Skip to main content

tv   Inside Story  Al Jazeera  March 4, 2021 8:30pm-9:01pm +03

8:30 pm
spring last year you'll see little islands with with artists on them like in their own bubbles and the sea between them is filled with these screens at least screens that are filled with like really awful scary. that's how i felt at the time available as a free download the anthology provides many different perspectives on a shared world history gabriels under. new york. again i'm fully back to go with the headlines on al-jazeera the un human rights chief has aged ethiopia's government to let monitors into to grade to investigate reports of abuses that could amount to war crimes michelle says killings and sexual violence reported to be ongoing in the northern region in senegal supporters of leading opposition figure some call have been fighting with police in the capital
8:31 pm
because they're demanding his release after he was arrested for taking part in an unauthorized rally has more from dot com if you get behind me were at the university and police are firing tear gas to try to quell the angry crowd in the distance the protesters continue to throw rocks this is one of the major arteries of the capital and right now it's a battle zone between security forces and supporters of. earlier on the police had to push back a few 100 meters because the protesters came in and they called reinforcement for this threat the special brigade. protesters return to myanmar streets on thursday in defiance of a violent crackdown by the military giunta 38 people were killed on when say but the u.n. says the actual death toll since the military takeover. a month ago may be much higher than reported. in the u.s.
8:32 pm
to reports said capitol police have requested a 2 month extension for the national guard's deployment security agencies in washington are on high alert after threats that extremist groups were planning a new attack on the capitol building in hong kong $47.00 pro-democracy activists facing charges of conspiracy to commit subversion are to stay in prison the court granted bail to a 3rd of the defendants but sent the whole group to prison after the government appealed and loyalist paramilitary groups in northern ireland have told british prime minister boris johnson there temporarily withdrawing support for the p.c.l. they say it's because trade and commerce between northern ireland and the u.k. has been disrupted by breaks it the 1900 good friday agreement brought an end to the 3 day kate conflict between catholic nationalists sent protestant unionists those are the headlines coming up next on al-jazeera inside story.
8:33 pm
the international criminal court investigates alleged war crimes on palestinian territory israel calls it scandalous all the palestinians say it's long overdue so what can the inquiry achieve this is inside story. hello and welcome to the program imam some call it a chance for peace others an attack on israel the international criminal court is opening an investigation into alleged war crimes in the palestinian territories it
8:34 pm
a look into accusations of violations by both the israeli military and palestinian armed groups the palestinians have been pushing for the probe since joining the i.c.c. 6 years ago neither israel nor its close ally the united states are part of the court both have criticized the decision we'll bring in our guests in a moment 1st this report from the dead but on him in the occupied west bank. this is a moment many palestinians have been waiting for the international criminal court you must be getting allegations of war crimes in palestinian territory including violence against protesters near the gaza israeli offensive a few years ago. but the clearest violation of international law is the illegal israeli settlements in the occupied west bank more than 600000 israelis live in jewish only settlements killing any possibility for a future palestinian state it's been 6 years since palestine joined the
8:35 pm
international criminal court earlier this year the i.c.c. is chief prosecutor received a green light from the pretrial chamber confirming the court's jurisdiction over gaza and the west bank including occupied east jerusalem i think that we will be encouraging of prosecutor to look at all the situation in palestine all crimes crimes against humanity and war crimes and mainly the settlements regime because there is no complementarity and such. and this is a state policy and this is the stay the government of israel policies and it's a systematic and widespread violation for international law or cards family hopes the court brings them justice he is one of the palestinians who have been confiscated from their family. of collective punishment a recent report by you case for end sick architecture says it was shot and bled to
8:36 pm
death after being denied medical treatment israeli soldiers killed met at a checkpoint near a body stone the army said he tried to run over soldiers but the report says he didn't pose a threat. and i thought i don't get off with that he used his son as a guinea pig a subject for the trying this is a continuing policy that doesn't something like this off to my son and hundreds before he. dies he's chief prosecutor says it's also investigating allegations against palestinian armed groups in gaza. you can't equate the oppressor with the oppressed and the israeli occupation policies constitute a grave violation of international law but our national resistance is legitimate. israel is not a member of the hague based court prime minister benjamin netanyahu termed the decision absurd and anti-semitic without any jurisdiction in this cited are
8:37 pm
