robert says slowly too much of the paddock said he still had the support of the archdiocese direct quote was right now i know i do he said i even spoke to the cardinal. cardinal dolan how long do you think that cardinal dolan will continue to protect you as more men come out with their stories. father patrick said he didn't remember joseph but joseph told us he can't forget father patrick. we were very very serious. i had this stupid d.v.d. of like these clips maybe i interviewed him or something for the t.v. news i don't know with each discovery from his archive jews have seen counters when the priest came into sharper focus and there it is the junior ring ceremony mask i had forgotten that i was the elector at the mass that he was the celebrant of the mass.

it's called even name. the only church to separate from the bible and father patrick sat right behind him and there's no possible way that he could forget who i was based on the number of interactions i had with him the only thing that would make sense to me is if you know if i was just another kid that he touched and it was like you know one in the same faceless nameless. you know that was his way of justifying it blocking it out that's the only thing i can think of just another kid that he touched yeah seems to be quite a number of us you know. patrick's accusers had reported their abuse to family friends and therapist years ago. but for a long time these men didn't file lawsuits or seek prosecutions against the priest

. that's because new york's restrictive statute of limitations law made it nearly impossible for them to do so the legal system should be geared to the needs of the victim not the needs of the perpetrator or the institutions that caused it and essentially we're opening the door of the courthouse so when the victims ready they come forward for 17 years legal scholar marcy hamilton has fought for laws that give victims of child sex abuse more time to file claims. and in state capitals across the country the catholic church has been her adversary there's a sense of entitlement that they deserve respect and they deserve deference but nobody is going to get respect or deference is so long as they endanger children and that's what they're doing so long as they lobby against the victims in the state legislatures they're on the side of the pedophiles. this year

1000 states and the district of columbia brought in the statute of limitations for child sex crimes when new york's law went into effect in august to sit and hundreds of survivors filed lawsuits against the archdiocese of new york. i didn't think i would be able to do this i didn't think i would be able to tell anyone but when i found out that after now 8 of us have come forward and he's still in ministry in manhattan. it's something further had to be done jews have became the 2nd man this year to go public against father patrick. but his attorneys pointed to an even earlier claim back in 2012 another survivor just like mr care mon-el came forward he came forward he reported to the archdiocese the actions of monsignor product he reported to the district attorney the actions of monsignor

paddock i was with him during that report those years ago this is your proof of claim what does this say here 62712 in 20122012 this man who we'll call hector filed that initial report here rico who committed the acts of sexual abuse or other wrongful conduct father john and particular hector was a 17 year old student at cardinal hayes high school in the bronx that's when he went to father patrick for help dealing with the sexual abuse he'd faced as a child somebody is close to the family. a child a child unless when i was 5 years old. and i'm blogging me so the school. i'll talk about it and get it out and move on. but i said it's a wrong person. and he just sort of venice

a fellow has. just gone towards the pods. comfortable. back again he grabbed both of the handles like to stop when he was holding the handles on the chair what do you think he was trying to say with that stop moving the stop move. and i left out the room a little baffled as to my head and my knowledge is. because i just thought something was wrong with me. the archdiocese investigated hector's claim and cleared patrick of wrongdoing the archdiocese has known about the allegations against monsignor katic for years more than 6 years. those allegations have been kept quiet by the archdiocese they chose to believe the offender who had been accused and who had no doubt deny it and then silently and

quietly continue that offender in ministry from that day to this that's what they chose to do when we met father patrick at church he agreed to an on camera interview the next day he changed his mind and we ended up on the phone with him. they all have sort of strikingly similar stories and that's where you know it starts to get a little hard on telling us. there's. something wrong. would you pull them close to you is that would that be sort of a traditional way that you would counsel them as i point them close to you just. try scored a skirt or i don't know so. i'm ok would your knees ever be touching their ears. ok

would your knee ever would you ever have your knee inside their leg or anything like that certainly not consciously in your consolation process would you ever see yourself like rubbing on their on their leg are on their thought oh. never ok did you ever remove any students close any student or alter always clothing or any reason. so did you ever examined them medically examined them no you never did you never examined them. with a stethoscope no oh ok. ok all right yeah that's one of the claims that the few of them made was that you can't was. there was patrick for years it appeared the products parishioners were not aware of the claims against their priest and here's pat in 2015 presiding over

a confirmation mass through it all it seemed that father patrick could rely on the support of the archbishop and here is a picture of cardinal dolan and raising a glass with his buddy father paddy. looks like they're pretty close friends. as a cardinal dolan is among a select group of the vatican's most powerful men. for a time there was even talk of him becoming the next pope. he promised respect and obedience to me and my successors to god the speaker this could work you know bring it just so. we wanted to know how long cardinal dolan would take father panix word over that of his accusers. once again we found ourselves in church looking for a chance to greet the man who catholics refer to as his eminence.

