i i l, g 0 as a use all the news i'm can vanelle the doha with the headlines on al jazeera protest is in thailand have been facing off with the lease and the capital, bangkok, demanding the resignation of the prime minister and the calling for urgent reforms to the monarchy. they also want the government to be held accountable for the latest wave of the covered 19 outbreak. at least one person has been arrested so far. the taliban says it has captured a 2nd city in an intensifying campaign against the afghan government. beyond group says it to control low ship gun, the capital of the northern province of charles,

jumped on friday. the telephone captured the 1st city provincial capitals around since us and nato troops withdrew. shall about us has more from cobble it seems that the taliban does have control of all major government buildings like the police headquarters, the army compound, the governors compound, the intelligence offices. but they are still security forces at the airport. and i talked to the folks in the ministry of interior who says that they are planning a counter that they've started, it strikes sending and reinforcement, and special force. and so will the taliban may very well have control of the majority of the city at this point. whether or not it's safe like that with the government. now planning this i think that's to try to retake it. we'll have to wait and see the government is very concerned with the interior minister this morning and he had to rush off for an emergency meeting with the defense minister. he's been going to see president ghani marshall dawson, who is a leader in the province of jose. jan he had an emergency meeting with president

connie this morning as well, so very concerning times for the government. a 6 day math vaccination drive is underway in bangladesh. the government has set a goal of inoculating 3200000 people above the age of 25 and a pants to start offering jobs to bring refugees early next week thailand, vaccine campaign has been one of the slowest in south asia. have a child who is in dock up with more. let me give you some description where i'm at . i'm in doc i city in the morning i was in for middle hospital. this is just the labor hospital. the line has been like this since morning. it's been organized like the other place. people have been complaining, they've been waiting after getting stamped in their registration. each person are waiting like over an hour sometime in cases people are a little bit and not know since february about 14000000 people got vaccinated, some of them still didn't get the 2nd job. now that's about 3 percent of the

population of a $165000000.00, then over not a government grant shot or indian supply chart bunger that you're saying vaccine from china us and says, and not a planted to go at least 3200000 people within next one week, the idea was to vaccinate 10000000 people. but the ration of logistic in the rural area was challenging because many people don't have access to internet or compared to register online in order to able to go to the hospital. so the government's setting up in mobile clinic, i'm going door to door in the door lady as in order to get the papers vaccinated and the are been areas, people are doing it online and they come with the form in here. and then they're waiting in line to get vaccinated. parts of libya have entered another full lockdown in an attempt to curb the spread of crone of ours. the capital tripoli is

one of several areas now under restrictions. it's the 3rd time such measures have been imposed since the start of the pandemic. the government has received 2000000 doses of china is sign of farm vaccine. there are the mass evacuations, north of athens, as wild 5 tear through vast areas of pine forest and get closer to the greek capital. these are live pictures from there. thousands of people have now fled their homes more than a 10055 years, and 15 aircraft a battling infernal across greece, with reinforcements, arriving from other parts of the e. u. in turkey, tens of thousands of heck as far as to be destroyed wildfire there, there being described as the worst in decades, at least $36000.00 people have been displaced from the homes and the southern province of moolah, where they are, a tourist resorts. when you see here on out there right after the bottom line, we'll see very shortly, bye bye for now. ah,

i am steve clements and i have questions. just how dangerous is spyware like pegasus, and how much danger our ordinary citizens, like you and me. and because of our phones, let's get to the bottom line. ah, today no one lives without a phone, basically stuck to them all day. of course, smart devices make our lives more efficient, but they also generate records of almost everything we do. becoming little spies in our pocket, for the most part, we don't care when businesses track us, but things get more dangerous when intelligence agencies want to know where you're going and what you're doing and what you're thinking, what you're saying in private, and whose company you keep one of the most powerful spyware is out there is made by his really company called n s o group. and the software that governments can buy is called pegasus. it is the

power to extract your contacts, your messages, photos, movements, and more without you ever knowing. recently, a group of newspapers in human rights groups got together to expose just how insidious the spying has become. the investigation found that it's being used against human rights activists against business leaders, heads of state and other government officials, politicians, and journalists all over the world. so how pervasive is this digital surveillance, and what do we do to turn the tables on those watching us jamal cas shoji was monitored by this very software. so to his fiance, or the lives of social activists in journalist today and danger, as they agitate to change the world or try to reveal the truth. today we're talking with 3 experts you've been focusing on this threat posed by pegasus data priest is a reporter for the washington post, and she's the co author of a series of investigative pieces known as the pegasus project, which found the spyware is being used in, at least 50 countries the pegasus project was done in partnership with amnesty international. and we'll be talking with the secretary general of that global human