brutes all jews who do every precaution to avoid civilian casualties against the worst terrorist in the world we do liberally do this. is our soldiers who are war rooms this israeli government says it is considering functioning palestinian officials and in response to the i.c.c. opening its investigation they might even advance morph into building. all right let's bring in our guests in west jerusalem and herzberg legal advisor at m.d.o. monitor an organization that analyzes output of the international ngo community from a pro israel perspective in gaza raji sort ani lawyer and director of the palestinian center for human rights and in london william schabas professor of international law and former chair person of the commission of inquiry on the 2014 gaza conflict welcome to the program william let me start with you today what from your
8:38 pm
perspective happens next how long do you think that this investigation might take and what might it ultimately achieve. it's very hard to tell how long it will take this is a matter from the prosecutor she's been working on the situation although not in the context of a formal investigation for a number of years now so she must have quite a substantial file i don't that she's going to be able to pursue her investigation on the territory because of problems getting access to the territory so it might as my sense is that there's probably not a great deal more to be done the next visible sign we should see of the chord is likely to be the issuance of an arrest warrant. by the by the judges in the arrest warrant or a summons and that will come that could also come by the way. secretly they can issue a sealed arrest warrant in the hopes perhaps of catching one of the accused off
8:39 pm
guard when they travel outside of the territory and is it your point of view on this that the oslo accords do not allow the court from asserting jurisdiction and if not why is that. yes i think it's very clear when you look at the oslo accords which the palestinians mutually agreed to with the israelis in their mid ninety's the accords say that the palestinians have no criminal jurisdiction over israelis whatsoever and they do not have the ability to delegate criminal jurisdiction over any israelis whatsoever to any other institution international institution and it was quite surprising actually reading the pretrial chambers decision where they basically ignore this issue of the dissent when incidents but the majority opinion barely touched on it at all and i think it'll be quite interesting because i have any doubt that they will get any israelis in custody of
8:40 pm
the court i would find that to be quite remote however if they do this certainly be an issue never come up razi the palestinian authorities ministry of foreign affairs has urged a prompt conclusion of the investigation given how long it's taken to get even to this point do you think that that's possible 'd. could the court of. in the persecutor bin strudel. are very active and there was increased security pressure on them through the team. since february 'd 'd first amounted by israel us to was able to work on this we want and need the conditions for the persecutor to act with an independent professional environment and they do what
8:41 pm
they have to do we as representatives of victims. will be coming to this historic decision and we have a trust. in and in the persecutor office does the do the homework as the. william said rightly they have the political lot of math here and they have very good working on this precisely for the last 6 years and we supported them with what a lot a lot of information zygons by. i hope this will be their work they know the roadmap. to proceed and we will be in their assistance and the whole they will be allowed. in this to get a feeling to come with the crown crying here in got those time to close
8:42 pm
and to see buying their own eyes and to talk to the people directly and to conclude what they have to. the chain of command it's a clear and simple and the court knows most of what i am your heard rajiv there mentioned far too been sued you mentioned her a moment ago as well she of course is the outgoing. chief prosecutor at the international criminal court i want to talk for a moment about the fact that soon she is going to be replaced by another chief prosecutor kareem hahn is coming into that role in june do you believe that that could cause in the issues what i mean by that is that it's my understanding that kareem hahn is not bound to any of the decisions made by bensouda do we perhaps know his position on this case is it likely he would carry it forward could
8:43 pm
it cause any hiccups going forward well he is going to take over in june of this year is the prosecutor fled to bent's who will enter term she doesn't have much time left let's remember that the decision that she received the favorable decision of the beginning of february she had asked for about a year earlier and for some reason that took the pretrial chamber a long time to issue the decision had they done it earlier she might be more advanced the moment but absolutely it's going to go to the new prosecutor he's a man who's been working in the international justice system for many many years and he's well known to all of us he's a very competent lawyer and a man of integrity and he will take the decision as he as he sizes things up by i don't have any particular insight into his views on this issue if he has any except that he like his predecessor is committed to doing the job with independence and impartiality and that doesn't mean that he will take exercise his discretion
8:44 pm
differently than the current prosecutor will have to wait until june to see that and is it likely or unlikely that israel will cooperate formally with this investigation will they for example allow investigators into territories that israel controls. and i would find that highly unlikely i would not be surprised or perhaps find the scenes there's a meeting like a wine actually taken literally when a new prosecutor takes her since he may have a very different outlook on this case and a different approach to the case however i do not forsee the israeli government allowing her office any access to the territories raji do you believe that palestinian groups like hamas will also be investigated for war crimes when it comes to this investigation who think we have nothing to worry about and we're not and decision includes stores as there are and on the group mention the