as dolan greeted parishioners he appeared to be in good spirits. that began to change once we asked him about father patrick the archdiocese and now in about 6 of these things against father having for 7 years now and i was wondering why is he still in active ministry is what is necessary to be resounding in this but there's a moral obligation are you willing you are willing to take the free speech those who prescribe sure there are genuine shooters in multiple allegations or are you going to ask you are you probably are you. are you willing to her arms away are you willing to her in harm's way and like christ. they should call everybody starts with one thing in welfare before us and. what messed up their families or i'm going to bring himself up tell you no they

stopped a. priest 14 years old they didn't want to walk you know he's an old we don't have stop. and thankfulness and plagiary are going about the welfare of children in need to carry the worries there are many sure that a thank you thing found it or you know about it for 7 years i said who are financing since this and is the 1st chance. it's dolans policy to suspend a priest while the church investigates allegations of abuse against him. but when we spoke to patrick on the phone he seemed confident the dolan would keep him in ministry and what's the message to the public that a priest that's been accused of sexually abusing children gets to remain in their job as a priest still working with children while things like. the archdiocese has a 0 tolerance 7 policy and are substantiation. on

it all. and i don't want to go on a week after our encounter with cardinal dolan we got an update on paddocks case. the priest had sent this letter to his congregation after consultation with our no golan and for the good of you the parish and the church i have decided to step away from my role as pastor here and there to gone to stepping away. we still had questions where would patrick be during the investigation and where was he now. and he could be anywhere. in the boats in the park or the beach. you know he still is listed on the parish website as pastor. his letter to the parishioners basically said i'll be back when this all blows over . bad is the story of the catholic church abuse scandal is that

a perpetrator is identified and they either then disappear into another parish or they disappear into another state or they just evaporates they are gone. archdiocese officials declined to answer our list of written questions. however they revealed that father patrick hadn't just stepped away he'd been suspended. the rectory where father attic lives it's right up here it's right next to the church he stepped away from the church a few weeks ago but he didn't say where he was going or what he would be could be doing while this investigation takes place. when we returned to the parish weeks later patrick was still there inside the church compound. father patrick. nice to see you to meet you again

yeah we were wondering if you might have a few seconds to. go. to do that. but i know that there's been a lot that's happened in the last few weeks and we were just wondering where how you're feeling now and what's basically you know here if you're not in active ministry anymore are you going to stay here in the. here. where you're going to go during this time. you can't disclose where you're going to be are you going to be in ministry at all. because you can tell us. well now we know where father patrick is he's still here in the rectory but he couldn't tell us where he's going to be. during this investigation or even if he's going to be in ministry which is interesting. in september a review commissioned by cardinal dolan concluded that there were no active priests

under his watch facing substantiated abuse claims. meanwhile the archdiocese faced 2 new lawsuits accusing priests of abusing minors at least one of them is an active ministry. this is left all of our people you bewildered frustrated and angry our good and faithful priest demoralized in a spaceship somber and contrite. i have also heard this chilling comment more than once cardinal dolan we've been so let down that we're beginning to lose trust in you bishops. that stings without your trust i don't have a lot left. so i would ask him. she lost my trust. what do you expect to do about that.

i know you don't want this out there i know you doubt but have you asked for forgiveness so is your holy priest. and why the being the one and that's what. i want to say as is because i know and he knows i wouldn't just. in the land of the free the cost of medication is killing people this particular pill is going to be anywhere from $800.00 to $1100.00 and citizens are desperate the entire bus load of americans coming to wal-mart in kunar the to buy insulin because just where they can afford it faultlines investigates the spiraling costs of prescription drugs in the usa i will have to make a decision as to when to stop treatment and choose to die so that i can leave my husband with enough the cost of living on.