rights group at the great agnes column ard. and john scott rawlton from citizen lab at the university of toronto, which has been analyzing pegasus on infected phones and exposing how it works for years. now. thank you all for joining us today. and it's important conversation, john, let me start with you because you and citizen lab were among the 1st i began reading years ago that were essentially warning that the fear that we all have that governments were potentially tracking us. what's happening? can you sketch? what has been unfolding and what your principal concerns are. well, 1st of all, thanks for having me and for this great panel. one of the things that i think it's important for people to know is that the industry is not new. we're just learning about it because it's growing and the scale of harms that it's causing are growing as well. this is an industry that basically says to governments around the world, look, you want to hack. maybe you don't have that technology within your country. but you

can do it if you have a big enough checkbook and companies like and so, but also companies with a like hacking team from italy before them. fin fisher from germany in the u. k. before that, have gone to governments and said, look, we will sell you an untraceable technology for pervasive surveillance. first of people's laptops and computers, more recently their phones and you do with it, what you will. the industry says this is about stopping terror. this is about preventing crime, but for the last decade, myself, my colleagues and some of the researchers, adamus international, have documented how extensively this software is misused. if there's a bottom line here, it's that if a government gets it and they don't have good oversight, they will abuse, misuse it. thank you, agnes, call him ard when i saw the reporting by dana priest and others on this and saw that there were more than 50000 numbers and began looking at some of those who were on there, including emanuel microns phone, the president of france, where,

where you are now and you began looking at countries all around the world. and that it wasn't, was, as john said, necessarily those that were engaged in mob like, transnational criminal activity or trans national terrorism. but these were journalists, human rights advocates in others. you know, tell us what the tell us what our fear is, auto look like given what you help discover and help disclose. i think 2 of the dimensions to the right recent tradition. the 1st one is there overreach the fact that so many countries, so many people are concerned. and in the past we are received and they don't talk of individual things targeted right now we've the latest discovery. what we are finding out is that the scale of the phenomenon, the global reach of the pickets, is spyware,

and of the government using it. it, he's a systematic problem. it's tammy, formal violation. so that's the 1st point. the 2nd ease, the wrench, of violations that come from the use of because of course, we are aware that by using spyware people are undermining and via right to privacy . what we are also finding out is that governments are violating the right to freedom of expression. they are violating a freedom of the media. they are bio politi core, right? because a number of political parties, members of the, your position, some different countries being targeted. they are also important in potentially violating knife because of that nature. so step

2 of fall, great job ration such as duction these appearances and killings should be shown. and finally, you pointed to the example of the french president even was targeted by a foreign country all these all territory. and that he's not the only example trauma east in french, west target to morrow. cool. so those governments are using the find where extract territory. therefore, we can, you know, we can conclude that this is a weapon, which i spend potentially very much can petition war and pete so that i think he's the late relation and the fact that we are so equipped to respond to it as a global society. well, thank you, dana priest,

you won a pulitzer prize as i recall for a series that you did in the washington post on america's intelligence industrial complex and looking at the enormous sprawl of that intelligence complex. and the fact that there was very little accountability baked in, or cornering or channeling, you know, that capacity is the work that you're doing on the pegasus project. essentially the globalization of the same phenomena that you wrote about about the u. s. case. well, i do think it is, but in a particular way, electronic surveillance. it is, as says, this is a weapon, is real, requires that the ministry of defense approve each failed each country because of it's just a cation, it's a military, great software. and that tells you something important, it's very powerful. it's hard to detect and pay. this is the group that owns it,

is selling it, not just to anybody. they're selling it to countries in the gulf who are already very repressed against their own citizens and their citizens. who have fled and have are now living in exile. they're also selling it. we learn to faltering democracies, mexico, india hungry places where we'd like to see democratic would like to see democracy strength not weekend. and yet the spyware we learned, and others who reported on this earlier, is being used against independent journalists, not just journalists, but independent ones that are really trying to bring information to the citizenry. and finally, i'd like to, i'd like to know, you mentioned the industrial complex of intelligence, which really grew up after $911.00. this is a great example of how this industry,

in particular is unregulated in most of these countries. there is no regulation that says how you should use this type of equipment. in the western democracies, there are laws limited and still. those laws are often abused. as we saw when edward snowden, the documents were weak, but in the breast of these countries there, there is no regulation. and the international community i think is more or less united in the call for some type of regulation, which would need also some type of transparency right now. those companies very secretive denies everything that we've ever said about it and others. and so there's no way to even even vet what they're doing right now. and that would be part of any kind of international regime that looked at this industry and tried to regulate it to some degree. dana just is one of the other elements that come up