8:45 pm
political but as. agreed signed on petition when barisan tarbox wanted to sign under to fire on those that they are endorsing this and they are supporting this as well i think yesterday the issue but a clear cut statement and they will come without and that is the creation the decision opens to the source. i mean there will be happy and to engage you. in any coming investigation and i want to ringback ringback say something i mean israel. never was a member state of the i.c.c. or they have signed on record by this though when we began to engage with i mean
8:46 pm
they were having quote the record meeting with the i.c.c. prosecutor or as we know about that and we were a lot of the. road to bring get quite a lot of arguments away from there is many states a repro chambre. when they are scored. some missions because it is the members. of missions. as many countries who far and days are the door into view legally so this is a heavy heavy. besides all security threats and may be exposed on the i.c.c. prosecutor over his sword that that is against the b.b.c. and it looked to me like you may have wanted to jump in to respond to some of what roger was saying please go ahead yeah you know i do think it's worth pointing out
8:47 pm
that israel is not a member of the court it would have liked to join the court but it was pretty well aware that it was going to take this type of direction politicized direction on the part originally be an operations in 2002 and the fact that they have now allowed themselves to exercise jurisdiction over the palestinian authority which itself is not a state and does not have the capacity legally to join the rome statute. you know it's one of the reasons why this case is so contentious. and that is why so many countries spoke out against this move by the prosecutor our man other irish concern we have is you know potentially she may investigate hamas we'll have to wait and see but one thing that greatly concerned me and there her brief to the court last year as well as in the tree trial chamber decision was they only refer to israeli authorities how mass and house during an armed groups that appeared to exclude
8:48 pm
palestinian authorities and there are many many documented or crimes committed by palestinian authority officials and so i find that highly troubling that the court appears to be giving them a free pass. to be investigated when it's clear they have a lot of responsibility. for many crimes not only against israelis but also against palestinians wm based on what you've seen do you believe that the i.c.c. is going to investigate groups like hamas or that they would investigate palestinian officials had the prosecutor's already made it clear that that does fall within the scope of the referral and so yes i mean i would have no reason to think that that she wouldn't do that i think it's been clear she hasn't the but the previous speakers suggested that there was something a bit suspicious about the fact that she didn't mention the palestinian authority but i don't think there can be any doubt from the statement she's made that the
8:49 pm
palestinian authority is also included everybody who is on the territory of palestine or who is done acts that affect that there. isn't prince look subject to the jurisdiction that could be investigated by her but like all prosecutors she keeps her cards close to her vest which is normal and appropriate and we'll have to wait and see from her actions what she does but she has made statements making it clear that she's investigating come out and i believe the palestinian authority and any other individuals on the territory raj if investigators from the i.c.c. don't have access to territories controlled by israel how will they go about collecting testimonies what will that process look like. one time in number in where israel allowed any investigative team from by the who or any other
8:50 pm
body to come and visit the cooper territories they haven't block any in missions of inquiry or investigation bodies and need to come and visit the caput it is including their special happened to or they complained territory's of the human rights council so most likely i mean you know. we're not because of the names that nation stage. ringback they wanted me to come and visit us and 2015 and to see by their own arms what's happening what's 'd going on on the ground there a bit of destruction all the claims i mean we have against the israeli army and crimes i mean they did it in the gaza in the can suppose because of the poor people but they were absolutely did not mean to come to all and that's why our victims whom we're representing disappointed through zoom
8:51 pm
anscar him with the translation for them was we didn't hear and they were you know investigating been some was calm and zoom show we will love i mean to see her and disappointing and be a lot of them i mean to come to they can point to injuries and took him to their advantage and then see what the crimes policy and then what they did to. me i suspect that most likely i mean they will be denied access because that's their record of israel with any justice missions that. is besides the. only thing. one possibility if you will to the book is. victims. their families will be mission impossible and mean to leave
8:52 pm
gaza and to go to hate is. serious a problem even some some. cases if we say 20 of the cases we want to take the victims and their families and it really is not a. court it will be very hard if not we should report if it does are subject to criminal. blockade for the last 2 or pene years imposed boy is or. that will make him very hard even poor becomes to go themselves to the court to get is going to look to their eyes and listen to them directly and to deal with them humanly. so that's why most likely there would be once and again having a high intake resuming order. to transfer the