iraq's parliament fails to meet to discuss protesters demands as those killed by security forces are laid to rest. and we shall carry this is al jazeera live from doha also coming up president announces a major cabinet reshuffle after

a week of anti-government protests. california struggles to tackle another round of wildfires as its largest utility company warns that make up power for the 3rd time and as many weeks. place in britain charge a truck driver with multiple manslaughter charges after the discovery of $39.00 bodies in a refrigerated container. at least 44 people have been killed over the last 2 days in iraq as mass protests continue against prime minister government and the capital baghdad police have fired stun grenades or protesters are trying to enter the heavily fortified green zone where the iraqi parliament is to the south in austria 2 people were killed after guards opened fire when demonstrators tried to storm an official's office funerals are being held for some of those who've been killed by security forces at least 44 people have been killed in the past 2 days and more than 2000 others are

injured protesters had set fire to government buildings and party offices or corruption and economic hardship a curfew has been imposed in 8 mainly shia provinces natasha game has more from baghdad. the number of protesters here in tahrir square is beginning to grow trucks are coming in and with water food pepsi for protesters to clean their eyes if they're attacked with tear gas later this evening this was supposed to be a one day protest on friday it is now spilled into a 2nd day not only here in baghdad but in several cities across iraq people are saying they will not leave the streets until this government of prime minister maliki goes ahead he has already said that the government will not resign because if it does they are will follow protesters i mean i know who the parliament was supposed to meet today as part of a regular session and because not enough members turned out there was no koran that

is only angering protesters who say there is a crisis in the country and members of parliament meets the ministry of interior released a statement saying that it is condemning the criminals they say attacked security forces and vandalized government and political party offices. and that they are committed to protecting the human rights of these cold protesters they say they have not used excessive force meanwhile we've spoken to many protesters who said just the opposite and they've asked us to relay a message to the international community thing we need your help we need to be protected from our own government. so as president sebastian pinera has called for a cabinet reshuffle a day after a 1000000 people protested in the capital demanding economic reform a nationwide curfew has been lifted after more than a week of unrest panetta says he's heard the message of the protesters loud and clear demonstrations turned violent with riot police firing tear gas and lead

pellets to disperse crowds and a ruffle has more from santiago. historic night here in the chilean capital more than a 1000000 people i think the official estimate was 1200000 people that were marching on the streets of san diego well into the night well past curfew a military enforced or few and then another historic moment this morning when we heard that on saturday morning the president of the country so a sample yet as saying that he's calling for the voluntary the for calling on his ministers to basically hand over their paper were calling on them to resign not not firing anybody would call in on the voluntary resignation of ministers so there is a huge significance to this people are comparing this in 1988 when a 1000000 people marched on the capital of to you live that marked the beginning of the end of dictatorship in the beginning of democracy for the country so it's a day full of meaningful moments we're hearing from people on the street in

a much different way than we've seen in different days there's a there's a sort of calling that's already returned to the city since that large march that's in place on friday evening a couple more things that are no worthy that we should mention 1st of all that military curfew that took place for 7 nights in a row has officially been lifted on sunday the state of emergency. it will be lifted so there is a sense that things will be returning to normal but will be returning to normal in a different way there's a lot of optimism in the streets. that a new chile is being born out of the unrest that we've seen over the course of the last week turkey's president has threatened to open its borders to allow refugees to enter europe if the e.u. doesn't support it so call a safe zone and northern syria. will clear kurdish fighters from its border with syria if a deal signed with russia this week fails to hold a solid bench of a reports on the turkey syria border war fighting in syria between kurds and turks

backed syrian rebels in videos uploaded by kurdish fighters this is their defending their positions outside the so-called seized on south of the towns of the lobby and rough terrain fighters who formed a coalition called the syrian national army or any denied in making any territorial gains. really wasn't there he says 5 soldiers were wounded in attacks record as fighters were reportedly being backed by syrian government forces although no one has claimed responsibility turkish military sources accuse the kurds of carrying out 4 bombings in the last 4 days within the safe zone the fighting is happening despite an agreement for a 60 pause forces loyal to syria's president bashar al assad have moved into towns and villages outside of the 30 kilometer boundary agreed by russia and turkey and russian men are few police as well as soldiers from chechnya or patrolling areas and the kurdish controlled. they're implementing the agreement under which the kurds will leave their positions inside the safe zone turkey is

