions of the moment are left unanswered in the interest of just looking like they've got some sort of deal they can go home with rights and sarah lawrence lee live for us in brussels lawrence thank you and as the e.u. claims that agreement on dealing with migrants the crackdown against them continues in italy hours before the leaders met police clear this camp on the outskirts of the capital roam the victims' families and destroying prefabricated home it's an estimated twenty six thousand people are on target following orders by be unshared minister material teo that is sylvania that camp's been told of foreigners being expelled. john listed you money we're human beings we have all our documents in order my children are telling citizens they were born here they went to school here
4:34 pm
. it's hal an interior minister salvini and also virginia raji did this it would be better if they go to other camps to see the children they don't go to school and do nothing they are in bad condition they leave the camp like that this camp was in order and they destroyed it they left us in the middle of the road italy saw the countries that refused to let in a rescue ship carrying more than two hundred refugees a lifeline of eventually docked in malta after being stranded at sea for six days and now it's the subject of an investigation questioning whether it was assisting people smugglers has more from. the lifelines volunteer crew spent the day washing down the boat taking out rubbish accumulated during its six days at sea mission lifeline which owns the vessel has a more complicated cleanup of its reputation its interact lee accused of colluding to smuggle people to europe after it refused to hand over two hundred thirty three
4:35 pm
45 Views
Uploaded by TV Archive on