recently is the potential complicity of a number of americans in this story. even former obama administration officials that had been advisors or had been consultants to the holding company of n s. so group this had been reported in the guardy and also the american prospect. so is there a complicity, a culpability of certain americans in this, in this story of the, of the, of the actual software company itself. this is not unusual. you know, look at every general just about the leaves military, where do they go to work? they go to work for defense contract. so yes, you have liberal and conservative activist politicians. and, you know, in this case, political officials who became consultants. so really that shouldn't surprise us because the industry and these types of industries offer such lucrative deals to people who can smooth their way for them into,

into government. and that is another point. and also is really spending a lot of money in the united states on increase lobbying because it wants now to, to, to capture the market to get in here with law enforcement and with others. i'm sure the cia would like to sell it where to those agencies as well, so far we can't find a trace of them here. they used to be here, but we can't. we have not found them to be here so far, but they're definitely making efforts. john, is there any chance, as you look at this struggle with how wired and interconnected we are and how i don't even know if i can even mentioned whether privacy exists in any real way anymore. but what are your thoughts about this? because i have to tell you, i'm so kind of feel desperate in this moment. we know that most governments countries don't have serious oversight frameworks for this technology. and even governments that do have some oversight, their wind up being abuses,

the real fear that i see here though. if we pivot this from the technology to the feeling, is that for many authoritarians, fear is the tool self. censorship is the point. and if people feel that they can be monitored, if their most intimate personal lives can be monitored to the cell phone, which is basically attached to them, they may center themselves. they may think, you know, i'm not sure i should criticize x or y powerful person. they may think that about somebody in their country, but as we're seeing with pegasus, they may start having to make that calculation about people a 1000 miles or an ocean away. that is absolutely fuel for growing authoritarianism and it's something that has to be break. well, let me ask agnes column art, a big, kind of geopolitical question with this and, and, you know, i don't know where it's going to come out actually in this because, you know, agnes, you've been so involved with united nation. so involved with major, you know, trans yet national human rights in g o, z like in this,

the international. but i guess my question is, you know, i'm wondering like, who's going to blow the whistle if you have your opinion, nations inside the you, with the key cream in a tar, committed to certain values and rule of law who are buying the software and using it against their people, you know, where, where do you go with that? if you have the united states that may not have bought the software. i don't know, i haven't seen reporting on that. but nonetheless, you have january 6 protests and you have a kind of complicated question around democracy going on in this country. where is the beacon on the hill, or where's the leadership that you see to try to reverse these trends and either shame these nations or develop protocols against them? is there a playbook that you see that can help turn this tied your hand in my hand. i think what we are we're missing right now is the can wendy's and the lack of commitment on the part of government to take action. i think

most government really hoping that the wave of attention we have to wait and that's where we continue be because usually ease in it is up to you to to try to and to me mind why don't we must bring a case to court and then the toner activities are going to court on the basis of the regulations. most do that. they need, we need to evolve. judges, we need 22 courts. there have been a couple of good cases related to somebody else including congress. it's trevino damage to be more if we cannot be protected by our government. let's try to be protected by o. l judges and by our court, civil society must get organized. we know you did say they went, but few government subs an intentional interest in doing it. i think

the week before this was revealed in france and you know, was adopted on target children and some other things that made it even easier for police and all those to, to get involved in still else without the level of protection that we, we don't require at the moment, he's a big problem globally, there is no control over that kinda stretching tom ashan or level, but it is feeding on the fact that domestically nationally, they more crises, us, although sticks a very poor protection against target to. so i've asked those people who hoped germany's we must really act so that they all know is being adopted at the national level that protect us against. don't get

to somebody else by don't own government. how do you arm yourself? how do you teach your students to be prepared for this kind of harassment and surveillance from those they're trying to report on well, i teach journalism students and insecurity is one of the basic things we teach now, which was not the case in my day. and i'm still surprised at how young students are surprised at how big their digital exhaust is. this definitely adds a huge leap to that because most people, i think, believe that a smart phone, especially apple, they've done a good job of marketing themselves and having a secure device in fact, secure. and on top of that, there's nothing you can do really to make it secure. so this is good for me because

i think journalists maybe going to talk to people face to face more. so that is one of the, one of the solutions is to stop using your devices for everything and to go back and talk to people face to face. but of course, you know, that is not an ultimate solution. i teach about and surveillance industry now as part of the global campaign of censorship in so many countries just like john was saying it's a fear fear equal censorship. censorship, but also in newspapers that depend on tax revenue for advertising, that sort of thing. so it has, it has a bath reach, just this one industry that inter gianna would love to get your thoughts on that as well. but in doing so, i should say that the n s o group has denied that this list is, is accurate. they have denied that pegasus was used to fracture mall because shoji and his fiance, they've denied a culpability. and said that if they saw these practices,