a nato member and its dealings with russia in syria have not been welcomed by many of its western allies for arriving in ankara germany's foreign minister called turkey's offensive against the kurds and invasion that's to discuss. we were told the proposal on creating an international safe zone is not a realistic suggestion that's why we use the time to deal with those issues which are important for the people in syria right now the issue of what happens with the ceasefire after 150 hours and the issue of how humanitarian aid continues with those who are fleeing in syria the invision comment outreach to these leaders they say european allies don't share the burden of refugees and refused to support turkey's operation against fighters who are designated a terrorist group by the european union. from bilateral issues we found this a good opportunity to talk about the syrian issue as a whole i also focused on the fact that the u.s. and russia have recognized the developments in the field without peace spring operation there are so many imes of that operation one of them is to return the

syrian refugees we need to clean the syria from the terrorist organizations. he says it's safe zone is meant to create a space for refugees to return but more people have been displaced since turkey began its military operation and within syria almost 3 weeks ago the world food program says 176000 people have so far fled the fighting and if we left did nothing . to escape to save ourselves and our children they provided some blankets and fruit but. this is how. the 150. turkey and russia expires on tuesday the us president says he expects a permanent ceasefire and has warned of reimposing economic sanctions on turkey if ceasefire violations take place but turkish president is adamant that he wants to establish the 30 kilometer deep so in inside syria to repatriate more than 3000000 syrian refugees with or without the support of his allies solomon job with

al-jazeera a truck on the turkey syria border. and britain police have charged a truck driver with multiple manslaughter after $39.00 bodies were found and a refrigerator container the 25 year old has been charged with conspiracy to traffic people and does that ireland have arrested a 5th suspect in connection with the discovery on wednesday the prime minister has ordered an inquiry after it emerged vietnamese people may be among the dead. he did say he was on the truck all $39.00 and he must be one of them he's gone now there's nothing left of him he died i know he was in that truck because i have relatives who are working over there who called me and told me they were supposed to pick him up at the drop point but then they called and told me to was in that truck they knew the route the time in the drop point of the truck so if they see it so it must be true. place in essex are working to establish the identity of the dead it's

clear from everybody that we are getting a large amount of engagement from the vietnamese population from communities home and abroad and i need to try and separate those what i've done this morning is i met with the vietnamese ambassador and we are building a really good and rapid report and again we have agreed and i've made it perfectly clear to the ambassador that everything every state will be treating you know these individuals with victims with dignity and respect. spain's prime minister condemning recent violence at pro independence rallies in catalonia and hundreds of mayors from across catalonia have traveled to the regional capital barcelona to show their support for self-determination catalan leaders are repeating their calls for talks with the national government and an interest if you like of emotion what we saw on the streets of barcelona last weekend was very clear what we saw was not a clash between police and violent factions what we saw was an attack by violent factions on catalan society and in the middle where the national police the civil

guard and the catalan police defending pedal one side. has more from barcelona at least tens of thousands of people have gathered in central los lobos saturday evening to cole not just for the release of the 900 titian's a time activist who was sentenced mr titian maybe 3 weeks ago but also for the opportunity to decide on the status of fact a loan yes this demonstration that was called for by the 2 main procession grassroots organizations whose leaders are in jail now while they are still keeping up with the past mobilizations the civil disobedience it is not with the same intensity as it took place just after the sentencing however it is election season in spain there are general elections happening on the 10th of november and the procession movement to wants to make sure that the issue remains a priority for spain central government. still ahead on al-jazeera protesters

blocked roads in lebanon during the 10th day of mass demonstrations against the government. and going nowhere these trucks have been stuck in nigeria's border for months and it's costing businesses millions. well we have got some dry weather around the eastern. sort of the mediterranean over the next day or 2 will improve because you can see where they still have this little clutch of storms around the sinai peninsula heading towards lebanon jordan israel could see some more showers long spells of rain in here for a time but even by sunday things starting to brighten up the wetter weather will be stretched across the northern and central parts of iraq heading towards iran wanted to showers on your possibility into kuwait as well least on sundays ago into monday that.