8:53 pm
message i hope i'm wrong and the whole israel. disappoint us and the. i.c.c. investigative team to come to the point. i hope the same time that you know i'm to go and be i'm starting or up here just that we're starting to run out of time and i just want to ask a question of and right now with regards to how all this might impact elections in israel do you believe that this announcement as far as the investigation of the i.c.c. is this going to end up favoring parties and candidates who would take a stronger line against palestinians and perhaps are more supportive of expansion of settlements i think that and his decision that memory and that the peace process and definitely could involve an hour and as individuals you know as i want to have
8:54 pm
. you know more out maybe punitive measures. dealing with the palestinians so that that's definitely a possibility. i you know i don't see how you know what really what this whole case really is about is about politics the palestinians over the almost 10 years ago said that they want to go to the international court and use it as a political weapon in order if you advance its nationalist claims to advance its rejectionist claims towards the state of israel rather than getting engaged in the goshi sions and working out a compromise for a 2 state solution and so you know that's the way things should be going rather then the palestinians taking on these unilateral steps to be going to these international bodies. and so unfortunately i think what the court has got here has really set back the cause for peace and the ability to are less in the conflict in
8:55 pm
this area and it's quite unfortunate william that the u.s. announced that it is firmly opposed to and disappointed by this i.c.c. decision to investigate 1st i want to ask you if that could impact the proceedings going forward in any way as far as you know the political pressure that the court could come under also i want to ask you if you think that u.s. president biden will maintain the sanctions that were imposed on the i.c.c. officials by the trumping ministration well the trumpet ministration made it very clear that they were 'd angry about the prosecutor's investigation both into the american conduct in afghanistan but also into the investigation of their close outlook which is israel i don't think that that general policy has changed although no doubt the by the inspiration is not going to be as hostile and then taking the
8:56 pm
step towards the. as was the administration of donald trump and his secretary of state might come pale but i think anyone who expects the united states is now going to fall in love with the international criminal court is going to have a rude surprise i do think if i made the i disagree with the previous speaker who talked about the threat to peace i actually think that this is a new element in the intractable conflict israel and palestine the decades have gone by without a result resolution and without any clear idea of where the sanz and a new ingredient just as international justice to be directed at both sides has the potential to to to to kind of shuffle the cards a little bit and hopefully make make a final. peaceful agreement more possible and not less possible and we should welcome this william just very quickly i want to ask you some have
8:57 pm
said that there's a concern that the u.n. security council could at some point step in and delay the investigation perhaps if they're able to get a peace process restarted just very quickly do you think that something that might happen it's theoretically possible under the rome statute but article 16 of the room statute would require the security council to adopt a resolution and that's going to require the 5 affirmative votes or the cooperation of the permanent members the united states obvious new will try to get the courts or will be in a position to do it but i don't think that we can assume that russia and china are going to agree so i think that it's theoretically possible i think it's unlikely all right we've run out of times we're going to have to leave the conversation there thank you so much to all of our guests and herzberg sort ani and william schabas. and thank you too for watching you can watch this and all our previous episodes anytime of visiting our website al jazeera dot com and for further discussion go to our facebook page that's facebook dot com forward slash a.j. inside story you can also join the conversation on twitter our handle is at a.j.
8:58 pm
inside story for me mohammed join the whole team here by for doubt. they captured the hearts of songs around the world but they just for pulled those that unlike most of those they fold hard. time put themselves in the minds of something more important than the beautiful game footballing legendary considine introduces fivefold of players who bucked the trend and stood up for what they
8:59 pm
believed in that's the way. the new season of football rivals coming soon on al-jazeera. 9 years ago now to 0 was the 1st major network to find evidence of genocide in me. when the tragedy of the ruling was mostly unknown. rule. it in genocide on al-jazeera. coveted beyond. taken without hesitation the forgotten died for iraq our defines our old and all those new babies were toilet i did it not the rebels and it's that lack of babies to death people in power investigates exposes and question the schools they use and abuse of power around the globe. on
9:00 pm
how to 0. in this time the differences and similarities of cultures across the world is another matter weighing in with the news and current affairs that matter to you. al-jazeera. this is a news hour on al-jazeera i'm fully back to go live in doha coming up in the next 60 minutes the un human rights chief ethiopia to allow monitors in duty gray region to investigate reports of killings and sexual violence that may amount to war crimes police and protesters find for a 2nd day in senegal.

23 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on