they would shut down those clients. so i guess i'd ask you the extra, you know, be question which is when you discovered what you have, but you have a firm that has officially denied any culpability with, with regards to this. what's the pathway forward, the responsible pathway forward? well, this is a great question. let's, let's address it head on. because i think denise, that a good, a good number of things about journalism, i would just observe. every time we as citizen lab investigate a case of a nation state operations and governments hacking gone, wild journalists are among the target. they among the targets they are the through line in so many cases of hacking we observed and it's no accident. first, they do the work, they go out and they find sources, they get people to talk to them who governments want to monitor. but secondarily, especially for authoritarian regimes, journalists are among the truth tellers that those regimes would like to stifle and stop and monitor. with respect to and it shows denials, this is a company that has denied everything it can for as long as it can and it only be

grudgingly admits certain facts. when the evidence is public and incontrovertible. i think you're looking at an industry that is trying to borrow from the big tobacco playbook, seed uncertainty question the science don't necessarily provide much of an alternate experiment, an alternate explanation. just go for the researchers. and this to me highlights why this industry isn't capable right now of self regulation, which is the industry will say, look, we understand how we work. we have to operate in secrecy. let us take care of the human rights issues. what we find though, again, and again, is that when the industry is shown to be doing bad things instead of investigating instead of taking action and instead of reforming their practices, they may send private spies against those who find things out. or they may simply embark on a well funded p r. campaign of denial. that is not the mark of a responsible industry. and it's not away forward for living. the heart of the

industry is doing agnes as the revelations have come out about the governments that have purchased the soft, the software and use it out there. you know, whatever purposes have any of them, essentially been interest spec. they've step forward, been chase and, and say we're going to change our practices. has any single country on that list said, hey, sorry, we shouldn't be doing this. no, that's what i was saying. it to me very depressing that even country, but i mean, we would expect take action such as french because they were talking to the printer, the, the crazy star get the civil me to the way targeted in mexico. the current president of the annoys close circle was targeted, but they have response. i've been so weak. so you know, so new to then, you know, we're, we're really gonna stop. you should call me here. we're going to investigate the

summons. or you only think the french government that's going to confirm the findings of the security lab because they also went to explore the the, the mindful of barriers people that concluded that there for that indeed been a, been hacked by guys. so they've done that one thing, but no government has been, i've been remarkably weak and that's, that's the biggest problem in my view. and if i may, i had to follow up on on it, so you know, it to be your own and it, so really it's due diligence. what we are covering right now is really a form of corporate, concrete, c t in human rights, violations committed by the state. they kind of just pretend that they did not know . but dana, do you think that modern society is going to be able to make sure up those ethical

dimensions of how we use facial recognition software to find lost kids and not use them as a way to control and control every one in society. i mean, our is, is the essential inevitability of acknowledge being the enemy. is that what we're talking about here? technology is always going to advance the key. he is now, it is bad so much further ahead of laws and people even facebook, you know, that's going around for a long time now. and legislators still can't figure out how to make it stop abuse the products. so our lawmakers at every level need to need to be able to catch up and rein these things and we did it with nuclear weapons to a large degree. we did it with other sorts weapons, and this, these are all weapons. so we need to, we need to confront, and we need to confine, well,

we will end it there. i really appreciate the conversation and your candor. washington post reporter dana priest, amnesty international secretary, general august column art and citizen lab senior researcher john scott rawlton. thank you all so much for being with us today. thank you so much. so what's the bottom line? tech advances like artificial intelligence, big data, facial recognition, and the cloud are double edged swords. they do make our lives easier, but they're also weapons used by states that control and monitor us. this is exactly what's going on with the n s o group and pegasus. just know this. if a government wants to find you, it will. you think your, what's that messages are encoded and you have software that will protect you think again, russian president vladimir putin might have nailed it when he said that the facade of democracy is over. he and most leaders are active cheerleaders for liberal states that don't care what citizens want, and they definitely don't care about your privacy. honestly, there's not much we can do. just remember that your phone is your friend of me, half friend, half enemy. and that the bottom line,

ah, join the debate, do not have vaccines reaching those who are most of the nice and amplify your voice . it allows a diverse community and how an array of different story know topic it off the table . it's such a tough ethical debate where there is obvious discrimination and systematic discrimination of play. people are thursdays for new boys. the stream where a global audience becomes a global community on al jazeera ah, era will be the

most $1000000.00 online sex scam in the philippines is black mailing men from around the world, one on one east, uncovered. how small time syndicate became a terminal. am i on al jazeera? ah, i'm kimbell and oh, how would the headlines on al jazeera? but this isn't thailand has been facing off with the lease in the capital, bangkok, the demanding the resignation of the prime minister and calling for urgent reforms to the monarchy. they also want the government to be held accountable for the latest wave of the cove at $900.00 outbreak. at least one person has been arrested so far. the telephone says it has captured a 2nd city and intensifying campaign against the afghan government. the group says it took control of shiver gone, the capital of the northern.